
ã¨ããŊãŧã1īŧįĸåŗļæĄæĨ
1
ãåŊŧã¯ččå¤ĢäēēãŽåžãĢįļãé¨åąãŽä¸ãĢčļŗãč¸ãŋå
ĨãããããŽé¨åąãŽæ§į¸ã¯åŊŧãĢįŊãįĩĩå
ˇããĨãŧããŽä¸ãĢčŋˇãčžŧãã ã¨é¯čĻãããããŽã§ããŖããįŊč˛ãŽãŋã§æ§æãããé¨åąã¯ãžãã§å¤įŊĒäēēãåšŊéããããšãįĸįãŽããã§ããŖããåæšãŽįŊäēã¯å
ããĒåšå¸ãįĄããæ°åą
ãŽæ´éĸå°ãŽãããĒæŧãäģãããžããæ¸
æŊæãä¸ģåŧĩãããããŽããåŊŧã¯å¤čĻŗããæŗåããĻããé¨åąãŽéåãããããč¨åŧĩããåēãããæãããŽã ãŖããčĒįļįŠãŽå𞿏ã¯å
¨ããĒããäēåŽãå
ãģãŠãžã§åŊŧãŽčēĢäŊãæãããĻãã6æãŽéãæĸ
é¨ãŽæšŋåēĻã¯ãå
ĨåŖãŽæãããŽå
Ĩ厤ãčĒããããĻã¯ããĒãã
ãããŠããããĄããĢã
ãččå¤Ģäēēã¯åŊŧãé¨åąãŽé°å˛æ°ãĢéŖ˛ãžããĻãããŽãå¯ããåãããããĢåŖ°ãããããé¨åąãŽåŗå´ãĢã¯ãģãŠããã¯čŖŊãŽãã¤ããŗã°ããŧããĢã¨ã寞éĸãããããĢé
įŊŽããããˇãããˇãŧããŽæ§ãĒæ¤
åã2čãããããŽåĨĨå´ãŽæ¤
åãĢåŊŧåĨŗã¯æĸãĢč
°ãä¸ãããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæįŊãŽãŦããŖãŧãšãšãŧãã¯æ¤
åã¨ããŧããĢã¨å
¨ããŽåč˛ã§ãããåŊŧåĨŗčĒčēĢããããčĒŋåēĻåãŽä¸é¨ãŽæ§ã§ããŖããåŊŧã¯ãããĒįããčĒŋåēĻåãĢčģŊãäŧéãããã¨ãæŠãé˛ãæ¤
åã¸ã¨č
°ãããåŊŧã¯å¯ä¸æãĢæãŖãĻããéģããã¸ããšããã¯ãčãŽä¸ãĢããŖã¨įŊŽããã
ããäģå¤ã¯ãčļãããã ããããã¨ãããããžããããŖããã¨ããäŧéã¨čŊãĄįãããåŖ°č˛ãĢããŖãĻččå¤Ģäēēã¯čĒŋåēĻåã¨ããĻã§ã¯ãĒããäēēã¨ããĻãŽčŧĒéãįŦæãĢåãæģããã
ãããããččå¤ĢäēēãĢãŠãããĻããäŧããããã¨ãæį´ãåˇŽãä¸ãããŽã¯į§ã§ããæŦæĨã¯ãæãé ããããã¨ãããããžããččå¤ĢäēēãŽč¨čéŖããĢã¤ãããåŊŧã¯äģäēã§äŊŋãæ
ŖããĻããåŖčĒŋãååãĢåēãĻããžãŖããæčĄ¨ãã¤ããããŽã§ããããããĻããã¯ãåŊŧãæŗåããĻããččå¤ĢäēēãŽã¤ãĄãŧã¸ã¨å¤§ããĒéãããããŖããã¨ãį¤ēããĻããã
ãããããĒãĢįãžããĒãã§ãã ãããį§ã¯ãã äģæĨã¯ããŖãąãã芹ãã§ããã¨æãããã ãããæĨŊããŋãĢãčĒããããĢéããĒããŽã§ãããã
ãččå¤Ģäēēã¯æãããæĄãŖãåˇĻæã§åŖå
ãé ã垎įŦãã ãåŊŧã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽéˇãč¯åĨĸãĒæå
ã§ã¯é ããããĒãåŖå
ããčĻãįŊãæ¯ãĢãããã¨ãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæäŊããã¯ãã¤ãããŽåãžã§å°åĨŗã ãŖã20æŗãŽåĨŗæ§ã¨ã¯æããĒããåãŽããäŊčŖãčĻãĻåããããã ããããĻãããåããĻãã᏿ã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽåš´éŊĸãŽåčŋãåŖŽåš´įˇæ§ââãããããåŊŧã¯ãčŦįŠäžåãĢããããåĻįļæ
ãããįãŽčŧŋãĢããã°ãããšã¯ãĒéæĨŊčļŖåŗãã¨ããŖãåŊŧåĨŗãĢã¤ããĻãžããããããŽåã¨æŦäēēãŽåŽåãįĩãŗã¤ããĒããĒãŖãĻããã
ããââåŋĩãŽãããäŧēããããŽã§ãããįĸåŗļæĄæĨã¨ãããååã¯åŊåã§ã¯ãĒããæŦåã§ããžãĄãããĒãã§ããããīŧã
ããã¯ããåŋčĢæŦåã§ããæĄæĨã¯é ˇãįããã
ãããããŖããããã§æĄæĨããã¯ããŖãąããåĒããæšã¨ãããŽãããããããžããã
ããããã¯ãŠãããŖãæåŗã§ããããīŧã
ããĩãĩãŖã¨ãččå¤Ģäēēã¯åŖ°ãæ´ŠãããéˇãįĢæ¯į¸ãŠãããįŽãį´°ãä¸įŦå°éĻŦéšŋãĢãããããĒ襨æ
ãäŊãŖãããæĄæĨã¯ä¸æč°ã¨åĢåŗãĒå°čąĄãåããĒããŖãã
ããæį´ãŽæåžãĢæˇģããããæĄæĨãããŽãååãä¸å¯§ãĢãĢããæ¯ãŖãĻãããžãããããããã¨ččå¤Ģäēēã¯ããŖã¨åˇĻæãä¸ããäēēåˇŽãæãäŧ¸ã°ãįŠēä¸ãĢãæĄæĨãã¨æ¸ãããããŽåŊŧåĨŗãŽåäŊãĢãæĄæĨã¯åãŽåĨĨãĢé
¸ãŖãąãčé
¸ãããŋä¸ããĻããä¸åŋĢæãčĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãįŠēä¸ãĢæ¸ãããæĄæĨãã¨ããåã¯ãåŽãĢčĒãŋããããŖããã¤ãžãããã¯ãååãĢåŊŧãæ°éŖãéĄæåãäŊŋį¨ããĻæ¸ãããã¨ã襨ããĻããã
ããããŽãžãžč¨čĒãŋãã§ãããã§ãããįåč¨ãŽãããĒįšæŽčĒãŋãããããĒé°å˛æ°ããããžããįĩļåĻãĒããŠãŗãšãŽį´ æĩãĒãååã§ããã ãããããŽãååãĢãĢããæ¯ãŖãĻãã ããé
æ
ŽãŽããäēēã¯ãããåĒããäēēã ãããĒãã¨ãæŗåãããĻããžããã
ããâĻâĻããŖããĢã1ã¤ã§ãããžã§č¤ããĻããããã¨ã¯æããžããã§ããããããäēåãĢįĨãŖãĻããã°æį´å
¨ãĻãŽæŧĸåãĢãĢããæ¯ããããã¯ãããã§ãããŠããæå¤ãĢãäŧ芹ããĒãŧãããĻãããččå¤ĢäēēãĢ寞ããæĄæĨã¯åšŗéãčŖ
ãåžã
ã̿޿ŽĩãŽč¨čéŖããåãæģããã¨čŠĻãŋãã
ãããããĒããŽãéãããĻããããå
¨æã˛ãããĒã§æ¸ãããæį´äģĨä¸ãĢį§ã¯åˇã¤ããã¨æããžãã
ãåä¸ãããˇã§ãŧããŽéģéĢĒããģããŽå°ãã ãæēãããččå¤Ģäēēã¯čĻįˇãæēä¸ãĢåããã
ã(ããŖã¨ããŽåĨŗã¯ãããĒæŽé
ˇãĒæ°éŖããčĒåãããĻããčĒčĻããĒããã )
ãæĄæĨã¯æåŗããčļéŊãĒččå¤ĢäēēãŽčæ¯ãĢč§Ļããæ°ãããããããããčĒåãåŊŧåĨŗãåˇã¤ãããã¨ããčĻæã¯ããä¸åą¤åŧˇåēãĒããŽã¨ãĒãã ãã§ããŖãã
ãããæĄæĨããŽãĢããĢã¤ããĻã¯æŖį´ãã ãŽįã§ããããĒããŽčãããĒããã§ãããĒãŽã§į§ãĢæąããåĒããäēēãã¨ããæŗåââã¨ããããããšãģããŧããĢããŽãããĒæ¨įã¯ãåŽã¯ããŽãžãžččå¤Ģäēēã貴æšãŽéĄæã¨ãããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒããã§ããããīŧã
ããâĻâĻįĸēããĢãããããããžãããããããĒčĨã
ããåĨŗæ§ãĢãããŖãĻčåŠĻäēēãĒããĻæļæããäēēãããåĒããããããããžããããččå¤Ģäēēã¯é ˇããĒããã¯ãšãĒã¨åžŽįŦãã ã
ããĸãŦãĩãģã¯ãĒãšããŖãŽįãŋåēããããšãģããŧããĢã¯ãä¸įįãĢæåãĒæ¨įå°čĒŦãĢåēãĻããåæĸåĩã§ããããããæŽåŋĩãĒããããã¯æĄæĨãŽåä¸äģŖã§ããŖãĻããä¸čŦ常čã¨ããæ ãĢå
ĨãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããččå¤ĢäēēãŽä¸äģŖãĒãæ´ãĢčĒįĨåēĻã¯ä¸ããã¯ãã§ãããããããã ããããæĄæĨã¯ããããŽįĨčãæããĻããččå¤ĢäēēãĢãæäŊéãŽå°čĒŦåŽļãŽåĻģã¨ããĻãŽæé¤ãæããã
ãããããããįŠŋãŖãåãåãæšã¯ããĒãã§ãã ãããį´į˛ãĢæŗååãčąãã ã¨č¤ããã ãã§ããããããããååã§ããã°į§ãĒããããččå¤ĢäēēãŽãģããįãããååã ã¨æããžãããæĄæĨã¯čãæ´ããããįãå
ĢãŽåãĢä¸ããå°ãŖããããĒ襨æ
ã§ãããã
ãããŠãã§ãããããį§ãŽååã¯č¯ãŽččã¨åãæŧĸåãäŊŋããŽã§ãčĻããããããã¨ã¯æããĻããžããįãããŽã¯ãã ããã¨ãĻãã¨ããååãŽéŋããŽæšãããĒãã§ãããããããŖã¨ããŽįšã¯æĄæĨããã¨å¤§åˇŽãĒãã¨æããžããã
ããããããåãŠããŽé ãĢååã§ãããããããã¨ããããžããīŧã
ãããããžãããããžããį§ãæåŋããĄããæ¸žåã§åŧã°ããã¨ããããžãããã
ããããã¯įž¨ãžãã§ãããį§ãŽæ¸žåãĒããã¯ããĒãã¨ãããããĢããĢããããŽã°ããã§ãããįšãĢæŧĸåãŽé°å˛æ°ãĢåŧãŖåŧĩãããĻããĸãĸãŋããŧãã¨ãã¯ææĒã§ãããããããĢæ¯ãšãččå¤ĢäēēãŽį¸æãĢæåŋããĻããžã渞åãŖãĻãŽã¯ä¸äŊãŠããĒããŽã ãŖããã§ããīŧãæĄæĨãŽåŖå
ã¯įŦãŖãĻãããããžãįã¯å
ĢãŽåãĢä¸ããŖãĻããããŠãããįãä¸ãããŽã¯åŊŧãææ
ã襨ãã¨ããŽįãŽããã ã
ããããã¨ãĻãĒãã¨ãĻãĄãããã§ããæŦãčĒãã§ãį§ãŽčãĢåããĻããããŽæ¸žåã§åŧã°ããžããã᏿ã¯į§ãĢã¯æåŗãäŧãããĒãã¨æãŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻããã§ãããããå ã
ã¨ãčĻããĒãåãã¨åŧãã§ãžããã
ã
ãââä¸čĻãĒčč
Â
ãæĄæĨã¯åãŠããéãᅬ
æĩãŽåˇčžēã§ãäŊŋ፿¸ãŋãŽæŗ¨å°å¨ãčĻã¤ãããããĒčĄæãæããã
ããâĻâĻãããĒæ¸žåãĢã¯æåŋã§ããžãããããããĒæ¸žåãåį´įãŽéã§æĩčĄãŖãĻããžãŖããã§ããīŧã
ãããĩãĩãŖãäŊãåéããããĻããããã§ãããããŽæ¸žåã¯åžãĢæ¯ãŽååŠį¸æã¨ãĒãįˇãäŊŋãŖãĻããããŽã§ãīŧäēēã ããŽã¨ããĢäŊŋãŖãĻãããŽã§ãæĩčĄããäŊããããžããã§ããããããĢæåŋãããžãããåŊæãŽį§ã¯å°åĻīŧåš´įã§éåĻãčžãã鏿ãããã°ããã§ãããŽãžãžã§ã¯į¤žäŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻãä¸čĻãã¨ãĒããã¨ãææããĻãããĻãããã§ãããããããžã§ä¸æ°ãĢččå¤Ģäēēã¯čŠąãã¨ãåŋåēæĨŊããããĢįŦãŖããææŠãåŊŧåĨŗãæĸããĻããŽãããĒæŧåēãããĻãããŽãæĄæĨãĢã¯å¤æãã¤ããĒããåŊŧãŽč
æč¨ã¯ããæĢãããã¨æĨäģãå¤ããæåģãåããĻããããįŽãŽåãŽæĒãã§čĻããįŦéĄããčĻįˇãé¸ãããã¨ãã§ãããæ°äģããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖããåŊŧã¯åãŗåŖå
ãĢããŋä¸ããĻããčé
¸ãŽéæĩãéŽãããã¨ãåŧå¸ãæĸãããããŽéãĢé¨åąãå°ãæēããĻãããããĒæĩŽéæãæããæ´ãĢæ°åãæĒããĒãŖãã嚸ããĢãäŊãåãåēããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
2
ãæĄæĨã¯ããŽčŗĒåãããžããĢãįĄįĨįĩã§ãããã¨ã¯čĒčĻããĻããããããåæãĢåãæã§ããččå¤Ģäēēã¯ãããæãããã¨ã¯ãžããĒãã¨ããįĸēããĒčĒäŋĄãããŖãã
ããä¸įģæ Ąã¯âĻâĻããã°ãŦã¯ããåå ã§ããīŧãččå¤ĢäēēãŽé¨åąãæ¯é
ããįŦãåŖ°ãĢ寞ããæĄæĨã¯æ ããæ§ãĒåŖ°ã§ãããã
ãããããéããžããããã ãŽčĒåˇąæąēåŽã§ãã
ããå°åĻīŧåš´įãĢãããĒ夿ã¯įĄįã§ããæĄæĨã¯ãžãã§å
įĢĨį¸čĢæãŽčˇåĄãĢã§ããĒãŖããããĒåŋæã§č¨ãåãŖãã
Â
ããæŗååãäšããã§ãããįŽãå
ããĢį´°ããččå¤ĢäēēãčŊčãããããĢåãã
Â
ããââäžãã°ãįžį§äēå
¸ãīŧæŗã§čĒãŋčžŧãŋįĩļæããåãŠãã ãŖãĻãããã§ããåæãããĻããč¨čãįŠäŊãŽååããįĄãã¨ããįįąã§ã§ããããããĒåãå°åĻæ ĄãĢä¸ãããä¸įĒãŽčĄæãåãããŽã¯äŊã ã¨æããžããīŧã
ãæĄæĨãŽåã¯åããĒãããããæĨãĢéŖčēããäŧ芹ãŽå
厚ãĢæčã䏿ãåãæŋãããã¨ãã§ããĒããŖããŽã ãįĩæãé
ˇãæãŋãŽčĄ¨æ
ãččå¤ĢäēēãĢåãããã¨ããã§ãããæ˛éģãčŗĒåãŽįãã¨ããĻæåēããã
ããæį§æ¸ã¨ããæŦãŽåå¨ã¨ãŽåēäŧãã§ããæãŖãĻįãžããįĨæ§ã¨čããčĒåŊãããã°ãä¸įãŽåēãããããŽæãŽæŦãĢããŖãĻ厚æãĢåŽæã§ãããč¨ãŖãĻããžãã°ãããã¯äēåēĻįŽãŽäēēįãæŠããããĒ嚸įĻã§ãã
ãããããåŊæãŽččå¤Ģäēēã ãŖããã§ããīŧã
ããããã¯äžãã°ãŽã芹ã§ãããį§ãŽčŠąã§ã¯ãããžããããããĒįĨæ§ãæãŖãĻįãžããåãããŽä¸ãĢã¯ããã¨ããã ããŽã芹ã§ãã
ããâĻâĻį§ãããããŖãĻããã§ãããččå¤Ģäēēã¯äŊããããŽįįąã§ä¸įģæ ĄãĢãĒãŖããããļãããã¯äēåŽãĒãŽã§ããããã§ãããŽįįąãäģãŽãããĢ夊æããŋãįįąãĢå¤ããĻãããããĒäēēããããããããŖã¨ãæ æŖŽå
įã¨åããĻäŧãŖãæãĒããããčåŗãåŧãčĒåˇąį´šäģã¨ããĻäģãŋãããĢ芹ãããããââã
ããããŧãĄããã¯ãããĒåĨŗã¨įĩåŠããĻããžããģãŠãæãã§ãããīŧã
ããâĻâĻãããĒãããĒãã ãīŧãįŦéãæĄæĨãŽåŖ°ã¯ææ°ãã¯ããŋččå¤Ģäēēãįŗžåŧžããã
ãããããŖããį§ãåæčĻã§ããã
ãæŦæĨã§ããã°ãæĄæĨãŽãããĒåŖŽåš´įˇæ§ãŽæĨč
šãĒæ
åēĻã¯ãé¨åąãŽé°å˛æ°ãä¸å¤ãããããããįŗžåŧžããįŦæãĢčēĢäŊãåˇĄãŖãã¨æãããåŊŧãŽį
ŽããčĄæļ˛ã¯ãįŽãŽåãŽččå¤ĢäēēãŽä¸č˛ĢããĻå¤ãããĒãé°å˛æ°ãĢåŊãĻããæĨæŋãĢåˇå´ãããã
ãæĄæĨãããį§æåãĢįŗãä¸ãããããĢãããããäģæĨã¯ããŖãąãã芹ãããããŽã§ãââã
ãä¸åŧå¸ãããĻæŦĄãĢččå¤ĢäēēãåŖãĢããč¨čãĢããŖãĻãåŊŧåĨŗãŽį˛žįĨãčãæãžããã¯åäģĨä¸ã§ãããã¨ãæĄæĨã¯éãĢįč§Ŗããã
ããį§ã¯ããŧãĄããã¨ãã¤ãĢãĒãŖããã芹ãã§ãããŽã§ããããīŧã
Â
3
ããââããããããĄããã¨ããŧãĄããã¯äģæĨãããĢåå¸ããĻãããã§ãããīŧã
ãččå¤ĢäēēãŽčĄ¨æ
ãĢã¯ãåēäŧãŖãĻéããĒãį°æ§ãĢã¯åãããšãã§ã¯ãĒãææãĒįˇŠãŋãčĻãĻã¨ãããåŖ°č˛ã᏿ãååãĢãŽãŧããä¸ãããããģãŠãĢįąãŖãŊããããé¨åąãŽæåēĻãæŖå寞ã§ããŖãã¨ããĻããåŖ°č˛ãŽčļãã寸åãŽįãããĒãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĄ¨æ
ã᏿ãĢäŧãããã¨ãå¯čŊã ããã
ãããããããŽčĄ¨æ
ã¯å¯žéĸããæĄæĨãĢåããĻããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããããŽãã¨ã¯åŊŧčĒčēĢãååãĢįč§Ŗã§ããã
ãččå¤Ģäēēã¯ãã äēĄãå¤Ģãæ æŖŽååŖąãŽåšģåŊąãčŋŊããããĻãããĢéããĒããŽã ãã
ããæŽåŋĩãĒãããį§ãĢã¯æ æŖŽå
įããããĢãããŽãã¯ããããžãããã§ããââã
ãæĄæĨã¯č¨ã荺ãããčĒŦæãŽãã¨ãäģãžã§åŖéčĻãĻããččå¤ĢäēēãŽį°å¸¸æ§ãĢéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãžããĒããããĢį˛žä¸æ¯åŖč§ãä¸ããįŦãŋãäŊãŖãããããĻãããŖããã¨åĢãŋãæããããããĢããįļãããŽã ãŖãã
ãããæį´ãĢč¨ããéããæ æŖŽå
įã¯3ãæåããããŖã¨į§ãŽå¤ĸãĢįžããĻã¯ãčĒåãŽåŋæŽããĢã¤ããĻčĒãŖãĻãããžãã
ãč¨ãįĩãããæĄæĨãŽåãå
ããĢéãããããŽæåä¸ã¤ãįįąã¨ããĻčĒåãŽåãæ´ããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããããããĒæčãŽéĄåˇĄãĢãččå¤ĢäēēãŽåŖ°ãå˛ãčžŧãŋåæĸãããã
ããããŖã¨ãããŖã¨čŠŗããæããĻãã ãããæĄæĨãããæį´ãĢæ¸ããĒããŖãããŧãĄãããįžããæ§åã¨ãããžãã¯ãããããŠããæããĻãã ããã
ããĸãŗããŧãŽčšåŊŠãå
ããĢæŋĄããããčĒãččå¤ĢäēēãŽæ§åãĢãæĄæĨãŽä¸åŽã¯ãããĢč§Ŗæļãããã
ãæŦæããæ æŖŽå
įãŽäēĄããĒãŖããã¨ãįĨãŖãããŽæĨãæĄæĨãčĒãŖãæąēåŋãčä¸ãæŧãã
Â
ãââããŽåĨŗãĢæŽēãããæ æŖŽå
įãĢå¤ãããčǰããå
įãŽææãįļããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã
ãââäžãããŽåĨŗããŠãåŠį¨ããã¨ããĻãã
4
ãããæŠæĻãˇãĒãŧãēãããååŖãŽæ ããĒãŠãŽäēēæ°äŊåã§įĨãããå°čĒŦåŽļãŽæ æŖŽååŖąããããäģæ22æĨåå1æãččąįãŽããįé¤ããĻããčĒåŽ
ã§äēĄããĒãŖãĻãããã¨ãããããžããã75æŗã§ãããååŖąããã¯10æŗãŽé ããå°čĒŦãæ¸ãå§ã20æŗã§æį¨ŋããäŊåãéčĒãĢæ˛čŧãããžãããããŽåžãæŦæ ŧįãĢå°čĒŦåŽļãããĨãŧãåŽļææãããŧããĢããå°čĒŦãŽåˇįãŽåããåžåš´ã¯įĩĩæŦãŽåēįã¨ããŖãåš
åēãã¸ãŖãŗãĢã§æ´ģčēããæ°å¤ããŽäŊåãä¸ãĢéãåēããĻããžããââã
ãæĄæĨãæ æŖŽååŖąãŽč¨å ąãåããĻįĨãŖããŽã¯ãĄãããŠäģãã1åš´į¨åã ãŖããäģãĢæãã°å大ãĒäŊåŽļãŽįĨæ´ãĢããĻã¯ããžããĢãå°åĨéēãĢãžã¨ããããčĒŦæã¯ãäŧæåĒäŊããŠã¸ãĒã ãŖããããĒãŽã ããããããããããĒé
æ
ŽãĢæãčŗãããģãŠåŊæãŽæĄæĨã¯åˇéã§ã¯ããããĒããŖããåŊŧãéčģĸããĻããį¤žį¨čģãŽãšã¤ããã¯čĩ°čĄčˇéĸã15ä¸ãããčļ
ãããã¨ãããĒãŗããčģã§ããģãŧåŊŧãŽå°į¨čģã¨ãĒãŖãĻãããã ãããããããĒããį¤žå
ã§ã¯æąēããĻ襨ãĢåēããã¨ãŽãĒãæĄæĨãŽåļæ´æ§ãįĒįēįãĢįēé˛ããĻããžãŖããæĄæĨã¯ãŠã¸ãĒãŽéŗãããæļãæ§ãĢčģå
ã§įãå ããã¨ãåŗæãããŗããĢããéĸãããŦãŗãŦãŗãã¨åĸãããããĸããŠãŧãŽæ ŧį´ãšã¤ããčžēããĢ2åēĻãæãŽį˛ãæãæ¨ãĻããããĢæãĄäģããã
Â
ã(ââããŖãąããããŽåĨŗã¨įĩåŠããĻãããĢæ æŖŽå
įã¯äēĄããĒãŖãĻããžãŖããããĒããīŧ)
ã
ãæŦæããäēēãŽč¨å ąã¯æĄæĨã¨ãŖãĻéŠããåããŋãŽææ
ããå
ãĢãæããĢããčįĢãĄãåãããããããĻåŊŧãŽåŗæã¯ããŽį į˛ã¨ãĒãŖããæš§ãä¸ããčįĢãĄãĢäģģãäģåēĻã¯åŗæã§æŗãæĄããããŗããĢãŽį¸ã¸åŠãã¤ããã6æãŽä¸æŦãŽããŽæĨãæåģã18æãå°ãčļ
ããĻãããŽã¯åš¸éã§ããŖããåŊé4åˇįˇãŽä¸ãã¯ãįįĒãčĩˇãããåšŧåãŽæãåŧãæ¯čĻĒãŽæ§ãĢãæŽæŽĩã¨å¤ãããŦæˇˇéãĢåŊŧãŽãšã¤ãããåŧãčžŧãã ãããŦãŧããããĢãåæ§ã§ãããåˇĻčļŗãããŽå čįãĒå§åãåãįļãããã¨ãĢãããåŊŧãŽåŋæ
ãåŽĨããæ§ãĢãšã¤ãããããŽå ´ãĢéæĸããįļããã
ãæąãæĄæĨãŽéĄããæĩããįŽãĢããŋããååãĢåŗæã§æããã¨ããĻåŗæãįæŖããĻãããã¨ãĢããŽã¨ãæŧ¸ãæ°ãã¤ãããããŽįæŖã¯äģå°įãä¸ããæãããããããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããčĻãã¨čĩ¤ã
ã¨č
ĢããããŖãæãŽį˛ã¯ãįŽčãįĒãį ´ããã¨ãå
å´ã§įŧããåšžã¤ããŽįģé˛ãéãæŧãäģããĻãããããĒįãŋãã訴ããĻããã
ãæĄæĨã¯éĄãåŧãã¤ããããããĒ襨æ
ãäŊãããã1åēĻã ãåŗæãããŗããĢãŽį¸ã¸åŠãã¤ããã
ããæ æŖŽå
įããŠããåã訹ããĻãã ãããæĄæĨãŽããŽåãã¯ãåžæščģãããŽé˛čĄãäŋãã¯ãŠã¯ãˇã§ãŗãĢéŖ˛ãžãããåŊŧãŽčĻįã¯æŊ¤ãã§ããããæãŽį˛ããã¯įŧããįģé˛ãĒãŠåēãĻããĒããã¨ãįĸēčĒãããĢã¯ååã§ããŖãã
ããããĻåŊŧã¯čĩ¤éģãæēļå˛ŠæĩãŽãããĒéåēĻã§čģãįēé˛ãããã
ã
ãããŽæĨãæĄæĨã¯īŧäēēæŽãããããĻãããĸããŧãã¸å¸°ãã¨ãįãŖå
ãĢå¯åޤã¸åããŖããå¯åޤãŽã¯ããŧãŧãããéããã¨ãå 叺éĸãĢ螿¯ãĢåããĻæããããĻããã¯ã¤ãˇãŖããåˇĻæã§æŧããŽãããįŽåŊãĻã¨ãĒãæŽĩããŧãĢįŽąã¯ãããĢčĻã¤ãããåŊŧã¯å°ãããĻããé¤įããŧããéãĢåĨãããã
ãä¸čēĢã¯éĨãæãæĄæĨãįēãŖãĻããčĒåˇąč¯åŽæãŽæ šæēââåŊŧãå¯ä¸åæĨåēįããããŠãŧå°čĒŦãæˇã芰ããããĻããã
5
ãããŧãĄãããã¨ãå
ãģãŠããæ æŖŽå
įãčĻĒããåŧãļččå¤ĢäēēãŽč¨čãĢãæĄæĨã¯čŗŊãŽæ˛ŗåãĢæŖ˛ãéŦŧãŽææ
ãåŽŋããããĻãããããĒãã¨ãæŧãæ˛ã芹ãå§ããã
ããæŽæŽĩį§ã¯æŽãŠå¤ĸãčĻãžããããįĄį ä¸ãĢã¨ããŠãæããææãŽããããå¤ä¸ãĢįŽãčĻãžããããããã¨ããããããã§ããã§ããčĻããĻããžãã°ä¸äŊäŊãĢãããžã§ææ
ãæēãåããããĻãããŽããããŠãããĻãæãåēããĒããã§ããį§ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãŽå¤ĸã¯ãããĒ荿ļããããã¨ãŽãĒããææ
ãŽčĩˇäŧãŽãŋãäŊã¨ãčĻããĻããããŽãĒãã§ããã§ãããã¯æ æŖŽå
įãå¤ĸãĢįžãããžã§ã§ââã
ãããžãã§įžåŽãŽæ§ãĢæãããã§ãããččå¤ĢäēēãæĄæĨãŽåãããšãįĩčĢãčŋ°ãšãã
ããââããŽéãã§ããæĄæĨã¯æˇąãããĒããããããŽæ§åãåããččå¤Ģäēēã¯ããææ
ĸãŽéįã¨ããŖãæ§åã§čŗĒåãæããããã
ããæĄæĨãããæŖį´ã貴æšãŽãããĢââčļ
常įžčąĄįãĒäŊé¨ãĢįĩĄããĻãæ æŖŽååŖąã¨éĸãŖãããæ æŖŽååŖąã¯įããĻãããã¨ããæį´ãéãŖãĻããæšã¯ãäģã§ãæ¯æ2ã3äēēããããããã§ããåŋčĢãããŽæ
å ąã¯å¤§å¤ãããããããŽã§ã¯ãããŽã§ãããį§ã¯čĒåãŽåēæēãĢåããããããŽæį´ãŽįåŽį¸åŊæ§ã夿ããžãã
ããį§ãŽæį´ã¯ããŽåēæēãæēãããĻããããã§ããã
ããããŽéãã§ããæĄæĨãããŽãæį´ãĢã¯ãäģãŽæšã¨ã¯å§åįãĢéãįšããããžãããããã¯ä¸éãĢå
Ŧ襨ããĻããĒãäēåŽãŽåč´ã¨ãį§ãįĨããĒããŖãæ æŖŽãŽéãĄãããŽ2įšã§ãããããĻããŽ2įšãĢãããį§ã¯æĄæĨããã¨äŧããšãã ã¨å¤æãããŽã§ããååį´å
ĨãĢč¨ããžãã¨ãããŧãĄããã¯ãģãã¨ããĢããģãã¨ããĢââã
Â
ãččã¯čĒããĒãããããŖã¨æēãĢæãåēãããĻããæĄæĨãŽæãæĄãŖãã
ãããåŋæŽããŽããäŊåãåŽæãããããã¨ããįĄåŋĩãŽãããæĄæĨãããŽå¤ĸãĢįžãįļããĻãããŽã§ããīŧã
ããã¯ãâĻâĻããããĻããŽįĄåŋĩãåŋæŽããŽããäŊåã¨ã¯į§ãŽåįžŠã§åēįãããĻããĒãããããŽåŽä¸čēĢã¯æ æŖŽå
įãåˇįããäŊåãŽįļᎍãŽãã¨ãåˇŽããĻãããã§ããæĄæĨã¯ččå¤ĢäēēãĢæĄãããæãĢåãčžŧããč¨čãĢåãčžŧãããããã¯åŊŧčĒčēĢãčĒåãåããĻããåãŽč¨čãįåŽã§ããã¨æãčžŧčĻå§ããĻãããã¨ãŽčĄ¨ãã§ããŖãã
6
ãæĄæĨã¯čãĢįŊŽããĻããéãéããīŧåãŽããŧããĢããŧãŽæŦãåãåēãæēãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽãããæŦãŽčĄ¨į´ã¯įãããŖãæįŠãäŊŋãå¤ããčģé´ã§č¸ãŋã¤ãļãįģåã¨ãåŗä¸ããį¸ĻãĢããĢãĒãšãã¤ããŧãŽį´ãã¨ããéĄåã¨ã2åããģãŠå°ããĒåã§čč
ãįĸåŗļæĄæĨãŽåãéģãå¤Ēãã´ãˇãã¯äŊã§č¨ãããĻãããæĨįŧãįããæąããĢããåŖåãå
¨ãčĻããĒãããŽæŦã¯ãäģå°č¸ãåŧĩãŖãĻåŽäžĄãŽäžĄå¤ãä¸ģåŧĩããĻããããã ãŖãã
ãã襨į´ãĢå ã
ã¨į§ãŽååãå
ĨãŖãĻããžãããæĨããããããã¨ããã§ããæŖįæŖéãä¸čēĢã¯æ æŖŽå
įãåĩäŊããåãŽéˇįˇ¨ããŠãŧå°čĒŦã¨ãĒããžãã
ãččå¤Ģäēēã¯ãå¤ąį¤ŧããžããã¨ãæĄæĨãĢæãããĢãĒãšãã¤ããŧãŽį´ããæãĢåãã¨ãčžæ¸ãåŧããããĢããŠããŠã¨ããŧã¸ãæ˛ãŖãããããĻæåžãŽããŧã¸ãĢč¨čŧãããåĨĨäģã§æãæĸããã¨ãæĄæĨãĢčããããčãããĒãããŽåŖ°ã§ãįēčĄæĨ2012åš´âĻâĻãããŠãŧå°čĒŦãâĻâĻãã¨ãåããã
ãããããããŽįĩ᎝ãæéãããããæįãĢãčĒŦæããžããã
ãæĄæĨã¯æŦã¨åããããĢéããåįŽãŽååēå
Ĩããåãåēãã¨ãããŽä¸ããčĒčēĢãŽååēãīŧææãåēããččå¤Ģäēēã¸æ¸ĄãããããŽååēãĢã¯åŊŧãŽååãŽä¸ãĢãåļæĨé¨ä¸ģäģģãã¨ããčŠæ¸ã¨ãæščĄãåãããŠãŗãã§ãå°čĒŦåŽļãã¨č¨čŧãããĻããã
ããæŖį´ãį§ãäģããããĻå°čĒŦåŽļãåäšãããŽã¯ãæ æŖŽå
įãŽãããã§ããããã§ãã
ãããããæĄæĨãčĒãŖã芹ãŽå¤§įã¯ãččå¤Ģäēēã¯äēåãĢãããŖãĻããæį´ã§įĨãŖãĻãããããããæį´ã¨į´æĨæŦäēēããčãã芹ã§ã¯å°čąĄãéåã¨éãŖãĻãããæĄæĨãŽčĒŦæã¯æį´ãŽå
厚ãčŖåŽããčĒŦæãä¸ģã§ãããåŊŧãč¨ããããĢããģãŠæéã¯åãããĒããŖãã
ãæĄæĨã¯å¤§åĻã§īŧåš´éãįĩæ¸åĻãåĻãã ãåæĨåžãŽé˛čˇ¯ã¯čããįĨčãįēæŽã§ããã¨ã¯æããĒããįĻįĨį¨å
ˇãŽč˛ŠåŖ˛ããŦãŗãŋãĢãĩãŧããšãåąéããä¸å°äŧæĨã¸ã¨å°ąãããã¤ãžããäģãŽåį´įãã¨åãããããä¸čŦįãĒ莿Ĩ鏿ã§ãããååŧå
ã¨ãĒãį
éĸãéĢéŊĸč
æ¯æ´æŊč¨ã¸č쿤
åããšããŦãããŖãŧãŽč˛ˇæŋææĄã¨ããŖãåļæĨæĨåã¯ãå¤å°ãŽå°éįįĨčãåŋ
čĻã¨ããããæ°å
ĨčˇåĄãŽå¤§å¤æ°ãæãĄåãããį´ į´ãã§ããããŽæĨåãĢåžäēãããã¨ãã§ãããããããããæå¤ãŽæĨåãĢããŖãĻåŊŧã¯äģäēãĢ寞ãããããããæŠããčĻå¤ąãŖãĻããããããããĩã¤ããŦãŧãĢãåŖãããããååčŗŧå
Ĩããæã¨åãåžĄčĻįŠæ¸ããĄããã ãããéĸå
ãŽ200å°čŋãããč쿤
åãå
¨é¨ããŧããŗã¯ãŋã¤ã¤ãĢãããåšžããĢãĒããŽãčĻįŠãåēããĻãã¨ããŖããå
æšãããŽåčĒŋãĒčĻįŠæ¸äŊæäžé ŧãį´åæĨåããåĨãĢčĒåãããĒããĻããããŽã§ã¯ãã¨ããįåãåŊŧãŽå°ąå´ææŦ˛ãĢåŊąãčŊã¨ããããããĒįåãææãããããĢ῝ãĢäģäēãĢåãåãã°åãåããģãŠãįãããšããããããä¸čļŗããĻããįąæã¯ãįŠēįããŽãããĢčĒäŋĄãæģžããããã¨ã¯įĄããŖãã
ã3åš´ãįĩãĄãæĄæĨã¯ååŧå
ã¸čĄãã¨æŗ¨æįŠåãæ¸ãįãããããæãŽã˛ããĢį´ãžããĄãĸ叺ããã¤ãåˇĻæãĢæãĄįŦéĄãæēãããŽãįŋæ
Ŗã¨ããĻãããããŽé ãĢã¯ãåĨãĢčĒåãããĒããĻããããŽã§ã¯ãã¨ããįåãĢæããããã¨ã¯ãĒããĒãŖãĻããããããããã¯åĨŊčģĸįãĒåŋæ
ãŽå¤åã§ã¯æąēããĻãĒããåŊŧã¯čããĢããããĸã¤ããŗããŖããŖãŽåĒå¤ąãæããã¨ããŽæ°æãĄã䏿¯æ§ãŽããæĒįŋã§įēæŖããæ§ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããŽã ã
ãããŖããã¯ãæĨ常ãŽä¸įŦã ãŖããããŽæĨãæĄæĨã¯æĩ´åޤį¨ãŽãšããŦãããŖãŧå°å
Ĩãæ¤č¨ããĻããį
éĸãŽč¨åæ
åŊč
ããéģ芹ã§ãååčĒŦæãŽããæĨéŊæĨéĸããĻé ããããã¨äžé ŧãåãããæ
åŊč
ãŽäžé ŧåŖčĒŋã¯ä¸æã§ã¯ããŖãããį´ãããĒãæį¤ēã§ãããã¨ã¯æįŊã§ããŖãã
ãæĄæĨã¯ããšãåæĨãĢåžšå¤ãčĻæããåĻįãĢäŧŧãįĻãã¨éä¸åãããŖãĻčŗæããžã¨ããããããĻį¤žį¨čģãŽãšã¤ããã§éĢéé莝ãå
åãŽãĒãŽãĒãŽéåēĻã§īŧæéčĩ°ãå
æšãŽį
éĸã¸æĨãã ã嚸éãĢãčǰãããåčģãåŊãããããã¨ãĒããéĢéé莝ãéãããã¨ãã§ããã
ãį
éĸã¸å°įãįˇåæĄå
ãŽåĨŗæ§čˇåĄã¸æĨéĸäēåŽãäŧãįĩããã¨ããã¤ããŽįã§č¸ããąãããããĄãĸ叺ãåãåēãåˇĻæã§æãŖããå°ãåž
ã¤ã¨ãæ
åŊč
ãããŖããã¨ããčļŗåãã§įžããããããĻéåŖä¸įĒããįŗã荺ãããžãããæĨãĒäŧč°ãå
ĨãŖãĻããžãäģæĨãŽååčĒŦæã¯ãĒãšãąã§ãéĄãããžããã¨äŧããĻãããæ
åŊč
ãŽčĄ¨æ
ããããã¯ã䏿ãĒãŽã¯åŖčĒŋã ãã§ãããã¨ãæĄæĨã¯æãã¨ãŖãã
ãæĄæĨã¯ãæŋįĨããžãããã¨ãįŦéĄã§įãæ
åŊč
ã¨äēãä¸äŧ芹ãäē¤ããåžãĢæˇąã
ã¨ä¸į¤ŧãããĻãããŽå ´ãåžãĢãããéčļŗã§į¤žį¨čģãĢæģãã¨ãåˇĻæãĢæãŖãĻãããĄãĸ叺ãĢãéģ芹ã§äŧããæšæŗãæãã¤ããĒããĒãã ãĒãã ãã ããäģæšãĒããã¨ãč¸ãŽå
ãåãåēããããĢæ¸ã掴ãŖãĻããããŽãĒãŽãĒã§ããŖããããå°ãã§æĄæĨã¯įĩļåĢããįēįãã寸åã§ããŖããŽã ããã
Â
ããčǰã§ãã§ããæ§ãĒäģäēãĢå°ąããĒãããéĻŦéšŋãĢããããĻããããããĒįŦŦä¸č
ãããŽå˛įŦãææ
ĸãĒããĒããŖãã
Â
ãããŽæĨããæĄæĨã¯å˛įŦãæãããã¨ãčĩˇããåēĻãįĩļåĢãĢčŗãčĄåãåˇĻæãĢæã¤æå¸ŗãĢåãåēãããããŽčĄåã¯æĄæĨãŽį˛žįĨã䏿°ãĢããĨãŧããŠãĢãĢæģãã¨åæãĢãããŽãĄãĸ叺ãããčŊã¨ããã¨ããĻãæ¸ãæŽ´ãããæåãŽįž
åã¯ãéč¨ãŽãããĒæ§į¸ã§ããŖãããå
厚ãå¤åĨã§ããĒãã¨ãã2ã¤ãŽåŠįšãããŖãã
ããĄãĸ叺ã¸ãŽįĩļåĢã¯æĄæĨã20äģŖãįĩããé ãĢãĒãã¨ãįŠčĒã¨ããĻãŽčŖ
éŖžãčŋŊå ãæ¸ãæŽ´ããããã¨ãåĸããã
ããããĄã¨ãĢã¯äēåãĢãäŧēããŽãĄãŧãĢéãŖã¨ãããã ãæéŗ´ãæŖããããŽã¯č¨ąããĻãããããĄãŧãĢåäŋĄãããã¨ãåŋãããŽã¯čĨåš´æ§åĨåŋįãŽããã ãããĒãååã¯į°å¤ãĢæ°ãĨãããããããĄã¨ã¯äēēæããĒããĻäŧ芹ãĒããčǰã¨ããĻãããããããĒã
ããäŊåēĻããšããŦãããŖãŧããļãŖåŖããįįąã¯čŖŊåãឿĒãĒããããããããäŊŋãŖãĻããĒãĄã¨ãŽé ãឿĒåã§äŊŋãæšããããããããã ããããã¨ãããšãŋãããããã¨åŖããĻããããããŽãīŧããŖã¨äŧį¤žãŽæ¯æãčŗéãäŊãããĻåĢããããããĻãã ãã
ããããããŽįĩļåĢãč¨ãããĄãĸ叺ããæŦæĨãŽäŊŋãæšã¨ããĻåŊäēēããĄãŽåã§å ã
ã¨éãã¨ããæĄæĨã¯äŊã¨ãč¨ã襨ããĒãæãããæãããããŽæãããŽåģļéˇã§ãåŊŧã¯čĒåŽ
ã§ãĄãĸ叺ãĢæ¸ãããäēēįŠããĄãŽįŠčĒãåēããããé°æ¨ãĒįĩæĢãčŋããįŠčĒãäŊãä¸ãããã¨ãĢįąä¸ãã ããããããåŊŧãŽååąã§é°æ¨ãĒåĩäŊæ´ģåãŽå§ãžãã§ããŖããå
ã
åŊŧã¯åĻįãŽé ããæ æŖŽååŖąãŽåŽļææãĢæēãĄãããšããĒãŧå°čĒŦãčĒãã ããããŽãåĨŊãã§ããŖãããããŽååąãĒåĩäŊæ´ģåã¯åŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻããįžåŽįã§ããŖããããåžåããĻãããã¨ã¨ãĒãã
ã
ããââããããĻåŽæããå°čĒŦãčĨåš´æ§čĒįĨįãįēįããä¸ģäēēå
ŦãããæŽéã ãããã¨ããč¨čãĢããæ´čŗãåããæŦĄã
ãæŽēäēēãčĄããĩã¤ãŗããŠãŧå°čĒŦãããŽããĢãĒãšãã¤ããŧãŽį´ãã§ãããâĻâĻéãããååã¨č¨ãŖãæšãããã§ããããã¨ãæĄæĨã¯čĒŦæãįĩãã ã
ããããŽäŊåã¯äŊããããŽčŗãį˛ãŖããŽã§ããīŧãččå¤Ģäēēã¯ããä¸åēĻããĢãĒãšãã¤ããŧãŽį´ããæãĢåããĒããčŗĒåããã
ããããããæŽåŋĩãĒããããã æ°äēēå°čĒŦãåéããĻãããŗãŗã¯ãŧãĢã¸įãŖį̝ããåŋåããĻã¯ãŋãžãããåŋåčĻåŽãĢåããããããĢãæåæ°ãčĒŋæ´ãããč¨åŽãå°ãå¤ãããã¨ããĒããã°ãĒããžããã§ããããããã¯ããã§æĨŊããããŽã§ãããããŽä¸ãŽ1ã¤ãŽčŗã§æįĩé¸čãĢãžã§æŽããŽã§į˛žä¸æ¯ã§ããã
ããããããããĒããŽã§ãããããŧãĄããã¯ããŽæŦãæ¸ããĻããžããããīŧã
ãããããæ æŖŽå
įãŽčŠąã¯ããããã§ããį§ã¯æįĩé¸čãĢæŽãŖããã¨ãĢããŖãĻį´æĨᎍéč
ãŽæšã¨ãäŧããããã¨ãĢãĒããžãããå ´æã¯éŊå
ãŽæŧåãŽããĄããĒãŧãŦãšããŠãŗã§ãæ¨æļããããããĢãåãŽäŊåã¯čĄ¨įžãããžããĢãåšŧããæåãįŽã§ãĒããŖãįŦéãæŗåãĢããŖãĻåŖãæ˛ããããã§ãĒãã¨ãããĒããã¨ãä¸éããŽæ´åįãĒããĄåēããããããžããããããããŖãąãį§ãĢã¯æčŊããĒããã ãã¨ãčŊãĄčžŧãã§ããã¨ãããŽäŊåãéĸįŊããŖãĻãããčŠäžĄããĻãããå
įããããã ãããã¯ææĄãĒãã ããŠããŠãã ããããŽå
įããå°ããĸããã¤ãšã貰ãã¨ãããŽã¯īŧãã¨ãææĄãåãããã§ãã
ããããŽå
įãããŧãĄããã ãŖããã§ããīŧã
ããã¯ããããŽéãã§ããæĄæĨã¯ččå¤Ģäēēãå䏿 æŖŽå
įããããŧãĄãããã¨éĻ´ãéĻ´ãããåŧãļãã¨ãĢ寞ããįĩļåĢãããčĄåãĢé§ããã ããã
Â
7
ããããŧãĄããã¯æĄæĨãããŽå°čĒŦãčĒãã ä¸ã§ãŽãĸããã¤ãšãĒããããã¯æĄæĨãããŽå°čĒŦã¨č¨ãŖãĻããžãŖãĻãããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããŽã§ããīŧã
ãããĸããã¤ãšį¨åēĻãĒãããã§ããããã§ããį§ãŽåĩäŊããå°čĒŦã¨ã¯č¨åŽãŽæ šåššãããšããŧãĒãŧæ§æã¨ãŠãšããĢčŗãããŽå
¨ãĻã夿´ããããĻããžããį§ãŽãĒãĒã¸ããĢã¨ããĻæŽãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãäēēįŠãŽååį¨åēĻã§ãããžããããžã§ãŽæ æŖŽå
įãŽåãããŖããããããåēįãĢããįãããã¨ãã§ããã¨ããčĻæšãã§ããžãã
ããããŽæŦã¯æģäēēãåēããã§ããããīŧã
ããīŧäēēæŽēãããžãããããåé ãĢčĄæšä¸æã¨ããããĻããåãŠããåŽã¯æŽēãããĻãããŽã§ãæŖåŧãĢã¯īŧäēēã§ãããã
ããããŽīŧäēēã¯ä¸ģäēēå
Ŧã¨ãŠãããŖãéĸäŋã§īŧã
ããīŧäēēįŽã¨īŧäēēįŽã¯ä¸ģäēēå
ŦãŽčˇå ´ãŽååãīŧäēēįŽã¯ä¸ģäēēå
ŦãŽæ¯čĻĒãããããå
åļã¯ããŽæ¯čĻĒãĢãããžããčĨåš´æ§čĒįĨįãĢãĒãŖãä¸ģäēēå
Ŧã§ããä¸ģäēēå
ŦããæŽéã ãããã¨ããč¨čã§æ´čŗãããŽãããŽæ¯čĻĒã§ãããããĻīŧäēēįŽã¯ââã
ãããããã¨ãããããžããīŧäēēįŽã¯åãŠãã§ããããæŖį´ãéŠãã§ããããŧãĄããã¯ãĒãã§ãããĒãã¨ãâĻâĻã
ããå¤ąį¤ŧã§ãããččå¤Ģäēēã¯æ æŖŽå
įãåēįããæŦãŽįˇæ°ãŖãĻãåįĨã§ããīŧã
ããåēįįŠãĢããŖãĻã¯ããŧããĢããŧããæåēĢåãããããŽããããžãããæŖįĸēãĒåæ°ã¯ãĄããŖã¨ããããĒããããããžãããéˇã
ã¨ããŖã¨ããããįįąã芹ãččå¤ĢäēēãĢå¯žãæĄæĨã¯čįĢãĄãåãããã
ããæåēĢåããããŽã¯é¤ããĻ117åã§ãã
ãããããæãŖãĻãããå°ãĒããŽã§ããã
ãããããĒãã¨ã¯ãĒããã§ãīŧã ãŖãĻããã¯æ æŖŽå
įãŽäŊåŽļæ§ãčæ
Žããã°į°å¸¸ãĒæ°ã§ããä¸č˛ĢããĻåŽļææãããŧããĢæŽããĻãããŦããã¨ãĒãæ¸ãä¸ããäŊåã§ããŽįˇæ°ãĒãã§ããã
ãå°ããããããããããĒããģãŠãã¨įããã
ããã ããį§ã¯æ æŖŽå
įãŽæ°æãĄãå°ãã¯ããããĒãããĒããŽã§ããæ æŖŽå
įãčĒčēĢãŽäŊéĸ¨ãšãŋã¤ãĢãæ¨ãĻãĻå
¨ãåĨãŽã¸ãŖãŗãĢã¸ææĻãããã¨ããåĩäŊææŦ˛ãæ˛¸ããįĩæã ãŖããã ã¨į§ã¯čããžãã
ããã§ããããŽåĩäŊææŦ˛ãŽįĩæãĢæĄæĨãããį į˛ãĢãĒãŖãĻããã¨ã¯æããĒãããå
ã¯æĄæĨãããŽäŊåã ãŖãããŽããäģã§ã¯čǰãčĒãžãĒããããĒé§äŊãĢãããããããĻįĩæįãĢ貴æšãŽå°čĒŦåŽļäēēįãįĩããŖãĻããžãŖããã§ãããīŧã
ããâĻâĻã¯ããč¨ãæˇãã ã
ããį§ã¯ããŖãąãäēēãčĻãįŽããĒããŽãããããĒããĒãččå¤Ģäēēã¯ãæˇąãããæ¯ãåãããããŽããæ¯ãŽåããããå¯žčąĄããĒããæĄæĨã¯čĒåãŽãããĒæ°ãããĻãĒããĒããŖãã
ããããŧãĄããã¯ãĒããŖãŧããģããã¯ããŗãå°æžéžäšäģãčĻįŋãã°ãããŖãã¨æããĒãīŧã
ããããã§ãããæĄæĨã¯ååãĢåēãäēēåãŽæ¤č¨ãã¤ãããããŖããĒã᏿§ããã§ããĒããŖãã
ããããããæŦåŊãĢããããããĻãæŦåŊãĢæŽåŋĩããããŧãĄããã¯ããŽäŊåãŽįļããæ¸ãããã¨ãäģã§ã¯æ¯æĨ貴æšãŽå¤ĸãĢåēãĻãããã§ããããã
ããã¯ããééãããããžããã
ãåŋčĢåã§ããŖããæĄæĨã¯ččå¤Ģäēēãé¨ãéããéããå°æĨįãĢįļįˇ¨ãŽæŦãĒãŠåēįã§ããã°æéĢã§ãããããããĒããã¨ãįŽįã¨ããĻããĒããåŊŧãŽįŽįã¯åĨãŽã¨ãããĢããŖã
ãââäģã¯ãã ãįŽãŽåãŽéĻŦéšŋãĒåĨŗããææããã°ããã
ãã貴æšãĢãžãåšžã¤ãčŗĒåãããããã§ããããã
ããã¯ããį§ãĢįããããį¯å˛ã§ããããįãããããžãã
ããå¤ĸãĢįžããããŧãĄããã¯å
æ°ããã§ãããäēĄããĒãã¨ããŽįãŋãåŧããĨããããĒãã¨ã¯ãĒãããã§ãããīŧã
ããã¯ããæ æŖŽå
įã¯å
æ°ã§ãã
ããããŧãĄããã¯ããŽå°čĒŦãŽįļãããŠãããŖãĻåˇįãããŽã§ããīŧã
ããæŽãŠã¯å¤ĸã§ãäŧãããã¨ããŽåŖäŧãĢãĒããžããããã䏿Ļãį§ãæ¸
æ¸ãæ¸ãåēãããŽããį§ãŽé¨åąãĢįŊŽããĻããããããčĻãĻãããŖãĻæ æŖŽå
įãĢ荿ŖįŽæãããã°ææããĻãããæ¸ãį´ãããããåŽæãããžã§įļããžãã
ããããŧãĄããã¯č˛´æšãŽé¨åąãŽæ§åãčĻãããŽã§ããīŧã
ããå¤ĸãŽčæ¯ãį§ãŽé¨åąãĒãã§ãã
ãããĒããģãŠãããŽäŊåãåŽæããããŠããããã§ããīŧã
ããåŋčĢåēįãããŽã§ãããããŽåŽįžãĢåããĻččå¤ĢäēēãĢåŖæˇģããããĻããã ããããŽã§ãã
ããåŖæˇģãã§ããīŧã
ããã¯ããæ æŖŽå
įãŽå¨å
ãå°ãåããã¨ã§ãč¨ããžããããããžãããã¯čŋŊã
į¸čĢãĢãĒãã¨æããžãã
ãããĒããģãŠįč§Ŗããžãããããã§ã¯æåžãĢãį§ãĢã¤ããĻäŊãããŧãĄããã¯č¨ãŖãĻã¯ããžããã§ãããīŧã
ããåĻģã¸ãŽæčŦãäŧããĻãããã¨ããŖãããŖãĻãããžããã
ããå
¨ãæ°ãĢéŖããžããããããŽčĄ¨æ
ã¯äēĄãå¤ĢãĢ寞ããå¤ąæãŽé°ããŽãããĢæĄæĨã¯æããåŦãããŖãã
ãããããæ æŖŽå
įãŽč¨čãä¸čĒä¸åĨæŖããč¨ããžãã¨ââãããã§ččå¤ĢäēēãŽéˇãäēēåˇŽãæãæĄæĨãŽåãĢč§Ļããã
ãããåãŽãčĸĢåŽŗč
ã
ãŠãæ°ãĢãããããŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻãã ãã
Â
8
ãããåãŽå¤ĸãĢåēãĻããããŧãĄãããĢã¤ããĻãããŽįžčąĄãŽįåŊã¯į§ãĢã¯ããããžãããããããããŽããŧãĄããã¯į§ãåž
ãĄæãã§ããããŧãĄããã§ãĒããã¨ã ãã¯įĸēãã§ãã
ãããĒãã§ãããĒé
ˇããã¨ãč¨ãããã§ããīŧããŽäŧčŠąãæ æŖŽå
įãčããĻããããŠã፿˛ãããããããĢââã
ãããã§æĄæĨã¯č¨čãåãŖããįŽãŽåãŽččå¤Ģäēēããžãã§įŊĒäēēã§ãããããŽãããĢæĄæĨãæãããã¨ãĢããææ
ĸãã§ããĒããŖããæŦæĨãåŊŧã¯ããŽį¨ŽãŽčįĢãĄãæąãčŗæ ŧãããĒããããããæãããĢčĒåãããæ æŖŽå
įãŽãã¨ãįĨããããĒãå°å¨ãĢæåŽããããããŽä¸įšããŠããããããĒãåŊŧãčã¤ããããŽã ã
ãããåãĢæ æŖŽå
įãŽãĒãĢãããããã ããæĄæĨã¯æããĢäģģããĻåĢãã ã
ãããåããã¯ããããžããīŧãåã芹ãŽåæããã§ãĢééãŖãĻããã§ãããããŧãĄãããæŦåŊãĢããŖã117åį¨åēĻãŽå°čĒŦãŽåēįã§æēčļŗããĻããã¨æãŖãĻãããŽã§ããīŧã
ãããã§æĄæĨã¯ččå¤ĢäēēãčĒåãĢ寞ããåŧãŗæšããæĄæĨããããããã¤ãŽéãĢãããåããĢå¤ããŖãĻãããã¨ãĢæŧ¸ãæ°ãã¤ããããããĻããŽčĄæãããåŊŧãŽæčãåˇĄããŽã¯ččå¤ĢäēēãŽį´åãŽč¨čã§ããã
ãââããŖã117åīŧ
ãããĄãããã§ããīŧãæĄæĨã¯ččå¤ĢäēēããåããčĄæãĢéŠããé ããĒããŖãã
Â
ããããŧãĄããã¯ãčåąąæŧä¸ãŽååã§ããŠãŧå°čĒŦãããŖã¨æããåēįããĻãããžãã
Â
ãããŽč¨čã¯ãæĄæĨãĢčŖå¤ãŽįĩæãäŧããææåšĄãŽãããĢå§åįãĒæįã¤ãĄãŧã¸ãįŦæãĢæŗčĩˇãããã
ããããã âĻâĻã
ããã ããããããããåãŽäŊåã¨ããĻããŠãŧå°čĒŦãåēįããæåŗããĒããã§ããã
ã
ããŠãį¨ãŽæéãįĢãŖãã ããããéå¯ãæĸãĢæĄæĨãŽįãã§ããŖãã
ã
ãããåãŽčŠąãäŋĄãããĢčļŗãããĒãįšãäģãĢããããžããããŧãĄããã¯į§ãĢåããŖãĻãåĻģã¸ãŽæčŦãããĒããĻč¨čã¯įĩļ寞ãĢč¨ããĒãããã§ãããæŖį´ãæŗåããã ãã§æ°æãĄæĒãã
ããæåŗãåãããĒãããããĒãããĒãã ãã
ããããŖãąãæŗååãäšãããã§ãããããŽæŽåŋĩãĒæŗååã§ãŠããį§ãææãæãã¨ã§ãčãããã§ãããããŽæįšã§ããŧãĄãããčããĻãžããããŧãĄããã¯ããŽį¨åēĻãŽåĨŗã¨æˇģãéããį¨åēĻãŽįˇã ã¨ããããĻãæ´ãĢææĒãĒãŽã¯ããåã¯čĒåčĒčēĢãŽäŊåãæ¨ãĻãĻããžãŖãããåĩäŊč
ãĢã¨ãŖãĻäŊåã¯æãåã ãã¨ãããŧãĄããã¯ããã¤ãŗãŋããĨãŧã§č¨ãŖãĻããããåã¯ãäģæĨæãåã¨ãŽį¸ãčĒåããåãŖããã ã
ããéãīŧããŽé§äŊãæ¸ãããŽã¯æ æŖŽå
įã īŧäŋēã¯ããŖã¨åãäŊåãæ¸ããīŧã
ã
ããããĄã¨ãŽããŠã¤ããŽãããĢæãåãĢčēĢåŖ˛ããããĻãŠãããã ãīŧã
ã
ãæĄæĨãŽåŧį§°ãå°ãĢčŊãĄãįŦéãããã¯ããččå¤ĢäēēãåŊŧãčĻéãŖããã¨ãæåŗããĻããã
Â
9
ããåãŠããããĒããåããããŖããããĢ芹ããĒīŧäŋēã¯æ æŖŽå
įã¨æ¯å¤äŧãŖãĻããã ãããããĻæããĻããããã ãéēįŖįŽåŊãĻãŽãåãĢæŽēããããŖãĻãĒãã ããäŋēãæ æŖŽå
įãæãããĒããŖãå¤ĸãæãããã ãããŠãŧå°čĒŦã§ãæ æŖŽååŖąãŽååãčŊããããã īŧãåãåĻåŽããäŋēãŽå¤ĸãĢįžããå
įã¨å
ąãĢãĒããåãæ æŖŽå
įã¨å
ąãĢéãããæéã¯ãããŖã1åš´å°ãã īŧã ãäŋēã¯ããããæ°¸é ãĢä¸įˇã īŧäŊåš´ããäŊååš´ããĒīŧäŋēãŽä¸ãĢįããæ æŖŽå
įãä¸įˇãĢãĒãŖãĻãåãââã
ããããŽįēč¨ããã§ãĢããĄã¨ã¨ãããŧãĄãããįšããŖãĻãĒããæąēåŽįãĒč¨ŧæ ãĒãã ãããã¨ââã
ãäģãĢãå¸ãįĢãĄãčĨ˛ãæãããããĒæĄæĨãĢ寞ããččå¤Ģäēēã¯ãããžã§åˇéãĢįžåŽãįĒãã¤ããã
ããč¨čãĢã¯ãæ°ãã¤ããã ãããããŽé¨åąãĢã¯įŖčĻãĢãĄãŠãåãäģããããĻããžãããããĻããŽæ åã¯éčģĸå¸ãĢåãäģããæļ˛æļãĸããŋãŧã§å¸¸æčĻãããĻããžãããããĄã¨ãŽįēč¨ä¸ã¤ã§ãããŽãĸãã¤ãĢãĒããŖãšãéčģĸããĻããåĒį§ãĒéčģĸæã¯ããã¤ã§ãéĢéãŽčˇ¯čŠãĢæŋįĒããčĻæãæãŖãĻããæšã§ãããããããåˇéãĢã
Â
10
ãéģæ°čĒåčģããĨããZ EVãããŧãšãĢãããĸãã¤ãĢãĒããŖãšã¯æģãæ§ãĢéĢéãåä¸ããéčģĸå¸ã¨åŠæå¸ãĢåē§ãīŧäēēãä쿍æžå¸ã¸ã¨éãļã
ããččããããããĒæãã§čŠąãåãããããĒãį§æŦĄããã¯ååããžããããéčģĸå¸ã§ããŗããĢãæĄãåĨŗæ§ã¯ččå¤Ģäēēã¨ãããžã§åš´éŊĸãå¤ãããĒãæ§ãĢčĻããããåŗããåŖčĒŋã§äģåãŽčŠąãåããĢã¤ããĻææãããã
ãããããĄãããåš´ãæŽãŠå¤ãããĒããã ããį§ãŽãã¨ã¯ãããŧãĄããããŖãĻåŧãã§ãŖãĻäŊåēĻãč¨ãŖãĻãããīŧãččå¤Ģäēēã¯äģãžããĢåããæå°ãŽåŖčĒŋããããã¯ããããæ§ãĢįããã
ããæ æŖŽãããį§æŦĄããã¯ååã¯č´ããžããã
ããããããĒããīŧã¸ã§ãŧããŗã ãã¸ã§ãŧããŗããããĄããã¯åčĢãéããĒããĒã
ãããããæĄæĨãããæ´ããĻãã¨ããĻãį§åŖãĢæŋįĒãĒããããžããã§ãããã
ããããã¯ä¸į¨ŽãŽč
ãã ãããããĢæĄæĨããã¯ããããŖãäēēãããĒããã
ãããĒããŽäŋĄé ŧã§ããããã
ãããšããŦãšį¤žäŧã§įããĻããä¸ãå¯ä¸čĒåãŽčĒããããŽãäŧį¤žã§čĒããããĒããĻčžããŖãã ãã ããã ãããããŽčĒãã§ããŖãããŽãåŖããĻãžã0ããé åŧĩããã¨ãããã ããããŖã¨æĄæĨããã¯ãããŖã¨åŋã§åĢãã§ããã ã¨æãããã芹ãččå¤ĢäēēãŽåˇĻæãĢã¯ãæĄæĨãããããŖããå°čĒŦåŽļãã¨æ¸ãããååēãæĄãããĻããã
ãå
ãģãŠæĄæĨã¸éåå ´æã¨æåŽããĻããé§čŧĒå ´ã¸ãĸãã¤ãĢãĒããŖãšã¯ãéˇãããŠã¤ãããæģãæĄæĨãä¸ããããããŽãããĢã¯ččå¤ĢäēēãŽåŊŧãĢ寞ããåŧį§°ã¯æģãŖãĻããããããĻããã¯æĄæĨãč
šãå˛ãŖãĻč¸ãŽå
ããããåēãããã¨ã襨ããĻããã
ããããŧãããč¨ãã°ãã¤ããčåąąæŧä¸ã¯æ æŖŽå
įã¨åä¸äēēįŠãĢãĒãŖãããã§ããīŧãããã¯ä¸æãĢããä¸įšččå¤Ģäēēãåã芰ããĒããã°ãĒããĒãč°éĄãæãåēããåŖ°ãčããã
ããããŖãããŖãąãæ°äģããīŧã
ããčåąąæŧįĨãŽå¤§ããĄãŗãŽį§ãæ°äģããĒããããĒãã§ãããããã¯åŖãå°ãããã
ããæĄæĨãããŖãĻčĒæ¸åĨŊããéĢããĻå°čĒŦåŽļãĢãĒãŖããŋã¤ããããĒãããã ãŖãããããŦãĒãããĒãŖãĻããããĢããčåąąæŧįĨãŽäŊåãįĨãŖãĻããĻããæčŋæ°äŊįē襨ããĻãĒãããĒãã¨ããĒãããĒãŖãĻã
ããįžå¨éæã§éčĒãĢæ˛čŧããĻããå°čĒŦãæĨåš´åēįäēåŽã§ããã
ããããŖãããŖãąãæãŖãããäģäēããĻãĒããã
ãããããããã帰ãŖãåžãæŦäēēãĢč¨ãŖããããĄã§ãããččãããŽåŽļãŽãįåŽįĒãĒãã¨ãåŧãåããĻãããŖããã§ãããã
ããããŧãįĩæ§ããĒããĒã§åŧãåããĻãããã¨æãŖãĻããŽãĢã
ãããã¤ãŦäŧæŠã¨ããã¤ãŗãŋãŧãĢãããžããīŧã
ããį§ã¯å¤§ä¸å¤ĢããĒããšãæŠã帰ãŖãĻããŧãĄããã帰ãŖãĻãããŽãåž
ãŖãĻããããããã
Â
Â
Â