
èã«éããã㊠ã2. Methodsã
åã®è©±ïŒã1. Introductionã
æãéšå±ã®äžã§ã倢ãã€ã€ã®å¢çãææ§ã«ãªããããªæ°é
ã®äžã
äœåŠãããšããªãããã®äžå¯è§£ãªç©é³ãšãšãã«ããŸã¯ãŸã¯ãšããå·æ°ãæŒã£ãŠããã
æãæãåžå£ã®å€ãäžç¥ããŠãããã¯ãäœãããããã«ã¯èŠããªãã
ã ããããã«é ããŠãããããšæå
ã®éãèç¡ã®ç©ºéãæå·®ãã
颚ãªã©ãªããšããã®éã¯åŸ®åŒ±ã«æºããå°ããã€éŠãæ¯ã£ãŠããã
åŸäœã®ç¥ããªã圱ã®éãå¯ãé³ã鿥çã«ãã®åããããªã¢ã«ã¿ã€ã ã«æ ãåºãããã
ãã¯ã³ãã¯ã³ãšæ³¢æã€å¿èãè¿žãæ±ãããã§ãäœãšãèšé²ããã°ââããæããã³ãæ¡ã£ãç¬éã
éãå¢ãããé³ã鳎ããããããããšåãåºããã
ïŒ
ãæ¹äœééïŒã
æ°ç·ãä»ãã«éŠãããŽãŒã«ãã³ãŠã£ãŒã¯æãã®å¹³æ¥ã
æ¥å
ã®è³ãããäžæ®µèœãã鿣ãšããé£å ã®ååŸ3æéããéçãšå¯æšã¯å®äœçœ®ã«éãŸã£ãŠããã
äºäººãå²ãæºã«ã¯çãå¡©ããæããããããå®ããè人圢ãªã©ããã«ãæªãããªã¢ã€ãã ãç«ã¡äžŠã¶ãä»ã«ãåªãã®ååŒãå§ãŸããããªé°å²æ°ã®äžãéçã¯éå€ãªéå ·ã®å±±ããå¹³ããåç€ãã²ãããšæŸãäžãããããªãã ãã©ããšå¯æšã«èŠããã
ããã¯æã«ä¹ããµã€ãºã®ç©äœã§ãã¬ã©ã¹èã®äžã«ã¯2çš®é¡ã®éãèŠããã
æåã«ã¯çãéãããããã®å¯ååã«äœéèšã黿µèšã«äŒŒãç®çãå°ããæç¶ã«äžŠã¶ãçŸåšæã瀺ããŠããå€ã¯ã»ãšãã©0ã«çããã
äžæ·ãæãã§å¥¥ã«ã¯é·éãããã軞ãäžå¿ã«360床åããç³ãæšã§äœããããããªè³ªæã®éã§ãç端ã®ã¿èµ€ããåè§£ãããšÂ å³1 ã®ããã«ãªãã ããã

ãäœãšããããæèšãšã³ã³ãã¹ãè¶³ããŠ2ã§å²ã£ããããªïŒã
ãã«ã³ãšå£ãéããŠãã坿šãåããåé¡éãè§£ãæãæ¢ãŸããæ©20åãçµéããŠããã
ããã£ã±ããããªæãã«èŠãããããååããæ¹äœç£éããããã£ãã ãã ãã
ããèšããéçã¯ãã®éå
·ã坿šã®æ¹ã«çœ®ããã
åè«ååã§ãã©ãæž¡ãããããŸãããããªããšã¯ã坿šã¯é ã«æãåœãŠãã
éçã¯ãã®åŸãªã«ç ã®æ°æãèŠããéšå®€ã§å¹œéé¢é£ã°ããºã®æ°ã ãè§ŠãããŠããã£ããšãããããã«ãã®å Žã§ä»å ¥ããæ å ±ãåºã«ããã€ã代ãã¯ãããŠæªãããªé販ãµã€ãããèªåã®éå ·ãäžåŒæããããã ã
ãæ¡ã®å®ãããã»ãšãã©ã¯çåŸãªæ°ãããŠããŠãæ¬åœã«äœ¿ãç©ã«ãªãã®ãã¯å€§åæªãããšããã ã£ãâŠâŠãã®æ¹äœééãé€ããŠã
ããèªãéçã®ç®ã®ã¯ãã¯ã以åãããæ¿ããªã£ãŠããããã®1ã¶æã®éãä»¶ã®éãšééãã床ã«ãããã®éå
·ã®å¹çšã詊ããŠããããšã窺ããã
èŠé£ã®æ»²ã颚è²ã§ãã£ãããå£èª¿ã®æ¹ã¯æå€ã«ãæ¢ã«èœã¡çããŠãããæ¹äœééã«åžæãèŠåºããããã ãããã
ããšã¯ãããã£ã±ãç¢ºèšŒã¯æãŠãŠãªããŠããããã§ä»æ¥ã坿šãåŒãã ã®ã
è ãçµã¿ãèšããã«æºäžã®ã³ã³ãã¹ãçºãã坿šã
ããã®ãŸãŸãªã«ç ã§çžè«ã«ä¹ã£ãŠè²°ãã°è¯ãã£ãã®ã«ããªãã§ïŒã
åœç¶ã®çåã ãããããèšãããéçã¯å€©äºãèŠã€ããªãããåœæã®ãããšããæãèµ·ããã
ããªã«ç ã®äººãã¡ã«ãšã£ãŠæªç°ãå ãã¯ãåºæ¬çã«è©±ã®ãã¿ã§ããããšã³ã¿ã¡ã®ææãªã®ãããããã°ããºã«ããŠããå®éã«å¹æããã®ããã©ãããã確ããããã®ããçªãè©°ããããšã«ã¯ãã»ã©é¢å¿ãé«ããªãããã§ãã寧ããã®èŸºãã«çްããèšåããããšãé¿ããŠããããã«ãèŠãããã
ãäžèª¬ã«ãããšããšããä¿¡ãããä¿¡ããªããã¯ããªã次第ãã®ç©ºæ°æãå®ã£ãŠããããšã§ãèšãã°è¯ãã®ããªâŠâŠãŸãèªåãã¡ãã£ãšåãŸã§ã¯ãã£ã¡å¯ãã®æèŠã§ãªã«ã«ããæããŠããããã ãããã®æåãæªããšã¯æããªããã ãã©ã
äœãšãªãç¶æ³ãå¯ãã坿šããæ¹äœééãæã«åãåŸããã
æ¹åæ§ã®éãããšããã¯ãŒããæµ®ãã¶ã
ãå°ãªããšãä»éçãæ©ãã§ããå«ç·ã®èª²é¡è§£æ±ºã«ã¯ç¹ãããªããã£ãŠãšããïŒã
ããã«ãããšéçã¯åã¿ç· ããããã«é ·ãã
ããã®ãŸãŸãã€èšªããã®ãåãããªãææã«ãæ¯ãç¶ãããã¯ãªãããã®åã®ç¢ºããããã¯å€§äºãªåé¡ãªã®ã
ããèšã£ãŠã坿šã®æã«ããè¡æ£èãã³ã³ãã¹ãæå·®ããã
ãããã®åãã£ãŠããã£ããæçæ¹§ããŠãã®ãâŠâŠã
ãªã«ç ããããããçµç·¯ã§è·é¢ãããããšããã®ã¯ãçŸæ©è²ã£ããšããŠã
æãããŠèªåãªããã®è©±ã®åœ¹ã«ç«ãŠãã®ã ãããïŒ
坿šã«ã¯ç¥ãç±ããªããšããã ããäœããä»ã«éçã®äºæ
ãç¥ã£ãŠãã人éãããªããã²ãšãŸããæ¹äœééã®è©±ã®ç¶ããèãããšã«ããã
ïŒ
ãã®æ¹äœééãšããã®ã¯ãæè¿ãã®çã®çéã§ããããæµè¡ãå§ããŠããã¢ã€ãã ã§ãããããã¢ããã°çã®ã°ãããïŒãã°ãæ¢ç¥æ©ïŒãšã§ãããã¹ãç©ãããã
çéã®æ¯ãã¯å¹œéã®æ¥è¿ãæå³ãããã®å±
æãé·éãæã瀺ãâŠâŠãšããåããã以äžã®ãŸãšããªèª¬ææžã¯ãªãã£ãã
ãããå®éã®äœ¿çšæãšããŠã¯ã確ãã«éçããããŸã§æããŠãããäœããã«åå¿ããŠãããã ãšããã
ããããããã°ãŸã§æ¥ãæ°é
ããããšãçéã¯å€§ããªå€ã瀺ãããããŠé·éãã«ã¿ã«ã¿ãšé³ãç«ãŠãŠäžèŠåã«åãåºããšã®ããšã
ã©ããã®æš¹æµ·ã§ã¯ã³ã³ãã¹ãå¹ããªãããšããè¿·ä¿¡ã圷圿ãšãããã
å°ãªããšãåãç¶æ³äžã§æ®éã®æ¹äœç£éãããã®ééãšåãæåã瀺ããªãããšã¯ç¢ºèªæžã¿ã ã£ãã
ãæ¬åœã«ããã§ã幜éã®å Žæãç¹å®ã§ããã®ãââæ©ãŸãããŠãã
ããéçããèããŠã坿šã¯æäžã®æ¹äœééãããã£ãšèŠã€ããã
äžèŠäœã®å€å²ããªããã®éããåæã«åãããåã£ããããã®ãïŒ
çŸç¶ããããªçŽ æ¯ãã¯äžåèŠããªãã
ïŒãããããããçã£ãŠã話ã¯é²ãŸãªããâŠâŠïŒ
坿šã¯äžæŠãéçã®å ±åå 容ãçã ãšçœ®ãããšã«ããã
ã ãšããã°ãéã¯äœããã®å€åã«ãã£ãŠåãçã ãéçã®ãã幜éãšãããä»®ã«ååšãããšããŠããã®åã§åŒã£åŒµã£ãŠããã®ã ãšããããé·éã®å ã«å¹œéãããã®ã¯èªç¶ã«æããã
é·éãã§ãããã«åãã®ã¯ã©ãããããšã ããïŒâŠâŠå¹œéãã³ã³ãã¹ã®çŽäžãŸã§æ¥ãŠããç¶æ³ãªããå¯èœæ§ãšããŠã¯ããåŸãã忥µã«æ¹äœç£éã眮ãã®ãçŸå®çãªã€ã¡ãŒãžã«è¿ãã ãããã
çéãæããåæ§ã®åçã§ããã®åŒã£åŒµãåã®åŒ·ããããã°ããã®åŠãéã®åãã«å€æããŠããããšããä»®èª¬ã¯æãç«ã€ã ããã
ããšãããããé·éãšéãåãã«é²ãã°ããã§è¯ãããããªãã®ïŒã
æçŽã«èãããšãããããããšã«ãªãæ°ããããã
ãæ¬åœã«ããèšãåã£ãŠè¯ãã®ããªãã
ãããªå¯æšã«å¯Ÿããæžãé¡ãåããéçã ã£ããåžããããªå£°ãšå ±ã«ã話ã¯ããåçŽãããªããšäž»åŒµããŠããã
ãããããã幜éãããå Žæã«ãã³ãã€ã³ãã§ååšãããªããŠèšããã®ããªïŒã
ãããã¯èšããªãããã ãã©ãäžæŠããã¯åçŽåããŠèããŠãè¯ãã®ã§ã¯ã
ãã ãšããŠããè€æ°ã®éãè¿ãã«ãããäžæãæ©èœããªããããäŸãã°ãããªãå¯èœæ§ãããã§ãããã
ãããã£ãŠéçã¯å¯æšã®æå ã«ãã£ãè£çŽã匷奪ããå³2 ãæãã

äžäžã®å¹œéã«åŒã£åŒµãããå Žåãéã¯ãã®äžéãæããŠããŸãã確ãã«ãã®æã®éãåãããæç«ãããªããé·éãæãæ¹åã¯å¿ ãããéã®ããæ¹åãšã¯äžèŽããªãã
ãåãããã©ããããŸã§å€§ããªåé¡ãªã®ãïŒã
ãã坿šã¯æããŠãéçã«èªã£ãã
ãæ¹äœééã¯æã«æã£ãŠèªç±ã«åããã§ãããé©åœã«æ°ã¶æã§èšæž¬ããã°ãå€å°ã®ãºã¬ã¯ããã©ã倧äœã©ã®èŸºã«éãããã®ãæ€èšã€ããããããªãïŒã
ããŸããããããããâŠâŠãããã§ããã
寧ã坿šã®é ãæ©ãŸããããšã«ãªã£ãã®ã¯ã次ã«éçãæç€ºããå¯èœæ§ã ã£ãã
ããããã幜éãçã£çŽãéãåŒã£åŒµã£ãŠãããããªã€ã¡ãŒãžã§æããŠããã©ããããã£ãŠæžŠãå·»ããŠããã±ãŒã¹ãåŠå®ã§ããªãããïŒâŠâŠããäœçœè¶³ããªããããã1æã¡ããã ãã
坿šãæž¡ããæ°ããè£çŽã«ãéçã¯Â å³3 ãæããã

ãããŒâŠâŠãªãã»ã©ãã
ãã®æãæ¹ã¯ãæ°Žã倧æ°ã®ãããªæµäœã«è¿ãæãæ¹ã ããã
ãªãã°ã幜éã¯é¢šåã®æ ãæããæã«ã§ããæžŠãšããå°é¢šã®ãããªååšã«åœãããæ¹äœééã¯ç£ç³ãšãããããã颚èŠé¶ã®ãããªé¢šåèšãšããŠæ©èœãããã
ãå·ãã空æ°ã®ãããªæ°é ãã£ãŠã€ã¡ãŒãžçã«ã¯ãã£ã¡ã®æ¹ããã£ããããããïŒã
ãã ãšæãã
坿šã®åãããã«ãéçã¯é ·ããã
確ãã«ãã®ä»®èª¬ã«åºã¥ãã°ãé·éã®å ã«å¹œéããããšã¯èšãããããæžŠã®å·»ãæ¹ã匷ããã°åŒ·ãã»ã©ããã®ãºã¬ã倧ãããªããæ°ã¶ææž¬å®ããçšåºŠã§ãååãšã¯èšããªãã ããã
ãèŠã¯ãå Žã«å転ãããã©ãããã£ãŠãšããã ãªã
ããã¯ããšãªãæ¢èŠæãããã¯ãä»ãŸãã«å¯æšãéžæå±¥ä¿®ããŠãããšããã®ããã¯ãã«è§£æãšããåéã«éããŠããã
ãå Žã£ãŠäœïŒã
ããããããããé»å Žãšãç£å Žã£ãŠãèããããšãªãïŒã
ãé»ç£æ°ã®ææ¥ã§ãã£ããããªæ°ããããã©ãããŸãã¡ããåããããªã
ãåãããæ£çŽåããã¥ããããããã ã話èªäœã¯ãããªã«é£ãããªããããã®Â å³3 ã¯ããŸãã«å Žã®ã€ã¡ãŒãžãå ·çŸåããç©ã ããã
ããèšã£ãŠå¯æšã¯ãäœçœã«æ°ããªå³ãæžãå ããã
ãéçãæŒ ç¶ãšæãåã£ãŠãããã®äžæè°ãªæµããããšãããããéæ°ããšã§ãåŒãŒãããå®äœã¯äžåäžæã ãã©ãããã¯å¹œéãã空éã«æ¹§ãåºããŠããç©ã ãšããŠâŠâŠã
ãããŒããå®äœäžæãšèšãããŠãâŠâŠäœãšãªãã颚ãã€ã¡ãŒãžããŠè¯ãã®ïŒã
ãããã§æ§ããªãã幜éãšããå°é¢šããããããåŽãåºããŠãããããªæãããªããããŠæ¹äœééã¯éæ°ã®åãåããŠãé·éã§ãã®åãïŒæ¹äœïŒããçéã§ãã®å€§ããïŒåŒ·åºŠïŒã瀺ããšèãããåããšå€§ããã§æ±ºãŸãéâŠâŠã£ãŠèšããããããã³ãšããïŒã
ãããŒãâŠâŠãã¯ãã«ã ã£ãïŒã
ããããããçŽ æŽãããã
ã髿 ¡ã§ãã£ããããããããã¯æµç³ã«ã
èŠããã«æ¹äœééã¯ãéæ°ããã¯ãã«ãšããŠæž¬ã£ãŠãã£ãŠèšãããããïŒã
ãããã«ããããããããã£ãæãã幜éã®åšãã§ãå°ããã€æ¹äœééã®äœçœ®ããºã©ããŠæž¬ã£ããã©ããªãïŒããã®éæ°ã®ãã¯ãã«ã䞊ã¹ãŠã¿ããšâŠâŠã
æç€ºã«åŸã£ãŠãéçãå°ããã€çŽã®äžã«ç¢å°ãå¢ãããŠããã
ãããŠãå³4 ã®ãããªçµµãåºæ¥äžãã£ãã

ïŒç°¡åã®ããããã¯ãã«ã®å€§ããã¯çµ±äžïŒ
ããªããã倩æ°å³ã¿ããã«ãªã£ããªã
ãåãããæ¥æ¬åå°ã®é¢šåãã衚瀺ããããã¡ããã©äŒŒããããªå³ã«ãªããšæãã
ããã§ãã®ç¢å°ãã¡ã®åããæ»ããã«ç¹ãã ããå³3 ã¿ããã«ãªããšæã£ãŠè¯ãããããªæãã§ç©ºéäžã«åºãã£ããã¯ãã«ã®ååžããäžè¬ã«ãã¯ãã«å Žã£ãŠåŒã¶ããã ã
ãã«åž¯é»ããç©äœã¯é黿°åã«ãããåšå²ã«é»å Žãäœãåºããå·ã®åç¹ã§æ°Žã®æµããéåºŠãæž¬ãã°ããã®ååžã¯éåºŠå ŽãšããŠæããããããããã¯ãã«å Žã®ä»²éã ã
ã幜éãåšå²ã«äœãåºãéæ°ã®ãã¯ãã«å Žãšèšãã®ã§ããã°ããéæ°å ŽããšåŒãã æ¹ãè¯ãïŒã
ãããããããæ¡çšã
坿šã¯éçã®æ¡ãåãå
¥ããã
éçã¯ããã«ãèªåã®çè§£ã確ãããããã«ç¶ããã
ããããªããšããã£ãã®åé¡ã¯ãéæ°å ŽãæžŠå·»ããŠããã©ãããã£ãŠããšã«ãªãããïŒãã ã£ãããŸãã«ãå³4 ã®åŠã枬ã£ãŠã¿ãã°è¯ããããã
ããããåãããããããå·»ããŠããã«ããŠãå³å·»ããå·Šå·»ãããããã«ã¯å·»ãã®åŒ·ããåé¡ã«ãªã£ãŠããã ãããã
ãã幜éãæ¥ãæèŠããããããã®èŸºãããããªæãã§ããŸãªãåãåã£ãŠã¿ãã°ãéæ°å Žã®å
šäœåãæŽããããããã¡ãã£ãšãã€åããŠããã®åºŠã«é·éã®åããèŠãŠã¿ãŠâŠâŠã
ãããã£ãŠéæ°å Žã«é¢ããæèãç¶ããŠãã坿šã«ãéçãéãåºããã
ããããããåŸ ã£ãŠãæ¯åãããã£ãŠéæ°å Žãæ¢ãã®ã¯æ¬æ«è»¢åãããªãïŒã
次ã®è©±ïŒã3. Methods IIã