
èã«éããã㊠ã6. Discussionã
æåã®è©±ïŒã1. Introductionã
åã®è©±ïŒã5. Results IIã
âŠâŠãã®äºä»¶ãã3ã¶æä»¥äžçµã¡ãŸããããããŸã ã«è§£æ±ºã®ç®åŠã¯ç«ã£ãŠããŸããã
ä»å¹Žã®6æ7æ¥ãKçã®ç¥ç€Ÿè·¡å°ã蚪ããæ±äº¬éœã®å¥³å倧åŠçããè¡æ¹äžæãšãªããŸãããèŠå¯ã«ãããŸããšSåºåšäœã®å¥³ååŠçã¯ã忥ã®ååŸ7æé ãåã倧åŠã«åšç±ããç¥äººã®å¥³ååŠçãšäºäººã§ãçŸåšå»ç€Ÿãšãªã£ãŠããKçMåžã®ç¥ç€Ÿã蚪ããŠããŸããã女ååŠçã¯ããã§ç¥äººãšå¥è¡åãåã£ãŠå¢å
ã«å
¥ããç¥äººãšã®é話ãåããã®ãæåŸã«è¶³åããéçµ¶ãããšã®ããšã§ãã
èŠå¯ãæ¶é²ãæçŽ¢ã«åœãã£ãŠããŸãããçŸå Žã§èŠã€ãã£ã女ååŠçã®ç§ç©ã®ä»ã«æåãªææããã¯æªã ãªãâŠâŠ
仿ãèªå®€ã«ãã¬ãã®éçœãå ã ããç §ã£ãŠãããæ®æ®µãªãäœæ°ãªãèãéããŠããŸããããªãæ·¡çœãªã¢ããŠã³ãµãŒã®å£°è²ã
æããå€ãã®äººã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ããšãã«æŒçœããŠããŸã£ãäžçã®åºæ¥äºã®æ¬ çã«éããªãããã®èªã¿äžããããéå»ãã坿šã®å¿ãŸãããèšæ¶ã®åè·¯ããã¯ãªãšåºæ¿ããã
ïŒ
ãâŠâŠãŸã ãã ãã
ãâŠâŠããããããã
éçãæŸã£ããããã®æã声ãæåŸã«ãé話ã¯éåããŠããã
坿šãç¥ç€Ÿã®æ£é¢ã«æ»ã£ãŠããæãããã§åŸ
ã£ãŠããçã®éçã¯ããªãã£ãã
ãŸã äžã«ããã®ããšæããç³é段ãç»ã£ãŠå£ãããã®é³¥å±
ã®åã«ç«ã€ã
éå¯ã«å
ãŸããæéãèŠãã倧声ã§åŒã³ãããŠã¿ãã
声ã¯è空ãåžã蟌ãŸããã°ããã§ãè¿äºã¯ãªãã
å°ããã€è¶³ãèžã¿å ¥ããã
åŸæ©ã§äžåš20åçšåºŠã倧ããŠåºããªãå»ç€Ÿã®å¢å
ã
è³ãæãèŠãå°œããéè²ããã£ãèã
æããææãšååã«åºãè©°ãŸã£ãææ°Žèã
æ£ãããç¯ç¯ãç³ç³ã®æ®éªžã
æ±ãåããããã£ããæŸçœ®ãããããªããã®ç€Ÿæ®¿ã
人圱ããªãç©ºãæŸããã瀟åæã¯ç©Žã ããã§ãç¯ããåããã°ãå¥¥ã®æãŸã§å
ãå±ããã
倧人1人ã身ãé ããããªã¹ããŒã¹ãªã©ãããŸããªãããã«èŠããããããå
ã»ã©ãŸã§é»è©±ã«åºãŠãã声ã®äž»ã¯ãäœåŠã«ããªãã
èäžãããŒããšäŒããäžçã®æ±ã
ãããè
°ãŸã§å±ããã®ãç®åãã«ããã€ã£ã£ã³ãšé«åšæ³¢ã®å§è¿«é³ãé èã«é¿ãå§ããã
æ¢ã«ç°å€ã¯èµ·ããŠããã
å床ã¹ããã®é話ãã¿ã³ãã¿ããããã
ãã«ã«ã«ã«ââéãªãåŒã³åºãé³ã«ãéŒåãéãŸã£ãŠããã
ããæãã«ãªã£ãé»è©±ã¯é»æ³¢ã®å±ããªãå Žæã«ãããã黿ºãå ¥ã£ãŠããªãããâŠâŠã
ã©ãããŠãäœåºŠæãçŽããŠããäžåã«ç¹ãããªãã
ã«ã¿ã«ã¿ãã«ã¿ã¿ãã¿ã«ã¿ã«ã«ã«ãã«ã¿ã«ã¿ãã¿ãã«ãã¿ã¿ã¿ã«ã«ãã¿
å ¥ãæ··ããéå€ãªé³ã®ééãçž«ã£ãŠã銎æã¿ã®ãªãäžèŠåãªé¿ãã蟺ããåãå°œãããŠããããšã«æ°ã¥ããã
äœã ãäœã®é³ã ããããã°ã§é³Žã£ãŠããããã ããäžäœäœåŠããã
åŸããæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠãã鳿ºãããç©äœã¯èŠåœãããªãã
é³Žãæ¢ãŸã¬æªå¥é³ãæããã«çä¿¡é³ã®é¡ã§ã¯ãªãã
äžãäžãåãäžãã®é³ãéçã®ã¹ããã®ç©ã ãšããŠãã©ã®æ¹è§ãããå šãåãããã«å±ãããšãããããã
åæ¹å
«æ¹ãåãå²ãæéããç®ãèããã
ç®ç©ã
äœã ããæ¯è²ãäžèªç¶ã«ãºã¬ãŠãããããªã
æèŠããäžçããé ã®äžã®äœãããããããããªã£ãŠããŸã£ããã
å¹é£ãã¬ãããšæãåŒããããããªæè§Šã
èŠçã®ç«¯ã«ãæå ã®æ¹äœééãæ ã蟌ãã
ãã®é·éã¯ãããããšç¡çç¢çåããããåžžè»ãéžããå転é床ã«ç¡ç§©åºãªç²é«ãæ²é³ŽãäžããŠããã
ãã®åŸã®ããšã坿šã¯ã»ãšãã©èŠããŠããªãã
èšæ¶ãèŠããæã«ã¯ãè¿å Žã®äº€çªã«ãããææŽããã£ãŠããã®ããæ§åãèŠãèŠå®ãããã«å±
ãããŠãããã®ã ããã
å€ã¯å€ãæããããšããšãšäºæéšã®è¶³é³ãç
ã£ãŠããã
幟ããã®äºæ èŽåã®åŸã«ãæçŽ¢ãå§ãŸã£ãã
ããããŠ9æãŸã§ã«èŠã€ãã£ãã®ã¯ãå¢å
å¥¥ã®æã§äºåããŠããéã端æ«ããããŠããã«å¥¥ã«é ãããŠããé»çžã®çŒé¡ã®ã¿ã
坿šãããèŠç¥ã£ãŠãããããã®ç©åã¯è¡šé¢ã«å·ãããå·ããªããããããããã«ãã£ãšçœ®ãããããã ã£ããšããã
åŸæ¥ããªã«ç ã®å¯éšé·ãåä¹ã人ãšè©±ãæ©äŒããã£ãã
坿šããã¥ãŒã¹ã®ç¥äººå¥³ååŠçã ãšãäœåŠãããå
ãã€ããã®ã ãããã
ãã®å»ç€Ÿã¯ã圌ãã®ãããªäººã
ãããå
šãå¯ãä»ããªãææãã®å±éºã¹ãããã§ãããç¡éã«è©±é¡ã«åºãã®ãæãããã»ã©ã§ãããšããã
ãŸããšãããã«åãããŠããåã«ããã°ããã®å Žæã§å€ã¹ãŸã§éãã§ããåäŸãã¡ããçžæ¬¡ãã§æ¶æ¯ãçµ¶ã£ãã®ã ãšãã
é»è©±è¶ãã«ãäŒãã£ãŠãããéçã®æ¯ãã
ãã¯ããã®æãç¡çã«ã§ã調æ»ãäžæ¢ããŠéçãåŒãçããŠããã°ã
éçããã®ææ¡ã ã£ããšã¯ãããæšªçããŠå¥è¡åãåãã¹ãã§ã¯ãªãã£ãã
ããããéçã«ãããå°ããªã«ç ã®äººãã¡ãšå¯Ÿè©±ãç¶ããããå§ããŠããã°ããããªããšã«ã¯ãªããªãã£ãã®ã§ã¯ãªããïŒ
é€
ã¯é€
å±ãä»®ã«åœŒããæªå¥èãæ¥œãã¿ããã ãã ãšããŠãããã®é·ã«åŸãããšã§é¿ããããéåœã¯ãã£ããããããªãã®ã«ã
ç¥é ãââååãããã¯ã坿šã§ãç¥ã£ãŠããããããããããªã«ãéè¿ã§ãä»ãšãªã£ãŠã¯ããã®é話è¶ãã«èãããŠããéçã®ææã®èšèããåœã®æ¬äººããçºãããç©ãã©ãããå®ãã§ãªãã
æ°žãã坿šã®å¥¥åºã«ç ã£ãŠããæ¯ãããç®èãé£ãç Žãçºé²ããŠããã
幌ãé ãèº«ã®æ¯ããã ã€ãããªå¿éæ åããã®ç®ã§èŠãæ¥ã®å€ã
å®¶äžã®ããããããå
ã¿èŸŒãæããããäºçްãªç©é³ãæ°ã«ãªã£ãŠç ããªãã£ãã倢ã®äžã«ãŸã§ãã¿ãã¿ãšã€ããŸãšããéŠå
ã«æããããŠããããã®çå±ãªãæçžæã
ãããã«èãããŠãçç¥ã®åŠåã«èº«ããã€ããŠããçãªã®ã«ãæ³ãéããã«ã€ãããã®é²è¡ã®çè·¡ãããå¿ãå»ã£ãŠããçãªã®ã«ã
æ¹äœééã®ç°åžžãªæåãèšæž¬æ©åšã®åŠ¥åœæ§ãçãã
è³è£ã«çŒãã€ããè³é³Žããä»ã®å¯èœæ§ãæ€èšããã
ãã®äžãªããããã®ãšã®æ¥è§Šãéçã®å€±èžªãšãããã®å æé¢ä¿ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãæ éã«æ€èšŒãããªããã°ãªããªãã
åœããåã ãäž¡è ãç¡é¢ä¿ãªãããªãããããããèãéãã ã
ããããã®å»ç€ŸãæåŸã®èª¿æ»å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠéžãã ã®ã¯éçã®æå¿ã§ãªããæ¥äŒã¿ä»¥æ¥åãæããŠããäœè ãã«åŒã³æ»ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªããïŒ
ãã®ãããããŒã«äº€ããããšãããèªåããéé£ãã«ããããšããŠã
å®çŸè±¡ã«ã¯èå³ããªãããªã©ãšå¯ãããã®ãã
éçã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ç®ã«èŠãã¬ææãªã©ããã¯ãæ¥åžžè¶é£¯äºã§ååã«ç¢ºããããååšã ã£ãã®ã ããã
ã§ãèªåã¯ããã§ã¯ãªããä¿¡ããŠããªãã£ãããããããæã蟌ãã§ç®ãéžãããŠããã ãã ã£ããä»®æ³äžã®æŠå¿µã§ãã幜éã®å®åšæ§ãªã©ãèªåã«ã¯ã©ãã§ãè¯ã話ã§ãããšã
ãããŸã§äœãšãªãã«å¯ãŠé£ã¹ãŠæ®ãããŠãã空éã«ãããããæºã¡æº¢ããŠãããããããªãã
èçã®åãŠã€ãåŸä»ãã®èªèã«ããã ãèãŸããã
ïŒ
é·ãæ¢
éšãæããæèŠããå€ãéããŠããã
èæšã®ãããã®ã¯å®ãèœãšãããŸããããã®ã¯å®ãçµã³å§ããé ã ããã
åããçŸãã圌æ¹ãžé£ã³ç«ãšããšããŠãããå人ãšã®èšæ¶ã
貫ãããå¿ã«ç©Žã空ããŠããã倧åãªäœããæŒãåºãããè空ã¯ã¿åºããŠããã
ç ã£ãŠããéãåçãããããããšãã®æ°ã
ã
çªãåºããçŸå®ã¯æ±ºããŠåŒãæããªãã
ãããŠãæŒãåºãæ®æ»ãå°ãã§ãããéããªããã°ã
æ®ãå
ããªééãããã®èè
ããæ¹§ãåºãèæãæ··æ¿ã§åãå°œããããŠããŸãåã«ã
çµå±ãéçå®ãé²åŠã®çžè«ã«ä¹ã£ãŠãããæ¥ã¯èšªããªãã£ãã
ããã§ãã坿šæªçœã¯æ©ãããšã決ããã
å®çŸè±¡ãšæœè±¡æŠå¿µãšã®çéã«ããŠãæ°åŠã»ç©çã»æ
å ±ã®äº€é¯ããé åãžãšã
坿šã®æ£²ãã§ãããè軞ã®äžçã
å人ã®åœ¢èŠã§ãããå®è»žã®äžçã
äºã€ã®è»žã匵ãå¹³é¢ã®äžã«å転ãçãŸããæ¢ãŸã£ãŠãã坿šã®æã¯ãå°ããã€å»ã¿å§ããã
å®è»žãè軞ãå®è»žãè軞âŠâŠ
çŸè±¡ãšæœè±¡ãè¡ãæ¥ããæ§ã¯ããã¯ãåªæäžæãªæºããã§ã¯ãªãã
ãã®èå®ãæš¡ãæ··è²ã®æ¥ã¯ãåç¬ã®è»žã ãã§ã¯æãåŸãªãè€éãªè»éãæããŠããã
éçååšã®ç¢ºããããã
èžäžã§ãæ¯ãç¶ãããã¯ãªãããšåãåã®å£°ã
åãåãããã«èªåã¯ã©ããããè¯ãããäœãå¿
èŠãã
幞ãã«ãããã®æã«ã¯æ¹äœééããããŠæ°åŠãããã
ãã¯ã察象ãåŠå®ããé ãããããã®ç©ã§ã¯ãªãã
ãªãã°ãããããšã¯äžã€ã
è¬ã«æºã¡ãææã®å¯Ÿè±¡ããã®æ£äœãçç ŽããŠããã
å§¿ããèŠããªããšããå®äžçã«å¹²æžããŠãããèæ°ã®åŠããã®æ£äœãã
ãã£ãšèªåãªãããã®æ£äœããåãã£ãŠããŸãã°æãã¯ãªãã
ãã®æ³åããæ¹çšåŒãèŠã€ãåºããç§åŠã®ç·šã¿ç®ã«çž«ãä»ããã°ã
ãããããèã«æ¶ããåã®ãè¶³åãã远ãéã«ä»ãªããªãããã
ãããããèã«æ¶ããåã®ãæå¿ãç¶ããåŒãéã«ä»ãªããªãããã
ãããããèã«æ¶ããåã®ãææãšåãåãéã«ä»ãªããªãããã
ãã®åœ±ããã€ãŠåãåã£ãŠããã§ãããããã®ææãšââ
ãããã
å€ã®èžãæããæ®ãç©å¯ããéšå±ã®çé
ã«ãå¿åœããã®ãªãæ°Žã®æ»Žãé³ã
ã«ãã«ãããã³ããããªã³ããããã³ãã
ã²ãããè³ãå¡ãã§ããäžå¯è§£ãªç©é³ãé«åšæ³¢ã«æ··ããéŒèãå§è¿«ãããèºã¯ããããç«ã€ã°ããã
ãããç®ã«ã¯èŠããªãäœãã®æ°é ãã確ãã«ãã®è空ãè ¢ããŠããããšãéãæã瀺ããé ããã€ãŸå ãããŸã§ãŸã¯ãŸã¯ãšæ«ã§ãŠãããã²ããããšããæ°è²æªãã
çã坿°ã«ã¯äžåã«çµãããèŠãããæ ¹æºçãªåæžã«é«ãæ»ããããããŠããã
ããã«äžäœãäœãããã®ãæ¬åœã«ããã«ãäœããããã®ã
ãèã«éããããŠãå šè©±äžèЧ