Much as I love this comm and have many many fond memories of it - not to mention that most of my shorter fiction for One Piece were first posted here and inspired by the prompts here - it really does seem like activity is dying down for good now. I know I don't have half the ideas I used to have, myself, and also less energy - but like I think many of us, there's also a downward spiral when you don't get much feedback, you get less enthusiastic about writing or drawing, you're also less likely to give feedback to others, who also feel less encouraged, etc etc. There's really not much on LJ anymore for One Piece when it comes to fandom comms, and on Dreamwidth the fandom as far as I know never truly took off around any comm (apart from in the shape of talented RPers, which is admittedly great).
I could well be wrong, but to me it seems like it's more or less all Tumblr these days. We've tried to advertise this comm here, but it doesn't seem to have led to a true renewal, alas. But even if I don't have that many creative One Piece ideas myself anymore, I still really like this kind of challenge community and especially the one here, which is unlimited when it comes to pairing types or the choice of no pairing. I know judging is often tough, and winning is nice and all; but the best thing about it being a contest is for me simply that the choice of prompt gets handed over, much like in chaos threads: it's not just the same person who comes up with different prompts, nor is it randomly chosen.
Maybe on Tumblr, it would work if everyone posted their contributions to their own blogs using the same tag (could be "onepiece-300" or "op-300", for instance); the current judge would then just have to track the tags to find the contributions. But the announcement about the winner and the new prompt should probably be posted to a main blog just dedicated to this activity - maybe via submissions. The rules could also be found there.
But that's the problem, right? Even if the actual contributions are posted elsewhere and only found via tags, for this to work I feel that a main blog would have to be curated much more often and more extensively than a fandom comm, just because the Tumblr format is so different. And honestly it's not something I would feel prepared to take on myself, which of course means I can hardly expect anyone else to want to!
Besides, even if we did try there is of course no guarantee that one could really get the ball rolling on Tumblr, either.
So I have a feeling this will not be a very useful post after all... but I still wanted to raise the issue.
I could well be wrong, but to me it seems like it's more or less all Tumblr these days. We've tried to advertise this comm here, but it doesn't seem to have led to a true renewal, alas. But even if I don't have that many creative One Piece ideas myself anymore, I still really like this kind of challenge community and especially the one here, which is unlimited when it comes to pairing types or the choice of no pairing. I know judging is often tough, and winning is nice and all; but the best thing about it being a contest is for me simply that the choice of prompt gets handed over, much like in chaos threads: it's not just the same person who comes up with different prompts, nor is it randomly chosen.
Maybe on Tumblr, it would work if everyone posted their contributions to their own blogs using the same tag (could be "onepiece-300" or "op-300", for instance); the current judge would then just have to track the tags to find the contributions. But the announcement about the winner and the new prompt should probably be posted to a main blog just dedicated to this activity - maybe via submissions. The rules could also be found there.
But that's the problem, right? Even if the actual contributions are posted elsewhere and only found via tags, for this to work I feel that a main blog would have to be curated much more often and more extensively than a fandom comm, just because the Tumblr format is so different. And honestly it's not something I would feel prepared to take on myself, which of course means I can hardly expect anyone else to want to!
Besides, even if we did try there is of course no guarantee that one could really get the ball rolling on Tumblr, either.
So I have a feeling this will not be a very useful post after all... but I still wanted to raise the issue.
10 | Leave a comment

nostalgic