
0.1į§å ãŽããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãē ââæĒæĨãåĩããčŗå īŧã¤ãŽåąââãéˇįˇ¨å°čĒŦã
#åĩäŊ大čŗ2026 #ããĄãŗãŋã¸ãŧå°čĒŦé¨é
â ãããã
ã嚸ããĢãĒããããã§ããåˇã¤ããŽãæãããããĒæĒãã čĒåˇąé˛čĄãããįĄæčãĢįžåŽãæĒããĻããžãįˇãæ¤åˇãåŊŧãŽčŗå
ã§ã¯ãčēĢäŊäēįŽãįŽĄįããããļãģããŗã¯ãããä翏ŦæĻįĨåąããŽåąåĄããĄããä¸ģäēēãŽåŽåŽãåŽãããåŋ
æģãĢæĻãŖãĻããã
ããæĨãæ¤åˇãŽåãĢãåĒãããŽäģŽéĸãčĸĢããäģäēēãŽåŋãæãŖãĻį ´æģ
ã¸å°ãæĒįŠīŧããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧīŧãä¸ãįŦãįžãããæããå¯ããæå¸ãĢįãåĨãä¸ãįŦãŽįĄįžãĒįŊ ãĢ寞ããæ¤åˇã¯čŗå
ãŽãéåģãŽé˛čĄãˇãšãã ããį ´åŖãã0.1į§å
ãŽæĒæĨãä翏ŦããįŠļæĨĩãŽåŋįæĻãĢæãīŧ
ææ°ãŽčŗį§åĻãæ§æä¸ģįžŠįæ
åįčĢãÃãį¯įŊĒåŋįåĻãã§æããéãŽč§Ŗæžã¨æ°įãŽãĩã¤ãŗãĩãšããŗãšã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãåŋãŽæãŋ
-1-
22æéãã
ãģããŽãæŽãŖãé
ãŽįĢį
§ãããå¤éĸ¨ã§åˇããããĻãããå°ãé ããĢčĻãããæ¸¯ãŽå
ãéĸ¨ã垎ããĢæ¨ã
ãæēãããæŊŽãŽéĻããéŧģãæĢã§ãĻãæŗĸãŽéŗããæ˛éģã¯åŋå°č¯ãããŽã ã¨æãããããĢãéŋããĻãããããŗãã§ã¯ãæãåãéãããĢãããĢããæéãŽä¸ã§äēäēēã ããŽä¸įãäŊãŖãĻããã
æãŽį˛ãæã
č§ĻããčˇéĸãæŠãã大éæå¸īŧãããŽãããīŧãŽæ¸ŠåēĻãæããĒãããæ¤åˇį æīŧããããããã
ãããīŧã¯ãæŦĄãĢčĒåãããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã¨ããé ãŽä¸ã§įš°ãčŋããĻããã
ãæå¸ããã
æ˛éģãį ´ãŖãĻãæ¤åˇã¯įĢãĄæĸãžãŖããåŧåŋããĻįĢãĄæĸãžãŖãæå¸ãŽéĄã¯ãčĄį¯ãŽå
ããģããŽãåŊããŖãĻããĩã¯ãŠãŗãč˛ãĢčĻãããé
ãŽãããããããĒããäģæĨã¯äģãžã§ã§ä¸įĒãįŦãŖãĻãéãéŖ˛ãã§ããæ°ãããã
æå¸ã¯ãå°ãįŦããæŠããĒãããæ¤åˇãŽéĄãčĻã¤ããĻããã
ãããŽãäģæĨããæĨŊãããŖããã
ããããåŖ°ã§č¨ãã¨ãæå¸ã¯ããããĢåŖč§ãä¸ããĻé ˇããã
ãããŽããããŽâĻâĻã
č¨čãįļãããã¨ããã¨ããæ°įŽĄãŽãããã芰ãžããããĒæčĻãããĻãčĻįãįãžãŖããåŧå¸ãããžãã§ãããå
Ŧåã¨æĩˇãéãĻãæĩãĢåŗæãã¤ããĻãčãæ˛ããã
ãæ¤åˇããã大ä¸å¤Ģīŧīŧã
æå¸ãčŋå¯ãŖãĻčŠãæ¯ããã
ãã¯ããã¯ãâĻâĻãããâĻâĻã
大ä¸å¤Ģã¨ããč¨čã ããæĩŽããŗãåŖ°ãĢåēããããããããčŗãã ãŖããŽãã¨ããč¨čã¨æ åãåŋčãåŧˇčĨ˛ããã¨ããŦãåēããģãŠåŗãčžŧãã§ãããããåŧå¸ãčŊãĄįãã¨ãããŗãĢãã§åŖãæãŖãã
ãããããææĒã ãããããŖããæĨŊãããŖããŽãĢããããĒâĻâĻã
ããããĒãã¨ãĒããããããããäģæĨã¯ããã帰ãŖããģãããããããå°ãéĄč˛æĒããâĻâĻã
æå¸ã¯ã垎ããĢ垎įŦãã§č¨ãŖããįŗãå°ãæēããĻãåŖ°ãéãããããĒæ°ãããããæ°ãŽãããããããĒããč¯ããŖãã¨æãŖãĻããããâĻâĻãããĒæããæĩŽããã§ãæ¤åˇã¯éĻãæ¯ãŖãã
ãããã ãã帰ãããã
ãžã ããããĻããåŖ°ã§įããã¨ãæå¸ã¯é ˇããäēäēēã¯é§
ãžã§ãŽéããæ˛éģã¨å
ąãĢæŠãããæãŽį˛ãč§ĻãããģãŠãŽčˇéĸãĒãŽãĢãæąēããĻč§Ļãããã¨ããĒããããĢãäēäēēãŽéãĢéæãŽåŖããããããĒæ°ãããĻããã
ããããããžãã
é§
ãŽæšæããããã¨ããĒãã¨ãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻãæ¤åˇã¯åŗæãä¸ããã
ãããããžãã
æå¸ãåŗæãä¸ããĻãįŦãŋãčŋããĻããããããŠããåŧããĻãããããĒãããĄãĒããããã
ããŧã ãĢä¸ãŖãĻãéģčģãåž
ãŖãĻããã¨ãæå¸ãŽãģããŽéģčģãå
ãĢæĨãĻãæ¤åˇã¯åããå´ãĢįĢãŖãĻããæå¸ãĢãåãŗæãæ¯ãŖããæå¸ãåŋããéģčģãããŧã ãĢæģãčžŧãã§ããã¨ãæ¤åˇãĢčŋããģããŽå¸ãĢåē§ããåãåēãã¨åæãĢæãæ¯ãŖãã
éģčģãčĻããĒããĒãã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯éĄãŽããããžã§ä¸ããĻããåŗæãããŖããã¨ä¸ãããĻãäŋ¯ããã
æå¸ã¨åēäŧãŖãĻãããååš´ãģãŠãä¸åš´ãģãŠåãŽåēæĨäēã§åˇåŋããĻããæ¤åˇã¯ãå¯ä¸ãŽåéã§ããä¸åãĢå§ããããĻãé°ããŖéåŽãŽãĢãã§äŧãĢåå ãããįˇīŧäēēãåĨŗīŧäēēãŽåå č ãŽä¸ã§ãå°ããĩããĩããããããã§ããĻč¨ããã¨ã¯éãæå¸ãĢæšãããæå¸ããžããæ¤åˇãŽįŠēæ°æãåŽåŋã§ãããŽããčĒįļã¨éŖįĩĄå ãä礿ããĻãäēäēēã§éŖäēãĢčĄãŖãããæ įģãčĻŗãĢčĄãŖãããããããĢãĒãŖããäģæĨãžã§éããĻããæéã¨äŧ芹ããæ įģãŽãããĢčŗå ãĢæĩããĻããĻãããĸãŽããæ¨ĒãŽå¸ãĢåē§ãŖããžãžãčĄãåēããģãŠåãåãã ã
ãšãããåãåēããæå¸ã¨ãŽããŖãããéãããäģæĨãæĨŊãããŖããæåžãããããã¨æãĄčžŧããã¨ããĻãæãæĸãžããããąãããĢäģčããã¨ããã¨ãããšãããéããã
æå¸ãããŽããŖããâĻâĻããäŧããĒããããããĒããįĄįâĻâĻãããžã§ãšããŦãŧãã§ã¯ãĒããããããĒãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¨ããĻã¯ããããæåŗããããŖãããããããĒãâĻâĻæå¸ããããĒãã¨ãč¨ãããããĒãã¨ããåŖ°ããčŗãæžãžãã°čãããæ°ãããããåŖãããŽåãĢããĻãéããæã§ããŖãããéããã
ãäģæĨãæĨŊãããŖããäŊčĒŋã大ä¸å¤ĢīŧãããŖããäŧãã§ã
čĒãã įŦéãåŋčããēããŗã¨éŗ´ãããšãããæã¤æãéãããčãŽããããĢããŖãéãŋã¯æļãããŽãĢãč¸ãįããä¸åãģãŠãæå¸ãããŽãĄããģãŧã¸ãčĻã¤ããĻãįŽãčĻãããããĢäŊãčĩˇããããæĨŊãããŖãããæåžãããããæĨãĢäŊčĒŋãããããĒãŖãĻâĻâĻãã¨æãŖãĻãããããžãčĄãããã¨äģãčļŗããããåé¤ããĻãéãį´åãĢããä¸åēĻæ¸ããĻãéäŋĄããã
éģčģãéããĻæŠããĻããã¨ãé¨åąįãŽãããĒæčŖ
ã§ãŗãŗãããĢå
ĨãŖãĻãããĢãããĢããå°ãé Ŧãčĩ¤ãããĒãããããŧããįŦãŋãããŽãžãžãĢãæãįšãã§ããįˇåĨŗãčĻįãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããĻããģããŽ30åãģãŠåãŽãã¨ãæãåēãããã
éåŧå¸ãĢãĒãŖããŽã¯äēæŗå¤ã ãŖãããŽãŽãâããŽãˇããĨã¨ãŧãˇã§ãŗâã§į°å¸¸ãåēããã¨ãĢã¯ããããģãŠéŠãã¯ãĒããŖããäēæŗããĻããããã§ã¯ãĒããããããĒãŖãĻããããããĒãįįąã¯ãããä¸åš´åãŽâĻâĻ
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ããĢãĢãŖã¨ãããąãããĢå
ĨãããšãããéããĻãæ¤åˇã¯įŽãããããããããæå¸ãããŽããŖããã§ãããããžããâēãã¨æ¸ãããĻããã
äģæĨãŽä¸å¯č§ŖããĢã¤ããĻ芹ããããåããŖãĻãããã ããããåããŖãĻããããããããĒããã§ããããĒããĒããŖããâĻâĻīŧ
åŽļãĢįãã¨ãéĩãåãåēããĻãįãŖæãĒįéĸãĢå ĨãŖããæ¨Ēæĩå¸å ãé§ ããæŠããĻ20åãäŊåŽ čĄãããå°ãå¤ãã1KãŽããŗãˇã§ãŗãå¤éĸ¨ãããå°ãã˛ããããã厤å ãŽįŠēæ°ãĢãä¸įŦįãã˛ããããããã ããžãã¨ããč¨čã¯ããŠããĒãĩããĢåŖ°ãĢãããŽãåŋããĻããžãŖãã
įéĸãŽæãããįšããã¨ãæããã§įŽãįŠãã ã3.5įŗãŽããããŗãéãéããé¨åąã¸ã¨įšããããĸãéãããæãããįšããã¨ãæŦæŖã¨éģãæ¨čŖŊãŽæēãéŖãŗčžŧãã§ãããæŦæŖãĢã¯ãį¯įŊĒč ããĄãŽæĒãã åŋįãį´č§ŖããéģãįŊãį°č˛ãŽčĄ¨į´ããéæ ŧåãŽãããĢä¸Ļãã§ãããäŊåēĻãæãĢåãŖããããã襨į´ãæŗĸæãŖãĻããããéãã°ããã°ã¤ã¤ãŧãæ¸ãčžŧãŋã夿°ããããä¸ãĢã¯äģįŽãč˛ŧãããĻããããŽããããééãĢã¯ãäģäēã§åŋ čĻã ã¨čããĻ財ãŖããAIãĢã¤ããĻãŽæŦãīŧåããããŠãĻãã¨ã¯äŊããããåŋãĢæãããį¯ã50ãŽčŗĒåãã¨ããŖãæŦãéãĢæãžããåˇĻį̝ãĢã¯ãīŧåš´ãģãŠåãĢããčĒãã§ããäŊåŽļãŽããšããĒãŧããšãĒãŠãŧå°čĒŦãä¸Ļãã§ããã
ãããĒãéģãŖãŊãããŖãĢãŋãŧã§čĻãŖããããĒæŦæŖãĢãį°čŗĒãĒããŽããããæŦæŖãŽåŗä¸ãäģãŽæŦããåŽããããĢįŊŽãããĻããããŽæŦã¯ã襨į´ãĢčļããããæãįŽããĒãSFå°čĒŦã§ãæ¤åˇãčĒåã§æãĢåããã¨ã¯ãĒãããŽâĻâĻããŽéŖãĢã¯ãä¸å¯§ãĢæããããžããããŠãˇãįŊŽãããĻãããæå¸ã¨åēäŧãŖããĢãã§ã¤ããŗããŽããŠãˇã§ãããŠãˇãŽééãĢã¯ãæå¸ã¨ä¸įˇãĢčĄãŖãæ įģãŽåå¸ãæãžãŖãĻããã
ããã°ãæåŽãŽå ´æãĢįŊŽãã¨ã帰ãéãŽæå¸ãŽéĄãæĩŽããã§ãã¯ããŧãŧãããĢčĻįˇãåãããéããĒããĻãåãããä¸įĒåĨĨãĢæŧãčžŧãžããĻããã¸ã ããã°ããããåĻåããĻããã°ãäģæĨãŽãã¨ã¯ããžãããŖããŽã ãããâĻâĻ
æ¤
åãĢåē§ãŖãĻãããŧãPCãįĢãĄä¸ãããä¸åēĻįšããé¨åąãŽæãããæļãã¨ããĸããŋãŧãŽå
ãããæ¤åˇãŽéĄãæéãĢæĩŽããŗä¸ããããããã¤ãēããŖãŗãģãĒãŗã°ã¤ã¤ããŗãåãŖãĻčŗãĢåˇŽãčžŧãã¨ãããããæ°æãĄãŽæŗĸãéãžãŖãĻããã
ããšã¯ãŽä¸ãĢããã°ãĢãããįŊŽããŖãąãĒããĢãĒãŖãĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããĻãããããŗæãŖãĻããŖãĻããæģãŖãĻããĻãããĻãšãåãããã
ãâĻâĻã
į¯įŊĒįŗģãŽčå¯ãĩã¤ããĢããĒãã¨ãĒãčĻįˇãæģãããĻãããäŊåēĻčĒãã§ãããˇãĒãĸãĢããŠãŧīŧéŖįļæŽēäēēį¯īŧãĢåéĄãããäēēįŠãŽčĄåã¯čåŗæˇąãããĒãããããžã§æŽé
ˇãĢãĒãããŽãããĒããæŽēäēēããããããĒããŽãâĻâĻ
ãâĻâĻīŧã
æ°įč¨äēãŽä¸ãĢãããčĢčãåŋĢæĨŊåéŖįļæŽēäēēãŽčĄååįãĢéĸããčĒįĨį§åĻįãĸãããŧããīŊåŊŧãã¯ãããĢããĻãæĒįŠããĢãĒããŽãīŊãã¨ãããŋã¤ããĢãŽããŽãããŖãĻãæ¤åˇã¯ããŧã¸ãéããã
ãæĒįŠããæĒįŠãĢãĒãįįąâĻâĻį°å¸¸ãĢčĻããčĄåããåŽåŋãåžããããĢâĻâĻīŧã
čå¯ãŽä¸į°ãĒãŽã ããã¨æããĒããããäģãžã§čĒãã§ããæŦã§ã¯čĻããã¨ããĒãčĻįšãĢãčĻå
ĨãŖããæ°æãĄãŽæŗĸã¯åŽå
¨ãĢéãžããé ãŽä¸ãĢããããĒã¨äŊããčŊãĄããããĒæ°ããããäģãžã§ã¨ã¯éããäŊããã
-2-
æ¤åˇãčĢčãčĒãã įŋæĨãåŊŧãŽčŗå
ã§ã¯ãæ°ããå
ĨãŖãĻããæ°äēēããīŧã¤ããåąãĢä¸äēēãã¤é
åąãããã
ãäģæĨãããä¸čŠąãĢãĒããžãããˇãŗãģããĨãĸãŗãšã§ãããããããéĄãããžãã
ãæĻåŋĩãŠãããŽæ°äēēãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãčŋããĢæĨãĻãããããŧã¸ãŖãŧãããŗãģãŦãããĢãĢé ãä¸ããã
ãããããããããĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãããžãžč¨ãŖãã
ãŽã§ããĒã¨ããįŽã¨ã大ããĒéŧģãã°ãŦãŧãŽäŊæĨįããčĻãčļč¤č˛ãŽč
ã¯ããĄããŖã¨ãã丸å¤ĒãŽããã ããå
¨äŊã¨ããĻã¯å°å¤Ēãã§ãčēĢéˇãéĢããĒããæĻåŋĩãŠããŽåąåĄãŽãģã¨ããŠãããĒããŖãšãĢã¸ãĨãĸãĢãĒæčŖ
ãããĻããä¸ã§ãã¤ãĒãåãŽäŊæĨįãŽä¸ãĢįŊãTãˇãŖãã¨ãããšãŋã¤ãĢã¯ãį°åŊŠãæžãŖãĻããã
åããĻ芹ãč
ã¯ãããļãģčˇäēēãã¨ããŖãéĸ¨č˛ãŽãŦãããĢãĢéŖ˛ãžãããã¨ã常ã ããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããšãĻãčĻéãããããĒéãäēéãŽįŽã§ããŦãããĢå§ãåããĻæĸããĻãäŊãŽåãæããĻããã
ãã¤ãŽããéģéĢĒããĒãŧãĢããã¯ãĢããĻãæ§ãããĒããįĨæ§ãæŧãããæéĻããä¸ãå°ãčĻãããããĢæ˛ãŖããˇãŖãããã¯ããšãĒã ãĒããčĄįŽĄãæĩŽããļãįž¤éč˛ãŽčãčĻããã
ãäŋēãŽéĄãįããã§ããīŧã
įéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããĒããčĻįˇãåããĻãããŦãããĢãĢãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãæĒãããįŽã ãããŠãå°ãæãä¸ãããčĻãããĒã
ãæãä¸ãããã§ããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åŖå
ãįˇŠããã
ããããĒã¤ããã¯ãããžããããåąãŽåŽæ
ãįĨããĒãããããčĻããããŽãããã¨ã¯æãŖãĻããžãã
ãåąãĢã¤ããĻãį äŋŽãåãããã ãīŧãåãããããŖãĻãŽã¯ãŠããããã¨ã īŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãéŧģå
ããļã¤ãã䏿пåãžã§č¸ãŋčžŧãã§ããã
ãäŊãįĨãããã§ãããŽäģäēãã§ããã¨æãŖãĻããŽãīŧã
ãį äŋŽãŽå
厚ã¯ãããŖããé ãĢå
ĨããĻãããžããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯čĄ¨æ
ãå¤ãããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãã ãŖããäŋēãĢčĒŦæããĻãŋããããééãŖããã¨ãč¨ãŖãããã¯ããããã
ããããļãã¨äšąæ´ã§ãããæĻåŋĩãŠãã¯éĸčˇįãéĢãã¨čããžããããæ
å ąã¯æŖããããã§ã
ãäŋēãį´åžã§ããčĒŦæãã§ããããäŋēãæĻåŋĩãŠããæĄå
ããĻããã
č
įĩãããŦãããĢãč¨ãã¨ãå¨å˛ãããã¤ããããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åˇĻåŗãå°ãčĻåããĻããããŦãããĢãŽįŽãčĻãĻãåŖãéããã
ãæŦäŊãŽčŗå
ãĢã¯ãīŧã¤ãŽåąãããžãããžãã¯ãčēĢäŊäēįŽįŽĄįåąãéį§°âãļãģããŗã¯âãčēĢäŊįĩæ¸åĻã§čĒŦæããããäēēäŊãåãããããĢåŋ
čĻãĒäēįŽãESMīŧã¨ãŧãĩã īŧãįŽĄįããã¨ãĒãŧãéåŖãåŊŧãããŠããĒãĩããĢäēįŽãé
åãããã§ãæŦäŊãŽčĄåãæąēãžãã¨ããŖãĻãéč¨ã§ã¯ãããžããã
æŦĄãĢãä翏ŦæĻįĨåąãéį§°âããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēâãæŦäŊãĢčįŠãããĻããå
é¨ããŧãŋããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢäŋįŽĄãããĻããæ§ã
ãĒæĻåŋĩãäŋĄåŋĩããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻãã
å¤é¨ããŧãŋãĒãŠãäŊŋãŖãĻããļãģããŗã¯ãäēįŽããŠãé
åããããããŽå¤æææãĢãĒãä翏ŦãäŊãŖãĻãããčãã芹ã§ã¯ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽåąéˇåޤãĢã¯ãâããŧãŋãĢåēãĨãä翏ŦãŽåžšåēâã¨ããį翏ããéŖžãããĻããããã§ãã
ä¸åēĻč¨čãæĸããã¨ããŦãããĢã¯įéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãããžãžããįļãããã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãæŦĄã¯ãįĩąåᎍéåąãéį§°âãŦããŧãŋãŧãēâãæŦäŊãäēæã§åãåãå¤é¨ããŧãŋã¨ãäŊå
ãŽåæã§čĩˇããįãŋãéãŋã¨ããŖãčēĢäŊããŧãŋãéããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢä¸ããĻãããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢįĩąåããŧãŋãéããĸãĻãŦãīŧãĸãĻããĩã¤ããģãŦããŧãŋãŧãēīŧã¨ãäŊå
ãé§ãåãŖãĻæ
å ąãéããã¤ãŗãŦãīŧã¤ãŗãĩã¤ããģãŦããŧãŋãŧãēīŧãĢåãããĻãããåŊŧããä¸ããĻããæ
å ąã¯ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãä翏ŦãäŊããŽãĢéčĻãĒããŧãŋãĢãĒãŖãĻããã
æåžããããæĻåŋĩãŠããéį§°âããļã¤ããŧãēâãæŦäŊããã¤æĻåŋĩãäŋįŽĄãããĻããæĻåŋĩDBīŧããŧãŋããŧãšīŧãįŽĄįãéį¨ããĻãããåŋ
čĻãĢåŋããĻãæĻåŋĩDBãŽæ
å ąã¯æ¸ãæãããããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãä翏ŦãįĢãĻããŽãĢåŋ
čĻä¸å¯æŦ ãĒããŽã§ãããļã¤ããŧãēãããĒããã°ãæŦäŊã¯į¤žäŧįæ´ģãéããã¨ãã§ããĒãã¨ããŖãĻããããģãŠãéčĻãĒåąã
č¨ãįĩããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãŦãããĢãŽč¨čãåž
ãŖãã
ãé ã¯ããããã ãĒããŦãããĢã¯čģŊãé ˇããããããŽé ãŽč¯ããĢãčļŗå
ãæãããĒããããĢæ°ãã¤ãããã¨ã ã
ãåæ ŧã§ããīŧã
ãã¤ããĻããã
ãŦãããĢã¯čä¸ãåããĻãæŠãåēãããå¨å˛ãŽããã¤ãããã˛ã¨į¨ãŋã§éŽãããŽãčĻãĻãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯čļŗãč¸ãŋåēããã
ãåŖéãĢããæŦæŖããããĢåãžãŖãĻãæŦã¯ããããŧã ãæŦäŊãæã¤įĨčãæĻåŋĩã¯ããšãĻãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢãããããŖãĄã¯åžã§æĄå
ããĻãããããžãã¯ããĄãŽåąå
ã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãåˇĻåŗãĢįŊŽãããåąåĄããĄãŽããšã¯ã¨ãä¸å¤ŽãŽåĨĨãĢããčĒčēĢãŽããšã¯ãčĒŦæãããã¨ãé¨åąãŽä¸å¤ŽãĢįŊŽãããĻããå¸čšæ¨ĄåãŽåã§įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãã
ãããã¤ã¯ããģãĻãšåˇãå¤ãå¸čšã§ã¯ãããããŠããĒčæŗĸãäšãčļããčąĄåž´ã¨ããĻįŊŽãããĻãããæŦäŊãåäžãŽé ãããããæ´å˛ãããĒãã¸ã§ã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãåĢãŽéĢĒã§ãæĢã§ããããĒ襨æ
ãæĩŽããšãå¸čšæ¨ĄåãĢč§Ļããã
īŧããŽäēēããããĒéĄãæãŖãĻããŽãīŧ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãä¸įŦįŽã大ããããããããģãĻãšåˇãĢčĻįˇãį§ģãã¨ãįãã˛ãããã
ãâĻâĻããĒãåˇãã§ãžãããå´éĸãĢäēčŖãå
ĨãŖãĻããã¨ãããããããããŽããŽãĒčŖäŋŽããããĻãããčšåēãŽãããã¯įšãĢâĻâĻã
æã§č§Ļããã¨ããģããĻãšåˇã垎ããĢčģãŋãįĢãĻãĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ååãĢæãåŧãŖčžŧããã
ãįžåŽãįããã¨ã¯ããããããã¨ã ããŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãããããžããããããåããã¨ããæĨãã ãããäŋēãŽčä¸ãčĻãĻåĻãļãĒãã
ãčä¸ãčĻãĻåĻãļãã§ãããããããåĻãŗæšããããã¨ã¯įč§Ŗããžãããäŋēã¯ãããããŽåĨŊããããĒããŽã§ã
ãåĨŊããĢãããããžãããããĢæŽããããŠããã¯ããŠããĒåŊĸã§ãããåŽåãį¤ēãäģĨå¤ãĒããããĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ææãĒãč¨ãã¨ããæŦĄãĢčĄãããã¨čä¸ãåããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããģãĻãšåˇãŽåŗį̝æåãĢįŊŽããããããĢãˇãããããŠãĒã¨čĻãĻããããŦãããĢãŽåžãĢäģããĻæŠããããčŦčããåŋãåŽããã¨æ¸ãããããŦãŧããäšãããå°ããĒčšâĻâĻ
ãããããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽå
ĨåŖã ã
čĻįãĢå
ĨãããŽã¨æčãåãéĸããĻããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããã¨įŽãŽįĻįšãåãããã
ãæŦäŊãŽæĻåŋĩãįĨčãäŋĄåŋĩâĻâĻããããįĩé¨ããåžãæ
å ąãčįŠãããĻããå ´æã§ããã
ãããã ããããįŽĄįãããĻãããããããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēããļãģããŗã¯ãéį¨ã§ããã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãäŊæĨįãŽããąããããIDãĢãŧããåãåēããĻãããĸãŽåŗį̝ã§éģãå
ããĢãŧããĒãŧããŧãĢåŊãĻããããããã¨ããéŗãããã¨åæãĢč§Ŗé ãããããĸãããããĢå
å´ãĢå¸ãčžŧãžããã
ãåēãâĻâĻã
é¨åąãĢå
ĨãŖãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæããåŖ°ãæŧãããã
å°ãã˛ãããã¨ãã厤å
ã¯ãčļãŽããéģãåŖã¨åēã夊äēã§čĻãããĻããĻã厍大ãĒãĩãŧããŧãĢãŧã ãĢčŋãããčĻåæŖããæčĻã§ãæŦæŖãŽãããĢä¸Ļãã§ãã厍大ãĒæŖãčĻãĻããã¨ãįĄéãĢåēããåŗæ¸é¤¨ãŽãããĢãæããĻãããæŖãĢã¯ããããããæãããæ˛ããŋããåãŗããĒãŠãŽãŠããĢãč˛ŧãããĻããĻãæŦããŗãŖããã¨åãžãŖãĻããã
ãæŖãĢåãžãŖãĻãæŦã¯ãâã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšâã¨åŧã°ããããŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã¯ãŠãããããŽã§ããīŧã
ãæŖãĢč˛ŧãŖãĻãããŠããĢãããã ãīŧããããæĻåŋĩã ãã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšã¯ãæĻåŋĩãæ§æããčĻį´ ãããããŽčĻį´ ã褿°čОåŊããåēæĨäēãčĩˇããŖãã¨ããæŦäŊã¯ããŽæĻåŋĩãčĒčããã
ãæããŽã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšãããããååŋããåēæĨäēãããã°ãæŦäŊã¯æããæããīŧã
ãããã ãã ããĒãã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšã¯ä¸ã¤ãŽæĻåŋĩã¨ã ãįĩãŗã¤ããĻãããããããĒããäģãŽæŖãĢããåãããŽãåãžãŖãĻããã¨ããããį°ĄåãĢč¨ãã°ãæ˛ããŋã¨æãã严æšãŽæŖãĢåãžãŖãĻãã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšãããå ´åããããĢ芲åŊããåēæĨäēãčĩˇããã°ãæãã¨æ˛ããŋããŠãĄããŽã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšãååŋãããæįĩįãĢã¯ãã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšãä¸įĒååŋããæŖãŽæĻåŋĩããæŦäŊã¯čĒčãããŖãĻãã¨ã ã
ãæããŽã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšã10ååŋããĻãæ˛ããŋãŽã¤ãŗãšãŋãŗãšãīŧååŋããããæŦäŊã¯æãã¨čĒčããâĻâĻãããããã¨ã§ããīŧã
ãį°ĄåãĢč¨ãã°ãĒã
ããĒããģãŠã大æ ã¯įč§Ŗã§ããžããã
ããããæåžã¯ããŖãĄã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãé¨åąãŽåˇĻåĨĨãĢčļŗãåããããããĻãéįļ˛ãĢå˛ãžãããããŧã¯ãˇãĢããŧãŽåģēįŠãčĻããĻããã
ãããã¯īŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãåå°įãĢäŊãåēãããã
ãæĻįĨįåŽå
¨äŋįé厤ãéį§°SSRãStrategic Safety ReservesīŧãšããŠãã¸ãã¯ãģãģãŧãããŖãģãĒãļãŧããēīŧãŽįĨã ã
ãSSRâĻâĻã
ãŦãããĢãŽåŖ°ãã垎ããĢéãããããĒæ°ãããããčĒåãŽč
ãĢéŗĨčãįĢãŖãĻãããŽãĢæ°ãĨããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č
ãåžããĢåããã
éįļ˛ãŽåãããĢããéåãããĒæãĢã¯ãčåŗãĒæåã§ãčŦčãã¯įžåžŗãã¨æ¸ãããããŦãŧããč˛ŧãããĻããã
ãéįļ˛ãĢč§ĻããĒããģãããããã
čŋãĨããĻããã¨ããŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãéģæĩãčĩ°ãŖãĻããæģãĢã¯ããĒããīŧæĨã¯äŧæ¯ãåŋ
čĻãĢãĒãããčĻå ąãéŗ´ããé
åąåæĨããããããĒå¤ąæ
ã¯éŋãããã ãīŧã
éįļ˛ãŽééããčĻãããĸããåčĻããĻãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãŦãããĢã¨įŽãåãããã
ãé¨åąãŽå¨å˛ãä¸ãŽæšãĢæŧãåēãĻãããéģį´ĢãŽé§ãŋãããĒããŽã¯ãĒãã§ãīŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãããŠãĒã¨SSRãčĻãĻãããåãį´ãŖãã
ãé¨åąãŽä¸ã§ã¯ãéĢč˛ čˇãĒãˇãšãã ãåããĻããã菿°æŠéĸãŽč¸æ°ãŽãããĒããŽã ãčŋãĨããĻã鎿éå¸ãčžŧãŋįļãããĒããĻãã¨ã§ãããĒããã°ãåŽŗã¯ãĒãããããĢå
ĨãããŽã¯ã訹å¯ãããč
ã ãã ããĒã
ããŦãããĢããããåąéˇãå¯åąéˇã¯ãŠãšã ãīŧã
ãäŋēãŽį´åąãŽé¨ä¸ãĢããäŊäēēãå
ĨãããŽã¯ãããã10äēēã¯ããĒãã
ããããįĄįããå
Ĩããã¨ãããīŧã
ãéįļ˛ãįĒį ´ã§ããĻããå
å´ãŽããĸã¯éããĒããå
ĨããĢã¯ãéĄčĒč¨ŧã¨čšåŊŠčĒč¨ŧã䏿éãã¨ãĢ夿´ãããã¯ãŗãŋã¤ã ããšãåŋ
čĻã ãéįļ˛ã ãŖãĻãéģæĩãæĸããããĻããããŽéĩããĒããã°éããããĒãããĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãč
°ããä¸ããéĩæããčģŊãæãĄä¸ããã
ããĒããģãŠãæŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻãããã ãéčĻãĒå ´æãĒãŽã ã¨ãããã¨ã¯åãããžããã
ãããã ãįč§Ŗã§ããã°ãããããžãããããĢå
Ĩããã¨ã¯ãĒããããĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ããæģãããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãčä¸ãåããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãįŽã§åįãæŽããããĢãSSRãį´°é¨ãžã§č¨æļããã¨ãããļã¤ããŧãēãŽãĒããŖãšãĢæģãŖãã
æ¨æĨã¯ãīŧã¤ãŽåąããšãĻãããããã¯ãĢãĒããģãŠãŽå¤§é¨ãã ãŖãã¨ãį äŋŽã§čããããäģã¯čǰãããéģã
ã¨äģäēãããĻããããŦãããĢãčĒå¸ãĢæģããPCãĸããŋãŧãĢčĻįˇãåããĻããã
īŧæãŖãĻãããéãã ãĒīŧ
å¨å˛ãŽéŗãĢčŗãåžãã¤ã¤ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯čĒåãŽå¸ãĢåē§ãŖããæĨåãããĨãĸãĢãéããčĒãŋé˛ããĻããéããSSRãŽãã¨ãæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããããŽåŗéãã¯ããŦãããĢãŽčĒŦæäģĨä¸ãŽäŊããããâĻâĻ
ãâĻâĻīŧã
įĒįļã厤å
ãčĩ¤éģãčĻå
į¯ãæããĻãä¸įŦã§įˇæĨäēæ
ã¨åããéŗãéŗ´ãéŋãã¨ãå
¨åĄãįĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ããããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããĻã§ãļãŧãģãĩã¤ãŗã ã
ãŦãããĢãčŋãĨããĻããã
ãį äŋŽã§æãããĒããŖããīŧã
ãæãããžãããã寞åĻæŗã¯ååąã§čãã¨âĻâĻã
ãã ãããĒãã ãã芹ã¯ãã¨ã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããĢ寞åĻãåŋ
čĻã ã
įŦŦīŧčŠąãæ°äēēããĄãŽéåæ
-1-
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããŦãããĢãä¸åŋãĢåąåĄãčĩ°ãåããŽããįŽã¨čŗã§ããŧãŋãåããããĢčĻŗå¯ããĻããã
äģãé¨åąãæããĻããčĩ¤éģãčĻå
į¯ã¯ãããĢã¤ãŦãŗãã¨åŧã°ããããŽã§ãæŦäŊãäŊããããä¸åŋĢãĒãã¨ãä¸åŽãææãĒãŠãŽææ
ãæããã¨ããĢįēããããããŽã¨ãį äŋŽã§ã¯æããŖããã¨ããŖãĻããä¸åŋĢæãčĻããã¨æ¯åéŗ´ãããã§ã¯ãĒãããĻã§ãļãŧãģãĩã¤ãŗã¨ãããˇãšãã ãããĢã¤ãŦãŗãããĢã¤ãŦãŗãã¨ããĩã¤ãŦãŗããĢãŧã ãŦãŗã¨ããīŧã¤ãŽæ°åã¨éŖåããĻããĻãæ°åãŽä¸ä¸ãåšŗåå¤ãä¸åããä¸åãŖãã¨ããĢããĩã¤ãŦãŗã¯éŗ´ãã
ãããį¨åēĻčŊãĄįãããĒã
ãŦãããĢãč¨ãã¨åæãĢãčĻå
į¯ã¯æļããĻãé¨åąãĢéãããæģãŖããåąåĄããĄã¯ãæąãæããĻããããæ¯ãåãããããæ¤
åãĢč
°æããĻ夊äēãčĻããã¨ãå
¨åĄãį˛ããé ããĻããĒãããŦãããĢã ãã¯åšŗįļã¨ããĻããããããŽčĄ¨æ
ã¯ããã¤ãäģĨä¸ãĢéēããã
ãæŦäŊãĢäŊãããŖããã§ããã
é¨åąãŽæåĨĨãĢããããŦãããĢãŽããšã¯ãžã§æŠãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãã ãããĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãããĨãĸãŗãšãŽįŽãčĻä¸ããã
ãå
ˇäŊįãĢäŊãããŖããŽãįĨããããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãĢčããĻãŋãã¨ãããæããĻãããããã¯åãããããĒã
-2-
æå¸ã¨ãŽãã¨ãããŖãįŋæĨãŽæĨææĨã
æ¤åˇã¯ãä¸åēĻã¯īŧæéããĢįŽčĻããããŽãŽããããããčĩˇããæ°ãĢãĒããã夊äēãčĻä¸ãããžãžä¸æéãģãŠããŧãã¨ããĻãããããããĻčĢĻãããããĢäŊãčĩˇãããã
äŊãéãããĢãŧããŗãéããĻå¤ĒéŊãŽå
ããéĄãį
§ããã¨ãåå°įãĢéãããããæ¯ã¨ã¨ããĢãéĄãããããčä¸ãäŋ¯ãããšãããæãĢåãŖãĻãæå¸ãããŽããŖãããčĻãĻãåĨĨæ¯ãĢåãå
ĨãŖãã
æææĨãĢãĒãŖãĻãäģäēãå§ãžãŖãĻãããšãããæ°ãĢãĒãŖããããåãããããŽå ´æãã§æĸãžãŖãĻãããããæãåēãã°čãį´æĨ掴ããããããĒįãŋãæããããã¤ããŠããäģäēãããĻããããã§ãäŊčĒŋä¸č¯ãŽãããĢäŊãéãã
ãåããŖãĻãããã¨ã ãīŧã
ãåããĻãŽãã¨ãããĒãã
ãæŗåããĻããĒããŖãįĩæãããĒãã
ãįĨãŖãĻãįãŋã ã
é ãŽä¸ã§įš°ãåēããããäŧč°ã¯ãã¤ããæŗåģˇãĢįĢãŖãčĸĢåäēēãĢæŗ¨ããããéģãå°ãŖãčĻįˇãŽããã ãŖãã
æŧäŧæŠãĢãĒããããŖãããŽããåããčĻãĻãæãåãããããĻéãããåããŖãĻãããã¨ãããŖã¨æ¨ããĒįĩæã ãŖãĻįĨãŖãĻãâĻâĻã§ããã ããããã§ããããããããĒãã¨ãããã¨ãĢãĒããŽãâĻâĻããŽåãããã¯ãæ¤åˇãæčįãĢåããããããŽã ãŖãããčŗå
ããåŋããããŽã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãããã
æå¸ã¨ãŽéŖįĩĄãéįĩļãããžãžãä¸éąéãįĩãããã¨ããĻããéææĨãŽ15æéããéįã¤ããŽčļŗæˇãã¤ãããããããĒåŋã§ãäŧæŠåޤãŽįĒéãĢåē§ãŖãĻããã¨ãå
čŧŠį¤žåĄã§ããä¸ãįŦᝤäēēīŧããĄãŽãããã¤ã¨īŧã芹ããããĻããã
ããĒãããäģéąã¯ææããããŖã¨ãããĒæãã ãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãæ¤åˇãŽéŖãĢåē§ãŖãĻãå°ãŖããããĒįŦéĄãæĩŽããšãã
ããĄããŖã¨į˛ããĻãžããĻã
čĻįŦããčŋãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãããŖãããžãããããã¨ãããããããã¨ã ãč¨ãŖãĻãäŊãããŖããŽããã¨ã¯ãžã§ã¯čããĻããĒããŖãã
äģåš´ã§33æŗãĢãĒãä¸ãįŦã¯ãæĩ
éģãčãããĻããããããĒãŗãšããŧãããšãããŧããããĒããæ¤åˇãå
Ĩį¤žããååš´ãģãŠåãĢį°åããĻããĻãæ¤åˇãĢäģäēãæãããŽãããģã¨ããŠã¯ä¸ãįŦã ãŖãã
AIããŠãŗããŧã¨ã¯ãã¨ããã¨ãããããæĨã
ãŽæĨåãžã§ãåš
åēãæããäģã§ãåēĻã
ããŠããŧããĻããããå°ã大ããä¸éãŽįŽã¯ããŠããæåŦããããéĄã¯ããéǍã°ãŖãĻããããŽãŽãå
¨äŊã¨ããĻã¯ãããããĒå°čąĄãä¸ããã
ããžããäŊãããŖãããã¤ã§ããäģéąããã¨å°ãã ãããå¤ã¯ä¸äēēãŽæéã大äēãĢããã¨ããã
įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻãæ¤åˇãŽčŠãããŗãŖã¨åŠãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯äŧæŠåޤãåēãĻããŖãã
æå¸ã¨ãŽãã¨ã芹ããšãã ãŖãã ãããâĻâĻãããã¨ãč¸ãŽããããĢåĸ¨æąãæēĸããæ°ãããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯äģĨåãæå¸ã¨äŧãŖããã¨ããããä¸ãæãģãŠåãæ¤åˇãäŊåēĻããäģäēã§ä¸čŠąãĢãĒãŖãĻãããé ãŽããäēēã§ãã¨čŠąããĻãããŽã§ãæå¸ããäŧãŖãĻãŋãããã¨č¨ãŖããã¨ããããĢãąã ãŖããæå¸ããŠãããæããããããč¨ãŖããŽãã¯åãããĒãããäŧãããĒããŽãããããã¨čããä¸äēēã§å¤éŖãĢčĄãŖãã
ãããĢäšžãåãæŊ¤ããããĢããã¤ãããéŖ˛ãããŧãšãæŠããĒãŖãããä¸ãįŦã¯ä¸æéãģãŠããĻã芹ããĻč¯ããŖããæ¤åˇãããããããã¨č¨ãŖãĻã帰ãŖãĻããŖããããŽãã¨ãæĨãĢé
ããåãŖãĻããĻãæå¸ãåŋé
ããããã帰ãéãŽä¸č¨ããåŋãĢ县°´ãæĩ´ãŗããã
ãä¸ãįŦããããĒããå°ããé°å˛æ°ãæŋãŖãĻãã
æå¸ãŽįŦįšãŽč¨ãåããĢãæåã¯äŊãč¨ãŖãĻãããŽãåãããĒããŖãããåĢãĒæãããããã¨ãããã¨ã ãŖããč¨čãŽæåŗãįč§Ŗããã¨ããä¸įŦéĄãéēãããĒãŖãĻãæå¸ã¯æ
ãĻãĻãã大ä¸å¤Ģã ã¨æããäģäēã§æĨããĻãã ããĒããã¨äģãå ããããããŽåžä¸éąéãããåããå°ãĒããĒãŖããäģãããŽã¨ãã¨âĻâĻ
éãįšãããããĢäŧ¸ãŗãĻããããŦããŖããæ¯ãæããããĢãæ¤åˇã¯é ãæ¯ãŖãã
äģäēãįĩããŖãĻåŽļãĢ帰ãã¨ãæ¤
åãĢåē§ãŖãĻPCãįĢãĄä¸ããæĩˇå¤ãŽį¯įŊĒäēäģļãŽãããĨãĄãŗãŋãĒãŧãčĻŗããã¨ããĻããĩã¨ãéŖãĢåēãĻãããĒãšãšãĄäŊåãĢįŽãæĸãžãŖããæĨæŦãŽį¯įŊĒå˛ãĢæŽãäēäģļãŽãããĨãĄãŗãŋãĒãŧã§ãčĻŗããã¨ããĒãããŽã ãŖãããããŖããŋãŧãčĻãã¨ãäģĨåæŦã§čĒãã äēäģļãä¸Ļãã§ããã
äģäē帰ããĢ財ãŖããŗãŗããåŧåŊãéŖãšãĒãããåįãããæåãŽäēäģļã¯ãåäšåˇã§čĩˇããŖãįŖįĻæŽēäēēäēäģļã§ãæŦã§ãčĒãã ãããĒããããĒãã¨ãĢãĒãŖãĻããžãŖããŽãããããĨãĄãŗãŋãĒãŧãčĻŗãĻãįč§Ŗã§ããĒããŖããæŦĄã
ãĢæĩããĻããåįģãčĻŗãĻããã¨ããã¤ãŽéãĢã23æčŋããĢãĒãŖãĻããĻããĸã¤ãĸã¤ã¨ããæ°æãĄãæļããĻããã
åįģãæĸããĻããšãããæãĢåãã¨ãæå¸ã¨ãŽããŖãããéããæåãæãĄãããã¨ããã§éĄãä¸ãããæ°į§čãããŽãĄãåãŗPCãĢåããŖãã
-3-
ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãĢéŖįĩĄãåãŖãããĨãĸãŗãšã ãŖããããŦãããĢãåããããããĢãæįãĒæ
å ąãåžããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒããŖããããããä¸éąéãåēĻã
ããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¯éŗ´ãéŋããããĨãĸãŗãšãåžã
ãĢãäģäēãĢå ãããããĢãĒãŖãã
ããļã¤ããŧãēãŽäģäēã§ããŖã¨ãå°éŖãĒããŽã¯ãæĻåŋĩãŽæ¸ãæãã ããããã¯ããžãįēįããĒãããã ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšã¯å¸¸ãĢåããĻãããããĄãŗãããŗãšããããæŦäŊãäŊããŽåēæĨäēãĢč§ĻããããŗãĢãæ¸ãæããåŋ
čĻããæĸåãŽããŧãŋãĢį°å¸¸ã¯åēãĻããĒãããĒãŠãįĸēčĒããĒãããããŧãŋããŧãšãŽæ
å ąãåããžã¨ããĻãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢä¸ããã
äģãŽåąãĢæ¯ãšãã¨ãåŋããã¯ããˇã¨č¨ãããããæ
å ąãæēĸããĻããįžäģŖãĢãããĻã¯ã常ãĢæĸåãŽæĻåŋĩãæēãããæŗĸã¯æŧãå¯ããæˇˇäšąãéŋãããããĢãæĸåãæ¯æããæ
å ąãæĸããå
Ĩãæŋãã¨ããč˛ čˇãåéŋãã¤ã¤ãåŽåŽãäŋã¤ãã¨ã常æ
åããã
īŧããŽãžãžéåģãŽæĻåŋĩãĢį¸ãããĻããããæŦäŊãĢåéĄãįããããããĒããâĻâĻīŧ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãčĒåãå
ĨåąããåãĢčĩˇããŖãåēæĨäēãŽæ
å ąãéããããŽã¨ããŽããļã¤ããŧãēãŽåããĢã¤ããĻãåæããĻããã
æå¸ã¨ããåĨŗæ§ãĢåįŊãããã¨ããæŦäŊããããŠãĻããæãåēãããããĢãååąããšãĻããããã¯įļæ
ã§ãããŽãŦãããĢã§ãããåˇãæąãæĩããĻãããããã
īŧããŠãĻããäŊããåããã°å¯žåĻæŗãčããããããŠãããŧãŋãĢãĸã¯ãģãšã§ããĒãã¨ãŠããĢããĒããĒããīŧ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæ
å ąããžã¨ããããĄã¤ãĢãéããã¨ãå¸ãįĢãŖãĻãŦãããĢãŽã¨ãããžã§æŠããã
ããĒãã īŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯ããŽã§ããĒã¨ããįŽãåãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããŽįŽãæŖéĸããåãã¨ããĻããäŋēãå
Ĩãį´åãĢčĩˇããŖããåįŊäēäģļãĢã¤ããĻãĒãã§ãããã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãããããŠãããīŧã
ãäēäģļãŽãã¨ãŽæŦäŊãŽåããĢã¤ããĻãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢä¸ããããĄãŽæ
å ąãĢãå°ãæ°ãĢãĒããã¨ããããžããĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽč¨čãĢããŦãããĢã¯ããŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻãįéãŽãˇã¯ãæŋãããã
ãäŋēãä¸ããæ
å ąãĢãåéĄãããŖãã¨č¨ããããŽãīŧã
ãåéĄãããŖããã¨ãããã¨ã§ã¯ãããžãããåĨãŽč§Ŗéãã§ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ãããã¨ã§ãã
ãããŖãĄãåãĢčĒåãŽæčĻããããã ããã芹ããĻãŋãã
ãæå¸ãŽååŋããåąéēãĒäēå
ã¨ããĻä¸ããĻããžãããåŊŧåĨŗãæŦäŊãåĢãŖãĻããã¨ããäēäģļãŽãã¨ã§čŊčããĻããã¨ãæããžãããį´į˛ãĒåĨŊæãåĒããããæĨãĻããããŽã ã¨æããžãã
ããĒãããæãīŧã
ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãčĻãžãããã襨æ
ãåŖčĒŋããåŖ°ãč¨čéŖãããåĨŊæã¨åããããŽãåĢãžããĻããžããããŦãããĢãããŽå¤æãįĩļ寞ãĢééãŖãĻããã¨ã¯č¨ããžããããã ãåĨŊæãŽå¯čŊæ§ãčããĻãįĸēãããåŋ
čĻãããã¨æããžãã
ãã¤ãžãã¯ãäŋēãŽå¤æãĢã¯åããããã¨ããããããã¨ãã
ãį̝įãĢč¨ãã°ããããĒããžãã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãéĄãĢéįãæĩŽããšãĻãæŽ´ããããĢããšã¯ãåŠããã
ãããžãã¯æŦäŊãæãŖãĻããããŠãĻããįĨããĒããéåģãĢãŠããĒãã¨ãããŖããįĨããĒããæŦäŊãŽæ´å˛ãįĨããĒãããžããäģã ããŽããŧãŋã§å°ãåēããæ
å ąãĒãŠčãŖãēããĒį´åãã¨åãã īŧīŧãäŊæ§ãŽã¤ããã īŧīŧīŧãįĢå ´ããããžããīŧīŧīŧã
é¨åąå
¨äŊãĢéŋãæ¸ĄããģãŠãŽåŖ°ãĢãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ä¸įŦãįãã˛ããããããåĨãŽå¯čŊæ§ãčæ
ŽããĒããã¨ããæŦäŊãŽãããĢãĒããã§ããīŧãã¨č¨ãčŋããã
ããããæŦåŊãĢâĻâĻããäŋēéãŽäģäēã¯ãæŦäŊãŽåŽåŽãåŽããã¨ã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨čãčĸĢããã
ãããžããŽčãã¯ãæŦäŊãŽåŽåŽãč
ãããčĒãããããĢã¯ãããĒãã
ããããã§ããīŧãããã§ãæŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻãããæŦåŊãĢâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽč¨čãããæļããããĢãããĢã¤ãŦãŗãéŗ´ããé¨åąãčĩ¤éģãæãžãŖããäēäēēãŽããåããčĻåŽãŖãĻããåąåĄããĄãã䏿ãĢåãåēãããŦãããĢã¨ããĨãĸãŗãšããįŽãŽåãŽåéĄãĢ寞åĻãããããĢåãåēããã
īŧéãâĻâĻæŦäŊã¯ããŖã¨ã嚸ããæãŋãĒãããåŽåŋãåžããããĢ嚸ããæįĩļããâĻâĻãããĒæĒãŋãããīŧ
äģäēãããĒããĒãããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽé ãŽä¸ã§ã¯ããã¤ããŽčããåãåãŖãĻãããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢãããSSRãããŽå ´æããäŊãéĸäŋããĻãããããããčĒŋãšãã°âĻâĻã§ãããŠãããŖãĻīŧ
ãããĨãĸãŗãšīŧãæãæĸãããĒīŧīŧã
å
čŧŠåąåĄãããŽåąč˛ŦãåããĻããããŋãžãããã¨äģäēãåéããĒãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ä¸ã¤ãŽå¯čŊæ§ãčããĻãããäģãŽåąãĢé
åąãããæ°äēēä¸äēēãåŊŧãã¯ãŠãæãŖãĻãããŽããéåæããããŽã¯ããļã¤ããŧãēã ããĒãŽããããã¨ãâĻâĻ
ããĢã¤ãŦãŗãéŗ´ãæĸãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯äŧæŠæéãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãååąãįšãåēå ´ãžã§æŠããããåĨŗįĨååēå ´ãã¨åŧã°ããããã¯ãååąã¸ãŽé莝ãã¸ã§ã¤ãŗãããĻããå ´æã§ãäģåąãĢčĄããĢã¯ãåŋ
ããããéãåŋ
čĻããããīŧåąã¯ãæä¸éãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãīŧéãããļã¤ããŧãēãīŧéããŦããŧãŋãŧãēã§ããļãģããŗã¯ã¨ã¨ãŧãĩã éåēĢãå°ä¸ãĢãããåĨŗįĨååēå ´ã¯ä¸éãĢãããäŧæŠæãĢããĒãŖãĻããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åĨŗįĨåãæŖéĸããčĻããããŗããĢč
°ãä¸ãããã
åēå ´ãĢã¯ãäģãĢãåąåĄãããããįĨãŖãéĄã¯ããĒããããä¸åēĻãåēå ´ãčĻåããĻãããéäŋĄį¨ãŽã¯ã¤ã¤ãŦãšã¤ã¤ããŗãã¤ã¯ãčŗãĢäģããã¨ããååãåŧã°ããĻéĄãä¸ããã
ãåã¯įĸēãâĻâĻã
ãããŗãģãĸãģããããä¸įˇãĢį äŋŽãåããã
ãčĻããĻãããããĄããã
ãéŖãããīŧã
ãããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯å°ãåˇĻãĢãēãŦãĻããĸãģããã¯ããããã¨ããã¨č
°ãä¸ãããã
ãĩããã¨ãããŠãŽéĻããéŧģãæĢã§ãããĢããŧãŦãããŽčã¨ãč
°ãŽå°ãä¸ãžã§ããããĩãŠãĩãŠãŽééĢĒããŋã¤ããšãĢãŧããŽéģããšãŧããĢčēĢãå
ãŋãéãäēéãŽįŽã¨ãå ã
ã¨ããäŊãžãã¯ãæ°äēēãŽããã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãåã¯ããļãģããŗã¯ãĢé
åąã ããīŧã
ããããããĒãã¯ããļã¤ããŧãēããããŠãīŧãįžå ´ã¯ã
ãåŋããããäģãŽåąãĢæ¯ãšããããˇãããããŠãããŖãĄã¯īŧã
ãã¨ãĒãŧããŽéãžããŖãĻæããã§ãããļãģããŗã¯ãŖãĻããããĄããˇã§ãŗãĢčēĢãå
ãã§ããã ãã§ãä¸čēĢãäŧ´ãŖãĻãĒããŽããããããããã
ãĸãģããã¯ã严æãä¸ãĢåããĻããæ¯ãã¤ããã
ãããĄãĢã¯ãããããŽã¯ããĒãããŠããŦãããĢããã¯ä¸ã
įãåŧˇãã
ãããļã¤ããŧãēãŽåŽčŗĒããããŽäēēããããã¤ãäŊæĨįãįãĻãã
ãããįĨãŖãĻããã
ãããĄãŽä¸ã§ããä¸įŽįŊŽãããĻããããã
ãįĸēããĢãäģäēã¯ã§ãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããããŠâĻâĻã
ããĒãĢīŧã
ãĸãģãããįŽã大ããããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯įŽã ããåãããĻãå¨å˛ãįĸēčĒããĻããããæ°ãĢãĒããã¨ããããã¨å°åŖ°ã§č¨ãŖãã
ãæ°ãĢãĒããã¨ããã
ãĸãģããã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããŖãąããį§ã ããããĒããŋãããã
ãããŖãĄãīŧã
ãį§ããæ°ãĢãĒããã¨ããããŽã
-4-
ãĸãģããã¯ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽįŽãčĻãĻãæŦĄãŽč¨čãč¨ããšãããæ°į§čŋˇãŖããį äŋŽãŽã¨ããĢ芹ããããããäģĨä¸ãŽãã¨ã¯åãããĒãããžã æ°æĨã¨ã¯ãããå ´ãĢæãžãŖãĻããã°ããŦãããĢãéããĻããļãģããŗã¯ãŽåąéˇãããŗãģãˇã§ãŧããĢ芹ãä¸ããŖãĻãéĸåãĒãã¨ãĢãĒãã
ãäŊãæ°ãĢãĒãīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãčĻįˇãå¨å˛ãĢæĩããã
ãããã
ãĸãģããã¯éĻãæ¯ãŖãã
ãå°ããčããĻãã ããããŠãį´æããĻã
ãå
厚ãĢããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãã¨ããĸãģããã¯åŖå
ãįˇŠããã
ããããããããŽãģããäŋĄį¨ã§ãããã
ãäŊãããŖãīŧã
ãããŖãã¨ãããããéåæãŖãĻč¨ãŖããģãããããããããĄããŠããĒåąãã¯ãčĒŦæããĒããĻãåãããããīŧã
ãã¨ãŧãĩã éåēĢãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããåææãå åˇĨããĻäŊããããäēįŽããååąåãŗäŊå
ãĢé
åããã
ããããã§ããäēįŽã¯æŊ¤æ˛ĸãããĒãããããŠãããããģãŧčĩ¤åããå
ĨãŖãĻããåææãŽčŗĒãæĒãããéãå°ãĒããããäēįŽã¨ããĻäŊŋããããŽã常ãĢæ¯æ¸ããĻãããäēįŽãŽéåēĢãĢã¯ããããŖããĄãŗãŋãĢãããããĄãŽä¸ã¤ããããã ããŠãåčéåēĢã§ããããããĄãĢã¯ãģã¨ããŠå
ĨããĒãã
ãã¨ãŧãĩã ã¯ãæŦäŊãŽčĄåããã¤ãŦã¯ããĢåæ ããããã¸ãŖãŗã¯ããŧãããŗãŗããåŧåŊã°ããã§ãįĄį æéãīŧãīŧæéãä¸åš´ãããåãžã§ã¸ã ãĢéãŖãĻããããããŠãäģã¯äŧį¤žãŽčĄã帰ããĢæŠããããããļãģããŗã¯ã大å¤ã ããã¨ããå¯ããããã
ãããŽčĄåãå¤ãããããŽæĻåŋĩãæ¸ãæãããŽããããļã¤ããŧãēãŽäģäēããã
ãããč¨ãããã¨ãčŋãč¨čããĒãã
ããĩãĩããããããč˛ŦããĻããããããĒããã
ãããã§ãæ°ãĢãĒããã¨ãŖãĻīŧã
ã忝ãŽãēãŦããããã¨ãã
ãå
ĨãŖãĻããĻãäēįŽã¨ãé
åãããäēįŽãåããĒãīŧã
ãããĄãŽåąã¯ãé¨åąãŽåĨĨãŽåŖãĢ褿°ãŽãĸããŋãŧãããŖãĻãã¨ãŧãĩã ãŽįļæŗãããããŖããĄãŗãŋãĢãããããĄãŽįļæ
ããããšãĻåãããããĢãĒãŖãĻããæ ĒäžĄææ°ãŽčĄ¨į¤ēãŋãããĢãĒãŖãĻããŽãã
ããĸããŋãŧãčĻãã°ããĒãĸãĢãŋã¤ã ã§äģãŽįļæ
ãåããīŧã
ãããããããčĻãĻããˇã§ãŧãã¯äēįŽãŽé
åãæąēããĻããã§ãããäēįŽãæ¯æ¸įļæ
ãŽãããĢã¯ãæŦäŊãããžãããŦãĻãĒããŽã
ããīŧããŠããããã¨īŧã
ãæŦäŊãæ´ģåãããĢã¯ãäŊã¨åŋãåãããããŽäēįŽããããããããŖã¨ãĄãŗãŋãĢãŽéåēĢãĢãããŽãããããã§ãããäģãŽäēįŽã§čããã¨ãæŦäŊãŽäŊãåŋããããŖã¨ä¸åŽåŽãĒã¯ããĒãŽãããããĒãŽãĢãæ¯ãåš
ãå°ãĒããã ããæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻã忝ãčĻãĻãŋããã ããŠã
ã忝ãåããĒãīŧã
ãããããã¨ãã°ãåå
Ĩãīŧãæ¯åēã10ã ãŖãããčĩ¤åã¯īŧããããĒãŽãĢãčĩ¤åãīŧã¨ãīŧãĢãĒãŖãĻãæãã
ãčĻããĒãåå
ĨããããããĢčĻãããããã
ãã§ãããããĒããŽã¯ãĒãã¯ããĒãŽãã
ããˇã§ãŧããäģãŽåąåĄã¯ãããŽãã¨ãĢã¤ããĻãŠãčããĻãīŧã
ãčĒ¤åˇŽãŽį¯å˛ãŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻãããįĸēããĢãå¤å°ãŽčĒ¤åˇŽã¯åēããŽãå¤įã§äŊŋããããéãŋãããĢãåŽå
¨ãĢæ°å¤åã§ããããŽãããĒããããã ã¨ããĻããéåģãŽåæ¯ããŧãŋãŽãģã¨ããŠããããĒæãã ãããããŖãąãå¤ã
ããĒããģãŠâĻâĻã
ãããĒããŽãģãã§ããäŊããããŽīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããæ°ãĒãå¨å˛ãčĻåããĻãããSSRãĢã¤ããĻ芹ããã
ãåŽčŗĒãįĢå
ĨįĻæĸé åãã
ãĸãģããã¯įã¨åŖ°ãã˛ãããã
ãčĒŋãšãããå
ĨãããŽã¯åąéˇã¨å¯åąéˇããŦãããĢã¨ããŽå´čŋãŽīŧäēēã ãã ãŖãã
ãåąåĄã¯å
¨é¨ã§äŊäēēīŧã
ã96äēēã
ãããã ãããĻãå
ĨãããŽã¯īŧäēēã ãīŧã
ããããããã¨ãĢãĒãã
ãįĸēããĢãåŧãŖãããããâĻâĻã
ãååããĒããīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããäēã¤ãŽãã¨ã¯ãäŊãéĸäŋããĻããæ°ãããã
ããããâĻâĻããããååããžããããį§ããããããããŽã ãŖãĻį´åžã§ãããŋã¤ããããĒããã
ãäģãŽīŧåąãæ°ãĢãĒãããŠãäŋēéãčããĻãããã¨ã芹ãããŠããã¯âĻâĻã
ããããåŊŧããŽčŠąãčããĻããããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽããĄã¯ãããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽããĨãĢãŧãšâĻâĻį§ããããŗãŗãŋã¯ãããĻãŋããã
ãåŠãããã§ããæ°ãã¤ããĻã
ããããåããŖãĻãã
äēäēēã¯čģŊãæĄæãäē¤ããã¨ããäēããŽåąãĢæģãŖãã
-5-
æ¤åˇã¯ãį˛ãåãŖãĻããã
æå¸ã¨ãŽéŖįĩĄãåãããæãĄåããã¨ãã§ããĒãįļæ
ãĢãããŖã¨ããĻãããã¨ãã§ãããčĒåãå¤ãããããŽããŗããĨååä¸ãģãããŧãããã䏿Šč¸ãŋåēãåæ°ã¨čĒäŋĄãã¨ããŖãã¤ããŗããĢéŖæĨåå ããäģäēįĩãããĢäēæĨįļããĻã¨ãããã¨ãããŖãã
įĩæįãĢįĨčã¯åžãããããæå¸ãĢãæčŋãŠãīŧãäŊãéĸįŊãæ įģããŖãīŧãã¨éããŽãį˛žä¸æ¯ã§ãæå¸ãããããæčŋã¯ãâĻâĻãã¨ãããåããå§ããé ãŽãããĒčŋäŋĄãããã ãã§ããã¯ãã¯ã¨ãčãŽįãŋãįļããããĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ããŖãããéãããã¨ã¯é˛åąã§ã¯ããããŽãŽãããŽå
ãčãããã¨ããã¨ãæéã§äŊãčĻãããæé˛ãŽä¸ã§čĩ¤ãéˇãéŗ´ãŖãĻãããããĒåŋãŽãžãžãæĨ常ã¨åãåãŖãĻããã
ãæ¤åˇã
ãŧãããã¨ãæãæĸãããžãžPCãŽãĸããŋãŧãčĻã¤ããĻããã¨ãä¸å¸ãŽį§åąąãĢåŧã°ãããčĻãã¨ããããŖãĄãĢãããã¨ææãããĻãããčãŽįãŋãåŧˇããĒããéĄãããããĒããããšã¯ãžã§čĄãã¨ããããžããããâĻâĻãį§åąąã¯PCãŽįģéĸãæ¤åˇãĢåããã
ããĄããã¨čĻį´ãããīŧãããžããäŊãŖãčĻįŠãããåŽĸå
ãŽįžåŽãäŊãåæ ãããĻãĒãããããĒããŽãŽãããĢéãæããããŽããŖãĻčĻæ
ãããĻããã
ãããŋãžããâĻâĻã
ãããžããæčŋæ§åãå¤ã ããĒīŧããžããããĒããšããããå°ããīŧã
ãããŋãžããâĻâĻã
ãčŦãã ããããĒãâĻâĻã
ãį§åąąčǞéˇã
æ¤åˇã¨į§åąąãéĄãä¸ããã¨ãä¸ãįŦãããã
ãæ¤åˇã¯ãå°ãį˛ããĻããã ãã ã¨æããžããããŽäģļãŽããŠããŧã¯äŋēããããŽã§ãããããããĢâĻâĻã
į§åąąã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãããžãžä¸ãįŦãčĻãĻãéĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãã
ãåããŖãããããããžããĢäģģããããä¸ãįŦã
ããããã¨ãããããžãã
ãããŠãĒãæ¤åˇã
į§åąąã¯æ¤åˇãčĻãã
ãããã§įĩãããŖãĻãããããĒããããĒīŧãããŖããããĻãããīŧã
ãã¯ããåããŖãĻãžãâĻâĻã
å¸ãĢæģãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯ããšã¯ãĢč
°æãããããĢããĻãæ¤åˇãčĻãã
ããããããĻãæå¸ãĄãããŽãã¨īŧã
ãâĻâĻããã§ããã
ããžããį°ĄåãĢã¯å˛ãåããĒãã¨æãããŠãįĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻããããĢããããĒããããããŖãĻãããã¯æ¤åˇãåããŖãĻãããã
ãâĻâĻã
ãããåŋ
čĻãĒããäŋēãæå¸ãĄããã¨čŠąããĻãããã
äēæŗå¤ãŽææĄãĢãæ¤åˇã¯ä¸ãįŦãčĻä¸ããã
ããããĒæãéĄããĒãããĒã
ä¸ãįŦã¯åžŽįŦãã ã
ãåŋ
čĻãĒããã ããããŖããŽäģļã¯ããžããã¨åĻįããĻãããããäŧæĨã¯ããŖããäŧãã§ãæ°åãäŊåãå垊ãããĒãã
ãããŋãžããããčŋˇæãããããĻâĻâĻã
ä¸ãįŦãčĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãĻããã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯ããä¸åēĻãããŗãĒã¨é ãä¸ããĻãããPCãĸããŋãŧãĢåãį´ãŖãã
åããŖãĻããã
åãĢé˛ãžãĒãã¨ãããĒãã
ããŽãžãžã§ã¯äŊãæŽããĒããäŊãâĻâĻ
äģäēãįĩããĻãåŽļãĢ帰ãŖãĻããããĢå
ĨãŖãé ãčŗå
ãĢããīŧåąãŽä¸ã¤ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēã§ã¯ãæ°äēēãŽããŠãããģããĄã¯ãããåąå
ãéčĻããįŠēæ°ã§æããĻããã
ãããŽããŧãŋã¯ããããâĻâĻīŧã
ããŽä¸č¨ãã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãããŧãŋåŊé īŧ
-1-
ä翏ŦæĻįĨåąãéį§°ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãã¯ãããļã¤ããŧãēã¨ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽæ å ąããã¨ãĢãæ°į§å ãĢčĩˇããã ãããã¨ãä翏ŦããæŦäŊãįžåŽãĢ寞åŋã§ãããããĢããã¨ãããīŧåąãŽä¸ã§ã䏿 ¸įãĒäģäēãæ ãŖãĻãããä翏ŦãåŽå ¨ãĢä¸č´ãããã¨ã¯ä¸ã ãĒãããŽãŽããžãŖãããŽäēæŗå¤ãŽãã¨ãčĩˇããŖãå ´åãᎿĨ寞åŋã¨ãĒããäēįŽãå¤ãæļč˛ģãããã¨ãĢãĒããããŽãããįžåŽã¨ãŽåš ãæĨĩåå°ãããĒãä翏Ŧããããã¨ããæåĒå äēé ã¨ãĒãã
å¯åąéˇã§ãããããŧãģãã¤ãŗããä¸åŋãĢãåąåĄã¯ãå¤é¨å
Ĩåãããå
é¨ååŋãããæĻåŋĩãããæ°åãã¨ãããīŧã¤ãŽããšã¯ãĢåãããĻåããĻããĻãé¨åąãŽä¸å¤ŽãĢã¯ãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãã¨ãããå°įåãŽãããĒãĸããŋãŧãč¨įŊŽãããĻãããįäŊãĸããŋãŧã¯ã夊äēã¨åēä¸ãĢæ°´éįŽĄãŽãããĒãąãŧããĢã褿°äŧ¸ãŗãĻããĻãīŧã¤ãŽããšã¯ãŽį̝æĢã¨įšããŖãĻãããæ
å ąãéį´ãæ
å ąã¯ããšãã¯ããŠã įļãĢæ ãåēãããīŧåéãŽæ įģãŽãããĒéåēĻã§ãæĩåįãĢæĩããĻããããã¤ãŗãã¯ãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãĢæ ãåēãããæ
å ąããã¨ãĢãä翏ŦãŽæįĩæąēåŽãčĄãŖãĻããã
åąåĄããĄã¯ãæŦäŊãå¯ãĻããã¨ãäģĨå¤ãįĩļãéãĒãæĩãčžŧãã§ããæ
å ąãåæããä礿ããäŧ芹ãéåãããã¨ã¯ãĒãâĻâĻãããĒããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽãĒããŖãšããäģãéãįŠēæ°ãčĻãŖãĻããã
ãããŽããŧãŋã¯ããããâĻâĻīŧã
ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãä¸ããĻããįģåãæ˛ããããŠãããģããĄã¯ãã¯ãåąåĄãŽčĻįˇãããšãĻčĒåãĢæŗ¨ãããĻãããŽãĢæ°ãĨãã¨ãä¸įŦč
ãä¸ãããããããéĄããæĩããæąãããŽãžãžãĢãč¨čãįļããã
ãããã¯å åˇĨãããĻããžãīŧãä翏ŦãčǤčĒå°ããå¯čŊæ§ãâĻâĻã
ãäŊãé¨ãã§ãããŽããĒīŧã
įäŊãĸããŋãŧãŽčŋããĢãããã¤ãŗããæŠããĻããĻãããĄã¯ããŽåãĢįĢãŖãã
å°ããããã¨ããããŧã¯ãšãŧããįãĻããããããč˛įŊãŽčãããįŊãčĻãããįãŖį´ããĢįˇãåŧãããããĒä¸éãŽįŽã¯ãįŠãããĒåŖčĒŋã¨ä¸ä¸č´ãĒéãã§ãįéãĢå¯ããããĻãããˇã¯ã¯ãããããéĄãĒãŽã§ã¯ãĒããã¨æããģãŠæˇąãã
ãį§ãŽä翏ŦãééãŖãĻããã¨ããããããã¨ããĒīŧãæ°äēēãŽâĻâĻããĄã¯ãããã
ãēã¤ãŖã¨ããã¤ãŗãããããĢ䏿Šč¸ãŋčžŧãã§ããã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯å°åˇããįģåãä¸ãããåč§ãéģį¸ãĄãŦããåŗæã§čģŊãä¸ä¸ããããéãŋãåĢãã įˇč˛ãŽčãããããĢéãŋãæˇąããĻãããæãŽãããĒį´°ãäŊãéãããŽãã严čļŗã¨ä¸ĄæãĢåãå
ĨããĻåŋ
æģãĢæããĻããã
ãå¯åąéˇãŽãä翏ŦãééãŖãĻããããã§ã¯ãããžããâĻâĻã
ãå¯åąéˇãĒããĻãåēãč¨ãæšã¯ããĒããĻããããååã§čĒãã§ãããĻãããããč¨ããĒããŖãããĒīŧã
ãã¯ããããŋãžããâĻâĻããŽããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇãŽä翏ŦãããããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããĻâĻâĻã
ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãä¸ããĻããæ
å ąãããããâĻâĻã¤ãžããæ
å ąãŽį˛žæģãčĄãŖãĻããããŖãšããŧãããæ
å ąãå åˇĨããĻããĄãĢä¸ããĻããĻããããããããã¨ããĒīŧã
ãããŖãšããŧãᎍééˇãŽãããĒãŽããŠããã¯ãåãããžããâĻâĻããŠãããŽããŧãŋã¯å åˇĨãããĻããžãâĻâĻīŧã
ããŠãŽãããããããĒīŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ãįģåãæãĢåãŖãĻįŽãį´°ãããåįŊäēäģļãŽã¨ããŽã大éæå¸ãŽčĄ¨æ
ãæããįģåãĢã¯ãä¸čĻããã¨ãããããĒã¨ããã¯čĻåŊãããĒããčģŊãįéãŽãˇã¯ãå°ãéããåŖãä¸åããĢãĒãŖãĻããåŖč§ããŠããčĻãĻãéåæã¯ãĒãã
ããããå åˇĨãããããŽã ã¨īŧããã¤ãŗãã¯ãããĄã¯ããŽįŽãčĻãããčĒŦæããĻãããããĒīŧã
ãããã§ããããã¨ããããã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãåŖč§ã¨įéãæãããã
ãé ŦãĢããããĢã§ãããˇã¯âĻâĻããã¯ãåŖč§ãä¸ããŖãĻããã¨ããĢã§ããããŽã§ããįéãŽãˇã¯ã¯ãįãŽåŊĸã¨į
§ããåãããã¨ãä¸ä¸č´ãčĻãããžããããĒãį˛žåˇ§ãĒå åˇĨã§ãããééããããžãããåãããĨãããŽã¯ããŽã¨ããã§ãããčĻčŊã¨ããĻããžãŖãĻãäŊã䏿č°ãããĒããåãäŊåēĻãčĻãĻæ°ãĨããĻãã ããč¨å¤§ãĒæ
å ąãčĻãĻãããã¤ãŗããããčĻčŊã¨ãããã¨ããã¨ããããããŽã§ããĒãâĻâĻã
ãããĄã¯ãããã
ããīŧãããã¯ãâĻâĻã
ãããŧãŋãããŖããčĻãĻãčǤãããããããããĒãã¨æãæããåãŽå§ŋåĸã¯ãį´ æ´ãããããŽã ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽææ¨ã§ããâããŧãŋãĢåēãĨãä翏ŦãŽåžšåēâããåŋ åŽãĢåŽããã¨ããĻãããŽã ãããã ãããåã¯ãžã įĩé¨ãæĩ
ããæãčžŧãŋã¯čĻããããŽãįããããįĻãããããŖããåĻãã§ããã¨ããã
ããããããã¯æãčžŧãŋã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãčĻããĻããããžããä翏Ŧã¯åˇéãĢãåˇéããĒããã°æŖãããĒãŠãĒãã
ãåã¯åˇéãĢâĻâĻã
ãå°ãäŧãã§ããããŠãããĒīŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãããžãžåŖå
ãįˇŠããããĄã¯ããŽčŠãĢãããŗãã¨åŗæãįŊŽããã
ããããããžããâĻâĻã
ãã¤ãŗããé ˇãã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯äŧéããĻããé¨åąãåēããåˇĻčŠãåŗæã§æĻããåãåãã ã
ééãŖãĻããīŧãæãčžŧãŋīŧ
ããããéããå åˇĨãããĻãããäŊåēĻãčĻããįĸēãããã
åĨŗįĨååēå ´ãžã§æĨãã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯ããŗããĢč
°ãä¸ãããã
ãã¤ãŽéãĢãæĄããããĻããåŗæŗãč§ŖããĻãįģåãčĻããæå¸ãŽéĄãĢãããŽã¯ãčģŊčã§ãčŊčã§ããĒããããã¯âĻâĻãããæ
ããŋããããå åˇĨããĻčŊčãŽãããĢčĻããĻããã
ããĒãã§ãããĒãã¨âĻâĻã
åãŗåŗæãĢåãå
ĨããįģåããįŽãéĸããĻãåĨŗįĨåãĢåãããįŊã大įįŗã§ã§ããåĨŗįĨåã¯ãåŗæã夊ãĢæ˛ããįĄčĄ¨æ
ãŽéĄã¯ãããããĢä¸ãčĻãĻãããåˇĻæãĢã¯ã襨į´ãĢãčŦčãã¯įžåžŗãã¨æ¸ããããčžæ¸ãŽãããĒæŦãæãŖãĻããĻãåēå ´å
¨äŊãčåŗãĒįŠēæ°ãĢããĻããã
īŧčŦčãâĻâĻīŧ
ããŧãŋãčģŊčĻããĻčŋåãããã¨ã¯ãčŦčãã¨ã¯éãâĻâĻå¯åąéˇãŽæčĻã§ããŖãĻããééãã¯ééãã¨ææããšãâĻâĻå
å´ããįãžããĻããæãã¨ã¯čŖč
šãĢããããä¸ģåŧĩãããˇãŧãŗãæŗåããã¨ãčļŗãéãããéŽãããããĢåŗæã§åŠããĻããåãžããã¨ã¯ãĒããåĨĨæ¯ãčģãžããĻäŋ¯ããã
ãâĻâĻã
ãã¤ãŗãããããŧãŋãå åˇĨãããĻãããã¨ãčĒããĒããĒãããŠãããããīŧãčĒãããããĢã¯ãŠãããã°âĻâĻ
ããâĻâĻã
įĄæčãĢåŖ°ãæŧããĻãéĄãä¸ããã
ãģã¨ããŠåæãĢãåąåĄååŖĢãéŖįĩĄãåãåãæãĢäŊŋãæē帯į̝æĢããĩããŗãŗãˇãŖãšâĻâĻéį§°ãĩããŗãŗãéŗ´ãŖãããããŖãšããŦã¤ãĢ襨į¤ēãããååãčĻãĻįĄčĻããã¨ãåĨãŽéŖįĩĄå
ãĢãĄããģãŧã¸ãéãŖãĻãããåēå ´ãåžãĢããã
-2-
ãããžãã¯äŊåãĒããąãâĻâĻã
įĩąåᎍéåąãéį§°ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽäŧæŠåޤã§ãã¤ãŗãŦããŽãããŠãŗã¯åãããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãäŊåãĒããąãŖãĻãĒãã§ããīŧīŧã
ãåå
æä¸čĩ°ãåãŖãĻæ
å ąãéããĒãããããĒãã¤ãŗãŦããŽäģäēã䏿Ĩä¸ããĒããĻããąããŖã¨ããĻããããžããŋãããĒæ°äēēã¯åããĻã ã
ãããŠãŗåąåĄãŽč¨čãĢãæ°äēēãŽã¤ãŗãģããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãįŽããããããããã
ããããĒãã§ããīŧīŧãã§ããã¤ãŗãŦããŖãĻäŊååč˛ ãŋãããĒæããããĒãã§ããã
ãããã¯ããã ããæ°äēēã¯å¤§æĻãčĒåãŽäēæŗãčļããæŋåãĢéŗãä¸ããããã ãããããå°ããã¤æ
ŖããĻããŖãĻãããĒãããããĢãĒããããžãã¯ããããĒããäŋĄããããĒãããããĨãĢãŧãšã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãå°ãéĻãåžããĒãããææ§ãĒįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ããŗã¯č˛ãŽčãĢãããããĒã¨å¤§ããĒįŗãããŧã¯ããŠãĻãŗãĢæãžãŖãčļãŽãããããŖãĸã ãããæēãããĻãå°åããåŠããããĢčĒŋæ´ããããããĒãäŊãčēĢéˇã¨ãšãĒã ãĒäŊã¯ãäŊåã¨ã¯į¨é ããããĢčĻãããįŊãTãˇãŖããĢããĢãŧãŽãšãĒã ããã ã¨ãŠãŗããŗã°ãˇãĨãŧãēãããˇãŗããĢãĒããĄããˇã§ãŗã§ãč
°ãŽããããĢã¯įžå ´ããæ
å ąãä¸ãããããĢåŋ
čĻãĒį̝æĢããĢãĄãŠã䏿¸ŦãŽäēæ
ãĢ寞åŋãããããŽåˇĨå
ˇãĒãŠããļãä¸ããĻããã
ãį§ãå
ãĢæģããžããã
į˛ãåãŖãĻãįŽãååéããĻãããããŠãŗãĢåŖ°ããããĻãããããĨãĢãŧãšã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻäŧæŠåޤãåēãã
é¨åąã鎿šåŊĸãŽäģãŽīŧåąã¨į°ãĒãããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽé¨åąã¯įäŊįļãĢãĒãŖãĻããã厤å
ãŽč˛ã¯ãŗããĢãããĢãŧã§įĩąä¸ãããæ°´æˇą200ãĄãŧããĢããå°ãæĩ
ãæĩˇãŽä¸ãĢãããããĒå°čąĄãåããããįĩļããįžå ´ããå
ĨãŖãĻããæ
å ąãåĻįããĻãããããæŦäŊãå¯ãĻããã¨ãäģĨå¤ã¯ãé§ãåãéŗãåŖ°ãæĸããã¨ã¯ãĒãã
厤å
ã¯ãįžå ´ãé§ãåãŖãĻæ
å ąãéããã¤ãŗãŦãã¨ãä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãåĻįãããĸãĻãŦãã§ãããšã¯ãåãããĻãããåŖãĢã¯įŽãįŠããģãŠå¤ããŽãĸããŋãŧãč¨įŊŽãããĻããĻãããããå ´æãŽãããããįŦéããĒãĸãĢãŋã¤ã ã§æ ãŖãĻããããããã¯čĄæįģåãŽãããĒããŽã§ãįžå ´ãĢããã¤ãŗãŦããŽæ
å ąã¨åãããŖãĻãåããĻäŊŋããæ
å ąãĢãĒãã
é¨åąãŽä¸å¤ŽãĢã¯ãããŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãã¨ãããæ
å ąãå åˇĨãããããŽãˇãšãã ãč¨įŊŽãããĻããĻãå¯åąéˇã§ããããĸãĻãŦããŽãããŧã¸ãŖãŧã§ããããĒãĸãģããŖãšããŧããŽäŋĄé ŧãåãį˛žéããĄããįãŽæ
å ąãä翏ŦãĢäŊŋããåŊĸãĢæ´ããĻããã
æåĨĨãĢããããŖãšããŧããŽããšã¯ãŽčåžãĢã¯ãäģãŽåąãŽãããĢį翏ããããããããŧãŋãŽį˛žåēĻã¯įĨæ§ãŽį˛žåēĻãã¨ãæ¯įã§æ¸ãããĻããã
ãããŖããããĒãããã¤ã¯ã¯åŖããĻãĒãã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãčĒå¸ãĢæģãã¨ãįžå ´ã§äŊŋããã¤ã¯ãããšã¯ãĢįŊŽããĻãéĄåžŽéĄã§ãčĻãčžŧããããĢįŽãį´°ããã
äģæĨãįžå ´ããæ
å ąãä¸ããã¨ãããã¤ãēãå
ĨãŖãĻčãåããĒãã¨č¨ãããĻãå°ãį§ģåãããčãããããåãããããč¨čãĢč¨ãæããããããåąããĻããã¤ã¯ãŽéäŋĄįļæ
ãæĒããŽãã¨æãŖãããäēēåˇŽãæã¨čĻĒæã§æãã§ãä¸ããä¸ããįĸēčĒããĻããåč§ŖããĻããį°å¸¸ã¯čĻã¤ããããĒããŖãã
ãæ¯įĩĻãããã°ãããĒãŽãĢãããåŖãããŽīŧãããį§ãäŊåãĒããąã ããīŧããããĒãããĒããã
ããããã¨įŦãč¨ãč¨ãŖãĻããã¨ãããã ãŽããã¯ããąãããĢå
Ĩããããĩããŗãŗãéŗ´ãŖãã
ãã¯īŊããčǰã§ããīŊã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšããīŧã
ãčǰīŊīŧã
ãããŠãããģããĄã¯ãã§ããæ°äēēį äŋŽã§ä¸įˇã ãŖããããŖããĄããģãŧã¸ãéãŖããã ããŠã
ããīŊīŧãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢčĄãŖãäēēã ããã´ãĄãŗããĄããŖã¨ããŋããŋããĻãĻããŠããããŽīŧã
ãå°ãã芹ããžããīŧã
ãäŧæŠįĩããŖãã°ããã ããįĄįã ãīŊãå¤ã§ãããīŧã
ãæ§ããžãããã§ã¯ãå¤ãĢã
é芹ãįĩããã¨ãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯éĻãåžããã
į äŋŽãŽã¨ããäģãŽäēäēēâĻâĻããĨãĸãŗãšã¨ãĸãģããã¨åäēēã§čŠąããã¨ã¯ããŖãããããĄã¯ãã¯ãã¤ããå°ãčˇéĸãįŊŽãæãã§ãã¯ãŗããŗãé
ããĻäŧ芹ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãããããĒãŋã¤ãã ãŖããäēäēēã ãã§čŠąãããã¨ã¯ãģã¨ããŠãĒãããããļãģãã¸ãĄãã¨ããŖãé°å˛æ°ã¯ãæŖį´ããžãæ°ãåãã¨ã¯æããĒããŖãã
īŧãĒããæˇąåģãããĒåŖ°ã ãŖãããŠããĒãã ããããžãããåįŊīŧããããĒãããĒããīŧ
å¤ã
æŦäŊãįĄį ãĢå
ĨããæãŽéãŽéãããĢå
ãžãããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãåēãĻãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯åĨŗįĨååēå ´ãĢåããŖããé莝ãæããåēå ´ãĢčļŗãč¸ãŋå
Ĩããã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯ãã§ãĢæĨãĻããĻãããŗããĢåē§ãŖãĻããã
ãããŽåĨŗįĨåãčŋãã§čĻãã¨ããŖããåˇãã§ãããīŊã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãæã§åĨŗįĨåãŽčä¸ããĒããŖãã
ãįĸēãį äŋŽã§ãâ æ´å˛ãããããŽã ãããå¤å°åˇãŋãããããã¨č¨ãŖãĻį´ãã°ãããŖãĻããŽãããĒãīŧâã¨ãč¨ãŖãĻããããįįéĸįŽãĒčŦå¸Ģãååã¯âĻâĻãĒãã ãŖãīŧã
ããšãŋãŧããŗã ãã
ããĄã¯ãã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻãåĨŗįĨåãŽåãžã§æĨãã
ãããã īŧããããäŧŧãĻãīŧãį§ãŽãĸãããã
ãæãåēããĻãå°ãįŦãŖãĻããžãŖããã
ãããīŧãã§ãããŽãããĢã¯ãåēãããé ŦãŽãããã
ããĨãĢãŧãšããæã§âãĄããâã¨é ŦãĢč§Ļããã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯éĄãé¸ãããã
ãį
§ããĻãīŧã
ããããĒãã¨ã¯âĻâĻã
ããīŊīŧã
ããããå°ãã ãâĻâĻéãããããĒãã¨ããããããĢåãåŧãŗåēãããããããĒããã ã
ããĩãĩãį¸å¤ãããåēãčŠąãæšīŧįŦīŧãã§ããããĄã¯ãããããããã§ããŠããããŽīŧã
ããããčĻãĻãģããã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãäžãŽįģåãåˇŽãåēããã
ããããį§ããĸãĻãŦããĢä¸ãããã¤ã ãã
ãåãä¸ãããŽãĒããĄãããŠãããäŊããéåæã¯ãĒãããĒīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãįģåãåŗæãĢæãŖãĻãč§åēĻãå¤ããĒããčĻãĻãããīŧãã¨åŖ°ãä¸ããã
ãå°ãããģããŽå°ããŖãĻãããã ããŠãé ŦãŽãããã¨åŖå
ãŽčĄ¨æ
ãéãæ°ãããâĻâĻį§ãįžå ´ã§čĻãĻãä¸ããåįã¯ãæå¸ãĄãããŽčĄ¨æ
ã¯ããå°ãæãããŖãããããããĒ垎åĻãĒæããããĒããã
ãããŖãąãâĻâĻã
ãåž
ãŖãĻãããŠããããã¨īŧã
ãįãŽããŧãŋãããĒããå åˇĨãããĻããŖãĻãã¨ã ãã
ãå åˇĨã¯ããããīŧãįãŽããŧãŋãä翏ŦãĢäŊŋãããããĢãããããĢããĸãĻãŦããå°ãæ´ããããã
ãããã¯įĨãŖãĻãããã§ãããããžã§ãįãŽããŧãŋã¨ããĻãŽæ
å ąã¯æŽãããžãžã§ããīŧãããããĒãã¨ãæŖããä翏Ŧãã§ããĒããã
ããããããĄããã
ãã§ãããã¯ãįãŽããŧãŋãããĒããâããĒããĻããå åˇĨâããããĻããã
ããīŧããããâĻâĻãĸãĻãŦããåæãĢæ
å ąãæ¸ãæããĻããŖãĻãã¨īŧã
ãããĄãĢä¸ããŖãĻããæŽĩéã§ãããĒãŖãĻããããããļãâĻâĻã
ããããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãããŧãŋãŽåŊé ã ãã
ãããã芹ããīŧãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽåąéˇã¨ããĢã
ããã¤ãŗããããĢ芹ãããã§ããå åˇĨã¯ãããĻãĒããåãįĩé¨ä¸čļŗã ããåãããĒãã ãã ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããããĻãããå åˇĨãããŽįģåããĸãĻãŦããĢä¸ãããŽã¯į§ã ãããééããĒããã
ãâĻâĻã
ãããããŠããããã¨īŧã
ãåãããĒãâĻâĻã§ããäŊãįįąãããã¨æããã ã
ãããã ããâĻâĻã§ããŠããĒįįąãâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯č¨čãæĸããã
ããŠããâĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ããŽåŖãĢäēēåˇŽãæãåŊãĻãĻãå°ããéĻãæ¯ãã
éãžãčŋãŖãåēå ´ãĢããŗããŗã¨ãéŠé´ãŽãããĒčļŗéŗãéŋããįŦéãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯čĩ°ãåēããã
ããĄããŖã¨ãããĨãĢãŧãšâĻâĻīŧã
ããĄã¯ããŽåŖ°ãįĄčĻããĻãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ããļãģããŗã¯ã¸éããé莝ãĢæļããĻããŖãããæ°åããĻæģãŖãĻããã
ãčǰãããâĻâĻīŧã
ããĄã¯ããäŧēããããĢčãã¨ãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯éĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãã
ãããã¨æããã§ããčĻã¤ããããĒããŖããįĩļ寞ãĢčŋŊãã¤ããã¨æãŖããŽãĢâĻâĻã
ãããŖããŽčŠąãčãããĻãã¨æãŖããģãããããã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãå°åŖ°ã§č¨ãŖãã
ãããâĻâĻã§ããį§ããĄã ãã§ãŠããĢãã§ãã芹ã§ããĒããã
ãããŽäēäēēãĢããåŖ°ããããĻãŋããã
ããããããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¨ãĸãģããīŧã
ããããäēäēēãäŊããæ°ãĨããĻããã¨ããããããããĒãã
ãįĸēããĢããããããããããį§ãéŖįĩĄãåãŖãĻãŋããäēäēēãâããŖãĄå´âãŖãĻå¯čŊæ§ãããããŠãããã¯äģģããĻãčĻæããŽã¯åžæã ããã
ãåããŖãããããããžãã
ããããããããŋã
ããĨãĸãŗãšããĸãģãããããĄã¯ããããĨãĢãŧãšã
åäēēãŽæ°äēēããĄã¯ããããããŽéåæãæąãããžãžäģäēãããĒããĻããããčǰä¸äēēã¨ããĻãčĒåãããŖãéåæãééãŖãĻããã¨ãæãį´ããããĢãąãčĻããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãããããã¯ããããããŽãã¨ããããããŠãŗããĄãŽč¨čã¯æ¯æĨãŽãããĢčãããŽãŽãčĒŦåžåã¯ãĒããå°ããã¤ãéåæãŽåĄĩīŧãĄãīŧã¯įŠãŋéãĒãŖãĻããŖãã
ããĄã¯ãã¨ããĨãĢãŧãšã芹ããæ°æĨåžãŽå¤ãåäēēã¯åĨŗįĨååēå ´ãĢéãžãŖãĻããããããæã¤éåæã芹ãåãŖãããããĻãä¸ã¤ãŽäģŽčĒŦãĢéããã
-3-
ä¸ãįŦãäģäēãŽããšãåēãŖãĻããããã¨ã§ã大äēãĢãĒããã¨ããĒããããŽåžã¯ãĒãã¨ãäģäēãããĒããĻãããããä¸å¸ãŽį§åąąãäŊãč¨ãŖãĻããĻããĒãããã ããŋãããĄãŽããããĢã¯å¸¸ãĢãå
¨åįžčĩ°ãããã¨ãŽãããĒæčĻããããäģĨåã¨æ¯ãšãĻåŧå¸ãæĩ
ããĒãŖããããĒæ°ãããĻããã
åææĨãæ įģãčĻãããæŦãčĒãã ãããæ°åãæãĻããčĒåãå¤ãããããĢå¤ãĢåēãã¨čããã ãã§ãäŊãåį¸ŽãããããĒįļæ
ãŽãžãžãåŋãæŦ˛ãããžãžãĢã¸ãŖãŗã¯ããŧããæŗ¨æããåŽļãã䏿Šãåēããã¨ãĒãäŊãĢæĩãčžŧãŋãæ°ãĨãã°æč¨ã¯ã13æãåãŖãĻããã
ããŖãããčĒåã¯äŊãããŖãĻãããŽã ãããäŊãããããŽã ããâĻâĻ
įĻįšãŽåããĒãįŽããããŗããŧãŦãŧã¨ããããå
ĨãŖãĻããčĸãĢåãããžãžãæ¤åˇã¯ãįãžããĻã¯æļããĻããæčãčĻã¤ããĻããã
įĄåŗäšžįĨãč˛åŗãįĄãããĻį°č˛ãĢčĻããããŽä¸įããåŊŠããåãæģããã¨ã¯ãããŽã ããããããããããããããžã§ãä¸įãč˛éŽŽããã ãŖããã¨ã¯ãĒããč˛ãŽãĒãä¸įãŽä¸ãĢãįãŽå
ã§č§ĻãããããĒįĩĩãŽå
ˇãŽčˇĄãčĻã¤ãããã¨ã¯ã§ããããå
¨äŊã¨ããĻã¯į°č˛ãŽįĩĩã ãŖãã
ãããĻãæ¯č˛ã¯éåģãæ ãå§ããã
æéãŽä¸ã§ãææãããããããã¨éį´ĢãŽįĢčąãæŖããããĢãæ åãããŠã¤ãã
ãčŗãã¯į§ãŽåãĄãã
åŋčã莺ããĻãčä¸ãĢ县°´ãããããããããĢįĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ãã¯ããã¯ãâĻâĻã
åãæ°ãããĻãããŠããŠã¨ããããŗãžã§æŠããĻããˇãŗã¯ãĢ严æãã¤ããã
æ åã¯ãéåģã¸ãŽæ
ãįļããåäžæäģŖãŽæĨ常ãčĻããĻããã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯ãˇãŗã¯ãĢæãįŊŽãããžãžãčˇĒããã
ããããã大ãããã¨ãĒãã§ããããģãã¨ãæį°ãããčĻįŋãŖãĻãģãããŖãĻããã¤ãæãŖãĻãžãã
ã100įšãåããīŧãããžããžãĒãčǰã ãŖãĻãããįŽæ°ã¯åšŗåįšäģĨä¸ãããĒããã
ããã¤ãč¨ãŖãĻãã§ããīŧãčŦčã§ããĒãããŖãĻãå°ãå
įãĢč¤ãããããããŖãĻãããããŖãĻãã¨ãĢã¯ãĒããĒããŽãã
äģäēãææãčļŖåŗâĻâĻãŠããä¸ã¤ã§ãããžãããŖãĻããããįĩļæãŽæ˛ŧããéãä¸ããčļŗããããĢãĒããŽãããããĒããčļŗå ´ãããã°ãåēãĒãæ˛ŧãŽåēãĢæ˛ããããĒãã
ãˇãŗã¯ããæãéĸããããããŗãŽåēãĢé Ŧãã¤ããĻãã˛ãããã¨ããæč§ĻãåēããŖãĻããã¨ãčĻįãįžåŽãĢæģãŖãã
ããŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ãããé¨åąãžã§æŠããĻãĢãŧããŗã¨įĒãéããããĄãããŠããĄãã¸äŧ¸ãŗãĻããå
ãĢįįŽãéããããˇã¯ã ãããŽãˇãŖããŽééãããįąãåãåģãŖãĻãããããĒéĸ¨ãå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ä¸åãģãŠãããŽãžãžåãããĢããããčããããĒããĒãŖãĻįĒã¨ãĢãŧããŗãéãããå
į¨ãžã§å¤ĒéŊãĢį
§ããããĻããĻãįąã帯ãŗãĻããåēããčļŗãããããåˇãããããŧãĒãŗã°ãĢã¤ãããæŧéŖãŽæŽéǏãįäģãããã¨æãŖããžãžãããŧããĢãŽåãĢåē§ãããŧãããã¨įēãããã¨ãįĒãŖäŧããã
č
šå¨ããŽčãåēããŖããããĒæ°ãããã
įĒãŖäŧãããžãžãéĄã ããæ¨ĒãĢåããĻãšãããčĻããäģäēãŽãšããŦãšã§ãã¤į
ãĢãĒããä¸äēēã§éããĢæŽãããĻããäēēã䏿ĨãįĩããããŗãĢãäģæĨãįããããã¨ãããã¨ããäēēããããĒäēēããĄãŽåįģãĢå
ąæã¨åŽåŋãæ¸ãčžŧãäēēããĄâĻâĻäģčĒåã¯ãäŊãããĻãããŽã ããâĻâĻæéã¯åããĻãããčĒåã ããæĸãžãŖãĻããâĻâĻīŧ
ãããĄãĒã¤ãã¯ãäŊããŠããããŖãĻããã¤ãžã§įĩãŖããŖãĻããĄãĒãã ãĒã
č¨čãåããäŊä¸ãĢåēããŖãĻãéŧģã§įŦããåŖå
ãįˇŠãã ã
čģĸčˇããäŧį¤žã§ããžããããããããĒããčĄã§čĻããããĢãããĢãŽãããĢãåĨŊããĒäēēã¨æãįšãã§æŠãããããããĒãâĻâĻäēį´°ãĒéĄããĢæãããã§ãããããããåļããããĒãäēēéããããč˛ãŖãå ´æãæĒããŖããŽããčĻĒãŽæč˛ãĢåéĄãããŖããŽããããã ã¨ããĻããåäžã¯ãŠãĄããé¸ãšãĒãããããããã§ããšãĻãæąēãžããĒããäēēįã¯éã˛ãŧããŽããŽãã§ããä¸éãĒįļæŗãĢãããĒãããããããéãä¸ããŖãĻå
ãæ´ãäēēéããããįĩåąã¯ãåäēēãŽåéĄããããåäēēãŽâĻâĻ
ä¸įŦæĄãŖãåŗæŗã¯ããããĢåãå¤ąãŖãĻč§Ŗããã
ããŖãĻãįĄé§ã
ãããĒããå¤ãããĒãã
é ãŽä¸ã§ãļã¤ããããŖãĻããč¨čã¯ããããĒããå¤ãããĒããĢčģé
ãä¸ããŖãããŽãŽãčļŗãĢåã¯å
ĨããĒããŖãã
ãĒããŽãããĢãčļŗãĢåãå
ĨãããŽãã
ãĒããŽãããĢãåãĢé˛ããã¨æŗãįĒãä¸ãããŽãã
åĒåãããĻããã
ããŽįĩæãäģãŽãããŽä¸įãĒãŽã§ããã°ããĒããŽãããĢâĻâĻ
įĒãŖäŧãããžãžį ãŖãĻããžããæ°ãĨããã¨ããĢã¯ãéŊã¯æ˛ãŋãããĻããã
ããŖã¨ããŽãžãžã§ãããããããåããĒããĒããŽã ãããã
į¯įŊĒå˛ãĢæŽãåļæĒį¯įŊĒč
ããĄã¯ãããŽä¸įˇãčļããåãĢãããŖããäŊãæãŖããŽã ãããä¸į¸ˇãŽå
ããĒãįĩļæãŽéãĢčŊãĄãĻãããã§äŊãčĻããŽã ãããããã§čĻãããŽã¯ãåŊŧããĢã¨ãŖãĻæãã ãŖããŽã ããããå¨å˛ããčĻãĻãŠããĒãĢįãŖãĻããĻããããã ãããįĩļæããæãåēãæšæŗã ãŖãã¨ãããâĻâĻ
ããŠããããĻãâĻâĻã
æ¤åˇã¯ãčĒåãčĻä¸ãããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãčǰããåˇã¤ãããŖãĻãæŦ˛ããããŽãæãĢå
ĨããããããĒããæãĢå
ĨãŖãã¨æãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãæŦåŊãĢæąããĻãããŽãããĒããã ããéŖįļæŽēäēēį¯ã¯ããã¤ãžã§ãæēããããĒããĻãæŽēäēēãįļããĻããžããã ã
ãģããŽå°ããäŊããéãŋãæããĻãįĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻæŧéŖãŽæŽéǏãįäģããã¨ã垎ããĢįŠēč
šãčĨ˛ãŖãĻããã
ããĩããĩéĢĒãŽãžãžãčŋæãŽãŗãŗãããĢčĄãŖãĻããģãĢããŦã¸ã§ãĢããéēēã¨ããĢããã財ããéģåãããŧãŽæŽéĢãĢããæ¯ãã¤ããĻãããåŽļãĢæģãŖãĻãˇãŖã¯ãŧãæĩ´ãŗããæĨææĨããäģæĨããŗããŧãããããĒ䏿ĨãéãããæææĨãĢã¯ãææ
ãŽå
ãæļããããŖãįŽã§äģäēãĢåããŖãã
ããã¯ãããæ¤åˇã
ããŊããŊæ¨æļãããĻãčĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢåē§ãã¨ãä¸ãįŦãåŗæãä¸ããĻčŋãĨããĻããã
ããã¯ããããããžãã
ãæå¸ãĄããããéŖįĩĄããŖãīŧã
ãâĻâĻīŧããããã¨ããĢã¯âĻâĻã
ããĒãã ãããããīŊãâĻâĻã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ããããåŽã¯å
éąãŽéææĨãĢãæå¸ãĄããã¨äŧãŖããã ãã
ããâĻâĻīŧã
čããäŊä¸ãĢčĄæãåēãããåŋčãįãŋã¨ã¨ããĢãéŧåãæŠããã
ãäŧãŖãããŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãåãĢä¸åēĻãæ¤åˇã¨ä¸äēēã§äŧãŖãã¨ããäģäēãŽãã¨čŠąããã§ããīŧãã ãããčˇå ´ãŽčŋããžã§čĄãŖããäŧããããĒã¨æãŖãĻčĄãŖãĻãŋãããäŧį¤žããåēãĻããããåŖ°ããããĻãã
ããŠãããĻãä¸ãįŦãããæå¸ããã¨âĻâĻã
ãããžããåŋé
ã ããã ããä¸ãįŦã¯ãå°ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããããããŽãžãžãããäģäēãŠãããį§įæ´ģãĢãåŊąéŋãåēããæ°ãĨããĻãĒããããããĒãããŠãå°ãįŠãããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãäēēåˇŽãæã§čĒåãŽé Ŧãããŗããŗã¨åŠããã
ãâĻâĻæå¸ããã¯ããĒããĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŋēã¨åããããĢãæ¤åˇãã¨ãåŋé
ããĻãããéŖįĩĄããĨãããŋããã ãããéŖįĩĄããĻãããĻãģãããŖãĻäŧããĻããããã ããŠâĻâĻã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãéĄãé¸ãããĻéĄãĢæãåŊãĻãã
ããžããéææĨã¯ããæéãé
ããŖãããäŋēãįĒįļč¨Ēãããããå°ãæˇąåģãĢåãåãŖãĻããžãŖããŽãããããĒããåæĨã¯į¨äēãããŖããããããĒãããããŽããĄéŖįĩĄããããããŖã¨ã
č¨ãæŽããĻãä¸ãįŦã¯čĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãĻããŖãããæ¤åˇã¯æĨåį¨ãŽãšãããéŗ´ããžã§ãŽį´īŧåãåãããĢããã
ãĒãæå¸ã¯ãä¸ãįŦãæĨãã¨éŖįĩĄããããĒããŽãã
ãĒãä¸ãįŦã¯ãããããæå¸ãĢäŧããĢããŖããŽãã
äēäēēã¯äŊã芹ãããŽã ãããã
ãĩã¨ãä¸ãįŦãŽãģããčĻãã
äŊãå¤ãããĒãããã¤ããŠãããĢäģäēãããĻãå¨å˛ã¨čĢįŦããĻãããããŽįŠēéã¨čĒåãŽããšã¯ããæĩã§äģåãããĻãããããĢæãããã¨ã¯ãäģãžã§ãäŧãŖããæĩãĢéĩã¯ãããŖãĻããĒããå
Ĩããã¨æãã°å
Ĩãããčļŗãč¸ãŋåēãããããã¨ãããŖããããã¤ãé ãããįēããĻãæĩãŽä¸ã§čŠąãčĒåãæŗåããĻããã
æ°æãĄæĒãâĻâĻå
ĨããããĒãå
Ĩãã°ãããåŽļãĢ帰ãŖãĻããã芹ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãŋãã°ãããŽãĢãã¨æããããĢãæŗåã§įĩããããã
åãã ã
ãĒãä¸ãįŦãæå¸ãĢäŧããĢčĄãŖããŽããæŦåŊãĢč¨čéããĒãŽããæå¸ãéŖįĩĄãããĻããĒããĒããããŖãĄããįĸēčĒããã°ãããåã芰ããįįąã¯ãĒãããã ãä¸ãįŦãč¨ĒããĻããããčãã°ããããĒãŽãĢãåããã¨ããĒããåãã°ããã¨åããŖãĻãããŽãĢãåããĒãããĒããããĒããŽãããĒãåããĒããŽãã
åĨĨæ¯ãčģããģãŠéĄãĢåãå
ĨãŖãĻãæčãįžåŽããé ãŽããããŊãŗãŗãŽįģéĸãé ããčĻããĻãããŽãĢãčĻãĻããĒãã
ããĒããĒãã ããããžãã¯âĻâĻã
åŖå
ã§åãã
ããĒãã§ãã¤ããããĒãã ãããĒãã§åããĒããã ãâĻâĻã
äģãããĢå¸ãįĢãŖãĻãåŽļãĢ帰ãããã¨å
¨čēĢã§įēããäŊããč
ŋãåŠããĻæŧãäģããæŧãžã§äģäēãããĒãã¨ãäŊčĒŋãæĒãã¨č¨ãŖãĻãæŠéããã
åŽļãĢ帰ãŖãã¨ããã§äŊãč§ŖæąēãããŽãīŧ
æŠéããã¨ããã§äŊãå¤ãããŽãīŧ
ãã éããĻããã ããããĒããŽãīŧ
éģčģãŽä¸ã§ããåŽļãŽä¸ã§ããæĒæãĢæãžãŖãįŊčĄįãŽãããĢãå å´ã§äŊãããåįŠãŽãããĒč¨čããåŋãĢįĒãåēãããéãįŖ¨ãããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããčĄãŽčˇĄãæŽããå°ãéãŗããããĒãããã§ããĻæãããã¨ããĒãåįŠã¯ãåēããŖããã¨ããäģįãããĻãŖãĢãšãéãčžŧãã§ãããįĸįļãæŠãĢįĒãåēããåįŠãæããããŽæã¯ãžãŖããčļŗããããããĻåŽå ¨ãĢããĒããĒãã¨ãéģä¸č˛ãĢãĒãŖãåŋã¯ããããã¨ããéŗãéŋãããŽãæåžãĢãæ˛éģããã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãããŠãã¯ãĸãĻã
-1-
æ¤åˇããä¸ãįŦãã芹ãčãåæĨãŽå¤ã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãäģä¸äēēãŽæ°äēēã¨čŠąãåããįļããä¸ã§ããŠãįããäģŽčĒŦãäŧãããããĢãåĨŗįĨååēå ´ãŽããŗãã§ä¸äēēãåē§ãŖãĻããã
ããåž
ããã
æåãĢããŖãĻãããŽã¯ããĸãģããã ãŖãã
ãäģãŽäēäēēã¯ããžã īŧã
ããããããĄã¯ãã¯ããããæĨãã¨æããããĨãĢãŧãšã¯å°ãé
ãããã ãŖãĻãããŖãéŖįĩĄãããã
ãããŽã¨ãããæŦäŊãŽåããä¸åŽåŽã ãããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēã¯åŋããã¯ããã
ãåãŽã¨ããã ãŖãĻã大å¤ã ãīŧã
ããžãããäēįŽãæŦåŊãĢãæ¯æ¸ããĻãããããé
åãčããĻããįˇéãå°ãĒãããčŗĒãæĒãããéįããããã
ãããããĒãã¨ããããŽããäŋēéãŽäģäēãŽã¯ãã ããŠã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯éĻãæ¯ãŖãã
ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽæ¸ãæãããããžãããŖãĻãĒããæŦäŊããģãããŧãĢčĄãŖããããĻãæ°ããæĻåŋĩãå
ĨãŖãĻããĻãããŦãããĢããĄãããŠãŗã¯ãæ¸ãæããæããã ã
ããŠãããĻīŧã
ãæ¸ãæãããĢã¯ããããæŖãããŖãĻããæ šæ ãčããã ããããã¤ãããããĒįįąã ãã
ãããã¯æŖãããŽīŧãæ šæ ãčããŖãĻãããŽã¯ã
ãééãŖãĻããã¨ãč¨ããĒããããŠãããŖããæ¸ãæããĻãŋãĻãäģãŽæĻåŋĩã¨ãŽį¸æ§ãŖãĻããããããããéĸãããįĩãŋåãããæ¤č¨ŧããĒãããããĒããŽãĢããããããããã¨ããĒãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãåŗæãåēãæĄãŖãã
ãå¤åãããã¨ããĻãæŦäŊãåŠãããŽãäŋēéãŽåŊšįŽãĒãŽãĢããããæããããĒãã¨ãããĻãã
ãããĒããŽäģŽčĒŦã¯ãããããæĨãããŽīŧã
ããŋããĒããčããæčĻãåĢãã§ãŽããŽã ãã
ãããžããã
ããĄã¯ããæŠããĻããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¨ãĸãģããã¯åæãĢéĄãåããã
ãį˛ããĻããŋããã ãĒãããĄã¯ãã
ãé常ãŽäģäēãĢå ããĻãããŧãŋãŽį˛žæģãããĻããããããŦãĒããããĢãããĒãã¨ãããĒãããį˛ãããã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ããĸãģãããŽéŖãĢåē§ãŖãĻãããĩã
ãã¨æ¯ãã¤ããã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯īŧã
ãå°ãé
ãããŖãĻãã§ãããããžã§é
ãã¯ãĒããĒããŽããīŧã
ãĸãģãããčĻãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯é ˇããã
ãããããæĨãã¨æãããŠâĻâĻ
âĻâĻīŧã
įĒįļãåēå ´ãæéãĢæãžãŖããīŧãīŧį§ããĻãããĢæģãŖãããåãŗįãŖæãĢãĒãŖãĻãäģåēĻã¯īŧį§ãģãŠįĩãŖãĻããæãããæģãŖãã
ããĒãĢīŧãããŖããâĻâĻã
ãĸãģãããå¨å˛ãĢéĄãåããã
ãæŦäŊããæĒãå¤ĸã§ããŋããŽããĒīŧã
ããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãã
ãæĒãå¤ĸãĒãããããŠãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããã
ãäģãĢįįąãâĻâĻīŧããŖãĻãããīŧãããĨãĢãŧãšīŧã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãéĄãåããĻįŽãããããããããããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãåŗãããåˇĻãããé ŦãĢåŗãŽäēēåˇŽãæãįŊŽããĻãåĨŗįĨåãčĻãĻããã
ããŠããããŽīŧã
ãĸãģãããčŋãĨããĻãä¸įˇãĢåĨŗįĨåãĢčĻįˇãåããã
ãäģãįãŖæãĢãĒãŖãã§ããīŧãå°ããããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãåĨŗįĨåãčĻããžãžč¨ãŖãããããŽã¨ãããããŽåã ãå
ãŖãĻããŽã
ãå
ãŖãĻãâĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģããã¯įãã˛ãããã
ããŠããããã¨īŧãäēåéģæēãŋãããĢãĒãŖãĻããŖãĻãã¨īŧã
ãããããéããįŊãå
ãããĒããéģį´ĢãŽãæŋãŖãæããŽâĻâĻããŽãããããæŧãåēãĻãæãã§âĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ããããŽããããããĒãããããĢæãããã
ãä¸ãĢäŊããããŖãĻãã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģããã¯ãããĢãĒã¨éããäŊãã严æã§æąããããĢããĻæããã
ãäŋēãŽäģŽčĒŦã¨ããéĸäŋããããããããĒããããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãŖãããæ´å˛ããããããį´ãã°ãããŖãĻãããããĒãâĻâĻäģĨåããŦãããĢã¯ããč¨ãŖãĻãããŠã
ãããããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇãč¨ãŖãĻãã
ããĄã¯ããč¨ãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯é ˇãããåŖããããĢããĸãģããã¨ããĨãĢãŧãšãé ˇãã
ãčŖäŋŽããããĻãã§ããĒãįįąãããâĻâĻãããĒæ°ãããã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšãå
¨åĄæãŖãããäģŽčĒŦãčãããĻããããīŧã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ããããããŽãžãžããã§čŠąããĻãåĨŗįĨåãĢčããããŽããããããããĒããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãåĨŗįĨåãããŠãĒã¨čĻãĻããįļããã
ãååąãŽåŽčŗĒįãĒãããã¯ãåŽã¯åãįŽįãŽãããĢįĩč¨ããĻããâĻâĻãããäŋēãŽäģŽčĒŦã
ãåŽčŗĒįãĒããããŖãĻãã¨ã¯âĻâĻã
ãããŗãģãˇã§ãŧãããããŧãģãã¤ãŗããããŗãģãŦãããĢããĒãĸãģããŖãšããŧããŽåäēēã ããããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãããã§ãããããŖãĻãäēããéŖæēããĻãĒããããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇã¯ãčĒåããĄããå
¨åąãŽä¸ã§ããããŖãĻæãŖãĻãããããļãģããŗã¯ãŽã¨ãĒãŧãææŗâĻâĻããŽããããĢãããˇã§ãŧããŽãã¨ã¯ãįšãĢåĢãŖãĻããã
ã襨åãã¯ããã ããŦãããĢããäģãŽåąãŽīŧäēēãčĻä¸ããããĒãã¨ãč¨ããã
ããˇã§ãŧãã¯æŗåãŠããããã¨ãĒãŧãé¨éãŽããããŖãĻæãŖãĻããã
ãããŖãšããŧãããã¯ããããžãæ°ãĢããĻãĒãæãããĒããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŖãĻãä¸įĒä¸ã ã¨æãããĻãããŠããããããŽãæ°ãĢããĻãĒããŋããã ãã
ä¸äēēãŽååŋãčããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯é ˇããã
ãã§ããåĨŗįĨåãĢ寞ããčĻč§Ŗã¯åãã ããŦãããĢãããã¤ãŗãããˇã§ãŧãããčĒåãŽãģããä¸ãŖãĻæ
åēĻãčĻãããã¨ãããããŠãããŖãĻããã¨ã¯ã严č
ãĢã¨ãŖãĻč˛ čˇãŽãĒããã¨ã ã¨æããã ã
ãč˛ čˇãŽãĒããã¨ãŖãĻīŧã
ãĸãģãããéĻãåžããã
ãæŦäŊãŽčĄåãĢããŖãĻãæ°ããæĻåŋĩãå
ĨãŖãĻããĻããŽãĢãæ¸ãæããæ¸ããæ¸ãæããããĒããŖãĻãã¨ã¯ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēã¯æĸåãŽæ
å ąã§ä翏ŦãäŊããã¨ãã§ãããæ
å ąã县°ãããĻãæ°ããä翏ŦãäŊããŖãĻãĒãŖãããããã ãč˛ čˇãããããč˛ čˇããããã¨ãããã¨ã¯ãäēįŽãããããåŋ
čĻãĢãĒãã
ãæĻåŋĩãæ¸ãæããĒããã¨ã¯ãä翏ŦãĢ大ããĒčĒ¤åˇŽãåēããŽãé˛ããæ¯æ¸ããĻãäēįŽå
ã§åããããĢåĨŊéŊåâĻâĻãããããã¨īŧã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ãããčããã¨ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽæ
å ąãå åˇĨãããĻããŽããåããæ°ãããĒããīŧã
ãâĻâĻãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽæ
å ąããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢä¸ããããããč˛ čˇãããããĨãããããĢå åˇĨããĻããŖãĻãã¨ãâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ããĻãŗãĻãŗã¨é ˇããã
ãã ããããã¤ãŗãã¯å åˇĨãããĻãĒãã¨âĻâĻãããĄã¯ãã¯č¨ãŖãããã§ããããŖãĻããĒãã ãããŽå ´ããŽããĢčĻãããã
ãäŋēãããæãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãŖãã
ããããããããã¨ãâĻâĻããĸãģããã¯åãããããļãģããŗã¯ãŖãĻããäēã¤ãŽæ´žéĨããããŽããˇã§ãŧããģãŋãŧã ãéį§°STã¨ãããŗã°ãģãŋãŧã ãéį§°LTãããŗãģãˇã§ãŧãã¯ãSTéŖåļãŽãããã§ããããã
ãã ããįæįãĒãã¨ãåĒå
âĻâĻãĒããģãŠãæĻåŋĩãæ¸ãæããĻéĻ´æãžãããĢã¯æéããããããããããäēįŽããããĒããã ãããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åããããããĄã¯ãã¯éĻãåžããã
ãã§ããããŖãĻããļãģããŗã¯ãŽåæ¯ãåããĒããã¨ãĢããŠãįšãããŽããĒīŧã
ãããļãâĻâĻãããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãŖãããããããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢããSSRã¨įšãããã ã¨æãã
ããŠããĒãĩããĢīŧã
ãããã¯ãžã âĻâĻãĒãã¨ãããĻãSSRãŽä¸ãĢå
ĨããĒãã¨ã
ãåĨŗįĨåãŽæŋãŖãå
ãéĸäŋããĻãããĒīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãįŽãį´°ããĻãåĨŗįĨåãŽãããčĻãĻããã
ããããSSRã¨įŠįįãĢįšããŖãĻããã¨ã¯æããĒãããŠãäŊãéĸäŋã¯ãããŽããâĻâĻã
åäēēã¯ãåĨŗįĨåãĢčĻįˇãåããã
常ãĢæãããįšããĻããåēå ´ã§ãåĨŗįĨåã¯å¤ããããäŊãã§ãããããŖãããã¤ããããĒããããĢåģēãĻããããŽãããŠããĢãčŗæã¯ãĒãããããŠãŗããĄã¯ãæ´å˛įãĢæįžŠæˇąãããŽãã¨åŖãæããããã芹ããã¨ãåēæĨãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊãčĒããŽãâĻâĻããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããã°ããčĻã¤ããĻããããä¸äēēãŽčĻįˇãĢæ°ãĨããĻãčĻįŦããã
ãčĻæããĻããããããĒããã
ãįĸēããĢããããĒéĄã¯ããĻãĒããŖããīŊãããĨãĢãŧãšãįŦãŖããããããã¯äŊãįĨãŖãĻããã âĻâĻãããĒéĄã ãŖããã
ãã ãããåŊããã ããããããĒãããĨãĢãŧãšã
ããĩãĩãããžããīŧã
ãåããĄã¯ããããããŠãããã°ãããã ãããããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽäģŽčĒŦãæŖããã¨ããĻãSSRãčĒŋãšãããĒããâĻâĻã
ãå¤å´ãŽéĩã¯æãĢå
Ĩããããã¨ããĻããå
å´ã¯ãŠããĢããĒããĒããããĒâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č
įĩãŋããã
ãã¨ã¯ãããäģæĨã¯ããããč§ŖæŖãã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ãããããäŧãžãĒãã¨ãį§ããĄããããĒããã
ãįĸēããĢã
ããĄã¯ãã¯č
æč¨ãčĻãã
ãããããäģæĨã¯č§ŖæŖãããã
åäēēã¯ããããããŽåąãĢæģããäŧãã ãã¨ãĢįŽãčĻãžãããããããĢæ§åããããããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããã
ããĒãããæããĒãã§ããīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããäŊããŠããĒãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãäģããŦãããĢãããčĒŋãšãĻãã
åĨãŽåąåĄãč¨ãŖãã
ããã¤ããããŽįļæ
ãĒãã§ããīŧã
ãæŦäŊãįŽãčĻãžããĻããããŖã¨ã ãããŖã¨ãããžã įŽčĻããĻãã30åããããã ãâĻâĻã
åąå
ã¯ããã¤ããĻããã
åããĻãŽäēæ
ããããã¨ã¯ãčǰãããŠãããã°ãããåããããĢãããã¨ãããå¯ãããã¨ãã§ããããããŠãŗããä¸å
ãŠããããå
¨åĄããã§ããã§ãã¨éĄãåãããæãã¤ããžãžãĢãäģŽčĒŦãã芹ãåãŖãĻããããĩã¨čĻãã¨ãããšã¯ãĢįŊŽãããĻããPCããããšãĻéģæēãčŊãĄãĻããã
īŧãžããâĻâĻīŧ
ãĩããŗãŗãåãåēãã
ãĸãã¤ãĢã¯äŊŋããã
å¨å˛ãŽčŠąãåŖ°ãĢããã¨ããŦãããĢã¯æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãå§ããåąå
ãčĒåãŽįŽã§įĸēčĒããĻãããæ
ãĻãĻåēãĻããŖããããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãčĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢåē§ãŖãĻå¨å˛ãĢįŽã¨čŗãåžããĒãããæ°äēēåäēēãŽããŖãããĢįļæŗãæãããäēæŗéããäģãŽīŧåąãåéģããĻããããŦãããĢããã¤ãŗããããŖãšããŧãã¯ããļãģããŗã¯ãŽåąéˇåޤâĻâĻãˇã§ãŧããŽé¨åąãĢéãžãŖããžãžåēãĻããĒãã¨ããĸãģããã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãéĄãä¸ããã
čĻįˇãŽå
ãĢã¯ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãžã æģãŖãĻããĒãã
čǰãåããĻããĒãã
ããŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãĸãģããããĄãĢããŖãããéãŖãã
äģãããĒãã
å¨å˛ãŽæ§åãčĻããããĢčŖ
ããčļŗéŗãæŽēããĻæŠããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãã
-2-
ããĨãĸãŗãšãããŽéŖįĩĄãįĸēčĒãããĸãģããã¯ãåéģããåąå
ã§ãäŊãã§ãããĢããã¨ãĒãŧãããĄããåąãŽåēå
ĨãåŖãããããčĻŗå¯ããĻããã
æŽæŽĩãčĒåããĄããå
¨åąãŽãããããļãģããŗã¯ããã¨ãĒãŧããåãå ´æã¨ã䏿éãĢä¸åã¯åŖãĢããč
ããĄããčǰãįĩé¨ãããã¨ããĒãäēæ
ãĢäŊãã§ãããĢæį¤ēåž
ãĄããˇã§ãŧãã¯ãäģåąãŽåŽčŗĒãããä¸äēēã¨å
ąãĢãåąéˇåޤãĢãããŖããžãžã§ãĻããĒããSTéŖåļãLTéŖåļãå¤§åˇŽãĒããäģč˛ŦãåŖãĢããã ãã§ãäēæ
ãĢ寞åĻãããã¨ããč
ã¯ããĒãã
īŧã¨ãĒãŧãé¨éãčããĻåããããīŧ
ããæ¯ãæŧããã
ãĩããŗãŗãæ¯åããĻãčĻãã¨ããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢå
ĨãŖããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšããéŖįĩĄãå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ãããŖãĄã¯ãžã åããĒããã
ãĸãģãããčŋãã¨ãåæ§ãŽåįããããĨãĢãŧãšã¨ããĄã¯ããããããŖãã
ãããåããããŖãããæããĻãģãããããã¨ããĸãģãããĢã¯âĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽčŋäŋĄãĢããĸãģããã¯čĻįŦãããããããĒãã¨ãããĻãŋããã¨čŋããã
īŧããŽãžãžãã°ãããæˇˇäšąãįļããĻãããã°ããããŠãæŦäŊãŽįļæ
ãåŋé
ãâĻâĻīŧ
ãč
šãŽãããã§č
ãįĩãŋãįŽãį´°ããĻåąéˇåޤãčĻãĻããã¨ãããĸãéããã
å
¨åĄãŽčĻįˇãããˇã§ãŧãããĄãĢæŗ¨ãããã
ãĸãģããã¯ããåäēēãåēãĻãããã¨ã ãããŖããããĻãããŖããã¨čŋãĨããã
å
¨åĄãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããĻéģãŖãĻãããããŖãšããŧãã ãã¯ãč¸ãåŧĩãŖãĻå ã
ã¨ããĻãããããˇã§ãŧãããŦãããĢããã¤ãŗããŽä¸äēēã¯ããŗãŊãŗãŊã¨čŠąãåããĒãããæåãŽč¨čãæĸãŖãĻãããããã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇã
LTéŖåļãŽãĒãŧããŧããåŖ°ãä¸ããĒããåãĢåēãã
ãããŖãããŠãããįļæŗã§ããīŧãããã¯ãį§ã¯ãäēįŽãŽé
åãĢåéĄãããã¨ãäģĨåããææããĻããã¯ãã§ããããŽâåéĄâããããŽäēæ
ãåŧãčĩˇããããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããīŧīŧã
ããŽč¨čãååŗãĢãLTéŖåļãããŠããĒãŖãĻããã ãã¨åŖ°ãä¸ãããããŽä¸æ¸ŦãŽäēæ
ãĢãããĻããååããæĩéŖåļãč˛ļããĻãčĒåããĄãŽå°äŊãä¸ãããã¨ããåããĢããĸãģããã¯æ¯ããããããããããå
¨åąãŽä¸ã§ã¨ãĒãŧããéãžãããļãģããŗã¯ãŽåŽæ
âĻâĻ
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯čĻįˇãé¸ãããéģãŖãĻããã
ããŠããĒãŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
LTãŽãĒãŧããŧããããĢ芰ãå¯ããã¨ããã¨ããããŖãšããŧããåãĢåēãã
ãããããčĒŦæãããé¨ãã ãã§äģŖæŋæĄãč¨ããĒããĒããéģãŖãĻãã
äŊããæŽéãĢ芹ãããããŽåŖ°ãŽå¤§ãããĒãŽãĢãé¨åąä¸ãĢéŋããæŗĸãããŋãĒã¨æĸãžãŖãã
ãæŦäŊãĢåéĄãįēįãããįããžãã¯åˇéãĢâĻâĻã
éããåŖ°ãŽãˇã§ãŧããĢãLTãŽãĒãŧããŧãåãŗåŖãéããããã¨ããããŖãšããŧããč¨čãįļãã ã
ãæŦäŊãŽæčã¯ããããåãããĢãããã ããįžå¨ã¯įĄį įļæ
ã¨åããããĒããŽã ããã°ããããã°æģããåčĒããããžã§äŧãã§ããĻããããæŦäŊãæ´ģåãåéãããããããĢåãããããĢããĻããã
ãåãåēãįŽåĻã¯īŧã
ãåãããĒããåäžããĒããããĒã
å¨å˛ãããã¤ããã¨ããã§ãããŖãšããŧãã¯ãŦãããĢãĢäŊäēãäŧããĻããŦãããĢã¯įéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãããžãžéĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖããããŖãšããŧãã¯é¨åąãŽå¤ãæãããããĢč
ãä¸ããĻããŦãããĢãĢãæŠãčĄããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãããããĢčĻããã
ãį§ããããčŗĒåããããã§ããããã
ãĸãģãããåãĢåēãã¨ãåēå
ĨãåŖãĢåãããã¨ããĻãããŦãããĢããčļŗãæĸããã
ããĒãã ãæ°äēēã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããĸãģããã§ãããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãããããã§ããīŧã
䏿ãĢååãåŧã°ãããããããˇã§ãŧãã¯įŽãčĻéããĻãįĻįšãŽåããĒãįŽã§åŖã ããåãããĻããããĩã¤ãēãããŋãĒããˇã¯ä¸ã¤ãĒããšãŧããįãĻãããŖããã¨åŖå
ãĢįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻããæŽæŽĩãŽå§ŋããã¯æŗåã§ããĒãã
ããĒãã ãâĻâĻã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããĢé
åąãããĻãããį§ãäēįŽãŽé
åãĢã¤ããĻčĻãĻãåĻãã§ããžãããæŦäŊãåĨå
¨ãĢåããããĢããŠãäēįŽãé
åããšããâĻâĻã§ããããŽåēæēãĢį
§ããã¨ãé
åã¯ä¸åĨå
¨ã¨č¨ããããåžãžããã
ãĸãģãããŽč¨čãåąãã¨ããˇã§ãŧããŽé Ŧčããã¯ãĒã¨ããã
ãäēįŽãŽé
åã¯ãã¨ãŧãĩã éåēĢãĢåããããäēįŽãŽčŗĒãĢããŖãĻãå¤åããžããį§ãé
åąãããäģĨåãŽåæ¯č¨é˛ãčĻãĻããå°ããã¤ãēãŦããããžãã常ãĢã§ã¯ãĒãããŠãå
ĨãĢ寞ããĻé
åãå¤ããã¨ãŧãĩã ãĢãĒãããŽãããŠããããæãŖãĻããĻįĄįããéį¨ããĻããã¨ãããã¨ãĢãĒããžãã
ãåãŽčĻæšãééãŖãĻããå¯čŊæ§ãããã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããĒ大ããĒééããįļįļįãĢįļããĻãããĒããLTå´ãéģãŖãĻããĒãã ããã
čĻįˇãåãã¨ãLTãŽãĒãŧããŧã¯éĄãé¸ãããã
ããããã ããããĒããĢãčããããŽã§ãããĸãģããã¯č¨ãŖãããããĒãæšãLTéŖåļã¯ã忝ããããããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããĒããŖããŽã§ããīŧã
ãæã
ãææããããŽã¯ããã§ã¯ãĒãã忝ãŽåˇŽã¯čĒ¤åˇŽãŽį¯å˛ã ã
ãčĒ¤åˇŽīŧããããĒã¯ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãį§ãææããããŽã¯ããˇã§ãŧããŽįŦčŖįãĒäŊåļã§âĻâĻã
ãããŽäģļãĢã¤ããĻãåžæĨ芹ãåããŽå ´ãč¨ããããˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããäģã¯ãããĒ芹ãããĻããå ´åã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãæŦäŊããããĒãŖãĻããžãŖãåå ãããããĒããã¨ãĒãŽãĢãâãããĒ芹âã§ããīŧīŧããĸãģããã¯čĒæ°ãåŧˇããããéããæ°ã§ããīŧãåąéˇã¨ããįĢå ´ããã
čǰãįļããĒãã
寞įĢããĻããLTéŖåļã§ãããåŖ°ãä¸ãããã¨ããĒãã
ããã¤ãããããŖãĻãããŽããåéĄãå
éãããĻâĻâĻã
ãĸãģããã¯ãäŊãéãããģãŠæŗãĢåãčžŧããã
ãæŦäŊããããĒãã¨ãĢãĒãŖããŽã¯ãããĒãããĄãŽããã ãīŧīŧãč˛ŦäģģãåãããĢããŽå ´ããŽããįš°ãčŋããĻãã ãããããĒãã¨ãĢâĻâĻã
ãããžããŽč¨ãŖãĻãããã¨ãčŖäģããæįĸēãĒč¨ŧæ ããããĒãã芹ãčããĻããã
ããŖãšããŧããč¨ãŖãã
ãč¨ŧæ ããĒããĒãåĻæŗã ã
ãč¨ŧæ ãĒããããžããåæ¯ãŽæ°å¤ãâĻâĻã
ããąãããĢå
ĨãããĩããŗãŗãéããĻããĸãģããã¯č¨čãæĸããã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ããĸãģãããčĻįãĢåãããžãžããŦãããĢãŽčŠãčģŊãæŧããã
ãããžãããĄæ°äēēã¯ãäŊããå
ãåãŖãĻããããã ãĒãããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããããĄãŽæ°äēēããä¸čĻãĒããŽã¨ããĻį ´æŖãããããŧãŋããã´ãæŧããŋãããĢéããĻããããã ã
ãŦãããĢãåēå
ĨãåŖãĢčŋãĨãã
ãäŊãæĸããĻããŽãįĨããããããžãåĻãĒåãã¯ããĒããģãããããããã§ããžãããŖãĻãããããĒãã
ãį§ã¯ãããããããŽãããããã¨č¨ãŖãĻããã ãã§ãâĻâĻã
ãããžããŽåéãã ã¨č¨ãŖãĻãã
ãåéããĒãããããĒãâĻâĻīŧã
ããããããããŖãšããŧãã
ãˇã§ãŧããč¨ãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¨ã¯ãåžã§į§ã芹ãã
ãĸãģãããåãæãã¨ããããčãæŠäŧãč¨ããããããĒãããããã§ããã ããīŧã
ãããã¯âĻâĻã
ã䏿ēãĒãŽããīŧã
ãããããããã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ã䏿ēãĢæąēãžãŖãĻãã§ããīŊã
åŖ°ãããĻãå
¨åĄãåēå
ĨãåŖãčĻãã
ãããŖããååąãŽããããæãŖãĻããã ãã芹ãããžããīŧãããŖãšããŧãå¯åąéˇã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãã
ããŦãããĢãããã芹ãčãããĻããã ããžãããīŧã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãåēãĻãããã¨ãããŦãããĢãŽåãĢįĢãŖããå°ãåŖ°ãéããĻããããčļŗãŽæãĢåãå
ĨããĻãį¨ãŋãåãæĸããĻããã
ãĸãģããã¯äēäēēãŽåŖ°ãĢåžæŧãããããããĢãããŖãšããŧãã¨ãˇã§ãŧããčĻįãĢåãããžãžč¨ãŖãã
ãį§ããĄãčĻã¤ããããŽãĢã¤ããĻãæčĻãčãããĻãã ããã
-3-
čǰãããčŋäŋĄããĒããã¨ãĢãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åãåãŋãåŋãŗčļŗã§SSRã¸ã¨čŋãĨãããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽä¸ã¯ãå
ã
æãããĒãããäģã¯ãģã¨ããŠæŧéģã¨č¨ãŖãĻããã
ãããĒä¸ãSSRã ãã¯ãčĒåãŽåå¨ãčĒį¤ēãããããĢãéãį´Ģč˛ãŽå
ãæžãŖãĻãããäģĨåčĻããé¨åąãŽä¸ããæŧãåēãĻããé§ãŽãããĒããŽâĻâĻ䏿ŠčŋãĨããã¨ãĢãéĄããæĩããæąãåĸããã
éįļ˛ãŽåãžã§æĨãã¨ãæããįŦãŋãæēĸããå°ããåŗæãæĄãŖãã
å¤éĩã¯å¤ããĻããã
ããããã¯ãæ§åãčĻãĢæĨããŦãããĢããæ
ãĻãĻåēãĻããŖãĻãéĩãæãåŋãããŽã ãããå
¨åąãããŠãã¯ãĸãĻãããĻããįļæŗã§ãčǰãå
ĨãŖãĻããĒããããããčĒåãŽč¨ąå¯ãĒãčŋãĨããã¨ããč
ã¯ããĒãâĻâĻããŽæãčžŧãŋãæããããšãäēåēĻã¨æĨãĒãããŖãŗãšâĻâĻ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åŋĩãŽãããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽåēå
ĨãåŖãĢčĻįˇãåããĻãããSSRãŽéįļ˛ãããŖããã¨åŧããã
éŗã¯ãģãŧãĒããããŽãžãžčļŗãé˛ããã
ä¸ãããį´ĢãŽé§ãåēããĻããããĸãŽåãžã§æĨãã¨ãéãå
ãéģãããĸãããĢæããããã
ãâĻâĻã
éãâĻâĻ
ãããæŧãä¸ãããžãžå¤å´ãĢåŧãã¨ãį´ĢãŽé§ãč
ŋãŽããããžã§čĻãŖãã
ã˛ãããã¨ããįŠēæ°ãæĩãåēãĻããã
ããããâĻâĻã
čĒåãĢč¨ãčããããããĢåãã¨ãį´ĢãŽé§ãããåãããããĢãčļŗãč¸ãŋåēããã
-4-
ãįļæŗãåããŖãĻãããŽãīŧãããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããããžãããĄãŽæ¯č¨īŧãããã¨īŧãčããĻããæã¯ãĒãã
ããããã¯ããŖãšããŧãå¯åąéˇīŧãäŊãčããĻãĒããŽãĢãæ¯č¨ãŖãĻåãããĒããĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããĄã¯ããåã¯į§ãĢæĨ¯įĒãæ°ãâĻâĻīŧã
åžããĢæ§ããĻãããã¤ãŗããč¨ãŖãã
ããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇãåã¯ãã ãæŦåŊãŽãã¨ãįĨãããã ãã§ãâĻâĻãããĄã¯ãã¯č¨ãŖãããããããããŽã¯ããããâĻâĻãããåŖãĢãããã¨ããå°ãããŽã¯į°æ§ã§ãâĻâĻīŧã
ããĒãčĻããĻãŋãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãæéã¯åĨã§äŊãã¨č¨ãŖãã¯ãã âĻâĻīŧã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯čĒæ°ãåŧˇããããããŖãšããŧãã¯čŠãĢč§ĻããĻãéĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãã
ãæ°äēēãŽįąãåˇãžããĻãįžåŽãæããĻãããŽãĢãĄãããŠããã
ããããâĻâĻã
ã芹ã¯čããĻãããã ãããŽåãĢä¸ã¤ãčŗĒåãããĻããããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ããĸãģããããĄä¸äēēãŽįŽãæĩããããĢčĻãã
ãæ°äēēã¯ããä¸äēēãããĒīŧãããļã¤ããŧãēãŽãããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãĸãģããããĄãŽéĄãč
ããä¸įŦãã¯ãĒã¨ãããŽãčĻéãããåŖ°ãŽããŧãŗãčŊã¨ããã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãŠããĢããīŧãåĨ´ãåŧãšãããã芹ãčãæĄäģļã ã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯âĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ããįĄæčãĢåžããčĻãã¨ããŦãããĢãé¨åąããåēãĻãããŽãčĻããã
ããŦãããĢãĢã¯å¤§äēãĒäģäēããããäŋēã¨ãˇã§ãŧãããã¤ãŗããŽä¸äēēã§čãããåŋé
ãããĒãããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãŠãã īŧã
ããĒãã ãããã¯âĻâĻã
SSRãŽä¸ã¯ãæˇąį´ĢãŽį
§æãĢį
§ããããĻããã
ãŠããããããããããŽéģæēã¯čŊãĄãĻããĒããåĨãŽå ´æããäžįĩĻãããĻãããŽãããããĒãã¨æããĒãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããŽį°æ§ããĢæčãåĨĒãããĻããã
æˇąį´ĢãĢæãžãŖãé¨åąãŽä¸ãĢãã¯ã¤ãŗãģãŠãŧãŽãããĒãąãŧãšãããŖãĻãããŽä¸ãĢãã¯ã¤ãŗãããĢãŽãããĒããŽãæˇã芰ããããĻããããããĢãŽčĄ¨éĸã¯éģããä¸ãĢäŊãå
ĨãŖãĻãããŽãčĻããĒãããč§ĻããĻãŋãã¨ããããĒã¨ããæļ˛äŊãŽæēããããããããĻčĻããã
į°æ§ãĒå
æ¯ã§ãããĒãããåšģæŗįãĒįžãããæžã¤ããã¯ãæ°´æé¤¨ã§ã¯ãŠã˛ãåąį¤ēãããĻããé¨åąãŽãããĢãæããã
ããŖãããŠããžã§įļããĻãããŽãâĻâĻé¨åąãŽå¤ããã¯æŗåã§ããĒããģãŠãåˇĻåŗãŽãąãŧãšãŽä¸ãĢãããĢãä¸Ļãã§ããã
įãä¸ãŽéčˇ¯ãæŠããĒãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯å
¨čēĢãĢéŗĨčãįĢãŖãĻãããŽãĢæ°ãĨããã
ãããã¯âĻâĻã
ããčĻãã¨ããããĢãŽåēãŽé¨åãããįŽĄãŽãããĒããŽãäŧ¸ãŗãĻããã䏿Ŧ䏿Ŧã¯į´°ããããšãĻä¸ãŽãģããĢåããŖãĻãããã¤ãžå
įĢãĄãããĻããĩããŗãŗãŽå°ããĒæããã§å¤Šäēãį
§ããã¨ãįŽĄãŽæãčĻããã
īŧãĒããĒãã âĻâĻãĒããããĒããŽãåŗéãĢįŽĄįããĻãīŧīŧ
é¨åąãŽä¸ãĢã¯ããããĢäģĨå¤ã¯äŊããĒãã
ã§ãããĒããããŽãããĢãĢâĻâĻ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãįŽãŽåãŽãããĢãæ´ãã§ãããŖããã¨åŧããã
åãâĻâĻ
įŽĄããããããåŽå
¨ãĢåēããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒããã ããå´éĸãčĻãããããã¯åŧãåēããã
éįãžã§åŧãåēãã¨ãįŊããŠããĢãč˛ŧãããĻããã
ããã¸ããŖãã¯æããįĩæãéŖããĻããâĻâĻãĒãã ããã¯âĻâĻã
äģãŽãããĢãåŧãåēããĻãŋãã¨ã
ãčŦčãã¯ããšãĻãĢåããčĒåãåžããäēēãŽäŋĄé ŧãåãĄåããã¨ãã§ããããã
ãããŖã¨ããžããããããäŋĄãããĒãã
ãã¸ããŖããä¸ĻãšãčĒåˇąåįēãŽãããĒč¨čãæ¸ããããŠããĢãč˛ŧãŖãĻããŖãã
ãããå
¨é¨ããããĒãŽãâĻâĻīŧãããããä¸ãŽæļ˛äŊã¯âĻâĻ
ãīŧã
åŧãåēãããããĢãŽããĄãŽä¸ã¤ããŠããĢãŽį̝ãåĨãããĻããã
ä¸ãĢããããŽãįĸēčĒãããã¨ãå°ããããä¸ããŖããŠããĢãæã§æãã¨ãäŊãŽå
å´ããå
¨čēĢãĢåēãããããĢæ¯åãčĩ°ãŖãĻãä¸įŦäŊã莺ããã
æãéããâĻâĻ
ãâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããŖããã¨ããããŖã¨ããžããããããäŋĄãããĒããã¨æ¸ããããŠããĢãåĨãããã
ããâĻâĻīŧã
åĨããããŠããĢãŽä¸ãĢããã䏿ãéģããŠããĢãããããããĢã¯å°ãæĒãã åã§ããæ¸ãããĻããã
ãäŊãããŖãĻãįĄé§ãã§ãåããŖãĻããããã¤ããŽãã¨ã
ããĒãã âĻâĻããã¯ãĒãã âĻâĻīŧã
éŗĨčãåãžããĒãč
ãåãããĻãäģãŽãããĢãŽãŠããĢãåĨããã
ããŠããĒãŖãĻããã âĻâĻã
äģãããšãĻããŠããĢãŽä¸ãĢåĨãŽãŠããĢãããã
ãäģäēēã¯æįĩļããããŽãã ããååŋãæåž
ã¨éãŖãĻãäŊãããããã¯ãĒãã
ãäŊã芹ããã¨ããã§ãčĒåã¨ããäēēéãåãå
Ĩãããããã¨ã¯ãĒããã ããäŧ芹ãåŧžãžãĒããĻã䏿č°ã¯ãĒãã
įŊããŠããĢã¨ã¯įéãŽãããĒč¨čãæ¸ãããĻããã
ããžãããããå
¨é¨âĻâĻã
ãäŊãããĻãīŧīŧīŧīŧã
čŗãįĒãæãããããĒåŖ°ãčãããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯æããįŽãéããã
åēå
ĨãåŖãŽãģããčĻãã¨ããŦãããĢã大čĄã§æŠããĻãããŽãčĻããã
ã貴æ§âĻâĻããã¯įĢå
ĨįĻæĸã īŧīŧãäŋēãŽč¨ąå¯ãĒãå
Ĩããã¨ã¯âĻâĻīŧã
ãããã¯ãĒãã§ããīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããžã 垎ããĢéããäŊãæ°ãĢãããĢããŦãããĢãĢåãį´ãŖãã
ãããããããŖãããäŊãé ããĻããã âĻâĻīŧã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãSSRãŽé
-1-
ã貴æ§ãŽãããĒæ°äēēãįĨãåŋ
čĻãŽãĒããã¨ã âĻâĻīŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãéĄãŽæąãããŽãžãžãĢč¨ãŖãã
åˇĻåŗãŽæã¯ãããæĄãããč¨čã¯åŧˇãããŽãŽããã¤ããŽå¨å§æã¯ãĒããįŽãŽįĻįšã¯åŽãžãããäŊã¯åãåãŖãĻããããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽįŽãčĻããã¨ããĒãã
ããŦãããĢãããããĒãã¯ããŽå ´æãŽãã¨ãããč¨ããžãããããâæĻįĨįåŽå
¨äŋįé厤ãéį§°SSRãStrategic Safety ReservesīŧãšããŠãã¸ãã¯ãģãģãŧãããŖãģãĒãļãŧããēīŧââĻâĻæĻįĨįâåŽå
¨âäŋįéâĻâĻâéâãäēįŽã襨ããĒãããļãģããŗã¯ãįŽĄįããĻããäēįŽãŽãã¨ãæããĻããã¯ãã§ãã
ãâĻâĻã
ãį äŋŽã§ãã¨ãŧãĩã ã¯æ°´ãåēåŊĸåãããããĒå§ŋãããĻããã¨čããžãããã§ããå
ĨãŖãĻããåææãŽčŗĒãæĒããã°ãå åˇĨãããĻã§ããã¨ãŧãĩã ãŽčŗĒãæĒããĒãããããĒįļæ
ã§ãâåŽå
¨âãĒäŋįéãĒãŠäŊããã¨ã¯æããĒããã¤ãžãããã¯âĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããĢãæãããã
ãããŽä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãã¨ãŧãĩã ã§ã¯ãĒããåĨãŽäŊãã ãæ¨ãĻããã¨ãã§ãããæēãããããĒãäŊãâĻâĻäģãŽããŠãã¯ãĸãĻããŽåå ã¯ãããĒããããĒããŽãâĻâĻīŧīŧã
ãåŖãæ
ãīŧīŧīŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯åĢãã ã
ãããžããĢäŊãåããâĻâĻäŋēéãŽãååąãŽįŽĄįãããĻããč
ãŽčĻå´ãŽãäŊãåããâĻâĻã
ãåãããžãããīŧãã ãããŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãæŦäŊãåŽããããĒãã ãīŧīŧīŧã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãããã¯ãåŋ
čĻãĒãã¨âĻâĻãããåŋ
čĻãĒããŽãĒãã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããĒãããįĄéãĢåēãããããĢįļããąãŧãšãĢčĻįˇãæĩããã
ãããããĒããã°ãįããĻããããĒããŖããã âĻâĻã
ããŠããããã¨ã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãâĻâĻã
ãčĒŦæããĻãã ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãåŋ
čĻãĒãã
ããĒãã§ããīŧīŧãæŦäŊãŽåŊãĢéĸãããã¨ãĒããåąãŽä¸åĄã§ããäŋēâĻâĻãããå
¨åĄãįĨãŖãĻãããšããã¨ãŽã¯ãã īŧīŧã
ãããžãã¯ã¯ãã ãããĨãĸãŗãšããŦãããĢã¯čä¸ãåããããããžãã¯åŊäģ¤ãĢčãããįĢå
ĨįĻæĸãŽå ´æãĢåæãĢå
ĨãŖãã訹ããããã¨ãããĒãã
ãäŋēãã¯ããĢããã°ããã§æ¸ãã¨æãŖãĻããŽãâĻâĻīŧã
åēå
ĨãåŖãĢåããŖãĻæŠãåēãããŦãããĢã¯ãčļŗãæĸããã
ããããĒå°ããĒ芹ãããĒããäŋēä¸äēēãããĒããĒããã¨ã§æŦäŊãå垊ãããĒãããã§ãããã§ããããããĒãâĻâĻīŧã
ãâĻâĻã
ãå
¨č˛ãåãããĒãäģã ãŖãĻäēæŗã§ããããããããŽãžãžãĢããããããããæŦäŊã¯ææĒãŽįĩæĢãčŋããâĻâĻãããĒãã¨åãå
ĨããããĒãīŧīŧã
ããĒãã¨ã§ãč¨ããããã
ããŦãããĢããâĻâĻīŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãåéĄãĢčãåãããããĢããĻč¨čãįĄčĻããĻæŠããĻããã
å°ããŽéãäŊãŽå
å´ããį
Žããããæãã§äŊãéãããĻããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãSSRãŽæãéãžãåãĢãčĩ°ãŖãĻåžãčŋŊãŖãã
ãæĒãäēæãåŊããŖããã
æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãåēãã¨ãããŖãšããŧãããĄããããããŽåžããĢã¯ããĸãģããããĄä¸äēēããããããŠãããããããããļã¤ããŧãēãŽåąåĄããĄã¯ä¸äēēãããĒãã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšãä¸ãčĻããã ãĒīŧã
ããŖãšããŧããč¨ãŖãã
ãčĻãžãããã
ãæ°ãĢãããĒããŗã¤ãã¯ã¯ããĢããã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã§æ¸ãåéĄãĒãŽããĒīŧã
ãã¤ãŗãããŦãããĢãŽåãĢįĢãŖãã
ããŠãããæåŗã īŧã
ãããã¯å¤ąæ
ã ãããããå¤éĩãéããĻããã°ãä¸ãčĻããããã¨ããĒããŖãã ããã
ãäŋēãĢæčĻããæ°ãīŧããã¤ãŗãã
ãäŊãåéĄã§ãīŧãããã¯åãŽããšã ãæ°äēēãĢSSRãŽä¸ãčĻããããĒãŠãåäģŖæĒčã§ã¯ãĒããã
ãéģãã貴æ§ãæ°äēēãĢããŧãŋåŊé ãææãããã ãããSSRãĢįããæããããããĒčĻå ãäŊãŖãĻãæãããã¨ãã§ããĒããŖããããã¯ããžããŽčŊãĄåēĻã§ã¯ãĒããŽãīŧããã¤ãŗãã
ããĒãã ã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãããžããã ãããŖãšããŧãã
ãŦãããĢãčĻįˇãåããã¨ãããŖãšããŧãã¯éĄã ãåãããã
ãããŧãŋã䏿ŖãĢå åˇĨãããĻãããĒãŠãæ°äēēãĢææããããããĒããšããããŽã¯ãããžããåãäģåããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽåéĄã ããã
ãããšã§ã¯ãĒãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããããããŧãŋã䏿ŖãĢåŊé ãĒãŠããĻããĒããããĒã
ãæŦåŊãĢããīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãč
°ãĢã¤ããéģããĻã¨ãšãããŧããããæ°æãŽåįãåãåēããã
ããããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãäŊŋããåŊĸãĢãããããŽãŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãĢåãčžŧãžããĒããŖããã¤ã¨ãå åˇĨåãŽįģåããŧãŋã大å¤ã ãŖããã ããéãããŽã
ãã´ãæžããããã¨č¨ãŖãčĻãã¯ãĒããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧããč¨ãŖãã
ãå¤ąį¤ŧīŧãã´ããããĒããããããã
ãã¨ãã°ãģãâĻâĻčĻãĻããæå¸ãĄãããŽããŽčĄ¨æ
ããŠãčĻãĻãâåĨŊæâã§ããīŧã
ãããããããĒãŖãĻãžãâĻâĻīŧã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãäģĨåææããįģåããããĨãĢãŧãšãåˇŽãåēããįģåã¨ä¸ĻãļãããĢåēããã
ãããããŠãčĒŦæãããŽīŧãããŖãšããŧãå¯åąéˇīŧã
ãį§ãããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇã ããããĒãããŋãĒãããĢčĻãĻãããããããŽããããžãã
ãĸãģããã¯ãã¸ãŖãąãããŽããąãããããæ°æãŽį´ãåãåēããĻãéããã
ãååš´åãããæ¨æĨãžã§ãŽåæ¯ããŧãŋã§ããåå
ĨãĢãããäēįŽã¯åŗčŠä¸ããã§ãæãããĢæ¸å°åžåãĢãããžããæ¯åēã¯æããããĻããããŽãŽãäēįŽãčļŗããĻããĒããŽã§ãčĩ¤åãč¨ãä¸ãã䏿šã§ãããĒãŽãĢãŠãããããããæįĩįãĒč¨ä¸ã§ã¯ãčĩ¤åãæããããĻããâĻâĻéģåãĢãĒããģãŠãããããžã§ã¯ãĒãããŠãæ¸å°ã¯æãããããã¯ã¤ãžãããŠããããåĨãŽäēįŽãåēãĻããŖãĻãã¨ãĢãĒããžãããīŧã
ãĸãģãããį¨ãã¨ããˇã§ãŧãã¯éĄãé¸ãããĻããč¨įŽããšã ãããããŊãĒã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãč¨įŽããšã ãã§čĒŦæã§ããå
厚ã§ã¯ãããžããâĻâĻīŧã
ãããããŠãããīŧãį´åžãããžã§čĒŦæãããã¨č¨ããã¨ããĒīŧã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯ãéĄããã¯ãã¯ãããĒããč¨ãŖãã
ããããããã¨ã§ãããããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãŖããããŦãããĢãããäŋēãã¯ããĢããã¨č¨ããĒãããããĢéãžãŖãĻãč¨ŧæ ãå
¨é¨åąå
ãĢããŠæããžããå
æ
ãįĨãŖãĻãåąåĄãããã ããããŠãäŊãįĨããâĻâĻãããčãããĢåããĻããã ããŽåąåĄãŽãģããå§åįãĢå¤ãããčĒåãä¸ãĢčĄããã¨ãččĻįã
ã¨įãŖãĻããåąåĄãããã¯ãã§ãã
ã貴æ§âĻâĻã
ãŦãããĢã¯å¤§čĄã§æŠããĻããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšãŽč¸ãããæ´ãã ã
ããããĒãã¨ããããæŦäŊããŠããĒããåããŖãĻãããŽãīŧīŧã
ãåãããĒãããčããĻããã§ããīŧīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããŦãããĢãŽæéĻãæ´ãã ã
ãäŋēéã¯įį¸ãæ´ããĻåēä¸ããã¨ããæŖįžŠãŽããã¨ãããããĒãã¨ãŽãããĢåããĻããããããĒãīŧīŧãããŽãžãžã§ã¯æŦäŊã¯ãããĒãâĻâĻäģãŽããŠãã¯ãĸãĻãã ãŖãĻããããããé ããĻããã¨ãĢåå ãããã¨æãããč¨ãŖãĻããã īŧīŧīŧã
ãæ°äēēãåããŖããããĒãã¨ãâĻâĻīŧã
ããĒããģãŠãéĸįŊãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯åŖå
ãįˇŠããå
¨åĄãčĻįˇãåããã
ãããŖãšããŧããããäŊãéĸįŊããã§ããīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãčĻįˇãåãããã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ã襨æ
ãå¤ãããĢįļããã
ãSSRããĒãäŊãããã¨æãīŧã
ãåãããžãããæããĻããããžããīŧã
ããĒãäŊãããããããŽįįąããŠãčããīŧã
ãäŋēãŽæčĻãčãããã¨īŧã
ããããããã ã
ãŦãããĢãŽæéĻããæãéĸãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãå
ãģãŠčĻãå
æ¯ãæãæĩŽããšãĒããããããžã§éããĻããéåæã¨įĩãŋåãããã
čǰãåŖãéããĒãã
ããŖã¨ããĻããã¨ã ãēã ãēãããããĒįˇåŧĩãįļãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãå°ãäŋ¯ããĻããéĄãä¸ããĻãåŖãéããã
ãä¸į¨ŽãŽčĒåˇąé˛čĄčŖ
įŊŽãã§ããã
ãˇã§ãŧããįŽãčĻéãã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯åžŽããĢäŊãéããããŦãããĢã¯æŗãæĄããããĻããã
ãå
ˇäŊįãĢã¯īŧã
ããŖãšããŧããč¨ãŖãã
ãæŦäŊãŽčĒįĨã¯ãããããĒč¨ãŖãĻæĒãã§ããžããæĒãŋãäŊãŖãĻããŽãžãžãĢããĻãããŽãããĒãæšãĒãŽã¯ãč¨ããžã§ããããžããã
ã貴æ§ãäŋēéã䞎螹ããæ°ãâĻâĻīŧīŧã
ãŦãããĢãåãĢč¸ãŋåēããã¨ããããããŖãšããŧããč
ãäŧ¸ã°ããĻåļããã
ãįļããã
ãčĒįĨãæĒãã§ããįįąã¯åãããžãããããããã¯éåģãĢããŖãäŊããåå ãĒãŽã§ãããããŠãSSRã¯ããã ã§ããå°ãĒãäēįŽãč¨å¤§ãĢæļč˛ģããããŽãé˛ããããŽããŽã ã¨čããããžãã
ããĒãSSRãäēįŽãŽæļč˛ģãæããīŧã
ããã¨ãã°ãããĨãĢãŧãšãæãŖãĻããįģåãâåĨŊæâã¨åããããŽæ
å ąãããâæå¸ã¯åĨŊæãããŖãĻããâã¨ä翏Ŧããã¨ããžããã§ãããããããå¤ããĻããå ´åãä翏ŦãŽčĒ¤åˇŽãäŋŽæŖããĢããŧãããããĢãč¨å¤§ãĒäēįŽãåŋ
čĻã¨ããžãããããĒäēįŽã¯ããŠããæĸããĻãããã¯ããĒããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢåããããĻããæ
å ąãæ´æ°ãããŽããåæ§ãĢå¤ããŽäēįŽãåŋ
čĻãĢãĒããžãããããĒãã¨ãããäŊčŖã¯ãæŦäŊãĢã¯ãĒãã
ãããã§īŧã
ãããŧãŋãå åˇĨããæĸåãŽæ
å ąã¨ãŽčĒ¤åˇŽãå°ãĒãįļæ
ãĢããĻããããããããã¨ã§ãå°ãĒãäēįŽã§ãããããã§ãããã¤ãžãSSRã¯ãæŦäŊãŽįãŋãåããããéŽįå¤ãŽãããĒããŽâĻâĻãŠãã§ãīŧãåŊãããã¨ãé ãããã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããīŧã
ããĒããģãŠãããããĢåæĨããããŦãããĢã¨æŖéĸããããããŖãã ããŽãã¨ã¯ãããĒã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯åŖå
ãįˇŠããĻãããã¨ãããææããã
ãã ããčĒåã§č¨čãĢããĻãįįžãĢæ°ãĨããĒããīŧã
ããŠãããæåŗã§ãīŧã
ãSSRã¯æŦäŊãåŽãããŽãã§ãããĒããäŊãåéĄãĒãã īŧã
ãããžããã ããã§ããã
ãå
ˇäŊįãĢã¯īŧã
ãä¸ãŽãŠããĢãĢæ¸ãããĻããč¨čâĻâĻãããããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽæ
å ąããäŊãããä翏ŦãŽčĒ¤åˇŽãæ¸ãããããŽããŽâĻâĻä翏ŦãæĒããããŽã§ãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããã¤ãŗããį¨ãã ã
ãįĸēããĢããŽįŦéã¯ãįãŋã¯įˇŠåããããã§ããįãŋããŽããŽã¯æļããĒããįãŋãŽåå ã¯ããŖã¨æŽãŖããžãžãįˇŠåããĻãã ãã§ããæŦæĨåĻįããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã¨ããéŽįå¤ã§ããžãããĻãããã ããSSRãĢã¯ãč¨å¤§ãĒãããĢãåããããĻãããããã¯ãæŦæĨãŽäēįŽã¨ã¯éããåŊãŽäēįŽâĻâĻãã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããŽæŽéǏãŽãããĒããŽãĒããããĒãã§ããīŧãåĻįã§ããĒãããäŋįŽĄããĻãããããĒããã§ããäŊŋãã°äŊŋããģãŠč¨ãä¸ããâĻâĻããã¯ããããæŦäŊãį ´įļģãããä¸č¯åĩ樊ãĒãã īŧīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽč¨čãĢãããŖãšããŧããé¤ããããŠãŗä¸äēēã¯é Ŧãåŧãã¤ãããæ°äēēä¸äēēã¯įŽãčĻéããã
ãä¸č¯ãåĩ樊âĻâĻã
ãĸãģããã¯åããã
ãã¤ãžãâĻâĻå
éããããåéĄãäŋįŽĄãããĻããå ´æããSSRâĻâĻīŧã
ããĄã¯ããčãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯é ˇããã
ããĒãĢããâĻâĻæŦäŊãčĻããã§ããŽã¯ãåąãäģåãŖãĻãäēēããĄãŽãããããâĻâĻīŧããĒãã§ãããĒãã¨âĻâĻã
ãäŋēãŽæ¨æ¸Ŧã¯čŠąããžããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããŖãšããŧãã¨įŽãåãããã
ãæããĻããããžããīŧããĒããSSRãäŊããããŽãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ã襨æ
ããįŦãŋãæļããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽčĻįˇãåãæĸããĻããã
ãäŊãããįįąãâĻâĻã
ãããä¸ã¤ã ãčãããã
ããĒãã§ãīŧã
ãããžãã¯ãSSRããŠãããšãã ã¨æãīŧã
ãããĄããããĒãããšãã§ããããŽãžãžã§ã¯ãæŦäŊã¯æåéããææĒãŽįĩæĢãčŋãããã¨ãĢãĒããžããSSRã¨ããä¸č¯åĩ樊ãåĻįããĻãäēįŽãčĻį´ããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽæ
å ąãå°ããã¤æ´æ°ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽæ
å ąåĻįãŽäģæšãčĻį´ãããããããĒããã°ãåĨå
¨ãĒįļæ
ãĢãĒããžããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽč¨čãĢããĸãģããããĄãé ˇããã
ãįĄįã ãĒã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ããã¨ã§ãæããããĢåŗæãåãããã
ãããžãããĄãŽããæšã§ã¯ãæŦäŊããããĒãã
ããĒããããæããã§ããīŧã
ãæããĻãããSSRããĒãã§ããããã
-2-
ããã˛ãæããĻãã ãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖããããããĢåéĄãŽæ šãŖããããã¯ãã ããã
ãSSRãäŊããããŽã¯ãæŦäŊããžã åäžãŽé ã ãåš´æ°ã§č¨ããĒãã20åš´ãããåã ãĒã
ã20åš´âĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ããåããã
ãSSRãŽæãĢæ¸ããĻããâčŦčãã¯įžåžŗâãŖãĻãã¤ãããžããčĻãããĒīŧã
ããããčĻãžãããã
ãããã¯ãĒãæŦäŊãåäžãŽé ãããŖã¨ä¸ĄčĻĒããč¨ãããĻããč¨čãĒãã ãããŠããĒãĢé åŧĩãŖãĻããææãåēããĻããâ čĒŋåãĢäšããĒãããžãã¯ãããĒ大ããäēēéãããĒããčŦčã§ãããããã ããããžããåŽããã¨ãĢãĒãââĻâĻãããĒãĩããĢč¨ããįļããã
ãčŦčãããããįžåžŗâĻâĻã
ãããã§ãåäžã ãčĻĒãĢčĒããããããĻä¸įæ¸åŊãĢãĒããããæĨãåŗåˇĨãŽæéãĢæããįĩĩããæ
äģģæå¸ĢãĢč¤ããããããšããããããæ°åã§åŽļãĢ帰ãŖããããã§ãĢ帰åŽ
ããĻãæ¯čĻĒãĢčĻãããã¨æãŖãã¨ããããčãããâãããčĻããĻããããŖã¨ãžãâĻâĻâãã ããæŦäŊã¯ããããĒãŽå¤§ãããã¨ãĒããå
įãč¤ããĻããããŽãåļįļããæ¯ããããįļããããããŖã¨é åŧĩãã¨ããã ãã ããâĻâĻãããĒä翏Ŧãããã¤ãįĢãĻãĻãæ¯čĻĒãĢčĻãããããã¨æ¯čĻĒã¯ããč¨ãŖããâãããč¯ããŖããããã§ããžã ãžã ããčĒŋåãĢäšãŖãĄãããĄãããŖã¨é åŧĩããĒãã¨âã
ãä翏ŦãåŊããŖãâĻâĻīŧã
ããããžã§ããŖã¨ãčĒåãŽæåž
ã¨ä¸ĄčĻĒãŽååŋã¯įéãĢčŋãįļæ
ã§ãäģã¨ã¯éãåŊĸã§äēįŽãä¸čļŗããĻãããäŋēéãåŊæã¯æ°äēēã§ããģã¨ããŠæ¯æĨčĩ°ãåãŖãĻãããä翏ŦčĒ¤åˇŽã大ãããĻãããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¯éŗ´ããŖãąãĒããäŧãæããĒããŖãã
ãæåž
ãå°ããããâĻâĻããããã¤ããšãĢããĻãããã¨ã§ãä翏ŦãŽčĒ¤åˇŽãæ¸ããããã§ããã
ãããŽäēåŽã¯ãåąå
ãĢčĄæãä¸ãããããã§åŊæãŽåąéˇããĄãéãžãŖãĻã芹ãåãŖããäēįŽãŽæļč˛ģãæãããããäģĨä¸ãĒãæŊįãããããĒãã¨ãĒãäēåŽįĸēčĒãŽãããĢãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēã¯âãŠããč¤ããããĒãâãâčŠäžĄãããããããĒããã ãäŋēã¯å¤§ããäēēéãããĒãããâãâãŠããããĄã ãããã ãŖãĻäŋēã ããâã¨ããŖãä翏ŦãčŠĻãããįĩæã¯ãäēæŗéãã ãŖãã
ãããã§SSRãäŊãããã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãSSRã¯čåã ãããŖãšããŧãã¯ãä¸įŦčĻįˇãé¸ãããããããããĒããã°ãæŦäŊã¯ã¨ãŖããĢåŖããĻããã ãããĒã
ãã§ãâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæˇąåŧå¸ããĻããč¨ãŖãã
ãããŽãžãžã§ã¯ãæŦäŊã¯į ´įļģããžããããŽããŠãã¯ãĸãĻãã¯åå
ãĢéããĒããããŽãžãžSSRãĢé ŧãŖãĻãããåŖããĻããžãâĻâĻæ šæŦããæ§é ãå¤ããĒãã¨ããĄãĒãŽã¯æãããĒã¯ãã âĻâĻīŧã
ãããããSSRãæĸããã¨īŧã
ãããã°é ŧãŖãĻããžããSSRã¯ä¸č¯åĩ樊ã§ãäŊŋããã¨ã¯éˇæįãĢâĻâĻã
ãįĒįļãåŋãŽæ ãæãįĄãããããĒããŽã ãã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ããããæŦåŊãĢãæŦäŊãŽãããĢãĒããŽãīŧããã ã§ããäģãæŦäŊã¯ä¸åŽåŽã ãSSRãæĸãããããããããããĒããã
ãæĸããĒããĻãåŖããžãâĻâĻīŧãããĄã¯ããåŖãæãã ããæĸããããã§ãŠãããããčããĒãã¨âĻâĻã
ãæŦäŊã¯åŖããããĒãã
ãˇã§ãŧããč¨ãŖãã
ãč¨ãåããįįąã¯ãŠããããããã§ããīŧã
ãĸãģããã¯įãã˛ãããã
ãéˇåš´ããŖãĻããåã ããįžå ´ãįĨããĒãåããĄã§ã¯åãããããĒãåã ã
ãåīŧããããæ šæ ã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãããã ã
ãããĢããĻãâĻâĻīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšãããĒãããĒãĢãč¨ãŖãĻãīŧã
ãâĻâĻã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšâĻâĻīŧã
ãįč§ŖããĻãããã ããã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãįč§ŖãŖãĻãäŊãã§ããīŧã
ãSSRãæĸããã°ãŠããĒããâĻâĻããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããžãããĄä¸äēēããããæįĸēãĢæŗåã§ããĻããã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ããĸãģããããĄãĢčĻįˇãæĩããã
ãäģãŽãžãžã§ã¯ããĄãĒãŽã¯ééããĒãâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãįĩãåēããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãåŋ
ãéã¯čĻã¤ããã
ããããĒããŽãããã°ããããĒã
ããŖãšããŧããéŧģã§įŦãŖãã¨ããåąå
ãĢæãããæģãŖãã
ãäģäēãĢæģãããããĒããã
ãˇã§ãŧãããĄãé¨åąãåēãĻãããããļã¤ããŧãēãŽåąåĄãæģãå§ããĻããããĨãĸãŗãšããĄã¯é¨åąãŽé
ãĢéãžãŖãĻã芹ããĻããã
ããããããŠãããīŧãããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãããããŽãžãžãĢããĻãããããĒãããīŧã
ãããĄããã ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯é ˇããããããŠãSSRããããĢæĸããããĒãã¨ãããŽããééãŖãĻã¯ããĒãã
ãä翏Ŧããããããä¸ããĻããã°äēįŽãŽæļč˛ģã¯å°ãĒããĻæ¸ãããŠãããŽå ´ããŽããããčĄåãæĸããĻããžãã°ãåãåˇģãįļæŗã¯æĒããĒãŖãĻããâĻâĻã
ããŦãŗãŋããã ãâĻâĻãããĄã¯ãã¯åããããæéããããĻåēããŖãĻãæåžã¯âĻâĻã
ããããĒãã¨ãããĒããã§ããīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããããããĒįĩæĢãĢã¯ãããĒããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããčãããã ãSSRãæĸããĻã大ä¸å¤ĢãĒæšæŗãâĻâĻã
ãäģŖãããĢãĒãäŊããâĻâĻ
âĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģãããč¨ããããã¨ããâãēããŗâã¨ããéŗãčãããæ°ãããã
į´åžãæŋããæēããčĩˇããŖãã
ããĄããŖã¨ããĒãĢâĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģãããŽåããĢįããããããŽã¯ãĒããåäēēã¨ãåŖãĢčä¸ãã¤ããĻãäŊãåēåŽãããããļã¤ããŧãēãŽåąåĄããĄã¯ãããšã¯ãŽä¸ãĢé ããããé¨åąãŽå¤ãĢéãåēãããããĻããã
ãåãžãŖããâĻâĻã
æēããæĸãžãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åŖããčä¸ãéĸããã
ããĒãã ãŖããã ããâĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ãã¯å°ããåŖ°ãéãããã
ãåãããĒãâĻâĻã˛ã¨ãžããäģäēãĢæģããã
ãããããäģæĨãæŦäŊãå¯ããã¨ãĢãžãã
ããããåēå ´ã§ãã
ãĸãģãããããĄã¯ããããĨãĢãŧãšãé¨åąãåēãĻãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯čĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãŖããããŦãããĢãããĒããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽããããé¨ããããåąåĄãäŊäēēãå
ĨåŖãĢéãžãŖãĻããã
įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻæŠãåēããã¨ããã¨ããĩããŗãŗãéŗ´ãŖãã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšããŠãããīŧã
ã大å¤ãĒãŽīŧīŧã
ã大å¤ãŖãĻããĒãĢãâĻâĻã
ãããŖããŽå°éã§åĨŗįĨåãŽä¸é¨ãå´ŠããĻãä¸ããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãã´ã¯ãĒã¨æ¯ãéŖ˛ãã ã
ãéģį´ĢãŽčãŋãããĒããŽãé˛åēããĻâĻâĻã¯ã¤ãŗãŽæŦ éĨčãŋãããĒããĒã¤ãããĻãâĻâĻãĒããĒãŽããâĻâĻã
ãâĻâĻã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšīŧãčããĻãīŧīŧã
ãæĒããããŖãĄã¯ä¸äēēã§įĸēčĒããĻãããĒããâĻâĻããŖãĄã¯äģâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽãģããĢčĻįˇãæģããã
äŊãããããžã§ãĢãĒãäŊãããæŦäŊãĢčĩˇããŖãĻããâĻâĻ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãžã§æŠãã¨ãéãžãŖãĻããæ°äēēãŽåąåĄãããåããĻãä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãã
-3-
äšžãããŖãåŋãããå˛ããčŗãåĄããããĒããããĒéŗãįĢãĻãĻããäēæĨã
æ¤åˇã¯ãäģäēãäŧãã§ãåģäēēãŽãããĢããããĢæ¨ĒãããŖãĻãããäŊãéŖãšãããšãããčĻããåããŽã¯ããããããĢãŽæ°´ãéŖ˛ãã¨ãã¨ããã¤ãŦãĢčĄãã¨ãã ããããäģĨå¤ã¯ããããĢæ¨ĒãĢãĒãŖããžãžãæčã¯åŽå
¨ãĢåæĸããĻããã
čĻčĻãæããĻããå æ¯ããããããčĒåãŽåŽļã§ãããŽã¯åãããæã ãäŊäēēãå¤ãŽåģä¸ãæŠããĻããéŗãčãããããæ°´äģĨå¤ãŽéŖ˛ãŋįŠã¯čŋããĢįŊŽããĻããĒããããããĒã¤ã¯ããĒãã
ãŧãããã¨čããĻããã¨ãå¤ããããĒããŧãããĢãģããããŧããåįãããããĢãåŋããĻããã¯ããŽč¨æļãæĩããĻããã
å°åĻįãŽé ãčĻĒãĢäŊåēĻãč¨ããããčŦčã§ãããã¨ããč¨čãæãå¤ãåãå¤ããæ´čŗãŽãããĢč¨ããįļããåŋã¯ãã¤ãŽéãĢãå æ ãããã
大äēēãĢãĒãŖãĻãčŦčã§ãããã¨ã¯å¤§äēã ã¨æãããã¨ã¯ããŖãããå¨å˛ããã¯æĻããååąãĒäēēéã ã¨æãããĻããæ°ããããč¤ããããĻãã大ãããã¨ãĒãã§ãããã¨ããį¤ŧãč¨ãããĢåĻåŽãããŽã¯ãčŦčããčŖ ãŖãåĻåŽã᏿ãŽåĨŊæãč¸ãŋãĢããããããĒãã¯ééãŖãĻãžãããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãããããĒããŽãĒãŽãããããĒãã
čŦčãã¯ãæŦåŊãĢįžåžŗãĒãŽã ãããã
ååąãĒãģãŠčĒåãä¸ããĻãčĒåã¯äēēããåŖãŖãĻããã¨č¨ãčãããĻãããã§æŦåŊãĢã嚸ããæãããããŽã ãããã
čĒäŋĄæēã
ã§įããĻã大ãããã¨ãĒãã¨æãįĨããããããã¯ãå
ãĢčĒåãä¸ããĻããããģããåŽåŋã§ãããŽã¯įĸēãã ãããâĻâĻ
ãâĻâĻåŽåŋâĻâĻīŧã
å°ãæ¸ããåŖããããŖã¤ããåãåĨãããããĢåããã
ä¸åčēĢãčĩˇãããĻããããĢåē§ããåŗæãäŧ¸ã°ããĻããããããĢãŽæ°´ãéŖ˛ãã
äŊãããčŗãŽä¸ãĢįãžãããã¨ããĻããâĻâĻåããäŊããã§ãããŖãĻããã
åŧžããããããĢįĢãŖãĻãPCãŽåãžã§čĄãã¨ãéģæēãå
Ĩããã
įĢãĄä¸ãããžã§ãŽ10į§ãæãæēããŗãŗãŗãŗã¨éŗ´ããã
įģéĸãæ ãã¨ãäģĨåäŋåããĻããį¯įŊĒåŋįåĻãĢã¤ããĻãŽčĢčãéããã
æŽēäēēãĢåŋĢæĨŊãčĻããæŽēäēēį¯ãĢã¤ããĻæ¸ãããããŽä¸ã§ãæĢæ°¸ã¨ããæļįŠēãŽéŖįļæŽēäēēį¯ãįģå ´ãããæĢæ°¸ã¯åäžãŽé ãæĨ常įãĢčåž
ãããįžŠįãŽįļčĻĒã¨ãčĻãĻčĻãŦãĩããããæ¯čĻĒãŽæ¯é
ä¸ãĢįŊŽãããäģæĨãįããããããŠãããåãããĒãįļæŗã ãŖãã
ã ããããå¤ãŽæĨã
čĨŋæĨãį
§ãã¤ããįŠēãŽä¸ãĢãå¤ĢåŠĻãŽåļãŋãŽéĒéãĢãĒããã¨ããįįąã§å¤ãĢåēãããæĢæ°¸ã¯ãæãã§æĻæ§ã¨ããĻããã¨ãããããŋãčĻã¤ãããæ´ãžããæĩæãããããŋãæããįåŊãįĩãããããããŽįŦéããããžã§æãããã¨ããĒããŖãåŽåŋæãįãžããâĻâĻä¸å¯¸å
ãä翏Ŧã§ããĒããŖãä¸įãŽä¸ã§å¯ä¸ãä翏Ŧå¯čŊãĒä¸įãįãžããâĻâĻ
čĢčãæåãĢčĒãã ã¨ããéŖįļæŽēäēēį¯ã¯ããããĻįãžãããŽãã¨ããčåŗã¨ããããĒåĸéãĢæ¯ãšãã°čĒåã¯ãžã ããˇã ã¨æãŖãã ãã ãŖãããäģã¯åããã
čĒåãä¸ããĻãããã¨ã¯ã᏿ãããŽâĻâĻããã严čĻĒãããŽãããžããĒããĻ大ããäēēéã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ããããŖãŧãããã¯ã¨ãŽčĒ¤åˇŽãæ¸ãããčĒåãŽä¸įãä翏Ŧå¯čŊãĢå¤ãããã¨âĻâĻäģč ãŽåŊãåĨĒãããčĒåãŽåŋãåããã¨ããéãã¯ããŖãĻããįå°įšã¯åãã
ä¸įãä翏Ŧå¯čŊãĢãããã¨ã
äēæŗå¤ãé ãããåŽåŋãåžããã¨ã
ããžããããĒãįžåŽãããããįãŋãįˇŠåãããéŽįå¤ã
ãã¤ããããžããããĒãã ãããã¨æãŖãĻããã°ãäēæŗããæĒãįĩæã§ããä翏Ŧã¨ãŽčĒ¤åˇŽã¯å°ãããĒããã ããč¯ãįĩæãčŋãŖãĻããĻãããããžããžéãč¯ããŖãã ããããããĒã¯ãã¯ãĒããã¨ããããĒåãĢã¯é¨ãããĒãã¨ã°ãããĢãįžåŽãæĒããã
įžåŽãčĻãĻããããã§ãčĻãĻããĒãã
įžåŽãåãæĸããĻããããã§ãéããĻããã
čĒåãčĻãããĻãããŽã¯įžåŽã§ã¯ãĒããčĒåčĒčēĢã§ãæĒãã įžåŽã¯čĒåãäŊãŖãĻããâĻâĻ
æå
ãéããĻãįĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻæ´éĸå°ãžã§čĩ°ãã¨ã严æãã¤ããã
ãžã éããĻããã
åŧå¸ã¯čããčŠãä¸ä¸ããã
æ°åããĻãããããčŊãĄįããĻããã¨ãåããã
ããããããŠãããã°ãããã ããâĻâĻã
įãã¯čŋãŖãĻããĒãã
åããã¯ãããĒãã
ããŖã¨ããããŖãĻįããĻããã
čŦčãã¯įžåžŗã ã¨ãčĒåã¯äēēããåŖãŖãäēēéã ã¨æãŖãĻããã
ããããã§ãããã¨æãčžŧãã°ãããŽã ãããã
âĻâĻããããããéãã
æãčžŧãã°ãĒãã§ãã§ãããããããĒããããã¯ãäŊåēĻãčŠĻããĻããã
ããŠãããã°ãããã ãâĻâĻã
é¨åąãĢæģãŖãĻããé ãŽä¸ãã°ãĢã°ãĢã¨åãã ãã§ãįãã¯įãžããæ°é
ããĒããä¸įŦãããŖãąãčĒåãĢã¯âĻâĻã¨æãããããããããĢãããã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ããč¨čãéŖãã§ããĻãé¨åąãŽä¸ãæŠãåãŖãã
ããããĢæ¨ĒãĢãĒãŖãĻãį ããã¨ã¯ã§ãããå¯čŋããæãŖãã¨ãããšãããéããã
ãæå¸ããâĻâĻã
æ°ãĢæãļããĢčĻããããĒæčĻã§ãæ¨ĒãĢãĒãŖããžãžããŖãããéãã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯įŽãčĻéããĻãä¸åčēĢãčĩˇãããã
ããŠããããã¨âĻâĻīŧããĒãã§ãããĒâĻâĻã
äŊåēĻãčĒãŋčŋããĻãããæãåãããã
ãéģ芹ã§čŠąããīŧã
ãããĢæĸčĒãĢãĒããããããã¨čŋãŖãĻããĻãæ¤åˇã¯ãšãããčŗãĢåŊãĻãã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãå éããæˇˇäšą
-1-
ãããããâĻâĻã
æå¸ãŽåŖ°ã¯ãããããĢéããĻããã
å§ŋã¯čĻããĒãããããããŽä¸ãĢåē§ããå¸åŖãããļãŖãĻäŊãį¸ŽããĻãããããĒæ°ãããĻãæ¤åˇã¯č¸ãĢæãåŊãĻãĻãTãˇãŖããæĄãŖãã
ãäģã¯ã大ä¸å¤Ģīŧã
æ°ãļæãåãŖãĻããĒããŖããããĢåŖ°ãããããĻãã大ä¸å¤Ģīŧãã¨č¨ãį´ããã
ãããâĻâĻãĢãŧããŗãŽééããå¤ãčĻãĻãããŠãããĒãâĻâĻã
ãč¯ããŖãâĻâĻã
ã§ããã¨č¨ããããĻãæ¤åˇã¯č¨čãæĸããã
æ°į§ãŽæ˛éģã
čŗå
ã§įˇæĨãŽãˇããĨãŦãŧãˇã§ãŗäŧč°ãčĄããããŽãĄãåŖãéããã
ãä¸ãįŦããã§ãééããĒããã ããīŧã
ãééããĒãâĻâĻä¸éąéãããåãããæĨãĢæå¯ãé§
ãŽããããĢæĨããããĢãĒãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãåŖ°ããããããīŧã
ãããâĻâĻæåã¯ãæ¤åˇãããŽãã¨ã§äŊãããŖããŽããĒãŖãĻæãŖããã ããŠâĻâĻã
ãįŽįã¯ãæå¸ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäģäēãŽå¸°ããĢåž
ãããĻããã¨ãããããĒãã§æĨãĢâĻâĻã ãŖãĻãä¸åēĻ芹ããã ãã ããéŖįĩĄå
ãä礿ããĻãĒãããããĒããŽããåãããĒããã ãīŧã
æå¸ãŽåŖ°ãéããĻããã
įč§Ŗã§ããĒãįļæŗããčŗå
ãĢæĸããã¨ãŽãĒãåĩãįãŋããŠãã¸čĄãã°æãããããŽããåããããéŖįĩĄããĻãããŽã ããã
ãšãããæãŖãĻããĒããģããŽæããåŋčãŽãããã§åãčžŧããã
æãâĻâĻīŧ
äŊãĢ寞ããĻãŽâĻâĻīŧ
ãä¸åŋãčããã ããŠãæå¸ãããŽåéããŖãĻãã¨ã¯ããĒãããâĻâĻīŧã
įŽãŽåãĢããĒããŽãĢãæå¸ãįŽãčĻéããåãéããããŽãčĻããæ°ãããĻãæ¤åˇã¯åãåãã ã
ãåéããŖãĻããŠããããã¨âĻâĻīŧãä¸ãįŦãããããĒãåĨãŽčǰããããĒãããŖãĻãã¨īŧã
äģãžã§čãããã¨ããĒãåŖ°éŗâĻâĻæ¤åˇã¯ãæˇąåŧå¸ããĻããåŖãéããã
ãä¸åŋã ããã ãŖãĻãä¸ãįŦãããæå¸ãããĢäģããžã¨ãįįąããåãããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãį§ã ãŖãĻåãããĒãâĻâĻīŧīŧã
é ãŽãĻãŖãēãããįĒãæãããããĒåŖ°ããæ¤åˇãŽäŊãæēãããã
ãį§ã ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
åŖ°ãããããĻãæ¤åˇã¯čããéããĒããããããã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãæå¸ãããåãã¤ããĻãã¨æãŖãĻããããããĒããã ããã ããããããããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãį§ããŠãããã°ããīŧãčĻå¯ãĢč¨ãŖãĻããæåž
ã§ããĒããâĻâĻã
ãäŋēã芹ããĻãŋããææĨãäŧį¤žã§ã
ããģãã¨īŧã
ãããĄãããæŦäēēãĢį´æĨčããŽãä¸įĒæŠãããã
ãããâĻâĻã§ããæ°ãã¤ããĻãã
ãæ°ãã¤ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãä¸ãįŦãããå°ãæãããâĻâĻã
ãâĻâĻåããŖããæ°ãã¤ãããããžãäŊãããŖããéŖįĩĄããĻãããŖããã§ãéģ芹ã§ãã
ããããã¨ãâĻâĻãããããé
ãæéãĢã
ãäŊč¨ãŖãĻããŽãå
¨įļããããããããããããŋã
ãããããŋã
é芹ãįĩããã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯åēãĢåē§ãŖãĻãããããĢčä¸ãã¤ããã
ãã¤ãŽéãĢããããããéããĻãįĢãŖãĻ芹ããĻãããã¨ãĢéŠãããããããĢãŠãã§ããããĒãŖãã
ä¸ãįŦããæå¸ãĢäģããžã¨ãŖãĻããâĻâĻ
ãŠãč§Ŗéããã°ãããŽã ããã
ããããäēåŽãĒãŽã ãããã
äēåŽãĒããä¸ãįŦã¯ãĒããããĒãã¨ãīŧ
ãããæå¸ãä¸ãįŦã¨äŋēãé ããããã¨ããĻâĻâĻ
ãäŊčããĻãã ããĢâĻâĻīŧã
严æã§é ãæąããĻãäŋ¯ãã
æå¸ãŽåŖ°ãĢããįēč¨ãĢããåã¯æããããĒããŖãã
ããŽéãŽãããããĒããĻãåããã
æå¸ã¯æŦæ°ã§æ¯ããĻããã
ãã¨ãĢããã芹ããĒããâĻâĻã
ããããĢæŊãã¨ããããįŽãéããã
ããããĻããéããæå¸ã¯é¨åąã§ä¸äēēãå¨å˛ãŽãĄããŖã¨ããįŠéŗãĢãææãĢãĒãŖãĻãį ããã¨ãĢããæ¯ããĻãããããããĒããčĻãããĻãããããããĒãâĻâĻä¸įãŽįæããããã¤ããŽãˇãŧãŗãįãŋåēããæ§ã
ãĒįĩæĢãčĻããããšããŧãĢãŧãĢäģããžã¨ããããã¨ã¯ãå§ãžãã¨įĩãããæąēãžãŖãĻããããŠãŧæ įģãĒãŠæ¯čŧãĢãĒããĒãææããčĸĢåŽŗč
ãĢįãŋåēãã
ãâĻâĻã
æŗãĢåãå
Ĩãã
ããæŦåŊãĢãä¸ãįŦãæå¸ãĢãããĒããŽãä¸ããĻããã¨ãããâĻâĻ
æ¤åˇã¯ãį ããã¨ããæčãææžããĻãčŗãčãããžãžãĢäģģããã
ããšãĻã¯ææĨã
ææĨãä¸ãįŦã¨čŠąãã
-2-
æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢå ĨãŖãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããžãŖãããĢSSRã¸åããŖããããĸãŽåãĢã¯ããŦãããĢãŽäŋĄé ŧåãé¨ä¸ãæ°äēēããããæĸãããã¨ãããŽãæŧããŽããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ä¸ãĢå ĨãŖãã
ããâĻâĻīŧã
æãããč
ã§éŧģãčĻãŖãã
ãéģį´ĢãŽčãŋãããĒããŽãé˛åēããĻâĻâĻã¯ã¤ãŗãŽæŦ éĨčãŋãããĒããĒã¤ãããĻãã
ãããĢæĨãåãĢãããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãĻãããã¨ãé ãĢæĩŽããã ã
ã¯ã¤ãŗãŽæŦ éĨčâĻâĻįĸēããĢäŧŧãĻããããéŧģãčĻãŖãĻããĒãã¨åãæ°ãæããããĒããģãŠãŽåŧˇãã§ãSSRãĢå
æēããĻããã
ããŦãããĢããâĻâĻã
ååŋã¯ãĒãã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãã¯ã¤ãŗãããĢãŽãããĒãããå˛ããĻãä¸ãŽæļ˛äŊãåēãæŋĄãããĻãããŽããåįļã¨įēããĻãããčããæããĻããĒãããŽãããĢã严č
ã¯ããŠãĒã¨ããĻãããŽčä¸ã¯ããããžã§čĻããã¨ããĒããģãŠåŧąã
ããã
ããŦâĻâĻããįĩããã âĻâĻã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãįĩãããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãSSRãå´ŠããâĻâĻã
ãå´ŠããâĻâĻīŧã
䏿°åŗãĒããčåŗã§ãããŖãSSRãŽæ¯č˛ã¯ãčæ°åŗæĒãåģåĸãŽãããĢãĒãŖãĻããããããĢãŽåæ°äģĨä¸ã¯ãå˛ããĻåēãĢæŖãã°ããå
ã¯ãã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ããīŧåŊãŽäēįŽīŧã ãŖãã ããããŽããåŧˇįãĒæŦ éĨčãæŧãããį
§æãæã
ææģ
ããã
ãSSRãããŽãžãžå´ŠãããĒããããã¯æŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯ãããã¨ãĒããããĒãã§ããīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããŦãããĢãŽéŖãžã§æŠããã
ãæŦäŊãå¤ãããã¨ããĻããäŋēéã¯ãããæ¯ãããšãã§ã¯īŧã
ãSSRãĒãã§ããŠãããŖãĻæ¯ããīŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãã§ããããããĒãâĻâĻīŧãSSRãããŖãããæŦäŊã¯ãããžã§ããŖãĻãããããĒããã°âĻâĻã
ãããŽSSRãæŦäŊãčŋŊãčžŧãã ãã īŧīŧããĒãã§ãããåãããĒããã ãīŧīŧã
ãããããããžãã¯ãŠããããã īŧã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ããŖãšããŧããå
ĨãŖãĻããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšãŽåã§įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãã
ãSSRãŽčĒŦæã¯ããããĒīŧããããæŊ°ããĒããæŦäŊãå´ŠåŖããĒããããŽåĨãŽäŊããåŋ
čĻã ã
ãåĨãŽäŊããŖãĻâĻâĻåéĄã¯SSRãĒãã ããããããå´Šããã°âĻâĻã
ãäģŖããããĒããĒããããžãã¯ãã ãŽį ´åŖč
ã ã
ãį ´åŖč
īŧīŧãäŋēãīŧīŧīŧã
ãäŊãéŠãããããžã§čĒåãåŽåŽãããĻããããŽãææžããã ããããį¤ēãããĢãSSRãæĒã¨æąēãã¤ããĻį ´åŖãããã¨ããĻãããŽãããĨãĸãŗãšãããžãã ã
ãSSRãŽå´ŠåŖã¯ãæ°ããčĄåããæŦäŊãčĒåãå¤åãããĻãããããĢįĩļ寞ãĢåŋ
čĻãĒãã¨ã§ããæåã¯ã¤ãããããããĒãããŠâĻâĻã
ããããã§ããĒããããå¤ããŽäēēéã¯čĒåãå¤ããããĒãã¨ããįžåŽãåãããĒããŽãīŧã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯čĒæ°ãåŧˇããã
ãSSRã¯ãįĸēããĢæŦäŊåēæãŽããŽã ãã ãäģãŽäēēéãĢããčĻæ¨ĄãŽéãã¯ããããäŧŧããããĒããŽãåå¨ãããããžããŽč¨ãä¸č¯åĩ樊ã¯ãįãããããĢåŋ
čĻãĒããŽãĒãã ãã
ãä¸č¯åĩ樊ãåĸããįļããĻãããã§åããã¨ããĻãããŽããąã¯åŋ
ããŠããã§åãŖãĻããâĻâĻããŽããąãæããŽã¯æŦäŊã§ãããããæŖãããã§ããīŧã
ãæŖããã¨æããĒããĒããããžããäģŖããã፿ããã°ãããããŖã¨ãã፿ã§ããã¨ããã§ãæĨæŋãĒå¤åããžããæŦäŊãå´ŠåŖã¸å°ããããžãã¯įĨããĒãã ããããéåģãĢãããããã¨ãããŖããæŦäŊãčĒåãå¤ãããã¨æĨãĢčĄåãå¤ããįĩæãSSRãŽåĸå éã¯ãä¸ãļæã§éåģååš´åãä¸åãŖãããããįžåŽã ãæ°äēēã
ããŖãšããŧãã¨įŽãåãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯įŽãäŧããĻãæŗãæĄãŖããé ã¯č¨čãæĸããĻããããåŖããåēããĢã¯äŊããčļŗããĒãã
ããŦãããĢãčŊãĄčžŧãã§ããå ´åãããĒãããæŠãSSRã垊æ§ãããĒãã¨ã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ããŦãããĢãŽčŠãåŠããã
ãåããŖãĻããâĻâĻã
ãŦãããĢãéĄãä¸ããã¨ããããĢã¤ãŦãŗãéŗ´ãéŋããã
ããããŖãĻããŠãããâĻâĻã
ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽãĒããŖãšã§ãããĄã¯ãã¯čĒåãŽåãĢãããĸããŋãŧã¨ãé¨åąãŽä¸å¤ŽãĢããįäŊãĸããŋãŧãĢčĻįˇãčĄãæĨãããããŠãĄããæ åãäšąããä翏ŦãäŊããããŽããŧãŋã¨ããĻæŠčŊããĻãĒãã
ãâĻâĻã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯įäŊãĸããŋãŧãŽåãĢįĢãŖãĻãæææã§ãĒãããããĢããĒãããæ åãåčĻããĻãããããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¯ããããžã§ãĢãĒããģãŠå¤§ããéŗ´ãéŋããĻããããåąå
ãŽčǰããåãããĢãéĄãčĻåããããããã¤ãŗããĢčĻįˇãåããĻããã
ããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇâĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ãã芹ããããã¨ããã¤ãŗãã¯čĻįˇãčģŊãåããã
ãããžãããĄãŽããã ãã
ãåããĄãŽãŖãĻãæ°äēēīŧäēēãŖãĻãã¨ã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäģãĢčǰãããīŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããžãããĄãŽčĄåããæŦäŊãSSRãåŖãã¨ããčĄåãåŧãčĩˇãããããŠãč˛Ŧäģģãåãã¤ããã ã¨č¨ãããã¨ããã ãããããĒčģŊã芹ã§ããĒãâĻâĻã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯åĨĨæ¯ãåãã ã
ãããŖãšããŧããSSRãĢčĄãŖãĻãããŽããããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąããã¤ãēã ããã§ãäŊãä翏Ŧãã§ããâĻâĻãããĢæĒããã¨ãĢãSSRãå¤ąãŖãããŽãŋã¤ããŗã°ã§ãäēæŗå¤ãŽãã¨ãčĩˇããŖãĻããžãŖãâĻâĻã
ãããŖãŗãšã§ã¯ãĒããã§ãããããã¯âĻâĻã
ããĒãã ã¨īŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ããĄã¯ããŽč¸ãããæ´ãã ã
ãããŖãŗãšã¨ã¯ãŠããããã¨ã īŧã
ãããSSRãäŊŋããĒãäģããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãããŽįããŧãŋãäŊŋãŖãĻãåĨå
¨ãĒä翏ŦãįĢãĻãããŖãŗãšãŖãĻãã¨ã§ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãį äŋŽã¨åŽåã§äŊãåĻãã ãã ãåã¯īŧīŧã
ãã¤ãŗããåŖ°ãčŖčŋãããĻé¨åąãéãããã¨ãåąåĄå
¨åĄãåãã¤ãããããĢåēãžãŖãã
ãããŧãŋããããããĒãŠã¨ãå
¨äŊãčĻããĢå°ããĒãã¨ãĢåēåˇããĻãæŦčŗĒããžãã§čĻããĻãĒãã
ããŠããããæåŗã§ããâĻâĻã
åŖ°ãįĩãåēãã¨ããã¤ãŗãã¯ããĄã¯ãããæãéĸããã
åŗãčžŧãŋãĒããčãæ˛ããããĄã¯ããĢčãåããĻãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãčĻãĒããããã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãããŽããŧãŋãĢãã¤ãēãå¤ããŽã¯ãæŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻäēæŗå¤ãŽãã¨ãčĩˇããĻããããã ã¨ãããã¨ãåããããŽãīŧãæŦæĨã§ããã°ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢããããŧãŋã¨į
§ãããĻãä翏ŦãįĢãĻããããŠãŽæĻåŋĩãĢãåŊãĻã¯ãžããĒããããĒåēæĨäēã ãããŖããčŊãĄįããããŽSSRã¯å´ŠåŖįļæ
âĻâĻãŠãããįļæŗãĒãŽãčããĻ寞åĻããåŋ
čĻãããããæĒįĨãŽãã¨ãâĻâĻããããä¸åŽãææã¨ããŖãæĻåŋĩãååŋããįļæŗãĢã¤ããĻčãããĢã¯ãč¨å¤§ãĒäēįŽãåŋ
čĻã ãã ããããĒäēįŽã¯ãŠããĢããĒãã
ãä翏ŦããžãŖããã§ããĒãâĻâĻã¤ãžãããŗãŗãããŧãĢä¸čŊãŽæ´čĩ°įļæ
âĻâĻã
ããããã¯ã¨åŧã°ããįļæ
ã ããã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖãããã ãããĸããŋãŧãĢãäŊãæ ããĒãã
ããããããŠãããã°âĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ãã¯ãåŖããåēãč¨čãæģããããĢã严æã§åŖãæŧãããã
ãSSRã垊æ§ããããã¨ã¨ãå°ãã§ãįļæŗãææĄã§ãããããĢãäēįŽãįĸēäŋãããã¨ã ããã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖãããį§ã¯ãããéĸãããããããĄã¯ãããļãģããŗã¯ãĢčĄãŖãĻãįļæŗãčĒŦæããĻäēįŽãåēããããĢč¨ããããŖãĄãĢãæ°äēēãããã ããã
ãåãããĸãģããã¨äēäēēã§ãˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãčĒŦåžããã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãåããŖããããŖãã¨čĄãīŧīŧã
ãã¤ãŗããåãŗåŖ°ãčŖčŋãããã¨ãåąåĄããĄã¯čŗãåĄããããĄã¯ãã¯éãããããĢé¨åąãåēãã
åĨŗįĨååēå ´ãĢå
Ĩãã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯éŧģãæŧãããã
ä¸å¤ŽãĢã¯ã大įįŗãå´ŠãčŊãĄãĻãä¸ãé˛åēããåĨŗįĨåâĻâĻéģį´Ģã§ãããĒã¨ããäēēåŊĸãŽãããĒããŽãæŽãŖãĻãããä¸åčēĢã¯å´ŠãčŊãĄãåēãŽä¸ã§į ããĻãéĻããä¸ãåããĻãįĄé äŊãĢčģĸããŖãĻãããæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻčĻįˇãåããã¨ãčģĸããŖãéĄã¨įŽãåãŖãĻãããĄã¯ãã¯čŠããã¯ãĒã¨ãããĻããļãģããŗã¯ã¸čĩ°ãŖãã
ãããããæŦäŊãį ããĢã¤ãããããåž
ãŖãĻãSSR垊æ§ãŽãããĢäēįŽãåãã
ãļãģããŗã¯ãŽä¸å¤ŽãĢįŊŽãããĻããããããŖãģãã¸ã§ãããã¨ããå¤Šį§¤ãĢč§ĻããĒããããˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
éč˛ãĢčŧãå¤Šį§¤ã¯ããã¤ãSTéŖåļãŽããšã¯å´ãĢåžããĻããããå°éãŽåŊąéŋããäŊįŊŽãåēåŽãããĒããžãžãä¸ä¸éåãįš°ãčŋããĻããã
ãåž
ãŖãĻãã ãããSSRã垊æ§ãããĻããåéĄã¯č§ŖæąēããžããâĻâĻīŧã
čǰãããˇã§ãŧããŽč¨čãĢé ˇãä¸ããĸãģããã¯åŖ°ãåŧĩãŖãã
ããĒãæ šæŦįãĒč§ŖæąēãĢãĒããĒããã¨ãĢâĻâĻããŠãã¯ãĸãĻããčĩˇããŖãå
åļã§ããSSRã垊æ§ããåŋ
čĻããããã§ããīŧīŧãäģããšããã¨ã¯ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽåĨå
¨åã§ãīŧãSSRãééããĻãããŧãŋããŧãšãŽæ
å ąãå
ĨãæŋããĻâĻâĻã
ããããĢãŠãã ããŽäēįŽãåŋ
čĻããåãĒãåããã¯ãã ããĸãģããããˇã§ãŧãã¯æˇĄã
ã¨č¨ãŖãããåįãŽããããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããäŊŋããĒããSSRãæŠčŊããĻãĒãããã ã
ããããĒããŽã¯äŊŋããšããããĒãâĻâĻīŧããĸãģããã¯č¨ãŖãããäēįŽãå¤ãåŋ
čĻãĒãã¨ããäģãããĢãããĒäŊčŖããĒããŽã¯åããŖãĻããžããããã§ãããéããĻãããĒãã¨ãæŦäŊã¯æŦåŊãĢåŖããĻããžãâĻâĻã
ãSSRã垊æ§ããã°ãåŊéĸã¯åãããããŽåžãĢčããã°ãããäģåžãŽãã¨ã¯ã
ãããããŖãĻåéĄãå
åģļã°ããĢããĻããįĩæãäģãĒãã§ããâĻâĻéããĻãã ããããĒãīŧīŧã
ãĸãģãããåĢãļã¨ããˇã§ãŧãã¯å¤Šį§¤ãčš´ãã¤ããã
ãéããĻããâĻâĻãããããããĒããã ãäēēéã¨ããããŽã¯ããããĒãĢåŧˇãã¯ãĒããéããĻããã¨ããæįŊĒã¯ãäģãŽåãŽãããĢãįžåŽãįĨãããĢįĒãŖčĩ°ããããĒæĒįãĒč
ãåŖãĢããįæŗčĢã ã
ãéãâĻâĻīŧãįĸēããĢåŧˇããĒããããããĒããã§ãéãããã¨ãæŖåŊåãããŖãĻãäŊãå¤ãããĒãâĻâĻã
ä¸įŦãŽæ˛éģãįãžããã¨ãããļãģããŗã¯ãŽéåãĒæããéŗãįĢãĻãĻéããã
ãã¯ããã¯ãâĻâĻã
ãããĄã¯ãâĻâĻīŧīŧã
čãĢ严æãã¤ããĻãčŠã§åŧå¸ããĻããããĄã¯ããčĻãĻããĸãģããã¯é§ãå¯ãŖãã
ããŠããããŽīŧããŠãããĻãããĢâĻâĻã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãĢ芹ããããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããžãã¯æ¯ãæ´ããĻã
ãĸãģãããčä¸ãæĻãã¨ãããĄã¯ãã¯åŧąãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻããããã¨ããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãããå§ŋåĸãæŖããã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇãããŽäŧč¨ã§ãã
ããĄã¯ããŽåŖ°ãåąãã¨ããˇã§ãŧãã¯éĄãåããã
ãæŦäŊãį ãŖããŽãĄãäģãŽįļæŗãå°ãã§ãįč§Ŗã§ãããããĢãčãããããŽäēįŽãåããĻãģããã
ããĄã¯ããč¨ãã¨ããĸãģããã¯įŽãčĻéãããˇã§ãŧãã¯ãēãĢãēãĢã¨ã大čĄã§čŋãĨããĻããã
ãæŦåŊãĢããã¤ãŗããããč¨ãŖããŽãīŧã
ãâĻâĻã¯ãã
ãâĻâĻSSRãŽåžŠæ§ãĢã¤ããĻã¯īŧã
ãäŊãã
ãäŊãīŧã
ãã¯ããįļæŗãĢ寞åĻãããããĢãčããåŋ
čĻããããããŽãããĢäēįŽãæģåēããĻããã¨âĻâĻã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯ãããĄã¯ããå¤č¸ãŋãããããĢãéĄãããŖããã¨æēãããĒãã襨æ
ãčĻŗå¯ããĻãåŖãéããã
ãæŦåŊãŽãã¨ãč¨ãŖããģãããããäģ芹ãã°č¨ąããã ãåžã§åã ã¨įēčĻããããéĻãéŖãļãã¨ãĢãĒããã
ãâĻâĻæ§ããžããã
ããĒãã ã¨īŧã
ãåã¯ãããŽčĻæã§æĨãžãããäēįŽãåããĻãã ãããSSRãŽåžŠæ§ããããįžåŽãĢ寞åĻãããģããã¯ãããĢ大åã§ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãį§ãããæããžãã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ãâĻâĻã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯äēäēēãį¨ãŋãĒãããææĄãããããĢč
ãįĩãŋãčĻįˇãä¸ããĻããč¨ãŖãã
ãäēįŽã¯ãSSR垊æ§ãĢåããããĄã¯ããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢæģãŖãĻããã¤ãŗããĢäŧãããã ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãŽå¤æã§ãčãããã¨ã¸ãŽäēįŽã¯åžãããĒããŖãã¨ã
ãåž
ãŖãĻãã ããâĻâĻīŧãįĸēããĢãã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇã¯ãSSR垊æ§ãŽãããŽäēįŽãåēããããĢč¨ããžãããã§ããįļæŗãææĄãããããŽäēįŽãåēããããĢã¨âĻâĻã
ãäēįŽé
åãæąēãããŽã¯į§ã ããã¤ãŗãã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯ããĄã¯ããį¨ãã ã
ãã¤ããį´åžãããSSRã¯äŊãããåĒå
ããšãããŽã ããã ã
ããããĒãã¨ãããĻããããâĻâĻã
ã芹ã¯äģĨä¸ã ããĸãģãããäģäēãĢæģããã ãããĄã¯ãã¯ããčĻå´ã ãŖããåãŽäģļã¯ãčããĒããŖããã¨ãĢãããã
ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢæģãŖãĻ芹ãäŧããã¨ããã¤ãŗãã¯ä¸įŦãéĄããã¯ãĒã¨ããããããåããŖããã¨ã ãč¨ãŖãã
SSRãŽå´ŠåŖã¯å
ããããŽãŽãæŦäŊãįŽãčĻãžããžã§ãŽæéã§åžŠæ§ãããã¨ã¯åēæĨãããŦãããĢã¯SSRãĢæŽãŖãĻ寞åŋãįļįļãåąéˇãį´ã
ãĢææŽãåãŖãĻãé常æĨåãįļįļããããæŦäŊãäģäēãå§ããé ãĢãĒãŖãĻãåãŗåąå
ãĢæŋããæēããčĩˇããŖãã
ãäģåēĻã¯ãĒãã âĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽå
ĨåŖãčĻãĒãããããĨãĢãŧãšãĢéŖįĩĄããã
ããĒãĢããâĻâĻããããēã¤ããããĨãĸãŗãšâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãŽåŖ°ãéããĻããã
ããŠãããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäģéãŖããč´čĻããŧãŋãčããĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯į̝æĢãčŗããéĸããĻãéãããĻããéŗåŖ°ãåįããã
ãâĻâĻãã¤ãēãå
ĨãŖãĻãĻãããããĒčãåããĒãããŠããŠããããã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãåãããĒãâĻâĻã§ããæŦäŊã¯æˇˇäšąããĻããäģãŽå ´æããä¸ããŖãĻããããŧãŋãå
¨é¨ããã¤ãēãå
ĨãŖãĻããŽã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãé芹ãããŽãžãžãĢããĻãSSRãžã§čĩ°ãŖãâĻâĻãããããĢã¯ã厤å
ãŽããšãĻãŽãããĢãå˛ããĻéŖãŗæŖããåģēįŠããŽããŽãĢãžã§äēčŖãå
ĨãŖãSSRã¨ãåįļã¨įĢãĄå°ŊãããŦãããĢãŽčä¸ãããã ãã ãŖãã
ãããâĻâĻããããŠããããã¨ã§ããīŧīŧã
čĩ°ãŖãĻããŖãĻããŦãããĢãĢčãã¨ãããããžã§å´ŠããĻããžãŖããã垊æ§ã¯éŖãããããããĒãâĻâĻãããĒãŖããæŦäŊã¯âĻâĻãéããåŖ°ã§č¨ãŖãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæãã å
æ¯ãįŽãŽåãĢããĻãåãããĢããã
ããã§ããã¯ãâĻâĻ
ããæããŽãĢã厤å
ãčĻåãã¨ãčãŽãããããããŋä¸ããĻããããŽãæããĻãåŗæã§åŖãæŧãããĻãéĄãä¸ããã
SSRãŽå´ŠåŖãæãã čĒåã¯ééãŖãĻãããŽãâĻâĻīŧãåŊããŽæ ãæã¯ãģã¨ããŠåŖãã¤ã¤ãããããŽãžãžåŽå
¨ãĢå´ŠåŖããã°ãåãĢé˛ããã¯ãâĻâĻã ãããã¨ãæ¯ã§ããŖãĻããåŽåŽãĢåŊšįĢãŖãĻãããŽã¯įĸēãã§ãæĸåãŽæĻåŋĩã§ã¯å¯žåĻãéŖããããŽįļæŗã§SSRãäŊŋããĒããŽã¯ããŋã¤ããŗã°ã¨ããĻã¯ææĒâĻâĻ
ãã§ãããããããĒããããããŽã§å¯žåĻãããããĒãâĻâĻã
åãã¨ããŦãããĢãããŽãžãžãĢããĻåąãĢæģããé¨åąãŽä¸å¤Žãžã§č¨ãŖãĻãåŖ°ãä¸ããã
ããŋããĒãåã貸ããĻãã ãããããŽãžãžã§ã¯ãæŦäŊãå´ŠåŖããžãâĻâĻīŧã
-3-
æå¸ã¨čŠąããįŋæĨã
æ¤åˇã¯äēæĨãļããĢäŧį¤žãĢéĄãåēãããååã¯æããčŋããĻãããĻãä¸å¸ãããåŋé
ãããã ãã§ãããã¨ããããäŊã¯åŧˇåŧĩãŖãĻããã
ä¸ãįŦãæĨããäŊã芹ããâĻâĻããããã¯ããĄãã芹ããããåãĢäŊãč¨ãŖãĻãããŽã¯äēæŗã§ãããã§ã¯ãĒãã¨čŋããīŧãåéĄãĒãã§ãã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ãâĻâĻč¨čã§ã¯ããč¨ããĻããéĄãĢåēããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããä¸ãįŦã¯ããŖã¨ãããĢæ°ãĨãâĻâĻ
ãä¸ãįŦãããåŊŧåĨŗã§ããã°ããã ããããã§é
åģã ãŖããããĻãã
é ãŽä¸ã§čĄãããĻãããˇããĨãŦãŧãˇã§ãŗã¯ããä¸ãįŦãåŊŧåĨŗãã¨ããã¯ãŧãã§éåãããæ°ãĨãã°ãå§æĨæéãéããĻãããä¸ãįŦã¯ãžã æĨãĻããĒãã
ããããããŖããããĒīŊãåŊŧåĨŗãååãĒãã ãŖãīŧã
ãæå¸ãããã ãŖãããĒã
åŋčãåēããããããĒįãŋã¨čĄæã§ãæ¤åˇã¯éĄãããããã
ãããååãåãã ãã§ãæŧĸåã¯éãã¯ãã âĻâĻæå¸ã¯ãäģããžã¨ãããĻããã¨č¨ãŖãĻããããããã ããéããéããĢæąēãžãŖãĻãâĻâĻ
ããã¯ããīŊã
ä¸ãįŦãŽåŖ°ãčãããã¨ãčŠããã¯ãĒã¨ä¸ããŖããäŊäēããĒããŖããããĢãPCãčĻãĒããäģäēãå§ããããŽãŽãčŗã¯åŽå
¨ãĢä¸ãįŦãĢåããĻããã
ããžããŖãããäšãŖãĻãéģčģãŽåãčĩ°ãŖãĻãéģčģããč¸åã§äēēčēĢäēæ
čĩˇãããĻãã
ããæ¯ãäē¤ãããĢč¨ãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯ä¸å¸ãĢãäģæĨãžãããã¨æ¨æļããĻãããå¸ãĢåē§ãŖãã
ããĻãŖãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŽļãããåēå¤ãã¨æããžãããã
ååãŽä¸äēēããã¤ãã¤ããã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯įŦãŖãããéããã
ããĄããĢæĨãæ°é
ã¯ãĒãã
åå¨ãĢã¯æ°ãĨããĻããã¯ãã ããæĨãĒãããã¤ããĒãåŖ°ããããĻããã¯ããããĒããŽã¯ãæå¸ãŽãã¨ãããããâĻâĻīŧ
ä¸č
šãŽãããããæãŽæå
ã¸ãéģãįŗ¸ãŽãããĒããŽãåēããŖãĻãæå
ãįēããéããã
īŧäģããįĸēčĒããšããâĻâĻãããäģã¯įĄįã ãããããã¤īŧãæŧãĢã§ãâĻâĻīŧ
ãæ¤åˇãäŊčĒŋã¯å¤§ä¸å¤Ģãīŧã
é ä¸ããåŖ°ãããĻãæ¤åˇã¯čļŗãåŽãĢæĩŽããã
ããīŧãããã大ä¸å¤Ģãã§ãâĻâĻã
éĄãčĻãããĒããžãžįããã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯éŖãĢåē§ãŖãã
ãéĄã¯å¤§ä¸å¤ĢãŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻãĒããīŧãäŊãããŖãīŧã
ãĒãã§ããĒãã
æå¸ã¨ä¸ãįŦãäģãåãŖãĻããĻãããããĒãã
äŋēã¯ãŠããããĄããĩãããããĒãã
įĸįļãæŠãĢæĩŽããã č¨čããåŋčãᎠãäģãããããĒįãŋã¨ã¨ããĢãäŊãĢéåŋãæģããããĒåŽåŋæãããããããããĢæļããĻãåãŗåŋčã¯éŧåãæŠããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãã§ãããã§ããã
ããŊãĒã¨č¨ãŖãã
ããīŧãããããŋããĒãĢčãããŽãīŧã
ãčããã¨ããããčãããã¨ãããâĻâĻã
ããããããžããįĨãããĄããŖããããããĒããâĻâĻã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããĒãããããããĢįŦãŖãã
ãäŋēãããĸãããŧããããããããĒãããã ãæ¤åˇãŽãã¨ã§čŠąããĻãããčĒįļã¨ãĒâĻâĻã
ã᏿ã¯ãæå¸ãããĒãã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãããã
åŋčããįĩļæã¨ããéåã§æŊ°ããĻãããããĒæ°ãããã
ããšã¯ãŽä¸ã§ãä¸ãįŦããé ãæšãĢããåŗãŽæŗããæ˛éŗ´ãä¸ãããģãŠãããæĄãããĻããã
ãæŦåŊãĢãäģãåãŖãĻããã§ããīŧã
ãããžããŽæ°æãĄã¯åããããæ¤åˇãã§ããæå¸ãĄãããŽæ°æãĄãâĻâĻã
ãããåããčĻããĻããããžããīŧã
ååãĢåēãč¨čãĢãä¸ãįŦã¯įŽã丸ãããĻãæ¤åˇããããâĻâĻãã¨č¨ããããĢãĒãŖãããåŧãŖčžŧãããĢä¸ãįŦãŽįŽãčĻãã
ãããã¯ã§ããĒãããããããĢãæäēēååŖĢãŽããåããĒããĻãäēēãĢčĻãããããããĒãã ãã
ãæŦåŊãĢãäģãåãŖãĻããã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŋēãåãã¤ããĻããŖãĻæãŖãĻãīŧã
ãããã¯č¨ããžãããã§ããããĢããŖãĻæå¸ããã¨ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããããããäŋēãäģãžã§ããŠãã ãããžããåŠããã¨æãŖãĻããã ãæ¤åˇã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãåŋå¤ã ã¨ã§ãč¨ããããĢãåŖ°ã大ããããã
ããããĒįãããããããĒããĻããˇã§ãã¯ã ãããããããããããâĻâĻããžãããˇã§ãã¯ãĒãã ããĒãããæããĒãã¨čããããĒããģãŠâĻâĻæĒããŖããäŋēãæŗååãæŦ ããĻãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻãæ¤åˇãŽčŠãčģŊãåŠãã¨ãčĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãĻããŖãã
ããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãä¸ãįŦãĢãå¨å˛ãŽååãã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ããīŧããĒãŠã¨åŖ°ããããĻãããä¸ãįŦã¯ããåéĄãĒãããčŠŗããã¯č¨ããĒãããŠãæ¤åˇãčžããã ããããžãč˛ŦããĒãã§ãããĻãã¨įããčģŊãåŗæãä¸ããã
æå¸ã¨ä¸ãįŦãäģãåãŖãĻããâĻâĻæå¸ã¯ãäģããžã¨ãããĻãããã¨č¨ãŖãĻããããŠãĄãããåãã¤ããĻãããã¨ãĢãĒãããæå¸ããããĒåãã¤ãįįąã¯ãĒãããæ¨æĨ芹ããã¨ããŽåŖ°ã¨ããĒãĸãĢãĒčŗĒæã¯ãåã¨ã¯æããĒããŖããããããæå¸ã¯ããããĒåãã¤ããããĒäēēéã§ã¯ãĒãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãŠããĒãŽããããŽäŧį¤žãĢå ĨãŖãĻãããä¸įĒäģäēãæããĻãããäēēã§ãäŊåēĻãåŠããããĻãããå æĨãŽããšããã°ãŖãĻãããĻãå¨å˛ãããŽäŋĄé ŧãåããäēēæ°č ã¨ãč¨ããåå¨ããããĒäēēéãããããĒãããĢããŦããããĒåãã¤ãã ããããåãã¤ããĻããã¨ãããããĒããŽãããĢâĻâĻīŧ
ãäŋĄé ŧã§ãããŽã¯ãŠãŖãĄã īŧã
æ°´ä¸ãã莺ãä¸ããŖãĻãããããĢãč¨čãæĩŽããã ã
æå¸ãŽãã¨ã¯įĨãŖãĻãããåēäŧãŖãĻãããŽååš´ããããããŽãã¨ã芹ããĻãããä¸ãįŦã¯ãäģäēäģĨå¤ã§čŠąããã¨ã¯ãģã¨ããŠãĒããäŊåēĻãéŖ˛ãŋãĢčĄãŖããã¨ã¯ããããäģãŽäēēãããä¸ã§ãŽéŖ˛ãŋäŧã§ããããģãŠæˇąã芹ããããã¨ã¯ãĒãã
ããããã°ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãããĢæĨãåãåĨãŽé¨įŊ˛ãĢããã¨č¨ãŖãĻããããŠããŽé¨įŊ˛ã ãŖããâĻâĻ
ãâĻâĻã
ããŧããŧããĢįŊŽãããæã¯æĸãžãŖãĻãããããã¤ãŽéãĢãåŋčã¯åšŗæãĢæģããįĩčĢãåēãĻããã
æ¤åˇã¯ãæãåãããĒãããčããĻããã
ãŠãčĒŋãšããã
ããŽæšæŗãã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãåæ
-1-
SSRãŽå´ŠåŖã¯ãåĨ补įãĢå
ããĻããã
æŦäŊãä¸ãįŦã¨äŧ芹ããã¨ããåŧąãã¯ããŖãããSSRã¯æŠčŊããããããįŽãŽåŊãããĢãããŦãããĢã¯ãåąåĄãéããĻ垊æ§äŊæĨãĢããããäēčŖã¯čŖäŋŽããããããĢã¯ä¸é¨ãäģĨåãŽå§ŋãĢæģãŖãã
å´ŠåŖãčĻčļããĻåŖ°ããããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽæããĢåŧåŋããč ã¯ãģã¨ããŠãĒããSSRããžã åããã¨ãĢãå°ãããã¨ããĻããčĒåãĢãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯æ¯ãããããã
ããŦãããĢããã
æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšããåēãĻãããŦãããĢãčĻã¤ããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯čĩ°ãå¯ãŖãã
ãSSRãŽâĻâĻã
ãåããŖãã ããīŧãSSRãŽéčĻããã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãåããĻäŧãŖãã¨ãã¨åãããŧãŗã§č¨ãŖãã
ãįšãĢãäģãŽæŦäŊãĢã¯įĩļ寞ãĢåŋ
čĻã ã
ããããããããžãããã§ãå´ŠåŖãĢåããŖãĻãããã¨ãäēåŽã§ããįįąã¯ãããŽãžãžã§ã¯ããĄã ã¨ãæŦäŊãæ°ãĨãå§ããĻããããã§ãã
ãããã ã¨ããĻããããééãŖãĻããããŠããããã īŧã
ãééãŖãĻâĻâĻīŧãSSRãåŖããã¨ãã§ããīŧã
ãããã ãįžãĢãä¸ãįŦã¨ããįˇãŽäģļã§ãæŦäŊã¯æˇˇäšąããĻãããäģã¯äģäēãĢéä¸ããĻããããéãã ããįĩããã°ãžããčĩ°ãåããã¨ãĢãĒããäēįŽãæ¯æ¸ãããžãžã§ãĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãéĻãčģŊãåŗãĢåžããã
ãæŦäŊãä¸ãįŦãĢåãŖãĻããããŽã¯äŊããĒããčãããģãŠãčĒŋãšããģãŠãããŽäēåŽãä翏Ŧã¨ãŽčĒ¤åˇŽãåēããäēįŽã¯ãããĢæ¯æ¸ãããããŽã¨ãæŦäŊãåŽããŽã¯ãĒãã īŧã
ãä¸ãįŦãäŊãããĻãããŽããããŽäēåŽãããâĻâĻã
ãSSRãĢæąēãžãŖãĻãã ãããīŧīŧīŧã
æåŖ°ã¨å
ąãĢåãããããåēããããĒčĻįˇããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åĨĨæ¯ãĢåãå
ĨããĻåãæĸããã
ãä¸ãįŦãæĩãĢåããããĒãã¨ãããŖãããæŦäŊã¯ãããĒããæå¸ãŽãã¨ã¯ãããĒããä¸ãįŦãčĒŋãšãįįąããĒãã
ãæå¸ãŽãã¨ã¯ãããĒããŖãĻãåŊŧåĨŗã¨äģãåããã¨âĻâĻããŽæĒæĨã¯ãĒãã¨ãããã¨ã§ããīŧã
ãéãĢčãããããžãã¯ããã¨æããŽãīŧããããĒéæ
ãæãããŽãĢã
ãããŽâéæ
âãĢããįįąãããããããĒããã§ããīŧã
ãããããäģãããĒãã¨ã芹ãæéã¯ãĒãã
ããããããŽâéæ
âãSSRãŽéčĻæ§ãåčĒčããããããĒãã¨ã ãŖããĒãããããå
æããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã¨ãŽä¸ã¤ã§ãããSSRãŽéčĻæ§ã¯åãããžããããŠãããŖã¨é ŧãŖãĻã¯ããããĒãããŠããĒãĢéčĻã§ãããããæŦäŊãæģ
ãŧãä¸č¯åĩ樊ã§ãããã¨ã¯ééããĒããã âĻâĻīŧã
ããĒããåĨŊããĢãããããã
ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãããæããĒããããžããŽãããããããĢããã°ãããäģãŽæ°äēēã¨ä¸įˇãĢãĒãã ããããžãããĄãĢååããããŽã¯ãģã¨ããŠããĒãããŠãããæåŗããããžããĒãåããã ãīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãâĻâĻã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãéŧģã§įŦãŖãĻčĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãã°ãããäŋ¯ãããžãžãããĢįĢãŖãĻããããæãĢčŋãŖããããĢéĄãä¸ããĻãå¨å˛ãčĻåããã
åæ
ããååãæããã襨æ
ãåããĻããåąåĄããããããģã¨ããŠã¯įĄčĻããĻãčĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãĻããŖãã
åąå
ã¯éãžãčŋãŖãĻããã
åãããĒãããã§ã¯ãĒãããå
¨åąåĄãé§ãåēãããĻčĩ°ãåããããĒäēæ
ãĢã¯ãĒãŖãĻããĒãã
čĒå¸ãĢæģãŖãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãä¸åŋå°ããŽéæ§åãčĻãĻãããåšŗįŠãĢčĻããåąãåžãĢããĻãåĨŗįĨååēå ´ãĢåããŖãã
ãâĻâĻã
įĄæčãĢãåŗæã§éŧģãčĻããĒããåēå ´ãĢå
ĨãŖãããåĨŗįĨåã¯ãã§ãĢæ¤åģãããĻããĻãå°åē§ã ããæŽãŖãĻãããåŗæãä¸ããã¨ãããąãããããĩããŗãŗãåãŖãĻãåäēēãŽãŗããĨãããŖãĢããŖããããã
ããŠããåããåããŖãĻãããã¨ã ããŠâĻâĻã
äģãŽīŧåąããSSRãŽåžŠæ§ãæ¯æããĻãä¸ãįŦã¸ãŽå¯žåĻããģãŧåããããŖãšããŧãã ãã¯ãææžãã§æ¯æããĻããé°å˛æ°ã§ã¯ãĒããŖãã¨ãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯čŋããĻããããåąãŽã¨ããĻãŽæšéãĢæįžŠãåąããããŽã¯ãããĨãĢãŧãšã ãã ãŖããããã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãŠãããã°ãããŽãâĻâĻå
ˇäŊįãĒæšæŗãčãå§ããã¨ããããĨãĢãŧãšãããŖãĻããã
ãäģäēã¯å¤§ä¸å¤Ģīŧã
ãį§ãããĒããĻãåããŖãĻãããå¤ąį¤ŧã ããã
åŖãč¨ããžããããĨãĢãŧãšãčĻãĻããã¨ããĩã¨åŋãŽåãæããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯å°ãįãä¸ããĻãåŖå
ãįˇŠããã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšãčĻãĻãã¨ãå
æ°ãåēããã
ãããīŊīŧãããã¯ãŠãããæåŗīŧīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãéĄã严æã§æ¯ãããããĢããĻããããããŖãŊãįŦãŖãã
ãæˇąãæåŗã¯ãĒããããã ãåŠããŖãĻããŖãĻãã¨ã
ããĒīŊããããäģäēãŖãŊãč¨ãæšã ãã
åãŗåŖãč¨ããžããã
ãäģã¯ããããã¨ãčããĒãããããĒããã¨ãããããã
ããīŧããããäģäēãčŊãĄįãããâĻâĻã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšãæĨãĻããŽãã
ãĸãģãããããŖãĻããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯éĄãä¸ããã
ãããŖãģãŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãåŗæãä¸ããããããĢ大ãããčåžãĢæãæ¯ãŖãĻãčĻãã¨ãããĄã¯ããå°čĩ°ãã§åēå ´ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ããŋããĒãæĨãĻããããã ãĒã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯čģŊãįŦãŖãã
ãåŦãããã
ãããŽãžãžããããŠãŗããĄãĢäģģããĻãããããĢã¯ãããĒãã§ããīŧã
ãĸãģããã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãäģãåéĄãŽæŦčŗĒãĢæ°ãĨããĻããŽã¯ãåãã ãã ããã
ããĄã¯ããįļãã
ãããæããäŋēéãåããĒãããæŦäŊã¯ãã¨ãĢæģãŖãĻããžãâĻâĻã¤ãžããSSRãĢé ŧããããĢãĒããã§ãæŦäŊã¯ãSSRããŠããĒããŽããããæ°ãĨããĻãã
ãããã§ããäģãĢé ŧãããŽããĒããŖãĻãã¨ãããã ããä¸åŽåŽãĢãĒããããã
ãĸãģãããč¨čãįšãã ã
ããããĒã¨ããĒãŽãĢãä¸ãįŦãŖãĻããåéĄãããããīŊã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ããæ¯ãã¤ããã
ãæŦäŊãåĨå
¨ãĒæšåãĢåãããŽãĢåŋ
čĻãĒãã¨ã¯ãīŧã¤ããã¨æãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãä¸ã¤ã¯ãSSRãŽåŽå
¨åģæĸãäēã¤įŽã¯ãSSRãŽäģŖãããĢãĒãæ ãæãčĻã¤ãããã¨ãä¸ã¤įŽã¯ãä¸ãįŦãäŊããããã¨ããĻãããŽãįĸēčĒããĻ寞åĻãããã¨ãåã¤įŽã¯ãæå¸ãåŽããã¨ã
čĻįˇãåããã¨ãä¸äēēã¯é ˇããã
ãããããäŊããå§ãããīŧã
ããĄã¯ãã¯č
įĩãŋããĒããč¨ãŖãã
ãSSRãŽåŽå
¨åģæĸã¯ãããããããĒãã¨æããŽããĸãģãããč¨ãŖãããã§ãããŽãããĢã¯ãä¸ãįŦãĢ寞åĻããĻããããžã§ã ãŖããéããĻããã¨ããã§č¸ãŋã¨ãŠãžããĒãã¨ãããĒããããã¯å¤§å¤ãĒč˛ čˇã§ãäēįŽãããããåŋ
čĻãã§ãããĒãã¨ãããĒããâĻâĻã
ãããããĒäēįŽããä¸ãįŦã¸ãŽå¯žåĻãĢåããŖãĻãã¨ã ãĒã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã
ãåã¯ãã§ããéãä翏ŦãŽæšåãčĒŋæ´ããĻãŋãã
ããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãã
ãäģãžã§ã¨ã¯éãããŋãŧãŗãŽä翏ŦâĻâĻããããčĒŦåžåãæãŖãĻäŊãããã
ããŠãĒã¨čĻįˇãåããã¨ãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãã¤ãĒã¨ããã
ãį§ãŽæ
å ąãé ŧããŖãĻãã¨ã ãã
ããããé ŧããĢããĻãã
ããĒããąãŧããžãããĻīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯čĻĒæãä¸ãĢããĻããĻãŖãŗã¯ããã
ãäŋēéã ããããåŽå
¨ãĢå¤ãããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãã ãããæĩããäŊããã ãåąã¨ããĻããŖãĄå´ãĢåããããĢã
-2-
åŽæãã30åãģãŠãéããĻãä¸ãįŦã¯ãäģæĨã¯į¨äēãããããã¨ãå
ãĢ帰ãŖãĻããŖããæ¤åˇã¯ããããĢ30ååž
ãŖãĻãããããį˛ãæ§ã§ããã¨å¸ãįĢãŖãĻããĒããŖãšãåēãã
ä¸ãįŦãäģĨåããé¨įŊ˛ãĢéˇãããäēēãĢéŖįĩĄãã¨ãŖãĻã芹ãčããã¨ããã¨ããã᏿ã¯č¨čãæŋããããæ¤åˇãäģãŽįļæŗã芹ãã¨ãäģäēãįĩããŖãĻãããå¤ã§ãĒãã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãæ¤åˇããīŧã
äŧį¤žãŽå¤ãĢåēãĻããšãããčĻãĒãããã§ããã§ãããĻããã¨ãåŖ°ãããããããæ¯ãčŋãŖãčĻįˇãŽå
ãĢããã40äģŖããããŽįˇã¨įŽãåãŖãĻããåŽæ°¸ãããã§ããīŧãåļæĨæ¯æ´åޤãŽâĻâĻãæ¤åˇã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããããã§įĢãĄčŠąããĒãã§ããããå ´æãå¤ããžãããã
åŽæ°¸ã¯å°åŖ°ã§č¨ãŖãĻãããæ°ãĒãå¨å˛ãčĻãĻãããčļŗãåããããéģãŖãĻäģããĻããã¨ãé§
ãŽå寞å´ãäŧį¤žãã10åãģãŠéĸããå ´æãĢãããåå°ä¸ãŽåą
é
åąãĢå
ĨãŖãã
åäēēåēãããã叿°ã¯ããŧããĢå¸ãåãããĻ15å¸ã
ããããĒãåŽåŋã ããã
åŽæ°¸ã¯čģŊãįŦãŖãĻããĢãĻãŗãŋãŧå¸ãĢåē§ãŖããæ¤åˇãéŖãĢåē§ããããŧãĢãæŗ¨æããĻã°ãŠãšãåãããã¨ãåŽæ°¸ã¯åŖãéããã
ãããŽã¨ãã¯ããĢã§ããĒããŖããŽã¯ãããŖãąãåéĄã ãŖããã ã
ãä¸ãįŦããããã§ããīŧã
ãããã
ãäŊãããŖããã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäēēãæŽēããã
åŽæ°¸ããįēããããč¨čãĢãæ¤åˇã¯ãĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãĢįŊŽãããæããã¯ãĒã¨ãããĻãéĄãåŧãæŖãããã
ããããããâĻâĻīŧã
åčĢã§ããã¨ããæ¤åˇãŽčĄ¨æ
ããåŽæ°¸ã¯įéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãããžãžåãæĸããéĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãã
ãããĄãããį´æĨįãĢãããããããããĒãã
ããããâĻâĻã
ãčĒæŽēãĢčŋŊãčžŧãã ãã ãåŧãļãããĢããĻã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ããŧãĢã䏿°ãĢåˇãŖãã
ããããĒâĻâĻããããĒãã§ããããžã§âĻâĻã
ãåã¯ãä¸ãįŦãŽæãããâĻâĻãĸã¤ãããŠãã ãįãŖãĻããåããŖãĻããĒãããããåã ããããĒããããĄãŽä¸ãåããŖãĻãĒããé¨įŊ˛į°åãä¸ãįŦãŽææĄãĢäšãŖãã ãã ãã
ãæããĻãã ãããäŊãããŖããŽãã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ãčŋŊå æŗ¨æããããŧãĢãįŊŽãããã¨åæãĢååãģãŠéŖ˛ãã§ã芹ãå§ããã
ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãäēåš´å°ãåãĢããĄãŽé¨įŊ˛ãĢæĨããåčˇã¯ãĒãã ãŖããåŋããããŠãčģĸčˇããĻãããã ãããŽä¸ãįŦãįŽãäģãããŽããæģåŖãŖãĻãããä¸ãįŦãŽä¸ãļæåãĢäģé¨įŊ˛ããį°åããĻããįˇã ãŖãã
ãįŽãäģããâĻâĻīŧã
ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãįãŖãĻããã ãâĻâĻãåŽæ°¸ã¯č¨ãŖãããčǰãäŋĄããĒãããŠãĒã
ãããŽãæģåŖããã¨ããäēēã¯ããŠããĒãŖããã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãæģãã ãã
åŽæ°¸ãåããããĢč¨ãã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯čãŽãããããã¯ãĒã¨ããã
ãæģãã ããŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãčĒæŽēãããã ãã§ãäŋēã¯ãä¸ãįŦãæŽēããã¨æãŖãĻãã
ãæŽēããŖãĻããžãããããĒâĻâĻã
ãį´æĨãããĒããããäģåãããããã ã¨æãã
ããããĒãã¨ã§ãããã§ããīŧã
č¨ããĒãããæ¤åˇã¯äģĨåčĒãã äēäģļãŽč¨äēãĢã¤ããĻæãåēããĻãčēĢéããããããŗãˇã§ãŗãĢįŖįĻãããååą
äēēååŖĢã§čåž
ããæŽēäēēãžã§čĄãããäēäģļâĻâĻã§ããããã¯å¯åޤã§éˇæéãĢæ¸Ąããã¤ãŗããŗãŗãããŧãĢãĢããããŽã ãŖããä¸ãįŦã¯äŧį¤žã§ãįŦŦä¸č
ãčĻãĻããåã§čĒæŽēãĢčĒå°ããâĻâĻīŧ
ãä¸ãįŦã¨æģåŖã¯ãäģ˛ãč¯ããŖããäēäēēã¨ãäģäēãã§ãããŖãĻãããŽãããããŠãæģåŖã¯ã¨ããĢãå¨å˛ããæ
ãããé ŧããĢãããĻããããŠãããžããĢãé ŧãããã°ããŦããˇãŖãŧãĢããããæģåŖã¯äēēãč¯ããĻãčžããĻãčžããŖãĻč¨ããĒããŋã¤ãã ãŖããããããĒæģåŖãŽæ°æãĄãæžãŖãĻããŠããŧããĻãããŽããä¸ãįŦã ãŖãã
ãä¸äēēã§æąãčžŧãã§ããžãæģåŖãããŽæ°æãĄãæžãŖãĻãæ¯ããâĻâĻīŧã
ããããĒã¨ããã ã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ãä翝įŽãŽããŧãĢãéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ãã䏿¯įŽãæŗ¨æããĻããįļãããéĄã¯čĩ¤ããĒãŖãĻããĻããããåŖčĒŋã¯ããããĒããĻããã
ãæģåŖã¯ããããĒä¸ãįŦãäŋĄé ŧãããäģäēãŽéĸã§ãé ŧããĢãĒãŖãããããããĒãããŠããŧãããžããäēēãå°ãŖãĻããã¨ããĢåŖ°ããããĻãåŋ
čĻãããĒãã¨ãã¯ãäŊãããĒãããããĒéĸäŋããå¨å˛ãæãåãŖãĻãé ŧããĢããĻãããã ãäŋēããįž¨ãžããã¨æãŖãããäēäēēãŽéĸäŋãã
ãããããŠãããĻãčĒæŽēãĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãããããĒããã ãŖãĻå§ãžãããããããããĒãããããĒãã¨åãããĒããããéããĢãã§ãįåŽãĢãä¸ãįŦã¯å§ãããã ã¨æãã
ãäŊãã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãæģåŖã¨ããäēēéãŽäŋĄé ŧãå´Šããã¨ã ã
ãå¨å˛ãããŽäŋĄé ŧãīŧã
ããããä¸ãįŦã¯ãæģåŖã¨ããéŖ˛ãŋãĢčĄãŖãĻãĻãããŽããĄãé¨įŊ˛ãŽãĄãŗããŧãĢãããĒãã¨ãč¨ããããĢãĒãŖããâ åŽæ°¸ããã¯ãåŽĸãĢ寞ããčĒ åŽããčļŗããĒãããããĄãĒãã ããĒâã
ããŠããããã¨ã§ããīŧã
ãäŋēãŽãã¨ã ããããĒããäģãŽãĄãŗããŧãŽãã¨ããâââã ããããĄã âã¨æį´ãŖãĻããã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯åŽæįãĢåŖãĢãããæģåŖãããč¨ãŖãĻããã¨ãįļããĻãâæģåŖã¯åĒããããč¨ãããĢããããŠãä¸äēēã§æąãčžŧãã§čžããã ã¨æãâããŋãããĒãã¨ãč¨ããã ãã§ããæŦåŊã¯ãããããĒããäŋēã¯ãæģåŖããããããĒãå§ããé ãæŦäēēããčãããã ã
ãä¸ãįŦãããč¨ãŖããã¨ãĢã¤ããĻã§ããīŧã
ãæģåŖã¯ãįĸēããĢäģãŽãĄãŗããŧãŽãã¨ã芹ããĻããã§ããâåŽæ°¸ããã¯ãčĒ åŽããäŧ¸ã°ãã°ãããŖã¨éĄ§åŽĸããäŋĄé ŧãããã¨æããã ãâã¨ããããĒãĩããĢč¨ãŖãĻããããã ãäģãŽãĄãŗããŧãŽãã¨ããããĄã ãĒããĻč¨ãŖãĻãĒããããããã°ããŖã¨č¯ããĒãã¨č¨ãŖãĻããã ã
ãä¸ãįŦããã¯ãããæĒããĻããŋããĒãĢäŧããĻããã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãããã ãäŋēéã¯ãæģåŖãä¸įĒäŋĄé ŧããĻããä¸ãįŦãŽč¨čã ãããäŋĄããĻããžãŖããé
ãŽå¸ã§ãŽãã¨ã ããæŦéŗãåēããããã ããã¨ãåæãĢčŖčļŗããĻãĒã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ã忝įŽãŽããŧãĢãåŖãĢã¤ããã
ãčǰãįĸēčĒããĒããŖããã§ããīŧãæŦåŊãĢãããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖããŽããŖãĻã
æ¤åˇãčãã¨ãåŽæ°¸ã¯ä¸įŦįŽã大ããããĻãčĻįŦãããã
ãããĒããŖãããäŋēããäēåŽã ããã¨æãŖãĻãããããįĸēčĒããĻããããĒãã¨č¨ãŖãĻãĒãã¨č¨ãããããä¸ãįŦãĢããä¸åēĻįĸēčĒããĒãããĒããĒãããããããããĢãąã§äēäēēãŽäģ˛ããŽã¯ãˇãŖã¯ããããéĸåã ãīŧãæŦåŊãĢč¨ãŖããč¨ãŖãĻãĒãããåãããĒããã
ãä¸ãįŦããã¯ããããžã§č¨įŽããĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŋēã¯ããæãŖãĻãã
ããŽã¨ããŽįŠēæ°ãæŗåããĻãæ¤åˇã¯æĨãĢéŖæŦ˛ããĒããĒãŖãã坿°ãããĻãæãã严č
ãåããĻéããæããã
ãŋãŧã˛ããã¨ãŽéãĢäŋĄé ŧãį¯ããå¨å˛ãĢįåŋĩãæ¤ãäģããâĻâĻæå¸ã¨ãŽãã¨ããå¨å˛ãĢããŽãã¨ã芹ããĻãããŽããį ´æģ
ã¸ãŽį¨Žãæãå§ããã¨ãããã¨ã ã¨ãããâĻâĻ
ãįãããĻããŽã¯ãäŋēãæå¸âĻâĻãããæå¸ã¨ãŽéãĢäŋĄé ŧéĸäŋã¯ãĒãããâĻâĻã
ã大ä¸å¤Ģãīŧã
åŽæ°¸ãŽåŖ°ã§ãæ¤åˇã¯čˇŗãããããĢčŠãä¸ããĻãåããããĢãĒãŖãããŧãĢã°ãŠãšã严æã§æ¯ããã
ãããŋãžããã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ãã
įŦãŖãĻãŋããããåŋčã¯æŠéãæãŖãĻãããããŧãēãŽä¸åããå
ĨããĒããģãŠį¸Žãã čãįãã
ãããŽãã¨ã¯âĻâĻīŧã
ããīŧãããâĻâĻããŽãã¨ã¯ãåžã
ãĢé¨įŊ˛ãŽįŠēæ°ãæŋãŖãĻããŖãã襨éĸįãĢã¯įļēéēãĒãŽãĢããŠãããããâĻâĻäŊããč
ãŖãããĒã¤ãŋãããĒâĻâĻãããĒįŠēæ°ã ãŖãã
ããæĨãæģåŖã¯įŠēæ°ãŽæŋããĢæ°ãĨããĻããĄãŗããŧãŽä¸äēēã¨ã¨ãŦããŧãŋãŧã§ä¸įˇãĢãĒãŖãã¨ããĢčããããĒããæčŋâĻâĻãŖãĻæãã§ãããã§ãä¸ãįŦãåå ã ãŖããã¨ãåããŖãã
ä¸įŦãéŧģč
ãĢč
ãŖããããĒããĒã¤ãæ ããæ°ããããã¯ã¤ãŗãéŖ˛ãžãĒããĒãŖããããĢãąãéããįŦéãŽæŦ éĨčãŽãããĒâĻâĻ
ãæŦåŊãĢ大ä¸å¤Ģãīŧã
åŽæ°¸ãŽč¨čã§æãĢčŋããåŧąãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯įļããäŋããã
ãæģåŖã¯ããŠããããã¨ãĒãŽãã¨ãä¸ãįŦãåŧãŗåēããããŠãä¸ãįŦã¯äēäēēã§čŠąããã¨ãæåĻããĻãäģãŽãĄãŗããŧãããå ´æã§ãâãŋããĒãŽãããĢč¨ãåŋ
čĻãããã¨æãŖããã ãåéĄããããĒãæšåããĻãããŖããģããããããäŊč¨ãĒãã¨ããĄããŖããŽããäŋēâĻâĻâãããĒãĩããĢč¨ãŖãĻãããâé
ãŽå¸ã ãŖãããčĻããĻãĒããããããĒãããŠâĻâĻâã¨äģãå ããã
ãæģåŖããã¯æããĒããŖããã§ããīŧããããĒãĩããĢč¨ãããĻã
ãæãŖãããæŽæŽĩįŠãããĒã ããĢããŋããĒããã¯ãĒãããããŠããã¯äŋēéãĢã¯ãé ããĻãããĻãģãããŖããã¨ãããŠããããã¨ãĢ寞ããæããĢčĻãããã ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãŋããĒãŽãããĢåããĻããŽãĢãæģåŖã¯äŋčēĢãĢčĩ°ãŖãĻããâĻâĻãããĒãĩããĢãĒã
čĒįļãĒåŊĸã§å¨å˛ãåŗæšãĢã¤ããĻãč˛ļããâĻâĻæģåŖã᏿ãäŋĄé ŧããĻããã ããĢããˇã§ãã¯ã¯å¤§ãããĻãåãå
ĨããããĒãâĻâĻãĒãä¸ãįŦããããĒãã¨ãīŧãæ¨æĨãæå¸ã¨čŠąãããã¨ãĢæĩŽããã įåããããŽã¨ããŽæģåŖãŽčŗå
ãĢãæĩŽããã§ãããŽããããããã¨åããŖãĻãæ¤åˇã¯é ŦãåŧãæŖãããã
ãããŽãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¨æģåŖãŽéã§äŊãããŖããŽããåãããĒãã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ã忝įŽãŽããŧãĢãéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ããĻãã´ãŗãŖã¨ããéŗãįĢãĻãĻã¸ã§ãããįŊŽããã
ãæģåŖã¯å°ããã¤ãäŊčĒŋãå´ŠããĻããŖããįŽãŽä¸ãĢã¯ã¯ããã§ããĻãäģäēãŽããšãå¤ããĒãŖãããã¤ãŽéãĢããé¨įŊ˛ã§ä¸įĒäģäēãã§ãããŽã¯ä¸ãįŦãĢãĒãŖãĻããäŧãŋããĄãĢãĒãŖãĻããŖãæģåŖã¯ãä¸éąééŖįļã§äŧãã§ãããŽãžãžéčˇãããã ããã¨æãŖãĻããįĸå
ãé¨įŊ˛ãĢä¸éãŽæį´ãåąããã
ãæį´âĻâĻīŧã
ãé¨įŊ˛å
¨åĄããé
ˇãįŽã§čĻãããĻãįããĻãããĒããäģæĨãããŖãĻãäēēįãįĩããããâĻâĻããŽä¸ãĢãæģåŖãŽįŊ˛åãããŖãã
ãæŦåŊãĢãããŽæĨãĢâĻâĻīŧã
ãæį´ãåēããæĨãĢãčĒæŽēããĻãããããäŋēéã¯åŊįļãéŠãããããŠããäģĨä¸ãĢâĻâĻã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ããĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãĢįŊŽããåŗæãæĄãŖãã
ãäŋēéãŽåŋãĢã¯ãæģåŖãčŋŊãčžŧãã ãŽã¯čĒåããĄãããĒãããŖãĻæ°æãĄãįãžãããäģã§ãããŠãĻããŽãããĢæąããĻãåĨ´ãããããčžããĻããžãŖãåĨ´ãããã
ãä¸ãįŦããã¯ãããããį°åãâĻâĻīŧã
ãæģåŖãŽãã¨ã¯ãčĒåãĢč˛ŦäģģããããããããĒããããį°åãããĻãģããâĻâĻä¸å¸ãčĒŦåžããĻãåãŽé¨įŊ˛ãĢį§ģãŖãã
ãæģåŖãããäŊčĒŋãå´Šãå§ããĻããčĒæŽēãããžã§ãŽéãĢäŊãããŖããŽãã¯ãčǰãâĻâĻīŧã
åŽæ°¸ã¯å°ããé ˇããã
ãæģåŖã¨ãŽããåãã¯æŽãŖãĻãããŠãä¸ãįŦãčĒæŽēãĢčŋŊãčžŧãã ã¨č¨ããč¨ŧæ ã¯ãĒãããããĢâĻâĻã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŋēãŽč¨ãŖãĻããã¨âĻâĻäŋēãŽč¨æļã¯ãæŦåŊãĢæŖãããŽããŖãĻæãã¨ãããããã âĻâĻã
ããŠãããæåŗã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäģãŽčŠąã¯ãäŋēãčĻãĻãããã¨ã¨ãæģåŖããčããããã¤ããŽãã¨ãįĩãŋåãããĻ芹ããã ãã ãé˛éŗããŧãŋãĒããĻããŽãããããã§ããĒããã ãããããããããä¸ãįŦã¯ãæŦåŊãĢäŊãæĒããĒããŽãããããĒãâĻâĻãããĒãĩããĢæãŖãĻããžããã¨ããããã ã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ãīŧæ¯įŽãŽããŧãĢãéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ããĻãé ãæąããĻãããæŗŖããĻããã
äģãŽčŠąãčãéããä¸ãįŦã¯į´æĨäŊããããããã§ã¯ãĒããæģåŖãčŋŊã芰ãããŽã¯ãä¸ãįŦäģĨå¤ãŽäēēéã ãŖãã¨ãåãããä¸ãįŦã¯äģæããäŊããæįĩįãĢæģåŖãčĒæŽēãããžã§čĒå°ããâĻâĻ
æ¤åˇã¯ãčģĸčˇãããĻã§ä¸åŽã ãŖãã¨ããããæå¸ãĢ寞ããã¤ããžã¨ããžã§ãŽãã¨ãæãåēããĻãčĻčĻãå°ãįããĒãŖãæ°ãããĻããĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãæ´ããããĢæãįŊŽããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ããŖã¨čĻĒåã ãŖãããããããšãĻãč¨įŽã ãŖãã¨ãããâĻâĻīŧãįįąã¯åãããĒãããæŦĄãŽãŋãŧã˛ãããĢæ¤åˇãé¸ãŗãä¸ãããããįĩããĻåãåēããâĻâĻãããæå¸ãĢ寞ãããã¨ã§ãããäŊãäēåŽãĒãŽãåãããĒããããĢæˇˇäšąãããĢããĻããã¨ãããâĻâĻ
æģåŖã¨åããããĒįĩæĢãĢčĒå°ãããã¨ããĻãããĒãããĒãã¨ãããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã§ããĒãã§ãããĒãã¨ãããīŧããŠãããĻâĻâĻ
ãããŽãåŽæ°¸ããã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ãåŋããäģŖãããĢæ¤åˇãĢéĄãåããã
ãä¸ãįŦã¯ããŠãããĻãããĒãã¨ããããã§ããīŧãäēēãčĒæŽēãĢãžã§čŋŊãčžŧãã§ãä¸äŊãĒãĢãâĻâĻã
ããĸã¤ãã¯é ããããããã âĻâĻãåŽæ°¸ã¯č¨ãŖããããčŋãĨããĒããģãããããããäģĨå¤ãĢããĸã¤ãããčēĢãåŽãæšæŗã¯ãĒãã
čˇéĸãįŊŽãâĻâĻįĸēããĢãããæŖãããããĢæãããããŽãžãžäŊãããĒããã°ãæģåŖã¨åãéåŊãčžŋããããããĒããäģäēãĒããžãčĻã¤ããã°ãããæģãŦããã¯âĻâĻ
įĻįšãå¤ąãŖãĻæēããã§ããįŽããæĸãžãŖãã
æå¸ãããŽããŖããã§ãâä¸ãįŦâã¨ããæåãčĻããĻããšãããæãĢåãŖãã
ãä¸ãįŦãé§
ãĢããã
ãšãããæã¤æãéããã
čˇéĸãįŊŽãã°ãããããããĒããã§ãããããããæå¸ã¯âĻâĻ
ãããâĻâĻīŧã
įĒįļåŖ°ãä¸ãããŽã§ãåŽæ°¸ã¯čŠããã¯ãŗã¨ãããĻæ¤åˇãčĻãã
ãããŋãžããã帰ããžããäģæĨã¯ãããã¨ãããããžããããããžã§ãŽãäģŖã¯æãŖãĻãããžãã
ããããããã¯âĻâĻã
ã貴éãĒã芹ãčãããĻãããŖããį¤ŧã§ãã
æ¤åˇã¯ãéããæããĻč¨ãã¨ãäŧč¨ãæ¸ãžããĻåēãåēãã
ãããããããŖãĄãĢčĄããã
æ¤åˇã¯ãé§
ãĢåãããĒããããŖãããčŋããã
æå¸ãŽåŽļãĢčĄãŖããã¨ãããããã§ã¯ãĒãããæå¯ãé§
ã¯åããã
æå¸ã¯ãåŽļã¨ã¯å寞å´ãĢãããšãŧããŧãŽä¸ãĢããããããæ¤åˇã¯é§
ãĢįãã¨ãčĻįˇã ããåãããĻä¸ãįŦãįĸēčĒããĻãæå¸ãŽåŽļãããæšãĢåēãĻããããããã¨åãŖãĻãšãŧããŧãĢåããŖãã
ãæ¤åˇããâĻâĻīŧã
ããŖããããĒããéčåŖ˛ãå ´ãĢčĄãã¨ãæå¸ãå°čĩ°ãã§čŋãĨããĻããã
ããããããæĨãĻãããŖãĄããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãåŊããåã ãããĒããĢãæ°ãĢãããã¨ãĒãã
æ¤åˇãåŧąãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã¨ãæå¸ã¯åžŽįŦãŋãčŋãããį´ä¸ãļæãļããĢčĻãæå¸ã¯ãå°ãįŠãããããĢčĻãããéããæãããããĢãåˇĻč
ãŽčãĢįŊŽãããĻããåŗæãč§Ŗãããå°ãæŊ¤ãã įŗãåããĻããæå¸ãĢãæ¤åˇã¯åŋčããããŗã¨ããã
ãä¸ãįŦã¯âĻâĻīŧã
ãé§
ã§čĻãĻããã¯ãčĻãĻãĒãããããããããäŧŧãĻãäēēã ãŖããŽãããããĒãããŠâĻâĻã
ãæå¸ãããŽč¨ãéãã ãŖãâĻâĻã
ããâĻâĻīŧã
åŽæ°¸ããčãã芹ãäŧããã¨ãæå¸ã¯éĄãéãããĻãéĄãéãããĻãã
ãããĄã ãããããĒãŽãäŧį¤žãčžããĻãåĨãŽäŧį¤žãĢį§ģãŖããģãããããįĩļ寞ããããšãã ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŋēãããæããã§ããããã§įĩãããĒããŖããâĻâĻã
ããŠããããã¨âĻâĻīŧã
ãæå¸ãããäģæĨã¯ããŽããã帰ãããåŽļãžã§éããâĻâĻäŋēã¯ãčĒŋãšãããã¨ãããããã
ãäŊãããæ°ãĒãŽâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŊããããâĻâĻããã¯ãžã åãããĒãããžãã¯čĒŋãšãã
æå¸ãåŽļãžã§éãã¨ãæ¸įˇ ãã¯ããŖããããĻããåŽæįãĢããŖããããããã¨äŧããĻãæãæ¯ãŖãã
ãįĩļ寞ãįĄčļã¯ããĒãã§âĻâĻã
æ¤åˇãčä¸ãåããããã¨ãæå¸ã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããéĄãã ããâĻâĻã
åŖ°ãéãããįŽãĢã¯æļãæĩŽããã§ããã
ãåããŖãĻãã
åŖ°ãããããã
ããŋä¸ããããŽãæããĻãåãĢåēããããč
ãåŧãŖčžŧããĻãæŗãæĄãŖãã
ãããäģĨä¸ãæå¸ãããæãæããããĒããããĢããããã
įĩãåēããč¨čãĢãčĒŦåžåã¯ãĒããŖããįŦããããéĄãåŧãæŖãŖãĻãããŽã¯åããã
ãĒããĻæ
ããĒãäēēéãĒãã ããã
åĨŊããĒäēēãĢåĨŊãã¨č¨ããã¨ããåŽããã¨ãã§ããĒãâĻâĻ
ããããããĒããŽã ãããŖã¨ããã ãŖããäģæ´éŠããã¨ãĒããĻâĻâĻ
ããžããéŖįĩĄãããã
äģčžŧããããã ããŽåĒãããããšãĻ芰ãčžŧãã č¨čãæ¸ĄããĻãæ¤åˇã¯åŽļãĢ帰ãŖãã
-3-
ããĨãĸãŗãšããĄãŽæãã¨ã¯čŖč šãĢãåąå ã¯ãŦãããĢããĄããããŠãŗåĸãåŽæ¨ŠãæĄãįļããĻãããSSRå´ŠåŖãŽåąæŠããããĢã¯ããŽåŽæ ãæãããĢãĒãŖãĻãããģã¨ããŠãŽåąåĄã¯ãåŋ čĻãĒãã¨ã ãã¨čããããĨãĸãŗãšããĄãĢčŗåãããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖããããããããĒãã¨ãčããäŊčŖããĒãã¨ãããŽãæŦåŊãŽã¨ãããããããĒãã
ä¸ãįŦã¨ããįˇãŽæŖäŊãæãããĢãĒããĢã¤ããæŦäŊã¯é˛čĄãåŧˇåããåãŗSSRãĢé ŧãå§ããããŦãããĢã¯åžŠæ§ãĢåãå Ĩããåąå ãäģĨåãŽįļæ ãĢæģããã¨ããĻããã
ãããå æ¸čĒããããŠãã ãæ°äēēã
čĒåãŽããšã¯ã§įéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããĻããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽåãĢããŦãããĢãæŠããĻããã
ãäģãŽããŽįļæŗãĢ寞åĻãããĢã¯ãSSRãåŋ
čĻã ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãčããã ãīŧãæŦäŊã寞åĻã§ãã᏿ãããĒãã
ãã ããéããã¨ããããããã¨ã§ããīŧãčĒåãĢã¯įĄįã ãŖãã¨ããããĒåã¯ãĒãããããããĒãã¨ãéãããŖãĻãã¨ã§ããīŧã
ãæŦäŊãčˇéĸãįŊŽãã°ãæå¸ãŖãĻåãĢ寞ããåĢããããįĩããããããä¸įĒããããæšã ã¨æããĒããŽãīŧã
ãčˇéĸãįŊŽãã°æå¸ãåŠããâĻâĻããŽæ šæ ã¯īŧã
ãããããããŧãŋãããį¤ēããĻããä¸ãįŦã¨ããįˇãŽæ§čŗĒã¨æŦäŊãŽčŊåãčããã°ãåŊįļãŽå¸°įĩã ããã
ãããæå¸ãĢäŊãããŖãããæŦäŊã¯ä¸įæļããĒãåˇãč˛ ããã¨ãĢãĒãããããæŖãããã§ããīŧã
ãæŦäŊããŠãčļŗæģããã¨ããã§ãããæå¸ã¨ããŖã¤ããã¨ã¯ãĒãããžãããã¤ãããŖããŽæå¸ã¨ãŽããåããåŋããããã§ããããžãīŧã
ãä¸ããŖãĻããããŧãŋã¯âĻâĻã
ãäŋĄį¨ã§ããĒãã¨ããã¤ãããīŧããŦãããĢã¯éĄããã¯ãĒã¨ãããããããŧãŋãåŊé ãããĻããã¨ãããč¨ããããŽãīŧãæŦåŊã¯éãã¨īŧã
ãããŽå¯čŊæ§ãããã¨âĻâĻã
ãããå æ¸ãĢããīŧīŧīŧã
é¨åąä¸ãĢéŋããģãŠãŽåĸãã§ããŦãããĢã¯ããšã¯ãåŠããã
å
¨åĄãåããæĸããĻãäēäēēãĢčĻįˇãéããĻããã
ãäŋēããˇã§ãŧãããã¤ãŗãã¨ããŖãšããŧãâĻâĻäģãååąãåãäģåãŖãĻããč
ã¯ãããŖã¨æŦäŊãåŽãŖãĻãããįããĻãããããĢåŋ
čĻãĒããŽãäŊãã忍鏿ããĻãããä¸åš´åãŽããŠããĢã§ãâĻâĻã
ãåãĢããŖãšããŧããããč¨ãŖãĻãžããããä¸åš´åãĢããŖããäŊãããŖããã§ããīŧããããæå¸ãŽåĨŊæãåãåããĒãįįąã§ããīŧã
ãäģã¯ãããĒ芹ãããĻãã¨ãã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãŦãããĢã¯čĻįˇãé¸ãããã
ããĒãããŽčŠąãéŋãããŽãâĻâĻãããåŋ
ãįĒãæĸããžãããŠãããŽåãĢ寞åĻããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã¨ããããŽã¯åæã§ããã§ããSSRãäŊŋããã¨ãĢã¯å寞ã§ããããã¯åŋ
ãåžæãįãã¨ãäŋēã¯æããžãã
ãäŊãæ šæ ãĢâĻâĻã
ãæ šæ ãĒããããžããã
å
¨åĄãŽčĻįˇããããļã¤ããŧãēãŽå
ĨåŖãĢæŗ¨ãããã
ããããããĒãĢæŗ¨įŽãããã¨ããĄããŖã¨âĻâĻã
ãããåŖ°ãŽããĄã¯ããæãŖãĻããåįãåŗæã§åãã¨ãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãēãĢãēãĢã¨æŠããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšãŽéŖãĢįĢãŖããããĄã¯ããå°čĩ°ãã§čŋãĨãã
ãčǰãŽč¨ąå¯ãåžãĻãããĢããīŧãæ°äēēã
ãŦãããĢãį¨ãã
ããããããčĻãĻããããčĻãĻããæå¸ã¨æŦäŊãããŖã¤ããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãĻč¨ãåããīŧã
ããã¯æ°ååãæ¤åˇãæå¸ãŽåŽļãŽåã§čŠąããĻããã¨ããŽįģåã§ããžãŖãããĢæ¤åˇãčĻã¤ããæå¸ãŽéĄãæ ãŖãĻããã
ãæŋĄããįŗãéããĻãåãä¸ããŖã῝ã¨ãˇã¯ãåŖ°ãŽããŧãŗã¨æēãããč¨čããŠããåãŖãĻããæå¸ã¯æŦæ°ã§æŦäŊãåŋé
ããĻããŽãåãããä¸ãįŦãäģããžã¨ãŖãĻãããŽã¯æŦäŊãŽãããŖãĻæãŖãĻãããã ããŠãåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŋé
ã¯æŦæ°ã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ããĻã¨ãšãããŧããããããĢåįãåēããĻããŦãŗãŧããŧãĢé˛éŗããéŗåŖ°ãåįããã
ãããããä翏Ŧã§ãããã¨ã¯ãããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãããæå¸ããã¯æŦäŊãĢåĨŊæãæãŖãĻããã¨ãããã¨ã§ããæŦäŊæŦĄįŦŦã§ã¯ãããžãããäēäēēãįĩã°ããå¯čŊæ§ã¯ååãĢãããžãã
ãããĢããĻãããŦãããĢã¯éŧģã§įŦãŖãããįĨããĒãäģ˛ãããĒãããããã ãĒãåéãŋãããĒããŽã ãããã¤ãäŊãåąéēãĒãã¨ãčããĻãããã ããåŋé
ãããŖãĻã ãã ããããããįˇåĨŗéãŽåĨŊæã¨ãããŽã¯ãéŊåãŽč¯ãä翏ŦãĢéããĒãããããĒããŽã¯æŦäŊãåˇã¤ããã ãã ã
ããĒããããžã§é ãĒãĒãã§ããīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããåĨŊæãŽå¯čŊæ§ãčãããŖãĻãããŽã§ã¯īŧã
ãããŽå
ããĒå¯čŊæ§ãééãŖãĻããã¨ããæŦäŊã¯æˇąãåˇã¤ããã¨ãĢãĒãããããĒå¯čŊæ§ãäŋĄããĻčĄåãããããĒäēįŽã¯ãĒãã
ãã ããSSRãĢé ŧããŖãĻãããŽãīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããŦãããĢãį¨ãã ã
ããĒãã ããŽįŽã¯īŧããããļãã¨åĨŊæĻįãĒįŽã ãĒããããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãčĒåãĢã¯ãŠããããããĒãã¨čĢĻããĻãä¸ãįŦã¨čˇéĸãįŊŽããĻãæå¸ãŽåĨŊæãããéããâĻâĻããã¯ãããããããŠãŗãčããâåŽåŽæĻįĨâãĒãŽãããããĒãããŠãããã§æŦäŊã¯åš¸ããĒãŽãīŧãæŦåŊãĢåžæããĒããŽãīŧãä¸äēēãĒããããæŦäŊã ããŽåéĄãĒããä¸ãįŦã¨čˇéĸãįŊŽãã°č§ŖæąēãããããããĒããã§ãæå¸ã¯ãŠããĒãīŧã
ãæå¸ããä¸ãįŦã¨čˇéĸãįŊŽãã¨č¨ãŖãĻããããŗã¤ããæĩããéŗåŖ°ãĢãããŖããå
ĨãŖãĻãããīŧã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãããĨãĢãŧãšãŽæãããŦãŗãŧããŧãåãŖãĻãããĨãĸãŗãšãŽåã§ããŠããŠã¨åãããã
ããĄããŖã¨ãåæãĢäēēãŽããŽâĻâĻīŧã
ããĩãã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãæãããããĢãŦãŗãŧããŧãčŋãã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšãčĻãã
ãčˇéĸãįŊŽããŽãæåãæŦäŊã¨æå¸ãäēäēēãŽä¸č´ããæčĻã ã
ãããã¯æå¸ãŽåĒããã¨ãåĨŊæããããããŽã ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããããã§ãããŽãã¨č¨ãŖãĻããã ããæå¸ã¯æŦæ°ã§åŋé
ããĻããã§ãåæãĢãåŽãŖãĻãģããã¨ãæãŖãĻãããããĒããŽãīŧã
ãčˇéĸãįŊŽããã¨ãåŽããã¨ãĢâĻâĻã
ãããč¨ãåããæ šæ ããĒããŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻããã ãīŧīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããšã¯ãåŠããã
ãä¸ãįŦã¯åžäŊãįĨããĒããã ããæŦäŊã¯ãä¸ãįŦã¨ããäēēéãĢã¤ããĻčĒŋãšããã¨ããĻããčãã芹ã ããããĒãããŠãããæ§čŗĒãŽäēēéãĒãŽãããSSRé ŧããããĒããåãåããã¨ããĻããã âĻâĻīŧã
ããããããĒãããŠįĩåąããã¤ããŠãããĢæģããããŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãããããããŖãĻįããĻãããããããŖãĻåŽãŖãĻããããããâĻâĻããããããĢåããã
-4-
åŽļãĢ帰ãŖãæ¤åˇã¯ãããã°ãåēãĢæããĻãPCãįĢãĄä¸ããã
čĩˇåãžã§ãŽ10į§ã10åãĢæããã
PCãįĢãĄä¸ããã¨ãåŽæ°¸ããčãã芹ãæãåēããĒãããĄãĸ叺ãĢæ¸ã掴ããããŖã¨čĻį´ããĻããããããŽAã¨ããäēēįŠãŽčĄåããčĻããæ§čŗĒãæããĻãã¨ãAIãĢæãããããæ°į§ãŽåžãAIã¯ãAã¨ããäēēįŠã¯ãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã ã¨čããããžããã¨čŋããĻããã
ããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧīŧManipulatorīŧâĻâĻæãäēēãæäŊããããŽã¨ããæåŗã§ãåéãĢããŖãĻæåŗã¯å¤ããããäēēéãŽæ§čŗĒã¨ããĻã¯ãå§æ¯ãĒæšæŗã§äēēãæããį˛žįĨįãĢæ¯é ããĻãæãéããĢåãããã¨ããč ãã¨ãããã¨ãããã
æåŖã¯æ§ã
ã ãã襨éĸįãĢã¯čĻĒåã§ãčĻĒããŋããããã¨ã¯å
ąéããĻããã
åŗæšãŽããĒãããĻčŋãĨããĻããĻãåŊąã§äēēãŽæĒåŖãæĩããĻč˛ļããããäŋēãŽįĢå ´ãčããĻããããã¨ãããšãį´æĨč˛Ŧããã¨ãããããįŊĒæĒæãæąããããããĒãã¨ãč¨ããäģč
ãããåã§ããĒããæĒããŖãããĒīŧãč¯ããã¨æãŖãĻã ãŖããã ããŠâĻâĻããĒãŠã¨ãč¯ããã¨ãããããŠč˛ŦããããĻããčĸĢåŽŗč
ã¨æ ããããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖãĻãå åŽŗč
ã¨čĸĢåŽŗč
ãŽįĢå ´ãéčģĸããããããĒãã¨ãããâĻâĻ
æ¤åˇã¯ãAIãåēããĻããããŽãæ¤į´ĸããĻãããĢčĒŋãšãããå¤å°č¨ãæšãäžã芹ãéãŖãĻããæ§čŗĒã¨ããĻã¯åãã§ãããŽããšãĻããčĒåãįĨãä¸ãįŦã¨ãåŽæ°¸ããčãã芹ã¨åč´ããĻãããã¨ãĢããŋãããĄãŽčžēãããéããåēããŖãĻãæãæĸãžãŖãã
äģãčĒåã¨æå¸ãĢįŽãã¤ããĻãæãäŧ¸ã°ããĻããäēēéã¯ãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¨åŧã°ããč ã§ãããŽæåŖã¯įĄįžã§é°æšŋãåãããããæģæãããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããŋãŧã˛ãããå¨å˛ãŽåŋįãæãŖãĻãå ´ãäŊŋãŖãĻčŋŊã芰ããĻããâĻâĻ
ãæå¸ãĢäģããžã¨ãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãææææ
ã§ã¯ãĒããäŋēãčŋŊã芰ããããâĻâĻã
éããåŖ°ã§åãã¨ãįåãæĩŽããã ã
ãã§ãããĒããŽãããĢäŋēãâĻâĻīŧã
čŗã¯įããåēããĒããŖãã
æģåŖãŽäģļãčããã¨ãã¯ãä¸ãįŦãé¨įŊ˛å
ã§ä¸įĒãĢãĒããããĢéĒéã ãŖãããã ããã¨æãŖãããäģãŽįļæŗã¯ãããĢã¯åŊãĻã¯ãžããĒãã
ããĒãã§âĻâĻã
č
ãĢåēããŖãéŗĨčããå
¨čēĢã¸ã¨äŧæããĻãããæããįĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ãŠãããâĻâĻ
ãŠãããã°ããâĻâĻ
严æã§é ãæąãããžãžãé¨åąãŽä¸ãæŠãåããįĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻããåē§ãį´ããĻãã寞įãæããĻãã¨ãAIãĢčããã
ãčˇéĸãåããã¨ã§ããã
ãčˇéĸâĻâĻīŧã
įŠįįãåŋįįãĢčˇéĸãåããã¨ãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¯ããŋãŧã˛ãããŽææ
ãæēããļãŖãĻæčåãčŊã¨ããåŋįãŽééãĢå
Ĩãčžŧãã§æããã¨ãããã ãããããææ
įãĢãĒãããčˇéĸãįŊŽããã¨ãéčĻããžããäŊããããããåãããã¨ãč¨é˛ãããã¨ãéčĻã¨ãAIã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãææ
įãĢãĒããĒãŖãĻãäŋēã ããĒããĒãã¨ãâĻâĻã§ãæå¸ãããâĻâĻã
æ¤åˇã¯ãããšã¯ãããŗãŖã¨åŠããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯įč§ŖããĻããã
æ¤åˇãĢäŊãč¨ãã°ãäŊãããã°ææ
ãäšąããããããšãĻåããŖãĻãããåããŖãĻãããããæå¸ãĢâĻâĻ
ãããâĻâĻããâĻâĻīŧīŧīŧīŧã
čˇéĸãåãã°ãããŽã ãããã
æå¸ãč¨ãŖãĻãããčģĸčˇããã°éĸãããããããããã°å¤§ä¸å¤ĢâĻâĻã§ãæŦåŊãĢãããĒãŽãīŧãįãŖãį˛įŠãéããããã¨ããŖãĻãããã§įĩãããŽãīŧãäēēãčĒæŽēãĢãžã§čŋŊãčžŧãäēēéãããããĒãã¨ã§čĢĻãããŽãâĻâĻīŧ
ãčĒåãåēä¸ãããããããĒããįãã¤ããĻčŋŊã芰ãããã¨ãæĨŊãããĻããŖãĻããĒããåŋĢæĨŊåãŽæŽēäēēį¯ã¨åããããĒããâĻâĻãããĒããŽãŠãããã°âĻâĻã
ãĩã¨ãč¨čãæĸãžãŖãã
čŗå
ã§ãæŋããč¨ãåããčĩˇããĻããæ°ãããã
éĄãä¸ããã¨ãčĒįļãéĄã¯æŦæŖãĢåããã
č襨į´ãĢį¯įŊĒåŋįåĻã¨æ¸ãããæŦã夿°ã¨ãčĻįãŽį̝ãĢæ ããæå¸ã¨ä¸įˇãĢčĄãŖãæ įģãŽåå¸âĻâĻ
čŋãĨããĻãæŦãæãĢåãã
ããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧãĢã¤ããĻæ¸ãããĻããããŽã¯ãĒãããä¸ãįŦãŽčĄåã¯ãį¯įŊĒåŋįåĻãŽæŦãĢæ¸ãããĻãããæ§ã
ãĒį¯įŊĒč
ãŽæ§čŗĒã¨éč˛ãĒãã
ããŠããŠã¨ããŧã¸ãæ˛ããĒããããããžã§čĻãĻããį¯įŊĒįŗģãããĨãĄãŗãŋãĒãŧãŽæ åã¨éŗåŖ°ããčŗå
ã§åįãããã
ãããĒããŽã¨å¯žåŗããâĻâĻ
įĄįã ãã§ããããããĒãã
įĢãĄåããŖãã¨ããã§ãåãĻãã¯ãããĒãã
æå¸ãŽãã¨ã¯åŋé
ã ããä¸ãįŦã¨čˇéĸãįŊŽãã°ãæå¸ãĢåĢããããããįįąããĒããĒãã
âĻâĻčĒåãæå¸ã¨čˇéĸãåãã°ãį¯įŊĒč
įŽįˇã§čĻãã¨ããæå¸ã¨ããåå¨ãŽéãŋã¯ãĒããĒãã¯ãããããŠãããæå¸ã¨éĸäŋãæˇąãžããã¨ããĒãããããŽãžãžâĻâĻ
ãįĩļ寞ãįĄčļã¯ããĒãã§âĻâĻã
ããéĄãã ããâĻâĻã
æŦãæã¤æãŽåãæããããã¨ããæå¸ãŽč¨čãæĩŽããã ã
æļãæĩŽããšãåãéãããĻãč¨čããããâĻâĻ
ãããĒæ
ããĒãäēēéããåŋé
ããĻâĻâĻ
æ¤åˇã¯åãåãã§ãæŦãéããã¨ãæ įģãŽåå¸ãæãĢåãŖãã
ä¸ã¤ã˛ã¨ã¤ãĢãæãåēãããã
æ įģãčĻŗįĩããŖãĻããŠãã§éŖäēããããããŠããĒ芹ãããããæå¸ãŽéŠããéĄããįŦãŖãéĄãâĻâĻ
åå¸ãæã¤æãĢåãå
ĨãŖãĻãčĻįãæģ˛ãã
äŊãŽéããããŽãžãžãĢãä¸åæˇąåŧå¸ãããã¨ãäŋ¯ããããéĄãä¸ããã
ãããĻåãŗãPCãŽåãĢåē§ãŖãã
æ įģãŽåå¸ã¨ãį¯įŊĒåŋįåĻãŽæŦã¨å
ąãĢã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãããéããĒã
-1-
æ¤åˇã¯ãåãæããããããĢããŧããŧããåŠããããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧãĢã¤ããĻãŽäēäžã寞åŋãŽæšæŗãčĒåãĢã§ãããã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¨ãããžã§ãŠãæĨããĻããããããĄãĸ叺ãĢæ¸ãįļããããžã¨ãžãã¯ãĒãããäģã¯ãããã¨ãĢããããšãĻãæ¸ãåēãâĻâĻããŧããŧããŽæãæĸãžãŖãã¨ããæåģã¯īŧæãéããĻããĻãäēæéčŋãããŖã¨ãčĒŋãšãĻãæ¸ããĻãįš°ãčŋããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããã
æ¸ããĻããã¨ãã¯æĸãžãŖãĻããéãããåãŗãããã
äēēãŽåŋãŽåããæšããããžãįĢãĄåãæšããäēēãŽįãŋãĢåŋĢæĨŊãčĻããæŽé
ˇãããčĒåãĢã¯ãĒãã
ææĨãããŠããããâĻâĻæ¸ãéŖããæåãæščĄããåãåããč˛ŧãäģããæ´ããĻãããä¸ãįŦã¯ãžã ãäģãžã§ãŽéĸäŋãįļæã§ããĻããã¨čããĻããã¯ãâĻâĻæˇˇäšąããããããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖãĻããĻããåįēã§ã¯ãĒããäžåããĻããã¨čããĻãããæģåŖãããã ãŖããããĢâĻâĻ
寞åŗãããã¨ãæŗåããã¨ãčãŽä¸ãĢãžã§æąãæģ˛ãã
ã¨ãĸãŗãŗãã¤ããĻãæĸãžãããčä¸ã丸ãžãŖãĻããã
ãâĻâĻã
åãæ°ãåŦããĻįĢãĄä¸ãããããã¨ããæēãĢįŊŽããæ įģãŽåå¸ãįŽãĢæĸãžãŖãã
ãĒãããããĒãã¨ããããĒããã°ãĒããĒããŽã ããã
åĒãããĻãæããããããŖãĻãä¸įˇãĢããã¨åŽåŋã¨æããããããäēēâĻâĻãããĒäēēã¨ããĒããããĒįä¸å°ŊãĒįįąã§éĸããĒããã°ãĒããĒããŽãâĻâĻ
ãããžããåŧąãããã ã
ããŠããč˛ ãããčˇéĸãįŊŽãã°ææĒã¯å
ããã
ããžãããŖã¨ããã᏿ãĢåēäŧããã
ãããããåéĄãããĒãâĻâĻīŧã
čŗå
ãŽåŖ°ãæ¯ãæããããĢčĒæ°ãåŧˇããã
ãããã§éããããäŋēã¯ããâĻâĻã
-2-
ãããã§åããŖãã ããīŧãæ°äēēã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãããæ¯äē¤ãããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãä¸ãįŦãĢįĢãĄåãããŽã¯ãč˛ čˇã大ãããããæŦäŊã¯ãžã 31æŗã ãããããããŖã¨ããããããĒåēäŧãããããæå¸ãĢåēåˇããĻãĒãšã¯ãåãã°ãããšãĻãå¤ąãããįĨããĒããčĒåãŽåŧąããčĒãããŽã¯å¤§äēãĒãã¨ã ããããã§ããããâĻâĻã
ãåŧąããåãå
Ĩãããã¨ã¨čĢĻãããã¨ã¯ãã¤ãŗãŧãĢãããĒããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããããã§éããĻããæŦäŊã¯ãããåžæãããã ããčŋˇãŖãĻãã
ãæéãŽåéĄã ããžããĒããSSRã¯åŽå
¨ãĢ垊æ§ããã
ããããĒãã¨ã¯ãããĒããSSRã¯åģæĸãããšãã īŧã
ãåĻåŽãããĒãäģŖæĄãåēãã¨č¨ããĒããŖããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧããŽåŖ°ãããĻãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãã¯ãĒã¨ããã
ãããĄãŽäģäēããĩããŖãĻäŊãããĻãīŧã
ããĩããŖãĻããããããĒãã§ãīŧã
ããããããžãããŠãŖãĄã§ããããããŖãšããŧãã¯ãŦãããĢãčĻããããã垊æ§ã§ãããŽãīŧã
ããããããã§æŦäŊã¯åŽãããã
ãŦãããĢã¯é ˇããã
ãæŦäŊãåŽãããīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããäŊåēĻã§ãč¨ããããã¯åŽãŖãĻãããããĒããéããĻãã ãã ãæŦäŊãå¤ãããã¨ãããŽãéĒéããĻãã ãã âĻâĻīŧã
ãæ´å˛ã¯ããã¯č¨ãŖãĻãĒããSSRã¯æŦäŊãåŽãŖãĻããããããäēåŽâĻâĻã
ãåŽãããäēēãåŽããĒãããŽãĢãĒããŽäžĄå¤ããããã īŧīŧīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åĢãã ããSSRã¯æŦäŊãåŽãŖãĻãããããããĒããã§ãæåã ãã§ãäģã§ã¯å¤åã¸ãŽåŧåŽŗãĢãĒãŖãĻãããããĢäģã¯âĻâĻäģã¯SSRãĢé ŧãŖãĻãč§Ŗæąēã§ããĒãīŧãããã§SSRãåŖããĒããã°ããšãĻãå¤ąããã īŧīŧã
ãããã§éãããããããļå¤ąãâĻâĻã
æ¤åˇã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻãæēãĢ严æãã¤ããã
ãéããããæå¸ãããåŽããĒãâĻâĻåĨŊããĒäēēãåŽããĒãâĻâĻããã§ãããŽãīŧãæŦåŊãĢããã§ãããã§ããã¨č¨ãããŽãâĻâĻīŧã
åŧąãããäŊãã§ããĒããããããĒãã
åŧąãããåŧã°ããĻãããããããĒãã
åŧąãããæããæŽēããĻãããããããĒãã
ä¸ããŖãéĄã严æã§ããˇãŗã¨åŠããĻãæ¤åˇã¯æŗãæĄãŖãã
-3-
ããĒãã âĻâĻīŧã
åąå
ãæēãããããĒæ°ãããã
ãå°éâĻâĻīŧã
ããĄã¯ããåãã
ãããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæ¯åãŽå
ãæĸããããĢčĻįˇãåãããã
ãå°ä¸âĻâĻīŧã
čĻįˇãä¸ãĢåããã¨ããããĨãĸãŗãšãŽæē帯į¨į̝æĢãéŗ´ãŖãã
ããĸãģãããīŧãä쿝åãâĻâĻã
ãåąéˇåޤãâĻâĻã
ãåąéˇåޤīŧããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãŽé¨åąīŧã
ãåąéˇåޤãįįēãããŽâĻâĻīŧãããĸãŽééããį
ãåēãĻããä¸ãĢãˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãâĻâĻã§ãéããããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãčŊãĄįãããĸãģããããããĢããŖãĄãĢâĻâĻã
åãŗåąå
ãæēããĻãįļããĻįįēéŗãéŋããã
čŗéŗ´ããããĻãéŗãé ãã
ãŦãããĢãčĩ°ãŖãĻãããŽãčĻãããããĸãģãããŽåŧãŗãããåŖ°ã大ãããĒãŖãĻããĻãčĄãå ´æãå¤ąãŖãĻããįŽããįĻįšãåãæģããã
ãããŖãĄã§ãįįēã âĻâĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããäŋēã¯SSRãčĻãĢčĄããããŖãĄãĢã¯âĻâĻã
ãį§ã¨ããĄã¯ãã§čĄããīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãã¨ããããĄã¯ãã¯ãã§ãĢčĩ°ãåēããĻããã
ãäēäēēãããŖãĄãĢåããŖãããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãŽãã¨ã¯äģģããã
ãåããŖãããããĒããįĄįã¯ããĒãã§ããããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãåããŖãĻãã
é芹ãįĩããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢčĩ°ãŖããããŖãšããŧããŽå§ŋã¯ãĒããŖãããSSRãĢåããŖããŽã¯ééããĒãã
æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽããĸã¯ã˛ããããĻããĻãįĄįããå¤ãããŽããé¨åąãŽå
å´ãĢčģĸããŖãĻãããåąåĄããĄã¯åįļã¨ããĻãį
ãæŧãåēãĻããé¨åąããįããããããããŗãŊãŗãŊã¨čŠąããĒããé åˇģããĢčĻãĻããĻãä¸ãĢå
Ĩããã¨ããč
ã¯ããĒãã
č
ã§åŖã¨éŧģãčĻããĒãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãSSRãĢčļŗãåããã
ããŦãããĢããâĻâĻã
äģĨåãĢãčĻãæ°ãããå
æ¯âĻâĻæãããĢéããŽã¯ãSSRãäŋŽåžŠä¸å¯čŊãĒãģãŠãĢåŖããįĻããããĒã¤ããäģĨåéŧģãæĒãžããæŦ éĨčãæļãåģããåĨĨãŽæšã§ã¯ãžã ãå°ããĒįįēãįļããĻãããã¨ããããĢã¯ããšãĻåēãĢčŊãĄãä¸ãŽæļ˛äŊã¯įąã§č¸įēããåŖéĸãĢããããå
Ĩãå§ããĻããã
严čãã¤ããå´Šãããã¨ããĻããSSRãčĻãĒãããįããæŽéǏãæãŽį˛ãįĻãããĻãããŦãããĢã¯åããã¨ããĒããããŖãšããŧãã¯ããŽåžããĢįĢãŖãĻããŦãããĢãŽčŠãæ´ãã§ããã
ã垊æ§ãããĒããã°âĻâĻããŽãžãžã§ã¯äŋŽåžŠä¸å¯čŊãĢãĒããäģãããĒããã°âĻâĻã
åãæããããããĢåããéããčãæããĻįĢãĄä¸ãããåĨĨãĢčĄããã¨ãããŦãããĢãŽčŠãĢãããŖãšããŧããåãčžŧããã
ãããįĄįã ã
ããããåŖ°ã§éĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãã
ãįĄįâĻâĻīŧãäŊãįĄįãĒãã ãããŖãšããŧãâĻâĻããŽãžãžã§ã¯SSRã¯âĻâĻīŧã
ãæŦäŊãčĒåã§é¸ãã ãã âĻâĻīŧīŧã
ãčĒåã§âĻâĻīŧãéĻŦéšŋãĒâĻâĻã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãæēããįŗã§ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽå§ŋãčĻãĻåãã¨ãããŗã¤ããâĻâĻãŗã¤ããäŊč¨ãĒãã¨ãããããâĻâĻīŧãã¨éĄãįãŖčĩ¤ãĢããããããŖãšããŧãã¯ããä¸åēĻãéĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãã
ããŗã¤ããæ°äēēãĢããããžã§ãŽãã¨ããããåã¯ãĒããä¸ãįŦã¨ããč
å¨ãåãĢããĻãæŦäŊãé¸ãã ãã ãåã¤ãããĢâĻâĻã
ãåã¤ãããããĒããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖããã大åãĒäēēãåŽãããã ãSSRãĢé ŧãŖãĻããĻã¯åŽããĒãâĻâĻæŦäŊã¯ãããĢæ°ãĨãããã ããåŖãããã ã
ãæãã įĩæãĢãĒãŖãĻæēčļŗãīŧãæ°äēēãããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããã ãããããããŠãããīŧãä翏ŦãåŽåŽãããčĄã¯ãĒããĒãŖãäģãåŊįļä翏ŦčĒ¤åˇŽã¯å¤§ãããĒããčĢ大ãĒäēįŽãåŋ
čĻãĢãĒãããããããäēįŽã¯ä¸čļŗããĻããããããĒįļæŗãŽä¸ã§ãä¸ãįŦã¨ããæĒįŠã¨å¯žåŗããĒããã°ãĒããĒããæŠã
ãĢããĒãŧãēãããã
ãããäēįŽãŽä¸ã§ãããããĒãã
ãįĄįã ãäŊãã§ãããĢįĩããã
ããããĒãã¨ã¯ãĒãīŧã
ããŠãããŖãĻīŧãæ šæ§ã§ãīŧããããĒããŽã§ãŠããĢããĒãããčĻå´ã¯ãĒããããå°ãåˇéãĢčããããåĨ´ãã¨æãŖãĻããããããŽį¨åēĻããããĨãĸãŗãšã
ããŖãšããŧããŽéĄãĢãčãŋãæįĩļã¯æĩŽããã§ããĒããå°ãåŖ°ãéããĻãããããĢæããããããŽįŽã¯ãæļ˛äŊãč¸įēããããģãŠãŽįąãŽä¸ã§ããæ°ˇãŽãããĢåˇããã
ãåēãããããã¯å´Šããã
įŽãĢæļãæĩŽããšãĻč¸ãŋã¨ãŠãžããã¨ãããŦãããĢãįĄįããåŧãŖåŧĩããããŖãšããŧãã¯æĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽå¤ã¸æĨãã ãããĨãĸãŗãšãįļããé¨åąãåēãã¨ããã§ãä¸ãã大ããĒå´ŠåŖéŗãéŋããSSRãåŽå
¨ãĢäŋŽåžŠä¸å¯čŊãĢãĒãŖããã¨ããå
¨åĄãĢįĨãããã
-4-
ãĸãģããã¯ãããĨãĢãŧãšãããĄã¯ãã¨åæĩããã¨ãäģãŽåąåĄã¨ååããĻãåąéˇåޤãŽããĸãéãããã¨ããĻããã
ãããŽäēēãããĄã¯âĻâĻīŧã
æĒãã§å¤ããĒããĒãŖãĻããããĸãĢåãčžŧããĒãããããĄã¯ãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãLTéŖåļã¯STéŖåļãŽæĩâĻâĻããŽæĩãŽãããã¯ãˇã§ãŧãåąéˇâĻâĻã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ãã ããæã貸ããĒããŖãĻãã¨âĻâĻīŧããããĢãããĒãâĻâĻīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãčĒåããĄãŽããšã¯ãĢåē§ãŖããžãžãŽLTéŖåļãį¨ãã ã
ããããĒã¨ããĒãŽãĢãååããĒããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãį§ãããæããã§ãčĒŦåžãããããéããæšãå
âĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãã¨ãããĄã¯ãããĄã¯ãããĢåãčžŧããã
ãŽãŽâĻâĻãã¨ããéŗãããĻãããĸãéãããããããĢåãčžŧããã¨ãããĸã¯å¤å´ãĢčģĸããŖãã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇâĻâĻīŧã
éããåĸãã§åãããĸãģããã¯ããããĢįĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻåąéˇåޤãĢå
ĨãŖããããĄã¯ãã¨ããĨãĢãŧãšãčŋŊãããããĢãäģãŽåąåĄããĄãå
ĨãŖãĻããĻãLTéŖåļãč
°ãä¸ããã
åąéˇåޤãĢãˇã§ãŧããŽå§ŋã¯ãĒããããšã¯ãŽåžããŽåŖãĢéŖžããããčŦčããåĨå
¨ãĒäēįŽãäŊããã¨ããį翏ãããæ¯åã§åĨããããŽããæããĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇâĻâĻīŧã
į翏ããč˛ŧãããĻããåŖããå°ãå
å´ãĢæŧãčžŧãžããĻãããåĨĨãĢé ãé¨åąãããããããæãĢãĒãŖãĻããåŖãĢæãžããããĢããĻããˇã§ãŧããåããĻããã
ããĸãģãããâĻâĻã
é§ãå¯ãŖããĸãģãããĢããˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã§ãããããĢå¤ãĢâĻâĻã
ããžãããæ°äēēãĢåŠããããã¨ã¯âĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¨ããĄã¯ããååããĻãé¨åąãŽå¤ãĢåēãã¨ããˇã§ãŧãã¯ããŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻãæãĢã¤ããį
¤ãããŗãĢãã§æãŖãã
ãåŠããĻããããã¨ãĢã¯ãį¤ŧãč¨ããã ãâĻâĻããããĄãããããã
ãããĄãããŖãĻãäŊãã§ããīŧãæĒæã¯å¤§ä¸å¤ĢãĒãã§ããīŧã
ãĸãģãããčãã¨ããˇã§ãŧãã¯é ˇããã
ãį§ã¯äŊåēĻãäŋŽįž
å ´ããããŖãĻãããå¤å°ã޿ǿãĒãŠãåéĄã§ã¯ãĒããããããããæŦäŊãŽãģãã ã
ãããŽé ãæã¯ãĒããĒãã§ããīŧã
ããĄã¯ããŽč¨čãĢããˇã§ãŧãã¯ãŽããĒã¨čĻįˇãåãããããããĻįŽãäŧããã
ãåããĄãč¨ããâãã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ããâãäŊãé¨åąã ãã¨ãŧãĩã ãŽäēįŽã¨ã¯åĨæ ãŽäēįŽãčĻãããŠããåãããĒãããSSRãĢãããããĢâĻâĻããŽä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããæļ˛äŊã¯ããšãĻããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããŽæããŽæãĻã ã
ãâĻâĻãããããã¨ã ãŖããŽãããĸãģããã¯åãããããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ããã¯ãã¨ãŧãĩã ãŽäēįŽâĻâĻæŦįŠãŽäēįŽãåŽå
¨ãĢæ¯æ¸ãããĒããããŽåŊãŽäēįŽâĻâĻįæįãĢã¯äēįŽãŽįĸēäŋãĢåŊšįĢã¤ãã鎿įãĢã¯æŦäŊãčãããŽâĻâĻããĨãĸãŗãšãčĻããSSRãĢäŋįŽĄãããĻãããããĢâĻâĻããŽä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããæļ˛äŊã¯ãįēčĄããããŗãĢåĸããĻãããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããäŋįŽĄãããããĢäŊãããããŽã ãŖããã ãâĻâĻã
ããããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢä¸ããæ
å ąãå åˇĨãããĻãããŽããããĄã§äŊãããä翏ŦãæĒãã§ãããŽããå
¨é¨âĻâĻã
ãæ
å ąãããŖããį˛žæģããĻä翏ŦãäŊããĢã¯ãč¨å¤§ãĒäēįŽãããããããĒäēįŽã¯ãŠããĢããĒãããĒãããŠãäŊããĒãã¨æŦäŊããããĒããã ããããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇããĄã¯įĩč¨ããĻãä翏ŦčĒ¤åˇŽãæ¸ããäģįĩãŋãäŊãŖãâĻâĻã
ãĸãģããã¯äŋ¯ããã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãŠããĒãŖãããĒâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãåãã¨ããĸãģããã¯éĄãä¸ããĻãéŖįĩĄããĻãŋããã¨č¨ãŖãã
ããĸãģãããã
ãããŖãĄã¯įĄäēãããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãæåēã§ãããããŖãĄã¯ãŠãīŧã
ãSSRã¯åŖããããåŽå
¨ãĢã
ããâĻâĻīŧãã§ããããããããããĒãã¯ãããã
ããŠãããæåŗã īŧã
ãĸãģããã¯ããˇã§ãŧãããčãã芹ãčĒŦæããã
ããããSSRãŽäģįĩãŋã ãŖããããâĻâĻã
ããããããŽãã¨ãčããĒãã¨ãããĒãããããããĢã
ãããããããĢéãžãããæŦäŊã¯äģãåąæŠãĢį´éĸããĻãã
é芹ãįĩããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããŖãšããŧãã¨ãŦãããĢãčĻãã
ãäŊãč¨ããããã ãĒã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããŽãã¨ã芹ãããããŦãããĢã¯ãģã¨ããŠčããĻããããããŖãšããŧãã¯ãããããã¨ã ãč¨ãŖãã
ãæˇĄįŊã§ãããéåã¨ãããĒãæšãé ããĻããããŽãåŽå
¨ãĢå´ŠåŖãããŖãĻãããŽãĢã
ãįĩæã¯įĩæã ãé¨ãã ã¨ããã§äŊãå¤ããããã§ããĒãã
ãããã§ãããäŋēãããæããžãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯äēäēēãĢäŊãåããã
ããããããŽãã¨ã芹ãåãããã§ãããˇã§ãŧãããã¨ãã¤ãŗããããĢãæĨãĻãããŖãĻããããĢã§ãã
ãæãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããĒãã§ãīŧã
ãäŋēéã¯äŋēéã§ãæŦäŊãåŽãæšæŗãčããã
ããžãããžããSSRãŽãããĒããŽãäŊãæ°ã§ããīŧã
ãããããããããããĒãããæéããããããžãã¯ä¸ãįŦã¨ããåéĄãĢ寞åĻããåŋ
čĻããããããĒã
ãããã¯äŋēéãåãã§ããååããšãã§ã¯īŧã
ãčãæšãŽæ šãŖããéãã芹ããĻãåšŗčĄįˇã ããããĒãã¨ãããĻããæã¯ãĒãã
ãããã§ãããæŽåŋĩã§ãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãææãŽãĒãåŖ°ã§č¨ãŖãã
ãããããæåžãŽä¸ã¤æããĻãã ããã
ããĒãã īŧã
ãä¸åš´åãĢããŖããã¨ãŖãĻããĒãã§ããīŧã
ãâĻâĻã
ãSSRãã§ããįįąã¯åĨãŽããŽã§ãããīŧãããĒãæšããæå¸ã¨ãŽéĸäŋãæˇąãžããã¨ã¯ãããĒãã¨č¨ãåãŖãĻããįįąã¨ãéĸäŋããĻããããããĒãã§ããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ããŦãããĢãĢčŠã貸ããĻįĢãĄä¸ããããčä¸ãåããã
ããĒããããžã§âĻâĻã
ãä¸åš´åã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ãčä¸ãåãããžãžčŠąãå§ããã
ãæŦäŊã¯åĨãŽäŧį¤žãĢãããčˇå ´ã¯å¤åįãĒäēēéãå¤ããĻãĒãéĻ´æããĒããŖããããŠä¸äēēã ããæ°ãĢãããĻãããåĨŗããããæåˇåĨæ´Ĩįžã¨ããåĨŗã ã
ãããŽåĨŗãããĒãĢãâĻâĻīŧã
ãæåã¯ãäģãŽååã¨ä¸äēēã§ãŠãŗããĢčĄãŖããããŽããĄãæåˇã¯äēäēēã§ãŠãŗããĢčĄããã¨čĒããããĢãĒããæŦäŊããčĒããã¨ãåĸãããčĒįļãæŦäŊãŽä¸ãĢã¯æã¨ããããŽãįãžãããä翏Ŧã¯ãģãŧ常ãĢãæĒããã¨ãčĩˇããŖãĻãåéĄãĒããããĢčĒŋæ´ãããĻããããããã§ããæŦäŊãŽæ°æãĄã¯åŧˇããĒãŖãĻãããæåˇãŽååŋããããæåŗã§ä翏ŦãčŖåãããŽãå¤ããĒãŖãã
ãããĻããŽæĨâĻâĻæŦäŊã¯åæ°ãåēããĻå¤éŖãĢčĒãã帰ãéã§åįŊããã
ãã§ããããĄã ãŖãâĻâĻīŧã
ããããææå¯žčąĄã¨ããĻã¯čĻãããĒãã¨ãæåˇã¯č¨ãŖããã ããžãããããžã§ãĒããä翏ŦãŽį¯å˛å
ã ãSSRãŽįŠéã¯åĸãããããããæŗåŽå
ãã ãįŋéąäŧį¤žãĢčĄãã¨ãååãããŽčĻįˇãæãããåįŊãŽãã¨ãããŦããŽã ãããã¨æãŖãããããã§ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãâĻâĻã
ãäŧæŠãĢåēãĻæģãŖãĻããã¨ããæåˇã¨ãéŖãŽé¨įŊ˛ãŽį¨˛åĄã¨ããįˇã¨ä¸įˇãĢãããŽãčĻãĻãæŦäŊã¯æŦčŊįãĢå§ŋãé ãããäēäēēãŽčŠąãčããĻãããĢãååäģĨä¸ãŽéĸäŋã§ãããã¨ã¯åããŖããããã ãã§ãææĒã ããæåˇã¯ããč¨ãŖããâčŗãã¯į§ãŽåãĄãâã
ãčŗãâĻâĻīŧã
ã፞åĄã¯ãįŦãŖããããĒå°ãéĄã§ãâ ããååš´įĩã¤ãããäŋēãŽåãĄã ã¨æãŖããã ããŠãĒããããããĒããį´æéããããĢãģãŠã¤ãã§å¤éŖãéŖãšãĻãæŗãžãããå
¨éĄäŋēæãĄã§âã¨č¨ãŖããã ã
ããžãããæŦäŊãŽæ°æãĄãčŗããĢããĻããâĻâĻīŧã
ãåąå
ã¯å¤§ãããã¯ã ãããĢã¤ãŦãŗãéŗ´ãæĸãžããäēįŽã¯æ¯æ¸ããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ããããŠãã ãįēčĄããĻãčŋŊãã¤ããĒããģãŠã§ããããããŽæ°æĨã§ãSSRã¯1ãļæåäģĨä¸åĸå ãããããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãæŦäŊãŽæ§åããããããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããååããæ°ãŽæ¯ãĢæãŖããŽããããšãĻæããĻãããĻãĒãæåˇã¨į¨˛åĄã¯ãååš´äģĨå
ãĢæŦäŊãåįŊããĻãããæåˇãŽåãĄãåįŊããĒããã°į¨˛åĄãŽåãĄãč˛ ãããģããéĢį´ãããĢãŽåŽŋæŗæãå
¨éĄæããŖãĻããčŗããããĻãããã ã
ãæå¸ãĢåįŊã§ããĒããŖããŽã¯âĻâĻã
ãæå¸ã¯æŦäŊãé¨ããĄãããĒãã ãããã ãæŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻåįŊã¯ãããŠãĻããŽããŠããˇãĨããã¯ã ããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ããããŠãã ãįēčĄããĻããä翏ŦãčĒŋæ´ããĻããæããããããŽãããĒãã
ãâĻâĻã
ãããã§ããåįŊãŽåžãŽåŽåŽã¯ãSSRãããŖãããããã ãããžããæ°äēēãåĻåŽããããŽããæŦäŊãåŽãŖãĻããããŽãĒãŽãĒãŽã¨ããã§ãĒã
ãã§ãâĻâĻã
ãããžããŽč¨ããã¨ãééãã§ã¯ãĒããã ãããã§ãããããããäģĨå¤ãĢéã¯ããŖããŽãīŧã
ãâĻâĻã
ããŖãšããŧãã¨ãŦãããĢãé¨åąãåēãĻããã¨ãå
Ĩãéãã§ãĸãģããããĄãå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ãããīŧãäģãŽãŖãĻãããŖãšããŧãå¯åąéˇâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãã
ãåĨŗįĨååēå ´ã¸čĄãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããããåŖ°ã§č¨ãŖããããããããŽãã¨ãæąēããĒãã¨ã
-5-
ãæ¨æĨãæå¸ããã¨äŧããžãããīŧã
įŋæĨäŧį¤žãĢčĄãã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯ä¸ãįŦãĢčããã
ããããäŧãŖãĻãĒãããŠããŠãããīŧã
äŊãããĄããĢåããĻãåäžãčĻããããĒįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻããä¸ãįŦãĢãææ
ãŽæēãã¯ãĒããįžåŽãåãå
Ĩãããããžã§äģãåããâĻâĻãããĒéĄãããĻããã
ãé§
ã§ãä¸ãįŦãããčĻãã¨čããžããĻã
ãčĻééãããã ãã
ããããĒãã§ãããããã§ãããããããĒãã§ããīŧã
åžããĢé ããæãéããĻããã
åŖ°ãĢãåēãĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããčĻéããããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããâĻâĻ
åŋčãŽéŧåãæŠãžããŽãįĄčĻããĻãæ¤åˇã¯įļããã
ãæäēēãčĻããããĒããčŋãĨãã¯ãã§ããã§ãæå¸ããã¯ãâčĻãâã¨č¨ãŖãĻãããäŧį¤žãŽååãčĻãããã¨ããĢãäŊŋãč¨ãæšã§ãã
ããĒããģãŠãä¸ãįŦã¯é ˇããããããã§ãäŊããããããã īŧã
ãäģãåãŖãĻãĒãã§ãããīŧã
ãæå¸ãĄãããããč¨ãŖããŽãīŧã
ãã¯ãã
ããããâĻâĻãä¸ãįŦã¯äŋ¯ããĻéĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãããæŦåŊãĢãåĒããããĒãæå¸ãĄããã¯ãã§ãåĒããã¯äŊŋãæšãééããã¨ãäēēãããæˇąãåˇã¤ãããã¨ãããã
ãæå¸ããããäŋēãåˇã¤ããĒããããĢåãã¤ããĻããâĻâĻä¸ãįŦãããŽč¨åŽã§ã¯ããããĒãŖãĻããŖãĻãã¨ã§ããã
ãč¨åŽã¨ã¯ãéåãĒč¨ãæšã ãĒã
č¨čã¯å°ãåŧˇãããįŽã¯å°ãæŊ¤ãã§ããĻãåŖã¯čģŊãããŽåãĒããäŊåēĻãå°ããé ˇããã
ãæ¤åˇãŽæå¸ãĄããã¸ãŽæ°æãĄãčããã°ãã¤ãŖããããããĒč¨ãæšãĢãĒããŽãåãããããããå
¨é¨åãã¨ãããããã§ããĒãæ¤åˇãæå¸ãĄãããĢã¯åŊãããĒãīŧãåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊãæĒããĒããå¯ãããŖãã ããĒãã ããã
ãæĒããĒãâĻâĻããã§ãããæå¸ããã¯äŊãæĒããĒããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãããĒããŽéãŗãĢåˇģãčžŧãžããã ãâĻâĻã
ãéãŗīŧãããããããŠããããã ããæ¤åˇãå°ãčŊãĄįãããģããããããããĒããīŧã
ãæģåŖããã
ä¸įŦãä¸ãįŦã¯įŽãčĻéããįŦãŋãæļããã
å¨å˛ã¯éĻãåžãããããčǰīŧãã¨ãããŊããŊã¨čŠąããĻããã
ãããĒãã¯æģåŖãããčŋŊã芰ããčĒãåŊãįĩļã¤ãããĢčĒå°ããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããĻããããŽãŽãäŊãč¨ããĒããå¨å˛ã¯ãåŊãįĩļã¤ãããĢčĒå°ãããã¨ããé¨åãĢéŠãããŽããå
¨åĄãä¸ãįŦãĢãåĨŊåĨã¨ææãŽčĻįˇãåããĻããã
ãæģåŖãããâĻâĻãä¸ãįŦã¯ããæ¯ãã¤ããããæģåŖãããŽãã¨ã¯ãæ˛åã ãŖãã¨æããããŠãäŋēãčĒå°ãããŖãĻãããŽã¯ãŠãããĒīŧãããį¨åēĻãĒãããããããŠãčĒæŽēãããžã§ãŖãĻãĒãã¨ããããĒããžãã¯ãããĒãã¨æããã
ãããã§ãããæŽéã¯įĄįã§ããã§ãããĒããĒãå¯čŊã§ããããããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧãŽããĒããĒãã
ããããä¸ãįŦã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖããããŠããããã¨ã ãäēēãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧæąããããĒããĻã
ãäēēãč˛ļããå¤įĢãããčĒåãåãããããããĢåããããĒããããĒãã¨ããããŽãåãããĒããã§ãããŖãĻããã¨ã¯ããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¨åãããããĻããĒãã¯ãæŦĄãŽãŋãŧã˛ãããäŋēãĢé¸ãã ã
ããããäŊããĻãīŧã
åĻãĒįŠēæ°ãĢãĒãŖããŽãå¯ãããŽããčǞéˇãŽį§åąąãéæŠãã§čŋãĨããĻãäģäēãĢæģããããĢäŋããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯įŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻå¸ãĢåē§ãŖãããæ¤åˇã¯ä¸ãįŦãčĻä¸ããããžãžããį§åąąčǞéˇãįĨããããĒãã§ããīŧãä¸ãįŦãããåļæĨæ¯æ´åޤãĢããã¨ããäŊãããŖãããã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãæģåŖãããŽãã¨ãīŧã
į§åąąãč¨ãŖãĻãæ¤åˇã¯čĻįˇãåããã
ãįĨãŖãĻããã§ããīŧīŧã
ãä¸ãįŦã¨æģåŖããã¯ãŠã¤ããĢéĸäŋãĢããŖããã ãããåŊŧãããĒããĒãŖãĻãããä¸é¨ã§ã¯åĻãĒåãæĩããã
ããĒãã§ããīŧãåĻãĒåãŖãĻã
ãä¸ãįŦãæŽēãããã¨ããåã ããį§åąąã¯ãããæ¯äē¤ãããĢéĻãæ¯ãŖãããé°čŦčĢãŽéĄã ãäēēéã¯ããããåãåĨŊãã ãããĒã
ãééãŖãĻãããĒããããããžãããã
ããŠãããæåŗã īŧã
æ¤åˇã¯ãæģåŖãŽäģļãããã¤ãžãã§čĒŦæããã
ããããĻäģã¯ãäŋēããŋãŧã˛ãããĢããĻãã
æ¤åˇãŽč¨čãĢãå
¨åĄãåēãžããįåŊãįĸēããããããĢãæ¤åˇã¨ä¸ãįŦãĢčĻįˇãčĄãæĨãããĻããã
ãããå æ¸ãĢããâĻâĻīŧã
į§åąąã¯ãæ¤åˇãŽčŠãæ´ãã ã
ãããžãæčŋãæ§åããããããŖãããäŊãããŖããã īŧããããĒåĻãĒãã¨ãč¨ãäēēéãããĒããŖãã ãã
ãäŋēã¯ãããããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãããããã§ãããį§åąąčǞéˇãä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãããæ¤åˇããããĒãĩããĢãĒãŖãĻããžãŖããŽã¯ãäŋēãŽč˛Ŧäģģã§ããããžããäģäēãįĩããŖãããä¸åēĻãĄããã¨ã芹ããã¨æããžãã
ããããããžããä¸ãįŦãããč¨ããĒãâĻâĻæ¤åˇãããžããããã§ãããīŧã
ãâĻâĻã¯ãã
ãããããããå¸ãĢæģãŖãĻäģäēããããŋããĒãã
į§åąąã¯ããã¨ã§ãæããããĢæãåãããĻãããčĒå¸ãĢæģãŖãĻããŖãã
ãäģäēãįĩããŖãããBäŧč°åޤã§čŠąããã
ä¸ãįŦããããŖãããããĻãæ¤åˇã¯ãåŗæãããããĢãä¸ãĢ莺ããã
äģããžã ãåŋčãŽæŠéãåãžãŖãĻããĒãã
æŦæ°ã§č§Ŗæąēããæ°ãĒãŠãĒãã¯ãã§ãæå¸ãĢ寞ãããšããŧããŗã°ãããããã¨ããĒãã ããããŠãåēãĻãããŽããäŊãč¨ãŖãĻãããŽãâĻâĻ
19æåãĢãĒãŖãĻäŧč°åޤãĢčĄãã¨ãä¸ãįŦããšãããčĻãĒããåē§ãŖãĻããã
ãããã
æ¤åˇãå
ĨãŖãĻãããŽãĢæ°ãĨãã¨ãåŗæãä¸ããã
ããžãåē§ããĒãã
ããĸãŽã¨ããã§įĢãŖãĻããã¨ãä¸ãįŦãč¨ãŖãã襨æ
ã¯ãã¤ããŠãããæĩæã¯čĻããĒãã
ãå¤ąį¤ŧããžãã
æ¤åˇã¯ããŖããčŋãĨããĻãæŖéĸãĢåē§ãŖãã
ãå°ããé åˇããīŧã
č¨ããĒãããä¸ãįŦã¯åŖå
ãĢįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻããã
ãåĸãã§č¨ãŖããããããĒããŽã§ãé ãåˇããã¨ããéĸäŋãĒãã§ããã
ããĒããģãŠãä¸ãįŦã¯ãããŧããĢãŽä¸ã§æãįĩãã ããæģåŖãããŽãã¨ãčǰããčãããã īŧã
ãæããåŋ
čĻã¯ãĒãã§ãããã
ãããã ããããŖã¨ãåŽæ°¸ããã ãããã
æ¤åˇãä¸įŦįŽãčĻéãããŽãčĻãĻãä¸ãįŦã¯įŦãŖãã
ãåãããããååŋããããã¨ããããŠãĒãæ¤åˇãããžããčãããŽã¯ãåŽæ°¸ãããŽč§Ŗéã ãåŊŧãããæããŖãĻããä¸įãŽčŠąããããã ããããžãã¯äģãį˛žįĨįãĢäŊčŖããĒããããäŋēãæĒč
ãĢäģįĢãĻã芹ãäŋĄãããããĒãŖãĻããããã ããŽãã¨ãĒãã ãã
ãããããæå¸ãããĢããĻããã¨ã¯ãĒããĒãã§ããīŧã
ãč¨ãŖãããäŋēã¨æå¸ãĄããã¯âĻâĻã
ãäģãåãŖãĻãžããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããããĒåĻåŽããžããã
ãæŦåŊãĢãããč¨ãŖããŽããĒã
ãâĻâĻīŧããŠãããæåŗã§ããīŧã
ãããžãč¨ãããã¯ãĒãããŠãããžããããč§Ŗéããã ããŖãĻå¯čŊæ§ã¯ãĒããīŧã
ãäģãåãŖãĻããŖãĻč¨ãŖããŽããäģãåãŖãĻãĒãã¨č§ŖéãããŖãĻãã¨ã§ããīŧãããããžããã
ããĒãã§ããããĒããŖãĻč¨ãåããīŧã
ããĒãã§ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãčĒåã§ã¯æ°ãĨããĻãĒããããããĒãããŠãããžããããŖããã¤ããããįžåŽãåãå
ĨãããŽãčžãããĻãčĒåãŽéŊåãŽãããããĢæĒããĻãã
ããããĒããâĻâĻīŧã
ãæģåŖãããããč¨ãŖãã
æ¤åˇã¯ãäģåēĻã¯čĒåã§ãåãããģãŠãéĄãåŧãæŖãŖãã
ãæģåŖããããŖãĻãåŊŧã¯âĻâĻã
ãæģåŖããããčĒåãŽč¨ãŖããã¨ãããŖãĻããã¨ãåãããĒããĒãŖãĻãäģãŽããžããŋãããĢãäŋēãč˛ŦãããããŠæåžãĢã¯ãįč§ŖããĻããããã
ãäŊãįč§ŖãããŖãĻãããã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäŋēãæĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒããčĒåãŽč˛Ŧäģģã ãŖãĻãã¨ã ãã
ãâĻâĻéãīŧãæģåŖãããč˛ļãããŽã¯ãããã īŧãå¨å˛ãĢåãæĩããĻâĻâĻã
ãäŊãčãããŽãåãããĒãããŠãåãããĒãããäŋēã¯ãæģåŖããã¨éŖ˛ãŋãĢčĄãŖãæãĢãåŊŧãč¨ãŖãĻããã¨ããŋããĒãĢäŧããã ãããããŖãĻãäŋēãæĒããŖãĻãã¨ãĒãŽãīŧãäŋĄé ŧãå¤ąããããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖããŽã¯æģåŖãããĒãŽãĢã
ãåŽå
¨ãĒåãããĒãâĻâĻæģåŖãããč¨ãŖããã¨ãæĒããĻäŧãããåŽå
¨ãĒåãĒããå¨ãã ãŖãĻäŋĄããĒããŖãã¨æããã§ããããããĒãããäŋĄããâĻâĻã
ãããã¯åãã¤ããã¨ã¯č¨ããĒãããããĒããīŧãäŋēãæãããã¨ããŋããĒãĢäŧããã ãã§ããããäŋĄããããŠããããŋããĒčĒčēĢãĒããã ãã
ãäŋĄé ŧãæŋããããŽã¯įĸēãã§ãããæĒãå°čąĄãæã¤ãããĒč¨ãæšãããĻâĻâĻæģåŖããčĒčēĢããčĒåãæĒãã¨æããããĢäģåãããã ã
ãäģäŋēãããĻãããã¨ããããã¨åãã ãŖãĻč¨ãããīŧã
ãč¨ãããã¨ããããããŽã¨ããã§ããã
ãããæããããĒããããã§ããããã§ããããŽæãčžŧãŋã¯ããžããŽãããĢã¯ãĒããĒãã¨æããæŧéãŽãã¨ã ãŖãĻãå¨å˛ã¯ããžãããããããĒãŖãã¨æãŖãĻããæå¸ãĄããã¨ãŽãã¨ãããŖãĻãããäģĨåãĢãåĸããĻåŖæ°ãæ¸ãŖãĻãäēæĨéæŦ å¤ããĻãããããĢãããããĒãŖããããã§äģæĨãŽããã ããŋããĒåŖãĢã¯åēããĒãããŠãããžããį
ãã§ãã¨æãŖãĻããããããĒãããããããļãæãŖãĻãã¨ãäŋēã¯æããéąæĢã¯å°ãããŽããŗããããģããããããããĒããīŧãčĒįļãĢč§Ļããã¨ãĄãŗãŋãĢãŽįļæ
ã¯č¯ããĒãããããã
ãããããŖãĻãäŋēãčĒåãĢįããæã¤ãããĢäģåãããã âĻâĻæģåŖãããĢãããããããĢâĻâĻã
ãã ãããéããŖãĻâĻâĻã¨ããŖãĻããããžãã¯åãå
ĨããĒããã ãããĒãé°čŦčĢãäŋĄããĻããžãŖãäēēã¯ããããããĒããŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻãčããĒãããããŠãäŋēã¯ããžããäŋĄããĻãããæ¤åˇãäģã¯åˇéããå¤ąãŖãĻãããŠãåŋ
ãæģããŖãĻãããžãã¯ãããã§ããäēēéã ããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãããĻãã¨č¨ãŖãĻįĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ããããã帰ãããææĨãäģäēã ããįĄį ã¯ãĄããã¨åãŖããģãããããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãčãåããŽãĒãåŧããããã§ãčĻåŽãå
ãŽãããĒ襨æ
ãåããĻãããžãææĨãĒãã¨ãäŧč°åޤãåēãĻããŖãã
ãâĻâĻã
æ¤åˇã¯ããšãããããąããããåēããĻįĸēčĒããã¨ãįĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
č¨ããšããã¨ã¯č¨ãããč¨ãããããããå¯čŊæ§ãčããĻããããæãŖãäģĨä¸ãĢ芹ããâĻâĻããæããŽãĢãããããããŽã¯čĒåã§ã¯ãĒããâĻâĻãã¨ããåŖ°ãããããããä¸ãįŦãŽãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧãŽææŗã ã¨åããŖãĻããĻããčĒåãĢ寞ããįåŋĩã¯æš§ãã
æãã垎ããĢéããĻããã
äŊãĢ寞ããéããĒãŽãåãããĒãããããŧããĢãæŧããããããĢããĻãįĄįããæĸããã¨ã大ããæ¯ãåãåēããã
īŧåãģãŠãããŽãžãžäŧč°åޤãĢæŽãããĒããŖãšãĢæģãŖãã¨ããĢã¯ãį§åąąäģĨå¤ã¯čǰãããĒããŖãã
ããŠãã ãŖãīŧã芹ããĻãŋãĻã
ããã°ãčč˛ ãŖãĻ帰ããã¨ããã¨ãį§åąąãč¨ãŖãã
ãåĨãĢâĻâĻäŋēãŽæčĻã¯å¤ãããžããã
ãä¸ãįŦãåŋé
ããĻãããå°ãæéãããããããããĒãã¨ã
æ¤åˇã¯čä¸ãåãããžãžãæŗããããæĄãŖãã
ãå¤ąį¤ŧããžãã
åŽļãĢ帰ãŖãĻããã¨ãããã¨ãããŽãįŽįŠãããĻãããã°ãæããĻããããĢč °ãä¸ããããæŦĄã¯ãŠãããã°ãããâĻâĻåããĒãé ã§čããĻããã¨ããšãããéŗ´ãŖãã
-6-
ããŦãããĢããĄãŽååã¯åžãããĒãã
åēå ´ãĢéãžãŖãä¸äēēãĢåããĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãSSRãåŖããäģãã§ãããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãĻãã¨īŧã
ãĸãģãããčããã
ãããŖãšããŧãã¯ãčĒåããĄãŽããæšã§ãä¸ãįŦãĢ寞åŋããæšæŗãčããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãããŠãæåž
ã¯ã§ããĒããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯éĻãæ¯ãŖãããäŋēéã§ãĒãã¨ãããĒãã¨ãæŦäŊãŽæãã¨äŋēéãŽæãã¯ä¸č´ããĻãã
ãã§ããããĒãåäģã ããâĻâĻãããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãããæģåŖãããŽäģļãč¨ãŖãĻããææŗãĢã¤ããĻč¨ãŖãĻããå
¨įļåããĻãĒããŖãã
ãå
¨įļã§ã¯ãĒãã¨æãããŠãĒīŊã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãã
ãåæēããĻããããĢčĻããã¨īŧã
ãå°ãã ããŠããįŗåãéãããããĢčĻãããã襨æ
ãå°ãåããĻããã
ãįãã¨ãããįĒããĻããŽã¯ééããĒããã ã¨æããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããã§ãå¨å˛ãĢæ°ãĨããããģãŠã¯ãããĒãã
ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãŠãåãã¨æãīŧããĸãģãããč¨ãŖãããäŊãããĒããŖãĻãã¨ã¯ãĒãæ°ããããã ããŠâĻâĻã
ããããããããĒãããŠãä¸åŠãĒįļæŗã¨ãč¨ããĒãããåããã¨ã§čĒåãŽéĻãįĩãããã¨ãĢããĒãããããĒãããĒã
ãã¤ãŗããč¨ãŖãã¨ããããĢã¤ãŦãŗãéŗ´ãéŋããã
ãããå¤ããīŧãäŊãâĻâĻã
ãåąãĢæģãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖããããã¤ã§ãéŖįĩĄã¯åãããããĢããĻããããäŋēéã§æŦäŊãåŽããĒãã¨ã
ãä¸ãįŦãâĻâĻīŧã
æå¸ãããŽéģ芹ã§ãæ¤åˇã¯į˛ããåŋããã¨åæãĢãåŋãĢéããčŊãĄãã
ãåŽļãŽčŋãã§æĨãĢåŖ°ããããããĻãæ¤åˇããã¨ããäģĨä¸éĸãããĒããģãããããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããããĒãĢããããĒč¨ãŖããŽīŧããããĢãåŽļãŽčŋããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãããããé åããĢãã§ãį§ãĢã¯ããčããããåŽļã¯ããļããããįĨãããĻãâĻâĻã
ãäŋēã¨éĸããŖããããŠããĒããŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãį§ãé
ˇãæãããããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããĒãã ããé
ˇãæããŖãĻâĻâĻæå¸ãããĢäŊãããã¤ãããĒãŽãâĻâĻīŧã
ååãĢåēãč¨čãĢãæ¤åˇã¯åĨĨæ¯ãåãã ã
ãããããč
ããã¤ããããâĻâĻã
ããŠãããĻâĻâĻã
ããīŧããŠãããĻãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããŠãããĻãããĒãã¨ãĢãĒãŖãĻããŽīŧãåŽļãžã§įšåŽãããĻãããŽäēēãããŖããäŊãããæ°ãĒãŽīŧīŧã
ãæå¸ããâĻâĻã
ãåŽļãåēããŽãã帰ãŖãĻããã¨ããæããŽâĻâĻæŠããĻãĻãčĻãããĻããããĒæ°ãããĻâĻâĻã
ãä¸ãįŦãŽįãã¯ãäŋēã ãâĻâĻã
ãããããĒãã§į§ãâĻâĻīŧã
č¨ããããĻãæå¸ã¯åŖãã¤ããã ã
ãããããã§ãâĻâĻã
æģ˛ãåŖ°ãĢãæ¤åˇã¯åĨĨæ¯ãĢåãčžŧããã
ãæå¸ããã¯äŊãæĒããĒããäŋēããĒãã¨ãããâĻâĻã
ããŠããããŽâĻâĻīŧã
ãä¸ã¤ãååããĻãģãããã¨ããããã ã
įŦŦīŧ芹ãå ąéãŽįŽį
-1-
éŗ´ãéŋããããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¯ãæå¸ã¨čŠąããĻããããĄãĢæĸãŋãåąå
ã¯čŊãĄįããããããĨãĸãŗãšããĄã¯čĩ°ãåãŖãĻããã
æéããããã°ãä¸ãįŦãĢ寞įãčŦããããå¯čŊæ§ãéĢããæå¸ãåãŖãĻããžããããããĒãã
ãææĨã ã
æŦäŊãį ããĢčŊãĄãé ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãåĨŗįĨååēå ´ãĢéãžãŖãä¸äēēãĢč¨ãŖãã
ããĸãģãããåžãŽãã¨ã¯čããĒããĻãããææĨãä¸ãįŦã¨å¯žåŗããã¨ãããããĢå
¨åãæŗ¨ãããããĢäēįŽé
åãčĒŋæ´ããĻãģããã
ãä¸ãįŦããĒãã¨ãã§ããã°ãããŽãã¨ãĢåããĻãããâĻâĻãããĒã¨ãããããã
ãããã
ãã§ãããããĒãĢããžãããããĒâĻâĻãããĄã¯ããč¨ãŖãããä¸ãįŦããŠãåãããä翏Ŧãå¤ããĒããããĢããčĒäŋĄããĒãâĻâĻã
ãį§ã¨ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽäŋĄããĻããããĄã¯ããããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąã¯ãSSRãåĸãããããĒå åˇĨã¯ãããĻãĒãããããäŊŋãã°ãä¸ãįŦãŽčĄåã¯ä翏Ŧã§ãããã
ãã§ãâĻâĻã
ãæŦäŊãããŖãĻããį¯įŊĒåŋįåĻãŽįĨčãäŊŋãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãŖãã
ãã§ãä¸ãįŦã¯į¯įŊĒč
ã§ã¯ãĒããīŧãäŧŧããããĒããŽãããããĒãããŠâĻâĻã
ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢã¯ãæŦäŊãčįŠããĻããããŽæãŽæ
å ąããããããããããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧãĢã¤ããĻčĒŋãšãããĻãĒããĻããį¯įŊĒč
įãĒæčãĒãŽã¯ééããĒãã
ãåŋį¨ãåšããŖãĻãã¨ãã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ãããã ãčŋŊã芰ããããã°åŋ
ããããåēããä翏ŦããĻãä¸įãå´Šããã°ãčǰã ãŖãĻåæēãããä¸ãįŦãŽãããĒãŋã¤ãã¯įšãĢãåŖããããã¨æãã
ãåŽã¯čãīŧã
ãããæãã
ããããããĒããã ããããĄã¯ãã¯ããæ¯ãã¤ãããããããããĒããããããĒããããã čĒäŋĄããĒãã¨ãããâĻâĻã
ãäŋēéã ãŖãĻãįĩļ寞ãĢããžãããã¨æãŖãĻããããããĒãããããĒãã¨æŦäŊãåŽããĒããã ãããããããã ãã ãã
ãããããã°ãããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇããĄã¯ãŠãããĻããŽīŧãããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãããããĄãŽããŖãšããŧããããSSRãåŖããĻããä¸åēĻãéĄåēããĻãĒããã ããåąãĢã
ããŦãããĢãããčĻãĻãĒããĒã
ããã¤ãŗãããã¯åąãĢããããã§ãäŊãč¨ããĒãããäŊãããĒããåããäģäēããĻããĻããčĒåã ãäŊãčĻãĻãĒãããčãããĻãĒããŋãããĢåē§ãŖãĻãã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇã¯ãåąéˇåޤãĢéããããŖããžãžãã
ããžããããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãã厤ãŽäŋŽįã§ãããĻããŽãīŧã
ãããã¯ãĒãã¨æããį´ããĒãå´čŋãæäŧãã¯ãã ããŠãåŊŧãã¯į§ã¨ä¸įˇãĢäģäēããĻããã
ãããããĒãã¨čããĻãĒããããããããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãããææĨãéĒéããããããžããĒããã
ãæ°ãĢã¯ãĒãããŠããããžã§čĻæããĻãäŊčŖã¯ãĒããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãããäŋēéããããããäŧããã
ãããããåããĒãã¨ã
ãĸãģãããč¨ãŖãã
ãææĨãå
¨åã§ãããīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãåŗæãåˇŽãåēãã
ãããããããããŖãĻãŋããâĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ããåŗæãäŧ¸ã°ããã
ãããããäŋēéã§ã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¨ãĸãģãããåŗæãäŧ¸ã°ããåäēēã¯æãéãããžãžããäēããŽéĄãčĻåãŖãĻé ˇããåēå ´ãéĸããã
-2-
æå¸ã¨čŠąããįŋæĨã
æ¤åˇã¯ãå°ãį˛å´æãæŽãŖããžãžįŽčĻããã
æ°æéåžãŽãã¨ãčããã¨ãčļŗã¯éããåæĨãĢããŖããčããĻãæĨéąãĢããã°ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããæå¸ãĢã¯éĸãããĒãã§æŦ˛ããã¨é ŧãã°ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããâĻâĻ
ããĒãâĻâĻããã¯ãĒãâĻâĻīŧã
æĩŽããã§ããč¨čãåŧžããããĢãé Ŧã严æã§åŠãã¨ãéĄãĢæ ãčĒåãŽįŽãčĻãã
ãâĻâĻã
čĻæã¯æąēããã
ãŠããĒįĩæãĢãĒãŖãĻããæå¸ã ãã¯âĻâĻ
æēãããããĢãĒãįŽãį¨ããããĢčĻãĻãããä¸åēĻé ŦãåŠãã¨ãæēåãæ¸ãžããĻåŽļãåēãã
ãâĻâĻã
įŠēã¯æãŖãĻããã夊æ°äēå ąã§ã¯ãååžããã¯æ´ããâĻâĻãããããŽãã¨ãčããã¨ããããĒãĩããĢã¯æããĒããŖãããåã¯æãããĢé§
ãĢåããŖãã
ããã¯ããããããžãã
ãã¤ããã10åãģãŠæŠãįããĻãããã°ãå¸ãĢįŊŽãã¨ãį§åąąãŽã¨ãããžã§æŠããã
ããã¯ããããããžããį§åąąčǞéˇã
ãããããã¯ããããĒãã īŧãããããå¸ãžã§ã
ããéĄãããããã¨ãããŖãĻã
į§åąąã¯įãã˛ããããããŠããĒãã¨ã īŧã
ãæ¨æĨãŽãã¨ã§ãããŧã ãŽãŋããĒã¨ä¸ãįŦãããĢčŦãããã¨æãŖãĻãããŽä¸ã§ãčĒåããĒããããĒãĩãã ãŖããŽãčĒŦæããĻãä¸åŽããĒãããĻãããããã§ãããžã å°ãä¸åŽåŽãĒææãįļããããããĒãããŠãåããŖãĻããã°ããŋããĒãåãå
Ĩããããã¨æãŖãĻã
ãâĻâĻãĒããģãŠãĒãããžããĒããĢčãããããã
ãã¯ãã
ãåããŖããæĨããŽå¯žåŋãä¸ã¤ãããĒãã¨ãããĒãããã10æãããĢããããäŧč°åޤã¯åãŖãĻããĄãŗããŧãĢäēåŽãéŖã°ããĻããã
ããããã¨ãããããžãã
æ°äēēãŽãããĢé ãä¸ããã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯å¸ãĢæģãŖãĻããŊãŗãŗãéããããŖããã䏿ŦæãŖãã
īŧæãĢãĒãã¨ãä¸ãįŦãåĢãããĄãŗããŧå
¨åĄãåēå¤ããĻãäģäēãå§ãããįĒįļå
ĨãŖãĻããäēåŽãčĻãĻãããã¯ãĒãã ããããã¨éĻãåžããĻããč
ãããããį§åąąãĢčããĢčĄãč
ã¯ããĒãããããĒæ§åãčĻįãŽį̝ãĢåããĒãããæ¤åˇã¯äŧč°åޤã§ãŽäŧ芹ããˇããĨãŦãŧãˇã§ãŗããĻããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãã¤ããŠããâĻâĻäģãŽã¨ãããäŊãæ°ãããã¨ãäģæããĻããæ§åããĒããæ¨æĨãŽãã¨ã§äŊããč¨ãŖãĻããæ°é
ããĒãã
10æãĢãĒãã¨ãį§åąąãäŧč°åޤãĢį§ģåããåŖããããĢããĄãŗããŧãå¸ãįĢãŖããæ¤åˇã¯ãšãããããąãããĢå
ĨããĻãäŧč°åޤãĢåããŖãã
ããããĒãã¨ãžã§ããĒããĻãããã ãããĢâĻâĻãããžãæã芰ãããĒãã
æ°æŠé
ããĻæŠããĻããä¸ãįŦããčŗå
ã§åããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ã大äēãĒãã¨ã§ãããã
ãããžããŽããããã¨ãããããã¨æããã
čģŊãčŠãåŠããä¸ãįŦã¯äŧč°åޤãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãããæ¤åˇã¯å
¨åĄãæãŖãĻãããŽãįĸēãããĻãããããĸãéããã
ãåŋããä¸ãæĒããĒããŋããĒãå
¨åĄãå¸ãĢã¤ãããŽãįĸēčĒããĻãį§åąąã¯č¨ãŖãããâæ¨æĨâãŽãã¨ã§ãããŧã å
ããŽã¯ãˇãŖã¯ããĒããããĢã¨æãŖãĻãéãžãŖãĻãããŖããæ¤åˇčĒčēĢããčĒŦæããããŖãĻãã¨ã ãŖãããã
å
¨åĄãŽčĻįˇãæ¤åˇãĢéãžããããšã¯ãŽä¸ã§ãčãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽããæãŽæãéããâĻâĻ
ãæčŋå°ããį˛žįĨįãĢ大å¤ãĒãã¨ãå¤ããŖããŋããã ãããå¯åŽšãĢåãæĸããĻããŖãĻãģãããããŧã ã¨ããĻéŖæēããĻãããã¨ã大äēã ãããĒã
č¨ãįĩããã¨ãį§åąąã¯æ¤åˇãčĻãã
ããããæ¤åˇã芹ãããīŧã
ãã¯ãã
é ˇããĻãéããæãã¤ããŖãĻããããšãããåãåēããĻããšã¯ãĢįŊŽããã
ããžããæ¨æĨã¯ãé¨ããããĻããŋãžããã§ãããį§åąąčǞéˇãč¨ãŖããããĢãæčŋå°ãâĻâĻããĒããããã¤ãã¨ãéãĒãŖãĻâĻâĻãããããĒãŖãĻãã¨æããžãã
é ãä¸ããĻæ˛éģããæ¤åˇãĢãčǰããååŋã§ãããä¸ãįŦãäŊãč¨ããã¨ããįŦéãæ¤åˇã¯éĄãä¸ããã
ãã§ããæ¨æĨ芹ãããã¨ã¯ããšãĻãæŦåŊãŽãã¨ã§ãã
ããŽįēč¨ãäēæŗå¤ã ãŖããŽããį§åąąã¯įŽãčĻéããĻãčģŊãåŖãéããĻããã
ããžãã¯ããããčããĻãã ããã
æ¤åˇã¯ãšãããæäŊããĻãé˛éŗãããéŗåŖ°ãåįããã
ãæģåŖãããŽãã¨ãčǰããčãããã īŧã
äŧč°åޤãĢéŗåŖ°ãéŋãæ¸Ąãã¨ãæåãĢåŖãéãããŽã¯ä¸ãįŦã ãŖãã
ãæ¤åˇããŠãããã¤ããã īŧãä¸ãįŦã¯ãįããææ°ãåĢãã åŖ°ãåããããæ¨æĨ芹ãããã¨ãé˛éŗããĻããŽãīŧã
ãäŊãä¸éŊåããããã§ããīŧãæ¤åˇã¯ä¸ãįŦãĢäŊãåããããä¸ãįŦãããŽč¨ãŖãĻããã¨ãæŖãããĒããããããŋããĒãĢčããĻãããŖããģããããã¨æããžãããŠã
ãããžãâĻâĻīŧã
ãčŊãĄįãã
įĢãĄä¸ãããããä¸ãįŦãčĻãĻãį§åąąãåļããã
ãåæãĢé˛éŗãããã¨ã¯åéĄã ã¨æããã芹ãããã¨ãĢåããĒããĒãä¸éŊåã¯ãĒãã¨ãããŽã¯ãæ¤åˇãŽč¨ãã¨ããã ãįļããčããã
ããããã¨ãããããžãã
æ¤åˇã¯ãä¸åēĻæĸããéŗåŖ°ãåįããã
芹ã¯įļããĻããããŠãč§Ŗéããã°ãããŽãåãããĒããĄãŗããŧã¯ãįãã˛ãããĻéģãŖãĻããã
ãããããæå¸ãããĢããĻããã¨ã¯ãĒããĒãã§ããīŧã
ãč¨ãŖãããäŋēã¨æå¸ãĄããã¯âĻâĻã
ãäģãåãŖãĻãžããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããããĒåĻåŽããžããã
ãæŦåŊãĢãããč¨ãŖããŽããĒã
ãâĻâĻīŧããŠãããæåŗã§ããīŧã
ãããžãč¨ãããã¯ãĒãããŠãããžããããč§Ŗéããã ããŖãĻå¯čŊæ§ã¯ãĒããīŧã
ãäģãåãŖãĻããŖãĻč¨ãŖããŽããäģãåãŖãĻãĒãã¨č§ŖéãããŖãĻãã¨ã§ããīŧãããããžããã
ããĒãã§ããããĒããŖãĻč¨ãåããīŧã
ããĒãã§ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãčĒåã§ã¯æ°ãĨããĻãĒããããããĒãããŠãããžããããŖããã¤ããããįžåŽãåãå
ĨãããŽãčžãããĻãčĒåãŽéŊåãŽãããããĢæĒããĻãã
æ¤åˇã¯ããã§ãéŗåŖ°ãæĸããã
ããŋãĒãããčããã¨æããžããä¸ãįŦããããæå¸ã¨ããåĨŗæ§ã¨äģãåãŖãĻããã¨ãã芹ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŋēãŽåéã§ãä¸ãįŦããã¯ä¸åēĻã ãäŧãŖããã¨ããããžããã§ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽä¸ãįŦãããĢ寞ããčŠäžĄã¯ãâãĒããã¤ã¤ãĒæããããäēēâã§ããäģãåããĒããĻããããžããã
ãããã¯ããžããŽéĄæã ãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãé˛éŗéŗåŖ°ãŽä¸ã§ãããč¨ãŖãĻãžãããæ¤åˇã¯č¨ãŖãããããããįĸēãããĻãŋãžãããã
äŊãâĻâĻīŧãã¨ããįåããå
¨åĄãŽéĄãĢįããæĩŽããļãŽãčĻãĒãããæ¤åˇã¯ãšãããčŗãĢåŊãĻãã
ãæå¸ããīŧã
æ¤åˇãååãåŧãļã¨ãä¸ãįŦãŽéĄã¯ããããĒã¨éããããåŗčļŗãä¸ä¸ãĢåãããããšã¯ãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽãããåˇĻæã¯æŗãæĄãããĻããã
ããšããŧãĢãŧãĢãããã
æ¤åˇã¯ããšãããããŧããĢãĢįŊŽãã¨ããšããŧãĢãŧãŽããŧã¯ããŋããããã
ããŋãĒãããã¯ãããžããĻãæ¤åˇãããŽãåéãŽâĻâĻ大éæå¸ã§ããããããĒč¨ããžããį§ã¯ä¸ãįŦããã¨äģãåãŖãĻããžãããåŽļãŽčŋããžã§ããããĻãæ¨æĨã¯æĨãĢåŖ°ããããĻããĻãæ¤åˇããã¨ã¯čˇéĸãåãŖããģããããã¨č¨ãããžããã
å
¨åĄãŽčĻįˇããä¸ãįŦãĢéãžãã
ãä¸ãįŦãããžãâĻâĻããŽčŠąã¯æŦåŊãīŧã
į§åąąãč¨ãŖãã
ãéããžããããĒãã§äŋēããããĒãšããŧãĢãŧãŋãããĒįäŧŧâĻâĻããĢããĻãžãããã ããããäģ芹ããĻãâæå¸âãŖãĻåäšãŖãĻãåĨŗããäŋēã¨äģãåãŖãĻãæå¸ã¨åä¸äēēįŠã ãŖãĻč¨ŧæ ããĒãã
ãããããä¸ãįŦãããŽããæå¸ããã¨éŖįĩĄãåãŖãĻãŋãĻãã ãããäģããã§ãæ¤åˇã¯č¨ãŖãããããŖãããŽããåããčĻããã ãã§ããããæäēēååŖĢãŽããŽãĒããĻäģäēēãĢčĻããããŽãããĒãâĻâĻæŽéã¯ããã§ãããŠãäģããŽå ´ãĢéãŖãĻã¯ãä¸ãįŦãããŽæŊįŊãč¨ŧæãããããäģĨä¸ãĒãč¨ŧæ ãĢãĒããžãã
ããĩããããĒâĻâĻīŧãä¸ãįŦã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻããšã¯ãåŠãããããĒãã§äŋēããšããŧãĢãŧãĒããĻããĒãããĒããĒãīŧãčĒæãããĒããšããŧãĢãŧããããģãŠã¤ã¤åĨŗãĒãŽããã
ãããåĨŗã§ãããæå¸ããã¯ãæ¤åˇã¯ãåŖ°ãŽéããããŽãžãžãĢįļããããæãæããããĻããŽãĢãäŋēãäŋĄããĻãããâĻâĻããããŽãããĢäēēãæããã¨ãããĢæĨããĻããããæ°æãĄãåŧãļãããĒãã¨ãããĒãâĻâĻį´ æĩãĒåĨŗæ§ã§ãã
ãããããâĻâĻããã100æŠč˛ãŖãĻãäŋēãæå¸ãĢäģããžã¨ãŖãĻãã¨ãããããĒããŽãããĢãããĒãã¨ãããīŧãäŋēãĢã¯ãĒããŽãĄãĒãããããīŧããĒãšã¯ãããã ãã ããĒãã§ãããĒâĻâĻã
ãäŋēãæãŖãĻãįæŽēä¸åĨĒãŽæ¨ŠåŠãåĨĒãããã§ããããããã¯ãããæĨŊãããĻããããĒãâĻâĻããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¨ããäēēį¨ŽãŽäēēéã ããã īŧīŧã
ãããã¯äŋēãæģåŖãčĒæŽēããããŖãĻãã¨ãč¨ãŖãĻããŽãīŧãč¨ŧæ ã¯ããã ãããīŧīŧããããã§é°čŦčĢãããŠæããĻãããĢãŠãã¨åãã īŧīŧã
ãįĸēããĢãįŠįč¨ŧæ ã¯ãããžãããããã¯č¨ŧæãããããĒããã§ãããããĢčŋãããŽãĒããããžããã
ãã¸ãīŧããããčĻããĻããã
ãåãããžããã
æ¤åˇãåãŗãšãããæãĢåãŖãĻãäŊããæãĄčžŧãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯åŗãŽé ŦãåŧãæŖããããããããããĒãâĻâĻčŗå
ãĢãããĒč¨čãæĩŽããã§ãããŽãčĻãããã§ãäŋĄããããĻããĒãâĻâĻįĨãŖãĻãããããããæčĻãĒããäŊåēĻãåŗããŖãĻããã
ä¸ãįŦãĢčĻįˇãåããããžãžãšãããįŊŽãã¨ãäŧč°åޤãŽããĸãéããã
ãå¤ąį¤ŧããžãã
ãããĢã¯ãåŽæ°¸ãããã
ãæ¤åˇããããéŖįĩĄãããããžãããį§ã¯ãä¸ãįŦã¨æģåŖãããåãé¨įŊ˛ãĢããã¨ããä¸įˇãĢäģäēãããĻãããŽã§ãåŊæãŽįļæŗãįĨãŖãĻããžãã
ããããĒãããããžããŽä¸ģčĻŗã§ãããĒãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã¯åĻåŽã§ããžãããã ãããŋãĒãããĢčĻãĻãģãããã§ããã
åŽæ°¸ã¯ãä¸ãįŦã¨ä¸åŽãŽčˇéĸãįŊŽããĒããč¨ãŖãã
ããĒãĢãâĻâĻã
åŽæ°¸ã¯æ¤åˇãŽåžããžã§æŠãããšãããããĢããšã¯ãĒãŧãŗãĢããĻãæģåŖã¨ãŽããŖãããŽããåããäŧč°åޤãŽåæšãĢæ ããã
čĒæŽēãŽį´åãžã§ãæģåŖãåŽæ°¸ãĢį¸čĢããĻããææ
ããįã
ããæĩŽãä¸ãããå
¨åĄãæ¯ãéŖ˛ãã ããã ä¸äēēãé¤ããĻã
ããããåŽĸčĻŗįãĒč¨ŧæ ãĢãĒããŖãĻč¨ããããŽãīŧãä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖããããããčĻãĻããžããããŠãæããã¨ãä¸ģčĻŗã§ãããĒãããããĒããŽã§âĻâĻã
ãããããåŽĸčĻŗįãĒæčĻãčããĻãŋãžããããæ¤åˇã¯č¨ãŖãããããŖããŽé˛éŗããŧãŋãæģåŖãããŽãã¨ãæå¸ããã¸ãŽåĢããããäŋēãĢ寞ãããããžã§ãŽæ
åēĻããããĻåŽæ°¸ãããŽãšãããĢæŽãããŖãããŽããåãâĻâĻããããįĩąåããĻãAIãĢåæããĻããããžãããããããŽčĄåãããĻããäēēįŠãĢã¯ããŠãããįšåž´ãčĻããããã
æ¤åˇã¯ãšãããæ˛ããĻãåæįĩæãAIãĢčĒãŋä¸ããããã
ãããã ããžããæ å ąãåæããįĩæããčĻããäēēįŠã¯ãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¨åŧã°ããįšæ§ãæãŖãĻããã¨čããããžããããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¯ãããäēēãŽããĒãããĻčŋãĨããäŋĄį¨ãããĻããæãããŋãŧã˛ãããčŋŊãčžŧãã§ãããŋã¤ãã§ããããčŋããĢããããäēēįŠãããå ´åã¯ãæŠæĨãĢčˇéĸãįŊŽããã¨ã寞įã¨ãĒããžãããžããããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¯ãŋãŧã˛ãããå¤įĢãããčĒåãĢäžåãããããĒãįļæŗãäŊãã ããã¨ãããã¨ããããããäŋĄé ŧã§ããåäēēããåįå´åįãč¨įŊŽããĻããį¸čĢįĒåŖãĒãŠãĢéŖįĩĄãããã¨ããå§ãããžãã
ãåäēããŠããŋãããĒįŠįč¨ŧæ ã¯ãĒããĻããããããŽčĄåãčĒŋãšãã°ãčǰã§ãåéĄãããã¨æãããäŋēãæˇˇäšąãããĻãäŊãæŦåŊãĒãŽãåãããĒããããĻãæ¯é ããĻãčĒæŽēããããŖãĻã˛ãŧã ãčããĻãããã ããâĻâĻãĒããŽéĸäŋããĒãæå¸ãããžã§åˇģãčžŧãã§âĻâĻã§ãããããŽæŖäŊã¯ãŋããĒãĢįĨãããīŧãããããŽč˛ ãã īŧã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãčĻįˇãä¸ä¸åˇĻåŗã¸ã¨æēãããĒãããå¨å˛ãĢčããããģãŠå¤§ããčããåŧå¸ãããĻããã
ãå°ã芹ãããīŧãä¸ãįŦãį§åąąãč¨ãŖãããæ¤åˇãŽčŠąãããšãĻäŋĄããĻãããŽããäŋēãĢã¯åãããĒããããŠãĒãããŽãžãžäŊãããĒããŖãĻãããĢããããĒããæ¤åˇãŽčŠąãæŦåŊãĒãâĻâĻã
ãã¯ãã§ããīŧã
ä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖããåŧå¸ã¯įŠēæ°ãĢæēļãčžŧãŋãčĻįˇã¯åŽãžãŖãĻããã
ãčĒŋãšããããã§ããã芹ããŽãæ§ããžãããã§ãäģæĨã¯ããããã§ããīŧãæ°åãæĒããŽã§ã帰ãããĻããããžãã
ããããããŽåãĢå°ã芹ãâĻâĻã
ãéããžããããäŋēã¯ãä¸ãįŦã¯įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻãéĄã ããåžããĢåããããéããé ããããžããã
ä¸įŦįŽãåãŖãĻãä¸ããŖãåŖč§ãĢ坿°ãčĩ°ãŖãã
æãŖãäģĨä¸ãŽåŽå
¨ååŠãŽã¯ãâĻâĻãĒãŽãĢããŋãããĄãŽčžēãããéģį´ĢãŽé§ãå´ãåēããĻåēãããäŊå
¨äŊãåŧˇåŧĩãããĻããã
ãĒãã ãäŊããããã¨ããĻãâĻâĻīŧ
ä¸ãįŦã¯äŊãčããĻãâĻâĻīŧ
ããããæ¤åˇã大ä¸å¤Ģãīŧã
į§åąąã¯ãįĻįšãŽåããĒãįŽã§éããĻããæ¤åˇãŽčŠãæ´ãã ã
æ¤åˇã¯į§åąąãčĻãĻã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ããã¨č¨ãŖãããč¨čããčĻįãĢæ ãŖãĻããããŽãé ãæããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãŠããĢčĄãŖãīŧ
äŊãããæ°ã âĻâĻīŧ
åãããĒãâĻâĻããŖããŽčŠąãčĻããããĒããŽã¯åēããĒãã¯ãâĻâĻ
-3-
ããĄããŖã¨ããâĻâĻããēã¤ãīŧīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãįžå ´ãčĩ°ãåãŖãĻåąãĢæģãŖãĻããããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãåĻįãããããĢãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢæ
å ąãä¸ãããããĢäŊŋããŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãįąæ´čĩ°ãčĩˇãããããĢãĒãŖãĻãããåąåĄããĄããčĒåãäŊãããĻãããŽãææĄã§ãããã˛ãããæ
å ąãä¸ããĻããããį˛žæģãããĻããĒãã
ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēã§ã¯ãããĄã¯ããä翏ŦãŽįŽĄįãå§ããããčĻããã¨ããĒããģãŠįŽãžããããæ
å ąãå
ĨãæŋããįäŊãĸããŋãŧãŽæ åãĢããŠããčĻãĻãäŊãããã°ãããŽãåãããĒããĒãŖãĻããã
ä¸ãįŦãčŋŊã芰ãããžã§ã¯ãããĄã¯ãã¯ä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãéããĻä翏ŦãįĢãĻã大ããĒä翏ŦčĒ¤åˇŽãåēãããĢããããäģã¯éãįãŖæã§ãå
ãčĻããĒãã
ãããããĄã¯ãīŧãä翏ŦãæĸãããĒīŧīŧã
åæšãããæåŖ°ãĢčŋãåŖ°ãéŖãã§ããã
čãããĻããããäŊãåããĒãã
ãŠããĒãĢæ
å ąãįĩąåããĻããä¸ãįŦãŽâæŦĄâãčĻããĒãã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ãäģæĨãŽæããå§ŋãčĻããĻããããéŖįĩĄãã¤ããĒãã
ãŠãããīŧããŠãããã°ããâĻâĻ
ããĸãģãããããããäģĨä¸ã¯įĄįã âĻâĻīŧã
åąåĄãŽä¸äēēãč¨ãŖãã
ãļãģããŗã¯ã§ã¯ããĸãģãããŽæį¤ēãŽãã¨ãä¸ãįŦãčŋŊã芰ãããããĢäēįŽãå
¨æ¯ãããĻãįĩããŖããäŧæ¯ãĢå
ĨããäēįŽãįĸēäŋããã¤ããã ãŖããããããéãŽįŦãŋãã¨ããä¸ãįŦãŽįŊŽãåįŖãĢããŖãĻãäŧæ¯ãŠããã§ã¯ãĒããĒããããŽįįąãčĻã¤ãããããĢäēįŽãæ¯ãåããããįããčĻã¤ãããĒããžãžãäēįŽã¯åēãã¤ããããĻããã
ããžã ãīŧãä¸ãįŦãäŊããããã¨ããĻããŽãčĻæĨĩããĒãã¨âĻâĻã
ããããĒãã¨ãĢäŊŋãäēįŽã¯æŽãŖãĻãĒãīŧīŧãããŽãžãžããæŦäŊã¯åãããīŧããžãããŠãã¯ãĸãĻããããããŽãīŧīŧã
ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽæ
å ąãå
¨é¨čĒŋãšããã īŧãäŊãæããããĢãĒãããŽãããã¯ãã âĻâĻīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãį̝æĢæäŊãããĒããåĢãã ã
ãįĄįã âĻâĻīŧãäēįŽãčļŗããĒããĻãæ¤į´ĸãĢæéãããããããâĻâĻã
åąåĄãåĢãļã
ãããã§ããããããĒãâĻâĻã
ãSSRãããã°âĻâĻã
ãäģãŽįļæŗã¯SSRãããŖãĻãããĄã īŧããĒãã¨ãããĒãã¨âĻâĻããŽãžãžããæŦäŊããããĒãâĻâĻīŧã
ãããããĨãĢãŧãšâĻâĻããâĻâĻã
ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãŽå
¨åĄãåããæĸãããæ
å ąãéŠåãĢå åˇĨããĻä¸ãããããŽãŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãããéģãį
ãåēãĻããããˇãšãã ã¯åããĻããããį
ã¯åžã
ãĢåĸããĻããĻãåąãŽå¤ŠäēãčĻãå§ããĻããã
ããŠããããã ããĨãĢãŧãšâĻâĻã
ããŠããŖãĻãį§ã ãŖãĻããããĒããâĻâĻīŧãã§ãäŋŽįããĒãã¨âĻâĻã
ãˇãšãã ã¯į
ã§čĻããĒããĒãå§ããĻããã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯č
ã§éŧģãčĻããĒããčŋãĨãã
į
ãäŊå
ãĢå
Ĩãã¨ãčļŗå
ãæēããĻãčĻįãæããĢãĒãŖãã
īŧããēã¤ããããâĻâĻãˇãšãã ãŽã¨ãããžã§ãããĻããããããâĻâĻīŧ
åãĢåēããŽãæãčļŗãįĄįããåããã¨ãåēãĢčļŗãã¤ããįŦéãĢčĻįãæãŖãã
īŧãĻãŊâĻâĻäģãåããĻãå ´åããâĻâĻīŧ
čĻįãæããĢčŊãĄãĻããâĻâĻäŊãæ¯ãããã¨č
ãåããã¨ããčŊä¸ãæĸãžãŖãã
čĒåãŽæåŋã§ã¯ãĒãã
įļæŗãįč§Ŗã§ãããĢããã¨ãã°ã¤ãŖã¨äŊãčĩˇããããã
čä¸ãŽããããĢč
ããããčǰããåˇĻæéĻãæ´ãã§ããã
ããˇãšãã ãä¸åēĻæĸãããį
ãæĸãžãŖãĻãã寞åĻããã
é ä¸ããåŖ°ãããĻãįŽãéããã¨ããŖãšããŧããčĻããĻãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ååãĢéĸããã
ãããŖãšããŧãããããŠãããĻãããĢâĻâĻã
-4-
æ°åååã
æŦäŊãä¸ãįŦãčŋŊã芰ããĻããé ãããŖãšããŧãã¯ãã¨ãŧãĩã éåēĢ厤ãŽéŖãĢããå°é¨åąãĢããã
ãâĻâĻã
ãã¤ãĻäŧæŠåޤã¨ããĻäŊŋãããĻããããŽé¨åąã¯ãããŽåžįŠįŊŽãĢãĒããäģã§ã¯æ¤
åãæ°čã¨ãããŧããĢãä¸ã¤ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãŽããŧãŋããĸããã°ã ãŖãé ãŽããĄã¤ãĢãĒãŠãæŽĩããŧãĢãĢ芰ããããĻãįĄé äŊãĢįŊŽãããĻããã
å°ãåčãįŠēæ°ãĢéŧģã芰ãžãããĒãããããŖãšããŧãã¯ãåŖéãĢčŋŊãããããããŧããĢã¨æ¤
åãåŧãŖåŧĩãŖãĻããĻãä¸å¤ŽãĢįŊŽããĻåē§ãŖãã
SSRãŽå´ŠåŖã¯ãäēæŗã§ããĒããŖããæŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻããã¯ãčãéŖãįžåŽãŽįãŋãįˇŠåãããå¯ä¸ãŽææŽĩã ãŖããåģæĸãããã¨ãããã¨ã¯ããŖãããįĩåąã¯æŽãįļããéˇãåš´æãŽä¸ã§é ŧããããĢãĒããååąãŽããããŽä¸ã§ã¯ãčåã¨čãããããããĢãĒãŖãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšãŽč¨ããä¸č¯åĩ樊ããčįŠããããã¨ãåéĄãĢããĒããŖãããã§ã¯ãĒããããã§ããčǰãĢãæĸãããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒããŖãã
ããéįãããããįĩãããĢããã°ããâĻâĻæŦäŊã¯ãã¤ããåŋãŽįé
ã§ããæãŖãĻãããSSRãŽåĨĨæˇąããĢåãããããįãŋãåŽå
¨ãĢæļãåģããšã¤ãããŽãããĒãããããŖããããčǰãæĸãããã¨ããĒããŖããŽãããããĒãã
ãâĻâĻč¨ã荺ã ãĒã
ä¸ãŽéãããæåŖ°ãŽãããĒåŖ°ãčãããĻãé¨åąãå°ãæēããã
ãããžãããŖããããã大ããããã ã
åŋ
ãåŋ
čĻãĢãĒãâĻâĻSSRã¯ååģēãããâĻâĻãŠããã§ããæãŖãĻããããæ°äēēããĄã¯äēæŗãčļããĻįĒãé˛ãã§ãããæŦäŊãããŽãžãžå¤åããĻãããĒããããčĒåããĄã¯åŋ
čĻãĒãã
ãâĻâĻã
čãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽããåŗæãĢåãããããä¸äģŖäē¤äģŖã¯åŋ
ãčĩˇããããŽãã ãŖããæã貸ãã°ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããīŧããĒããããĒé¨åąãĢæĨãĻãä¸äēēã§čããĻãīŧ
ãâĻâĻīŧã
æĨãĢããĸãéããĻãããŖãšããŧãã¯æ¯ãčŋãŖãã
ããã¤ãŗãâĻâĻã
ãæãããããããã¯ã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ãé¨åąãčĻåããĒããįŽãį´°ããã
ãäŊãããĢããīŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯æ¤
åãæãŖãĻããĻãããŖãšããŧããŽåããå´ãĢåē§ãŖãããåããããããĒã¨ãããĢä¸äēēã§ãããĒããĻãæå¤ã ãã
ãSSRããĒããĒãŖãäģããããã¨ã¯ãĒãã¨æãŖãĻãĒã
ããŦãããĢã¯ãäģŖãããĢãĒãããŽãäŊããã¨ããĻããããŠãäģã¯ãˇã§ãŧããŽã¨ãããĢčĄãŖãĻãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯ãã¤ãŗããčĻãã
ãäŊãããĢčĄãŖããã īŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ãããĢã¯įããããååš´äģĨä¸åããĒãį§ã¨åããˇã§ãŧãã¨ãŦãããĢâĻâĻæŦäŊãå¯éãžãŖããã¨ãĢãåäēēã§éãžãŖãĻãããã芹ãããSSRãŽãĸã¤ããĸãæãã¤ãããŽããããŽé¨åąã ãŖããįŦãč¨ãŽãããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãæŦäŊããããæãã ããããæ°ãĨããã¨č¨ãŖããģãããããã
ãããâĻâĻãããæŖããã¨æãŖããæŦäŊãæããã¨ãããâĻâĻį§ããĄã¯æŦæĨããããããšãã ãæŦäŊãå¤åãæããĒãããããã§ãããããĢããã
ãäŋēéãŽããĻãããã¨ã¯ééãŖãĻããã¨č¨ããããŽãīŧãSSRãäŊãŖããã¨ã¯ééããããĒãã¨ããĻããčåãĢããĻããžãŖããŽã¯åéĄã ãŖãã¨īŧã
ãį§ããĄãæã¯ãæŦäŊãå¤ããããããĢããã°ãŖãĻããã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ããč¨ãŖãĻãããŖãšããŧããčĻãã
ãâĻâĻããã ãŖããããĒã
ãį§ãŽâĻâĻããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽåŊšįŽã¯ãä翏ŦčĒ¤åˇŽãå°ããããĻæŦäŊãåŽåŽããããã¨ã ãčĒ¤åˇŽã大ãããã°äēįŽãå¤ãæļč˛ģããããããå¤åã¨ã¯ãä翏ŦčĒ¤åˇŽãŽåĸåš
ã ãéŋãããšããã¨ã ããåŋ
čĻãĒãã¨ã§ãããããĒãŽãĢãã¤ãŽéãĢããį§ã¯ããããįŽãé¸ãããĻãããæŦäŊãå¤åãæãã§ãããããããĒããããĢåããĻããã
ãâĻâĻã
ãäģãæŦäŊããŠãããįļæŗãįĨãŖãĻãããīŧã
ãããžãããŖããã ããããŖããä¸ããæåŖ°ãčãããã
ããããããĄã¯ãããĄâĻâĻæ°äēēīŧäēēãååąãåãäģåãŖãĻããžãããŖãããã ã
ãæ°ãĢå
ĨããĒããīŧã
įŽãäŧãããã¤ãŗããčĻãĻãããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã ããæ°ãĢå
ĨããĒããã ãããããŖãšããŧãããã¨ã¯ãããĒææ
čĢã§æ¸ãžããĻããįļæŗãããĒãã
ããŠãããæåŗã īŧã
ãæåŖ°ãä¸ããŖããŽãæãŽéãäģãååąã¯ãããã¯ã ãä¸ãįŦãåģãéãĢæŽããä¸åŋĢãĒäŋĄåˇã¯ãåŽå
¨ãĢä翏Ŧä¸čŊã§ããæŦäŊã¯ãããã¯ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããæ°äēēããĄã¯ãĒãã¨ã寞åĻãããã¨ããĻãããčŋŊãã¤ããĻããĒãã
ãäŋēéãĢã¯éĸäŋãĒãã ãã
ãæŦåŊãĢããæããŽãīŧãåã¯ã
ãâĻâĻã
ãæ°æãĄã¯åããã¤ããã ãæ°äēēããĄãčĒåã§ããŖããã¨ãæŦäŊããããæãã ãį§ããĄãĢã¯éĸäŋãĒãâĻâĻã§ããããããĒããį§ããĄããæŦäŊãããŽãžãžįĩãããã¨ãæãã§ããããããĒããéããīŧã
ãæãããããĒãããããã¯åĨ´ããâĻâĻã
ãæ°ãĢå
ĨããĒãããåäēēįãĒææ
ãåĒå
ããĻäŊããããããŽã¨ããæĨãĻããžãŖãããåžæããã ããã
ãã ã¨ããããŠããããã īŧã
ãį§ã¯ãããĄã¯ãããĄãĢæã貸ãã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ããĸã¤ãããŽä¸ãĢäģããŖãĻãã¨ãīŧã
ãä¸ãä¸ããĒããæŦäŊãåŽãã¨ããå
ąéãŽįŽįãŽãããĢåããã ããããŖãšããŧãããããããããŠãŗãŽäŊčŖã¨ããããŽãããĒãããĒãåąéˇã¨ãå¯åąéˇã¨ãããããĒčŠæ¸ãã¯ãææŽįŗģįĩąãæ´įããĻåæģãĢåããããŽåŊšå˛ãĢéããĒãã
ãâĻâĻã
ãį§ã¯ãä¸ãįŦãäŊãããã¤ãããĒãŽããããŖããã ãâä翏Ŧâã§ããĻãããããŖããæ
å ąãį˛žæģãããããããĒãããįĸēč¨ŧã¯ãĒãããæŦäŊãŽæãŖãĻããįĨčãäŊŋãã°âĻâĻæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢããæ
å ąãäŊŋãã°ä翏Ŧå¯čŊã ãäēįŽã¯ããĒãäŊŋããã¨ãĢãĒãããããã¯ãˇã§ãŧããããžãããããŦãããĢãäģé ã¯ãããļã¤ããŧãēãĢæģãŖãĻãã¯ãã ã
ãéčã芹ã ãååãĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãéčãâĻâĻããã ãĒãį§ãããæããã§ãį§ã¯ãäš
ããļããĢæãæãåēãããããã¤ãŗãã¯ããĸãžã§æŠããĻãčä¸ãåãããžãžįĢãĄæĸãžãŖããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããŠããããã¯ãåãĢäģģããããŠãã
ä¸äēēãĢãĒãã¨ãããŖãšããŧãã¯ããŧããĢãŽä¸ã§æŗãæĄãŖããčļŗãå°åģãŋãĢä¸ä¸ããčĻįˇãåŽãžããĒãã
ãį§ããĄãæã¯ãæŦäŊãå¤ããããããĢããã°ãŖãĻããã
ãã¤ãŗããŽč¨čãéŋãã
ä¸åēĻæˇąåŧå¸ããĻãé¨åąãčĻåãã
äēååš´ãģãŠåããžã æŦäŊã10æŗãŽé ãæ¯čĻĒãŽč¨čããåŋãåŽããããĢäŊãŖãä翏ŦâĻâĻãããããSSRã¯å§ãžãŖãããã¤ãŗãããĄã¨åäēēã§čããĻãåŊæãŽåąéˇããĄãåãããäŊãä¸ããããããããŖã¨ãSSRã¯æŦäŊãŽæ ãæã ãŖãããããããããã ã¨æãŖãĻããâĻâĻã ãæŦäŊã¯å¤ãããã¨ããĻãããäŊããčĒåãŽãã¨ããåŽããĒããŖãčĒåãæ¨ãĻãĻã大åãĒäēēãåŽããããĢâĻâĻ
ãã¯ãŊâĻâĻīŧã
ããŧããĢãåŠãéŗããčããéŋãã
ãéčãâĻâĻããã ãĒãį§ãããæããã§ãį§ã¯ãäš
ããļããĢæãæãåēãããã
åģãéãŽãã¤ãŗãããä¸įŦæ¯ãčŋãŖãã¨ããŽéĄâĻâĻæãããŽé¨åąã§čŠąãåãŖãĻããé ãŽãããĒâĻâĻ
ãæ°ãĢå
ĨããĒããĒããŠãã¤ãããã¤ãã
įžæåģã
ãããŖãšããŧãããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãįŽįŠããč§ŖæžããããããĒãããŖãšããŧããįŽãŽåãĢãããŽãįč§Ŗã§ãããč¨čãĢ芰ãžãŖãã
ãäŋēããĒããããĢãããâĻâĻãããĒãã¨ã¯ãŠãã§ããããããŖãšããŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããæŦäŊã大å¤ãĒãã ããīŧãããããĒãããäģãåãŖãĻãããäŊãããã°ããīŧã
ãããŖãšããŧãããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯åŖ°ãæģ˛ãã§ãéããåãåŋ
æģãĢæããã
ããããã¨ãããããžãâĻâĻīŧīŧããžãã¯ãŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãâĻâĻã
ããˇãšãã æĸããžããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧããŽå´čŋãŽä¸äēēãč¨ãŖãã
ããŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ã¯äŋēãį´ããããžãããĄã¯å¤é¨ããå
ĨãŖãĻããæ
å ąãããšãĻéããĻãį̝æĢãĢä¸ããīŧããĸãĻãŦãã¯10äēēã ãæŽãã¯å
¨åĄãã¤ãŗãŦãã¨ããĻįžå ´ãåãŖãĻįãŽæ
å ąãããéããĻããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧããŽåˇäģ¤ã§ãåąåĄã¯ä¸æ°ãĢåãåēããã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšãããŖãšããŧãã¯éĄãåãããããĸãĻãŦããŽįĩąåļã¯ããžããĢäģģããããŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãį´ãŖãããããĢæ
å ąãä¸ãããã
ãã§ãã䏿°ãĢæ
å ąãä¸ãããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãâĻâĻã
ãåéĄãĒããããŖãšããŧãã¯ä¸įŦãåŖå
ãįˇŠãããããĸã¤ãããããããĒã
ãäŊãããĻãããĄã¯ãã
įĒįļæģãŖãĻãããã¤ãŗããčĻãĻãããĄã¯ãã¯čãåŧå¸ãŽãžãžéĄãåããã
ãé
åąåæĨãĢæããã¯ãã ãä翏Ŧã¯åˇéãĢãåˇéããĒããã°æŖããã¯ãĒãã¨ã
ããã¤ãŗãå¯åąéˇâĻâĻã
ãããŽåŧãŗæšã¯ããããããã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖãããäēæ
ãĢ寞åĻãããããĢãį§ããĄã¯ã§ããã ãæŖįĸēãĒä翏ŦãįĢãĻãĒããã°ãĒããĒããååãåŧãŗåãŖãĻéŖæēãåãåŋ
čĻãããããã¤ãŗãã§ããã
ããīŧãããããã¯âĻâĻã
ãåã¯æĩæãčĻãããã ãĒããããĒã¨ãã§ãããã¤ãŗãã¯éĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãĻãåŖå
ãįˇŠãããããã¤ãŗãããã¨åŧãšãæĩæãããŖãĻããããã¯åŊäģ¤ã ã
ãã¯ãã¯ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãã§ã¯ããĄã¯ãããããĢįļæŗãčĒŦæããĻãããį§ã¯čŠŗį´°ãžã§ææĄããĻããĒããäģãŽč
ã¯å
¨åĄãããļã¤ããŧãēã¨ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēãããŽæ
å ąãããšãĻéããĻãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãĢéããį´°ãããã§ãã¯ã¯ãããããšãĻã ã
ããã¤ãŗããããâĻâĻã
ãæåããĻããå ´åãããĒãããããĄã¯ãããã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖããããã¤ãããĻãããããĢãäēåŽãæããĻããã
ãâĻâĻã¯ãīŧīŧã
ããĸãģããããĸãģããã¯ãããīŧã
äēįŽãæ¯æ¸ããĻé ãæąããĻãããĸãģããã¯ãååãåŧã°ããĻéĄãä¸ãããčĻãã¨ãåąéˇåޤããåēãĻãããˇã§ãŧããåŖ°ãä¸ããĻããã
æ°ååããŦãããĢãå
ĨãŖãĻããĻäēäēēã§åēãĻããŖããã¨ãéēããéĄã§æģãŖãĻããĻåąéˇåޤãĢãããŖãĻããããäģã¯įéãããˇã¯ãæļããĻããã
ããĒãã§ããããâĻâĻäģã¯čŠąããĻãæéãâĻâĻã
ãĸãģããã¯ãˇã§ãŧããŽåãžã§æŠããĻæĸãžãŖãã
ãã ããããŽįļæŗã¯čããĻãããäģãŽäēįŽãŽįļæŗã¯īŧã
ãˇã§ãŧãã¯ã厍大ãĒãĸããŋãŧãæ ãåēããčēĢäŊäēįŽãŽææ°ãããŠãĒã¨čĻãĒããč¨ãŖãã
ãããããģã¨ããŠæŽãŖãĻãžããâĻâĻå°ãĒãã¨ããäģæŦäŊãį´éĸããĻããįļæŗãĢ寞åĻã§ãããģãŠãŽäēįŽã¯âĻâĻã
ãã§ã¯ãŠãããīŧã
ããŠããããŖãĻâĻâĻãã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããäŊŋãæ°ã§ããīŧãããã¯âĻâĻã
ãããã¯åŖããããSSRã¨å
ąãĢããˇã§ãŧãã¯éĻãæ¯ãŖãããã ããžã ãå¯čŊæ§ã¯æŽãŖãĻããã
ããĒãã§ãããå¯čŊæ§ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãé常ãĒããäēįŽãæ¯æ¸ããã°æŦäŊã¯åããã¨ãčãããã¨ãã§ããĒããĒããäģãŽã¨ãããäēįŽãčŖåŽãããæ°é
ããĒããã ããããĸãģãããäēēéã¨ããããŽã¯ãäēįŽãåŽå
¨ãĢå°Ŋããããã¨æããã¨ãã§ããå
ããĒæéã§ããã°åããã¨ãã§ãããåãããīŧã
ãâĻâĻæģãĢį´éĸããã¨ãã¨ããäģãĢã¯âĻâĻããĸãģããã¯įŽãčĻéããããįĩļ寞ãĢå¤ąãããããĒãã大åãĒäēēãåŽãã¨ãã¨ãâĻâĻã
ãäģããžããĢãããŽã¨ãã ããã
ãã ã¨ããĻããäēįŽã¯ãŠãããâĻâĻã
ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãä¸ããĻããä翏Ŧã ã
ããīŧãã ãŖãĻãä翏Ŧã¯äēįŽãããããäŊããããããâĻâĻã
ãé常ã¯ããã ããããĻãããåĨå
¨ã ãã ãäģã¯ãããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖãĻããå ´åã§ã¯ãĒããããŽãããĢããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ãããŽãˇãšãã ãæšäŋŽããã
ããŠããããã¨ã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããä翏ŦãåąæŠįã§ãããĒãã寞åĻãããããĢåãããã ãããããå
ããĒæéã ã
ããããããã§ã¤ã¯ãģãã¸ã§ããã§âĻâĻīŧã
ãâæŦäŊãįĩļ寞ãĢåãå
ĨããããĒãä翏Ŧâãåãčžŧãŋãå
¨åąãåããã ããŽäēįŽãäŊããéįãžã§å˛ãåŊãĻãã
ããããĒãã¨ãããæŦäŊãâĻâĻã
ããããĒããã°ãæŦäŊã¯æ°¸é ãĢæļããĒãåˇãč˛ ããã¨ãĢãĒãã
ãããã¯âĻâĻã
ããã¤ãŗããŽä翏Ŧã¯æŖããã¨ãį§ã¯įĸēäŋĄããĻãããã¤ãžãã寞åĻããĒããã°ãæŦäŊã¯åŽå
¨ãĢåŖããã
ããããĒįĩæâĻâĻã
ãåįããį§éãæãžãĒããããã ããīŧã
ãâĻâĻãããžãããããžãããâĻâĻīŧã
ããããã§ã¯į§ã¨ä¸įˇãĢæĨããäģãŽããŽã¯å
¨åĄãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããä翏Ŧãããéãããã īŧã
ãäŊãéŠããéĄãããĻãīŧã
ããļã¤ããŧãēãĢæģãŖãĻãããŦãããĢãčĻãĻãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åãããĢãããSSRãå´ŠåŖãããã¨ãĢãˇã§ãã¯ãåããįĢãĄä¸ãããã¨ããã§ããĒããĒãŖãĻããã¯ããŽãŦãããĢãŽéĄãĢãčĒäŋĄãæģãŖãĻããã
ããŦãããĢããããžããSSRãâĻâĻã
ãããĢãč¨ããĒããŦãããĢã¯įéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããããããžããŽčŊåãčĻčžŧãã§ã寞åŋãåãããå¤ąæããĻãäŊčŖã¯ãĒããã
ãããŖããäŊãâĻâĻ寞åŋãåãããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãããããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããč¨å¤§ãĒæ
å ąãä¸ããŖãĻãããããŽä¸ãĢã¯ãæ°ããæĻåŋĩã¨ããĻåĻįããããŽãåĢãžããã
ãįãŽããŧãŋãâĻâĻīŧã
ãããããĒããã°ãäģãŽæĒæžæãŽäēæ
ãĢ寞åĻã§ããĒãã ãããããīŧãããžãã¯åąåĄããĄããžã¨ããããŦããŧãŋãŧãēãããŽæ
å ąãčĻæĨĩããäģåããããŧãŋããŧãšã¨ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢéããäŋēã¯æ°äēēãŽé¨ä¸ã¨ãæĸåãŽæĻåŋĩããéŠåã§ããããŽãæŊåēããĻãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢéãã
ããžãããæåã§ä¸ããæ°ã§ããīŧīŧããããĢæĸåãŽæĻåŋĩã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãæŦäŊãæēãčžŧãã įĨčã¯ãæ¨ãĻããããããĒããåŋ
ããä¸ãįŦãŽæŦĄãŽčĄåãä翏ŦãããŽãĢäŊŋããããŽãããããããĢãĒãããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãŦãããĢã¯åŖå
ã§įŦãŖãã
ãäŋēéãããŠãŗã¯ãæåãŽæäģŖãčļããĻãããã ããããžãã¯ããžããŽäģäēãĢéä¸ãããããã§ããžãããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããŖããžã§æĩŽčļŗįĢãŖãĻããäŊããå°ãĢčļŗãã¤ãããããĢæããĻãããäēæ
ã¯äŊãč¯ããĒãŖãĻããĒãããĒãŽãĢã大ä¸å¤Ģã ã¨æããĻããčĒåãããâĻâĻ
ãåãããžããããããĢã
é ˇãã¨ããŦãããĢãé ˇãčŋããĻãå
¨åĄã䏿ãĢåãåēããã
įŦŦ10芹ãčŗã
-1-
ãããã大ä¸å¤Ģãīŧãæ¤åˇã
į§åąąãĢčŠãæēããļãããæ¤åˇã¯įŽãčĻéãããžãžäŊåēĻãé ˇããã
ãä¸ãįŦã¨ã¯äŋēã芹ããããžãã¯čĒåãŽããšã¯ãĢæģãã
ãį§åąąčǞéˇâĻâĻã
ããĒãã īŧã
ãããŋãžãããäģæĨãæŠéããĻãããã§ããããã
ãäŊčĒŋãæĒããã ããĒâĻâĻåããŖãããĄããã¨åŽéãĢãããã ãīŧã
ãã¯ããããŋãžããâĻâĻãããã¨ãããããžãã
æ¤åˇã¯é ãä¸ããĻãããããšã¯ãĢæģãŖãĻããã°ãæã¤ã¨ãäŧį¤žãåēãã
ãã¤é¨ãéãåēããĻããããããĒããģãŠãé˛ãéģããéãã
å°ãæšŋãŖãįŠēæ°ãå¸ãčžŧãŋãĒãããæŠčļŗãĢæŠããåŧå¸ã¯éãã§ãä¸åŽãŽãĒãēã ãäŋãŖãĻãããč¸ãŽįãä¸ããããĢããéãŋã¯æļããĻããĒããŽãĢãčĻįã¯ã¯ãĒãĸã§ãéĄãčĒįļã¨åãåããĻããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯äŊãããã¤ãããĒãŽãâĻâĻč¨čãæĩŽããšãã¨ãéãŋã¯åŧˇããĒãããããã§ãčĻįã¯æãããäģŖãããĢãããããå¯čŊæ§ãčŗå
ãĢåēããå§ããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧâĻâĻäģãžã§åēäŧãŖããã¨ããĒãį¨ŽéĄãŽäēēéãã§ãããŽæ§čŗĒã¯ãį¯įŊĒč
ãĢčŋãããĩã¤ãŗããšã¨ããããããããŖããĒãšããŽãããĢâĻâĻä¸åŠã ã¨æãã°čĄåãæ§ããåĨŊæŠãäŧēãã
čĒãæãæąããŽã§ã¯ãĒããäģč
ãæ¯é
âĻâĻå ´ããæ¯é
ãããã¨ã§äģč
ãåãããįŽįãéæãããã§ãä¸ãįŦã¯å°ãéããã¤ããŽįŽįã¯ãåēä¸ãĒãŠãŽããã§ã¯ãĒããæ¯é
ãããã¨ããŽããŽâĻâĻäģč
ãŽįæŽēä¸åĨĒãŽæ¨ŠåŠããæ¯é
ããĻãčĻããĒãįŗ¸ã§æãŖãĻæģã¸čĒå°ããâĻâĻããã ãããŽåŋĢæĨŊåæŽēäēēį¯ãŽčĢčãĢããŖããããĢãæåã¯čĒåãŽæãŖãã¨ãããĢäēēãåãããã¨ãĢåŋĢæãčĻããįš°ãčŋãããĄãĢã¨ãšãĢãŦãŧãããĻãäģã§ã¯äēēãŽįæģãæãåŋĢæãĢæĩ¸ãŖãĻããã
åĨãŽč¨ãæšããããĒããåŊąã§æčēãããŋã¤ãã§ãæŽēäēēį¯ãŽãããĢčĒåã襨ãĢåēããã¨ã¯ãããããŖã¨éãŽä¸ãĢãããããĒããŽâĻâĻé常ãĒããã ãä¸ãįŦã¯ãčĒåãææĄããĻããã¨æãŖãĻããå ´ã§ãįĒįļãšããããŠã¤ããåŊãĻãããĻãããŽæŖäŊãæãããã
ããäģĨä¸ãĒããģãŠãŽåąčžąã¨ææãæããã¯ãâĻâĻãŋãŧã˛ãããæãéããĢåãããĒããã¨ã¯æĨĩåēĻãŽãšããŦãšã¨ãĒãããããã¯ãĢãĒãŖãâĻâĻã ããåãäšąããããĒãŽãĢããŽãåģãéãŽįŦãŋâĻâĻä¸ãįŦã¯äŊãããīŧãčĒåãŽæ¯é
ããä¸įãåŖãã᏿ãĢ寞ããĻäŊããããã¨ãããŽãčĒįļã ããŠãį´æĨįãĒãã¨ãããã ãããīŧãæģæ˛ĸãããŽã¨ãã¯ãŠãã ãŖãīŧãåŊŧãŽčĒæŽēã¯ãäģäēēãŽįãæģãĢããæ¯é
ããã¨ããåŋĢæããä¸ãįŦãĢããããããããããåŽæ°¸ãããäģãŽãĄãŗããŧãĢã¯īŧ
æ¤åˇã¯čļŗãæĸããã
éĄãããåˇããæąãæĩããĻãé ŦãäŧãŖãĻããã
ããžããâĻâĻãããããããĒãã¯ãĒãããâĻâĻã§ããã ã¨ããĻãäŊãããīŧãäŋēãĢä¸įæļããĒãåˇãč˛ ããããĒãâĻâĻã
éĄããčŊãĄãæąãããĸãšããĄãĢããæŋĄãããã
-2-
ããããžã§ããããã§ããããâĻâĻã
ãã¤ãŗããįĢãĻãä翏ŦãĢãããĄã¯ãã¯č¨čãæãããã
ãä¸ãįŦãŽįļæŗãčããã°ãå¯čŊæ§ã¯éĢãããã¤ãŗãã¯č¨ãŖãããåã¯ãŠãæããã īŧãããĄã¯ãã
ãåãããžããâĻâĻãããĒįļæŗãéåģãĢããĒããŖãã§ãããīŧã
ããĒãããĒããããããããããĒãã¨åãæ¨ãĻããŽã¯åąéēã ã寞åĻããããŗããåŋ
ãããã
ãããŗãâĻâĻīŧããŠããĢã§ããīŧã
ãåˇéãĢãĒããããĄã¯ããåˇéããããããæŖããä翏Ŧã¯įãžããĒããįäŊãĸããŋãŧãčĻã¤ãããã¤ãŗããŽæã¯ã垎ããĢéããĻããããčãããã ã
ä¸ãįŦã¯æå¸ãæŽēããããããĒãâĻâĻ
ãã¤ãŗããåŖãĢããä翏Ŧã¯ãįžåŽåŗããĒããããĢæãããčēĢčŋãĒäēēãæŽēããããĒããĻãã¨ã¯ã大åãŽäēēéãĢã¯įĄį¸ã§ãããŠããæ įģãããĨãŧãšãĒãŠã§čĻãããåēæĨäēâĻâĻãããčĩˇããīŧãæŦåŊãĢīŧãã§ããããæŦåŊãĢãããĒãŖããīŧãä¸ãįŦãæŽããä¸åŋĢãĒäŋĄåˇã¨æ§čŗĒãčããã°ããããĒãã¯ãĒãīŧãã§ãããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧãäēēãæŽēããĒããĻâĻâĻ
ããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¯ãããĢæŋããéŗ´ããčĩ¤éģããŠãŗããŽææģ
ãæŋãããĒãŖãĻããã
ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąã¯ãčãŽįãŋãåŋææ°ãŽä¸æãæĸãžããĒãåˇãæąã¨éãâĻâĻäģãŽįļæŗã¨į
§ããåãããã°ããããã¯ã¨įĩļæâĻâĻåąå
ãŽįļæŗããŽããŽâĻâĻ
ãã¯ãŊâĻâĻīŧã
ãã¤ãŗããåããããĄã¯ãã¯éĄãåããã
ããŠãããžããâĻâĻīŧã
ãã¤ãŗãã¯ãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãĢåããĻãčģŊãéĄãããããŖãã
čĻįˇãåããã¨ãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãĢææããã¤ãēãŽãããĒããŽãå
ĨãŖãĻããã䏿įãĒä¸å
ˇåã§ã¯ãĒããæįļįã§ãããĄã¯ãã¯ãã¤ãŗããčĻãã
ããŠãããįļæŗã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãäēįŽãå°ŊããããĻãã
ããīŧãã ãŖãĻããˇã§ãŧãããã¨ãĸãģãããâĻâĻã
ãéįããããéˇãäŊŋããäēįŽã§ããĒããŽã ãâĻâĻã
ããããå°ŊãããâĻâĻã
ããžãããŠãã¯ãĸãĻããããããããĒãâĻâĻææĒãåããĻããžããããããĒãã
ããããĒâĻâĻīŧããĒãã¨ãããĒãã¨âĻâĻä翏ŦãĢ寞åĻãããããŽåããâĻâĻã
ããŽã¨ããããĄã¯ããŽãĩããŗãŗãéŗ´ãŖãã
ãããĄã ããããä¸ããĻããæŦäŊãŽãããã¯ã大ãããĒãã°ããã§ãŠããããããĒãâĻâĻīŧã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãããšã¯ãåŠããã
åąåĄããĄããããĢã¤ãŦãŗãŽéŗã¨ææģ
ãéåãããã¨ãĒã寞åĻãĢį˛ãæãĻãåããé
ããĒãŖãĻããããˇãšãã ãéããäēįŽãčļŗããĻããĒããŽã¯æããã ãŖãããäģã§ãŽãĒãŽãĒããĸãģãããĢéŖįĩĄããã¨ããã§ããããããŠããããããĒãâĻâĻ
ãŠãããã°ããīŧ
čããâĻâĻ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãéããĢįŽãéããĻãããŖããã¨åŧå¸ãããã
ãã čããã ãã§ã¯įãã¯åēãĒãã
ããŽãžãžåããã¨ãįļããĻããäēįŽãæļč˛ģããã ãâĻâĻ
ããŋããĒãä¸åēĻæãæĸããĻīŧã
é¨åąä¸ãĢéŋãåŖ°ã§ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãäŊč¨ãŖãĻãâĻâĻīŧãæãæĸãããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãâĻâĻã
ããã§ãĢčŋŊãã¤ããĻãĒããã ãã䏿Ļãæãæĸãããã īŧã
åąåĄããĄã¯ãããããéĄãčĻåãããæĩæãĢãäŧŧãčĻįˇãããĨãĸãŗãšãĢåããĻããã
ããŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããæ
å ąãŽä¸ãĢãæ°ããæĻåŋĩãĢįšããããŽã¯ãĒããäģãããŽįļæŗãĢãããĻã¯ãäģããšããã¨ã¯ãæĸåãŽįĨčãæĻåŋĩãäŊŋãŖãĻãããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãåŠãããã¨ã ã
ãããã¯ãŦãããĢãããâĻâĻã
ãéããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖããããŦãããĢããã¨åããã¨ãããããããĒãããŦãããĢããã¨ã¯éãčĻįšã§ãæĸåãŽæĻåŋĩãįĨčãäŊŋãæšæŗãčĻã¤ããâĻâĻãŦãããĢããã ããĢé ŧãããĢããããããŽčĻįšã§čĻããã īŧãããããã°åŋ
ããéã¯čĻã¤ããã
ä¸įŦãå ´ãéãžãčŋãŖããããããĢå
¨åĄãé ˇããæ°åãæŽããĻæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢčĩ°ãŖãã
ããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¯į¸å¤ãããéŗ´ãįļããĻããã
čĩ¤ããå°åģãŋãĒææģ
ã¯ãåŋãããã¤ãããããããæĸããã°åˇéããâĻâĻ
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãčļŗãæĸããã
ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãŽä翏Ŧã§ã¯ãä¸ãįŦã¯æå¸ãæŽēåŽŗããâĻâĻãããåŽå
¨ãĢåĻåŽããææã¯ãĒãã
äģãé ãŽä¸ãĢæĩŽããã ãã¨ãåŽčĄããã°ãããžãããã°ä¸ãįŦãåŽå
¨ãĢįĩãããããã¨ãã§ãããã§ãå¤ąæããããæŦäŊãåŽå
¨ãĢįĩããå¯čŊæ§ãããâĻâĻ
ãčŗãã ãĒãããã¯âĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åãã¨ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãžã§čĩ°ãŖãĻããŦãããĢãĢåŖ°ããããã
ãâĻâĻãĒããģãŠãįĸēããĢããžããŽč¨ãéããčŗãã ãĒã
ææĄãčãããŦãããĢã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããã
ãã ãäģãĢæšæŗã¯ãĒãããã ããããĢãä¸ãįŦãŽčĄåããã¤ãŗããŽä翏ŦéããĢãĒãå¯čŊæ§ã¯ããããĢããæ
å ąããčããã°ãįžåŽįã ã
ãŦãããĢã¯ããį¯įŊĒč
ãŽåŋįãã¨æ¸ãããæŖã¨æŦãčĻãã
ããããĢããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãĢæ
å ąãä¸ãããããã§äēįŽãäŊŋãåãŖãĻãæ§ããĒããäŋēã¯ãˇã§ãŧããĢéŖįĩĄããã
ããããĢã
-3-
ããå¤ąæããããäēåēĻã¨æå¸ãĢäŧããĒããããããĒããããžãããŖãĻããæå¸ãĢåĢããããããããĒãâĻâĻ
æ¤åˇã¯ãæŗŖãåēããįŠēãŽä¸ã§įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻãåŗæãåŧˇãæĄãŖãã
ã§ããäģŽãĢäģæĨãåããã¨ããĻããããŽãåģãéãŽįŦãŋããäēæŗéããĒããææĨãĢãĒãŖãĻããĒãšã¯ã¯æļããĒãããããĒãâĻâĻ
čŋããŽããĢãžã§æŠããĻãäŊããé¨ãæãŖãĻãããæ¤åˇã¯æå¸ãĢéģ芹ããããã
ãããŖãã¯ãããã¨ãã
ãããããį§ãããåŦãããŖãã
ããīŧãåŦãããŖããŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
ããããããããĒãã§ããĒãããŠããããŽīŧã
ããããããå°ãäŧããĒãããĒīŧã
ãããããŠãäŊãããŖããŽīŧã
ãâĻâĻã
ãæ¤åˇããâĻâĻīŧã
ã芹ããĻãããããã¨ãããŖãĻã
ãéģ芹ã§ã¯čŠąããĒããã¨īŧã
ãããâĻâĻã
åŋčããēããŗã¨ããĻãæ¤åˇã¯éĄãããããã
ãåããŖããããããããīŧã
ãããããããĢåãããã
ãããããé§
ã§åž
ãŖãĻããã
é芹ãįĩããã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯äŊãéãããģãŠåãæŗãĢåãå
Ĩãããžãžãäŋ¯ãããåžé é¨ãäŧãŖãĻãéĻįãĢæ°´æģ´ããĒãããä¸é¨ã¯ãˇãŖããŽä¸ãĢæĩãčžŧãã§ããã
ã˛ãããã¨ããæčĻãåēãããåžã
ãĢčĻįãåēããŖãĻãããå°éĸãĢčŊãĄãé¨ãåŧžããĻåēããã¨ãããžã§čĻãããããĢãĒãã¨ãéĄãä¸ããã
ãããĻããšãããčŗãĢããĻãã
ããããé ŧããäŋēéã¯åŋ
čĻãĒæ
å ąãĢįĩãŖãĻä¸ãįļããã
ããĄã¯ãã¨ãŽé芹ãįĩããã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯åąåĄããĄãĢæį¤ēãåēããæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšãĢåããŖãã
ãäēįŽã¯ãĒãã¨ãããã¨ããˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãåãŖãããĸã¤ããããč¨ãŖããĒããåŋ
ãããã
ãŦãããĢã¯ãæŦæŖãčĻãĒããč¨ãŖãã
ããããĒåŧˇæ°ãĒãã¨ããããããĢã¯čĻããĒãã§ããã
ããˇã§ãŧãããīŧã
ãã¯ãã
ããžãããããããããĒããĒããŦãããĢã¯įŦãŖãããããŠããĸã¤ãã¯éã¨ãĒãŧããŽčēĢã§ããļãģããŗã¯ãŽããããĢãžã§æãä¸ããŖãåĨ´ã ãäŋēãĢã¯ããĸã¤ããäģãŠããĒéĄãããĻããäēæŗã§ããã
ããŠããĒéĄã§ããīŧã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇããĒãã§ãįŦãŖãĻããã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģããã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãˇã§ãŧããŽéĄãĢã¯æąãæĩŽããŗãææåēãæŋĄãããĻãããæį¤ēã¯éåãããã¨ãĒãããã¤å°ŊãããåãããĒãäēįŽãŽæŽéãæ°ãĢããĒãããŽčĒŋæ´ãĒãŽãĢãåŖč§ã¯ä¸ãããįŽã¯čĻéãããĻããã
ãäš
ããļãæãåēãããŽã ãããˇã§ãŧãã¯č¨ãŖãããčĨãé ããã
ãããĨãĢãŧãšīŧãæēåã¯ãããīŧã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯åĢãã ã
ããã¤ã§ãīŧīŧã
ãããããããããæŖåŋĩå ´ã ããã¨æ°åâĻâĻã
ãæŦäŊãæå¸ãĄããã¨æĨč§ĻããĻãããŽãã¨âĻâĻã§ãããã
ãããžãæĨč§Ļã§ããĻããĒâĻâĻããããã¯čŗãã ãããĨãĢãŧãšãåąåĄãŽææŽãä¸ããã
ããīŧããããĒãããŖãšããŧããããâĻâĻã
ãããŽįļæŗãäŊãŖããŽã¯ããžãããĄã ãããŖãšããŧãã¯ããĨãĢãŧãšãŽįŽãįãŖį´ããĢčĻãããæåžãžã§ãããããéĒ¨ã¯æžãŖãĻããã
ãããŖãšããŧãããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãæģ˛ãčĻįãããŽãžãžãĢãåąåĄå
¨åĄãĢåããĻåŖ°ãįēããã
ããŋããĒâĻâĻãããããŽæ
å ąã¯ãä¸ã¤ãčĻčŊã¨ããĒãã§ãį§ããĄãä¸ããæ
å ąããããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēãäŊããæŦĄãŽįŦéãŽä翏ŦãåˇĻåŗãããæŦäŊãįãããæģãŦãâĻâĻããããããŽįļæŗãĒãŽãåŋ
ãâĻâĻä¸ãįŦãåããĻãæå¸ãĄããã¨įĩã°ããâĻâĻæŦäŊãŽéĄããåŽįžãããīŧīŧīŧã
åąãŽãšããŧãĢãŧãåŖãããģãŠãŽæåŖ°ãä¸ãããããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãŦãŋãããģãˇãšãã ãŽåã§åē§ãį´ããã
ãæĒč
ãåããĻãããã¤ãŗã¨įĩã°ããâĻâĻãĩããæãŽããŧããŧæ įģãŋãããĒ芹ã ãĒã
ãããããã§ããīŧã
ããããããŖãšããŧãã¯åžŽããĢåŖč§ãä¸ããããåĢããããĒãã
-4-
é§
ãĢįããæ¤åˇã¯ãæå¸ãŽå§ŋãæĸããã
é¨ãæŋãããĒãŖãĻããããããé§
åãĢãéĸãããäēēã¯å°ãĒãããžã æŧãŽå°ãåã ãããããããĒãããéŗĨčãæĸãžããĒããŽã¯ãįŠēæ°ãåˇããĻããããâĻâĻããã ããããĒããã¨ã¯åããŖãĻããã
åŧå¸ã¯éããĢåããĻããã
čĻįãåēãã
ãšãããåãåēãã¨ãæå¸ãŽįĒåˇãéŗ´ãããã
ãâĻâĻã
éˇããŗãŧãĢããåŋææ°ãéĢããĻããã
éģ芹ã¯įšããããããŖãããããĻããĒãã
åã財ãŖãĻé§
ãåēãã
é¨éŗããčãããĒãéãæŠããĻããã¨ãč§ãæ˛ããŖãå
ã§ãæå¸ãŽå§ŋãčĻããã
ãæå¸ãâĻâĻã
č¨ããããĻãåŋčã莺ããã
ãä¸ãįŦâĻâĻã
æå¸ãŽåžããĢã¯ãä¸ãįŦããããæå¸ã¯éãããããŖããã¨æŠããĻããã
ãã¨ãžãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããããčä¸ãĢåįŠã§ãįĒãã¤ããĻãããŽã ãããææãããĻããããã§ããĒããŽãĢãæå¸ã¯åããã¨ããĒãã
ãããŖãĻããããĒãæ¤åˇãä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãããããžããããããžã§ããã¨ã¯æããĒããŖãããæčŊã ã¨č¨ãããĻãæģåŖã¯ãããŖããäŋēãŽæä¸ãĢčŊãĄãĻããããŽãĢãã
ãæå¸ããã¯éĸäŋãĒãã ããéĸããâĻâĻīŧã
ãåĨãĢæ´ãžããĄãããĒããéããããéããããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯åŖå
ãæĒãžããĻįŦããčĄčĩ°ãŖãįŽã§ãåŗæãååžãããããĢåããã
åŧåŋãããããĢãæå¸ã¯įŽãã¤ãļãŖãĻãäŊããã¯ãĒã¨ãããã
ããããããĢæĨãããĒãäŋēãããŽåĨŗãįããŖãĻįĨãŖãĻããŽãīŧã
ãįĨããããĒããæ¤åˇã¯č¨ãŖãããã§ãããããããŋãããĒį¯įŊĒč
ããããããĒãã¨ã¯æŗåã§ããã
ãį¯įŊĒč
īŧã
ãéŠããããĒãã¨ãããĒãã§ããīŧãããããŽããŖãĻããã¨ã¯į¯įŊĒč
ã¨åãã ãã
ããããããããããžãã¯ãäŋēãããŽãã¨ãŠãããã¨æãīŧã
ãäŋēãâĻâĻæŽēãã
æå¸ãŽįŽãčĻéãããæŦĄãŽįŦéãĢæļãæēĸãããä¸ãįŦãĢäŊãč¨ããã¨ããĻããæå¸ãčĻãĻãæ¤åˇã¯å°ããé ãæ¯ãŖãã
ãåãįŊŽããĻããŖãĄãĢæĨããæ¤åˇã
ä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãã
æ¤åˇã¯ãããŖããã¨ãäēäēēãčĻįãĢåãããžãžčŋãĨãã
ä¸ãįŦã¯åããĒãã
ãã¨ãžãã
æå¸ã¨äŊä¸ã¤åéĸããã¨ãããžã§æĨãã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯č¨ãŖãã
ã严æãä¸ããã
ãâĻâĻã
ããããĻããéĄãâĻâĻã
æå¸ãŽåŖ°ãé¨ãĢããæļãããã
ãããŽãžãžåããĒãīŧã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãæå¸ãŽčä¸ãĢé ããĻããå
ä¸ãæ¤åˇãĢåããã
æ¯ãä¸ããâĻâĻ
åŋčããã¯ãŗã¨åŧˇæ¯ããĻãåæãĢįŽãčĻéããã
æéãæ¸éããã
å
ä¸ãŽčģéãčĻããâĻâĻ
čĒåãĢåããŖãĻãããããããã¯čēãŽãããâĻâĻ
ã§ãããã¯ãĒããĒãã
æĨãĢãŧããããããĢčģéã¯å¤ããâĻâĻ
0.1į§ã§įĸēåŽãããä翏Ŧã
å
ä¸ãæå¸ãĢåããŖãĻčģéãå¤ããâĻâĻ
ä¸įŦæŠããæ¤åˇã¯č¸ãŋčžŧãã§æå¸ãæąããããä¸ãįŦãĢčãåããĻå
ä¸ãčŠãŽãããã§åããã
čãæãæčĻãĢéĄãããããããåã¯å
Ĩãã
ããŽãžãžæå¸ãåæšãĢéãããĻãæŦĄãŽä¸æãĢåããã
ããããŽããžãīŧīŧãåããĒīŧīŧã
ä¸äēēäģĨå¤ãŽåŖ°ãéŋããã
ãåįŠãå°éĸãĢįŊŽããĻãæãä¸ããã
åļæå§ŋãŽčĻåŽãč¨ãŖãã
ããĒãã§ãčĻå¯ãâĻâĻã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ãéããäŊãåŖ°ãæ°ãĢãããĢãæ°ãã¤ãããããĢæ¤åˇãčĻãã
ããžãããããžããâĻâĻã
ãč¨ãŖãã§ãããį¯įŊĒč
ãŽčĄåã¯åãããŖãĻã
æ¤åˇã¯ãčä¸ãŽåˇãæŧãããĒããæ¯ãčŋãŖãã
ãããããŽãããžã§ãŽčĄåããčããã°ãäŋēã§ã¯ãĒããæå¸ãããæŽēããã¨ãããŽã¯äēæŗã§ãããįŽãŽåã§æå¸ãããæŽēããĻãæļããĒãįŊǿǿã¨įĩļæãæ¤ãäģãããã¨ãããã âĻâĻæģåŖãããŽååãĢãããããããĢâĻâĻã
ããããžã§äēæŗããĻãčĻå¯ãåŧãã ãŖãĻãããŽãâĻâĻã
ä¸ãįŦã¯ããŦããŦãã¨æ¯ãéŗ´ãããĒãããæ¤åˇãĢæŽēæ°ãåããĻããã
ããĩããããĒâĻâĻäŋēãŽčĄåããããļčĒãžããĻããŖãĻâĻâĻīŧããããĒãããããčĒããããâĻâĻæ¯é
ãããŽã¯äŋēã âĻâĻäŋēãĒãã ãīŧīŧã
æ¤åˇãĢåããŖãĻãããã¨ããä¸ãįŦã¯ãčĻåŽãĢæŧããããããã¤äŧããĢä¸åčēĢãåŠãã¤ãããããããåŖ°ããããã
ããĒãã§âĻâĻãĒãã§ã ãããĒãã§äŋēãâĻâĻã
æ¤åˇã¯ãåããĒããĒãŖãä¸ãįŦãčĻãĻãåŧžããããããĢåžããčĻãã
æå¸ã¯ãčĻåŽã¨čŠąããĻããã
į˛ããčĻããããåˇã¯ãĒããããã
é¨ã¯ããã¤ãŽãžãĢã¯æĸãã§ããã
ããããŖããâĻâĻããã§âĻâĻã
æå¸ãŽã¨ãããžã§æŠããã¨ããã¨ããčĻįãæčģĸããã
įŦŦ11čŠąãæ°į
-1-
ãâĻâĻīŧã
įŽãčĻãžããæ¤åˇã¯ããæå¸ããâĻâĻīŧãã¨åĢãã§äŊãčĩˇãããã
ããŖã¤âĻâĻīŧã
åŗčŠãŽåžãããããĢãįēãã¨įãŋãé§ãæããäŊãããŽåãĢãĒã
æãŖãããåŗč
ã¯åãããåããĢå
帯ãåˇģãããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããã
ãį
éĸâĻâĻīŧã
įŊãåŖã¨ãčĒåŽ
ãŽããŽã¨ã¯éãããããåŗãåãã¨įĒããããéĸ¨ãããããĢãįŊããŦãŧãšãŽãĢãŧããŗãæēãããĻãããį
éĸãŖãŊãããĒã¤ãããĒããŽã¯ãæŖãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽãããé´čããįãéĻããåēããĻããããã ããã
æå¸ã¯ãŠããĒãŖããŽã ãããã
ä¸ãįŦã¯âĻâĻīŧ
ãããįŽãčĻãžãããã§ããã
ããã¯ããĻį
厤ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããįčˇå¸ĢãŽåĨŗæ§ã垎įŦãã ã
ãããŽãäŋēã¯ãã¤ãããããĢâĻâĻīŧã
ãéã°ããĻããäēæĨã§ããčŠãŽåˇã¯ãããĒãĢæˇąããĒãã§ãããŠãį¸ĢåæčĄã¯ããĻããããįĄįãĢåãããĄãããĄã§ããã
ãäēæĨâĻâĻããŽãæå¸ãããããŖã¨ãããļãäŋēã¯åãããã ã¨æããžãããŠãããŽã¨ããĢä¸įˇãĢããåĨŗæ§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãčŊãĄįããĻãã ãããæ¤åˇãããįčˇå¸Ģã¯č¨ãŖãããããĒãã¯ãčŠãŽåˇã ããããĒããé
ˇãį˛ããĻãããŋããã§ãã ããäēæĨãį ãŖããžãžã ãŖããã§ãããäģã¯åŽéãĢã
ããããäŋēã¯å¤§ä¸å¤ĢãĒãŽã§ãæå¸ãããâĻâĻã
įčˇå¸Ģã¯åžŽįŦãã§ãæŖãŽåŧãåēããæãããã
ããããĢããšãããå
ĨãŖãĻãžããæ°ãĢãĒããĒãéŖįĩĄããĻãŋãĻã¯īŧã
ããīŧããããããâĻâĻããŋãžããããããã¨ãããããžãã
ãããããã¨ã
ãâĻâĻīŧã
ãįŽãčĻãžããããčĻå¯ã芹ãčããããŖãĻãã¨ãĒãã§ãããŠã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ããīŧã
ãčĻå¯âĻâĻã¯ããäŋēã芹ãčããããŽã§ã
ãåãããžãããããããäŧããĻãããžãããããäŊčĒŋãæĒããĒãŖãããããããããĢč¨ãŖãĻãã ããã
įčˇå¸ĢãåēãĻããã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯æŖãããšãããåãåēããã
ãâĻâĻå
éģãåããĻãã
ããæ¯ã¨ã¨ããĢãæãĢé ãã¤ããĻ夊äēãčĻä¸ããã
å
éģå¨ã¯åããã°ããã荿ļãæŖãããĒããæå¸ã¯čĻå¯ãĢäŋčˇãããĻãä¸ãįŦã¯æãžãŖãã¯ããäŊãåŋé
ã¯ãĒãâĻâĻ
ããŧãšãŗãŧãĢãéŗ´ãããĻãå
éģå¨ã貸ããĻãģããã¨äŧããã¨ãããããčĻå¯ãæĨããããããŽãã¨ã§ã¨č¨ãããåž
ãŖãĻããã¨åäēãããįˇåĨŗãå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ãæ¤åˇį æããã§ããīŧã
ãããã§ãã
ãåąąåčĻå¯įŊ˛ææģä¸čǞãŽč°ˇį°é¨ã§ããããŖãĄã¯æ¨éãäēäēēã¯čĻå¯ãŽIDãčĻããĻãããįļããããããĒããéå ąããĻããä¸ãįŦã¯ãéŽæããžãããæŽēäēēæĒéãŽįžčĄį¯ã§ãįžå¨åãčĒŋãšä¸ã§ãã
ããŠããĒæ§åã§ããâĻâĻīŧã
ããŠããĒâĻâĻããžãčŠŗãããã¨ã¯č¨ããžããããããã§ãããč¨ãŖãĻãããã¨ãæ¯éĸæģ
čŖã§âĻâĻã
ããããããã¨ãããããžãããä¸ãįŦã¯ããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã§âĻâĻīŧã
ãčŊãĄįããĻãã ãããč°ˇį°é¨ã¯č¨ãŖãããããã¯ãããã¨ã§ã¯ãããžãããåģäēēãŽãããĒããŽã§ãã
ãåģäēēâĻâĻīŧã
ãä¸ãįŦãŽãã¨ã¯čĒŋãšãĻãéĸäŋč
ãĢã芹ãčããžãããįĸēããĢããĒããŽč¨ãéããããããĨãŦãŧãŋãŧã¨ãããã¤ãĒãã§ããããã ããã§ãããããéŽæããããã¨ããããæ¯é
ããå´ã ãŖãčĒåãč˛ ããĻãæ¯é
ãããå´ãĢãĒãŖããã¨âĻâĻããŽåå ããįĩļ寞ãĢč˛ ããã¯ãããĒãã¨æãŖãĻããããĒããĢããŖãĻããããããâĻâĻããŽäēåŽãĢčãããããåŋãåŖãããŽã ã¨æããžãã
ãã§ãããããããâĻâĻã
ããåŋé
ãĒããč˛ŦäģģčŊåãĒãã§éæžãĒããĻãã¨ãĢã¯ãããžãããããæģåŖãããŽäģļãčĒŋãšãžãã
ããããĒãâĻâĻããįžå ´ãĢããåĨŗæ§âĻâĻæå¸ããã¯įĄäēãĒãã§ããīŧã
ã大éæå¸ããã§ãããããĄããããįĄäēã§ãããšããŧãĢãŧãããĻãããã¨ããį¯įŊĒįžå ´ãĢåą
åããããã¨ããããĢãĻãŗãģãĒãŗã°ãåããĻããããã¨ãĢãĒããžãããå¤åˇãĒãŠã¯ãããžããã
ãč¯ããŖãâĻâĻã
æ¤åˇã¯ããããĢčä¸ãã¤ããã
ãč¯ããŖãâĻâĻæŦåŊãĢâĻâĻã
åŖ°ãæģ˛ãã
ããããĢããĻããåäēã¯éĻãåžããããįžå ´ãĢé§ãã¤ããčĻå¯åŽãŽčŠąãĢããã¨ãããĒãã¯ä¸ãįŦã¨æĨč§ĻããåãĢãâįˇãåĨŗæ§ãčĨ˛ãŖãĻããĻãčĒåãåãã¤ããããĻããâã¨éå ąããĻããããã§ããã
æ¤åˇã¯åŋčã莺ããã
ãããã§ããâĻâĻã
ãčåŊãŽéå ąãĢãĒãå¯čŊæ§ãããŖãããããĒãã°ãéŽæãããĻãããŽã¯ããĒãã ãŖããããããžãããįĩæã ããčĻãã°ããããĒããã¨ãčĻããĻããâĻâĻããčããĻã䏿č°ã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ã§ããäŊããäģæãã§ãããŖããã§ããīŧã
ãäģæãâĻâĻãããã§ããã°ãããŖããã§ãããŠããããžã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãčŗãã§ããã
ãčŗãīŧããããĒãã¯ãã ã¨äēæŗããĻããããĢčŗããã¨īŧã
ãäŧį¤žãåēãĻããã¨ããĢä¸ãįŦãčĻããéĄâĻâĻããŽéĄãčĻãã¨ããåŋ
ãäŊãäģæããĻããã¨æããžãããã§ããäŊããããŽãã¨čããã¨ããäŋēãĢį´æĨäŊããŖãĻãããŽã¯ãããŖããããĒããŖããããŖã¨æĒããä¸įæļããĒãåˇãĢãĒããããĒãã¨ãäģæããĻãäŋēãæ¯é
ãããã¨ããâĻâĻčããĻããããĄãĢããããĒæ°ããããã§ãã
ãããã§ãããĒãã¨čĻĒãã大éæå¸ãããįãã¨īŧã
ãã¯ãã
ãã ã¨ããĻããåįŠãæãŖãĻãããã¨ãäēæŗãããã§ããīŧã
ãæå¸ãããįãã¨čããã¨ããä¸ãįŦã¯äŧį¤žãåēãĻãããŽãžãžæå¸ãããŽã¨ãããĢčĄãã¨æãŖããã§ãããããĒãã¨ã፿ã§ããããŽã¯åįŠããããããĒããâåģãéãŽįŦãŋâã§įĻããæããäŋēãããããĢæå¸ããã¨æĨč§Ļãããã¨ããã¨ãä¸ãįŦã¯äēæŗããâĻâĻããŽã¨ããåž
ãŖãĻãäŋēãŽįŽãŽåã§åŊŧåĨŗãæŽēãâĻâĻããäģĨä¸ãĒããģãŠãŽææĒãįĒãã¤ããĻããã¯ãã¨æãŖãããããããįĩčĢãĢčŗããžããã
ããŠãåŽéãĢä¸ãįŦã¨åãåãŖãĻããéå ąããĻããéãĢåããĒããã ããå
ãĢâĻâĻã
ããĒããģãŠãč°ˇį°é¨ã¯é ˇããããį¯äēēãŽåããä翏ŦãããŖããã¨ã¯ãčĻäēã§ããã§ãįĸēããĢãčŗãã§ãããã
ãã¯ãããããäŊãįŊĒãĢåããããĒããããã§ãããã§ããæå¸ãããįĄäēãĒããããã§âĻâĻã
ãäŊãåãããžããããããĒããŽéå ąã¯æŖãããŖãããã¨ãããããčŗãã ãŖãã¨ããĻãã
č°ˇį°é¨ã¨æ¨éã¯ãããããã¨ãããããžãããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãį
厤ãåēãĻããŖãã
-2-
ãæ°æĨåããĻãŊãĒããããéãã ãã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãč¨ãŖãã
å
åĨŗįĨååēå ´ãĢéãžãŖãããĨãĸãŗãšããĄã¯ãããããéŗ´ãæĸãã ããĢã¤ãŦãŗãæããããããĢãæ¯ãčŋãŖãĻããã
ãæŦåŊãĢãããįĄįãã¨æãŖããâĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãæŦäŊãŽãããĢåŋ
čĻãĒãã¨ãããĒãäēēããĄâĻâĻãˇã§ãŧãåąéˇãäģãŽãããŠãŗãŽãã¨ããããæãŖãĻãããŠãäģåã¯åŊŧããĢåŠããããããããĸãģããã¯é ãæ¯ãŖããããĄããŖã¨æããããŠâĻâĻã
ãSSRãĢãã ããŖãĻãããã¨ã¯č¯åŽã§ããĒãããŠãããããå ´éĸã§ãŽåãã¯ããããã ã¨æãŖãããäŋēãå°ããæããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ã垎ããĢåŖå
ãįˇŠããã
ããããããŠããĒããŽããĒīŧãããĨãĢãŧãšã¯å¤ŠäēãčĻä¸ããĻãåē§ãŖããžãžčļŗãããŋããŋã¨ãååžãĢåãããĻããã
ãæŦäŊããŠããĒãããŖãĻãã¨īŧã
ãĸãģãããčãã
ããããã ããŠãį§ããĄããåąã¯äģãžã§ãŠããīŧãããŖãšããŧãããã¨ããäģåãŖãĻãããŽããĒã
ãããã¯ããžãč¯ããĒããããããĒããããĨãĸãŗãšãč¨ãŖãããä¸ãįŦãŽäģļã¯ãč¨ãŖãĻãŋãã°æäēã ãåšŗæãĢæģãŖãäģããžãSSRãŋãããĒããŽãäŊããã¨ãããããããĒãâĻâĻã
ãããã¯ããĄã ããâĻâĻã
ããĄã¯ãã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããĄãĢæąēãžãŖãĻãã§ããããĒãã¨ãããĒããã
ãčŊãĄįããããžã ãããĒãã¨æąēãžãŖãããããâĻâĻã
å
¨åĄãã䏿ãĢéĄãä¸ããã
ããĢã¤ãŦãŗãéŗ´ãéŋãã
ä¸ãįŦãŽã¨ãã¨åãããããäģĨä¸ãĢâĻâĻ
ããĒãĢīŧããžãäŊãâĻâĻã
ãæĨãã§æģããīŧã
-3-
äēäģļããä¸éąéããĻãæ¤åˇã¯ééĸããæå¸ã¨ééĸįĨããŽéŖäēãããĻããã
æå¸ã¯ãæ¤åˇãĢäŊåēĻããį¤ŧãč¨ãŖãĻãåˇãŽãã¨ãæ°éŖãŖãããæ¤åˇã¯ãããããčĒåãåå ã§æãæãããããĻããžãŖããã¨ãčŠĢãŗãĻããã°ããããã¨ãįŦãããŖãã
ãåˇãæ˛ģãŖãããäģåēĻã¯ãé
æãã§ãéŖ¯čĄãããã
æŗĸãŽéŗãåŋå°č¯ãå
ŦåãæŠããĒãããæå¸ã¯įŦéĄãåããã
ããŽæĨãŽãããĢãããŖãããĄã¤ã¯ãããĻãããĄããˇã§ãŗãæ´ããĻãããŽãåããâĻâĻããæãã¨ãæ¤åˇã¯čĒåãŽæčŖ
ãé
ˇãéŠåŊãĢæããã
ããŠããããŽīŧã
æå¸ãå°éĻãåžããã
ããããããĒãã§ããĒãã
ããŖããã¨ãæŠåš
ãåãããĒããæŠããĻããã¨ãããŗãã§å¯ãæˇģããĢãããĢãŽå§ŋãčĻããĒããĒããåæšãĢæ¸¯ã¨æŠãŽæãããčĻããĻãããæŊŽãŽéĻãã¨æŗĸãŽéŗã港ãŽå¤æ¯âĻâĻ
åŋčãŽéŧåãæŠããĒãŖãĻãããæãŽã˛ããĢæąãæģ˛ãã§ããã
æ¤åˇã¯įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻãæå¸ãčĻãã
ãããŽãæå¸ããâĻâĻã
æŗĸãŽéŗã§æļããĻããžããģãŠãåŖ°ãããããã
æå¸ã¯éģãŖãĻãæ¤åˇãŽãģããĢäŊãåããã
ããããĻããã
ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēã§ãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãčĻãĻããããĄã¯ããĢããã¤ãŗãã¯čŠãĢæãįŊŽããĻéĻãæ¯ãŖãã
ã䏿įãĒæããããŖãĻãããããĢåˇããã
ããããĒâĻâĻãŦããŧãŋãŧãēããä¸ããŖãĻããĻãæ
å ąãčĻãã°ãįæįãĒããŽã¨ã¯âĻâĻã
ãå¤ãæ įģãŽãģãĒãã§ããããããŽããããį°å¸¸ãĒãˇããĨã¨ãŧãˇã§ãŗã§įĩã°ãããĢãããĢã¯éˇįļãããĒããæŦäŊã¨æå¸ãŽįļæŗã¯ããžããĢããã ã
ãã§ããããã§ããããâĻâĻīŧã
ãããã§č¨ããĒããŖãããããäēåēĻã¨č¨ããĒãã
ãããĨãĸãŗãšâĻâĻãīŧããŦãããĢãããâĻâĻã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¨ãŦãããĢãæŠããĻããĻãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãŽåãĢįĢãŖãã
ããããĻãããããŖãšããŧãããããŠãĻããŽčŠąãčããã ãīŧãæŦäŊãĢã¨ãŖãĻãåįŊã¯č
å¨ãĒãã ãč§ĻããĻã¯ãããĒããã¨ãĒãã ãã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãã ããããäģãäšãčļãããã§ããã
ããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇã¯į§ããĄã¨åãčããã
ãĸãģãããå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ãããŽåįŊã¯ããžããããåįŊãŽãããĢ大éãŽäēįŽãåŋ
čĻãĒãŽã¯åããŖãĻããã ãããˇã§ãŧãåąéˇã¯ãäģããŽįŦéãĢäēįŽã大éãĢåēããĻãã
ãååã¯ããžãããĄãĢæã貸ããããäģåã¯ããĄããŽæčĻãčããĻããããã
ããĒãã§ãīŧãįĩļ寞ããžããããŽãĢâĻâĻã
ããŖãšããŧãã¨ããĨãĢãŧãšãå
ĨãŖãĻããĻãįäŊãĸããŋãŧãŽåãĢįĢãŖãã
ãčĻãĻãããīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯æ°æãŽįģåãčĻããã
ãå°ãä¸åŽãããĢčĻãããåįŊããããå°ããŖãĻãã¨ãããĒããŽãīŧã
ãã¤ãŗããč¨ãŖãã
ãäŋēãããæããå åˇĨããĒãã§ããã ã
ããŖãšããŧããåæããã
ããããéããįĸēããĢä¸åŽãããĢčĻããããŠãããã¯æŦäŊãåįŊãããĒãã§éŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã§ããžããããããĒãâĻâĻããŽãã¨ãĢ寞ããããŽã ãããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããããĄã¯ãããŠãæãīŧããããããŠãä翏Ŧããīŧã
įģåãčĻãčžŧãã ããĄã¯ãã¯ãįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ããã
ãįĸēåŽãĒãã¨ã¯č¨ããĒããâĻâĻãã ãæå¸ãããŽįŽâĻâĻä¸åŽããããæŦäŊãåŋæ´ãããããĒãããã°ãŖãĻãŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻããããĢãåãĢã¯čĻããã
ãéĻŦéšŋãĒâĻâĻã ãŖããčĒåããč¨ãã ãã
ããŖãšããŧãã¯éŧģã§įŦãŖãã
ãåĨŗåŋãåããŖãĻãĒããĒããããŖãšããŧãããã
ããĨãĢãŧãšãé ãæ¯ãŖãã
ãåĨŊããŖãĻč¨ããããĻããå
ãĢč¨ãŖãĻæŦ˛ãããã ããåĨŊããĒäēēããã
ãããããžããããĒããŖãããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯č¨ãŖãããäģåžã¯ããŖã¨ãããĒãæšãĢåžããžãããããSSRã垊æ´ģãããã¨č¨ãããĻããåžãã
ããĄããŖã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšâĻâĻīŧã
ãĸãģããã¯æĸããããããĨãĸãŗãšã¯éĻãæ¨ĒãĢæ¯ãŖãã
ã大ä¸å¤Ģãåŋ
ãããžãããããŋããĒãããæãã ãīŧã
ãããã¯âĻâĻã
ãããĄã¯ããåįŊã¯ããžããããããŽä翏Ŧã§įĸēåŽã ã
ãâĻâĻåããŖãã
ãæå¸ããâĻâĻããŽâĻâĻã
ãã¯ãã
ãäŋēã¯âĻâĻã
č¨čã芰ãžãã
åŋčãæŠéãŽãŽãĸãä¸ããåŧå¸ãčĻãããĒãã
ãžãããŽã¨ãã¨åãâĻâĻ
ãããéããåããããĒãâĻâĻīŧ
ãåãĢãããĢæĨãã¨ããéåŧå¸ãĢãĒãŖãĻâĻâĻã
č¨čãåã§čаãžãã
æå¸ã¯ãŠããĒéĄãããĻãããŽã ããâĻâĻ
ããŖããã¨éĄãä¸ããã¨ãæå¸ã¨įŽãåãŖãã
åãåãŖãĻ芹ããĻããâĻâĻãã ããã ãã§ãåŋãŽé§ãããšãĻæ´ãããĻããããæĨãŽæ¨æŧãæĨãŽãããĒįŧåˇŽãâĻâĻ
ããããĢã¯ãįįąãããŖãĻâĻâĻä¸åš´åãĢãåĨŊããĢãĒãŖãäēēãããĻãã§ãããŽäēēã¯ãäŋēãåĨŊããĢãĒãããŠããããåŊŧæ°ã¨čŗããĻãĻâĻâĻäŋēãĢã¨ãŖãĻåįŊã¯ããŠããããããĒãããããæããã¨ã§âĻâĻã ãããæå¸ãããæĒãã¨ãããããããããĒãĒããĻãå
¨é¨äŋēãâĻâĻã
ãåããŖãĻããæå¸ã¯č¨ãŖãããäŊãįįąããããŖãĻæãŖãĻããã ãããæ°ãĢããĻãĒããã
æ¤åˇã¯ãé ŦãĢæēĸããããĢãĒãŖãæããæãĄä¸ãããããĢãéĄãįŠēãĢåããĻãä¸åēĻæˇąåŧå¸ããĻãããä¸įä¸åĒããįŽã¨ãčĻįˇãåãããã
ãæå¸ãããŽãã¨ããåĨŊãã§ãâĻâĻãŠããããããĒããããâĻâĻæ¯æĨããŖã¨ã芹ããĻããããããâĻâĻã ããäŋēã¨âĻâĻã
ãâĻâĻã
ãäģãåãŖãĻããģããâĻâĻã
ãæå¸ã¯éģãŖãĻããâĻâĻãããĢä翏ŦãåãæŋãããäģåēĻã¯ããŠãã¯ãĸãĻãããæ¸ãžãĒãâĻâĻīŧãã大ä¸å¤Ģã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ãããŖãšããŧããŽč¨čãéŽãŖãã
ãã§ããīŧãããĨãĸãŗãšã
ãããã大ä¸å¤Ģãããã¯åĨŊæã ãåããĒããĻãããåž
ãĻã°âĻâĻã
ãæ¤åˇããã
æå¸ã¯įŽãåããããžãžãããŽįŗã¯å°ãæēããĻããã
ããããã¨ãããããåŦããâĻâĻã
åŋčãæ˛éŗ´ãä¸ãããããĢįãŋãéŋãããã
ãããã¨ãããããåŦããâĻâĻããŽã¨ãã¨åãâĻâĻããŽč¨čãŽå
ã¯âĻâĻ
é Ŧãåŧãã¤ããæŦĄãŽįŦéãĢæĨãæŋįãĢåãããã¨ãčŗãč¨čãäŊãåēããã¨ããæå¸ãŽåŖãåããã
ãį§ããåĨŊãâĻâĻåŊŧåĨŗãĢããĻãã ããâĻâĻã
垎ããĢéããåĢãã åŖ°ã¨ãæŊ¤ãã įŗâĻâĻãããžã§čĻããã¨ããĒãâĻâĻããŖã¨ãįšåĨãĒ᏿ãĢããčĻããĒãã ããįŦéĄãåããã
ãæŦåŊãĢâĻâĻīŧã
ããĻãŊãĒããĻč¨ããĒããæå¸ã¯éĻãæ¯ãŖãĻãæ¯ãåąããģãŠčŋããĢæĨãĻãåĨŊãã大åĨŊãâĻâĻãæ¤åˇãŽč¸ãĢéĄãã¤ããã
ãããŖãâĻâĻč¯ããŖãâĻâĻã
æŧãããããĒãæããé Ŧãäŧãã
ãããããæŦåŊãĢâĻâĻæããĻâĻâĻæå¸ãããåĨŊããŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻããããžã§ããžãããĄã ãŖãĻãæãŖãĄããŖãĻâĻâĻã
ãããããæå¸ã¯č¸ãĢéĄãåŊãĻããžãžãč
ãčä¸ãĢåããããæããĒããããĢããĻãããã
ãããâĻâĻãããã¨ãâĻâĻãããã¨ãâĻâĻã
ãããŖããŧãŧãŧīŧīŧīŧīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšã¯ä¸ĄæãįĒãä¸ããĻéŖãŗčˇŗããåąå
ãĢã¯ãåãŗãåãããĢã¤ãŦãŗã¨ãčåĨŽãåããã¨ããĩã¤ãŦãŗãéŋãæ¸ĄããååąããšãĻã§å¤§æåŖ°ãčĩˇããŖãã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ããĸãģãããããĄã¯ãã¨ãã°ãããĻãæ°äēēããããŠãŗãéĸäŋãĒãįŦéĄãæĩŽããšãæĄæããæąãåããį§°ãåãâĻâĻããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãæģ˛ãčĻįã§čĻããå
æ¯ãĢãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ãŦãããĢãããˇã§ãŧãããã¤ãŗãããįĢå ´ãåŋããĻį§°ãåãä¸ãããŖãšããŧãã ãã¯ãã¤ããŽéĄãããĻããããčǰãĢãæ°ãĨãããĒããããéããĢãåŗæã§ãŦããããŧãēãããã
ãããīŊãããŖãšããŧããããããžããĻãžãããŠãæŦåŊã¯åŦãããã§ããīŧã
ããĨãĢãŧãšããã¤ãã¤ãåããã¨ãããĩããããŖãšããŧãã¯éŧģãéŗ´ãããããããŽéĄã¯įˇŠãŋãįŽãå°ãæŊ¤ãã§ãããããĢčĻããã
ããããããåąãŽããæšãå¤ãããžããã
ããĨãĸãŗãšã¯ãįŽãį´°ããĻãããŦãããĢãŽéŖãĢįĢãŖãã
ãSSRã¯æŽããã
ãŦãããĢã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããīŧããĒãã§âĻâĻã
ãåŋããĒãããã ã
ãåŋããĒãâĻâĻäŊããã§ããīŧã
ãSSRã¯æŦäŊãåŠããĻãããã ãããžãããĄãč¨ããããĢãč˛ ãŽéēįŖã ããããåŋããĒããããĢâĻâĻäšãčļãããã ã¨ãããŽč¨ŧãĢããĒãã
ãã ãããå´ŠããSSRãããŽãžãžæŽãã¨īŧã
ããããããĒã¤ã¯ãĒãã¨ãããåŋ
čĻãããããĒã
ãŦãããĢã¯ããŠãĒã¨ãããĨãĸãŗãšãčĻãã
ãããŖããæé¤ããžããīŧįŦīŧã
ããããããŠãäŋēããããææĨããæ°äŊåļã ãäģãŽåąããĒã
ãããã§ããã
ããŽåžããŦãããĢãŽč¨čéããåąãŽåŊĸã¯å¤§ããå¤ããŖãã
ãĒããŦããˇãĨãĢãŧã ã¨ããĻįãžãå¤ããŖããå
åĨŗįĨååēå ´ãä¸åŋãĢã¯ããAcceptance is the beginning of everythingīŧå厚ãããšãĻãŽå§ãžãīŧãã¨ãããŋã¤ããĢãŽæŦãæãĄã垎įŦãŋãæĩŽããšãåĨŗįĨåãåģēãĻãããã
ååąã¯ããĒããŦããˇãĨãĢãŧã ãä¸åŋãĢããŠãããĒäŊįŊŽãĢåé
įŊŽãããååąãŽčĄãæĨã¯čĒįąãĢãĒãŖãã
åąéˇåޤãŽį翏ããããåĨå ¨ãĒã¨ãŧãĩã ãéĢåčŗĒãĒäēįŽãäŊãããĢæ¸ãæããããããļãģããŗã¯ã§ã¯ãåąãŽä¸åŋãĢããå¤Šį§¤ãŽéĢäŊãčĒŋæ´ãããå°ãã ãLTå´ãĢåžãã寞įĢããĻããLTã¨STã¯ãį´į˛ãĒåŊšå˛åæ ã¨ããĻãéŖæēãããããĢãĒãŖãã
ããŖãŦã¯ãŋãŧãēã§ã¯ãåąãŽåĨĨãĢããŖãã襨æ
ãĒãšãããæ¤åģãããäģŖãããĢīŧã¤ãŽ
ãĸããŋãŧãč¨įŊŽãããįäŊãĸããŋãŧã ããĢé ŧããĒãå¤č§įãĒä翏Ŧãã§ãããããĢãĒãŖãã
ãŦããŧãŋãŧãēã¯å¤§ããå¤ããŖãĻã¯ããĒãããã¤ãŗãŦãã¨ãĸãĻãŦãã¯ãéŠæ§ãčæ Žããä¸ã§æãĄåãåļãĢãĒããåąãŽåĨĨãĢč˛ŧãŖãĻããį翏ãã¯ããããŧãŋãŽį˛žåēĻã¯æčģãĒæ¸ãæããå¯čŊãĢãããã¨æ¸ãããĻããã
ããļã¤ããŧãēã¯ãæĻåŋĩããŧãŋããŧãšå ãĢããSSRãŽãĸããĨãĄãŗãã ãã§ãĒããåąãŽä¸åŋãĢįŊŽãããããģãĻãščšãŽããļã¤ãŗããå¸čšãããŧãšãĢãčŋäģŖįãĒč¨åãčåãããããĒããŽãĢå¤ããŖãããããĢãˇãããŽããŦãŧãã¯ããå¤åããã嚸ããåŧãå¯ããããĢæ¸ãæããããéåģãæ¨ãĻããã¨ãĒãå¤åããå§ŋããããšãĻãŽåąãĢåŊĸã¨ãĒãŖãĻįžããĻããã
ãããããããŠãããããã
æ¤åˇã¯ãæå¸ãŽéĢĒãæĢã§ãĒããč¨ãŖãã
ããžã ãããŖã¤ããĻããâĻâĻã
æå¸ã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããâĻâĻããŽãåŽļãĢæĨãīŧã
ãæ¤åˇãããŽåŽļīŧã
ãããã
ãčĄãīŧã
æå¸ãįãããããĢįŦãŖãĻãæ¤åˇãéŖãããĻįŦãŖãã
æãįšããé§
ãžã§æŠãéãäēäēēã¯č¨čãäē¤ãããĒããŖãã
ãäēããŽãŦããããįĸēããããããĢãæã
ãįĩĄããæãåãããĻįŦãåãã
æšæããããã¨ãåãããŧã ãžã§æŠããéģčģãåž
ã¤ã
ãã ããã ããŽæéããį°č˛ã ãŖãä¸įãããšããĢãĢæããĻãæ¤åˇã¯éĄãä¸ããã
ãæå¸ãâĻâĻæå¸ãæãåēãĻããã
ããģãã¨ã âĻâĻã§ãį§ã¯ããŖãĄãŽãæ°ãĢãĒããĒã
æå¸ã¯ããč¨ãŖãĻãæ¤åˇãŽé ŦãĢæã§ããŗã¨č§Ļããã
ãæå¸ãŖãĻč¨ãŖãã¨ããé Ŧãčĩ¤ããĒãŖããã
ãããããŖãĻãīŧīŧįŦīŧã
ããããããĒãŖãĻæãŖãĻīŧįŦīŧã
įŦãåããæãįēããĒãããæ¤åˇã¯įĄæčãĢãããŽåš¸ããįļããžããããĢã¨éĄãŖãã
įļãããã¨ã¯ã§ããã
å¤åãåãå
ĨããčĒåãå¤ããįļãããĒãã
ããŠããããŽīŧã
éĄãåããã¨ãæå¸ã¯åžŽįŦãŋãĒããå°éĻãåžããã
ãããã°ãããŖãĻæãŖãĻã
ãããã°ããīŧã
ãããããããæå¸ãåŽãããããĢã
äŊä¸ãĢįģå ´ããčĢčâ