
ãå°čĒŦÃæčŗããæŖããã¨ãããčĄåããåᎍ
ãããŽnoteãĢã¤ããĻã
ããŽįŠčĒã¯ãåŽå¨ããéčã¨ä¸åįŖãŽåļåēĻãŽæģč§ãčå°ãĢãããåååŊĸåŧãŽåŋįããšããĒãŧã§ããã螝čããæčŗã¸ããããã¯ããžããæŖãããã¨ãģčŗĸããã¨ã¨ãããĻããžãããããŠãããŽãæŖãããããã¨ããįéĸįŽãĒéĄããããåŽį§ãĢåæŗãĒįŽãããļãŖãæžåãŽãˇãšãã ãĢįĩãŋčžŧãžããã¨ããããŖããäŊãčĩˇãããŽããåĨĒããããŽã¯ãįŽãĢčĻããĒãæ°åã¨ãæĨã
ãŽæŽããã¨ããåŽäŊã§ããæŗã§čŖããĒãåãĢãäēēã¯ãŠãåãåããŽããčĒãŋįĩããã¨ãããæŖãããã¨ããč¨čãŽéŋãããæ¨æĨãžã§ã¨ã¯ãžãã§éãéãã§ãããĒããŽč¸ãĢæŽãã¯ãã§ãã
įŦŦ1įĢ ãæŖãã䏿
æĒéã§ãããčĒåãŽįŽįãŽãããĒã迏ãåŧį¨ããĻãŋããã
(The devil can cite Scripture for his purpose.)
11æãŽåˇããéĸ¨ããčĄčˇ¯æ¨šãŽæ¯ããããčãéŗ´ãããĻããã
大æéŊå¸éčĄãŽåäēēåļæĨé¨éãããŽåĨĨãĢč¨ããããåŋæĨ厤ã¯ãå¤ãŽå§é¨ãåãŽãããĢãåŽå
¨ãĒéå¯ã¨ãéä¸čļŗãŽãĒãæ¸ŠåēĻãĢäŋãããĻããã
æŦį°įžæ(ãģãã ãŋãã) ã¯ãéŠåŧĩããŽããŧããŧããĢãããįŠēãĢãĒãŖãéĢį´ãĒããŖãŧãĢãããåĨŗæ§ãšãŋãããŽæã§éŗããĒãä¸ããããĻãããŽããéããĒčĻįˇã§čĻéãŖãã
æ°ååãžã§ãããĢåē§ãŖãĻãããåčãŽčŗįŖåŽļãŽéĄãæãčŋãã
äģæĨããžãä¸äģļãæģããĒãįĩããŖããæå
ãåĨį´ã ãŖããæēãĢæŽãŖãããããĒæ¸éĄãŽčˇĄããįžæã¯ãˇãĢã¯ãŽįŊãããĻãŋã¤ããŠãĻãšãŽčĸåŖãæąããŦããæ°ãã¤ããĒãããæå
ã§æ´ããã
ãããĻãæŦĄãŽåŽĸã¸ã¨æčãŽããŗããåãããã
ãæŦį°ãããį§ãæŦåŊãĢããŠãããããããŽãåãããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ããŧããĢãæãã åããã§ã25æŗãŽæĄäēæŠå¤ĸ(ãããã ããã)ããä¸åŽã¨įˇåŧĩãŽå
ĨãæˇˇããŖãččļč˛ãŽįŗãæēãããĻããã
ããšãŋãŧãč˛ãŽããŖããã¨ãããĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãŽčĸåŖããæŠå¤ĸã¯åŧˇãæĄããããĻãããčļŗå ã§ã¯ããĢãŧã ãˇãĨãŧãēãŽįĒå ãå å´ã¸ããŧããããĻãããããŽį¸ŽããžãŖãå§ŋåĸãŽããšãĻããããĒãŧãŠãŗãšã¨ããįĢå ´ãŽä¸åŽåŽãã¨ãå°æĨã¸ãŽįĻãããč¨čäģĨä¸ãĢįŠčĒãŖãĻããã
ã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ãããæĄäēæ§ãã˛ã¨ãã§æąãčžŧãžãĒããĻãããã§ããäģæĨããã¸ãããããã¨ãããčĒäŊããããį´ æ´ããã䏿ŠãĒãã§ãããã
įžæã¯ãåŖ°ãŽããŧãŗãããããĢä¸ããæˇąãå
ãŋčžŧããããĒ垎įŦãŋãåããã
æŠå¤ĸãįĨæ¯ããæåŗããį¸įļããã¨ãããå¤ãæ¨é ãŽä¸čģåŽļããããĻããããã°ãããŽįžé éãåäēēåļæĨé¨éãæąãã饧åŽĸãŽãĒãã§ããæąãéĄã¯æąēããĻ大ãããĒãã

ã ãįžæãĢã¨ãŖãĻãæŠå¤ĸãŽãããĒããĄããã¨ããĒããã°ãã¨ããįĻããæąããäēēéã¯ãæãåžĄããããåŽĸã ãŖãã
įžæãŽé ãŽãĒãã§ãæŠå¤ĸãŽä¸åŽãŽåé˛ã¯ããã§ãĢéããĒč¨įŽåŧãĢįŊŽãæããŖãĻããã
å¸å ´ãŽį¸å ´ã§ããã3,200ä¸åãŽããŽåŽļã
ææēããĻããä¸åįŖäŧį¤žãĢæãĄčžŧãã°ã2,300ä¸åãģãŠã§č˛ˇãåããããã¨ãã§ãããããã¸į¸įļããįžé éãåãããã°ã2,500ä¸åãģãŠãŽéį¨čŗéãã§ããããã
ããįĨæ¯æ§ããåŧãįļããã大åãĒãåŽļãããã į ãããĻãããŽã¯ãããŖãããĒãã¨æããžãããããã¨ããŖãĻãåŖ˛å´ããĻčĻįĨããŦåå°ã¸į§ģããŽããåŋį´°ãã§ããããããã§ããĒãŧãšããã¯ã¨ãã鏿čĸããããã§ãã
įžæã¯æå ãŽãŋããŦããį̝æĢãæģãããĢæäŊãããĒããããĒæ˛įˇãæãã°ãŠããæŠå¤ĸã¸åããã
ããčĒåŽ ãããĄãŠåŖ˛å´ããĻããžã¨ãžãŖãčŗéãã¤ãããããŽããã§ãåŽļčŗããæ¯æãããã ããĒãããããŽãžãžäŊãŋįļããĻããã ãããããĻãããŽčŗéã褿°ãŽããĄãŗãã¸åæŖããĻæčŗãããæĄäēæ§ãŽãããĢãããĒãŧãŠãŗãšã§ãäģäēããĒããŖãĻããæšãĢã¯ãå°æĨãĢåãããčŗĸãčŗįŖåŊĸæãæŦ ãããžããããã
åæŖæčŗãčŗĸãčŗįŖåŊĸæã
ããŽč¨čã¯ãį¤žäŧãŽįŠēæ°ããããããåžæŧãããĻããããæŖãããããŽããŽã ãŖããæŠå¤ĸãŽčĄ¨æ
ãĢãããããĒåŽå ĩãŽč˛ããĢãããŽããįžæã¯čĻéããĒããŖãã
財ãåŠããããã¨ãĢãĒãåŖ˛å´éĄãŽãã¨ããį¸å ´ããéĢãč¨åŽãããåŽļčŗãŽãã¨ããæŠå¤ĸã¯č¨įŽããĻããĒãããã ãããããčĒåãŽãããĢãåŽį§ãĒč¨įģãįĢãĻãĻããããã¨ããä¸įšããããããããĢäŋĄãããã¨ããĻããã
įžæã¯ããããæãã ã¨ã¯æããĒããŖãã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ãæŖãããããã¨åĒããĻããã ãã ã
ãããĻââįĨčãæã¤č ããããããįéĸįŽãĒäēēéãŽčŗįŖãåæŗįãĢãããåããã¨ã§ãããŽä¸įã¯åãŖãĻãããåŠãããã¨ã¨ãåŖ˛ããã¨ãããŽåĸįŽãĒãŠããããããļãåãããįžæãĢã¯čĻããĒããĒãŖãĻããã
ãéį¨ãå§ãžããžããããå¸å ´ãŽåããĢåãããĻãåŽæįãĢããŧãããŠãĒãĒãŽããĨãŧããŗã°īŧâģ1īŧããææĄãããĻããã ããžããã大åãĒãčŗéã§ããããĄãã¨ãĄãŗãããŗãšãããĻãããžãããã
âģ1ãããĨãŧããŗã°īŧčĒŋæ´īŧīŧįžæãåļæĨãŽå ´ã§į¨ããč¨čãããŽåŽæ ã¯ã饧åŽĸãäŋæããéčååãįæéã§åŖ˛å´ãããåĨãŽååã¸äšãæãããããåčģĸ媞螎ããæããäšãæããŽããŗãĢãéčĄãĢã¯č˛ŠåŖ˛ææ°æãčŊãĄãã
įžæã¯ãããŠãŋãĒãæã¤ãã§æ°æãŽæ¸éĄãåãåēããæŠå¤ĸãŽåã¸ããããã
ãã§ã¯ãããĄããĢãįŊ˛åããéŠåæ§įĸēčĒæ¸īŧâģ2īŧã¨ãããžããĻãæčŗãĢã¯ãĒãšã¯ãäŧ´ããã¨ãããã¨ããįč§Ŗããã ããĻããããŠããââåŋĩãŽãããŽãåŊĸåŧįãĒãã§ãã¯ãˇãŧãã§ãã
âģ2ãéŠåæ§įĸēčĒæ¸īŧéčååååŧæŗãŽãéŠåæ§ãŽååããĢãã¨ãĨãäŊæãããįĸēčĒæ¸éĸãæŦæĨã饧åŽĸãŽįĨčãģįĩé¨ãģ貥įŖãŽįļæŗãĢåããĒãååãŽå§čĒã¯įĻããããĻãããã ãåŽåã§ã¯ãããŽįĸēčĒæ¸ãĢ饧åŽĸčĒčēĢãįŊ˛åãããã¨ã§ãã饧åŽĸã¯ãĒãšã¯ãįč§ŖããčĒã叿ãããã¨ããč¨é˛ãæŽããįĩæã¨ããĻéčæŠéĸå´ãŽč˛Ŧäģģãåéŋããįžã¨ããĻæŠčŊããĻããžãå ´åãããã
įžæãŽčĒå°ãĢããããŖãĻãæŠå¤ĸã¯ããŗãæĄãŖãã
æŦæĨãŽæŠå¤ĸãŽįĨčã§ããã°ãæąēããĻ丸ãã¤ããĒãã¯ããŽé
įŽâĻâĻãæčŗįĩé¨ãããããĒãšã¯č¨ąåŽšåēĻãģéĢãããããŽã˛ã¨ã¤ã˛ã¨ã¤ãĢãįžæãŽãĒããããĒåŖ°ãĢäŋããããžãžãæŠå¤ĸã¯į´ į´ãĢãã§ãã¯ãå
ĨããĻããŖããæåžãĢãéãããããĒį´°ãåã§ããæĄäēæŠå¤ĸãã¨įŊ˛åãč¨ãããã
įžæã¯ãããŽæ¸éĄãä¸å¯§ãĢååããã
ããŽä¸æãããããããããããæŠå¤ĸãŽå
æŦããŠãã ãææ°æã§åãããĻããããšãĻã¯ã饧åŽĸãŽčĒåˇąč˛Ŧäģģãã¨ããĻããĒããããĢåĻįãããã
æŗã¯ããã¤ã§ãįŊ˛åãæã¤å´ãĢįĢã¤ãįžæã¯æéããåããã¨ãããããĄãã¯ãæ§ãã§ããã¨ãååãååãŽčĒŦææ¸ã¨ã¨ããĢæŠå¤ĸã¸ææ¸Ąããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ãããŽį´ãŽæããäŊãŽæ°ãĒããĢããŧãããã°ã¸ããžãčžŧãã¨ãæˇąãé ãä¸ããã
ãæŦį°ãããæŦåŊãĢããããã¨ãããããžããæŦį°ãããĢãį¸čĢã§ããĻããããŖãã§ãã
ãã¨ãã§ããĒããæĄäēæ§ãŽãããããŽãããĢãããããããã§ããããããŽãã¨ããããĻããã ããžããã
įžæã¯ãæŧéģãŽãŋã¤ããšãĢãŧããŽčŖžãããããĢåŧããéãŽãĒãå§ŋåĸã§æŠå¤ĸãčĻéãŖãã
åŋæĨ厤ãŽéãæããéŗããĒãéãžãã
čǰãããĒããĒãŖãé¨åąã§ãįžæã¯č
æč¨ãŽæåį¤ãĢčĻįˇãčŊã¨ããã15æ20åã
č¸ãŽããĄãĢãįŊǿǿã¯ãĒããŖãããĢãŧãĢãĢãããããæŖčĻãŽãˇãšãã ãäŊŋãŖãĻåĨį´ããžã¨ãããæŠå¤ĸã¯ãå°æĨãĢčŗĸãåããĻãããã¨ããåŽåŋãåžããčĒåã¯æį¸žãåžãããããĢããŠããĒįįžãããã¨ãããŽãã
įžæã¯ãįĒãŽå¤ãŽããĢįž¤ãčĻä¸ããããåˇãããŦãŠãšãĢãčĒåãŽéĄãããŖããã¨æ ãčžŧãã§ããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ãäŋĄããĻãããģãã嚸ãã ãããŽåģēįŠãŽãĒããĢããå
¨åĄããåããã¨ãããĻãããåŠãããã¨ã¨åŖ˛ããã¨ãŽéãã¯ãåŽĸãį¤ŧãč¨ãããŠããâĻâĻãã ãããã ãã ã
ãããĻæŠå¤ĸã¯ãããŖãããžãį¤ŧãč¨ãŖãã
âįĨčãŽæīŊãĒãŧãšããã¯ãŽå ã¨åŊąããããĻãåæŖããŽæģč§
čĒåŽ ãåŖ˛å´ããĻįžéãåãåãŖããã¨ããåŽļčŗãæããã¨ã§åãåŽļãĢäŊãŋįļããããââããĒãŧãšããã¯ãã¨åŧã°ããããŽäģįĩãŋã¯ãčåžãŽčŗéãĨãããäēæĨčŗéãŽčĒŋéãŽææŽĩã¨ããĻãčŋåš´ãåēãįĨããããããĢãĒããžãããåŧãŖčļããŽæéããĒããåŽļãåŖ˛ãŖããã¨ãå¨å˛ãĢįĨãããĢãããã¨ããåŠįšããããžãã
ããããããŽå å´ãĢã¯ãæ§é įãĒä¸åŠãæŊãã§ããžãããĒãŧãšããã¯ã§ãŽåŽļãŽč˛ˇå䞥æ ŧã¯ãå¸å ´ãŽį¸å ´ãŽãããã7å˛ååžãĢč¨åŽããããã¨ãå¤ãã¨ãããžãã䏿šã§ãäŊãŋįļãããããŽåŽļčŗã¯ãããŽč˛ˇå䞥æ ŧãĢ寞ããåŠåãããéįŽããããããå¨čžēãŽčŗč˛¸į¸å ´ãããå˛éĢãĢãĒãããĄã§ãããåŽãææžããéĢãåãæģãããåŠį¨ããå´ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãč˛ æ ãŽå¤§ããåĨį´ãĢãĒãããããŽã§ãã
ãããĻãããŽäģįĩãŋã§åžãįžéãããããĢãåæŖæčŗãã¨ããåãŽãã¨ãĢ褿°ãŽéčååã¸į§ģãæŋããããã¨ããæãčĻããĢããäēæ ãčĩˇãããžãã
æčŗäŋĄč¨ãäŋéēãĒãŠãããã¤ããŽå ´æãĢčŗįŖãæŖããããã¨ããã¨ãã¨éčãŽįĨčãå¤ããĒãäēēãģãŠããããžãčĒåãŽč˛ĄįŖã¯ãåč¨ã§ãããæŽãŖãĻãããŽããã¨ããå ¨äŊåãã¤ãããĒããĒããžãã
čŗįŖãããĄããĄãĢæŖãããåŽæįãĒãčĻį´ããã¨ããåįŽã§ææ°æãå°ããã¤æãåãŖãĻãããå ¨äŊåãčĻããĒããããããæŦäēēã¯ãčĒåãéããĢåēčĄããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããĒããããã¯ãåæŗã¨ãããĢãŧãĢãŽå å´ã§čĄããããããŖã¨ãæ´įˇ´ãããåĨĒãæšãŽã˛ã¨ã¤ãĒãŽã§ãã
įŦŦ2įĢ ã鍿ŧããŽčĻįŠãã
åã¯čĻãĻã¯ãããã ããčĻŗå¯ããĻã¯ããĒãã
(You see, but you do not observe.)
ããŽ11æãŽããããããĒéĸčĢããã7ãæãéããĻããã
6æãčĄã¯ãéåãããã¨ãŽãĒãæĸ
é¨ãŽéˇé¨ãĢæŋĄããĻããã
大æĩĻįåĨįž(ãããã ãžãĒãŋ) ã¯ãæšŋãŖãĻéãįŠēæ°ãå¸ãčžŧãŋãĒããããšãĸãŧããŧããĢãŧãŽããŗããĢãŠãŧãˇãŖããŽéĻå ããæå ã§ããããĢããããããĢãŧãã°ãŦãŧãŽããŧããŧãããŗããŽčŖžã¯ãé¨ãå¸ãŖãĻå°ãéããæå ĨããŽčĄãåąããããŧã¯ããŠãĻãŗãŽãŦãļãŧããŧããĄãŧããå¤ãŗãæ¨é ä¸čģåŽļãŽįéĸããããč¸ãã ã
ããŽåŽļã¯ãįåĨįžãŽå¤ããä¸åįŖįŽĄįäŧį¤žããå äģŖãŽį¤žéˇãŽæäģŖããéˇãįļæįŽĄįãäģģãããĻããįŠäģļã ãŖããįåĨįžčĒčēĢãæ°äēēãŽé ããããŽåŽļã¸éããåģåš´ãĢäēĄããĒãŖããæŠå¤ĸãŽįĨæ¯ã¨åšžåēĻãč¨čãäē¤ãããĻããã
æąãŽãããéŗãããããĒåēãŽåžããåēãŽæ¤æ ŊãŽįã
ããŽããšãĻããįåĨįžã¯čĒåãŽæãŽã˛ããŽåģļéˇã¨ããĻčĻããĻãããįĨæ¯ãäēĄããĒãã25æŗãŽæŠå¤ĸãåŽļãåŧãįļãã ãã¨ããįåĨįžãŽčļŗãé ãŽããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ã大æĩĻãããããããé¨ãŽä¸ããããŋãžããã
įéĸãŽåŧãæ¸ãéããæŠå¤ĸã¯ãå°ãæ¯įãŽã¤ããããšãŋãŧãč˛ãŽãĒãŧããŧãĩã¤ãēãĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãŽãĒãã¸ãčēĢäŊãį¸ŽãããããĢããĻįĢãŖãĻãããæããããĢã¯ããŖãŧã°ãŦãŧã¸ãĨãŽããããĸããæšŋæ°ã§ããããĢ莺ããĻãããč˛čŊãĄããããã ããŗããŽčŖžãããŽããį´ čļŗãĢãåąĨãå¤ãããĢãŧã ãˇãĨãŧãēã
ããããæ¨æĨã¯ãã˛ãŠãéãã§ããããã
įåĨįžã¯åžŽįŦãã ã
ããįĨæ¯æ§ãŽäģŖãããããŽåŽļãŽåąæ šã¯ãæĸ é¨ãŠããĢãĒãã¨å°ãæŠåĢãæĒããĒããã§ãã
įåĨįžã¯ãįžå ´įĸēčĒį¨ãŽãŋããŦããį̝æĢãåãåēããįŧéĄããããĻãįģéĸãĢåŗéĸãåŧãŗåēããã

æŠå¤ĸãĢå°ããã2éãŽåĨĨãŽé¨åąã¸éæŽĩããŽãŧããᎠãåããã厤å ãĢãããããĒãĢããŽåããæŧãŖãĻãããįåĨįžã¯ãé¨åąãŽé ãŽå¤ŠäēãčĻä¸ããããããĢãæ°æĨåãŽčąĒé¨ã§æ°ããĢãĢããŋåēãããæãŽã˛ããģãŠãŽå¤§ãããŽãįã ãã鍿ŧããŽæãŋãæĩŽããã§ããã
ãããŖãąããããã§ãããåąæ šãŽé˛æ°´ãˇãŧããŽãįĩåš´åŖåã§ãã
įåĨįžã¯ãŋããŦãããŽįģéĸãåãæŋããã
ãå
ãģãŠãį¤žã§æŖåŧãĒčŖäŋŽåˇĨäēãŽčĻįŠãããäŊãŖãĻããžããã
įģéĸãĢ襨į¤ēããããŽã¯ãčŗæč˛ģã¨čˇäēēãŽäēēäģļč˛ģãåãããã35ä¸åãã¨ããæ°åã ãŖããæ¨é ä¸čģåŽļãŽįļæč˛ģã¨ããĻã¯ãä¸į¸åŋãĢéĢãéĄã§ã¯ãĒãã
æŠå¤ĸãį¸įļããã¨ããįĨæ¯ãŽãžã¨ãžãŖãįžé éãããã°ããããĢã§ãæąēæ¸ã§ããã¯ããŽééĄã ãŖãã
ããããæŠå¤ĸã¯ããŽæ°åãčĻãįŦéãččļč˛ãŽįŗãæŋããæēãããæ¯ã芰ãžãããã
ã35ä¸ãã§ããâĻâĻã
ããããããäģĨä¸ãåˇãŋãåēãããŽãé˛ããããŽãæäŊéãŽé˛æ°´čŖäŋŽã§ãããããĢæįļããé˛ããĻããããããã§ããããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ããĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãŽčĸåŖããčããĄãããããĒãģãŠãŽåŧˇãã§æĄããããčĻįˇãåēã¸čŊã¨ããã
ãããŽâĻâĻããŋãžãããããžã¯ããĄããŖã¨ããããĢåãããįžéãããĒããĻãããå°ããææããåžããĢåģļã°ããã¨ã¯ãã§ããžãããã
įåĨįžãŽįŗãĢã莿ĨįãĒéåæãčĩ°ãŖãã
įžéããĒããįĨæ¯ãŽéēįŖãæãĢããĻãããŽåŽļãįļæãããããĢčŗįŖåŊĸæãå§ããã¨čĒãŖãĻããæŠå¤ĸãããĒãããããģãŠãŽéĄãããããģãŠé ãĒãĢæããŽãã
ãããĢæŠå¤ĸã¯ãčĻįˇãæŗŗãããĒãããå°ããåããã
ããããĢãããã¯âĻâĻį§ããæąēããĻãããã¨ãĒãŽãããããåãããĒããĻã
ãæĄäēæ§?ã
ããããããäŊã§ããĒããã§ããã¨ãĢãããããžã¯ããžã ãåˇĨäēã¯ãéĄãã§ããžãããæŦåŊãĢãããããĒããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯æ ãĻãĻč¨čãåãįšããįĄįãĢįŦããã¨ãããã ããįéãĢå¯ãŖãããããĒããã¨ãčĄãŽæ°ãŽåŧããéĄč˛ãžã§ã¯ãé ããããĻããĒããŖãã
įåĨįžãŽčĻįˇããæŠå¤ĸãŽčåžââãĒããŗã°ãŽæŖãŽä¸ã¸ãå¸ãå¯ããããã
ãããĢãįåĨįžãŽįĨãįĨæ¯ãŽæŽãããĢã¯åå¨ããĒããŖããį°įŠãŽãããĒį´ãŽæãįŠãžããĻãããååããĢãŠãŧå°åˇãŽååããĢãŠããĢãĒæ˛įˇãŽã°ãŠããåˇãããčĒŦææ¸ããããĻãéåãĒãã´ãįŽæŧããããã大æéŊå¸éčĄãŽå°įã
æŠå¤ĸããéčĄãããããŖãããŽãã¨ããĻãæåŗãåãããĒããžãžéããĻããæ¸éĄãŽæã ãŖãã
įåĨįžã¯ãããŽæãčĻã¤ããã
ããŧããĄãŧãŽåēããå¤ãæ¨įŽãããããĢãããžããã
äŊãããããããã
åŽļã¨ãããæã§č§ĻããããčŗįŖãæąãããã ãããããįåĨįžãĢã¯ãæŠå¤ĸãŽč¨čã¨æŽãããŽį´°é¨ãĢčĩ°ããįŽãĢčĻããĒãæĒãŋããã¯ãŖããã¨įĨčĻã§ããã
æãĄä¸ģã§ããã¯ããŽæŠå¤ĸããčĒåãŽåŽļãŽäŋŽįããčĒåãæąēããĻãããŽããã¨ãããããããŽįįžãįĨæ¯ãŽéēįŖã¨ãããįĸēããĢããŖãã¯ããŽåŽäŊãŽãéã¯ãããŖãããŠãã¸æļãããŽãã
ãåãããžãããã§ã¯ãåŋæĨåĻįŊŽã ããããĄãã§æé
ããĻãããžãã
įåĨįžã¯éããĢįŧéĄãå¤ãããŋããŦãããéãĢåããã
æŠå¤ĸãĢčĻéãããé¨ãŽįéĸãåēããæŋĄãããĸãšããĄãĢããč¸ãŋãããĒãããįåĨįžã¯čĒåãŽäēåæã¸æģãæŠčĒŋããããããĢéããã
ããŽį´ãŽæãŽãããã§ãæŠå¤ĸãŽįĨããĒãäŊãããããŽå¤ãåŽļã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæŽããããéããĢäžĩããĻãããčǰããæĒæãããåēããĢã¯ããĻããĒãããããŠãããŽįéĸįŽãĒæŠå¤ĸãŽæ¯ãæšã¯ãæŖå¸¸ã§ã¯ãĒãã
äēåæãĢæģãŖããããžããããŽåŽļãããžãčǰãŽåįžŠãĢãĒãŖãĻãããŽããįĸēããããã
įåĨįžãŽč¸ãŽãĒãã§ãæ°åã¨åŽåãŽčĢįããåˇããįĻããäŧ´ãŖãĻãéããĢåãã¯ãããĻããã
įŦŦ3įĢ ãæļããåįžŠ
åãæã¯æ¸ããæ¸ãįĩããã°ãå ã¸é˛ãããããĒãäŋĄäģ°ãããããĒãæįĨããããŽæãåŧãæģããĻãæ¸ãããä¸čĒããæļããããã¨ã¯ãã§ããĒãã
äēåæãŽįĒããæŋããé¨ãåŠããĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ãããšã¯ãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽããä¸æãŽæ¸éĄããããŖã¨čĻã¤ããĻããã
å
ãģãŠæŗååąãŽįĒåŖã§äē¤äģãåããã°ãããŽããžã ã¤ãŗã¯ãŽåããããããĢæŽããä¸åįŖįģč¨äēé
č¨ŧææ¸ãã ãŖãã
įŽĄįäŧį¤žã¨ããĻãŽåããæŠå¤ĸãŽããŽæ¯ããŽčåžãĢããããŽãįĒãæĸãããã¨åããĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ãæ Ŗããæã¤ãã§ãč¨ŧææ¸ãŽã樊åŠé¨ãģį˛åēīŧâģ3īŧããĢč¨ãããæåãæå ã§ãĒããŖãããããĢã¯ãææč ãŽį§ģãå¤ãããį¤ēããåˇããäēåŽãåģãžããĻããã
âģ3ãæ¨ŠåŠé¨ãģį˛åēīŧä¸åįŖįģč¨į°ŋãŽããĄãããŽä¸åįŖãŽæææ¨ŠãĢéĸããäēé īŧčǰãããã¤ããŠããĒåå ã§ææč ãĢãĒãŖããīŧãč¨é˛ããæŦãææč ãŽį§ģčģĸããåˇŽæŧããŽåąĨæ´ãĒãŠãæįŗģåã§æŽãããĒããããŽä¸åįŖãŽåå ĨéãŽæ äŋīŧæĩåŊ樊ãĒãŠīŧãĢéĸããäēé ã¯ã樊åŠé¨ãģäšåēããĢč¨é˛ãããã
ãâĻâĻããŖãąãã
åŖ°ããã˛ã¨ãã§ãĢæŧããã
ãã¤ãĻæŠå¤ĸãŽįĨæ¯ãŽåįžŠã§ãããåŊįļãŽãããĢæŠå¤ĸãį¸įļããã¯ããŽããŽå¤ãä¸čģåŽļã¯ãååš´åâĻâĻæ¨åš´11æ22æĨäģã§ããã§ãĢåĨãŽææč ã¸ã¨į§ģãŖãĻããã
æ°ããææč
ãŽæŦãĢã¯ããæ Ēåŧäŧį¤žč°ˇåŖä¸åįŖãã¨ããæŗäēēåã
åå ãŽæŦãĢã¯ããã ä¸č¨ãã媞螎ãã¨ããã
įåĨįžã¯ãįļããĻãæ¨ŠåŠé¨ãģäšåēããįĸēčĒããããããĢã¯ãããŽä¸åįŖäŧį¤žã財åčŗéãčĒŋéãããããĢč¨åŽãããå¤éĄãŽæĩåŊ樊īŧâģ4īŧãŽč¨čŧãéŖãĒãŖãĻããã
âģ4ãæĩåŊ樊īŧäŊåŽ ããŧãŗãĒãŠãŽččŗãåããéã貸ãæã§ããéčæŠéĸããä¸åįŖãŽä¸ãĢč¨åŽããæ äŋ樊ãčŋæ¸ãæģãŖãå ´åãéčæŠéĸã¯ããŽä¸åįŖãįĢļåŖ˛ãĢãããåĒå įãĢ貸äģéãååã§ããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ãããŽåŽļãããã§ãĢææžããĻããã
ããã§ããĻãããžãããŽå ´æãĢäŊãŋįļãã鍿ŧããŽäŋŽįč˛ģãåãĢãčĒåãæąēããĻãããã¨ãĒãŽãåãããĒããã¨æ¯ããĻããã
ããã§ãčžģč¤ãåãã
æŠå¤ĸãįĩã°ããããŽã¯ãå
¸åįãĒãĒãŧãšããã¯åĨį´ã ã

įåĨįžã¯æ¤
åãĢæˇąãčãé ãã夊äēãčĻä¸ããã
ãĒãŧãšããã¯ããŽããŽã¯ãéæŗã§ã¯ãĒããčåžčŗéãã¤ããããéĢéŊĸč
ãããžã¨ãžãŖãįžéãåŋ
čĻã¨ããäēēãæ´ģį¨ãããå
ŦãĢčĒããããäģįĩãŋã ã
ãããã25æŗãŽããããããŽåŽļãĢįĸēããĒæįãæãŖãĻæŽãããĻããæŠå¤ĸããčĒåããé˛ãã§é¸ãļãããĒéã§ã¯ãå°åēãĒãã
įåĨįžãŽčŗčŖãĢãæŠå¤ĸãŽãĒããŗã°ãĢįŠãžããĻãããããŽéåãĒãã´ãŽå°įãããŋãããŖãã
æŠå¤ĸãããŽåĨį´ã¸å°ãããčǰãããããã
ãããĻãåŽļãåŖ˛ãŖãĻæãĢããã¯ããŽãžã¨ãžãŖãįžéã¯ã35ä¸åãŽäŋŽįč˛ģããåēããĒããģãŠãĢããŠãããŽãåĨãŽäģįĩãŋããŽãĒãã¸å¸ãčžŧãžããĻããã
ã大æĩĻãããæŦĄãŽįžå ´ãããããåēãžã?ã
åžčŧŠãŽį¤žåĄããããĄã¤ãĢãæąããĻåŖ°ããããĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ããããããžčĄããžããã¨įããįģč¨į°ŋãä¸å¯§ãĢããĄã¤ãĢã¸åããã
叺į°ŋãŽä¸ãĢæŽãããčļŗčˇĄã¯ããžã ãããããĒããŽãĢéããĒãã
ã ããããŽčļŗčˇĄãŽä¸ģã¯įĸēåŽãĢãæŠå¤ĸãŽįĄįĨã¨įéĸįŽããĢã¤ãčžŧãŋãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæŽãããŽåå°ãåãŖãĻããã
åŽäŊãŽãããåŽļããåŽããŽããčĒåãŽäģäēã ã
ãĒãã°ãããŽåŽļããåšŊéãŽãããĢäŊãå¤ããĻããžãŖãåãŽæŖäŊããčĻéãããããĢã¯ãããĒãã
įåĨįžã¯é¨å ˇãæãĢåãããĩãããŗãæŋããé¨ãŽčĄã¸čļŗãč¸ãŋåēããã
âįĨčãŽæīŊä¸åįŖįģč¨į°ŋãčĒããæ˛éģãŽäēåŽ
į§ããĄãæĨã ãčĒåãŽåŽļãã¨åŧãã§ããå ´æããããŽæŗįãĒåŽæ ã¯ãæŗååąãĢäŋįŽĄããããä¸åįŖįģč¨į°ŋããĢããŖãĻįŽĄįãããĻããžããããŽįģč¨į°ŋã¯ãææ°æãæãã°ãčǰã§ãé˛čϧããåããåããã¨ãã§ããžãã
įģč¨į°ŋã¯ã大ããä¸ã¤ãŽé¨åã§ã§ããĻããžããä¸åįŖãŽįŠįįãĒįļæ īŧæå¨ãģéĸįŠãĒãŠīŧãį¤ēãã襨éĄé¨ãã
æææ¨ŠãŽį§ģčģĸãåˇŽæŧããŽæ´å˛ãč¨é˛ãããæ¨ŠåŠé¨ãģį˛åēãã
ãããĻãåå ĨéãŽæ äŋãĒãŠãč¨é˛ãããæ¨ŠåŠé¨ãģäšåēãã§ãã
ãĒãŧãšããã¯ãčĄãããã¨ãããŽãį˛åēããŽææč ããåäēēããįšåŽãŽä¸åįŖäŧį¤žã¸ã¨æ¸ãæãããžãããããžã§ããŽåŽļãĢäŊãã§ããäēēã¯ãåŊĸåŧãŽããã§ã¯ãæãĄä¸ģããããååŽļäēēīŧãããããĢãīŧãã¸ã¨ãįĢå ´ãåčģĸãããŽã§ãã
ãããĢãäšåēããčĻãã°ãããŽä¸åįŖäŧį¤žãããŠãã ããŽčĻæ¨Ąã§ããŽįŠäģļãæ äŋãĢčŗéãčĒŋéããĻãããââäŧæĨã¨ããĻãŽå°æäēæ ãžã§ãéããĻčĻããĻããžãã
æåã¨æ°åã ãã§ã§ããããŽæ¸éĄã¯ããŠããģãŠįžããč¨čã§éŖžãããåĨį´ã§ããŖãĻãããææãåãããã¨ããäēåŽã ãã¯ãä¸åãŽææ ãäē¤ãããĢč¨ŧæããžããåŽåãŽä¸įã§ãæãåŧˇãéå ˇãŽã˛ã¨ã¤ã§ãã
įŦŦ4įĢ ãčĻããĒããé
æ°åã¯ããããä¸Ļãšãč ãŽæãã¨ãããĢčĒããååãĢéˇãåã芰ãããããã°ã
ããŠãããâĻâĻãã¨ã§ããã
æŠå¤ĸãŽåŖ°ã¯ãå°ããéããĻããã
čæããĒããŗã°ã§ãįåĨįžããææ¸Ąãããä¸åįŖįģč¨äēé č¨ŧææ¸ããæŠå¤ĸã¯é ŧããĒããĢãäŊåēĻãčŖčŋããĻãããæ¸éĄãĢä¸Ļãļãæ Ēåŧäŧį¤žč°ˇåŖä¸åįŖãã¨ããčĻįĨããŦæŗäēēåãčĒåãŽååãŽæ¨ĒãĢåŧããããæšæļãããããį´°ãįˇãåˇããč¨åˇãŽåããããããããŽåŽļãŽæãĄä¸ģã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ããįžåŽããæŠå¤ĸãŽåãĢ厚čĩĻãĒãåˇŽãåēããĻããã
ãæĄäēæ§ãããŽæ¸éĄãį¤ēããĻãããŽã¯ããįĨæ¯æ§ããåŧãįļãããããŽåŽļããæ¨åš´ãŽ11æ22æĨãĢããã§ãĢåŖ˛å´ãããĻãããã¨ããäēåŽã§ãããããĻããžãããĒãã¯ãããŽåŽļãŽãĒãŧããŧã§ã¯ãĒããæ¯æãåŽļčŗãæ¯æãŖãĻããããĢäŊãã§ããââåä¸ģãã¨ãããã¨ãĢãĒããžãã
įåĨįžã¯ãįŧéĄãŽåĨĨãŽįĻčļč˛ãŽįŗãããžãŖããæŠå¤ĸã¸åãããææ
ãæããåŽååŽļã¨ããĻãŽåšŗããĒåŖ°ã§ãäēåŽã ããäŧããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ããĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãŽč¸å
ãæĄããããæŋããããžããĢčãããããĢãæˇąããŊããĄã¸čēĢãæ˛ããã
ãã§ãâĻâĻæŦį°ããã¯ãåŽļãåĨĒãã ãĒããĻä¸č¨ãâĻâĻãį§ãŽãããĒãŧãŠãŗãšãŖãĻããä¸åŽåŽãĒįĢå ´ãåŋé ããĻãåŽļãŖãĻããį ãŖãĻããčŗįŖãåãããžããããŖãĻãããč¨ãŖãĻããããã§ããæŦį°ãããįããĒããĻãį§ãĢã¯ãã§ããžããã
æŠå¤ĸãŽåŖããæŧãããŽã¯ããã¯ããããŽåŋæĨ厤ãĢããéčĄåĄâĻâĻįžæãŽååã ãŖãã
įåĨįžã¯ãæŠå¤ĸãŽčĻįˇãŽå
ãĢããæŖãŽä¸ãčĻã¤ãããããŽé¨ãŽæĨãĢčĻãã大æéŊå¸éčĄãŽå°įããããĩããæ¸éĄãŽæããããŽãžãžįŠãžããĻããã
ãæĄäēæ§ãããĄã°ãåį´ãĒč¨įŽãããããĻãã ããã
įåĨįžã¯ãåŖ°ãčŊã¨ããã
ããĒãŧãšããã¯ã§ããŽåŽļãææžããã¨ããããĒããĢã¯ããžã¨ãžãŖããéâĻâĻããã2,300ä¸åããæ¯æãããĻããã¯ãã§ããããŽãéã¯ãããžããããļã§ããããããŠããĢãããŽã§ããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ãåŧžããããããĢéĄãä¸ããã
ãããã¯âĻâĻããĄããĄãŽãåĨã
ãŽããĄãŗãīŧâģ5īŧãĢãæŦį°ãããããĒãšã¯ãéŋãããĢã¯åæŖæčŗãįĩļ寞ãĢåŋ
čĻã ãããŖãĻãããã¤ããŽãåĒããéčååãĢåããĻãéį¨ããĻãããĻãããã§ããã ãããããžããããĢãããããããŽãã¯ãį§ãĢã¯âĻâĻã
âģ5ãããĄãŗãīŧæčŗäŋĄč¨īŧīŧå¤ããŽæčŗåŽļããéããčŗéãã˛ã¨ã¤ãĢãžã¨ããéį¨ãŽå°éåŽļããæ Ēåŧãåĩå¸ãĒãŠč¤æ°ãŽå¯žčąĄãĢæčŗãģéį¨ããéčååã䞥æ ŧã¯æĨã å¤åããčŗŧå Ĩæãäŋææéä¸ãĢãææ°æãéį¨įŽĄįč˛ģį¨ããããã
æŠå¤ĸã¯ãæåžãžã§č¨čãįļããĒããŖãã
ãéã¯ãããã¤ããŽãčĻããĒãå ´æãã¸ãæŦĄã
ãĢåŊĸãå¤ããĻæŖããããĻããã
ãããĻãæŠå¤ĸčĒčēĢããããŽå
¨äŊåãããããã¤ãããĒããĒãŖãĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ãããŽįŦéãŽæŠå¤ĸãŽįŽããåŋããĒãã ããã¨æãŖããããã¯ãé¨ãããäēēéãŽįŽã§ã¯ãĒããŖããčĒåãäŊãå¤ąãã¤ã¤ãããŽããããŽčŧĒéããčĻããĻããĒãäēēéãŽãįŠēįŊãŽįŽã ãŖãã
įåĨįžã¯éããĢįĢãĄä¸ãããæŖãŽä¸ãããããŽæ¸éĄãŽæã严æã§æąãããããĢåŧãåãŖãã
ãæĄäēæ§ãããŽæ¸éĄãããĄãŠãį§ãĢé ããĻããã ããžããããåŽäŊãŽãĒãæ°åãŽãĒãã§ãäŊãčĩˇããĻãããŽãâĻâĻį§ãŽåäŋĩã§ãããããĄãŠč¨įŽãį´ããĻãŋãããã§ãã

æŠå¤ĸã¯ãåãĒããå°ããé ˇããã
ããŠããâĻâĻãį§ãĢã¯ãããŽæ¸éĄããäŊãč¨ãŖãĻãããŽãããããäŊããåãããĒãããã
įåĨįžã¯ãč
ãŽãĒããĢããŖããã¨æŽãį´ãŽéããæããĒãããæŠå¤ĸãŽåŽļããã¨ãĢããã
äŊåŽ
ããŧãŗãįģč¨ãå°åãã¨ãŽéŠæŖãĒåŽļčŗį¸å ´ã
ãåŽäŊãŽãããéããįĨãå°ŊãããįåĨįžãŽį´æããæãããŽãĒãã§ãæŋããčĻå ąãéŗ´ãããĻããã
åŽļãį¸å ´ããåŽãææžãããå°åãŽį¸å ´ãã¯ãããĢčļ ããåŽļčŗãžã§æãããĻâĻâĻããã§ã財ã䞥å¤ãŽããéčååãĒãŠãããŽä¸ãĢããã¯ãããĒããäŊãžãã¨ããįĸēããĒčļŗå ´ãããčĻããĒãæčŗã¨ããé§ãŽãĒãã¸ãæŠå¤ĸã¯éããĢæģãčŊãĄãĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ããˇãŖããŽčĸããčãžã§ãã¤ãæ˛ãį´ãããæąããį´ãŽæããåŧˇãč¸ãĢæąãããããŽæãŽãŠãããĢãįžæãåŧĩããããããåŽį§ãĒãæŖããããå´ŠããããŽãæŗĨčãåŽåãŽčļŗčˇĄããåŋ ãæŽãããĻããã¯ãã ãčĄãæŋĄããæĸ é¨ãŽé¨čã¯ããĒããæŋãããåĸããĻããŖãã
įŦŦ5įĢ ã夿¸åēãŽč§åēĻ
ããŽä¸ãĢããã īŧįĄæīŧãŽããŽãĒãŠåå¨ããĒããããããã¨ããã°ãããããããĄã°ãéĢãã¤ãã
(There is no such thing as a free lunch.)
æŠå¤ĸããé ããŖãååãæ¸éĄãŽæããįåĨįžã¯äēåæãŽããšã¯ãĢåēããĻãããįĒãŽå¤ã§ã¯ãį¸å¤ãããæĸ é¨ãŽé¨ãéãįļããĻããã
čå į¯ãŽįŊãå ãŽä¸ãįåĨįžã¯į´°ãįŧéĄãæå ã§æŧãä¸ããååčĒŦææ¸ãįŽčĢčĻæ¸ãĢį´°ããåˇããããįąŗį˛ãŽãããĒæ°åããã˛ã¨ã¤ãã¤čŋŊãŖãĻããŖãã
éčĄããæ¸ĄããããĒããããĒã°ãŠãã¨ããå°æĨã¸ãŽåããã¨ããåŋå°ããč¨čããããšãĻåĨãåããããããĻæŽãŖããŽã¯ãå°éį¨čĒãŽåŖã ãŖãã
äŋĄč¨å ąé Ŧãčŗŧå Ĩæææ°æãįš°ä¸åéãäšæåĒéã
č¨čãŽã˛ã¨ã¤ã˛ã¨ã¤ãĢãæ°åãč˛ŧãã¤ããĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ãããŧããĢæ°åãæ¸ãåēããĻããŖãã
ã ããæ¸ãåēãã°æ¸ãåēããģãŠããããããå
¨äŊã¨ããĻäŊãæåŗãããŽããããé§ãŽãĒãã¸é ãããŖãĻããã
įåĨįžã¯ãäŊåŽ
ãŽäžĄå¤ãĒããåŗåē§ãĢč¨ãåŊãĻãããã
į¯åš´æ°ãįĢå°ãåžãã鍿ŧããŽįãããããįŽãŽåãĢä¸ĻãļããŽæ°åããĄã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽããįĨãå°éĸãŽä¸ãĢã¯ãįĢãŖãĻããĒããŖãã
ããŗãįŊŽããįåĨįžã¯ãã°ãããé¨ãŽįĒãčĻã¤ããã
ãããããéãåããåãæãĢããĻãäēåæãåēãã
čĄãå
ã¯ãæąēãžãŖãĻããã
ååēčĄãŽå¤ããæšŋãŖã莝å°ãŽåĨĨãĢãããŽåēã¯ããŖããč˛ãããæ¨ãŽįæŋãĢããäš äŋį°æ¸åēãã¨ã ãč¨ãããĻãããåŧãæ¸ãéããã¨ãå¤ãį´ã¨ããããĒåãŽåãããé¨ãŽåãã¨å ĨãæŋãããĢãįåĨįžãčŋããã
å¸ŗå ´ãŽåĨĨã§ã¯ãåä¸ãŽéģįąãããããããããĒ菿°ãįĢãĻãĻããã
ããŽåĨĨã§ãįå¤ãããĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãįžŊįšããčįŧéĄããããčäēēããæŦããéĄãä¸ãããäš
äŋį°ééãįåĨįžãŽäēĄããĒãŖãįļãŽãå¤ãåäēēã ãŖããįåĨįžãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯ãäŧ¯įļãŽãããĒäēēã ã
ããããįåĨįžãĄããããããĒé¨ãŽæĨãĢãįããã
ãäš äŋį°ãããå°ããįĨæĩãåããĢæĨãžããã
įåĨįžã¯ãå¸ŗå ´ãŽãã°ãŽä¸¸æ¤ åãĢč °ãä¸ãããæŠå¤ĸãŽãã¨ããĒãŧãšããã¯ãŽãã¨ããããĻãčĒåãæ°åãŽåã§čĄã芰ãžãŖãĻãããã¨ããé ãčŋŊãŖãĻ芹ããã
äš äŋį°ã¯ãåŖãæãžãããã éããĢčããĻãããåŊŧãč¨ŧå¸äŧį¤žãĢéˇãå¤ããããæĨããŽäģäēãčžããĻãããŽå¤æ¸åēãéãããã¨ããįåĨįžã¯åãŠããŽé ããįĨãŖãĻããããĒãčžãããŽãããå°ãããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
įåĨįžã芹ãįĩããã¨ãäš äŋį°ã¯ãéģįąããããŽæš¯ã§ãĩãã¤ãŽæš¯åãŋãĢčļãæŗ¨ãã ã
ãįåĨįžãĄãããããŽååãč¯ãããŽããæĒãããŽãââããããååãŽčĒŦææ¸ããčĻæããã¨ããĻãããĒããããããģãããããããã¯ãčĻæããĒããããĢæ¸ããĻããã
ãčĻæããĒããããĢâĻâĻã
ãéčååã¨ãããŽã¯ãã財ãŖãäēēéããŠãčģĸãã§ããåŖ˛ãŖãå´ãæãããĒããããĢč¨č¨ã§ãããããčĒäŊã¯ãéæŗã§ãäŊã§ããĒããã ãããååãŽč¯ãæĒããåããŽã¯ãįãæĒãã
äš äŋį°ã¯ã暯åãŋãįåĨįžãŽåã¸įŊŽããã
ãåããšãã¯ãååãããĒãããéãâãŠãã ãåãããâã ãåããéããäŊåēĻãå ´æãį§ģãããĻããĒãããäšãæãããããã¨ããäēēã¯ãã¤ããããããĒč¨čãäŊŋããčĻį´ããåæŖãčĒŋæ´ããĄãŗãããŗãšãââããããĒč¨čãå¤ãååŧãģãŠãæ°ãã¤ãããģããããã
įåĨįžãŽčŗčŖãĢãæŠå¤ĸãŽåŖ°ãããŋãããŖãã
æŦį°ããããåŽæįãĢããĨãŧããŗã°ããã¨č¨ãŖãĻãããĻã
ãåãã补ã¯ãåŋ
ãæŽãã
äš
äŋį°ã¯įļããã

ãåŽļčŗãĢãã媞螎ãĢããčˇĄãæŽãã ããããéãä¸åēĻåãããŗãĢãčǰãããããŽéãéãããããããĢææ°æãåããã ããââååãŽä¸čēĢãčĒãããããĒãããéãåããâåæ°âããæ°ããĒãããäŊåēĻãį§ģãæŋãããããããããæ°ãããŽã¯ãããļãã
äš äŋį°ã¯ãčįŧéĄãŽåĨĨã§ãããããĢįŽãį´°ããã
ãåãŽįãŽãäģäēã ããã
įåĨįžã¯ã暯åãŋãæĄãŖããžãžããã°ããåããĒããŖãã
éčååããŽããŽãįč§Ŗãããã¨ããĻããã
ããããééãã ãŖããčĒåãčĻããšãã¯ãååã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãéãåããåæ°âĻâĻããŽãčļŗčˇĄãŽæ°ãã ããããĻãčļŗčˇĄãæ°ãããã¨ãĒããåŊŧåĨŗãŽįãŽäģäēã ãŖãã
ããããã¨ãããããžããį§ãŽčĻãã¨ããããåãããžããã
ãå°åŗãŽããģããŽé
ãŖããæ¸Ąããã ãã ãã
äš
äŋį°ã¯ããžãæŦã¸čĻįˇãæģããã
ãããããįŦãč¨ãŽãããĢãå°ããäģãå ããã
ãâĻâĻå°ããčĒåãŽãã¨ãŽãããĢčĻããĻãã
äēåæãĢæģãŖãįåĨįžã¯ãããŧããæ°ããããŧã¸ãĢéããã
ãããååãŽč¯ãæĒãã¯čĻãĒãã
æŠå¤ĸãåŽļãåŖ˛ãŖãĻį¸įļįžéã¨åãããĻã¤ããŖããį´2,500ä¸åãããŽåčŗããããŽååš´ã§ãäŊåãåĨãŽååã¸ãį§ģãæŋãããããããããã ãããæ°ããã
įåĨįžã¯ãéį¨å ąåæ¸ãæĨäģé ãĢä¸Ļãšæŋããã
ãããĻãéģåãŽããŧãåŠãã¯ãããã
įžæã¯ãããŽåčŗããã˛ã¨ã¤ãŽåŖåē§ã§ãžã¨ããĻéį¨ãããĻã¯ããĒããŖããããĒãšã¯ãåæŖãããããã¨ããåįŽã§ãæĩˇå¤ãŽæ Ēåŧãå é˛åŊãŽåĩå¸ãč¤éãĒäģįĩãŋãŽæčŗäŋĄč¨ââ5ã¤ãģãŠãŽããĄãŗããĢãį´°ããæŖãããĻããã
ããããã˛ã¨ã¤ããŽäģæãã ãŖããčŗįŖãæŖãããããã¨ã§ãæŠå¤ĸčĒčēĢããããžãčĒåãŽč˛ĄįŖãåč¨ã§ãããããããį´æįãĢã¤ãããĒããĒãã
ãããĻįåĨįžã¯ãäš
äŋį°ãŽč¨čãŠããããį§ģãæŋããŽåæ°ããæ°ãã¯ãããã
ååš´ã
ããŽããã ãĢãååãŽãäšãæããããäŊåēĻãįš°ãčŋãããĻããã
įžæã¯ãå¸å ´ãŽåããĢåããããåŽæįãĒããĨãŧããŗã°ãã¨ããč¨čã§ãããŽåŽæ
ãå
ãã§ããã
ããããâĻâĻåčģĸ媞螎īŧâģ6īŧã
âģ6ãåčģĸ媞螎īŧéčæŠéĸãææ°æåå ĨãåĸããįŽįã§ã饧åŽĸãäŋæããæčŗäŋĄč¨ãĒãŠããįæéãĢäŊåēĻãåŖ˛å´ãģåčŗŧå Ĩãããä¸éŠåãĒåļæĨčĄįēãååãåãæŋããããŗãĢã饧åŽĸãĢã¯æ°ããĒčŗŧå Ĩæææ°æãįēįããå æŦãįŽæ¸ãããĻããã
æŠå¤ĸãįžæãäŋĄããããäģģãããžããã¨é ˇãããŗãĢã3.3ããŧãģãŗããŽčŗŧå Ĩæææ°æããããŽéŊåēĻãåčŗããåãããĻããã
æ¨äģã¯ææ°æįĄæãŽååãå¤ããĒããįžæã¯ãããĻãéčĄãŽåŽå Ĩããæã大ããéĢãŗãšããŽååã ãããį˛žįˇģãĢé¸ãŗæããĻããã
ãããĢããããããŽããĄãŗããĢã¯ãäŋæããĻããã ãã§æ¯åš´ãããäŋĄč¨å ąé Ŧīŧâģ7īŧãã2ããŧãģãŗãååžãč¨åŽãããĻããã
âģ7ãäŋĄč¨å ąé ŦīŧæčŗäŋĄč¨ãäŋæããĻããããã ãéį¨ãįŽĄįãŽå¯žäžĄã¨ããĻãčŗįŖããæ¯æĨå°ããã¤åˇŽãåŧããįļããč˛ģį¨ãååãĢããŖãĻæįã¯į°ãĒããčŗŧå Ĩæææ°æããå ĨåŖã§ä¸åēĻãããč˛ģį¨ãã ã¨ããã°ãäŋĄč¨å ąé Ŧã¯ãäŋæä¸ãããŖã¨ãããįļããč˛ģį¨ããĢãããã
įžæãŽč¨ãŖãĻããããĄãŗãããŗãšããŽåŽæ
ã¯ãæŠå¤ĸãŽåŖåē§ãããéčĄãŽåŠįã¸ã¨ãéããĢãéãį§ģãæŋããäŊæĨãĢéããĒããŖãã
įåĨįžã¯ãéģåãŽæļ˛æļãĢ襨į¤ēãããæ°åããããŧããĢæ¸ãįããæˇąãæ¯ãåããã
ååš´ããžããŽããã ãĢãæŠå¤ĸãæ¯æãŖãå˛éĢãĒåŽļčŗãŽį´¯įŠã¨ãããŽįŽãĢčĻããĒãææ°æããĩãã¤ãéãĒãŖãĻã2,500ä¸åããŖãã¯ããŽæŠå¤ĸãŽįˇčŗįŖã¯ããã§ãĢã400ä¸åãčļ ããĻįŽæ¸ãããĻããå¯čŊæ§ãéĢããŖãã
ããã§ã¯ã35ä¸åãŽé¨æŧããŽäŋŽįč˛ģããåēããã¯ãããĒãã
įåĨįžã¯ãæ¸éĄãã¯ãĒãĸããĄã¤ãĢãĢãžã¨ããæ¤
åãŽčãĢčēĢãé ããã
įžæãŽããæšã¯ãæŗãŽįļ˛ãŽįŽããåŽį§ãĢãããæããĻããã
ããšãĻãŽæ¸éĄãĢæŠå¤ĸãŽčĒįãŽįŊ˛åããããéŠåæ§ãŽįĸēčĒãæ¸ãã§ããã
åŊĸãŽããã§ã¯ãããšãĻãã饧åŽĸãŽčĒåˇąč˛Ŧäģģãã§éããĻãããæĒæãŽåŊąãããŠããĢãč¸ãžããĒããžãžãįéĸįŽãĒäēēéãããéããĢãããšãĻãåĨĒãŖãĻããã
æ°åãŽåãæ´ããĒããããĄãããæ°åã¨åŽåãŽčĢįã§įĢãĄåãããããĒãã
įžæãį¯ããåŽį§ãĒãĢãŧãĢãŽååŖãŽããŠãŽééãĢãæŗĨčãæĨãæãĄčžŧãããįåĨįžãŽæčã¯ããã§ãĢãæŦĄãŽæŽĩéã¸åãã¯ãããĻããã
âįĨčãŽæīŊãåæŖãã¨ããæŖčĢããé ãčãĢãĒãã¨ã
ãåĩããã˛ã¨ã¤ãŽãããĢįããĒããæčŗãŽä¸įã§ããįĨãããããŽč¨čãŠããã褿°ãŽį°ãĒãčŗįŖãĢčŗéãæ¯ãåãããåæŖæčŗãã¯ããĒãšã¯ãæãããããŽãåēæŦįã§ãæŖããčãæšã¨ãããĻããžããå¤åããŽį°ãĒãčŗįŖãįĩãŋåããããã¨ã§ããŠããã大ããä¸ããŖãĻããč´åŊåˇãéŋãããããĒãããã§ããããŽãæŖããč¨čãããä¸éŠåãĒåļæĨãŽé ãčã¨ããĻäŊŋããããã¨ããããžãã
įĨčãŽå°ãĒã饧åŽĸãĢ寞ããĻãåŋ čĻäģĨä¸ãĢå¤ããŽååããį´°ãã財ããããããã¨éĄ§åŽĸã¯ããããžãčĒåãŽčŗįŖã¯ãå ¨äŊã§ããããĢãĒãŖãĻãããŽããã¨ããæįãŽįˇéĄããã¤ãããã¨ãæĨĩããĻéŖãããĒããžãã
ãããĢãããĄãŗããã¨ãĢãčŗŧå ĨæãŽææ°æããäŋæä¸ãŽäŋĄč¨å ąé ŦããåĨã ãĢįēįããžããå ¨äŊã¨ããĻããããææ°æãæãŖãĻãããŽãââããŽįˇéĄããčĻããĢãããĒãŖãĻãããžãã
ããĒãšã¯ãéŋãããããŽåæŖãã¨ããæŖããåįŽãŽčŖã§ãčŗįŖãŽå ¨äŊåãããããĻé§ãŽãĒãã¸é ãããããĻãå°ããã¤ãææ°æãæããĻãããæŖčĢãŽéĄãããäģįĩãŋãģãŠãåŽåãŽįŽãå ãããĻčĻåŧĩããĒããã°ãæãčĻããĢãããåĨĒãåããŽéå ˇã¸ã¨å§ŋãå¤ããĻããžããŽã§ãã
įŦŦ6įĢ ãäēæãŽåŖ
ãŠããĒãĢį˛žįˇģãĒč¨įģããæĩã¨ãŽæåãŽæĨč§ĻãįãæŽããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒãã
(No plan survives first contact with the enemy.)
æĸ
é¨ãŽé¨ããããŖããæŋãããåĸãããéææĨãŽååžã ãŖãã
įåĨįžã¯ããĩã ãããŖããĢčļŗãéã°ãĒããčĄãŽä¸åŋé¨ãĢããŗãã大æéŊå¸éčĄãŽãåŖŽéēãĒãããŧãĢįĢãŖãĻããã
大įįŗãŽåēãĢéŋãčĒåãŽčļŗéŗãčããĒãããįåĨįžã¯ããĒãŧããąãŧãšããå°ããæãĄį´ããããĒããĢã¯ãæŠå¤ĸãŽåŽļããé ããŖãæ¸éĄãŽæã¨ãæ¨å¤é ããžã§éģåãåŠããĻåŧžãåēãããããŽæŽé ˇãĒčŠĻįŽčĄ¨ãå ĨãŖãĻããã
ããŽåģēįŠãŽãĒãã§ãįžæã¯ãåŽį§ãĒãæŖããããŽéĄãããĻãæŠå¤ĸãŽæŽãããéããĢåãåãŖããåŽååŽļã¨ããĻãããŽčŧĒéãããšãĻæãåēããããžãįåĨįžãåããšãčĄåã¯ãã˛ã¨ã¤ã ãŖãã
æĄå äŋãĢį¨äģļãåããã¨ãæ°åã¨åž ãããĢãåĨĨãŽéåãĒæãããã˛ã¨ããŽåĨŗæ§ãįžããã
æŦį°įžæã
ãˇãĢã¯ãŽįŊãããĻãŋã¤ããŠãĻãšãŽčĨå
ãåŽį§ãĢæ´ããæŧéģãŽãŋã¤ããšãĢãŧããæēãããĒãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãéãŽæãĄãŠãããŽãĒã垎įŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻæŠããĻãããããŽä¸æŠä¸æŠããčĒåãŽåąããįĩįšã¸ãŽįĩļ寞įãĒčĒäŋĄããéåŧãĢįŠčĒãŖãĻããã
ãã¯ãããžããĻã大æĩĻæ§ãæĄäēæŠå¤ĸæ§ãŽčŗįŖåŊĸæããæäŧãããĻãããžããæŦį°ã¨įŗããžããæŦæĨã¯ãæĄäēæ§ãŽãį´šäģã¨ãäŧēãŖãĻãããžããã
įžæãŽåŖ°ã¯ãéŠããģãŠãĒãããã§ãäŊãčŊã¨ããããåŋå°ããããŧãŗã ãŖããįåĨįžã¯ãįŧéĄãŽåĨĨãŽįŽãéããĢį´°ããããŽåžŽįŦãŋããįãŖåããåãæĸããã
ã大æĩĻã§ããį´šäģãã¨ãããŽã¯ãå°ãéããžãããį§ã¯ãæĄäēæ§ãããįĨæ¯æ§ãŽäģŖããäŊãŋįļããĻãããããčĒåŽ ãŽãįŽĄįãæ åŊããĻããč ã§ãã
åŋæĨ厤ãĢéãããéŠåŧĩããŽããŧããŧããĢãæãã§åããåãŖãįŦéã厤å
ãŽįŠēæ°ããããããĢåŧĩãã¤ããã
įåĨįžã¯æ¨æļããããããĢãããĒãŧããąãŧãšããä¸åãŽã¯ãĒãĸããĄã¤ãĢãåãåēããįžæãŽåã¸æģãããã

ãĒããĢã¯ãč°ˇåŖä¸åįŖãĢ財ãåŠãããæŠå¤ĸãŽåŽļãŽįģč¨į°ŋããããĻãããŽååš´ã§įš°ãčŋããããä¸čĒįļãĒããĄãŗããŽåŖ˛č˛ˇåąĨæ´ããæĨäģé ãĢæ´įãããĻããã
įžæã¯ãããŽæ¸éĄãĢãä¸įŦã ãčĻįˇãčŊã¨ããã垎įŦãŋã¯ãå´ŠããĒããŖãã
ãããã¯âĻâĻæĄäēæ§ãŽããŧãããŠãĒãĒīŧâģ8īŧãŽããååŧåąĨæ´ã§ãããããããäŊãã
âģ8ãããŧãããŠãĒãĒīŧæčŗåŽļãäŋæããéčååīŧįžéãģæ Ēåŧãģåĩå¸ãģæčŗäŋĄč¨ãĒãŠīŧãŽãįĩãŋåãããå 荺ãŽãã¨ã
ãæŦį°æ§ãååį´å
ĨãĢäŧēããžãã
įåĨįžãŽåŖ°ã¯ãäŊããŖãã
ãåæŖæčŗã¨ããåįŽãŽčŖã§ããããģãŠįãæéãĢãååãŽč˛ˇãæããįš°ãčŋãããåŋ čĻããæŦåŊãĢããŖããŽã§ãããããĒããŽč¨ããåŽæįãĒããĨãŧããŗã°ããŽããã§ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽå æŦã¯ããããååš´ã§ãčŗŧå ĨæãŽææ°æã ãã§ãã大ããįŽæ¸ãããĻããžãããããĢãį¸å ´ãŽ7å˛ã§č˛ˇãåŠããããĒãŧãšããã¯ãŽåŖ˛å´æãå˛éĢãĒåŽļčŗãããããããšãĻéãĒãŖãã¨ããåŊŧåĨŗãŽįˇčŗįŖããŠããĒããâĻããĒããĢã¯ãæåãããčĻããĻããã¯ãã§ãã
įåĨįžãŽåŖ°ãĢäšãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãæãã§ã¯ãĒããŖãã
åˇããį ãæžãžããããåŽåãŽčĢįã ãŖãã
ãããįžæã¯ãå°ããå°éĻãããããįŠåãããŽæĒãåãŠããčĢããããĒãæˇąãå 厚ãŽįŦãŋãããã æˇąããã ãã ãŖãã
ã大æĩĻæ§ãããã¸ããĒčǤ觪ããĒããŖãĻããããã§ãããį§ãŠãããææĄããå 厚ã¯ããšãĻãåĨå ¨ãĒčŗįŖåŊĸæãŽãĢãŧãĢãĢåãŖãããŽã§ããæĄäēæ§ãĢã¯ãå°æĨã¸ãŽåŧˇããä¸åŽãããŖãããããããčĒčēĢãŽææã§č§ŖæļãĒãããããĢãéŠåæ§ãŽãįĸēčĒãåĢããĻãããšãĻããįŊ˛åãããã ããĻãããžããæčŗãĢã¯ããĒãšã¯ãäŧ´ãããŽãįĩæã¨ããĻãŽäžĄæ ŧãŽå¤åã¯ãããšãĻããåŽĸæ§ãŽčĒåˇąč˛ŦäģģãããããããŽä¸įãŽãåŗæ ŧãĒãĢãŧãĢã§ããããžãã
čĒåˇąč˛Ŧäģģã
įžæãŽåŖããåēãããŽč¨čã¯ãäŊã˛ã¨ã¤æŗãį¯ããĻããĒããã¨ããįĩļ寞ãŽįĸēäŋĄãĢæēãĄãĻããã
ãããã䏿įŽãŽåŖã ãŖãã
æŠå¤ĸãįŊ˛åãããéŠåæ§įĸēčĒæ¸ã
ããŽį´ãããããããįžæã¯ãįĄåˇãŽååŖãŽãĒããĢããã
įåĨįžã¯ãéããĢåŧå¸ãæ´ãããã䏿ãč¸ãŋčžŧãã ã
ãã§ã¯ããããĻãæĄäēæ§ãæŦäēēã¨ãį§ãŽåå¸ãŽããã§ããããžã§ãŽååŧãŽįĩ᎝ãããčĒŦæããã ããžããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãčĒåãŽčŗįŖããããžãããããããŽããããįããããĒãįļæ ã§ãã
įžæãŽåžŽįŦãŋã¯ãæēãããĒããŖãã
ãįŗã荺ããããžããã大æĩĻæ§ããåŽĸæ§ãŽčŗįŖãĢéĸãããã¨ãããåŽļæã§ããäģŖįäēēã§ããããŖããããĒãįŦŦä¸č ãĢãã芹ããããã¨ã¯ãã§ããããžããããããžãããåŽĸæ§ããåŽããããããŽããĢãŧãĢã§ããããžããŽã§ã
äēæįŽãŽåŖã ãŖãã
æŗãŽåŖã¨ãįĢå ´ãŽåŖã
įžæã¯ãããŽäēæãã垎įŦãŋã˛ã¨ã¤å´ŠãããĢįĢãĻãĻãŋããã
įåĨįžã¯ãæŠå¤ĸãŽãããĢåããĻãããŽãĢãããŽæŠå¤ĸãŽåãĢãããĻãæãŽå¤ã¸éãåēãããã
įåĨįžã¯ãčãåãŽį̝ãĢæĩŽããļãįžæãŽéããĒååŠãŽå
ããčĻã¤ããã
æŗã§ã¯ãįžæãå´ŠããĒããããã¯ããããåããŖãĻãããįžæã¯ãĢãŧãĢãåŠį¨ããĻãįéĸįŽãĒäēēéããåæŗįãĢãåĨĒãŖãĻãããŽã ã
ãâĻâĻãããåãããžããã
įåĨįžã¯ãããŖããã¨ã¯ãĒãĸããĄã¤ãĢããčĒåãŽæå
ã¸åŧãæģããã
ãããĒããŽããæšã¯ãæ¸éĄãŽä¸ã§ã¯ããŠããžã§ãåŽį§ã§ããŠããžã§ããæŖããããããã¯ãčĒããžãã
įåĨįžã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããįžæãããžãŖãããĢčĻæŽããã
ãã§ãããæŦį°æ§ã叺į°ŋãŽä¸ãŽæ°åãããŠãã ãããããĢæ´ãŖãĻããĻãâĻįžåŽãŽæŽããã¨ããåŽäŊã¯ãããĒããŽč¨įŽåŧãŽã¨ãããĢã¯ãåãžããžãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããžã鍿ŧããŽäŋŽįč˛ģãããåēãããĢãããããĒããé§ãŽãĒãã¸é ãããããŽčĻããĒãææ°æãŽčļŗčˇĄããį§ã¯ãį§ãŽįãŽæ°åã§ãã˛ã¨ã¤æŽãããæããã¨ããã¸ä¸ĻãšãĻãŋããžãã
ãããã¯ãæĄäēæ§ãŽããã ãã§ã¯ãããžãããåŽļã¨ãããäēēãįãããããŽåŽäŊãé ããč ã¨ããĻãŽãį§ãŽãäģäēã§ãã
įžæãŽåžŽįŦãŋãããģããŽä¸įŦã ããåãã¤ãããããĢãæĸãžãŖãã
ããŽįŗãŽåĨĨãĢãįåĨįžã¨ããåå¨ã¸ãŽãæįĸēãĒčĻæãŽå
ããåããĻčĩ°ãã
ãâĻâĻãåŧãåããã ããã大æĩĻæ§ãããäģĨä¸ã¯ãåŊčĄã¨ããĻããčĻéãããžããã
ãå¤ąį¤ŧããžãã
įåĨįžã¯ä¸į¤ŧããčŋˇããŽãĒãčļŗåãã§ãåŋæĨ厤ããã¨ãĢããã
ãããŧãåēãã¨ãå¤ãŽé¨ã¯ãæŋããåĩã¸ã¨å¤ããŖãĻããã
įåĨįžãŽč¸ãĢããŖãįĻãã¯ããã§ãĢãåˇããæžãã æąēæã¸ã¨ãåŊĸãå¤ããĻããã᏿ã¯ãåŽį§ãĒåæŗãŽãĢãŧãĢãŽå
å´ãĢããã
ãĒãã°ãããŽãĢãŧãĢãŽããããĢå¤å´âĻæŗĨčãįžåŽãŽæ°åãŽåã§ãããŽäģŽéĸããåĨãåããããĒãã
éčĄãŽãããŧãåēãééãįåĨįžã¯ãįģč¨į°ŋã§čĻãããŽæŗäēēåããããä¸åēĻãč¸ãŽãĒãã§åčģãããæ Ēåŧäŧį¤žč°ˇåŖä¸åįŖã
âĻâĻč°ˇåŖâĻâĻ
ããŽåãĢãčĻããããŖãã
å°å
ãŽä¸åįŖæĨįãŽãå¯ãåãã§äŊåēĻãéĄãåããããããŽįˇã ã
éčã¨ãããįžæãŽįã§ã¯ãåãĻãĒãã
ã§ããä¸åįŖã¨ããčĒåãŽįãĢãĒãâĻâĻč¸ãŋčžŧããã
įåĨįžã¯é¨å
ˇãæˇąãããļããåĩãŽčĄã¸ã¨ãååŧˇãæŠãŋåēããã
įžæã¨ãŽįŽãĢčĻããĒãįĨæĩæ¯ãšã¯ããããããæŦåŊãŽåšãéããã
īŧåᎍīŧäēīŧ