New pull request overview page in public preview ð #212186
Replies: 167 comments 79 replies
|
I have a few pieces of feedback, broken out here to be easier to respond to. I'd also be happy to split this into multiple comments if that would be easier to work with. Firstly, I like the redesign of the merge box and moving it to the top. Being able to see the status at a glance without having to scroll, no matter how active the PR is, is a huge win. On the other hand, I don't like the redesign of the rest of the page as much, for a few reasons. Here they are in order of least-to-most blocking for my workflow: I find newest-first sorting really hard to read (I'm in full support of having it be an option, and thank you for letting us change it back, but I think it's an odd default).
And finally the biggest issue for me is the split timelines. I use the activity timeline a lot to see what has actually happened to a PR since I last reviewed it, especially for force pushes, so having that information inline with the review and comment history is important to my workflow. Splitting them out means that now if I want to see what happened since I last reviewed I need to manually filter the activity list in my head. Additionally, there is no longer an easy link to view a force push's diff, which is a view I use extremely frequently due to our PR process. |
This comment was marked as duplicate.
This comment was marked as duplicate.
|
very cool design, i really like it ð |
|
I don't like it. |
|
Can we get rid of the scroll jump after approving a PR? In 90% of cases, my next action after clicking Approve is to merge, but the merge button is now at the top. |
|
I would love if it can show the project fields like iteration and when they change on PR. We manage testing on PR so when it moves from swimlane to swimlane that is visible but other project fields are not. |
|
Please keep the diff stat in a fixed position, independent of branch name length, so it's easier to compare stacked PR sizes. |
|
I assume that this is progressively rolling out to users? I've not seen the |
|
It would be useful to be able to pin a comment to the top. There are often comments or bot feedback that get lost in the noise that are important top level content. |
|
Iâd love a "back to top" button ð Both in the |
|
Please enable PR numbers in commits (e.g. merging a pr into another pr) to be actual links like in the current version in the commit log. |
|
The statuses check result seems unable to find in new overview page after it is merged. It can be seen when PR is open, but nowhere to locate after it is merged unless switch back to classical view. |
|
The current design is elegant in it's simplicity. The very top of the page is the PR description, the first thing that is created. As you go down, everything is ordered by when it happened in relation to each other. When did a commit occur? When did a comment get added? It's all in order. It's easy to follow and understand. It's easy to keep track of what's left to be addressed, and how we got here. The new system is a NIGHTMARE. Everything is hidden. It's all obscured. You can no longer see how anything relates to anything else. Everything is shoved away into a sidebar that is too small. It makes everything feel cluttered and claustrophobic. And you can't see things in context. You can only see them isolated and one at a time. YOU HAVE REMOVED CONTEXT. That's... BAD. THAT'S VERY VERY BAD. You could literally just keep everything as it is, and put a series of checkboxes at the top to filter what is shown in the existing timeline and it would achieve what you are trying to do, take like 5 minutes, and not completely ruin the page. I hate ALL of these recent changes. The ugly sidebars that can't be hidden, only collapsed. The useless "Checks/Comments/Approvals" graph at the top that will just be "checks" 99.9% of the time with an ugly 2/3rds of it only being relevant for the last 10 seconds of the PR. The most important part being the merge status is now basically impossible to find unless you explicitly go searching for it. I WANT THAT ALWAYS VISIBLE 100% OF THE TIME NEVER HIDDEN. STOP HIDING THE STUFF I NEED. STOP SHOWING THE STUFF I DON'T. The current system is great. It shows everything in order. I don't need that changed. I don't want that changed. I didn't ask for that to be changed. STOP BREAKING EVERYTHING THAT WORKS! Stop making everything worse! Stop shoving your co-pilot ads into every corner of everything. I don't want an advertisement inside an ESSENTIAL dropdown which is now the ONLY WAY to get to the mission-critical UI's that used to be immediate, obvious, always-visible, and updated in real-time. Now they are hidden, require effort to access, constantly hide the moment you click on anything else, and treated as pointless. I HATE THIS. I am so sick of these constant anti-pattern, brain-dead, slop redesigns. "Oh gee, what if we made everything worse, and then called it a "preview" so that we can get constant negative feedback and more ð than any other reaction.... then ignored all that feedback and did the thing everyone hates anyways". You did it. You already invented the Oreo. It's the perfect cookie. Just go home early, stop messing with it. You're not making ANYTHING better. NOT ANYTHING. |
|
There's a scroll jump bug(scrolls down then goes all up) that occurs after submitting a new comment when comments are sorted by newest. |
|
PR review page missing restart failed workflow steps from PR page, not going into workflow run page itself. |
|
If I want to merge a pull request it's right there at the top, which is nice, but if I want to close one, I have to scroll all the way to the bottom still. More often than not, when I would want to perform an action on a pull request immediately without scrolling down to read everything, I want to close it. Please add a way to close the pull request to the merge box at the top so I don't have to scroll all the way down to close it. |
|
Any way to get back to the Old UI the new UI sucks |
|
I don't know if it's a bug, but it feels odd: Using the 'Mine' comment filter button produces different results than selecting yourself from the drop-down filter-comments-by-author. The 'mine' filter appears to only show inline/code comments and not general comments (sorry if I got the names of the different comment styles wrong [side note: I wish the general comments could be 'resolved' too]) |
|
Constantly have to click "merge status" now to get all the info I need. Used to be on the page in the order of what I needed to do:
Etc. Now? I read the description. Then I scroll down to see the coderabbit/cubic/greptile summary at the bottom. Then I scroll slowly up to see the progress/conversation. Then I click "Merge Status" to see full details. It's more clicks, more scrolling, and a more crowded/busy UX. |
|
I'm not sure what was wrong with the old PR layout, it had been working for many years. Seems like a "don't fix what isn't broken" scenario to me. |
|
As someone who has been using GitHub pull requests for nearly 17 years, please keep a merge button at the bottom of the page where it has always been. If you want to put one at the top of the page, cool, but don't remove the one at the bottom of the page where everyone expects it to be. Every PR I look at with this new layout has me scrolling up and down aimlessly trying to figure out where they've hidden the merge button. |


















Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
On a long pull request, checking whatâs blocking often means scrolling past dozens of comments and timeline events just to reach the merge box. And once youâre there, you still need to work out what to do next. As people need to review more and more pull requests, time spent scrolling adds up. So weâve begun to rethink the entire experience, beginning with addressing a familiar challenge: finding whatâs blocking progress and determining what to do next.
Today, weâre introducing the Overview page as an opt-in public preview, with rollout continuing through the weekend. It brings merge status and next available actions to the top of the page in a compact readiness summary. Itâs the first step toward making pull requests easier to follow as code, conversations, and reviews evolve.
The merge box, distilled
Weâre starting with the merge box, the place developers go to see whether a pull request can move forward. Rather than just moving it higher, weâve also redesigned it to show the same information in less than half the space.
Start with the summary, then follow the detail that matters to your next step (e.g., get to failing checks, see who still needs to approve, or open the relevant comments).
Keep your place. Focus your attention.
This first preview also introduces more ways to catch up on activity and focus the conversation so you can spend less time finding your place.
You can also mark a draft ready for review or close a pull request from the header, with available actions depending on your permissions.
Try the new overview
To join, select the âĻ Try the Overview page button in the header. Weâre opening this preview early so you can try the new direction on your own pull requests and help shape what comes next. You can use the same menu to return to the classic overview during the preview.
ð Help shape what comes next
This preview is very much a starting point, not the finished pull request experience. Try it on your next pull request. What is easier to find? Where do you still lose context? What sends you back to the classic overview?
Join the discussion and leave feedback in the comments below!
All reactions