Xbox Series X|S unit sales in the United States fell 27% year over year in September 2026, according to Circana data that Pure Xbox reported on October 22. PlayStation 5 moved the other way, with unit sales up 22%. Nintendo Switch 2 slid 14%. Circana ranked PS5 first, Switch 2 second and Xbox Series X|S third.
The detail that gets lost in the headlines is the dollar figure. Xbox hardware dollar sales fell just 2%, which means the buyers who did pick up a console paid noticeably more for it. That gap between units and dollars drives most of this analysis, and it puts the long-running Xbox Series X vs PS5 debate in a sharper light as the holiday season opens.
Below, we walk through the full September scorecard, explain why Xbox Series X sales look worse inside Circana’s tracking window than they may look by year-end, and lay out what Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo face between now and January. Every figure covers the US market only. Where a claim rests on a single outlet, the text says so.
Don't miss new tech stories on Google
Add Tech Insider once in the Google app and our stories appear in your news suggestions.
What Circana Reported for September 2026
Circana is the market research firm formerly known as NPD Group, and its US retail tracking service produces the monthly hardware rankings the games industry watches. Its September 2026 report did not cover the calendar month. The window ran from August 30 through October 3, a detail VGChartz spelled out in its own writeup.
Mat Piscatella, a Circana analyst, posted the headline numbers on October 22. Total US video game hardware unit sales fell 3% against September 2025. Total hardware dollar spending rose 12% to $362 million, according to several outlets that reprinted the data. The table below pulls the platform-level figures together.
| Platform | US rank | Unit sales (YoY) | Dollar sales (YoY) | Average price paid (YoY) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PlayStation 5 | 1 | +22% | +43% | $646 (+17%) |
| Nintendo Switch 2 | 2 | -14% | -12% | $498 (+2%) |
| Xbox Series X|S | 3 | -27% | -2% | $663 (+33%) |
| Total US hardware | n/a | -3% | +12% (to $362M) | n/a |
| All US video game spending | n/a | n/a | -1% | n/a |
One note on the table. Circana’s average-price list showed three figures, and the PS5 line was not labeled in the reports we read. The math settles it. PS5 dollars rose 43% while units rose 22%, and 1.43 divided by 1.22 works out to roughly a 17% rise in average price. That matches the unlabeled $646 figure, so we assign it to PS5. All three prices are average transaction values, not official list prices.
Five Circana data points behind the story
The GamesIndustry.biz writeup of the same report, which led with Marvel’s Wolverine topping the software chart, carries the core Circana findings. In paraphrase, the five that matter most are:
- Circana found PS5 unit sales up 22% year over year in the US for the September 2026 period.
- Circana found Switch 2 unit sales down 14% over the same stretch.
- Circana found Xbox Series X|S unit sales down 27%.
- Circana found PS5 hardware dollar sales up 43%.
- Circana found total US hardware unit sales down 3%.
Xbox Series X Sales Drop 27% to a Reported September Low
Xbox Series X sales and Series S sales are tracked together by Circana, so the 27% decline describes the whole family. Several outlets, including Windows Forum, iXBT and GamingBolt, called the result the lowest September for Xbox hardware in US unit terms. That framing comes from secondary reporting, not from Circana’s public release or a Microsoft statement, so treat the record claim as reported rather than confirmed.
Context helps here. Console sales swing hard from month to month, and Xbox has had stronger stretches in 2026. Pure Xbox ran a headline earlier this year calling one month Xbox’s biggest for US console sales in 2026 so far, and a reader on the September thread cited a gain of 86% in June. We could not verify that June figure independently. It still shows how volatile a single month can be, and why one weak September does not prove a permanent collapse.
Units sank while dollars barely moved
Units down 27% and dollars down 2% cannot both come from the same product mix at the same prices. Something pushed the average sale up. Either buyers shifted toward pricier Series X units, or bundles and price moves lifted the typical ticket, or cheaper entry-level sales dried up faster than premium ones. Circana’s public numbers do not say which. What they do say is that Xbox earned almost as many hardware dollars as a year ago from far fewer boxes.
The $663 average price paid
Circana’s Retail Tracking Service put the average price paid for Xbox Series hardware at $663 in September 2026, up 33% from a year earlier. Compare that with $498 for Switch 2 and about $646 for PS5. Xbox now carries the highest average ticket of the three, and it is selling the fewest units. That combination usually signals a shrinking, higher-spending core audience rather than a broad base of casual buyers.
It also leaves Xbox exposed on volume. A platform that depends on enthusiasts to carry its sales has little cushion when those enthusiasts wait for a sale, a bundle or the next hardware generation. The September figures read like exactly that pause.
PS5 Hardware Dollars Jump 43%, Best Share Since May 2025
PS5 was the clear winner. Units rose 22% and dollars rose 43%, and VGC reported that Sony’s hardware dollar share reached its highest monthly level since May 2025. PS5 led the US market by both units and dollars, so Sony won on volume and on revenue at the same time.
The dollar jump outran the unit jump because the mix leaned expensive. Sony’s current lineup, as listed on its own shop pages, includes the PS5 at 1 TB, the PS5 Digital Edition at 825 GB and the PS5 Pro at 2 TB. Sony’s UK shop showed £569.99, £519.99 and £789.99 for those three on October 23. Those are UK prices, not US ones, but they show how wide the ladder is. Our PS5 Pro, Xbox Series X and Switch 2 price comparison covers the US side of that spread.
Sony’s own listings during October 17 to 23 also show limited bundles, including a Marvel’s Wolverine Battle Yellow edition and a Ghost of Yotei Black edition. Sony has also announced a Japan-only Midnight Black PS5 Digital Edition for November 19, 2026, priced at 55,000 yen with tax, according to its listing. That model is announced, not yet on sale. No PS5 successor has been confirmed, and the PS5 Pro remains the newest model in the current lineup.
Switch 2 Slips 14% Against a Tough Comparison
Switch 2 unit sales fell 14% and dollar sales fell 12%, with the average price paid at $498, up 2%. A decline sounds bad, but the comparison base explains part of it. Nintendo released Switch 2 on June 5, 2025, so September 2025 sat inside the console’s early, launch-driven run. Matching that in year two is hard for any platform. Switch 2 also held the top hardware spot earlier in 2026, with My Nintendo News noting it was No. 1 in March.
Nintendo is already feeding the holiday window. A Switch 2 and Switch Sports Resort bundle went on sale October 22. Nintendo’s UK storefront reportedly lists a Switch 2 and Mario Kart World bundle for October 29, and a Zelda 40th Anniversary Edition has been reported for the same date. Final Fantasy Resonance also launched on Switch 2 and Switch on October 22, per Nintendo’s Japanese site. None of that landed inside the September window.
For a head-to-head view of how Nintendo’s console stacks up against Sony’s, see our Switch 2 vs PS5 breakdown. The short version is that the two platforms chase different buyers, which is why a Switch 2 dip does not automatically feed PS5 gains.
Why the September Window Misleads Without Context
Because Circana’s period closed on October 3, the biggest autumn releases sit outside it. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 went on sale October 23, NBA 2K27 on October 16, and Xbox announced its leadership changes on October 8. Only EA SPORTS FC 27, which launched September 25, had any days inside the window. Anyone reading the 27% drop as a verdict on the holiday quarter is reading a snapshot taken before the season began.
| Date (2026) | Event | Inside Circana window? |
|---|---|---|
| Aug. 30 | Circana September period opens | Start |
| Sept. 25 | EA SPORTS FC 27 launches on Xbox (Standard Edition listed at $69.99) | Yes |
| Oct. 3 | Circana September period closes | End |
| Oct. 8 | Xbox announces XP division and new leadership appointments | No |
| Oct. 16 | NBA 2K27 launches (Standard Edition listed at $69.99) | No |
| Oct. 22 | Circana report published, Switch 2 and Sports Resort bundle on sale | No |
| Oct. 23 | Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 launches ($69.99 standard, $99.99 Vault Edition) | No |
The calendar cuts both ways. Xbox missed the benefit of the autumn releases, but PS5 also posted its gains without any of them. Sony’s lead came from a stretch before the big annual shooters and sports games arrived, which is the more impressive reading for Sony.
Marvel’s Wolverine and the Software Effect
Marvel’s Wolverine was the best-selling US game of the period. GamesIndustry.biz reported it as the highest monthly dollar performance for a Sony-published title since Helldivers 2. Exclusive tentpoles pull hardware sales forward, and the 43% jump in PS5 dollars lines up with that pattern. A buyer who wants Wolverine on day one needs a PS5, and a richer console mix helps explain why dollars outran units.
Xbox has no equivalent first-party driver in this window. A Pure Xbox headline noted that one of Xbox’s biggest successes of 2026 did not even release on Series X|S, which captures the platform’s problem in one line. Microsoft’s strongest titles increasingly ship across several platforms, so they stop acting as a reason to buy its hardware. That strategy may serve Microsoft’s software revenue well while it drains the case for the console itself.
A Hardware Market With Fewer Units and Higher Prices
Step back from the three platforms and the market tells a clear story. Units fell 3% while dollars rose 12%, which implies the average console sold for about 15% more than a year earlier. Consumers are buying fewer machines and spending more per machine. Total US video game spending, all categories included, still fell 1% in September according to Circana figures carried by Markets Insider.
Two forces can explain the pattern. First, premium models like the PS5 Pro lift the average ticket whenever they sell well. Second, bundles and price moves raise what a typical buyer pays, which would also explain why cheaper models such as the Xbox Series S versus PS5 pairing matter less to the dollar totals than to the unit counts. Sony benefited from both effects, because its dollar growth outpaced its unit growth by a wide margin. Xbox and Nintendo got the higher ticket without the volume.
The risk for everyone is demand elasticity. If households keep trading down on other spending while hardware gets pricier, the next few months could show unit declines across all three platforms. September’s 3% market dip is small, but it arrived before the holiday calendar began.
Xbox’s Leadership Reshuffle and the New XP Division
The sales report landed two weeks after Xbox reorganized. On October 8, 2026, Xbox announced a new division called XP, focused on how people experience Xbox franchises beyond the games themselves. Kayleen Walters, who had been at Mojang, was named president of XP. Maria Angelidou-Smith was named the incoming CEO of Mojang and Minecraft. Asha Sharma is listed on Xbox’s own site as CEO of Xbox and an executive vice president of Microsoft.
The XP move signals where Microsoft sees value. A division built around franchises, not boxes, fits a company that now sells games to PlayStation, Switch and PC players alike. It also fits the question of how Xbox prices its services, a topic we cover in our look at Game Pass, PS Plus and Switch Online. We are not quoting current Game Pass plan prices here, because the sources we checked did not confirm them.
Nothing in the sales data or the leadership news says Microsoft is retiring the Series X|S line. No source we reviewed reports a discontinuation, a rename or a successor on sale. The console family stays Microsoft’s current hardware, and it remains the Series X and Series S pair.
Competitive Comparison: PS5 vs Switch 2 vs Xbox Series X|S
Lining the three platforms up on what the September data shows, the ranking is straightforward but the reasons differ. PS5 won on momentum, a major exclusive and a premium model that sells. Switch 2 held second place on a lower price and a family-friendly library, but it faces the hardest year-over-year comparison. Xbox sits third with the highest average ticket and the sharpest unit decline.
- PS5: units +22%, dollars +43%, strongest dollar share since May 2025, Wolverine as the software engine.
- Switch 2: units -14%, dollars -12%, lowest average price of the three at $498, new bundles arriving in late October.
- Xbox Series X|S: units -27%, dollars -2%, highest average price at $663, strongest annual-release slate still ahead.
Readers weighing a purchase can find specs, prices and game libraries side by side in our Switch 2 vs PS5 vs Xbox Series X comparison. The reasoning behind a pick matters more than the ranking, since a console that tops the sales chart is not automatically the right one for a given household.
Historical Context: NPD, Circana and the 2020 Console Generation
The measuring stick itself has changed names. Industry veterans still say NPD, but the current name for the market-data business is Circana, and 2026 reporting uses it. The generation under discussion dates to November 2020, when Sony launched PS5 in select territories on November 12 and Microsoft launched its Series consoles the same month. Nintendo followed with Switch 2 in June 2025.
That timeline adds a useful footnote to Sony’s result. The last month in which Sony’s hardware dollar share was this high was May 2025, the month before Switch 2 arrived. September 2026 therefore shows Sony recovering ground it held before Nintendo’s new console reset the market. It does not necessarily mean Switch 2 has lost its appeal.
Nearly six years into the generation, the pattern is familiar. Late-cycle consoles live on price moves, premium refreshes and first-party hits. For a view of how this fits the wider console market, the useful comparison is not September against September but the quarter against the quarter, once the November data arrives.
Market Impact for Retailers, Publishers and Players
Retailers will read this report as a reason to weight holiday inventory toward PS5 and Switch 2, and to keep Xbox stock lean. A lower unit run at a higher price per unit argues for fewer shelf slots. Bundles will matter more than ever, since recent hardware headlines for both PS5 and Switch 2 involve a game packed with the console.
Publishers face a subtler calculation. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 lists at $69.99 for the standard edition and $99.99 for the Vault Edition on Xbox’s store, and EA SPORTS FC 27 and NBA 2K27 both list at $69.99. Annual franchises depend on large installed bases, and a shrinking Xbox base shifts more of their revenue weight toward PlayStation and PC. That helps explain why multiplatform releases are now the default.
For players, the practical effect is flexibility. If friends sit on different consoles, crossplay support across Xbox, PS5 and Switch 2 matters more than which logo is on the box. Weak Xbox hardware sales do not strand Xbox owners, because the games keep arriving on the platform. They simply make the console a smaller part of Microsoft’s business.
Buyout Chatter and Next-Gen Reports: Separating Rumor From Fact
Weak sales numbers invite speculation, and this week was no exception. Reports dated October 21 discussed outside interest in buying or spinning off Xbox, and one outlet, Pro Gamer, put a private-equity valuation of up to $150 billion on the business. Microsoft reportedly denied that Xbox is for sale. None of this is a confirmed transaction, and it predates the September sales report, so the sales data did not trigger it.
Next-generation chatter is also circulating. A report highlighted by Pure Xbox claims Xbox will release a next-generation handheld in 2027 and a more expensive Helix console in 2028. Microsoft has not confirmed those dates in anything we reviewed, so treat them as a rumor. Reader speculation about PS6 timing in the same comment threads is just that, speculation.
The rule we apply is simple. A claim from one outlet gets a hedge, a claim from none gets left out, and a number without a named source never makes it into a table.
Five Predictions for the Rest of the 2026 Holiday Season
These are our analysis, not reported facts, and they rest on the September data and the release calendar above.
- PS5 stays No. 1 through the holiday quarter. A 43% dollar gain, a strong exclusive and a premium model that sells give Sony a lead that one month of Nintendo bundles is unlikely to erase.
- Xbox unit sales improve in the October report but stay third. Modern Warfare 4 and NBA 2K27 both landed after the September window closed, so Xbox should see a software lift. A rebound to the second spot would need a much bigger swing than one release can deliver.
- Switch 2 narrows the gap in November. The Sports Resort bundle is already out, and the reported Mario Kart World bundle on October 29 targets the exact shoppers who drive holiday volume.
- Average prices keep rising. Premium models and bundles are lifting the typical ticket across all three platforms, so total hardware dollars should outpace units again.
- Microsoft leans harder on XP and multiplatform games. The October 8 reorganization points to a company that measures success by franchise reach, so expect more announcements about games, not boxes.
The next Circana release will be the first to include Modern Warfare 4, and it will give a better read on whether September was a trough or a trend. Until then, the one firm conclusion is that PS5 owns the momentum.
FAQ: Xbox Series X Sales and the September 2026 Report
Did Xbox sales really fall 27% in September 2026?
Yes. Circana data reported on October 22 showed Xbox Series X|S unit sales down 27% year over year in the US. Dollar sales fell only 2%, because the average price paid rose 33% to $663.
Which console sold best in the US in September 2026?
PS5 ranked first in both units and dollars. Switch 2 placed second and Xbox Series X|S third. PS5 units rose 22% and dollars rose 43%.
Does the September report cover the whole month?
No. Circana’s September 2026 period ran from August 30 to October 3, so it spans slightly more than the calendar month and ends before the October game releases.
Is Microsoft discontinuing the Xbox Series X|S?
No source we reviewed reports a discontinuation, rename or successor on sale. Xbox Series X and Series S remain Microsoft’s current consoles. Reports of a future handheld and a Helix console are unconfirmed rumors.
Why did PS5 dollar sales grow faster than unit sales?
The average price paid rose about 17%, which points to a richer mix of premium models and bundles. A 43% dollar gain divided by a 22% unit gain produces that figure.
Do these figures cover worldwide sales?
No. The data covers US retail only and says nothing on worldwide sales or on the finances of Sony, Microsoft or Nintendo.
Will Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 lift Xbox hardware sales?
It should help, but the effect will not show until the next Circana report, since the game launched October 23, after the September window closed. One big release is unlikely to change the ranking by itself.
