Shadowrun Chronicles - Boston Lockdown

Shadowrun Chronicles - Boston Lockdown

View Stats:
The magic of computers.
It always strikes me as bizarre that developers who port PnP games to the computer miss out on the concept of why it is done - to crunch the numbers for the players so that they can focus on the gameplay. The purpose of computers is to do the monotonous stuff so we don't have to. Instead, developers insist on rewriting a game into something unidentifiable with just enough token elements to justify the name on the box.

Shadowrun has suffered horribly from this ever since the team FPS game was released. I haven't played SR with the 5.0 rules, so correct me if I'm wrong - but how does the current skill tree system have any relationship with the PnP mechanics? I can't think of another MMORPG that felt that players were too dumb to understand character attributes and skills, yet this game is clearly concerned that such a typical concept in RPG's is too difficult for their audience to grasp.

This game suffers from a terrible lack of content, and from the DLC's it seems evident that the developers can't or won't improve the situation. There are so few skills that you can barely recognize even the basic classes from the books. The gear options are likewise limited to the point that they have to dole them out carefully over the course of the campaign. You will suffer through long stretches of play where you are stuck with one of the handful of weapons available and you're just sitting on a growing pile of money. Frankly, the whole economy and game system could suggest a development team trying to skate by with as little effort or interest as possible. The reason why the game departs so drammatically from the PnP rules feels like a concerted effort on the part of the developers to do as little as possible to make a game set in the Shadowrun universe.

I will say that the game is enjoyable to play on its own merits, but anyone who is hoping to play a Shadowrun game will find this is a just a pig with lipstick on it. Therein lies a major question for any developer - what makes them think that they can succeed with a game when they alienate the core players who would be drawn to the title? They are then relying on drawing in players who don't even know what Shadowrun is, and so won't judge it on the merits of the game it is named for. How is that a good marketing strategy? Who thought it was a good idea to dismiss the player base and hope anyone else would care?

Make a game that actually incorporates the rules of the PnP game as much as possible. Shadowrun fans don't want a PC game that reflects their favorite pasttime in name only. If you want an example of how it's done well and successfully, look to Bioware's Neverwinter Nights series.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 28 comments
did u hav a point? see i actually enjoy the game, sure its not PnP but given the resources available (u really need to read up on how this game came to be, u seem to be labouring under the misconception that this game actually had a budget) its pretty good and still being expanded upon, judge it by wot it is and not by what u think it should be
Although I do enjoy the game I have to say that you have some rather good points, and I for one am getting rather tired of "the devs almost went under" excuse for every flaw in the game. ... Yes, I understand that basic fact and am willing to look past the lack of polish and some of the missing features that I honestly expected in a Shadoowrun game; BUT a lack of budget is not responsible for PnP breaking decisions such as weapon tiers, skill trees, silly ammo counts, cyberware being a second set of clothes, or the fact that EVERYONE is a mage/sammy/decker/rigger with only a quick stop to swap weapons.
It's true, this game has next to nothing mechanics wise to do with shadowrun. There's barely even a story for most of the missions, which is what Shadowrun is all about, telling STORIES and using the gameplay mechanics as a narrative tool instead of the focus.

Sadly, however, people who are into Shadowrun are ♥♥♥♥ out of luck, because no one is making SR games. HK was the last one so Chronicles is all we have left in the entire world.
Originally posted by Hex:
It's true, this game has next to nothing mechanics wise to do with shadowrun. There's barely even a story for most of the missions, which is what Shadowrun is all about, telling STORIES and using the gameplay mechanics as a narrative tool instead of the focus.

Sadly, however, people who are into Shadowrun are ♥♥♥♥ out of luck, because no one is making SR games. HK was the last one so Chronicles is all we have left in the entire world.

+1
I will start by saying I'm a staunch proponent of PnP and have been so since the first edition in the good old 80's..

Ahem

Onto point; you guys are entitled to your opinions (and I do share them) however the devs have previously stated they read every post and respond / reply / cry <delete applicable>; in one such reply the reason SRC is the way it is, is due to a number of reasons.

A couple of these are:
Licensing issues - this means they can only use it in a fashion dictated by the IP holder.

Funds - I'm not going to broach this

Graphics engine - sure, unity3D is a free and for the most part a fairly robust engine, but the devs have to create most things from scratch; and since their team is quite small, their resources (see time) is valuable.

Overall, while I'd like SRC to somewhat mirror PnP, I acknowledge the limitations the devs face and honestly, I think they've done a pretty good job at releasing SRC as it is.

The replayable missions has been a welcome instalment which has given SRC some longevity; although one criticism, perhaps mission respawn could be a little quicker? Like 6 hour recycle time?

Back on topic about PnP; the devs have recently told us that they are figuring out a way to overhaul the system and gave us a quote on what they thought the cost and time resources it would take. I think this shows how much the devs listen to their community; the fact that they are even thinking about changing their product due to consumer demand speaks volumes of their commitment to us: the community.

**edit: added this; I struggle to think of a game developer that cares about what their community thinks about their product short of "sucks to hear you don't like the game; if you don't like it then don't play it".. end edit (on train and lost connection)**

(Apologies for being absent on the forums of late; have had some meatspace issues)
The thing is, pnp is pnp. When you're making a computer game, it seems a little pointless to spend hours to completely recreate the pnp experience. Doing so would make pnp obsolete and totally miss one of the main draws of pnp, using your imagination. How many films have you seen based on books that you love and thought, "Well, the book was better." Of course it is. It's always better in your mind. They're not going to make an entire film based on every single page of the book and every letter written, why would we need the book anymore? I think it's important to have a clear distinction between the pnp and the digital aspect of Shadowrun. With that in mind, I would like to say that I do agree this game is not what I had hoped for but it's not a disappointment. The developers have been very good on their word lately, so I'd think we should hold our tongues and wait to see what happens. The missions are a great addition and I'm sure they will add more variety and new gear in the coming months. More modes too. Keep the faith.
I just wanted to throw my hat in the ring here and talk a bit about I see things and maybe clarify stuff.

To start of I think it is not a good idea to use the "devs went bankrupt" statement to excuse everything. But on the other hand this is still a matter of fact which needs to influence the way the game is viewed and may excuse some of the rough edges and how things are moving forward. Things which could be covered by that are for example: Lack of new features, lacking speed of development and limited scope of new features.

Lack of budget is another thing often mentioned. We had a bit of a budget but a smaller one than the one which the HBS games had. From what I heard those guys had to stretch their budget to the limit to get the job done. I agree that our ambition was way bigger than what we could achieve.

Now for something seldomly heard sort of: I agree that we drifted a bit too far away from the PnP version. This is mostly a result of the ideas and vision changing over the course of development and it never really settled into something fitting.

I am still trying to find a way back to the PnP for the skill overhaul but that is another story.

In general I do not mind if a computer game takes liberties with a license as long as the end product is fun and maintains the feeling of the IP.
Just converting PnP rules into computer code was a thing of the 80s and 90s and it was quite hit and miss if it worked as a game.
It is not fun if the player is able to misskill the character within 20 minutes of starting the game. Furthermore having tons of skills of which half of them are never used in the game is no fun either. And sitting in front of the PC with pencil, calculator and a notepad is not even fun for me as a mathematically inclined person.

I hope it became clear what I wanted to say.
I... what audience were you hoping to reach? If it was Shadowrun fans then that reasoning seems incredibly flawed on a fundamental level. If players did not find it fun to have unique characters with useless skills for the fun of it thrown in the mix, what on earth makes you think they would *BE* Shadowrun players in the first place?

This notion that everything should be "casual" and "streamlined" is the dumbest thing that has happened. Even the so called "casual" players are getting bored with these new games that are specifically tailored to pander to people who are too lazy to figure things out. If someone enjoys the concept of a game, they will put in the effort to learn it, if they don't they will play with it for 10 hours and uninstall it. If a game has no depth, people get bored.

X-com is mehcanics wise very similar to SR:C and do you think people love it because it's streamlined and easy? NO, they love it because it takes EFFORT and FIGURING ♥♥♥♥ out to get good at and it's rewarding when you do so. HK was kickstarted in a matter of hours and in DF you could easily make a completely useless character that required you to be carried by your team OR you can make a character that can solo the game, it's what makes the system they use interesting.

The point is that if you want to make X-com lite then SR is the *WRONG* IP to use, because SR players expect depth and interesting character choices. If they didn't, they wouldn't be SR players. SR characters are made like this. "What kind of a person my character is" > "How can I use the system to reflect that". NOT "pick ear shape" > "pick random skills" > win.

In fact, SR is about not losing, it's not about winning because almost every runner is supposed to end up in a body bag eventually.
I never talked about streamlining or anything like that.
I just stated that there is no point in porting stuff 1:1. Yes we could have put in stuff like swimming, acrobatics and climbing. It would never have been used in the game and a player could sink their karma into it for no benefit. These are things I was talking about.

For X-Com I do not need to calculate stuff with Pen and Paper so I am able to play the game. There are games in my collection, which I started multiple times and never got into due to a steep learning curve. If I work and have a social life and other hobbies I do not want to play a game where I need to invest 20 hours to learn to play the game so I may enjoy it for 20 more. In my eyes neither "streamlining" nor "casual" games are evil and need to be avoided and even "hardcore" players might enjoy them sometimes.

I only know about a few reasons why stuff was cut.
Stealth was cut due to it slowing the game down and it not mixing well in coop. Legwork was cut due to time and budget constraints. Same for actual matrix and astral space.

How exactly the five skill per weapon type system came to be I do not know personally. The current skilltrees were a later addition and design change. Our former game design team had ideas that changed. While developing the game we had about 30 guys working on it now we have 5.

We considered perma death at one time but decided against it because it did not feel fun to play.

If I were absolutely happy with the system as is I would not invest my time into trying to put something more along the lines of what we all want into the game. But always I have to abide by the restrictions posed by the code and the software.
I don't think anyone was expecting a 1:1 conversion, but something besides combat would have been nice. I mean, we are talking about Shadowrun here, going loud should be the last option. Don't get me wrong, It's impressive what you guys did with what you had, but you have to understand that people expect more than just combat in a Shadowrun game.

But at least we have *a* Shadowrun game. My other favourite IP, Vampire: The Masquerade is dead and buried thanks to the morons at CCP.
Originally posted by Cliffhanger QA:
It is not fun if the player is able to misskill the character within 20 minutes of starting the game.
Picking the wrong background or orc/dwarf race is 1 minute in, 1 click away.
Originally posted by Cliffhanger QA:
Furthermore having tons of skills of which half of them are never used in the game is no fun either.
Hello scram, buckshot, ghostkiller and everything in summon tree besides wind.

Skill overhaul can't come soon enough :)
That's ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. Scram has it's uses as well as ghostkiller if you use Auto or Blade as a secondary weapon as a mage/summoner. Also, Wolves are OP as ♥♥♥♥ if you put every point and background into spirit control you can muster. Howl alone oneshots most enemies if it crits and the bite always heals to full while doing 40+ damage and you can have 2 out and shoot with an automatic.

Shaman wolves have always been OP, people just don't want to commit to it and only use summoning as a secondary skillset, but if you go fully into it, they are monsters. Not to mention they are super fast and can be used to eat bombers.
I agree a bit more would have been great especially the things I mentioned in my post.
While testing the game I always liked Summoning Bears. I know I am in the minority here but it was fun.

In regards to the race/background selection I am of the opinion that thanks to the "minor" influence of these choices it is not as devastating as skill options that are useless. But you do not know that they are useless.

I am quite happy to listen to feedback and make something great out of it. Or at least something better.

As for Vampire, we will always have Bloodlines. It is installed on each and every of my private PCs. :)
I've played through Bloodlines probably 20+ times over the years, Malkavian for life! I mean... having an argument with s stop sign... you just can't top that. :)
The talking TV is pretty sweet as well and obfuscate is quite OP. :)
< >
Showing 1-15 of 28 comments
Per page: 1530 50