Shadowrun Chronicles - Boston Lockdown

Shadowrun Chronicles - Boston Lockdown

View Stats:
Its time to raise the karma cap
I say double it, 4 to 6 karma a run is reasonable. There is no reason to keep it so low. I got like 10 character slots, but why would I make more than one or two heroes? The karma gain needs to be upped. I felt the karma nerf was too much near launch, but the game is old now, no reason to keep it so bad.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
? the difficulty of the campaign with too much karma is then too low -it should still be a not so easy to get through solo.

and if the difficulty is too high for you you can invite others for support in chat
and i do 3 different chars full fledged and 3 others started all with different settings and backgrounds....
I fail to see how this adds anything? If you increase mission caps, you will get more people making alts, which gives a much larger playerbase to group with. Increased Karma is a good thing, as is, there is no point in making more than one alt if that.
It's well-balanced for starting *players* to create a solid challenge through the story. If new players got a lot of karma up front, many would likely complain that the game is 'too easy'... It's happened, and I wouldn't mind seeing new players continue to trickle in.

As rentier also pointed out, there'd be less reason to look for teams if the karma gain was too high- and while solo is possible, some level of teaming should be encouraged in a co-op game. :cybereye:

That said, I agree, once you've run through it once or twice, getting a boost to speed up karma gain would be nice.

I wouldn't mind a 'veteran boost' to all a player's characters if you have at least one that has completed the entire storyline so far ("Chronicles" and "Infected!") or something to that effect. A flag gets added to any characters on that account once one of them has gone the whole way through. Or, maybe as a purchaseable add-on that flags your characters for extra Karma gain. It still wouldn't be "pay to win" since you can *always* continue to play and help others for more Karma.

But then, I think they should also have a way to charge for respec's, re-names, and some of the cosmetic outfit sets, too. They could even use the coupon system in the launcher for it.

Unfortunately, any programming may be beyond the scope of their abilites right now, though. Any resources they have a probably focused on the new project, and so any changes would probably be like the 'volunteer developer free time on the weekends' like the recent balance update was.

Still, not a bad suggestion though. We'll see what they have to say (probably after all the holidays have settled down and they've been able to get back to things).

Crunch~
what crunch said - any system that would simply add karma for end game is indeed beyond our abilities right now. Simply dropping the karma cap would not be an incentive either - if one of your chars could have EVERY skill in the game, why make more?
Originally posted by primetide_dev:
what crunch said - any system that would simply add karma for end game is indeed beyond our abilities right now. Simply dropping the karma cap would not be an incentive either - if one of your chars could have EVERY skill in the game, why make more?

Several reasons, because you make a magic runner, or cyber runner, choosing different perks and backgrounds. Tons of reasons. Right now its TEDIOUS to get karma unless you do the main quest. I have ALWAYS maintained the karma nerf was too much, it drove away sales and players when they did it. The fully cut Karma gain by 66%... too harsh. Change the values from 2 to 4 and 3 to 5... its not like the original karma system, but its enough to grab people back, and keep those playing more interested.

There is absolutely no reason not to, to be honest.
Well by now the actual amount of work involved is an issue - when we did the rebalancing patch, that would have been the point for this. However I still am not sure how this relates to the "one runner vs multiple chars". Is it because having multiple chars is too much work?
Originally posted by primetide_dev:
Well by now the actual amount of work involved is an issue - when we did the rebalancing patch, that would have been the point for this. However I still am not sure how this relates to the "one runner vs multiple chars". Is it because having multiple chars is too much work?


I argued a lot when they did such a massive nerf to karma gain, then. They didnt listen to me, and lost a lot of players. I have ten slots to make characters, and grinding out 40 missions to earn 120 karma seems absolutely excessive. (most missions give 3 karma). So the question is why have no many slots availiable when making more than one runner would be a chore?
I think a formula could be made to boost Karma gains so that higher level players who continually take the the time to help new players or low-alts are rewarded.

For example even when one has a PC with several skills maxed (11) there is fun in continuing on to give oneself a few more perks. i.e. Even after you have 11's in Body, Mind, Automatics, and Blades there is value in putting points into Blunt to get the HP gain (even if you never use a club), or Magic to get the M armour or Hacking to get T armour (and perhaps a boost in a 3rd loot skill - yippee!). All these "extra levels" still will help with the playability of that character, so you can slot them into any group in multiple roles just by changing your gear.

There are more than a few regular players in game who have a character or roster of characters with 11's in every skill. However they continue to make alts so as to do the same "maxing out" with a character of differant race and background and of course choices within each skill tree ("theory crafting" or "alt-itis" as it's known); i.e. not every "maxed out" (11 in all skills) Troll-Ganger will play the same way even when geared with the same all "Blue" gear as your other Troll-Ganger.
I am not a programmer and have no idea on the difficulty of coding and making patches however if future balance patches were to be considered in the future, I would suggest a Karma rebalance as follows:
1. Keep Karma at 2's and 3's unless/until,
2. The character is maxed in at least 4 skills,
3. If the character is 11 in 4 or more skills make karma awards 4 and 6.
Results?
-Those who wish to race to one uber character will be rewarded for using their main character to help newbs and low alts level.
-Those who like to experiment with every race / background combo imaginable only have to grind their first 4 skills choices i.e. Body, Mind, Weapon-1, Weapon-2, before being eligible for enhanced Karma rewards and being able to round out the 'toon with a few more skill areas.

For those that argue that an accellerated Karma gain would make the game too easy I have 2 points to consider:
1. By the time a "new player" has accomplished "maxing out 4 skills areas" they have already long completed the main story and Infected content i.e. they are no longer a newb and have fully completed all the base game has to offer and are now likely a daily runner attempting to max out their character and attempting to collect all the red/blue gear.

2. Consider a MMO such as Shadowbane whch had a fairly profitable 7 year run (and still lives on in emulated servers). It had 12 races, 36 creation runes (backgrounds / starter skills), 4 base classes, 24 advanced classes... And as well through each of the 75 player levels one could achieve there was personal points to add to your primary traits (the usual Strength, Dex, Con, Int, Wis traits) and skill points to put into your 15-20 class skills, Not enough choices?There was also the ability to add up to 4x "disciplines" (sub-class skills) from a roster of 20+ disciplines. Of course with all those variables there would be 100's of "viable builds" and 1,000s of garbage builds for each and every class. Because of this many players had their max 7 characters per account and also had multiple accounts so they could have 20 or more characters.
Why do I bring this up? Well because like any old school MMO when first released it would likely take you weeks or even months of play to max out a character and it was a proud achievement. Then a few years into the game they greatly inceased XP gains so one could max a character in mere days - and guess what? Regular players played even more as they could experiment with even more builds and "theory-craft" to their heart's desire. Sure a small minority of "originals" lamented the fact a new player could in a matter of weeks build a roster of several maxed characters.... But the vast majority of players old and new LOVED it as they could experiment with dozens of alts and trash unworkable characters without having had tp "waste" a 100 hours building that character. As well inviting in new friends was easy as they
could make a bunch of characters some good some crap and they didn't have to put in a 1,000+ hours to find out how all the builds work like one needs to in some MMOs.

So my point is; from my experience in other games that increased XP (Karma) gains do not hurt the player base and can often help and encourage players both veteran and new to experiment and keep playing because they can always make a nother new alt etc etc.

Long post.
Thanks for reading.
I think that the more experienced you become you should get less karma, because what are you actually learning if you already mastered it all? Karma represents learned experience. You dont learn more from doing the things you already learned.
Originally posted by Teralitha:
I think that the more experienced you become you should get less karma, because what are you actually learning if you already mastered it all? Karma represents learned experience. You dont learn more from doing the things you already learned.
The what is XP argument:
That is one way to look at it, and could be true if one only equates Karma as = XP, and only XP. It would of course make sense to say ones learns less from doing the sa,e action in the same way the 1,000th time rather than the 2nd, 3rd etc. This however does not account for doing a map (in real life a training or work scenario) with completely differant tools utilizing / exercising differant skills with differant partners who may have a myrid of differant skills and tactical pefernces.
If we are arguing for a more real life example of how experiences works with real humans; are we then to say that they are hard limits to how much one can learn on a topic? That there are only 11 levels of real world shotgun learning? From my own life I served 30 years in the army and was still learning when I retired, and not just about new equipment and technologies, but also about skills I had been using for 30 years such as shooting and physical training.
I went on operational deployments as a young soldier and used a much differant skillset in completely differant environments than I would use on other deploymnts as a leader in a completely differant environment with differant equipment and techs.
The what is Karma argument:
Karma classically of course has a much differant definition than "experience" and is often thought as closer to; the spiritual principle of cause and effect where intent and actions of an individual (cause) influence the future of that individual (effect). Good intent and good deeds contribute to good karma and future happiness, while bad intent and bad deed contribute to bad karma and future suffering.
So by this definition one gets out what they put in. In games terms this might be be equated as you contribute more and you get more. We already see this in the loot system where if I am assisting a lower friend they might their drop might be a Basic Doc Wagon and for the same drop mine might be Gold or Plat.

You raise a good question, and some people I'm sure will agree, but I, at this time tend to look at Karma in it's more philosophical definition than a straight RPG-XP function, you of course are free to convince me otherwise.
Its a game not philosophy. The word karma does not imply anything other than a number.
Its pretty obvious that no amount of persuasive argument will change their minds on Karma. I feel like its the biggest reason I always leave the game. I want to stay and play every day, but I cannot in good conscience stay for extended periods of time, to what seems to me be a giant waste of time.

I cant understand why they refuse to up the cap of Karma per mission. Just seems like such an asinine line to draw.
Then you dont understand any game and how they balance it.
Originally posted by Teralitha:
Then you dont understand any game and how they balance it.


I 100% understand the game, although you are right, I dont know why giving such small amounts of karma is considered balance.

As I previously stated, it takes 40 missions to get 120 karma. (this is after you finished the main storyline) which is absolutely absurd considering final costs are roughly 45 points.

Anyway as I stated, they will not change anything so there really isnt any reason to argue anymore.
Originally posted by Teralitha:
Its a game not philosophy. The word karma does not imply anything other than a number.
Your original thesis was espousing a certain philosophy i.e. "Karma represents learned experience. You dont learn more from doing the things you already learned." - I presented an alternative thought. We happen to disagree. yes, the Devs of SR:C might never consider changing it. But I don't think the probability of change bars the rest of us from discussing it or what we wished it might become.
I happen to think that in 1989 when Jordan Weisman used the term Karma to describe experiences in SR that it was not by accident; IMO it meant both XP and how our present deeds and intentions affect our future devlopement and/or experiences.
You may disagree but no reason to dismiss others opinions with, "Then you dont understand any game and how they balance it".
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
Per page: 1530 50