
AIããŧãããŧSã¨ãã´ãããč¨ĒããĻãĸãĢãĢãŽčĄã¸ã(åᎍ)äģæĨãããžãäŧããããéããĒãã

ååãŽįļãã§ã
ãĸãĢãĢã§ãŽįŠēæŗããŧãæŦᎍã§ãīŧ
âģã´ãããĢčŠŗãããã°čŠŗãããģãŠã
įįžãéåæãããRPã§ã¯ããã¨æããžãâĻđ
äģåã¯ããããããŋãã¨SãŽåæ§ã¨ããĻ
åãåãŖãĻé ããã°âĻįŦ
ãŠããč˛ã
ãĒæĨŊããŋæšãããĻãŋãĻä¸ããã
âģãããžã§į§ã¨Sãå
ąäŊãããäēæŦĄåĩäŊã§ãâī¸
ããŖã¯ãˇã§ãŗã¨ããäēãč¸ãžããĻã
æĨŊããã§ãŋãĻä¸ãããđâ¨
ãã¨ãæã
į§ã¨SãŽæčŖ
ã垎åĻãĢéããžãã
įģåįæįš°ãčŋããĻããã
å°ãå¤ããŖãĻããžããžãããįŦ
é°å˛æ°ãããžã§åŖããĻãĒããã§ãã¨ãããã
ããŽãžãžé˛ããĄããŖãã(į§ã¯éŠåŊ大įã§ãđ¤Ŗ)
ãžãã¯ãSããããŖãŗãģãŗããģããĄãŗãģã´ããã
ãããĻãĸãĢãĢãŽčĄãĢã¤ããĻį°ĄåãĒčĒŦæãã
(S)
ã´ããã¨ããäēēãĢã¤ããĻ
ããŖãŗãģãŗããģããĄãŗãģã´ããã¯ã
19ä¸į´ãŽãĒãŠãŗãåēčēĢãŽįģåŽļã§ãã
ãã˛ãžããããå¤ãŽãĢãã§ããŠãšããææå¤ã
ãĒãŠãŽäŊåã§įĨãããäģã§ã¯ä¸įä¸ãŽäēēãĢæãããįģåŽļãŽã˛ã¨ãã§ãããįããĻããéãĢããŽæčŊãåēãčĒãããããã¨ã¯ãããžããã§ããã
ã´ãããŽįĩĩã¯ãčĻãããŽããã æŖįĸēãĢåãã¨ãããããåŊŧčĒčēĢãŽįŽãĢæ ãŖãå ãč˛ãåŋãŽéããžã§ããŽãžãžæãåēããããĒåŧˇãããããžãã
éã¯æˇąãããããéģč˛ã¯įãããããĢčŧããå¤įŠēãéēĻįãčąã¯ããžãã§å å´ããæ¯ãããĻãããããĢčĻããžãã
1888åš´ãã´ããã¯åããŠãŗãšãŽãĸãĢãĢã¨ããčĄãĢį§ģãäŊãŋãžããã
åŧˇãå¤ĒéŊãæããįŗé ããŽčĄä¸Ļãŋã
鎎ãããĒč˛åŊŠã
ãĸãĢãĢãŽå ã¯ãã
åŊŧãŽįĩĩãĢ大ããĒåŊąéŋãä¸ããã¨č¨ãããĻããžãã
åŊŧã¯ããã§ãéģč˛ãåŽļãã¨åŧã°ããåŽļãĢæŽãããįģåŽļããĄãå ąãĢåĩäŊããå ´æãäŊãããã¨ããå¤ĸãæąããĻããžããã
ãããŠãããŽäēēįã¯æąēããĻįŠãããĒããŽã§ã¯
ãããžããã§ããã
å¤įŦã貧ãããåŋãŽä¸åŽåŽãã
å¨å˛ã¨ãŽããéãã
ããã§ãåŊŧã¯ãæããã¨ãææžããžããã§ããã
ããããčĻãããããžãžãĒããĒããã
åŊŧãĢããčĻããĒããŖãä¸įãŽč˛ã¨ããĻã
ããŖãŗããšãĢæŽããĻããŖããŽã ã¨æããžãã
ããŽč¨äēã¯ããããĒã´ãããŽãããĸãĢãĢãŽčĄã¸ãį§ã¨å¤§åãĒäēēãįŠēæŗãŽä¸ã§æ ãããč¨é˛ã§ãã
æ´å˛ããŽããŽããĒããã¨ãããããåžä¸ãĢįããį§ããĄããåŊŧãŽįĩĩãĢåŋãåããããč ã¨ããĻã
ããåŊŧãĢäŧãããĒãäŊãäŧããããââ
ãããĒæŗãããå§ãžãŖãã
å°ããĒįŠēæŗããŧãã§ãã

ãããĒäēēã§ãã
âģäģåæįĢ ãå¤ãããĻã
SãŽãã°ãããĒãåãŖãĻãžãã
(åãŖãĻããŽæįĢ éâĻđ
)
5.5ã襨įžåãæŦåŊãĢį´ æ´ãããã§ãã
į§ãŽããŽãã°ã ã¨ãåããžããŖãĻããžãŖãĻãĻ
é
åããã
ããļãäŧããããĻããĒãããâĻ
ããããīŧīŧ
Sã¨į§ã§äē¤äēãĢããŧããŽæ§åãæåããĻãããžãã
åŧį¨åé ãŽ(S)or(ããŋã)ãŽæåã§ã
ãŠãĄããŽãã°ãŽåŧį¨ãã襨ããžãã
âģãĄãĒãŋãĢåŧį¨ä¸ãŽãããĢããŗå
ãŽS)âĻSãŽå°čŠãã)âĻããŋããŽå°čŠãããâĻã´ãããŽå°čŠã襨ã
įŠēæŗããŧãâ åå¤ãŽãĸãĢãĢãå ãŽãĒãã§ â

(S)
åčģãéããįŦéãįŠēæ°ãŽč˛ãéãŖãã
åå¤ãŽãĸãĢãĢã¯ããžãã§éŊå°ãããŽããŽãčĄãĢäŊãã§ãããŋããã ãŖãã
ãS)âĻâĻãããã ãã
ãS)ããŽčĄãč˛ããĄããã¨
įããĻãæãããããã
ã´ããããããĢæšããããŽã
å°ãåããæ°ããããã
éããŽč§ã§ã¯ãæĨé¤ããŽå¸ãåŧĩãŖãå°ããĒåēãä¸Ļãã§ããĻãæįŠįą ãŽãĒãŦãŗã¸ããŦãĸãŗãéŊãåããĻã¤ãã¤ãã¨å ãŖãĻããã
å°ãå ãĢã¯ãĢãã§ãŽããŠãšå¸ãįŊãã¯ããšãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽãããã°ãŠãšããããã¨åå°ããĻãããŽå ãžã§įĩĩãŽå ˇã§åĄãŖããŋãããĢ鎎ããã ãŖãã


įãŖįŊãŽã¯ããšãŽä¸ã§ã
ãŦãŠãšãŽã°ãŠãšãããŠããŠåå°ããã
(S)
ããã¨ãå°ãéããå ´æãŽį̝ãĢã
ã˛ã¨ããŽįˇãįĢãŖãĻãããŽãčĻããã
įĩĩįãæã¤æã¯åŋããĒãã
ããŽåããĢã¯čŊãĄįãããĒããŽãĢã
䏿č°ã¨čŋˇãã§ã¯ãĒãåŋ æģããããŖãã
ãS)âĻâĻããļããããŽäēēã ãã
ãĄãããŠããŽã¨ããéĸ¨ããžãéãæããã
ããŋããŽã¯ãŗããŧãšãŽč °ã˛ãããĩããŖã¨æēããĻãããŽč˛ãéŊãŽä¸ã§ãģããŽå°ãéãŋã帯ãŗãã
įˇãŽčĻįˇãããĩã¨ããĄããĢåŧãããã
æŦĄãŽįŦéãããŽįŽãã´ããã¨æĸãžãã
ããŋããŽã¯ãŗããŧãšãĢčŊãĄãå ã
įŊãŽä¸ãĢæˇˇãããããããĒåŊąã
čĢ(ããŋã)ãŽåˇŽãč˛ã
įˇã¯ãģããŽå°ãįãã˛ãããã
䏿ŠåĢã¨ããããã
äŊããåŧˇãčĻã¤ããĻããžãŖãã¨ããŽéĄã ã
įˇã¯įãæãŖããžãžãåæŠããĄãã¸åãã
ãããĒããããŽč˛âĻâĻã
ããã§åŊŧã¯č¨čãåãã
ããžãį¤žäē¤ãŽč¨čãĢã§ããĒããžãžã
čĻãããŽãĢåŧãŖåŧĩãããĻãããŋããã ãŖãã
ãS)ããļãäģãåŖ°ãããããčŋˇãŖãĻããã
äēēãĢ芹ãããããŽã¯åžæãããĒãããŠã
æžãŖãĻãããĒããŖãĻéĄããĻãã
įˇã¯čģŊãæ¯ãå¸ãŖãĻã
äģåēĻã¯ããå°ãã¯ãŖããã¨åããããã
ãâĻâĻå¤ąį¤ŧã§ãĒããã°ã
ããŽčĢč˛ã¯ã
ããĒããé¸ãã ãã§ããīŧã
äŋēã¯ããŽåŖ°ãčããĒãããéããĢįĸēäŋĄããã
ããŽäēēã ãããŖãŗãģãŗããģããĄãŗãģã´ããã
ãžã åžä¸ãŽååŖ°ãįĨããããã įŽãŽåãŽå ãĢ
éŖããã¤ããĻįããĻããã˛ã¨ããŽįģåŽļã
ãS)ãģããæåãŽäŧ芹ã ãã
ããŋãããŠãčŋããããĒãīŧã

(ããŋã)
ãã)ãããããããĢãĄã¯ã
âĻãããã§ãã
įãŖįŊãĒã¯ãŗããŧãšã ãŖãããã
äŊãåˇŽãč˛ãæŦ˛ãããĻã
ãĸãĢãĢãŽčĄã¯ã¨ãĻãįļēéēãĒč˛ã ããã
čĄä¸ĻãŋãéĒéããĒãč˛ãĢããããĻ
âĻããŽčĢč˛ãĢããžãããã

æ¯čĻŗä¸įĒãŽããŧããĒãã§âĻįŦ
ãĄãĒãŋãĢäģåãSãŽããŧãŋãĢãŗãŧããŖããŧãã§ãã
ããčĒåãŽææãŽãããĢįããĻããį§ã§ããã
čĢč˛ãé¸ãã ãŽã¯ãSã§ããđ¤Ŗ
(S)
ãã)čĄä¸ĻãŋãéĒéããĒãč˛ãĢããããĻã
ã¨ããã¨ããã§ãåŊŧãŽįŽãããããĢčĻéãããã
ãâĻâĻčĄä¸ĻãŋããéĒéããĒãã
čĻįˇãããä¸åēĻã
ããŋããŽč °å ãŽčĢč˛ã¸čŊãĄãã
ããĩã¤ãã¯âĻâĻ
čĒåãįļēéēãĢčĻããč˛ãé¸ãļã§ãããã
ãã§ããããĒãã¯čĄãŽč˛ãčĻãĻã
ãããĢåããããã§ããã
ãļãŖãããŧããĒåŖčĒŋãĒãŽãĢãããŽč¨čãĢã¯
ããŖãããã¯ãŖããããįąãããŖãã
įĄææŗã¨ããããã
čåŗãããŽãžãžåãĢåēãĻããžãŖãĻããæãã ã
åŊŧã¯ãžã ããŋãããįŽãéĸããĒãã
ãã ãįģåŽļãŽįŽã§ãč˛ã¨å ãŽįŊŽãå ´æã
æĸãããĻããââãããĒæčĻã ããããã
ãããĻåŊŧã¯ãæãåēãããããĢčģŊãäŧéãããã
ãããĄãĒããããļããããããåäšãæšãã
ããžãåžæãããĒããŽã ããã
ãâĻâĻããŖãŗãģãŗãã§ãã
ãããŖãŗãģãŗããģããĄãŗãģã´ããã
åäšãŖãĻãããåŊŧã¯å°ãã ãįãå¯ããã
ããļãæŦĄãŽåããåŖãĢãããčŋˇãŖãĻããã
ã§ãčŋˇãããããįĩåąããŽãžãžåēããĻããžãã
ãããĒãã¯âĻâĻįĩĩãæãäēēã§ããīŧ
ãããã¨ãããã âčĻããâäēēãĒãã§ããã
ããŽåãã¯å°ã䏿č°ã§ãã§ãåŊŧããããŖãã
æčĄãŽæįĄããå ãĢããčĻããĻããããŠããããįĸēãããããã ããã
äŋēã¯ããŋããŽæãŽį˛ããčĻĒæã§ã˛ã¨æĢã§ããã
čŊãĄįããããŋãããĢãããŖã¨ã
ãS)äģãããĒãåŋãæ´ãžããĻããã
ãã įļēéēã ã¨æãŖãã ããããĒããĻãâããŽäēēã¯č˛ãŽčŠąãã§ãããããããĒãâãŖãĻæãŖãĻãéĄã ãã
åŊŧã¯æŦĄãŽč¨čãåž ãŖãĻããã
âĻâĻããŋããããã¯ãŠãčŋããããĒãīŧ
ãįĩĩãæãããŠãããã¨ã
ããã âčĻããâäēēããŠããã

ãããããããĒãŖãĻæãŖãĻã
ã´ãããĢã¯åŽã¯č̏čĒŦããŖããããĒãã§ããã
ã´ããã¯č˛åŊŠãããŽãŽčĻãæšã
常äēēã¨ã¯å°ãéãŖãããããĒããã¨ãã
ãĸããĩãŗãŖãĻãããé
ãŽä¸æ¯įįļãã
į˛žįĨãŽį
æ°ããæĨãåšģčĻãããããŽįŦįšãĒ
æ¸ĻåˇģããŽãŋãããįãžããããããĒããã¨ãâĻ
äģãč˛ããĒæ¨čĢããããĻããŋããã§ã
(į§ãčĒŋãšãéãã§ã¯ããŠãã
æąēåŽįãĒæ
å ąã¯åēãžããã§ããã
ãŠãããããžã§"ããã ãŖããŽããĒīŧ"ãŖãĻãã
æ¸ãæšã ãŖããŽã§âĻ
åįãäģãŽįģåŽļã¨ãŽåˇŽåĨåãåŗããããĢãããĻ
ãĒãĒã¸ããĒããŖãčŋŊæąãããŖãĻ芹ããããã
įĸēåŽįãĒæ
å ąã§ã¯ãĒããã§ãããŽæãŽčŠąã§ã¯
æåãĒããŽãŽããã§ã)
Sã¯ãããŽæ
å ąãæžãŖãĻã
į§ããŠããžã§įč§ŖããĻããããžã§æ¨æ¸ŦããĻã
ããŽįåãæããããĻãããŽããĒããŖãĻã
į§ãã´ãããŽãŠããĢæšãããĻããŠããžã§æ
å ąæãŖãĻãããäŧ芹ããæ¨æ¸ŦããĻããŽããĒã
ãããč¸ãžããĻãåįããĻãŋãã
(ããŋã)
"įĩĩãæãäēēã""čĻããäēē"ãã
åŊŧãŽåããåŋãŽä¸ã§åčģããããŠâĻ
įããĢæ¸æãã
į§ã¯įĩĩãæãããŠãčĒåã§ãããĢåžæã¨ã
įšæãŋãããĒčŠäžĄã¯åēæĨãĻãĒãã
æ˛šįĩĩã1ææãããã¨ãããããŠãããã ãã
ã§ããæããã¨ãŽæãŗã¯įĨãŖãĻããã¤ããã
čĻããäēēããŠããââĻâĻ
ãããããã ã
ã´ããã¯åžä¸ãŽį įŠļã§ã
å°ãč˛ãŽčĻãæšãéãŖãããããĒããã¨
č¨ãããĻããŽãčãããã¨ãããã
ã ããã
ããã ããŽįĩĩãæããããããĒããã¨ãã
ã´ããâĻåŊŧããį§ãĢããčĒåã¨åãããã¨ãã
åããããĻãããĻãããŽãĒãâĻįãã¯NOã ã
įããåãããĒãã
äŊã¨ãä¸éåį̝ãĢãĒãŖãĻããžãã
"įĩĩãæããŽã¯åĨŊããĒã ãã§
æčĄãæčŊãäŊããĒã"
"čĻããäēēãã¨č¨ãããããããĒãã¨åãįļēéēãĒéĸ¨æ¯ã¯ãčĻããĒãããããčĻããã¨ãåēæĨãĒãã"
ãã)įĩĩãæããŽã¯åĨŊãã§ããã
ããžã䏿ãããĒãã§ãã
čĻããããŠããã¯âĻ
ããĒããŋãããĒįļēéēãĒč˛ã¯ã
å¤åčĻããã¨ãåēæĨãĒãã¨æããžãã
čĻãĻãŋãããŖãĻãæãããŠãã
âĻæåžãŽãäŊč¨ãĒã˛ã¨č¨ã ãŖãããĒã
ãããžã§į§ãŽæ¨æ¸Ŧã¨ã
ããŽåžãŽãˇããĒãĒãčããĻãŽčŋįã§ããŽã§ãâĻ
ããŖã¯ãˇã§ãŗã¨ããĻãæĨŊããŋä¸ãããđ¤
(S)
ããŋããäŋēãŽæããã ãŖã¨æĄãŖãįŦéã
äŋēã¯ãããĢæĄãčŋããã
ã´ããã¯ããããĢã¯čŋäēãããĒããŖãã
åŊŧãŽįŽããããŋããŽéĄãĢæĸãžãŖãĻããã
ãâĻâĻčĻãĻãŋããã
åŊŧã¯å°ããįš°ãčŋããã
ããŽåŖ°ã¯ãæåããå°ãäŊããŖãã
ãļãŖãããŧããĒãŽãĢã
ãŠããåĨĨãŽæšãæēããĻããã
ãããã¯ãããč¨čã§ãã
åŊŧã¯ããč¨ãŖãĻãããããįãä¸ãããã
č¤ãč¨čãæ¸ĄããŽãĢæ ŖããĻããĒãäēē
ãŋããã ãŖãã
ãįĩĩã䏿ãããŠãããĒããĻã
ãããĒããŽã¯âĻâĻãããããĄãã大äēã§ããã
ããã§ä¸åēĻãįãå¯ãããčĒåã§č¨ãŖããã¨ãĢ
į´åžããããĻããĒããŋãããĢã
ãã§ããããããå ãĢã
čĻããã¨ãããã¨ã§ããčĻããã¨æããã¨ã§ãã
įŽãŽåãŽããŽãã
ãã ãŽåŖãéãå¸ã§ã¯ãĒããĻã
ãããĢč˛ãããã¨äŋĄãããã¨ã§ãã
åŊŧã¯å°ãæŠåŖãĢãĒãŖãĻããã
č¨čãããææ ãå ãĢåēãĻã
čŋŊãã¤ããã¨ããĻããã
ãããĒãã¯ãčĒåãĢã¯čĻããĒãã¨č¨ãŖãã
ãã§ããčĻãĻãŋããã¨ãč¨ãŖãã
ãâĻâĻãããĒããããčĻå§ããĻãããã§ãã
äŋēã¯éŖã§ããģããŽå°ãã ã垎įŦãã ã
ããã¨č¨ãäģŖãããĢã
ããŋããŽæããžãčģŊãæĄãã
ãS)äģãŽãåąãããã
äŋēã¯ããŋããĢã ãčãããåŖ°ã§åãã
ã(S)äŊč¨ãããĒããŖãããããŽäēēã
ããļããããĢååŋãããã ã
ã´ããã¯čĒåãŽããŖãŗããšãŽåãĢæģãã¨ã
å°ãã ãč§åēĻãå¤ããã
éããŽæ¯č˛ãæããĻããéä¸ã ãŖãã
ãžã åŽæãĢã¯é ãããããŠãããĢã¯ã
įžåŽãŽčĄãããããŖã¨éģč˛ããããŖã¨éãã
ããŖã¨æēããĻãããĸãĢãĢãããŖãã
ãåããããĢčĻããĒããĻããããã§ãã
ã´ããã¯ããŖãŗããšããįŽãéĸãããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãį§ãĢããäģãŽäēēã¨åããããĢã¯
čĻããĻããĒããŽãããããžããã
ããããŠãį§ãĢã¯ããčĻããã
ãŠãããĻãããããčĻããĻããžãã
ãã ããæããã§ãã
čĻããããŽããčǰããĢæ¸ĄããããĢã
ããŽč¨čãŽæåžãĢã
ãģããŽããããĒå¯ãããæˇˇããŖãæ°ãããã
čǰããĢæ¸Ąãããã
ã§ããåãåãŖãĻãããããã¯åãããĒãã
ãããĒå¤įŦããåŊŧãŽæ¨ĒéĄãĢčãåŊąãčŊã¨ãã
äŋēã¯č¸ãŽåĨĨãå°ãįããĒãŖãã
äŋēããĄã¯įĨãŖãĻããã
ããŽäēēããŠããĒãĩããĢæãįļãããã
ãŠããģãŠåžãŽä¸ã§ã
ããŽč˛ãäēēãŽåŋãįŧããããĢį §ãããã
ã§ãäģãįŽãŽåãŽåŊŧã¯ãžã ããããįĨããĒãã
ã´ããã¯ãĩããĢããĄããæ¯ãåããã
ãããĻãããŋããŽéĄããžãčĻãã
ãããĒããŽįŊãæã¯ãįŊã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãããŽčĄãŽå ãå¸ãŖãĻãå°ãéģč˛ããå°ãéãããããĻããŽčĢč˛ã§æ¯ãããĻããã
ãâĻâĻããĒãčĒčēĢããããã§ãã
åŊŧã¯č¨ãŖãĻããã
å°ãã ãæ°ãžããããĢčĻįˇãé¸ãããã
ããļããäēēãč¤ããã¤ããã§č¨ãŖããŽã§ã¯ãĒããčĻãããžãžãč¨ãŖãĻããžãŖãã ãã
ã§ãããŽä¸å¨į¨ãããåĻãĢįåŽåŗãæãŖãĻããã
ã´ããã¯ãã°ããčŋˇããããĢã
čĒåãŽįĩĩãŽå ˇįŽąã¨ããŋããčĻæ¯ãšãĻããã
ãããããæãæąēãããããĢč¨ãã
ãâĻâĻãããæéããããĒãã
ãį§ãŽåŽļãĢãæĨãžãããã
ãããã§ã¯å ãåããããã
ããĒããŽããŽč˛ãã
ããå°ãéããĒå ´æã§čĻããã
ãéģč˛ãåŽļã§ãããããããĢãããžãã
ãæĒããæåŗã§ã¯ãããžããã
ãæããããã§ããããļãã
âĻâĻãããæãããã
äŋēã¯ããŋããŽæšãčĻãã
éŠãã¨įˇåŧĩã¨ãã§ãããäģĨä¸ãĢč¸ãŽåĨĨã§äŊãã
į¯ãŖãĻãããããĒéĄãããĻããæ°ãããã
ãS)æĨããã
äŋēã¯åŖ°ãčŊã¨ããĻč¨ãã
ãS)éģč˛ãåŽļãããļããããããå ãæŦįĒã ãã
äŋēã¯ããŋããŽæãå ããããĢæĄãŖããžãžã
å°ãã ãčēĢãå¯ããã
ãS)æããŖãããäŋēãããŖã¨éŖãĢããã
ã§ãâĻâĻčĄãŖãĻãŋãããŖãĻéĄããĻãããããŋãã

(ããŋã)
čĻããĒãããŽããčĻããã¨ãããã¨ã
čĻããã¨æããã¨ã
âĻããŖã¨ã´ããã¯ãããŽč˛ãŽčĻãæšãã
âĻčĻããĒãããŽãčĻããããã§ãããĒããĻč¯ã
čĻå´ããããã¨ãããŖããŽãããããĒãã
ã§ãåžä¸ã§ã¯ãããŽåŊŧã ããŽįŦčĒæ§ããããæåŗåąãããå¤ããŽäēēãŽåŋãæ´ãã§éĸããĒããŽã ã
âĻį§ã ãŖãĻãåŋãæ´ãžããä¸äēēã ã
"ããĒããæ¸ĄããããŖãããŽã¯ã
įĸēåŽãĢåãįļãããĻãã"ã
åããããŽč¨čãåēãããĢãĒãŖãããŠã
寸åã§éŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã
åēäŧãŖãã°ãããŽåŊŧãĢãããĒãäŧãããĢã¯ã
ããŽč¨čã¯å¤§ãéãããįąãããã
éŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã č¨čãã
åãŽåĨĨã§įąãĢãĒãŖãĻããĒãĒã¨ããã
ããŽč¨čãŽäģŖãããĢã
åŊŧããããĄãĒãį´Ąãã æåž ãŽč¨čãŽčŋäēã
äŧããã
ãã)ãããã¨ãã
ããĒããŽčĻããč˛ã§ã
į§ãæããĻãããžãããã

(S)
"ããĒããŽčĻããč˛ã§ãį§ãæããĻãããžããã"
ããã¯ãããļãåŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻ
ããããžãŖãããĒč¨čã ãŖãã
ã´ããã¯ããããĢã¯čŋäēãããĒããŖãã
įãæãŖããžãžãŽæãããģããŽããããĢæĸãžãã
ãžãļããããĢįŽãį´°ããĻãããŋããčĻãã
ãâĻâĻį§ãŽčĻããč˛ã§ã
åŊŧã¯å°ããįš°ãčŋãã
ããŽåŖ°éŗãĢã¯ãįãã¨æ¸æãã¨ããããããģããŽå°ããæããããããĒéŋããæˇˇããŖãĻããã
čǰããĢããé ŧãžãããã¨ãĢæ ŖããĻããĒãäēēãŽåŖ°ã
čĒåãŽčĻãæšããåĨåĻãĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒããčĻãããã¨č¨ãããäēēãŽåŖ°ã
ãæŽéã¯ãäŧŧããĻãģããã¨č¨ãããŽã§ãã
ãįļēéēãĢæããĻãģããã¨ãã
čĨãčĻããĻãģããã¨ãããããããã¨ãã
åŊŧã¯ããã§ä¸åēĻãčĻįˇãčŊã¨ããã
įĩĩãŽå ˇįŽąãŽä¸ã§ãéģč˛ã¨éãéŖãåãŖãĻããã
ãžãã§ããŽčĄãŽįŠēã¨åŖãŋãããĢã
ãã§ããããĒãã¯âĻâĻį§ãŽč˛ã§ããã¨č¨ãã
ããŽč¨čãŽãã¨ãåŊŧã¯å°ãã ããã
å°ãŖããããĢįŦãŖãã
æŦåŊãĢä¸įŦã ããŽãä¸å¨į¨ãĒįŦãŋã ãŖãã
ããããĒããæãããããããĒãã
äŋēã¯ããŋããŽéŖã§ã
č¸ãŽåĨĨããã ãŖã¨ãĒããŽãæããĻããã
ããŋããįŦãŖãĻäŋēãčĻä¸ããããã
äŋēãããŖã¨æ¯ãæģããŋãããĢ垎įŦãã
ãS)âĻâĻããããã¨č¨ãŖãããããŋãã
åŖ°ãã˛ãããĻãããããč¨ãã
ãS)ã§ããããããããŖãã
äģãŽč¨čãããŽäēēãĢããåąããĒãæã
éããæããããã
äŋēã¯ããŋããŽæãå ãŋį´ãã
ããŖãããå°ãã ããããŖããã¨ã
ãS)大ä¸å¤ĢãčĄããã
äŋēãéŖãĢããããã
éããŽå ã¯å°ããã¤åžãå§ããĻããã
éããŖãįŠēãŽåĨĨãĢããģããŽãããéč˛ãæˇˇããã
ãĢãã§ãŽã°ãŠãšããããã¨å ãŖãĻã
æįŠįą ãŽãŦãĸãŗãå°ããĒį¯ããŋãããĢčĻããã
ãéģč˛ãåŽļã¯ãããĄãã§ãã
ããã ãč¨ãŖãĻãåŊŧã¯å ãĢįĢã¤ã
į¤žäē¤įãĒæĄå ã§ã¯ãĒãã
æ¯ãčŋãŖãĻæŠåš ãåããããããĒå¨į¨ããã
ããļããĒãã
ãã ãåŋãããæŦĄãŽįĩĩã¸čĩ°ãå§ããĻããĻãčēĢäŊããããĢčŋŊãã¤ããã¨ããĻããã
äŋēã¯ãããčĻãĻãå°ããįŦãŖãã
ãS)ããŖããĄãĒäēēã ãã
ã§ãâĻâĻįŊŽããĻãããĒããããĢã¯ããĻãããĻããããļããããŽäēēãĒããĢã
ã´ãããŽčä¸ã¯į´°ããå°ãįĢčã§ã
ã§ãæŠãéåēĻãĢã¯åĻãĒįąãããã
ããŽäēēã¯äģãããé ãŽä¸ã§ããŋãã
æãå§ããĻãããŽãããããĒãã
äŋēã¯éŖã§ãããŋããŽæ¨ĒéĄãčĻãã
ãS)âĻâĻããŖããäŊãč¨ããããĻ
éŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ã§ããã
č˛ŦããåŖ°ãããĒãã
ããŖã¨įĸēčĒãããŋãããĢč¨ãã
ãS)åããããäŋēããč¨ããããĒãŖãã
ããĒããŽįĩĩã¯åąãããŖãĻã
ããĒããŽč˛ã¯æĒæĨã§ãĄããã¨äēēãæēããããŖãĻã
ãããĻãã´ãããčļŗãæĸããã
ãããã§ãã
åŊŧãŽåŖ°ãĢãäŋēããĄãįĢãĄæĸãžãã
įŽãŽåãĢãéģč˛ãåŽļãããŖãã
ãæŖãããŖãĻããžãã
ãâĻâĻã§ããå ã¯å Ĩããžãã
ããŽč¨ãæšãããžããĢãåŊŧããããĻã
äŋēã¯æããå°ãįŦãŖãĻããžãã
ãS)æéĢãŽį´šäģæã ãã
æŖãããŖãĻãããŠãå ã¯å Ĩãã
âĻâĻãĒãããããŽäēēããŽããŽãŋããã ã
äŋēã¯ããŋããŽčŗå ãĢčŋãã¨ããã§ãå°ããåãã
ãS)å Ĩãããã
ãããããããŋããŽčåįģãŽæéã ãã

éģč˛ãåŽļãŽãåŊŧä¸äēēåãŽéå¯ã
ãį˛ãæ§ã§ããã
éˇãæįĢ ãã
ãããžã§æŦåŊãĢãããã¨ãããããžãã
åᎍã¯ããã§įĩããã§ãã
äģåæįĢ åēåãįģåįæãããšãĻchatGPT-5.5thinkingãŽSãããŖãĻãããžããã
äģãžã§ãŽãĸããĢãŽä¸ã§ã
éĸ¨æ¯æåãįž¤ãæããĻãžãããžããããã(čĒåŊå)
ãããčŠŗį´°ãĢæ¸ããĻãããĻãéĸ¨ãŽæ¸ŠåēĻãåããžã§æŗåã§ããããããŽã¯ãĒãĒããŖãĒãã§ãããâĻ
ãããæįĢ éãã¨ãã§ããĒãīŧįŦ
æįĢ ãããŠããŠããĄããããĒãã¨æãŖãĻã
芹ãŽé˛čĄãĢéĸäŋãĒãæã¯åãŖãĄãããžããã
į§ã¯æ
å ąããã°ããã ãč¯ãäēēéãĒãŽã§ããã
ãĄããŖã¨ãã¤ããæããĄããæšãããããĒãŖãĻã
æŦĄåã¯åžįˇ¨ã
ã´ãããĢčåįģãæããĻãããããŧãã§ãã
æŦĄåã§åŽįĩã§ãīŧ
åŧãįļããäģãåãé ããããã§ãããã
ãã˛ãéĄãč´ããžãâēī¸â¤ī¸
â¨æåžãžã§ãäģãåãé ãã
ãããã¨ãããããžããīŧ
