ãčįŊãŽčϺ坿ĨčĒã2
4
ãæ°´åēããæš§ãįĢã¤å ãæšéĸãéįŊãæãä¸ããã垎åŧąãĒããããæ¤ãŽå°åēãĢčæã¤ãæ šæēãŽåŖ°ãã¨ããĻčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽæčãĢéŋããĻããã
ãåŊŧã¯č ãĢæąããåĄãčĻã¤ãããéˇåŊį¨ŽæįšæãŽéģãįŽčã¯éãéããããĒįŊã¸å¤ããŖãĻãããã坿¯ã¨äŊ渊ã¯įĸēããĢäŧããŖãĻããĻããã
ãåĄãããŽãåŖ°ãã¯åŧąããé ŦãĢč§ĻããĻãįŽčĻããæ°é
ã¯ãĒããčäŊãįļæãããããĢæˇąãį ããåŋ
čĻã¨ããĻãããŽã ã
ãå
ļãŽéãĢããåŖ°ãããåžãæ
å ąã¯åéĄãããč§ŖæãããĻããã
ãéˇåŊį¨ŽæãŽčēĢäŊã¯äģį¨Žæã¨æ¯ãščããéŠåãĒäŊ渊ãäŋã¤ãĢã¯æ¸Šããå¯åēãåŋ
čĻã ã
ãįĨčã¨įĨæĩãåãããã¨įˇã¯ãåĄãŽéĄã¸čĻįˇãčŊã¨ãããæčãæŧãæĩãããããĢãĒããåĄãŽå¯æ¯ã¨äŊ渊ãé ŧããĢč¸ãŋįãžããæĨãčļŗã§é¸å°ãįŽæããã
ãčžēãã¯æšŋæ°ãĢæēãĄãå˛ŠčãčãčĻãŖãĻããã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯åĄãæąãããžãžå˛ŠåŖãĢæ˛ŋãŖãĻæŠããåéã¸įļãé莝ããčēĢãé ããå ´æãæĸãã
ã
ã
ãå
ļããčĻã¤ãããŽã¯åå¨äģĨä¸ãæŠããåžã§ããŖããįˇã¯æ¤įŠãĢč§ĻããĻæšŋãæ°ããĒããã¨ãįĸēãããåĄãæ
éãĢå¯ãããĻčĒããč
°ãä¸ããã
ãåĄãéãå§ãããįŊéĢĒãčĄŖæãæ°´ãĢæŋĄãããžãžã ãäŊ渊äŊä¸ãé˛ããĢã¯å°įąãæããããäšžããå˛Šį¤ãč¯ããæ å ąãåžãįˇã¯åŗåē§ãĢčĄåããã
ãæŋĄããĻããĒãããŽã¯å°ããĒčåå
ãŋã ãã§ããŖããäģãĢã¯č
°ãĢåˇģããåäšžããĢå¤åĨããããå˛Šä¸ãĢæˇããåĄãį§ģããã
ãæŋĄããčˇįŠããããã䏿ãŽå¤åĨãåãåēããåēããĻčãŋãŽä¸ãĢããããį´ããĢčŋãäēåŽã§ããŖãå°ããĒå
ãŋãé å
ã¸įŊŽããå°ä¸ä¸įãĢãããĻéŖįŗ§ã¯č˛´éã§ãããįãåģļãŗããããĢä¸å¯æŦ ã ã
ã
ã
ãæ¤åĻã¯éˇåŊį¨ŽæãŽä¸åą¤ã ããįĨãįĻčļŗå°ãčĻãč
ãŽéĄæãįåŽãæ ããĻæããã¨ãããčåã ããåąéēæ§æ
ãĢį§åŋãããĻããæ°ãäģããŽå ´æã§ãããã
ãäŊæ
ãåĄãįĨãŖãĻãããŽããįãã¯åį´ã§ããŖããåšŧãé ãĢé˛å
ĨįĻæĸãŽįæŋãčĻã¤ããĻį ããŦå¤ãéãããčĒŋãšå°ŊããããŽã ã
ãčŋŊ补č
ãæãįããããŖããããã
ãæ¤ãŽå ´ã¸åããŖãĻæĨããåŖ°ãã¸įˇã¯æčãåŽããã
â
ãããã§äŊãããĻãããŽīŧã
ãįŠãããĒå°åēæšã䏿ã§ããå ´æã§ãįˇåŧĩãŽæˇˇããŖãéãåŖ°ãéãããåãčŖããã
ããã¤ãĻãŽčåã§ãããįĻčļŗå°ãįĨãŽå¤æŗãã¨åéãįšãå¯ä¸ãŽé莝ãįĢãĄåĄãįˇãŽčĻįãĢãéˇčēĢãŽåĨŗãæ ãŖãĻããã
ãå°åŗãĒå¤åĨãčēĢãĢįããããŧããæˇąãčĸĢãŖãĻããããéããæ¤åĻã¸čžŋãįããžã§ãŽčļŗåããĢčŋˇãã¯ãĒããŖããå
ļããŠããããéãæŊããããåããįčˇĄãæŽããĒãããčĄåããĻãããã¨ãææĄæ¸ãŋã ã
ãäģã¯åĄãŽåŽå
¨ãäŊãããåĒå
ãããã
ãįˇã¯įĄč¨ãŽãžãžį¸æãŽåēæšãįĒēãŖããčĢĻããĻįĢãĄåģããĒãã°æéãįããã
ãį¸å¯žããåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããĢã¯ãéŠãã¨å°æãå ĨãæˇˇããŖãĻãããå ļãã§ããĒãããįŽįãåĒå ããåŧˇåēãĒææãåŊŧåĨŗãč¸ãŋįãžãããĻããã
ãåąåŽŗãå ããæ°ã¯ãĒãããäēēãæĸããĻããã ããããŖãã芹ãåãæéããĒããã ãããéĒéãããĒãã§æŦ˛ãããŽã ãããŠãįč§ŖããĻããã ãããããīŧã
ãå¤č¸ãŋãããããĢįˇãį¨ãŋä¸ããã芹ãéį¨ãããčŠĻããĻãããŽã ã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽč¨čãĢčŗãåžãã¤ã¤ãå ļãŽãåŖ°ãããčåŗæˇąãåčĒãŽåšžã¤ããæĸãåēããããããã䏿šã§ãæĨčŋããåēåŽĸéãŽãåŖ°ããĢæ°äģããčĻæãåŧˇãããæãæãããĢæžįŊŽããã°ãč å¨ããįĨãŽå¤æŗããåĄãĢãžã§åãŗãããĒãã
ãįã饰ããįˇãĢãæ¯ãžãĒãåĨŗã¯ãįĻããã䏿Šč¸ãŋčžŧãã ã
ãæĄå ã¯čĻããĒãããåæãĢæĸãããã
ãéģãčžŧãã§åããĒãįˇãįĄčĻããĻãããŽčãããæããĻčĄããããããžããĢãããŽæã ã
ãįˇãč
°ãĢåˇģãäģããĻããå¤åĨã¯ãäšžãå§ããã¨åæãĢæĩæåãå¤ąããįˇŠãã§ããããããå
ããĒåãã§č§Ŗãčļŗå
ã¸čŊãĄãã
ãčĒčēĢãŽčļŗä¸ãčĻãããããŖããã¨čēĢãåąããĻįˇã¯å¤åĨãæžãä¸ããã
ãåĨŊæŠã¨ãåããéãããŽéč˛ãŽå¤åĨãĢãåĨŗãŽčĻįˇãéäģããĢãĒããåŊŧåĨŗãĢã¨ãŖãĻæãåēãŽæˇąã螿ãĢč§ĻįēãããéĸéŖãã荿ļã䏿°ãĢčãã
ãäŊŋį¨ããįŗ¸ãå¸å°ããį´°ããæŗ¨æããĻãäŊåš´ã大åãĢįãĻããčĄŖæããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ã大åãĒčĒæ¸äģ˛éã§ãããŖãå°ããĒåäēēããĄãĢãĒãã°ã¨ãæŗããčžŧããĻæ°åš´åãĢč˛ãŖããŽã ã
ããããæį¸ĢããŽå¤åĨã¨ããå§ŋåŊĸãĢå¤ãããįŧåãĢåå¨ããĻãããä¸įãčēĢãĢįããĻããããĒãįˇãŽč °ãĢåˇģãäģããããčļŗå ãĢčŊã¨ãããã
ããŠãã§ããããīŧã
ãčĻæãåŧˇããåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããĢã¯ãä¸įŦãŽåæēãŽåžãįĻįĨã¨æããããŖããįį¸ãįĨããã°åŧãä¸ãããĒãã¨č¨ããã°ãããŽåŧˇåēãĒæąēæããåĨæĩãŽãããĢæŧãå¯ããã
ãæžãä¸ããå¤åĨãåŊŧåĨŗãŽåãĢåēããĻčĻããå ããŖãå ´æã¸æģããåģä¸åģã¨åéã¸æĨčŋããåēåŽĸéãŽãåŖ°ããĢãæčãį ãæžãžããã
ãčĻåŽãããĒããå¤åĨãč
°ãĢåˇģãį´ãįˇã
ã
ã
ãčŗãæžãžãã°ãæģ´ãčŊãĄãéĢãčãįŗãåŠããããŽåĨĨã§ãåŽãããĢæēãĄãå°ããĒ坿¯ãåŧå¸ãįš°ãčŋããĻããã
ãæĸããããĒčĻįˇãį°åŊĸãŽįˇãĢåãããããäŊãäģåēãããčĻæĨĩããĒããã°ã¨ãããåŖ°ãããéãéŋããĻãããäŋããããããĢããįžäģŖäēēãŽå¸¸čãįãĒæ¯ãčããåŽčĄããšããįˇã¯įéĄãŽãžãžåĨŽéãįļããã
ãä¸åãĢįĩãŗįŽã¯åŽæããĒããåãæããĒããŽãčĻãĻåãŖãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãįēããåãããã
ãä¸åēĻãããŽå¤åĨãį§ãĢ貸ããĻä¸ãããĒãīŧã
ãį´°ãįãŖįŊãĒæå
ãčĸåŖããčĻãã
ãå°ãčĻéããįŧã§ãããŖããã¨įŦãããĻéĻãåžããįˇãĢãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æĸčĻæãčĻãããå°ããĒåäēēãčĻããĻãããŽã¨å¯¸åéããåãäģčã§ããŖãããã ã
ãįĄéǍãĒæãå¤åĨãåˇŽãåēãã
ã大åãĒįŠãĒãŽããããŖãĄãŽį̝ãæãŖãĻããĻããããããīŧããããã¨ãã
ãæãåããĒããåŊŧåĨŗã¯å¤åĨãįˇãŽč °ãĢåˇģãäģããį̝ã¨į̝ãä¸å¯§ãĢįĩãã ã
ã貴æšã¯ãããŽåãĢäŧãŖããŽãīŧãį§ãããŽåãŽããæã¸æĄå ããĻãããĒããããīŧã
ãåã芰ãããæ°æãĄãį˛žä¸æ¯ãĢæãčžŧãįŧåˇŽããĢã訴ãããããĒå ãåŽŋããįˇã¯åŋããĒããžãžįĢãĄå°Ŋãããã
ãįŽčãäŧããæãį´ããããĢå°ããæ¯ãå¸ãčžŧãã¨ã严æãä¸ããĻããŧããå¤ããã
ããĩããã¨åēããįŊéãŽéĢĒãįˇãčĒčããį´åžãįĨããĢãäŧŧãæéĄã¨æąēæãŽãåŖ°ããį´æĨéŋããã
ãæšããĻéĄãčĻãã°ãéˇåŊį¨Žæã¨ã¯æããŦãģãŠãĢéãéãč˛ããå
ļåĻãĢããŖãã
ãéģãŖããžãžä¸æŠåžéãããã¨ãåĨŗã¯å åģļã°ããĢããĻããčĻæãæąēãããšãæãæĨããŽã ã¨å¯ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæãéĢĒãæĸŗããéĄãĢãããįŊéãŽéĢĒãŽæ¯å ããä¸į˛ãŽéĢãæģãčŊãĄãčļŗå ã§å°ããĒčãæēãããã
ãâĻâĻããããããŖããã
ãææ ãæããåŖ°ã§č¨ãã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯éãåēããããĢãĒãåãåãŋᎠãããæ°æãĄãčŊãĄįããããããĢč ãįĩãŋãæˇąåŧå¸ããã
ãæŗ¨ææˇąãčĻŗå¯ããĒããã°ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽåæēãįĒēãįĨããã¨ã¯ä¸å¯čŊã§ãããã
ãäēēãŽæ°é
ãããå ´æã§ã¯å¸¸ãĢæŗ¨æãæããé ãéããĻããæēãããäģåã¯ãåŖ°ããå
¨ãĻãæããŋãĢãããæ
ãįĨãåžããĢéããĒãã
ããé¨ããããĻããžãŖããããããã§ããæãããĻããã ããã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻéĄãä¸ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãčĒčēĢãŽåã¸åˇŽãåēãããæãĢæ°äģããčĻįˇãåããã
ãčļŗå ãæŗĨæŋãã§ãããé´ãæąããĻãæ§ããŦãĒãã°æãã
ãå
ļãŽč¨čéŖãã¯ãéŊĸå
įžãčļ
ããåš´å¯ããåŊŧåĨŗãĢæŗčĩˇãããã
ãįĄææŗã ãããããĄãĒãæäŊããã¯ãį¸æãŽæåãč¨čĒãå°éãããã¨ããå§ŋåĸãŽãããĒããŽãæãåããã
ãå°ãčŋˇãŖãåžãĢåŊŧåĨŗã¯é ˇãã大ããĒæãĢčĒčēĢãŽæãæˇģããã
ã
ã
ãįˇãŽæĄå
ãåããĻčĄãįããå
ã§ãåĨŗãįŧãĢããããŽã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗããããŽåãã¨åŧãã č
ãŽå¤ããæãĻãå§ŋã§ããŖãã
ãå¤åĨãå
ãŋé ããĻããäēēåãčĻãéį̝ãĢãå°ããåŧãæŖãŖããããĒåŖ°ãä¸ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯é§ãå¯ãŖãã
ãčēčēããĒãããå¤åĨčļããĢæãæˇģãéŧåã¨å¯æ¯ãįĸēčĒããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããã¨æ¯ãåãã
ãå¤åĨãŽį̝ããæãããĒįŊéĢĒãã¯ãŋåēããĻãããå°ãæ˛ãã¨įŊãå¯éĄãčĻããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ä¸įŦã ãįŧãčĻéããããį´ããĢįļæ
ãįč§ŖããĻäŊã§ããĒããããĢįŊãéĢĒãæĸŗãããããŽåããŽé ãæĢã§ãã
ã
ã
ãéããĢå¯ãæˇģãŖãĻããåĨŗãæĨãĢéĄãä¸ããã
ãéŖãšãããããŽãæãŖãĻæĨããšãã ãŖããéŖ˛æ°´ã¯č¯ãã¨ããĻãæŋããŽæã¨ææãããããĢããã¨ãæĨãã§ããããâĻâĻã
ãä¸č¨ãåŖ°ãĢåēããĒããŖãããŽãŽãčĒčēĢãč˛ŦãããåŖ°ãããįˇãĢã¯čãããĻãããé åãããããĢåãæããčä¸ã¸ãåŊŧã¯åŖ°ããããã
ãéŖį¨åããŽæ¤įŠãĢéĸããĻãå ļãŽįĨčãååãããããåĻäŊãīŧãã
ãäēæŗå¤ãŽææĄãĢ寞ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æ¯ãčŋããå ããĢææĄãåˇĄãããã
ããããåŋčĢãã貴æšããč¯ããã°ãåãã§įĨčãæäžãããĻããã ããã
ãæ°åŋãŽįĨããåäēēã᏿ãĢããããŽåĻãįããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯čĻĒãæ°ãĒįŦãŋãäŊãŖãã
ã
ã
ãå°ãå ´æãå¤ããå¨å˛ãŽæ¤įŠãčĻãĻåãã
ãããŽčžēããč¯ãããã
ãæšåãæãį¤ēãåŊŧåĨŗãŽå¤åĨãŽä¸ãããæ´žæã§ã¯ãĒããĒããããåã¨ããé°å˛æ°ãéįĢãããčĄŖãčĻãããį´°ãč
°ãŽčãĢã¯ãčŖ
éŖžãŽæŊãããįåŖãŽéãéãå
ãŖãĻããã
ããžãã§čąĒåĨĸãĒčąã¨čãĢé ããĻéŖãĒãæŖãŽããã ã¨ããããčĻãįˇã¯į´åžãããã
ãįãã°įãéĻããæžã¤ãŽããããéŖãšé ãŽååŗãæ é¤ãčąå¯ãæ¯æ§ã¯ãĒããããŠãéŖãšéãã¯č¯ããĒãããéŖãšãããæ¤įŠã¯äģãĢããããčĻåãæšã¯âĻâĻã
ãč¨čãé¸ãŗãĒãããéŖæãĢéĸããįĨčãæããŋãĒãæãå§ãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčŗå ã§ãå°ããĒéŖžããéĄãŽåããĢåãããĻæēããã
ãč¨čã¨ãåŖ°ããĢéä¸ããä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ãŽæ å ąãå¸åããĻãããæ¤įŠãŽčãĢč§ĻããĒãããå ļã ãŽįšæ§ãåãčžŧãã ã
ãéãŽå¤ãžã§éããã
ããč¨čãĢįããããĻããã ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åžŽįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãåˇŽãäŧ¸ãšãããæãåãŖãã
ã
ã
ãåéãŽįæŋãčļããå°ãéããå ´æãĢåēãã
ãããŽįæŋã¯č¯ãįŽå°ãĢãĒããããäēēéŋããŽåĒãããäģã¯åããĻããããåŊšãĢįĢããĒãã
ãé åããĒåŋ åãŽåžãããŧããčĸĢãį´ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãåĨããŽč¨čãį´Ąãããããã¨ããã
ãå
ãĢįˇãåŖãéããã
ãä¸čēžã§æĒãããããæĢããŽéãäģãåãŖãĻ貰ããã
ãäŊãå¸ããããĒåŖ°ã§åããåæšãŽæãããį¨ãŋæŽãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯å¨å˛ãčĻæããĻãæŖįĸēãĢįļæŗãįč§Ŗãããå§ŋããčĻããĻã¯ããĒãããŽãŽããã ãĒããŦæ°é ãæĨčŋããĻããã
ãį§ãåŽãĢäŊŋããŽīŧã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããããããĢæĩãããããĒįŊéãŽéĢĒãčŗãĢæããã
ãéåąéŗãããããã褿°âĻâĻã
ãæ°é
ã¨éŗãæ°ããĒãããæ¤ãŽå ´ãåãæšæŗãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æ¨Ąį´ĸããĻããã
ãčĻã¤ããåãĒãã°éãåããã¨ã¯åŽšæã ãããããæ°æãããæŽãããžãžįĢãĄåģãã°ãæ°ããĒåžæãįãŋãæ¤åĻãžã§čļŗãäŧ¸ã°ããæåŗããĒããĒãŖãĻããžãã
ãåˇįããã°ãããŽåãåąéēãĢæããã
ãįĒãåēããããĒéããæģ˛ãã åãããããĒåŖ°č˛ãå ļãã¯ãįžįļãĢ寞åĻããå ã§åž ã¤åąæŠãä翏ŦããåŊŧåĨŗãĒããŽčĻåã§ããŖãã
ãåŧãįããĻæĒããŖãã
ãįˇãŽįŧãĢãčįãåãããį¨ãŽåąéēãĒå ãåŽŋããŽãčĻãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãå°ããæēãæ¯ãæēĸãã
ããžããæˇåĨŗãįŦãã§å¸°ããããĒããĻãį´ŗåŖĢãĒãããĒããããīŧã
ãæãåãåĒããčĢããããĒåŖ°č˛ãŽåŊŧåĨŗãĢãįˇã¯å°ãéĄåˇĄãããæãĄãããããææĄãĢããŖãĻãæąēæãĢæēãããįããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æããã垎įŦãŋãå°éĻãåžããĻčŋįãåž ãŖãĻããã
ãæäŧãŖãĻããããīŧã
ãč¨čãé¸ãŗãįˇã¯ä¸åēĻããŽæãäŧ¸ã°ããã
ããããį§ã§č¯ããã°åãã§ã貴æšã¨įĩãããĒãåŋåŧˇããã
ãããŗãšãŽčĒããĢåŋãããããĒäģčã§æãéãããäēããŽįŧãå
ããĢäē¤ããŖãã
ãå
ļãäģĨä¸ã¯č¨čãäē¤ãããŦãžãžãäēäēēã¯æ°é
ãæēãĄãéãŽä¸ã¸čēĢãįŋģããã
ã
â
ãåéãčãĢãįˇã¨åĨŗã¯æˇąãéã¸ã¨éŖãŗčžŧããåŊŧããé¸ãã ãŽã¯ãåšžįãĢãæåããããčŋˇåŽŽãŽãããĒį´°éã ã
ããã¤ãĻå´åč
ãčĄãäē¤ãŖãéąįŗæĄæįžå ´ãŽčˇĄå°ãåŊãŽį¤žäŧæ§é ãäŊįžããããŽåĻãč¤éãĢå
ĨãįĩãŋãčĻįãéŽãéåŽŗįŠã§æēããããĻãããæ°ãŽä¸åŠãčŖããĢã¯æéŠãĒå°åŊĸã ã
ã
ã
ãįˇã¯éģéãĢå
ãįŗã§å¨å˛ãčĻŗå¯ããã䏿šãããŧããįŽæˇąãĢčĸĢãŖãåĨŗã¯ãå°éĸãæģããããĢį§ģåããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæã¤įĨčããč¤éãĒįĢäŊčŋˇčˇ¯ãŽéįãæãį¤ēããĻããã
ãåžæšããčļŗéŗãčŋĢããåŊŧãã¯äŋåŽæ´žãŽé įŽãæžãŖãéˇåŊį¨ŽæãŽåēåŽĸã ãæ°ã¯å
Ģãå
ļã
ãåĨãŽé莝ããæĨčŋããĻæĨãã
ãį˛įŠãåãĢåŖ°ãįēããĒãåŊŧããŽãåŖ°ããįˇã¯æããĻãããčãĢæãč§Ļããã
īŧã¤ããĻæĨãĻīŧ
ãčļŗãæĸããéĻãåããĻčĻįˇãčŋãã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åã¨æãŽåãã§æį¤ēãéãŖããč§ŖčĒæčĄãæãĄåãããĒãįˇã¯ãå åŽšã¨ææäŧéãĢéĸããįĻããåŊŧåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ãããåãåãŖãã
īŧä¸ã¤įŽãŽåĨãéãåˇĻã¸ãããŽå ãĢé ããĻãããéãããīŧ
ãįŦãã ããčŋãããåŖ°ããį¤ēããžãžé莝ãããæããå´ŠããįĻį¤ĢãŽé°ãĢčēĢãæŊããã
ãåēåŽĸãŽå é ãčĩ°ãäēäēēããįĻį¤ĢãŽæŖäšąããéčˇ¯ã¸æ˛ããŖãĻæĨããį补ãæãåãããåĨĨã¸ã¨æļããĻčĄãã
ãæŽããŽå äēēã¯ãåããéãĢåˇŽãæããŖãčžēãã§čļŗãæĸãããåŊŧããŽãåŖ°ããäēããĢįåŋĩãäŧéãåãã
īŧæ°é
ãéåããīŧ
īŧčãã¯æŽãŖãĻãããčŋããīŧ
ãå
čĄããäēäēēã¨ã¯åĨãŽé莝ã¸ä¸äēēãå
ĨãŖãĻčĄããæŽãä¸äēēã¯čŋčžēãæĸį´ĸãå§ããã
ã
ã
ãčä¸ãžã§čĻãã°ããŧããŽčŖ
įãįĩããåĨŗããéĻæ°´įļãŽä¸čēĢã§æšŋãããããŗãĢããįˇãĢææ¸ĄããåŊŧåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããįļæŗãäŧããĻããã
īŧåŗããä¸äēēæĨãīŧ
ãéããĒãåŗãŽé莝ããä¸äēēãŽåēåŽĸãįžãããåŊŧãã¯éãĢįŧãåãããæ¨įã¨į补ãæĸãã
ãįˇã¯įĻį¤ĢãŽé°ããéŗããĒãæģãåēãããåēåŽĸãŽä¸äēēã垎ããĒįŠēæ°ãŽæēãããĢãéĄãä¸ãããå ļãŽåŖå ã¸ãåĨŗãéĻæ°´įļãŽä¸čēĢãåšããããåēåŽĸã¯åŖ°ãä¸ããéããĒãæåããã
ãåãå¤ąãŖãæããæģãčŊãĄãĻčĄãéãåĨŗã¯į´ æŠãæ´ãã ã
ãæŽãäēäēēãŽåēåŽĸãŽãåŖ°ããĢãéŠæã¨ææãå ããĻå°æãåŽŋãã
ãä¸äēēã¯å°åãŽåŧãæ§ããããä¸äēēãäģ˛éã¸ååŗãéããã¨ãããäžãĢæ´ŠãããåŖ°ãã§įļæŗãå¯ããįˇã¯ãéŖæĨããįĸãįĄčĻããĻãååŗãéãč ãŽč ãæ´ãã ãæŦĄãã§ãããŗãĢããåēåŽĸãŽéŧģã¨åŖãĢæŧãåŊãĻãã
ãæŋããæĩæãããåãå ãããã¨ã§ãéǍãéãéŗãįĢãĻãĻį ãããįˇã¯æããč
ãč§ŖæžããĻã᏿ãŽé é¨ãæãčžŧãã
ã
ã大įˇãĢæ°ãåãããĻããå°ååŧãŽä¸äēēã¯ãčåžãã鎎ãããĒæåãåããæčãåãčŊã¨ãããã
ãįˇã¯įĄį čŦãå
ããããåēåŽĸãŽčãįĸēčĒããčĒčēĢãŽč
ãĢåēããŖãįĸãæããĒããããåŖ°ããĢæčãåããã
ã
ã
ãč´čĻãį ãæžãžããå¨å˛ãŽæ°é
ãčŋŊãåĨŗã¯ãåæã§ãããåēåŽĸãŽčēĢãæĄããĻããã
ãᎿ°ãå°ãĒãį¨Žæã§ããæ
ãĢãåæãŽå¤ãã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽčĻĒæã§ãããåąéēãĒäģäēãčĢãč˛ ãæ§åãããããã ã
ãäēäēēã¯įĻį¤ĢãŽé°ã¸åãŗčēĢãæŊããã
ãæĢãįĩãŖãåžãĢãå čĄããäģ˛éã¨åæĩããäēäēēãåŧãčŋããĻæĨããåããĻããä¸äēēãčĻã¤ããåŊŧããŽãåŖ°ããĢãčįĢãĄã¨åˇãŋãæĩã¸ãŽææãæˇˇããčžŧãã
ãä¸äēēããåããäģ˛éãŽįļæ ãįĸēčĒãããã¨æĨčŋãããčēĢãåąããĻč§Ļããééãįˇã¯æããããåŊąã¨ãĒãŖãĻčēãåēãã
ãæ°ãĨããåēåŽĸãåĢãŗãéįļãŽæããã¤ããį°åŊĸãŽįˇãŽčļŗå
ãæ ããã
ããã¤ããĢåĄãčžŧãžããæ¯ãŽį¨ŽéĄãããįããåŽããäŊįŊŽãžã§ããåŖ°ãããåãčžŧãã§ããåŊŧã¯ãå
ļããåˇéãĢčēąããã
ãæ˛åŖãæēããä¸äēēãäģæãããäŊåĸãå´ŠããŦãžãžįˇã¯å˛ŠãŽčãčš´ããæããĢčēĢãæģãããĻčēąããã
ãįĄææ ãĢæŦĄã ã¨čĨ˛ãæĨãåŖæãčēąãįļããåæãįš°ãåēããčŋãčĄãæĩ´ãŗãĻãįŗã¯æŋããããã įĄåŋãĢæŦĄãŽį˛įŠã¸ã¨į§ģãŖãĻčĄãã
ãåŊŧãŽæŗã¯å˛ŠåŖãį ãã夊äēãčļŗå ãĢãžã§å¤§įŠ´ãéããĻé莝ãåŠãæŊ°ããæ¯ãã į¸æãæ´ãã§åäģģããĢæžãæããåēĻãæĩãŽéŖåŊĸã¨éŖæēãå´Šããå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽãĢå§é¨ã¨æˇˇäšąãæĄå¤§ããĻããã
ãåĨŗã¯æĻæŗãįŠé°ããčĻŗå¯ããĻãããįˇãį¤ēãå§åįãĒį ´åŖåã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæŗåãéĨããĢčļ ããããŽã§ããŖãã
ãææ¸Ąããéå ˇãčĒŦæãåãããĢäŊŋãįããčĒ°ãŽæį¤ēãåãããĢãčåžãããŽæģæããéģã ã¨čēąããå°åŊĸãæ´ģį¨ããå°įˇãåæããããã¨ã§ãįĩąįãããåãå´ŠããĻããã
ãį°åŊĸãŽįˇãåŋåĒããåēčˇč
ã§ããčĄãĢéŖĸããæĒįŠã§ããĒããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æšããĻčĒčããã
ã
ã
ãæåžãĢæŽãŖãåēåŽĸãčĻã
ãããĢéĄãæĒãžããæįŦãéŗ´ãããæ¤éãŽååŗã ã
ãæŽŋã財ãŖãĻåēããĒãŧããŧæ ŧãŽįˇãåŧå¸ãæ´ããæ˛åŖãæ§ãį´ãã寞åŗããį°åŊĸãŽįˇã¯čēčēããĒãåæšã¸é§ãåēããä¸įŦãŽåžãĢæģãæļããã
ãčļŗå ãĢå¤§įŠ´ããããã¨ãå¤ąåŋĩããĻåą ããŽã ãæŖįĸēãĢã¯ãįŠ´ãŽį̝ã¸č¸ãŋåēããéį̝ãå´ŠãčŊãĄããŽã§ããŖãã
ãå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽãĢéå¯ãæģãããĒãŧããŧæ ŧãŽįˇã¯įĢãĄå°Ŋããããžãžæ¨įãŽæ°é ãčŋŊãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãä翏Ŧããæãã éããŽåąéã
ãį°åŊĸãŽįˇã¯ä¸åãŽåããæĸããįŽčãäŧããã¨å¨å˛ãŽãåŖ°ããĢæ˛ãã ã
ã
ã
ãåããĒãäģ˛éãĢčŠã貸ããĒãããåēåŽĸã¯æŖãæŖããĢåŧãčŋããĻčĄãã
ãåŊŧããŽéį¨ä¸ģã¯ãäģåãŽįĩæå ąåãåããĻãįŠãããæãåŧããĒããåŊãŽåįļã¨ä¸æãŽå¨äŋĄãĢæããäē大åĸåãŽé įŽãįĢļãŖãĻįŠããåŊããĻããã¨ãĒãã°ãčĢĻãããããĒãŠå°éŖã ããĒãŧããŧæ ŧãŽįˇãŽãåŖ°ãããããããĒæ å ąãčãåãŖãã
ãį°åŊĸãŽįˇã¯įŊéãŽéĢĒãŽåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããæĸãããæįĸēãĒæåˇããĒããžãžæ§åãåŗæšãĢäģããäēēéããŽå¤ãčĄã¸å
ĨãŖãĻčĄãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽįĨčã¨įĨæ§ã¯ãäģåžã貴éãĒæ
å ąãããããã ããã
ãčēĢãįŋģãããįĨãŽå¤æŗãã¸įšããéãæŊãŖãã
ãéæŽĩãéããĻčĄãã¨ãčąããĒå°åēæšãåŊŧãčŋãå Ĩãããæ°´åēããæš§ãä¸ããå ã¯ãæéãĢæ ŖããįŧãĢåŧˇãįŦããĻčĻããã
ãčļŗæãŽééãĢãæ°´ãåĢãã čãŽæč§Ļãįēããã¤ããå˛ŠåŖãŽčã¯éãčļŗéŗãå¸ãčžŧãŋãčļŗčˇĄãéįĢãããĻãį¨ãĒãå ãŽåŊĸįļã¸æģãŖãĻčĄãŖãã
ãæčã¯æšãŽåēããæš§ãä¸ããéįŊãå
ã¨įåŊã¸åãããããå
ļãŽåã§į ãããčĻãããåŖ°ããįĸēããĢæããã
ã
âââ
ããäģäēããį˛ãæ§ãããĢã
ãįĻį¤ĢãŽé°ããčãããĻããæãããĒåŖ°ã¨čļŗéŗãĢããĒãŧããŧæ ŧãŽįˇãčĻæãåãããį˛å´ãæģ˛ãžããĒãããåŊŧã¯åŖ°ããåŋåŊãããæĸãã¤ã¤ããã¤ã§ãåããããčēĢæ§ããã
ãâĻâĻãŦãīŧã
ãčĻįˇãŽå ã§ãéˇčēĢãŽåĨŗãå¤åĨãŽããŧããčąãã ãæĩããįŊéãŽéĢĒããĩãã¨įæã§æ¯ãæããčēčēãĒãåããžã§æŠãŋå¯ãã
ãä¸äēēãīŧãäģããŽä¸å¸¯ã¯åąéēã ãæŠãæģããâĻâĻãããäŋēãčĄãžã§éããã
ã᏿ãŽčēĢãæĄããææĄãããããŦãã¨åŧã°ããåĨŗã¯čŗã貸ããĒããåšŧéĻ´æãĢåäŧã§ããåãŗã¨ãč˛ åˇãčģŊåēĻã§ããæ§åãčĻãåŽå ĩããã襨æ
ãįˇŠããé ãæĢã§ããã¨æãäŧ¸ã°ããįˇåŧĩãæŽãŖãĻããįˇã¯åå°įãĢæãæãé¤ããã
ãį´åžãå
ļãŽæåŋããĢ寞ããåžæãæįĩļãŽææãä¸åãŖãã
ãããããĩããĢâĻâĻã
ããŦããŽãåŖ°ããĢã¯ãåŊŧãŽäģåžãæĄããæããæģ˛ãã§ããã
ãâĻâĻãããĒéĄãããĒãæŦĄã¯ãåã¤ãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãåŽåŋããããæãã¨ã¯åĨãĢãä¸åãåŽŖåãããããĒ襨æ ãåããããä¸åŽãįãããå ļãããéããããįēãŽæ šæ ãŽãĒãåŧˇããã ã
ããŦãã¯č¨ããã¨ããč¨čãåŧãŖčžŧããäģŖãããĢæããåŖ°ã§åŋããã
ãããããæŦĄã¯ããĄããã¨åŋæ´ããĻãããããããã°ããããĢããŖãĻã
ãčļåããŦããĢããĩããĢã¯å ããĒéã ãåŋãäšąããããããããĢæ°ãåŧãᎠããã
ãčĻãĻãããĒãæããĻããããĸãŦããŠãčĻãīŧã
ããĩããĢãŽįåŖãĒåŖ°ãåããĻããŦããįéĸįŽãĢįããã
ãčēĢäŊčŊåãŽį´ å°ã¯å¤čĻäģĨä¸ããããĢåą ãããã§ããĻæ°é ããĒããŽãĢãåš˛æ¸ã¯ããĻãããč¨čãæåŗãįč§ŖããããããĻäŊããåĻįŋéåēĻãį°å¸¸ãã
ãčļŗå ãŽįŠ´ãéŖãŗčļããĒããåŊŧåĨŗã¯æåžãĢäģãå ããã
ãã§ããč¯ãåãīŧãå°ãĒãã¨ãį§ãčĻãéããŽįžįļã§ã¯ã
ãæ¯ãčŋããåæ°ãĢåãããĻããéĄãčĻãĻãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĒãããŦãã¯įŠ´ãŽåããå´ã¸åģãŖãĻãããåˇŽãäŧ¸ãšãæãįĄįĸãĢããããĩããĢãŽãåŖ°ããĢ䏿ēãæˇˇãããäŊããåŠãã¤ãããããĒéŗãéŋããã
ãæŦĄãŽįŦéããŦããŽįēããč¨čããåŊŧãŽä¸ã§æåŗãå¤ããĻããã
ãâĻâĻåĨ´ã¨čŠąãããŽãīŧããããåįŦã§ã
ããĩããĢãŽåŖ°ãäŊãéããã
ãįĢå ´ãŖãĻããŽãčããããåãŽäģŖããã¯ããĒããã ãã
ããŦãã¯ä¸įŦã ãįĢãĄæĸãžããčŠčļããĢæ¯ãčŋãã
ããããæãããĄããŖããį§ã ãŖãĻåļįļåą åããããŽãīŧãæ°ãæ°ãããĒããŖããã ããã
ããããã¨čãåããĻæŠãåēããå ļãŽčãæŠčĒŋãĢãããããããæããããåįããĒããã¨ããĩããĢã¯čĻãĻåãŖãã
ãåž
ãĻããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸããåãããĒããĒãŖããâĻâĻã
ãããĢãããĒããĒãŖãããį§ãå°ããã
ãčĸĢãããããĢå°ããåããčģŊãããĢé˛ããŦããåŊŧåĨŗãčŋŊããĩããĢãŽåŖ°ã¨čļŗéŗããįĻį¤ĢãŽåããã¸æļããĻčĄãŖãã
5
ãæ°ãĨãã¨ãéįŊãå ã¨įŠãããĒæ¸ŠãããĢå ãžããĻãããæããæ¯ãåããããĒããããĒåŋå°č¯ããĢãå ¨čēĢããåãæããĻããã
ãåŖããæŗĄãŽį˛ãæŧãããįŽãéãã°ãããŽæŗĄããĄã¯ãããããã¨įĢãĄä¸ãŖãĻãããæ°æŗĄããŠãããåã¯æ°´ãŽä¸ãĢãããŽã ã
ã
ãããŽå
æ¯ãĢčĻæããĻããã¨ãåãŽčēĢäŊããéģããĸã¤ãæãŋåēãĻãããã¨ãĢãæ°ãĨããã
ãæãŽææãæ°´ãĢæēļãåēãĻãããŽã ãããīŧããããã¯ãįãŋããĒããžãžå
¨čēĢãæēļãå´Šãããã¨ããĻãããŽã ãããīŧ
ã
ã大ããĒæãĢæ´ãžããæ¸Šããæ°´ãŽå¤ã¸åŧãä¸ããããã
ãåŗãčžŧããããĢããĻãéŧģãåŖããå
ĨãŖãæ°´ãæŽããåãåēããããããĻããæ¯ãå¸ãčžŧãããžãã§å
¨čēĢãĢæãŋæ¸Ąãããã ãŖãã
ãããŽå¤Ēãč
ãŽæč§ĻãĢã¯čĻãããããįŧãä¸ããã¨ãčĩ¤éĢĒãæŋĄããĻãéĄãčŠã¸č˛ŧãäģããããĢįĩĄãŋã¤ããĻãããã
ãæãåˇŽãäŧ¸ã°ããéį̝ãéãéããããĢįãŖįŊãĒč
ãčĻįãĢéŖãŗčžŧãã ã
ãįēå ããæšãŽæ°´ãĢį §ããããį´°č ã¯ãéįŊãå ãŖãĻãããããĢčĻãããæãįĒãŽåŊĸã¯åãŽæã¨é ˇäŧŧããĻãããã§ããããããčĻŗå¯ããã°ãåšŧãé ãŽäēį´°ãĒ䏿ŗ¨æã§äŊãããå°ããĒįĢåˇčˇĄãčĻåŊãããĒãã
ãįŧãéããåĸããĻããã
ãåãŽæčã¯åžŽįĄãŋãŽä¸ã¸čŊãĄãĻčĄãŖãã
âââ
ãæ°´åēã¸æ˛ããããĢãæčãŽåĸįãæēããããĻãããæãããĒæ¸Šãããå
¨čēĢãå
ãŋã垎ããĒæ°´éŗãčŗå
ã§åããé ãæĨãŽč¨æļãŽæŽæģãããããã¯ãå¤ĸãŽįļããã
ã
ããžãŠããŋãŽä¸ãįĸēããĢæãåããæ°é
ãããŖããæ
ŖãčĻĒããã æåžãŽãããĒæ¸ŠãããããŽåŖ°ãŽä¸ģãåã¯įĨãŖãĻããã
ã
ã
ãæããįŧãæãĄä¸ããčēĢãčĩˇããããčĻæ¸Ąããéãæĸããããå¨å˛ãĢã¯čǰãŽå§ŋããĒããå°ããæ¯ãåãã
ãäŊåš´ãåãŽč¨æļãåšŧããŖãé ãŽå¤ĸã ãåĻšãĢãããžããåŖæĸããį´æãããįŽįã§éŖããĻčĄãŖããã¨ããããį§å¯ãŽčĒæ¸äŧããããŽé ã¯ãåäžåããŽįŠčĒã°ããčĒãã§ããããŠâĻâĻã
ãä¸ģåŦč ã¯ãæŦã大åĨŊããĒåĨŗæ§ã ãŖããåãŽãã¨ãĒãããã¨ãŖããĢåŋããĻããã ããã
ããĒãããããĒå¤ĸãčĻããŽããããã¯éčĻã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãããã¯ããŠãã īŧãåã¯ããŠãããŖãĻãããã¸æĨãīŧ
ãæ°´éŗãčããããéĢãčŊãĄãéŗãæšŋãŖãįŠēæ°ãįĨããĒãåãã¨ãããŽä¸ãĢæˇˇããįĨãŖãĻããåããåšŊããĢįēå ããčéĄãå¨å˛ãį §ããåēããæ¤įŠãéŦąčŧã¨ããĻãããä¸åą¤ã¨æä¸åą¤ãŽäŊäēēãæŠãžããéŖįŗ§ä¸čļŗåéĄãĒãŠããžãã§įĨããĒãããŽãããĢâĻâĻã
ãįĨããĒãã ãããĒãæ¤įŠã¯į¨ŽãčŊã¨ããå ´æãŽį°åĸãæ°ãĢå Ĩãã°čŊãåēããčĒåã§č˛ãŖãĻãããäēēãŽäēæ ãĒããããæ§ããĒãã ã
ããããĢãä¸ãŽäēēåŖã¯å¤ããããããã䏿Ĩãåž ããæ¨ãŽåššãæ šãžã§ãéŖãšå°ŊããããĻãčãå°ãåŽæããã ãã ãããäŊãč§ŖæąēããĒãã
ãæ¨ĒãããŖãĻå¯ãĻããåãŽčŠãĢã¯ãéč˛ãŽå¤åĨãæããããĻãããé å ããå°ãéĸããäŊįŊŽãĢã¯å°ããĒå ãŋããįŗãčãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽãããĻãããæē帯éŖãŽčąčåã ãããããããã¯čǰããĢč˛ãŖãã¯ãâĻâĻã
ãããã ãåã¯ãįŧįąæ˛ŧããĢčēĢãæããããšãĻįĩãããããã¨ããĻãâĻâĻããã¯īŧãããŽčĩ¤éĢĒã¯čŋããĢãããŽãīŧ
ãæãã¤ããĻčēĢäŊãŽåããå¤ãããã¨ããæãč§Ļããå˛ŠčãåĻãĢæ¸Šããã¨ããäēåŽãįĨãŖããåãįãĻããæãäšžããĻãããŽã¯ããããįįąãããã
ãããŧãã¨įåŖãčãŋãŽæãĢåŧãŖæããããĻãããé´į´ãåãããĢãããŧãæŦäŊãŽååãįãããžãžčąãããį´ čļŗã§åēæŠããããĒåĨ´ãããããĒå¨į¨ãããŠãã§čēĢãĢã¤ãããŽã ãããīŧ
ãããäģĨä¸ãĢä¸čĒįļãæĨĩããĻãããŽã¯ãåčĒčēĢãŽčãŽč˛ã ãæå ããč ãčļŗããéŧģãé ŦããéįŊããĻæ°åŗãæĒããčĒåãŽæãå ¨įļéãŖãããŽãĢčĻãããįŽãįããããĒããģãŠãŽåŧˇįãĒéåæãæããĒãã
ãäģãŽåãčĻãããåĻšã¯ãŠããĒååŋãããã ããīŧãéŠãã¯ããã ããããčŊãĄįããŽãåž ãŖãĻãããŖããčĒŦåžããã°äŊã¨ããĒãã¯ãã ã
ãäģãŽåæããĄã¯īŧããŠãããã°åæã ã¨č¨ŧæã§ããīŧãããããäŋĄããĻããããĒããŖããããŠããĒããŽã ãããīŧ
ã
ã
ãåã¯ãããã¨ããĻéãŽä¸ã¸æãæģããããæãĢéĻ´æãã ãĩã¤ãēæã¨å¸åŧĩããŽįŠãåãåēãã
ããŠãã¸čĄããĢãæãĄæŠããĻããæå¸ŗãå¤į´ãŽæãįļ´ããã ããŽį°Ąį´ ãĒäŊãã ããããŽä¸įãĢäēã¤ã¨ãĒãæĨč¨å¸ŗã ã
ãæĨã ãŽåēæĨäēãæ¸ãč¨ãäģãĢãčããããŗãŽæéˇčĻŗå¯č¨é˛ãčĒŋãšįŠãį´°ããč¨įŽãããæãĢã¯ãĄãĸ叺ã¨ããĻãæ´ģčēãįļããĻããã čǰãĢãč¨ããĒãį§å¯ãæį´ãåãåēããããŽæãåŖã ã
ããããäģãå¤į´ãŽæã¯ããšãĻã¯ãŋã¯ãŋãĢã¨ãŦæ˛ããŖãĻãããæåã¯æģ˛ãã§čĒããĒããģãŠã ãæ´ãĢã¯ãããŖããã¨ã§ã¯ããããŽãŽãįŊãæããããĢããĢäžĩãããĻããã
ãč¸ãįããã¨ããããããããããã¨åãããĻãããããĒæčĻã
ãæ¸ãæŽããĻãã荿ļããåãŽįåŽããåãæ¯ããĻãããį´æããæšŋæ°ãĢãģããããčŧĒéãå¤ąãå§ããĻããã
ãæå¸ŗã¯ããžã ãããĢåå¨ãããč˛ãåŊĸįļãå°ãå¤ããŖãã ãã ããããĻããããããå¤åŽšãįļããĻãããč
æãå¨å˛ãĢæãæŖãããĒããã
ãæ°¸é ãĒããĻåå¨ããĒãããããĒãã¨ã¯įč§ŖããĻããããã¤ã ãŖãĻåŋããããé ãĢãããããĻįŽåãĢįžããåŋããĒãļãã
ããžã å¤ĸãčĻãĻãããããĒæ°åã ãå¤ĸãĒãč¯ããŖããŽãĢâĻâĻã
ã
ã
ãããŽæãå˛ŠåŖãĢæ˛ŋãŖãĻé˛ãééæãŽããčļŗéŗãčãã¤ãããããŽå ´æã¸čžŋãįãããŽã¯ãå°åēãŽč¤éãĒé莝ãĢæ
Ŗããč
ããäēãåå¨ãįĨãŖãĻããč
ãŽãŋãåžč
ãĒãéĸåčããã ã
ãåã¯åå°įãĢčēĢãé ããå ´æãæĸãããčēĢäŊã¯ãžã éããæãéããĢã¯åããĒããčŋããŽå˛ŠåŖãĢįĒĒãŋãčĻã¤ããããã§čēĢãį¸ŽããĻãããéãããã¨ãĢããã
ãįĸēåŽãĢčŋĢãŖãĻæĨãĻãããåã¯ææŠãčˇįŠããžã¨ããã§ããéãį补ãæļããĻãįŠéŗãįĢãĻãĒãããæ°ãé
ããĒããį§ģåããã
ã
ã
ãčļŗéŗã¯é˛čĄæšåãå¤ããã
ãæ°´čžēãŽæˇĩãĢįĢãĄå¯ããããŽå ´ãĢč
°ãä¸ããããããããå°ãéãéããĻããŽãŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ãããããĒæ°é
ãããŖãã
ããããĻčļŗéŗã¯ãåãå ãģãŠãžã§å¯ãĻããå˛Šį¤ãŽåã§æĸãžãŖããæ¯ãæŊããĻããåãŽčŗãĢãčĒčēĢãŽéŧåãŽéŗãéŋãã
ãįãéå¯ãŽåžãåãŗéŗãčãããã大įˇãįĄé äŊãĢč
°ãä¸ããããããĒéŗã ã
ãįˇåŧĩãŽįŗ¸ãåããĻãåã¯éããĢæ¯ãåãåēãããããã¯ãããŽčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽå¯å ´æãã
ããŠããããæŧãįãæ¸ ãããĒéĻããåŽå ¨ãįĸēčĒãããããĢãåã¯įĒĒãŋããéĄãčĻãããã
ãčĻįãåãå°ŊãããŽã¯ãåšŊããĢįēå ããčéĄãĢį §ããããčąãå˛ãããæ¤įŠããĄã ãããŽåããã§ã¯æšãŽæ°´ãäģããĒå ãæēãããããéããĒåēåãéįŊãå ã§æēãããĻããã
ãåĄãŽä¸ģã¯å¯čģĸããŖãĻæ°į ãč˛Ēãããã ãããŽéãĢå°ãã ãæŖįããĻãŋãããã
ãã ããŠãé ãéãã
ã䏏䏿ĨãģãŠå¯ãæ°ã¯ãããŽãĢãčļŗããĻããĒããŽããéãĢå¯ããããŽããæ ãã§ããŠããŠãããä¸åĨå玿ĨĩãžããĒãčãŽč˛ã¯ãčĻįãĢå Ĩãã ãã§ãįŽãããĢããĢããĻãįŽįŠãåŧãčĩˇããããã ã
ãå˛ŠåŖãŽįĒĒãŋã§ãããŖã¨č¸ãŖãĻããããã§ããå¯åŋå°ã¯æåž ã§ããããĢãĒãããããŋãã¨čĒåãŽä¸įã¸æĩ¸ããĢã¯ãå°ãã°ããįŠãéããã
ãįŧãéãããĻããįŧčļããĢéįŊãå
ãããŠã¤ããæŖäŊ䏿ãŽåããéŧģč
ãããããŖãĻããã
ã
ã
ãįĩåąãä¸åŽãĢæŧãããåã¯čããããĻãããŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ãããŧãã¯æĸãĢäšžããĻãããã˛ãããã¨åˇããããåąĨããĻį§ģåãããŽãĢåéĄã¯ãĒããé´čŖãĢéãឿļ˛ãäģįããĻããããŠããã¤ãŽéãĢč¸ãã ãŽã ãããīŧ
ãããããã°ãããŽčĩ¤éĢĒãæãĢåŧãŖæããĻããããŽãĒããåžã§į¤ŧãčŋ°ãšããšãããæŠãåãããčŋãããããåãį¸ãã¤ããčĻãããĻããä¸čŦ常čã ã
ãåēäŧãŖãĻããããããžã§ãĢčĻããããåĨčĄãŽæ°ã ãã䏿°ãĢæĩŽãŗä¸ãããéĄãåãããéããŠããĒ襨æ ãäŊããäŊãč¨ãã°č¯ããŽããåãĢã¯ããããĒããŖãã
ãčããã ãã§æ°ãéãããããĒãäģã¯æĨŊãããã¨æĸããĢéä¸ãããã
ãåããããæĨč§ĻããĻããããããŽæãĢčããã°ããã寞åŋãĢå¤ąæããã¨ããĻããæãããåĨ´ã¯äŊããŠãčŋããĻãæããįŦãããåĨ´ã¯åæãĢįŦããŽã ãããåĨŊããĢãããĻããã°ããã
ã
ã
ãčãŋãŽåããã§ãææģ
ããæˇĄãå
ãčĒãã
ãčļŗå ã¯æãããčã¨æšŋãŖãåã§čĻãããææãįĄŦãå˛Šį¤ãéĄãåēãããŠããããæģ´ãéĢãčãåŠããããŽåžŽããĒéŋããããåãčãĢå¸ãčžŧãžãããå¨å˛ãĢã¯ä¸æč°ãĒãģãŠãŽéãããæēãĄãĻããã
ãããããæŠããå ã§ãå°éĸãŽä¸é¨ãįŠŋãčŋããããããĒå ´æãčĻã¤ãããčŋãĨããĻčĒŋãšãĻãŋãã¨ãæ¯ãŖãčã¨å°įŗãå˛ŠãŽįĒĒãŋãĢæˇã芰ããããĻãããããŽäģčŋãĢã¯æ¤įŠãäŊããŽéãæąã
ãããŖããå°éĸãæ´ãã§ããčã¨æ¯ãšãæ¯ãããĻããæéãįĩãŖãĻãããŽããäšžããĻãããããŽčã¨å°įŗãŽééãããå˛Ščã¨ã¯į°čŗĒãĒäŊããčĻããĻããã
ãäšžããčãŽä¸ã¤ãæžãä¸ããéį̝ãåã¯æããįŽã丸ããããčĻæ ŖããéŠčĄ¨į´ãŽå¤ãæŦããã˛ãŖããã¨įŊŽãããĻãããŽã ã襨į´ãĢã¯ãčĻčĻããŽããéč˛ãŽįŽæŧãã§ããŋã¤ããĢãåģãžããĻããã
ãåãŽæčĒæ¸ã ã襨į´ãŽæĻãå ˇåãããŧã¸ãŽč§ãĢæŽãŖãĻããžãŖãå°ããĒæãįŽčˇĄãĢãčĻčĻããããã
ãæšŋæ°ã§ããŧã¸ãŽį̝ã¯å ããĢæŗĸæãŖãĻãããããĢããĢäžĩããããã¨ãĒãããģãŧå¤ãããĒãįļæ ã ããããããåéãŽåããã§éããčãæšŋæ°ãå¸ãŖãĻãæŦãåŽãŖãĻããããŽã ããã
ãåã¯ãããæąããæ´ãĢå ã¸é˛ãã ã
ãæšįãä¸å¨ããã¤ããã§å˛ŠåŖãĢæ˛ŋãŖãĻæŠããæŦãŽä¸ã§ããčĻããã¨ãŽãĒãåĨåĻãĒæ¤įŠãįįŠãŽåŊĸ补ãčĻã¤ããåēĻãįĢãĄæĸãžãŖãã
ããããģãŠå¤æ§ãĒįåŊãæ¯ãĨããĻãããŽãĢãäģãžã§åå¨ããįĨããĒããŖãäēåŽãããã ãã§ãå¤ãĒéŠãã¨æåŋãčĻããã
ã
ã
ãããã¯åå¨ãģãŠæŠããčžēãã ãŖãã ãããã
ãå˛ŠåŖãĢäēēåˇĨįãĒå åˇĨãæŊãããå ´æã¸čĄãįãããæ´å˛ãæããããåŖįģãæãčžŧãžããĻããã
ãåã¯ãåŖãŽåšå¸ãæã§ãĒããŖãĻãŋããéˇåš´ãŽéĸ¨åã§æŠčããæŦ ããįŽæãããã¤ããããããããéåå¤ãæäģŖãŽåäŊã§ãããããĢãčĒããĒãæåãå¤ããŖãã
ãå ļã¯į ã ã¨čŧããäēēã ãŽįĨããĢįŽčĻããåŖ°ãĢå°ãããĻãåįŊã¨æˇˇæ˛ãŽä¸ãĢįĩįãããããã
ãããã§ãå 厚ãįč§Ŗã§ãããŽã¯čĻčĻããããŖãããã ãæ´å˛ææã¨ããĻå ãĻããããæŦãĢãåãåäŊãŽåæã¨įžäģŖčĒ荺ãäŊĩč¨ãããĻãããããčĻããĒ荿ļãããŽåŧį¨ã¨čŖčļŗã ãã大įã¯ééãŖãĻããĒãã¯ãã ã
ãįĨå ãéēããäŧæŋãčĻį´ããã°ãäēēã ãŽäŋĄäģ°åŋããããŽå°ãĢįĨãéãããå°éŖãéããį¤ã¨ãĒããã¨ããæãã ã
ãįĨãäŧčĒŦãįĢĨ芹ãŽä¸ã ããŽåå¨ã¨ãĒãŖãįžäģŖã§ãåäžåãææã¨ããĻ荺ãã°ãåŋãæ¸ ãæŖããäŋãĄãĒãããããããã°äģäēēãããŽæ¯æ´ãåžããããĒããžãããã¨ããããĒããŽã ãã䏿č°ã ã
ãå¤Ēå¤ãŽæãĢåŽå¨ããã¨ããįĨã¯ããŠããĒå§ŋåŊĸã§éĄįžããįĨæ ŧãæãããĢį¸åŋããæ¨ŠčŊã§åįŊããäēēã
ãæãŖããŽã ãããīŧ
ã
ã
ãåŖįģãŽéŖãĢã¯ãä¸ã¸äŧ¸ãŗãį´°éˇãéæŽĩãããŖããããããããĒãå¤ãé ãã§ããŠããåĻãĢčĻčĻããããã
ãããŽå ã¸é˛ãã°ãåãŽįĨãå ´æã¸å¸°ããã ããããé ãåŽļã¨åĻšãĢãâĻâĻã
ãäģã¯ããžã é§įŽã ãåĻšãéŖãåēããĢã¯ããããĒããŽæēåãããã
ã
ã
ãæ´ãĢé˛ãã§ãæšįãŽåããå´ã¸čļŗãåģļã°ããããã§åĨåĻãĒãããŗãčĻã¤ãããįēå
ããčéĄã¨ã¯į°ãĒãã鎎ãããĒį´Ģč˛ãŽåãæãĄã襨éĸãĢã¯į˛æļ˛ãčĻããããĢ䏿°åŗãĒé°å˛æ°ãæžãŖãĻããã垎ããĢįããããã§ããĻããŠããč
æãããããĒįŦįšãŽåããéŧģãįĒãã
ãåã¯č¨æļãæĸãã¤ã¤å¤§æĨãã§æĨč¨å¸ŗãæ˛ãŖããããŽåãããããĻãããŽå°ãŖãåéåŊĸã
ããããŗãŽæéˇčĻŗå¯č¨é˛ãäŊãéã螿ãĢåããį°åĸäŊãã¨č˛ãĻæšãŽäģãĢãį¨ŽéĄãįšæ§ãčĒŋãšããããŽä¸ãĢã¯ãčĒįąį įŠļãĢä¸åãã¨ãããåąéēãĒį¨ŽéĄãåå¨ããã
ãåšģčĻäŊį¨ãŽãããããŗã ãæčãæˇˇæŋããįžåŽã¨ã¯į°ãĒãå æ¯ãčĻããįŽįŠãåãæ°ãĒãŠãŽåŊąéŋãåãŧãã
ãčļŗå ãŽå°įŗãæžããį´Ģč˛ãŽåãĢããēãã¤ããĻããã°ããæ§åãčĻããåį¨Žåã¯æģ˛ãã§čĒããĒããĒãŖãĻããããčĻåããæšæŗã ãã¯äŊã¨ãčĒãŋåãããããēãéãå¤č˛ããã°įĸēåŽã ã
ããããã¨éãŋãåĸããĻããã
ãåã¯ãįŧįąæ˛ŧãã¸čēĢãæããį´åãĢãæčĒæ¸ãäšžããčã¨å°įŗã§é ãããããã¸čŗããããåãäžãã°åéããéããéæŽĩãŽéä¸ãĢããããŽãããŗãčĒįããĻããã¨ãããīŧ
ãéæŽĩãéããå ã§čĻãį ŽãæģžãįŧįąãŽæšãčãä¸ããįãŽį˛ãčãåēããããĒįąæ°ãæ˛¸ã ã¨įããéŗããããĢãįĄĢéģãŽčãã
ããããå ¨é¨ãããããŗãŽåšģčĻäŊį¨ãĢããŖãĻããããããåšģã ãŖããŽã§ã¯ãĒããīŧããããĻãããŽčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽį°æ§ãĒå§ŋãããããåãŽæˇˇäšąããæčãäŊãåēããåšģčĻã ãŖãã¨ãããīŧ
ããããįˇã¯įĸēããĢåŽå¨ãããåãæšããåŧãä¸ããæ¸Šããå˛Šį¤ãŽä¸ãĢéãã ãŽã¯į´ãããĒãäēåŽã ãčąčåãįŊŽãããŽããããŧããčąãããĻããããŽã¯âĻâĻãžã ããĄããŖã¨ããģããŽå°ãã ãäŋĄãéŖãæ°ãããĻãããããŠãã
ãããŽå¤æã¯å°ãåžãĢåãã¨ããĻããįŧįąæ˛ŧããŽå æ¯ã¯ããŠãã ããīŧ
ãæčãæŦĄã ãĢéŖčēããĻãããåŖįģãĢåģãžãããįĨãŽå¤æŗããŽäŧæŋã¨æ´å˛ææãŽč¨čŋ°ãæ´ãĢã¯ãåãåŽéãĢäŊé¨ããåšģčĻã
ãčĻãč ãŽéĄæãį˛žįĨįļæ ãĢåŧåŋããĻãå ¨ãį°ãĒãå§ŋãæ ãåēããéįžåŽįãĒäŧæŋãæŽããããĢčŗãŖãåå ã¯ããããŗãĢããåšģčĻäŊį¨ãã
ãčå°ã¯åå¨ããããããĻãããã¯åãŽåŋãŽå ãéĄãŽãããĢæ ãåēã䏿č°ãĒå ´æã ãŖãã
ãčįãĢå ããĒéããčĻããĒãããåã¯æ§æ°ãĒå ãæēĸããæšãčĻæ¸Ąããã
ãããã¯ãįĨãŽå¤æŗãã§ããã¨åæãĢããįŧįąæ˛ŧãã§ãããŖããŽã ã
ãéåģã¨įžå¨ãįžåŽã¨åšģčĻããããĻãįã¨æģãããšãĻããããŽå ´æã§æēļãåããããŽåããĄãããįåŽãŽįéãĢãåã¯äģãããããĻįĢãŖãĻãããŽããįĨããĒãã
6
ãæåã¨čåĨŽãč¸ãŽå ã§įąãæ¸ĻãåˇģããããŽéĢéŗ´ããäģããčǰãã¨åããĄåãããããããĒčĄåãĢįĒãåããããčļŗå ãĢæ°ãé ããã¨ãåŋããĻãåã¯æŗĨæŋãŋãæ¨ĒåããããĢé§ããã
ãįŽæãå ã¯ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽå¯å ´æã ã
ãããããå˛Šį¤ãŽä¸ãĢčžŋãįããæ°į ãč˛Ēã厍äŊãįŽãĢããįŦéãįąįã¯æĨéãĢåˇããĻããŖãã
ããĒãããããĒãĢãæ¯ãåãããĻãããŽã ããīŧãčŦãč§ŖãæãããĻãããããčããããĻčǰãåãļīŧãããŽéĢæãįč§ŖããĻãããäēēįŠã¯åå¨ãããŽã ãããīŧããããžã§ãĢå¤ąæããåæ°ãčĻããĻã¯ããĒããããã ã
ãå¯čģĸããŖãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯ããžãã§æ¯č˛ãŽä¸é¨ãĢãĒãŖãããŽãããĢåããĒãã
ãåãĢã¯éŠãã¨æåãããããįēčĻã§ãã᏿ãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯čåŗãæšãããĒãįĄé§įĨčã§ãããã¨ãããããããäŧæ¯ãŽéĒéãããĻãžã§ãčãããäēæã§ã¯ãĒããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãįŽãčŧãããĻ芹ãĢčãå ĨãįˇãŽå§ŋãæŗåã§ããĒããæ°ãŽãĒãåŖ°ãčŋãããããįĄį ãåĻ¨åŽŗãããč šįããĢįĄčĻãããããæ˛éģãããžãžåˇããčĻįˇãčŋãå§ŋãĒã厚æãĢæŗåã§ããã
ãį¸æãŽæĸįĨæ å ąã¨ã¯æ°ãĨãããåžææ°ãĢčĒãåšŧå ã¸åãããããĒæ¸ŠåēĻæãŽãĒãįŽã§âĻâĻã
ããããããããŽįˇã¯åšģčĻãĢæ°ãĨããĻããį´ æ¯ããčĻããĻã¯ããĒããŖããīŧãåãŽįļæ ãææĄããä¸ã§ãåčĒčēĢãĢæ°ãĨããããã¨čŠĻãŋãĻããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããīŧ
ãåŖ°ããããĻãããŽããčąčåãæããĻå¯čļãããææĄãããŽããäēãįĨãŖãĻããããã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãéããĒæ¸ĻãŽãããĢįåŋĩã¯åēããŖãĻããã
ãã§ãããã¨ãĒãåãčŗĒããĻãããšãĻãčãåēããããã ããŠãäģäēēãĢæ¯ãåãããå´ãŽæ°æãĄãčããã°ãčĩˇãããŽã¯æ°ãåŧããããããĒãããããĻåž ã¤ãŽãéįã ããã
ãåã¯åããĢč °ãä¸ãããéããĢæ¯ãæ´ããã
ãčļŗå ãŽå°įŗãčģĸããčŊãĄããããŽéŗãĢåãããããŽãããĢãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽįŧãããŖããã¨æãĄä¸ããããã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯čĻįˇã ããåã¸åãããããŽįĨįãĢčĒčēĢãŽå§ŋãæããããįŦéãåĻãĒįˇåŧĩãĢå ãžããã
ãčĩˇããâĻâĻãīŧã
ãä¸éåį̝ãĒč¨čãåŖãã¤ããĻåēãã
ãâĻâĻããã
ãåž ãŖãĻããå´ã¨ããĻã¯éˇãæããããæ˛éģãŽåžãĢãåãįĄį˛žãĒįˇã¯įļããã
ãčēĢãæ¨ĒããããåŖ°ããĢčŗãæžãžããĻåą ãŖãããåãäŊãčĻäģããäŊãįĨããâĻâĻã
ãæˇĄã ã¨ããåŖ°č˛ã¨įĄčĄ¨æ ããã¯ãč¨čãŽäģãĢæŠåĢãŽč¯ãæĒããããčĒãŋåããĒãã
ãããã
ãįŖčĻå¯žčąĄã¨ãããĻããããã ããããĒčēĢãŽä¸ãåããĻįŖčĻč ã䏿°åŗããã°č¯ããŽããčĒčēĢãĢæåŋãåããããĻãããã¨ãåãšã°č¯ããŽããåãĢã¯åãããĒããĒãŖãĻããã
ãããŖããããåãã§å¤§ããĒįæããåãŽé Ŧã¸äŧ¸ã°ãããã䏿šãŽä¸åŽãčŗãéãããå ããĢčēĢãåãããĻéŋãããį¤ŧãæŦ ã寞åŋãããã°ãį¸æãŽæŠåĢãæããĻããžããããããĒãã
ãã§ããäŊãŽæ šæ ããĒã芹ã ãčĒããšããčŋˇããĒããčĻįˇã᏿ãŽéĄãĢčŊã¨ããĻãåã¯åŖãéãã
ãåŋé ã¯ä¸čĻã ã
ãéŽããããĢįˇã¯č¨čãįēãããããŽãžãžčŠčãã¤ããĻčēĢãčĩˇããã¨ãčĻįˇãŽéĢããéčģĸããã
ãå ļãŽčãŽįŊãã¯į ã§ã¯ãĒããææãããŦã
ãåãæĸį´ĸã¨čå¯ãĢæčãæŗ¨ããã¨ã§ãé ãŽé ã¸æŧãããŖãĻããä¸åŽãįˇã¯æŖįĸēãĢæŦãä¸ãããåãŗäŧ¸ã°ãããæãé Ŧã¨éĢĒãĢč§ĻãããããŽæ¸ŠããĒæč§Ļãåã¯éããĢåãå Ĩããã
ãæ˛ģããĻãããŦã
ãããã ãæŖã ãĢįĄčļįĄčŦãããŖãĻãŋãã大įˇãããŠããįĄåŋĩãããĒéŋãã§åãã
ãããŖã¨åéãã ãããããä¸įããŽå§ŋã§įããã°ãĒããĒããã¨ãĢčŊčããšãã¯ãããįŦããããããĒæ°ãĢãĒãŖããåã¯åŖå ãŽåŧãŋãé ããããĢåãåãã
ãããŽæãŽč¨æļãåŧãŗčĻãžããããčĩ¤éĢĒãåŧããåãŽæãåŖãĢãļã¤ããŖãčä¸ãŽéŗãč˛Ŧããã§ããĒãčĻã¤ãčŋãįŗã
ãé ŦãæĢã§ãĻãã大ããĒæãåãŽčŗãĢč§ĻãããčŗãŽį¸ããĒããæå ããå ãŽå°ãŖãåŊĸãæĸãåŊãĻããããããŖãããĢãčēĢåãããããĢãĒããŽãææ ĸããã
ãčŗãĒããĻčĻĒããéæã§ããĒã᏿ãĢã¯č§ĻãããĒãããŠãããã§ãĒãĸã¤ãŗããĒīŧã
ããããĒãŽã¯é常čã ãããæããĒããããéĢĒãæĸŗããããĢæģãæå ãããģããŽå°ãã ãč ããč§ŖããĻãããæ°ãããã
ãčĻįˇãäē¤ããã ãã§äēããŽéãĢæ˛éģãæēãĄãã
ãäŊæ ŧåˇŽããããč¨čãŽé¸ãŗæšããåãæšããäŊããããäŧŧãĻãäŧŧã¤ããĒããããã§ããįŽåãŽįˇãŽčĻįˇã¯ãåãŽč¨čãåž ãŖãĻãããããĢčĻããã
ãâĻâĻåãã
ãä¸åēĻãč¨čãæĸãããå°ãã ãæ¯ãæ´ããĻãããåã¯åãåēããã
ãåãŖãĻãååã¯ããããŽīŧã
ãåããĢ寞ããįˇã¯å°ãã ãéĻãåžããããžãã§čŗĒåãŽæåŗããŽããŽãéãŖãĻãããããĢãä¸éŖãŽäģčãĢã¯ããŠãã¨ãĒãčĻčĻãããããããĒæ°ããããåããŽįããįĨãåããĢäŧŧãĻãããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãåã¯æããŦã
ãããŽčŋįã¯åãŽäēæŗéãã ãŖãã
ãįããį´ ãŖæ°ãĒãčŋããããããĒ芹éĄã§ããįŽįãéãããžã§ã¯įĩããããĒããäģäģĨä¸ãŽåĨŊæŠããæŦĄãč¨ĒããããįĨããĒããŽã ããããããããæŦéĄã ã
ãâĻâĻåŋ čĻãīŧã
ãããã¯čŋįã¨ãããããčļŗå ãĢčģĸããįŗãéįĢ¯ã¸æžãæããããĻãããããĒæčĻã ãŖããåããå˛¸ã¸æ¸ĄããããŽčļŗå ´ã¨ããĻãįŽåãĢįŗãä¸ĻãšãããĻãããããĒæ°é ã ãč¨čãåŖ°č˛ããã¯å¤åĨããĨããããį ŠããããĢčĻããĻããĻãããžã æįĩļãããĻã¯ããĒãã
ãå°ãã ãčįãäŧ¸ã°ããæšããĻåãį´ãã
ãåŧãŗåãããåŋ
čĻããåãå°ããäŊãĻåŧãšã°ããīŧã
ãåĨŊããĒãããĢåŧãšã
ããģãŧåŗįã ãŖããæŗåŽå ãŽäŧ芹ã¨ããĻãäēã፿ãããĻããããã ãä¸ååš˛æ¸ããĒãã¨ããææčĄ¨į¤ēãåŧã°ãããã¨ãĢæåŗãæããĻãããããĒãããããĒé°å˛æ°ã ã
ãįĄé įãĒã¨ãããããã¨ã¯įč§ŖããĻããããæåž ãŽå¤§ãããĢæ¯äžããĻãčŊčã¸å¤ããŖãĻããéåēĻãéãããããé ããšãåãįšãã
ãããŽéããįˇãŽčĻįˇã¯åã¸åãããįļããĻããäēåŽãĢæ°ãĨãããéĸåŋäēã¨įĄéĸåŋäēã¨ãããããĒåēåĨãããĻãããŽã ã
ãåãŽãã¨ã¯ãåĨŊããĢåŧãã§ãããĻæ§ããĒãã
ãįˇã¯įŦãããããĢčĻã¤ãã垎ããĒæ˛éģãæãã åžã§åŖãéãã
ãâĻâĻãˇãīŧã
ãããããåã¯åŗæããčŋãããä¸åŽã¨åžæãæŧãå¯ãããŽãæãã¤ã¤ãåŧå¸ãæ´ããæ¯ããããĻ大ããæ¯ãåãåēããåãåãŋãåŖå ãĢæãŽéĸį¯ãæŧãåŊãĻãĒãããčĻįˇãæŗŗããčããåˇĄãããã
ãåŧãŗæããŽãč¯ããåŽį´ããããŽã¯ãããã ããĒããã§ããåŊšå˛ãåŽįžŠãæŧãäģãããããĒååãã¤ããĻãč˛ŦäģģãĢå§ãæŊ°ããããŽã¯åĢã ã
ãé ãæŠãžããĒããåã¯įˇãŽéĄãčĻä¸ããã
ãâĻâĻã¨ãˇãĨã
ãčĻãĻåãããģãŠæįĸēãĒååŋã¯ãĒããŖããåĻåŽã§ãč¯åŽã§ããĒãįĄčĄ¨æ ã ã
ãã ããŠãåŖ°ãĢåēããĻåãåŧãļ訹å¯ãåžãããããåãŽåéãã ã¨ããĻãåéĄã¯ãĒãã
ãããããå
ãäŊãé¸ãļãã¯æŦäēēæŦĄįŦŦãįĨããéĄããåĒããĢå¤ãããĒããįšåĨãĒæåŗãĒããĻãĒãæšãæ°æĨŊã§ããã
ãâ
ãæšŋãæ°ã帯ãŗãįŊãããĒåããčãæĢã§ãįŠēæ°ä¸ãŽéãæŋãį˛ãæ°ãĢäŧŧãããŽãé ãã¸éãã§čĄãã
ããŠããã§éĢãŽéŗãåŋå°ããéŋããåã¯įŧãä¸ãããæ°æĩãĢæēãčĩˇããããããŽãããĢã迍ãįŽčĻãå§ãããæšįãŽæã ã
ã
ãâ
ãåã¯įãåģļãŗãã
ãããŽæĨãĢįĩããã¯ãã ãŖãåŊããäģãããããĻįããĻããã
ãæēēããããĻããåãåŧãä¸ãããŽã¯ã¨ãˇãĨã ã
ãæ
ããæãããããŽã§ããĒããã°ãããŽåžãĢäŊããčĻæąããããã¨ããĒããŖãã
ãéŖ˛æ°´ãéŖæãŽčŠąéĄãæ¯ãã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åãĢå°åēæšãŽæ°´ãå§ããæåŽãå¯čļããĻãããæ°´ãæåŽããå§ããããããžãžéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ã
ãčēĢæããč˛Ŧãããæžãä¸ããįįąãčĒããĒãã
ãįŊ°ããĒããã°ãčĩĻãããĒããčããã°ãããŽæĨã
ãéããĻããã
ããããĒãããĒãåŠããīŧ
ããĒããããŽįŦéãĢæãäŧ¸ã°ããīŧ
ãæ¨æļį¨åēĻãŽč¨čãäē¤ãããæ ¸åŋãĢã¯č§ĻãããéŖäēãå
ąãĢããã
ãããŽæéãĢãäŊãŽæåŗãããīŧ
ãæ°ãžãããĒããããããæ¯ãå¯čļããĻæŦ˛ããã
ãįĄįēãĢįããããĻãããã¨ãčĻįã§äģæšãĒããŽãĢãåã¯ãžã åŧå¸ãįļããĻããã
ãäŊãæąããããĒãčĻããŋã
ãįããįįąãčĻã¤ãããããåŊšå˛ãä¸ããããĒããžãžããã įãããįļããã
ãäģĨåã¨äŊãå¤ãããĒãã
ããããæãã¨č¨ããã ãããīŧ
ã
ãâ
ãčŦč§ŖããŽčåĨŽãåˇããã¨ãæŦĄãŽčå¯äēæĄãæąãå§ããåãŽčŗã¯ãéåģãŽå¤ąæãä¸åŽã°ãããæ°ãĢãããããĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ãæšéĸãŽæēãããįēããæéã¯ãåĸå åžåã ããã¤ãžã§ãå˛Šį¤ãŽä¸ãĢå¯ããšãŖããžãžã§ã¯ããããĒãã
ãčēĢäŊãčĩˇããã¨ã大ããĒå˛ŠãĢč °ãä¸ãããĻæ°´éĸãčĻã¤ããčä¸ãããŖããæšįãŽä¸é¨ã§ããããŽãããĢæēļãčžŧãã§ãããčŋãĨããĻã垎åã ãĢããĒããŖãã
ããã¯ããã
ãå°ããåŖ°ãããããããã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯č¨čãŽäģŖãããĢčĻįˇãčŋããĻããã
ãéŖŊãããããæ˛ãããããäģããåŋãŽåŖ°ãã¨ãããĢčŗãåžããĻãããŽã ãããããŖã¨åŖæ°ãŽå°ãĒãã¯ããããåå ã ã
ãããŽæ°´ãéŖ˛ããã¨æãīŧã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãč¨ãããĢæšã¸ã¨æãäŧ¸ã°ããã大ããĒæãæ°´éĸãĢč§Ļããã¨ãčéãå ã垎ããĢæēããã
ãæŦãŖãæ°´ãåˇŽãåēãããååŋãĢå°ãŖãã
ãæčŋãĒæãã大ãããŽčã䏿ååããã¯ãĢã¯ãĢã¨ä¸¸ããĻåŗå¸ãŽãĢãããäŊããčãŽãĢããã§æ°´éĸããæ°´ãæŦãä¸ããã
ãį°čããĒããã¨ãįŽã§čĻããįįŠãæˇˇããčžŧãã§ããĒããã¨ãįĸēãããåŖãĢåĢãã§åŗãčĻãããŠãããįåąããčĨåš˛įãã
ããĄããŖã¨åŽå
¨įĸēčĒãŽãããĢčĻįˇãéãŖãĻãããå°ãã ãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã§ãŋããčēĢäŊãŽåĨĨã¸æãŋæ¸ĄããããĒ䏿č°ãĒæčĻã ãŖãã
ã
ã
ãããããäēæŋãåžãéŖãĢč
°ãä¸ããããåã¯å°ããĒå
ãŋãåãåēããčãĢįŊŽãã
ãããã¯ãåãĢč˛ãŖãã¯ã......ãĒãŽã ããŠīŧã
ãåĻšãäŊãŖãĻãããæē帯äŋåéŖã ãåãŽåĨŊįŠã§ããããå°ä¸ã§ã¯å¸å°ãĒæ¤įŠãŽį¨ŽãäŊŋãŖãčąčåãįŽãŽåãĢããŠã¤ãããĻčĻããããååŋã¯ãĒãã
ãįŠēč šãčĨ˛ãã°éŖäēēããããĒãã¨ããäēēįãéãŖãčēĢã§ã¯ã䞥å¤ãįč§Ŗã§ããĒããŽã ããã
ãä¸įˇãĢéŖãšãĒãīŧã
ãå ãŋãéãã¨ãããããįŧããčąãŽéĻã°ããéĻããåēãããéĻ´æãŋãŽåããĢå°ãæ°ãč¯ãããåã¨ã垎åã ãĢããĒãéŖäēēã
ããæ§ããĒããĢæåãŽä¸į˛ãčĒåãŽåŖãĢå Ĩããããããåãŋį ããĒããéŖäēēãŽå¤§ããĒæãåŧãå¯ããããŽæãŽåšŗãĢãä¸į˛ãäšããã
ãåŖãĢåēããį´ æ´ãĒįãŋãåãŋᎠãã¤ã¤ãååŋãããããŖããåããčąčåãĢãããŖããã¨čĻįˇãį§ģããå ãģãŠåãããŖããããĢåããå ããčąčåãåŖã¸éãã ã
ã襨æ ãĢå¤åã¯ãĒããæ§åãčĻãĻããã¨ãčãŽä¸ã§ãããčģĸãããããĒäģčãĢįļããĻéĄãåããååŧéŗãčãããã
ãæãčŋãã°ãåŖãĢåããĒãã¨å¤æããéį̝ãĢåãåēããããĒįˇã ããããčæ
Žããã°ãå
ããĒããã叿ãæãĻãã
ãåãããŽãåãåããåãŗåããåšŗåĄãĒéĸäŋãį¯ããå¯čŊæ§ããããŽããįĨããĒãã
ã
ã
ãéããĒįŠēæŗãĢčļŗãæēãããåã¯čãŽé°ã§č˛ãĨãč¨ããæåŽãįēããĻéãããã
ãį¨ŽéĄãčąå¯ã ããčĻŗčŗããã ãã§ãéĸįŊãããéŖį¨ã¨ããĻã¯ããŠãã ãããīŧ
ãæį´ĸãŽįŽããéãããããã˛ãŖããã¨éããĢããéãããĢããĻããéŖ˛æ°´ã¨ããĻåéĄãŽãĒãæ°´å ´ã¨éŖæãŽįĸēäŋãåŋ čĻãĢãĒãã
ããããĒãã¨ãããäģã¯čŠąéĄãåŋ čĻã ãåšŗåãĒ芹éĄãããã
ãé ãæŠãžããĻããã¨ãåãŽæãĢäŊããč§ĻãããįãéĻããæžã¤čĩ¤ãåŽã ãŖããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ããããåãŽæãŽåšŗãĢãããŖã¨įŊŽããã
ãæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻå¨å˛ãčĻæ¸ĄãããčŋããĢåãį¨ŽéĄãŽåŽã¯čĻåŊãããĒãããŠãã§čĻã¤ããĻããã¤įĸēäŋãããŽããéįļã¨ããĒããžãžåãį´ãã
ãčįŽãæå ã§ã˛ã¨æĢã§ããĻåĨãã¨ãæˇĄįŊč˛ãŽåéæãĒæčãčĻãããããŖããčããĻãŋããéããĒãåãŽåĨŊãŋãĢčŋãåĒããįãã ãčã§æŊ°ããéį̝ãĢãããŖãˇããŽææąãåēããŖãã
ãæ°éŽŽãĒæåŽã¯å¸å°ãĒãããå¸å ´ãĢåēåãæ°ã¯æĨĩå ããä¸åą¤åŽļåēãŽéŖåãĢä¸ãããŽã¯įšåĨãĒæĨãŽãŋãčĻãæŠäŧã¯åŋčĢãéŖãšãæŠäŧãæģ å¤ãĢãĒããŽã ãããæåã¯ã˛ã¨ããã ãŖãã
ããŠãã§čĻã¤ãããŽã ããīŧãéŖį¨ãĢåããæ¤įŠãŽįĨčããããĒãããããžã§ã¯éįįįŠãŽãããĢæåŽãéãéŖæãĢããĻãéããĢæŽãããĻãããŽã ãããīŧ
ãåãéĄãä¸ããå ã§ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãč¨ãããåãį¨ŽéĄãŽåŽãįŽãåĨããĒãã§åŖã¸éãã ãååŧãŽéŗã¯ããĒããŖãã
ãåãžããĢéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ãŽã ãããīŧ
ãįžåŗããããŽãåŗãã襨æ ã¯čĻŗå¯ã§ããĒããŖãããåãŽčĻįˇãĢæ°äģããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãæåžãŽä¸ã¤ãå¯čļããĻããã
ãããã¯įæ§ãã常čäēēã¨ããĻã᏿ãŽåĨŊæãįĄįĸãĢããĒãããæå¤§éãĢæŗ¨æãã¤ã¤é æ ŽããĒããã°ããããĒäŊŋåŊæããč¨čãæĸãããããå˛įŦãããŽãããĢãåæŗãããæļã§åŖå ãæēããããĻããŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éģįˇč˛ãŽį´°éˇãæåŽãŽåããå ãã§ãããããŽäģãĢã¯ã大ããĒčãå¨ãŽäģŖãããĢããĻéããããããããčĩ¤éģãå°į˛ãŽæ¨ãŽåŽã大ãããŽéãčĩ¤ãåŽãéãåŽãããŖãã
ãå¤čĻãŽéæ§åŗã¨ã¯čŖč
šãĢãčéŖä¸ģįžŠã ãŖãããããŽã ãããīŧ
ã
ã
ãããŖã¨įĨããããã§ããæįĩļããããŽãæããĻč¨čãåēãĻããĒãã芹ããããĻãããĻåŖãŽä¸ã§ãĸã´ãĸã´ããĻããããä¸åŋĢãĢæãã¯ãã ããããĒãããã¯éģãŖãĻããæšãč¯ããĢæąēãžãŖãĻããã
ãčąčåã¨æåŽãåãåãŖããäģã¯ãããã ããŽéĸäŋããããĒčˇéĸæã ã
ãååãåãããĒãæåŽãŽäēã¤įŽãéŖãšįĩããåã¯ã严č ãčēĢäŊãŽåãĢįĒãåēããĻããããĄãĒãäŧ¸ãŗããããéããĢæˇąãæãŽįŠēæ°ãå¸ãčžŧãã ã
7
ãä¸åą¤čĄãæŠãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĄ¨æ
ãčļŗåããĢå¤åã¯ãĒããååēčĄãŽčĻå¯ãĢæēčļŗãããŽã ãããããããĻãäē翎ˇãŋã¯åšŗæ°ãĒãŽã ãããã
ãåã¯ãããããéįã ãããŽäē翎ˇãŋã§å¨å˛ãĢæ°ãé ãįļãããŽãããåŋãŽåŖ°ããčããįļãããŽãã
ãããŗã財ãŖãĻ帰ãããīŧã
ãčĒæ¸äŧ补å°ãŽåžãã æãæŧãéããã¨ãå¤ãŽįŠēæ°ãæĩãčžŧãã§ããã
ãåã¨į´ãŽåããæˇˇããŖãįŠēéããį´°ãé莝ãæããå ãĢįŽãåãããĻããåŖããčĻããĒããæãŽåã§åļæĸãããåã¯éģãŖãĻå ãč˛ããã¨ãĢããã
ãé莝åŖãåēãå ´æã§ã¨ãˇãĨãįĢãĄæĸãžããããŖã¨čĻãčĻãã¨ãå¤į´åēãŽåãĢæĻčŖ ããåļæå§ŋãŽįˇãä¸äēēãč įĩãŋãããĻįĢãŖãĻããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽå¤čĻã¯įŽįĢãĄããããããčĄãæŠãã°äēēįŽãåŧããčĻãĻããčǰããæ å ąãæĩããåąéēã¨å¤æããã°ãåŊãŽæ˛ģåŽįļæãäģģãããĻããæĻčŖ įĩįšãåããŽã¯åŋ įļã
ããããžã§ã¯åã§ãįč§Ŗã§ãããããããä¸äēēã§įžããįįąãĢã¯čĻåŊãã¤ããĒããã
ãäēããĢåããããã éãæ˛éģãæĩããã
ãä¸äēēãīŧããĩããĢã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãåŖãéããããĩãŠãã¨ååãåŖãĢãããããĢčããããããããĒã¯ãã¯ãĒãã¨æãŖãĻãčãæĩããã¨ãĢãããã
ãåããåãįˇã¯įéãŽãˇã¯ãæˇąããã
ããåãčĄã§äŊãäģåēãããčĻåŽããĢæĨãã
ãããŽåŖ°ã¯äŊããææ ãæããĻããããã§ãæããããĒãäŊããããåēãĻãããä¸ã¤ééãã°ãäšąéé¨ããĢįēåąããããĒãé°å˛æ°ã ã
ãååēčĄãŽčĻå¯ã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯įããæŖį´ãĢįããã
ããģããŽä¸įŦã ãįŽãéĸããæ°ãããããŠãåãäŋč¨ŧããĻããããååŊããŽãĒãč¨čã ã
ãåãŗãæ˛éģãįļããã Â
ãäēãæ¸ããžã§čĒæ¸äŧ补å°ãŽé¨åąãĢåŧãčŋããĻãįŦãéããĢæŦãčĒãŋãããĒãŖãĻãããæ˛éģãŽå§åããæ´åãčĻæã ã Â
ãåēå ãĢä¸Ļãļį´æãŽį̝ãå°ãããããåãčĒãŖãĻãããéŗãįĢãĻãĒããããĢį§ģåããã°ãæ°ãĨããããĢæ¸ããŽã§ã¯ãĒããã
ãâĻâĻåžããĢä¸äēēãé ããĻããã¤ãããīŧã Â
ãčļŗéŗãĢã¯æ°ãé ãŖãã¯ãã ããŠãåã¯čįãæ¯ããããã垎ããĒčĄŖæĻããčãã§æ°ãĨããããŽãããããĒãã
ãčŋˇåãīŧããĒããäŋēãé ããã
ãããããčŋˇæãĒææĄã ãįžįļãčĒŦæãããŽãéĸåãĒä¸ãčēĢå ãŽč¨ŧæãĢæåããĻããåŽļãĢ帰ãããĻã¯å°ãã
ãčĄãã帰ããåŊäēēãŽčĒįąã ã
ãããã ãč¨ãæŽããĻãã¨ãˇãĨã¯é莝åŖãéĸããĻčĄããã¨ããã
ãé¨åąãĢåŧãčŋããĻčēĢãé ããšãããå§ŋãčĻããããŽãčĻæããĻã¤ããĻčĄããšããčŋˇãŖããã ããŠãčŋŊããĒããã°ã¨ãˇãĨã¯æģãŖãĻæĨãĒãæ°ãããĻãĒããĒãã
ãå¤åĨãŽããŧããæˇąãčĸĢããã¨ãˇãĨãŽåŊąãĢé ãããããĢããĻãæ˛ģåŽįļæãŽįˇã¨å¤į´åēãŽéãéãéããã
ãæ˛ģåŽįļæãŽįˇã¯éģãčžŧãŋãčŋŊãŖãĻãæĨãĒããŖãã
ããã¨ãĢã
ãé ä¸ããéãŖãĻããåŖ°ãčãã¤ããéĄãä¸ããããããĢã¨ãˇãĨãŽæãããŖããåã¯äŊãč¨ãããĢããããæ´ãã ã
ãäģæ´ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããããæãåēãããŽãããããĒæåĨãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãŋãĒããã
â
ãããäģĨä¸ã¯åŧãŗæĸãããããã¨ããĒããããŗã財ãŖãĻãįĨãŽå¤æŗãã¸æģãŖãã Â
ãæšãåãĢããĻč
°ãä¸ãããæ°´åēããæš§ãä¸ããéįŊãå
ãįēããã
ã
ã
ããžã ããŗãéŖãšãæ°ãĢã¯ãĒããĒããŖããįĄŦãããŗãé¸ãã ãããäŊæĨãã¯æã¤ã¯ãã ãæ°ãåããæãĢãå°ããã¤éŖãšãã°č¯ãã
ãéãã䏿ãŽį´ãåãåēããåã¯čãäēãĢčŊãŖãã
ãčĒæ¸äŧãčĄãããĻããĒããĒããä¸ģåŦč
ãæĸããŽã¯å°éŖã ãããŖã¨åå č
ãŽčǰãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæŖäŊãįĨããĒãããŠãŽåą¤ãĢåąããĻãããŽããååãããã
ãčĒæ¸äŧ补å°ã§čĻã¤ããį´ãæĄãᎠããį¨ãŋã¤ããĻããæēãæ¯ãæŧãåēãã ãã ã
ãæããå ´æã§čĻãã°ãįĄč˛ãŽæãŋãĢäŧŧãããŽãéããĻãããéĄãĢčŋãĨããĻããããŗčļãŽåãäģĨå¤ã¯å¤åĨã§ãããäŊãŽæãŋãã¯ä¸æã ã
ã
ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãč¨ããĒãããįĨãåãã ãŖããŽã ãããããããĒãããã¤ããŠããĒįĩ᎝ã§ãååãåŧãļãããĒéæãĢãĒãŖããŽã ããã Â
ãåäēēãĢããĻã¯ãåŖåãĒé°å˛æ°ãæŧãããĻãããäēããĢåŧãŗåãäģãããŖãããį´ æ§ãæãĄæãåããããĒéæã§ã¯ãĒãã
ã
ã
ãæģãŖãĻãããĢæ¤įŠãŽé°ã¸æļããĻčĄãŖãã¨ãˇãĨããéŖãĢč
°ãä¸ããã
ãįŠč¨ããããĒčĻįˇã§čĻã¤ããĻããã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãįããĒããįĄč¨ãŽãžãžäŊããŽčãå¯čļããĻãããããŽæŽããčĒåãŽåŖãĢå
ĨãããĸãŊãĸãŊã¨ååŧãããčĩ¤ã῝ãĢæčãįĩĄãžãŖãĻããĒãããįĸēčĒãŽãããĢäģäēēãã¸ãã¸ãčĻåãå¤ãĒã¯ãģãã¤ããĻããžãŖãã
ãäēæ
ããĻãąįããŽæ
æãįĨããĒãããããžãĢį°ĒīŧããããīŧãŽãããĢåēããĻæģãŖãĻæĨããéĢĒčŗĒãŽéããããŖãĻåãĢã¯į¸é ãæŠãŋã ã
ãå¯čļãããčãĢã¯ãã¯ãã¯ããį´°ããæ¯ãįããåãŋᎠããã¨čĻåŗãåŖãĢåēããŖããåŗãããįŦįšãŽéŖæãåžãåŧããč šãŽčļŗããĢã¯ãĒãããŠãå åˇĨããĻããéŖãšããéĄã§ã¯ããã
ãäŊäēãĢãįĄé įãĢčĻããĻãããããéŖæãĢéĸããé¸åĨįŧãĢã¯éŠããããĻã°ãããããã¨ãˇãĨãé¸ãŗåãŖãĻããæ¤įŠã§č šãåŖãããã¨ã¯ããããžã§ä¸åēĻããĒãã
ããã¤ãæšįãčĻåãŖã帰ããĢãåįŠĢįŠãæãŖãĻå°įąå˛ŠãĢæģãŖãĻæĨããčĻæåŋã¨é æ
ŽãããæãĢã¯éŖæŦ˛ä¸æ¯ãããæåĻãį¤ēãããã¨ã¯äŊåēĻãããŖãããŠããĢããĻããã¨ãˇãĨã¯æĸãåēããĻåãŽåãĢįŊŽããĻčĄãã
ã
ã
ãéŖæŦ˛ããĒãæãĒããčǰãĢã§ãããã
ãåĨŊãåĢããããããããéŖãšãĻããã¤ãįĢæ´žãĒ大äēēãĢãĒãã¨æãããč˛ãĻãããæŠãčŋããããĢã
ãåŊãįšããĢã¯éŖãšãĒããã°ãĒããĒããæãããåŊãä¸ããããäŊįã ãéŖãšãããĒããĒããĻã¯ãŦãããéį¨ããã¯ãããĒããä¸ããããæŠãĢã¯å ąããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã
ãâįžŠįãäŊŋåŊæã§ãäŊč¨ãĢčãåãäģããĒããįĩåąãčĻįãŽå¤ã¸čŋŊããããå˛Šé°ãĢé ãããâ
ããããĒæĨãįļãã¨ãéŖãšåããĒããŖãåãåžã
ãĢįŠãŋä¸ããŖãĻãããããŽä¸ã§ãæåãĢé ããčãæ¨ãŽåŽãčããĻãããŽãčĻãããããĻãããŽæĨč¨å¸ŗãŽãããĢč
æããĻããã ãããčããæžã¤ãããĢãĒãã°é ãåããĒãã
ãäģãããŠããã§čǰããéŖĸããĻããããåã¯æĩãžããĻãããã ãæčŦããĻéŖãšãã
ãįš°ãčŋãčĻĒããčããããĻããč¨čããčŗéŗ´ããŽãããĢéŋãã
ã
ã
ãããŗãĢæãã°ãããŽããĒīŧãããŽčãã¨åŊĸã¯čĻããĻãããã
ãåã¯ããŗãååãĄããŖãĻã¨ãˇãĨãĢæ¸ĄããããããåãåãŖãåžããããŖãĄã¸čĻįˇãå¯čļãããžãžãčããĸãˇãŖãĸãˇãŖã¨åãŋįļããĻããã
ãæ°ãĨããĒãããĒãããĻä¸åŖé ŦåŧĩããæšéĸãĢčĻįˇãæãããããŽčã¯ãåãã§éŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã åžãĢčžããåēãããããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åšŗæ°ãĒãŽãīŧãįåãéããŖããã襨æ ãĢå¤åã¯ãĒããããããįŧãįĢãĻããŗã串įŧããŽåããĢéŖæŦ˛ãåēæŋãããį´ æ¯ããčĻããĒããŖãããããč¸ãžããã¨ãå čĻãåŗčĻãåã¨ã¯éããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãčĻŗå¯ã¨čå¯ãįš°ãåēããéãĢããčžãã¯åŧˇãžãŖãĻãããããĒããĒã¨åãå å´ããįŧããããããĒįãŋãæããĻãčĻæåŋããŠããã§įŊŽãåŋããĻããčĒåãĢåĢæ°ããããĻããã
ãéãįŊŽãããžãžįĢãĄä¸ãããåã¯æšãŽį¸ã¸čĩ°ãŖãã
ãããŽéãįãŖãĻãããŽãããããĒããæ°´ãåŖãĢåĢãã åãŽįŽåã§ä¸æãŽį´ãčããæ°´éĸãĢčŊãĄãã
ãéãĢå
ĨããĻããé鿏ã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊéŖããŦéĄã§æ°´ãæģ´ããããæžãä¸ããåãĢã¤ãčŋãããåãéãããĒãããįįąãåããã ãããæ°æãĄãéãžããžã§å ĒãããåįãŽč˛ãčĻããĒãéĄãããããŖã¨ãã¨æŋĄããį´ã¸čĻįˇãį§ģããã
ãį´éĸãĢčãŖããã¨čĻããĻããæãŋãã鎎æãĢæĩŽãåēãĻãããã°ãã°ãæãæ˛ããŖãįˇã¯å°åŗãŽãããĢãčĻããã
ããããã§å°æã¨æãã¯åŧãŖčžŧãã ãåã¯æ°ããĢæį¤ēãããčŦãč§Ŗãæãããšããį´éĸãįēãåããã˛ãŖããčŋããĻæåãč¨åˇãæĸããã
ã
ã
ãâããæĨãããã¤ããĢåããĻããé ãå ´æãŽä¸ã¤ãããĢããčĻã¤ããåã¯ããããåãããã¨ãĢãããį¨ŽããčŊãåēãĻãããã°ãįŊǿǿã¯čããã
ãčĻåããĢåēãéãįãŖãããčĻãããĻããĒãããã¨ãˇãĨãĒãæ°ãĨãã ããã
ããĒãæãéããĢåããĒã᏿ãåãĢįŊŽããĻãããŽããæŗãæ¯ãä¸ãæãã¨å¤ąæã襨æããĻã寞įãčŦããåžšåēįãĢéãéãåĄããĒããŽãã
ããããčããĻãįč§Ŗã§ããĒãã
âââ
ãįˇã¯å¤æŗãŽįãĢč °ãä¸ãããæčãæĄåŧĩããããč¨å¤§ãĒãåŖ°ããŽæŋæĩããããįŊéãŽéĢĒãŽåĨŗããŽãåŖ°ããæĸãåŊãĻãã
â
ãæš¯ããĢãããĢæŗ¨ãããåŋå°ããéĻčãŽéĻããįĢã¤ããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸã¨åŧã°ããåĨŗãŽãæ°ãĢå Ĩããããã
ãããŖããéĻ´æãã éĻããĢãĩããĢãŽįˇåŧĩãč§ŖããĻãããŽãäŧããŖãĻãããåŊŧã¯æĨåŽĸį¨ãŽæ¤ åãĢč °ãä¸ããã
ãããĢãčĄãŽčĻåãããį˛ãæ§ã
ãčļéŖ˛ãŋäģ˛éãŽéĄããį˛å´ãčĻãĻåãŖãåŊŧåĨŗããéããĒįŦãŋã¨å ąãĢãå´ããŽč¨čããããããĩããĢã¯čŋäēããããåˇŽãåēããããĢãããĢæčãåããåŖãå¯ãããéį̝ãĢãåŊŧãŽãįąãīŧãã¨ããéãæč§Ļãåŧžããã
ãčļã¨čļčåãŽį¨æãæ¸ãŋãæ¤ åãĢč °æãããĒããčŗĒåãæããã
ãããã§ãäŧãããŽīŧã
ããã¤ããŠãã§ãã¨ãčãããĢããå åŋã§åãã¤ã¤ããĩããĢã¯čãããžã¨ãããããĢ䏿¯įŊŽããĻãį°ĄæŊãĢčŋãã
ããããåäžãä¸äēēãéŖããĻããã
ãįŊãéĢĒãŽåīŧã
ããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸãŽæčããä¸įšãĢéä¸ãããããĒéãã帯ãŗãã
ããĩããĢã¯į˛å´ããåããŽčŋįãå
éããĢããĻãæéį¨ŧããŽåŊãĻãæĸããæŋãæš¯æ°ãĢčĻįˇããããäŧčŠąã¸æģãã
ãããŧãã§é ããĻããĻãéĄãéĢĒãčĻãĻããĒããã ããåæãããããã
ãããŽåãå
æ°ããã ãŖãīŧã
ãæŠãå§ŋãčĻãããã¨ãåãåŧã°ããĻããã
ããĢãããŽä¸čēĢããšããŧãŗã§æģãåããåˇãžããã¨įģįããĒããã荿ļãæįš°ãå¯ãããã¨ãããããŽæ§åãåŊŧåĨŗã¯éããĢåž ãŖãã
ããããĻãįĻãããããĒæčãéŋãã
ãéŠåŊãĢčŗĒåãæããĻãããäŊãæãåēãããįĨããã
ãåããããčĻįˇãåŦäŋãŽãããĢæãããããããĢčãããããĩããĢãææĄããã
ãããŽåããŠããããŽīŧã
ããĸã¤ããéŖããĻčĄãŖããåŧˇåŧãĢãŖãĻæ§åã§ã¯ãĒããŖããã
ãããåŖãĢåēããééãĢãäŊãä¸åŗããã¨ããããīŧãã¨ããä¸åŽãéããã
ããããããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸã¯įŠããã§æ¸Šããææ
ãåĢããįˇŠãããĒæčãåˇĄããããŽãŋã ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĄ¨æ
ãĢæãããĒããã¨ãįĸēčĒãããĩããĢãŽåŋãĢããåŽå ĩãåēããŖãã
ãå
ĩčãŽååã¨ã¯äģ˛č¯ãããŖãĻãããŽīŧã
ãä¸čžēã ãã¯ãĒãéŠæ°æ´žã ãŽäŋåŽæ´žã ãŽããŠãŖãĄãčãčŗãįĢãĻãĻãããåããŖããããããĒããæ°ãæãã°æ¨ŠåéäēãŽé¤éŖã ã
ãįŦéĄããįéãĢãˇã¯ãå¯ãŖãĻãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæåãĒ垎įŦãŋãĢäŋããããĩããĢãŽææ ãæĨéãĢåĒãã§ãããŽãæãåããã
ãâĻâĻãŦããåŊãåŽããŽãäŋēãŽäģäēã ãäģããé˛åãåŧˇåããã°ãĒãããŽãĢããåãéˇčã¯ãæãčēĢãŽãåŽããåŊããĻããããŖãããããåĨ´ããéã¯éŖŊãããéŗĨãéŖãšãããįŠãŖãĻæĨããã¤ãžãã財ãåēããŽãããĢä¸åą¤čĄãžã§âĻâĻã
ããĩããĢãŽãåŖ°ããããåŊŧåĨŗã¸ãŽįĩļ寞įãĒäŋĄé ŧãäŧããŖãĻããã
ãå¯ããč¯ããĻåŖãå
ããåēä¸įĢļäēã¨ã¯įĄį¸ãŽå°äŊãĢåą
ãĒãããå¤éŠãŽåŋ
čĻæ§ãåˇéãĢčĒããįŠåĨæ´žã
ãã ããããåŊŧåĨŗãĢãĒã芹ãããæĨåä¸ãŽä¸é芹ã¯į¸čĢæãŽãããĒããŽã ã¨ã
ããĩããĢãåãŗãĢãããæãĄä¸ãããčĒŋåēĻč¯ã渊åēĻãĢãĒãŖãčļã䏿°ãĢéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ããã
ãããĢã¯ãããŽåžãŠãã¸īŧã
ãįŖæģå ąåã ãæ¸éĄã§æåēããã¨ãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽįŧåã§å¤§ããĒæēãæ¯ãåããã
ãæãããĒããã ããĒãããŽãæä¸ãĢéååĻįã§å¤§åŋããã
ãåšŗåãããããĢã
ãæãããĒãåŖ°ããĢã¯ãæãããĒããŗãĢå°ãåĄãäģããããįé
¸ãŖãąãã¸ãŖã ã¸ãŽæåž
ãæģ˛ãããããããĒč´
æ˛ĸã¸åããæčŦã¨įĨããæĩãčžŧãã§ããã
ãå°åēã§ã¯č˛ããĒãæ¤įŠãŽåŽã¯ãéãããč
ãĢãŽãŋ訹ãããå¸å°åã§ãããããã
ãčįĸããĻãããããããįĨéããããĢãå¤ąæãããã ããããĒįļæ ãããåŊã¯âĻâĻã
ããĩããĢãŽæčãã莿ĨæãŽįĻåĨãĢč§ĻããããĻéåãããããŽįŦéãåŊŧãŽč¨æļãããããååãæĩŽããŗä¸ããã
ãæãåēããããã¨ãĢããĸã¤ãã¯åäžãããåŧãã ããŦããããŽååãĢčãčĻãã¯īŧã
ãåããããããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæčãæˇąãæ˛ãã§ããããããĻįããéŋããã
ãâĻâĻäēčĻããč ãįĨãåšģčĻããč ãŽåãããã§ãå ąãĢæŠããã¨ãé¸ãļãŽããæĒããĒãå åã ãã
8
ãčĄãŽå§é¨ãéĢĒã¨čĄŖæãĢæãŋã¤ããĻéĸããĒããéŧģč ãåēæŋããåã¨čããéãããåύããéä¸åãåãã§ããã Â
ããããŠãæ¯æĨéŖ˛ãŋæ°´ã¨ããĻäŊŋãŖãĻããæšãŽæ°´ãæąããŽã¯ãããããĢæãããã Â
ãããã§åã¯å°åēæšãŽå¨å˛ãæŠããĻåããã¨ãĢãããæ°´éĸãĢčãæĩŽããšãæ°´ããŠãããæš§ãåēãããŠãã¸æĩããĻčĄãããæĸãã Â
ãä¸åãããįĩæãæĩãããããŽãããį´ äēēãĢã¯å¤åĨã§ããĒããŖãã Â
ããããĒãã°ã¨įæ´ģæ įšã§ããå°įąå˛ŠããéĸããčĒŋåēĻč¯ãæĩ įŦãæĸããã¨ãĢããã
ãčé°ã¨æ°´ä¸ãĢ夿ĩãŽåŊąããĒããã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽå§ŋãčĻããĒããã¨ãįĸēčĒããĻãããé´ãčąããããŖã¨čļŗãč¸ãŋå Ĩããã
ããģããŽã渊ããã
ãå¤åĨäģĨå¤ãŽčĄŖæãé ãĢčąããæ°´ãĢæ˛ããĻæãŽåšŗã§æŧãæ´ããįšįļãĢæãŋčžŧãã čããåãæ°´ãĢæēļãåēããĻããã
ãæ´ãįĩããããŽã¯ãįå°ãåˇããĒãããæ éãĢįĩããčãŋãŽæãĢåŧãŖæãããæåžãĢå¤åĨã¨ä¸įãæ´ããæčŋãĒįŗãŽä¸ãĢåēããĻåš˛ãã
ãč °ãģãŠãŽæˇąããããå ´æã¸į§ģåããčēĢäŊãããŖã¨æ°´ãĢæ˛ãããčŠãžã§æĩ¸ãããįŽãéãããčēĢäŊãĢæŽãŖãĻããįˇåŧĩããå°ããã¤æ°´ãĢæēļããĻããã
ãæˇĄãéįŊãå ãæžã¤æšéĸãĢãįŊéĢĒãæĩŽããļãčãæ ãčžŧãįŊãéĄãæšãå˛ãæ¤įŠããĄãįšããĒãä¸ä¸éããžãŽæ¯č˛ã
ãéãããŽä¸ã§ããĩã¨éåæããããããŠãããĻãããŽæ¸ æĩãĒįŠēéãĢããããĒå§ŋãŽåããããŽã ããã
ãäŊããããįĨãŽå¤æŗããįæ´ģæ°´åįļãĢæąããŽã¯ãčåãæąãčĄįēã ãįĨã¸ãŽåæļãĢäģãĒããĒããããããæąããåŋéŋãããĒããããŽčēĢãæ°´å翎ąããĢæ˛ãč æããããã¨ãããäŊãããŽåæļã ããã
ãäŋĄåŋæˇąãåš´å¯ãããĄãŽåãæŖããåŖ°ãčŗãĢéŋããæ¤æãŽéĄãčŗčŖãĢæĩŽããļã
ãåžãããããæ¯ãæããããĢãåã¯é ãžã§æŊãčžŧãã ãããããã°æ°´éŗããčãããĒãã
ãæããįĄãããåŽãã§ã¯ãĒãįĨįŊ°ãæããæ°æãĄãããäģããŽįŦéãįããããĻããã¨ããæčĻãåŧˇãæããã
ãæ¯ãæĸããĻæ°´éŗãĢčŗãåžããĻããããããããčĻãããĒãŖãĻããé ãæ°´éĸããéĄãåēãããįŽåãŽå æ¯ãĢå ¨čēĢãåŧˇåŧĩãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨããããåããã§ããĒãčĻä¸ãããĻããã
ãããčĻåããŽæéãĒãŽã ããããããã ã¨ããĻããæšãĢč¸ãŋčžŧãã§ãžã§åãŽæ§åãæĸãįįąã¯äŊã īŧ
ãč
°ãŽå¤åĨãå°ãæ°´ãĢæŋĄããĻããã
ãâĻâĻãã¨īŧã
ãããŖã¨åã¯éˇåą ããéãããĢéããĒãã
ãåãŽå¤åĨãæ´ãããīŧãå°æãįĩĄãåãŖãĻããéĢĒããããžãĢã¯æĢã§æĸŗããĻæ´ãŖããããã
ãããã¨æããåŖ°ãäŊãŖãĻčĒãããããã¨ãˇãĨã¯éģãčžŧãŋãããäģĨä¸ã¯äŊãč¨ããĒããŖãã
ãå¤åĨã¯ããé ããããžããããããã§ãããŽæšã渊ãããããŖã¨ãäŊãčŊãĄããããã¯âĻâĻããŗãĢãããĒīŧã
ãéįŊãå ãčĻã¤ããįĨįč˛ãŽįŗåã¯čĨčãŽč˛ãåŽŋããįã ããæžãã§ããã
ãåŧã°ããåēĻã訹ããããããĢæããĻããžããããå°ãã ãįãžãããããããĒãã¨ãčããĻããčĒåãĢæ°ãĨããããã§ãããžã åŧãļæąēåŋãã¤ããĒãã
ãåã¯åãįļãããæčãåˇĄããå§ããčĒčēĢãŽæčãé¸ãããã¨ãˇãĨãŽčãããããčŗãåĄãããããĢã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽå¤åĨãč§ŖããĻå¤ããå ãģãŠã¨åæ§ãæ°´ãĢæĩ¸ãããč °åããŽäŊæ¸ŠãæŽãŖãĻããã§ãããå¸å°ã¯ãæ¸Šãæ°´ãåĢãã§æ°´éĸãĢåēããã
ãåãŽįĨããĒãįĩãŗįŽã ãŖãã
ããã¤ãĻåãįĩãã éãéčĻã§ä¸æ ŧåĨŊãĒįĩãŗæšã¨ã¯éããã ããŠãã¨ãˇãĨãčĒåã§čžŋãįããããĒåäģģããŽåŖåįĩãŗã§ããĒãã
ãæŠčŊįã§ãããĒãããčĻæ ããŽč¯ããå
ŧãåããæ´įˇ´ãããįĩãŗæšã ãå°éįĨčã¨č¨įˇ´ãĢããŖãĻåžãããæčĄãŽãããĒããŽãæããã
ãč¨ãįĨããĒãįåŋĩãč¸ãĢãå¤åĨãæ°´ä¸ã¸æ˛ããã
ãčãæãæ˛ããæ°´ä¸ãĢč °ãčŊã¨ããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãįŠįããããĢæ§åãčĻãĻãããæ°´åēããéįŊãå ãæžã¤æšãŽæ°´éĸããå¸ãŽåããĢåãããĻæēããã
ãåãŽæčãåããããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨãããŽã ãããčĻįˇãčŋããĻããããįåãĢįããĻã¯ãããĒããŖãã
ãå°ããã°čŋããĻãããããįĨããĒãããč¨čãčĻã¤ããããĒããžãžãåã¯åãŗæå
ãŽå¤åĨãĢčĻįˇãæģããã
ãã´ãˇã´ãˇã¨æĻããŽã§ã¯ãĒããå¸ãæēãããĻæąããæĩŽããããį§ģåä¸ãĢäģįããã¨æãããæŗĨãčããįšįļãŽééããåĨããčŊãĄããčĄã§äģįããåã¨įģãããäŊããŽčãããéģãéãŽãããĢæēļãåēããĻããã
ããããčĻãĒããæ´æŋ¯ãŽå大ãĒåšæãåŽæããĻããæãæå ãĢ垎ããĒæĩæãæããããããããĻįå°ãŽįšįļããģã¤ããĻãããããããäŧŧãããŽãããã¤ãčĻã¤ãããæãĢã§ãåŧãŖããããŽã ãããã
ãååãŽčĄæŠãã§æšããĻæ°ãĨããããããŠãããŽå°éčˇãĢæēããäēēäģĨå¤ãŽä¸åि°ã§ã¯ãč§Ļãããã¨ããåļããĒããããĒįå°ã¨æŋãææãäŊŋãããĻãããįŊãŖãŊãæąãã°ãããįŽįĢãĄãéģãŖãŊãæąãã¯įŽãåãããĻãčĻã¤ãéŖãã
ãããŖããã¨æ°´ä¸ã§æãŋč§Ŗãéį¨ã§ãæžãã æ°´ãŽä¸ã¸å
ããĒčĩ¤čļãŽč˛į´ ãæģ˛ãŋåēãĻããããžããã¨ã¯æããããããĢåĨãŽææãããæĩŽä¸ããã
ãéŧģč
ããããã垎ããĒéãŽčãã
ãâ
ãããŖã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãããåēäŧãŖãåŊæãŽãžãžåˇčˇĄä¸ã¤ãããĒãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨããããŖããã¨æ°´ä¸ã§č
ãäŧ¸ã°ãããã¤ããĢãčēĢäŊãæ¸
æŊãĢããåŋå°ãããįč§Ŗãããã¨æãŖããŽã¯æãŽéãč
ãčļŗãåãããæ°´ãŽæĩæãæĩããčĻŗå¯ããåį´ãĒæ°´éãŗãĢčãå§ããã
ããã°ããæžãŖãĻãããĻåéĄãĒãã ãããã ããŠãããéŖŊãããããĒãæ§åãčĻãĻããåŋ
čĻããããčģĸå¯ãããã¨éĸåã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽæ´ģåæéã¯éˇãããã§įããå¯čģĸããŖãĻį ãå§ŋãčĻããã¨ã¯į¨ã ããåē§ãŖãĻãã¯ãĒã¨ãåããĒãæããããããããã䏿ĨãŽå¤§åãå ããæĨčǞã ã
ãéĻãŽč§åēĻãå¤ãããĒããã¨ãããįæŗãŽå¯čŊæ§ãéĢãããŠãæŗ¨æããĻãããĢčļãããã¨ã¯ãĒãã
ããããĢãå¤åĨãæ´ãįĩããããåš˛ããĻäšžããéãĢã῝ãäŊã¨ãããã¨æąēãããŽã ãããžãæãäŧããĻã°ãããããããĒãã
ãåãåããĻå°įąå˛ŠãŽä¸ã§įŽãčĻãžããæĨãå°įąå˛Šã¸åããŖãĻæŠããĻããã¨ãˇãĨããåãčããããã
ãåããĻåēäŧãŖãé ãĢčĻããåļčĄãŽčˇĄãããŠãããĢæŽãŖãĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããããããĒå¯čŊæ§ãįãŖãããåã¯äŊãčãåēãããĢæčããčŋŊãæãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æšãŽä¸ããåãåŧãä¸ããããŽãžãžæąãããããĻå°įąå˛ŠãŽä¸ãžã§į§ģåããã¯ããã¨ãˇãĨãŽįæ¯ãæŋĄããĻãéĻãčŠãĢįĩĄãžããããĢåŧĩãäģããĻãããŽãåã¯čĻããããŽæãĢå¤åĨãæŋĄããã¯ãã
ããããĒãæąãããŽã¯åãį ãŖãĻããéãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊč ãã¨ééããĻæĻãŖããŽã ãããå¤åĨãĢæŽãåˇã¨æãŋã¯ãããŽæãĢâĻâĻã
ãčǰãããįĨãŽå¤æŗããč¨ĒãããŽãīŧããããĢããĻã¯åŊĸ补ããĒãããã ããŠãã¨ãˇãĨãįäģããã¨ãčãéŖãããããĒãæĒãããŽã¯ãåéãæŊãæããå ãããŽåŖãäŊããå´ŠããĻãããĢãĒéããå¤§įŠ´ã¯ãäēēãæããããŽã ãããã
ãâĻâĻããŖãĻã䏿č°ã¯ãĒããįæ´ģé åãĢæĩãčŋãĨãã°ãčŋãæã¤ãŽããĒãšãŽæ§ã ãåããããæĩæã莺ãčŋããã¨ãˇãĨã¯åãĄæŽãŖããããã ãã¯įãããããĒãã
ãæŦãããĻãæãããĻããã¨ãˇãĨãĒãįŦæãĢæĒæãæ˛ģãããŽã ãããåˇįããĒããŽã¯åŊįļã ã
ãæ˛ģåŽįļæãŽįˇã¨įĨãåãŖããŽã¯ãããŽé ã ãããīŧãį¨ããããĒčĻįˇã¨åŖ°č˛ãããįĸēããĒčĻæåŋã¨įįåŋãæããã垊čŽåŋãįģãããæãããåãŋᎠããĒããčˇåãŽãããĢčĒåļããĻãããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãéˇåŊį¨ŽæãŽå¤§äēēããããã褿°åã¨įĢäŊčŋˇåŽŽã§äēããããŽåžãŠããĒãŖãīŧ
ãããŖããäŊäēēãåŊãčŊã¨ããīŧ
ãâ
ãããŽæŠčŊįžãæããįĩãŗįŽã¯ãåĨãŽčǰããįĩãã ããŽãĢéããĒãã
ããããĢãããŽæããã§čˇãããĒå¸å°ãŽããŗãĢãã¯ãä¸åą¤äģĨä¸ãŽåĨŗæ§ãæã¤ãããĒ貴éåã ãéįŗ¸ã§æŊãããččąæ¨Ąæ§ãŽåēįšãããããããäŧēãįĨãããæãŋæąãã¯ãĒããæŽãææããã¯įãéĻãã¨å ããĢéŧģč ãŽåĨĨãįĒããããĒåēæŋã ãã
ããžã æåŽãããĢã¯čŗããĒãããįĩãŗįŽã¨ããŗãĢããŽæãĄä¸ģã¯åãäēēããįĨããĒããæĩæãæãŖãĻããĒããŖããããããã¨ãˇãĨã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽæĨčŋã訹ããå¤åĨã¯įļēéēãĢįĩãŗį´ãããã
ãããŗãĢããæŽãããįĩ᎝ã¯ããããã§ãæŗåã§ããĻããžãããããããŖãĻčŦãåĸãã°ããã ã
ãčŊã¨ãįŠīŧãåããŋãããŽæŊãīŧãčŋį¤ŧåīŧãåãįŠãčŋãããŗããã ããīŧãããã¨ããåĨããæããŋåäŧãčĒãåãŖãč¨ŧīŧ
ãããŗãĢããčĻãã¨ãˇãĨãŽååŋã¯ããŠãã ãŖãã ãããåãŽįŽåã§ã大åãĒããŽãæ ãããããĢæžãä¸ããį´ æ¯ããããã ãããīŧ
ããããå ¨įļéããåãæžãä¸ãããŽãčĻãĻããåšŗįļã¨ããĻããããžãã§éĸåŋããĒããããããã¯ãããŗãĢããŽåå¨ã丸ãŖããåŋããĻãããŋãããĢã
ãæãĄä¸ģãäģãįããĻãããĒããæ´ãŖãĻįļēéēãĢæããããã§čŋããšãã ããŠããŽčĒ°ãŽæãĄįŠãã¯įĨããĒããâĻâĻã
ãååãããããĻåŽļį´ãåēįšãããĻããã°ãæĸããĒããã¨ããĒããéĢ䞥ãĒįå°ãĢįŽãįŠãã§åŊããčĒãč ãįžããã¨ããĻããã¨ãˇãĨãĒãįĸēåŽãĢčĻį ´ããã
ãč °å¸å§ŋãŽå¤§įˇãéŖããåæãŽåŽļãä¸äģļä¸äģļåããĒããĻãčããã ãã§æ°ãæģ å ĨãããããĒãįéĸįŽãããĒæ˛ģåŽįļæãŽäēēãĢé ããäģģããĻããžããããå¯čŊãĒããã¨ãˇãĨãã¨ã
ããããåļãã°ãåæãŽį į˛č ã¯åēãĒããĒããã ããŠããããĒãã°ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éĻčŧĒãįããããéãĢįšããããããĒįæ´ģãåŧˇããããã ããã
ããããĒãŖãåžããåã¯ããŽå ´æãĢįãžãæãįŠéĄã§å é ãããŽã ãããããžãã§įäēēãããĒããã
ãâââ
ãčǰãã¨čŠąãæã¯ããã¤ããŠããæ¯čĻãããĻãįˇåŧĩããĻããžãã
ãã§ãããį§å¯ãŽčĒæ¸äŧãã§ã¯čǰããŽčŠąãéŽãŖãããåĻåŽãããããĒãããããĒãããŧãčĒįļãĢå ąæãããĻããã
ãããæĨãåãé¸ãã ä¸åã¯ãå°ä¸ãčå°ãĢããåéēčã ãŖãã
ããããæčĒããĻããããããīŧã
ãæŦãŽæãĄä¸ģã§ãããä¸ģåŦč ããããčããĻãããåã¯åŖ°ãåēãããĢé ˇãã ãã ãŖãã Â
ãåŊŧåĨŗãčĒãŋå§ããã¨ãåå č ãŽčǰããčŗãåžããĻãããæãĢåēåžãéŖ˛ãŋãæãĢč¸ãæĢã§ä¸ãããåãŽä¸ãĢã ãããŖãææŋããäŧæãããŋãããĢåēããŖãĻããã
ãæčĒãŽåžãææŗãæąããããåã¯ããã¤ããŽãããĢåãŽåĨĨã§č¨čããããĻããã
ãæãããžãžčŠąããĻããããŽããčĻåŊéããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖãĻãįŦãããĻããžããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããčããããĄãĢæéã°ããéããĻãããä¸ģåŦč
ã¯éããĢåž
ãŖãĻãããããããæ¨ããããæããĻããã
ãâĻâĻããŽå°čŠãæŦåŋã¨ã¯éããããĒæ°ãããĻãč¨čãŽčŖãĢãããžãč¨ããĒãããŠãããŖã¨äŊãâĻâĻã
ã芹ãįĩããĒãããĄãĢåŖ°ã¯čãã§ãããäŋ¯ããåãŽčŗãĢåąãããŽã¯ãįŦãåŖ°ã§ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãããããããŽå ´éĸã¯ãããŖã¨åĨãŽæ°æãĄãé ãããĻãããį§ããããæãããã
ãåŧå¸ãããģããŽå°ãæĨŊãĢãĒãŖããããĒæčĻãããŖãã
ã
ã
ãåĻšãéŖããĻåå ããæĨãŽãã¨ã ã
ãåããä¸Ļãã§åē§ãŖãĻãããŽãčĻãä¸ģåŦč
ã¯ã垎įŦãŋãĒããåŖ°ããããĻããã
ã貴æšããĄãååãĄããīŧãããŖãããã
ãåãã¯ååã§ã¯ãĒããŖããããŠãįŊãéĢĒãĢéģãčã¨į´ ãįŽã¯ãéˇåŊį¨ŽæãŽįšåž´ã¨ããĻæãä¸čŦįã ãčæ ŧåĨŊã°ããããéĢĒåãæčŖ ãžã§äŧŧãĻãããããããééããããĻããã
ãæĨããããããĢéĄãé ããåĻšãĢããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åĒãã垎įŦãã§ãäģãŽåå č
ã¨åããããĢį´
čļã¨čļčåãåēããĻãããã
ãåĻšã¯čãŽä¸ãŽčļčåã°ããčĻãĻããĻčǰã¨ã芹ãããæŦãĢč§Ļãããã¨ããĒããŖãããããä¸ģåŦč
ã¯åãããį´
čļãåˇããĻããĒããã ããäŊåēĻãæ°ãĢããĻããã Â
ããžãã§ãčǰããŽåą
å ´æãŽæ¸ŠåēĻãäŋã¨ãã¨ããĻãããŋãããĢã
ãããäģĨæĨãåãä¸äēēã§čĒæ¸äŧãĢåå ããåēĻãåŋ ãåŖ°ãããããããããĢãĒãŖãã
ãįå˛ããĄããã¯å æ°ãããīŧã
ãæåã¯å°ãį
§ãããããŖããããŠããã¤ããčĒæ¸äŧåå č
ãŽéã§ããįå˛ããĄãããã¨ããå¤ãĒãĸãåãåŽįããĻããŖãã
ãããŽãĸãåããåã大åĸããä¸ãŽä¸äēēã¨ã¯éãäŊããĢããĻããããããĒæ°ãããã
ãâââ
ãæ´ãįĩããå¤åĨãįĩããåš˛ãå ´æãæĸããĻčžēããčĻåããčãããå¤§å˛ŠãŽä¸ããå¤ĒãæãããŠãĄããæŠãäšžãããéčĻã ã
ãæŖã čŋˇãŖãæĢãĢãæãæąēããĻã¨ãˇãĨãĢæãĄãããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨããããããŽčžēãĢåēããĻãããŖã¨æããĻãããŖãããåĒããäšããæãã§ã
ãæ¯ãčŋãŖãįĨįč˛ãĢãæēããæ°´éĸãŽæ¨Ąæ§ãæ ãčžŧãã§ãããäēæŋãæåĻãåŖãĢåēããããã éããĢčĻã¤ãčŋãã
ãããããåžã§ã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãããŖã¨įĢãĄä¸ããŖãĻå¤åĨãåãåããčĒčēĢãŽæãåąãį¯å˛ãŽæãĢãããŖããã¨ããåäŊã§åŧãŖæããã
ãåˇįãå
Ĩãåĸ¨ããĒãčä¸ãįēããĒãããåã¯čĒããŽįēč¨ãåčģããĻåžæãĢæ˛ãŋãéããĢčēĢæļãããĻããã
ãããããåŧã°ããå´ã¯æ°ãĨããĻããããĒãããæ°ãĢãįããĻããĒããįĄé įãįĢãŖãĻæŠããĻãããããĒåĨ´ã ã
ãããŖã¨æåįãĒå ´éĸãæŗåããĻãããŽãĢãčãäēãĢįąä¸ãéããĻãåŽå
¨ãĢæčãŽå¤ã ãŖãã
ãããį´ãããã
ãæ´ãįĩããããŗãĢãããããããŽãžãžåēããäšžããžã§ãŽéãĢãéįŗ¸ãŽččąåēįšãčĻŗčŗããã
ãåããĢįŊŽããé鿏ãįŽãĢå ĨãŖããåé ãĢã¯ãæåã¨ã¯į°ãĒãææã§å°åˇãããčŖ éŖžãããã
ãæŋĄããåããčĻããĻããããæ°ãĢįããĻããĒããŖããããã¯å ŦįãĒææ¸ãŽį¨į´ã ãį§įãĒæį´ã§ã¯ãĒãäģĨä¸ãčŖ éŖžãĢæéã¨č˛ģį¨ããããįįąãããã¨ã¯æããĒãã
ãããŗãĢãã¨é鿏ãä¸Ļãšãįēå ãããŗãŽå ãĢããããåēįšã¨å°åˇãŽčŧĒéãã寸åéãããĢéãĒãåãŖãã
ãåļįļã¨ã¯æããĒãããããĒãŖãããã¨ãˇãĨãĢåãčŗĒããšãã ããããåŊŧåĨŗã¨ãŽéĻ´ãåããã
ãåã¯é鿏ãŽčŦãĢåãį´ãŖããæĩŽããŗä¸ããŖãæ¨Ąæ§ãįēå ãããŗãŽå ãĢéããã
ãããŽį´ã¯ä¸åą¤é¨ãŽåŊšäēēãäŊŋãããŽã¨åčŗĒã ããããĒããčǰãäŊãŽįŽįã§į´°åˇĨãæŊãããŽãã
ãä¸ģåŦč ãŽåĨŗæ§ã¯ãéĢĒã¨čãŽé˛åēãéŋããį´ æ§ãé ããĻããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽææŗã¨åéããĻããæŦã¯ã樊åč ããĄããåąéēčĻãããããĒãããŽãæ°å¤ãããŖããåąããããŠãŗãšãŽä¸ãĢãããŽčĒæ¸äŧã¯æãįĢãŖãĻãããŽã ã¨ãäģãĒãįč§Ŗã§ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãĒã፿ããĻããã¯ãã ãéåŦã§ããĒããĒãŖãæãŽãããŽįŊŽãåįŖãåå č ã¨éŖįĩĄãåãææŽĩãã
ãå ¨äŊåãĢčĻčĻãã¯ãĒãããåŊĸãĢã¯čĻãããããåã¯č¨æļãé ŧããĢãčŗå ã§å°åŊĸãįĢäŊįãĢįĩãŋä¸ããã
ãããã¯å°åŗã ãį¤ēãããĻãããŽã¯ãåŊãŽå¤ããĢåēããįĢäŊčŋˇčˇ¯ã
ãåäžããĄãŽéãŗå ´ã§ãããäģ˛éå
ãŽåž
ãĄåããå ´æã§ããããåąéēãåãããäģ˛éã ããĢäŧããããããģãŠæéŠãĒå ´æã¯ãĒãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽį¨åŋæˇąããčããã°ãå°åŗãĢããįŽå°ã¯æį´ãĒãŠãŽåãæ¸Ąãå ´æãæ å ąåéãįŽįã¨ããä¸įļå°įšãŽä¸ã¤ã§ããã¯ããããã§ããįšãããåãæģããå¯čŊæ§ã¨ããĻååã ã
ãé鿏ãæããããŋãååãŖãčãŽååã ããæãŋčžŧããįĢãĄä¸ããã垎åã ãĢããĒãã¨ãˇãĨã¸åããĻåŖ°ããããã
ãå ´æããããŖããčĒæ¸äŧãŽä¸ģåŦč ã¸æį´ãåēããĢčĄããåã¯ããããĢæŽãŖãĻãããĻããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯įããĒããįĨįč˛ãŽįŗåãĢå˛ãžããä¸åŋé¨ãŽįŖæãŋãį´°ãįŗãåã¸åããããã
ãåãį´åžã§ããįįąãčãããĻããããĒããåã¯čããæšãããããããããŗãĢããŽæãĄä¸ģãŽæ å ąã§ãããã
ãæ˛éģãįļãéãĢä¸åŽãåãŖãĻãããäģäēēãŽéĄč˛ãĢæ¯ããčį¸Žããããã§ã¯ãæ¯ãåãããĻããé ã¨äŊãå¤ãããĒãã
ãåŽå ¨ãĒå ´æã§č¸ãããããĢåãžããã¨ããčĒåãŽå§ŋãé ãĢæĩŽããã§ãč šãįĢãŖãĻããã
ãåãŽč¨ąå¯ãæąããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããåãŽčĄåã§åãä¸åŠįãčĸĢããã¨ãããã°ãå°ãæ°ãŽæ¯ã ã¨æãã ãã ã
ãåã¯äŊãåŖ°ã§ãããäģãå ããã
ãæ°¸é ãĢãæããããæ˛éģãŽåžãã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããåéãŽæšã¸åããŖãĻæŠãå§ãããããŽčä¸ãčĻãĻå ¨čēĢãŽįˇåŧĩãč§ŖããĻãããŽãæããĒãããéããĢæ¯ãåãããã
ãåãã¯ãããä¸åēĻããŽčŋˇåŽŽã¸åããã
ãéåģãŽįšãããæįš°ãå¯ãããããããŽåčĒčēĢãŽįĢãĄäŊįŊŽãįĸēããããããĢã
9
ãįŋæããįĨãŽå¤æŗãã§ãŽæåžãŽéŖäēãæ¸ãžããčˇįŠãŽå
ĨãŖãéãčŠãĢãããå¤åĨãčĸĢãŖãĻåéãæŊãŖãã
ãæ°æŠåžããããã¨ãˇãĨãã¤ããĻæĨãã
ã
ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãč¨ããĒããããããã¨ãˇãĨãĒããŽäēēäģãåããĒãŽã ã¨ãæčŋããããįč§Ŗãå§ããã
ãåãŽåãĢéŖãšįŠãįŊŽãįįąããéŖãšæšããä¸åčĒŦæããĒããéŖãšãããŠããã¯åãŽčĒįąã ã鏿čĸãæį¤ēããã ãã§ãįĩæãĢã¯å𞿏ããĒããÂ
ãåãéŖãšãĒããŖããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨãã°ãįŋæĨã¯éãį¨ŽéĄãŽããŽãæäžããããããŽå ´ã§čĒããéŖãšå§ããããããã
ãįĄč¨ãŽåææĄãįš°ãčŋããä¸čŠąãįŧããŽã¯éŖäēéĸãŽãŋãčĒįąæåŋãĢå§ããĻãæžäģģããĻããé¨åã大åã ã
ãåãŽčĄåãåããããã čĻįˇãåããããæŦåŊãĢãããã§ãããŽãīŧãããåããããããĻãããããĒæ°æãĄãĢãĒããã ããŠãããčĻããĻãããŽã¯ãããŖã¨åãŽčŋˇãã ã
ã
ã
ãåéãæããã¨ãįŠēæ°ãå¤ãããå
æēãå°ãĒããããĢčžēãã¯æããĒããæšŋåēĻã¯ä¸ãããéŗãæ¸ãã
ãããããå§ãžãįĢäŊčŋˇčˇ¯ã¯ããžãã§čǰããæåŗįãĢäŊãŖãããŽãããĢãčĒįļãŽå°åŊĸãĢį´ãããããĢåå¨ããĻããã
ãéãã§ããé ãŽč¨æļã鎎æãĢčããčǰããįĨãŖãĻãããŽãĢããã¤ããåŋããĻããå ´æã
ãããŖã¨äģĨåãŽåēæĨäēã ãŖããããĢæããã
ã
ãæ¨ĒãĢä¸Ļãļã§ããĒããåžããĢä¸ããã§ããĒããä¸åŽãŽčˇéĸãäŋãĄãĒãããã¤ããĻæĨããä¸äēēãã¤ããéããĒããããĒįãéãĢåˇŽãæããŖãã
ããããĒæãåãé˛ããŽãĢåãããĻé˛ãŋãåãčļŗãæĸããã°æĸãžãã
ãåãé¸ãļãŽãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åž
ãŖãĻãããåãŽčŋˇããčãéãããæąēæãžã§ãŽéį¨ãĢčŗãæžãžãã
ãããã ãã ãäģãŽã¨ããã¯ã
ãâââ
ãããŽæĨãå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽãŽįŗåŖã¯åˇããæšŋããå čãčæãããæžãŖãĻãããį´°éãŽåĨĨããåéŋããåå ąããĄãŽåŖ°ããä¸ã¤ãä¸ã¤ã¨åĸããĻããã
ãčĻããã¤ããīŧã
ãåã¯å čãŽå°ãĒãå ´æãé¸ãŗãįĻį¤ĢãŽééãĢčēĢãæģãčžŧãžããæ¯ãæŊãããæéã¯æããĒããããããããŽį¨åēĻãŽæãã¯åãŽåŗæšã ã
ããŠãã ããīŧã
ãå
¨įļčĻã¤ãããĒãã
ãįã§æĸããĻããŽãĢäŊã§čĻã¤ãããĒããŽīŧã坿ĒãããĒãīŧã
ãããããåãæšč§ãŽéĸããäŊįŊŽããã褿°ãŽåŖ°ãéŋããĻãããæããįˇŠãŋãããĢãĒãåãåã¯ããĨãã¨åŧãįĩãļã
ã
ã
ããããĻåŖ°ãŽčĒŋåãå¤ããã
ãããã¤ããį˛ããããã
ããã¯ãâĻâĻã
ãéãæ˛ãã åŖ°ã
ãããŽåãéãŗæšãįĨããĒããŖããã§ããīŧãããŖã¨åæãĢ帰ãŖãĄããŖããã ãã
ãããã ããããŽåãããˇãŖãčĒãŖãĻããŽãĢåĢãããĒéĄããĻãĒããŖãīŧã
ãåãåˇģããŽåĨŗãŽåããĄãŽåŖ°ã ã
ããĒããæŦĄã¯åŽæĸãããŖãããããã
ãäģåēĻã¯åŧžããããĒįˇãŽåãŽåŖ°ã
ããããĒããåãããåŖãäŧãŖãĻčŗãĢåąããã
ãäģäēēãããčŗãč¯ãããã§ãåĢãĒãã¨ãžã§čãããĻããžããäŊåēĻãæ°åŗæĒãããããã¨ãããã
ããããĒæããããããããĒãæŦåŊãĢ帰ãŖãĻããããã
ããžã æĸãããīŧãįĩļ寞ãĢé ããĻãããīŧã
ãã˛ã¨ãã大ããĒåŖ°ãæããéŋãããããˇãŖãŽåŖ°ã ãäģãŽåãŽåŖ°ãĢæ¯ãšä¸įĒããããĒã¨čãåããã
ãįãã¨ããĢé ããĻåēãããĒããĒãŖãĻãããã ãããã
ãã§ããå
¨é¨æĸãããīŧã
ãããä¸åã ãããīŧããéĄãīŧã
ãåã¯čãæąãããžãžč´ãčŗãįĢãĻãĻããã
ãæąēããĻčĒåã§åēãããĒãã¯ãĒããã ããŠãčĒæ¸äŧãŽåžãĢäģãŽįããŠãã§äŊãããĻéãļãŽããäģĨåããå°ãæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããčĒããĢæĨããŽãããˇãŖã ãŖããããčŋˇãŖãĻããå ãĢæãåŧãããããããĻãããŽã ã
ãæŽĩã
č
šãįĢãŖãĻãããã§ããããˇãŖã¯ãŠããĒæ°æãĄãĢãĒãã ããã
ãåãåēãĻčĄãã°ããˇãŖãŽæŖãããč¨ŧæã§ãããåãåēãä¸ģåŧĩã ãŖãĻå ąãããã
ãâââ
ãįēå
ãããŗãįčŗãĢåŧãŖæããčŋˇčˇ¯ãŽå
ĨåŖãĢįĢãŖãã
ãããŽčžēãã§éãã§ããé ãŽč¨æļã¨æå
ãŽå°åŗãé ŧããĢãå¨å˛ãčĻæ¸ĄãããļãŠã¤ããåŖãŽčãåēãŽåžæãčŗéŗ´ããŽãããĢéŋãéŗã¨å
ããĒæ¯åãįžįļã¨č¨æļãæĻãåãããĻããã
ãããŽéãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éģãŖãĻåž
ãŖãĻããã
ãåãé˛ãã°ã¤ããĻæĨãĻãčļŗãæĸããã°ãåŖãŽčãčŖãįŽãčĻä¸ãããããĻããã
ã
ã
ãå°ããĒåå˛įšãĢåˇŽãæããŖããæčŋã§ããå¤§įŠ´ãŽåã§įĢãĄæĸãžããå°åŗãĢã¯ãĒããããããéãæããããã°ãįŽįå°ãžã§å¤§åš
ãĢčŋéã§ããã
ãâĻâĻãããåãåŖãããŽīŧã
ãįãããã¨æãå¯žčąĄč
ãčĻä¸ããĻå°ãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ä¸įĨãå¯čļããããåĻåŽãč¯åŽããããĢå¨å˛ãčĻããŖãã
ãå°åŗãåēããĻįĸēčĒããããæŖčĻãŽéã¯ãŠããé åãéãããäŊæĨããããã°ãįŽįå°ã¸įãåãĢæ°´ãéŖæãå°ŊããĻããžãã
ãåŖãŽåããå´ãĢčĄããã°ãéåŽŋãåéŋã§ãããããããĒãã
ãåŖãŽįŠ´ãčĻãĒããææĄããã
ãâĻâĻæããĻãããīŧã
ãåãæåˇŽããčžēããããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄč¨ã§å°įŗãæžããįŠ´ãŽåããã¸æžãŖããéãéŗã¨ã¨ããĢãįŗã¯åããå´ãŽåŖãĢæˇąãããčžŧãŋãį˛åĄĩãčãŖãã
ã
ã
ãįŽåã§čĩˇãããã¨ãįč§ŖãããŽãĢãåã¯éåã¨éˇãæéããããã
ãäģãŽã¯ãæį¤ēãč¯ããĒããŖãããįŠ´ãŽéĢããžã§åãæãĄä¸ããĻãããã ãã§ãããé ŧããīŧã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻãã¨ãˇãĨãĢčãåããĻåž
ã¤ã严čãŽä¸ãĢæãæˇģããããåãčžŧããããã严čļŗãå°éĸãéĸããåã¯åŖįŠ´ãĢ严æã¨įčļŗãåŧãŖæããĻåããå´ãįĸēčĒããã
ãäēæŗããéããéãããŽã¯į°Ąåããã ã
ãããŖã¨ãâĻâĻãããã¨ãã
ãããäģĨä¸ãŽčŖåŠã¯ä¸čĻã ã¨äŧããã¤ãã§ãĢãį¤ŧãããč¨čãčŋ°ãšãĻãããã
ãčļŗãæģãããĒããããæ
éãĢįĻį¤ĢããéããĻåšŗããĒå ´æãĢčŊãĄįã¤ãæ¯ãčŋãã¨ãįŠ´ãŽåããå´ããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãĻãããããŽčĻįˇãæ¨įãĢåããã
ãä¸åŽãæãå§ããåãŽįŽåã§ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ææĸãĢæãã ãčŠããļã¤ããčã§čēĢäŊãåãĢæŧãåēããã¨ããĻãčããļã¤ããĻåŽå
¨ãĢåããæĸããã
ãéãæãä¸å¯čŊã§ã¯ãĒãã¯ãã ã
ã
ãâ
ãâåã¯æ¯ãåããåŖ°ããããã
ãä¸åēĻãč ãå ãĢæģããĻãčŠãåŧãã
ãčæéãŽä¸ãéģéč˛ãŽå
ãæžã¤įŗããããĄããčĻãĻãããåčĻæãĢã¯čēĢãéããããģãŠãŽå¨å§æã ãŖããŽãĢãæ˛æ¨æĨĩãžãįžįļãĢčŗãŖãĻã¯åãŽããã ã
ãčēĢäŊãåŧãã¨åæãĢãčŠã¨å˛ŠåŖãŽį¸ãæĻããå°įŗã¨į ãããŠããŠã¨čŊãĄãã
ãæŦĄãåˇĻæã§æ¯ããĻãâĻâĻãããčēĢäŊãæģããã ãåãĒãåŖãåŖããã ããããŠãįčˇĄãæŽããŽã¯åžã ãŽãããĢč¯ããĒãã
ãæéãããéããã¨ãåŋčãåããĻæ´ãåēãããįĨããĒãã
ãįããŖããč¨ãŖãĻãįŽčã¨åŖãį´æĨæĻããĒããããå¸ãæãããã
ã严æãįšããå ¨åã§åŧãŖåŧĩãŖããæå æ¸ããã°åãããĒããŽã ãããå¤å°ãŽįãŋãĢã¯ææ ĸããĻããããããĒãã
ãčãæ˛ããĻããåŧãŖæããŖãĻåããĒãã§ããããâĻâĻã
ãåŖįŠ´ããč§Ŗæžãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãäŊäēããĒããŖããããĢįĢãĄä¸ãããč
°ãŽå¤åĨãĢã¤ããį˛åĄĩãæããč
°ãčŊã¨ããĻæ¯ãæ´ããĻããåãŽéĄãŽåã§ã ã
ããããĒæ§åã¯åããĻčĻããããĢæããæãĄįŠãĢæįãæãããã¨ããã¨ãˇãĨãĢããããŽã ãããīŧ
ãčĒæ¸äŧ补å°åãŽįãé莝ã¯ããŠãããŖãĻéãŖããŽã ãããčĻįˇãæčããã¨ãįˇåŧĩããĻ䏿ãã§ããĒããĒãæ§čŗĒãĒãŽãīŧ
ã
ã
ãâæ°ããĢæĩŽä¸ããčŦãæãĻäŊãã¤ã¤ãåããĄã¯åãŗæŠãŋãé˛ãããįēå
ãããŗãŽéįŊãå
ãé˛ããšãéããŧãããã¨į
§ããã
ãâãããĻčļŗå
ãå´ŠããããåēéãĢåˇŽãæããŖããäēēãä¸äēēãããŖã¨éããã ããŽåš
ããæŽãŖãĻããĒããčŋãĨããéįĢ¯ãæˇĩãå´ŠããĻįãŖéããžããĒããĻãã¨ãããåžãã
ãåã¯éããį´°ãį¸ã¨æĨãåãåēãããæé ãĒįŗãæžããå°éĸãĢæĨãæãĄčžŧãã¨ãį¸ãŽį̝ãæŦãäģããã
ãããŖãĄæãŖãĻãĻãæĨãæããĒãã§ãã
ãæĨãĢčŋãå´ãŽįĢ¯ãææ¸Ąããåã¯å寞įĢ¯ãæĄããããčļŗå ãįĸēãããĒããæ éãĢé˛ãã䏿Šč¸ãŋåēããã¨ãĢãé´čŖããį į˛ãããŧãčŊãĄãéã¸å¸ãčžŧãžããĻčĄãŖããéŗãé ãããåéŋããã¯ããĒãŽãĢãčĒčēĢãŽéŧåãį ŠããĻãäģãĢã¯äŊãčãããĒãã
ãįĻãã¨æĻããĒããæ¸Ąãåããæ¯ãčŋãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åãŽäŊåãéããåãæšæŗã§ã¯å´ŠčŊåŋ
čŗã ã
ãåã¯å¸°ããŽãããĢãããä¸ã¤ãŽæĨãå°éĸãĢæãĄčžŧãã§ãį¸ãæŦãã¤ãããåŧãŖåŧĩãŖãĻãå¤ããĒããã¨ãįĸēãããã
ãããŽéãĢįŠēæ°ãŽå§ãé ŦãããããĻæ¨ĒåãŖãã大ããĒįå°éŗã¨å°éĸãæĻãéŗãéŋãæ¸ĄããååãåˇģãįĢã¤ã
ãč
°å¸ãŽį˛åĄĩãæãįŠéŗãčããčĸã§čĻãŖãĻããįŽãčãéãããããĄãå´ã¸ãŽčˇŗčēãĢæåããã¨ãˇãĨãããããĢįĢãŖãĻããã
ã
ã
ããããĢé˛ãã å
ã§ããžãåå˛įšãĢåˇŽãæããŖããå°åŗãĢããã°ãåŗãæŖčĻãĢãŧãã ã
ãįēå
ãããŗãŽå
ãåŧąãžãŖãĻãããããããŽå
ã¯ãčĒįããĻããå
čãŽæãããé ŧããĢé˛ããããĒãã
ãããŽåãĢäŧæŠããããåĻãĒįŠ´ãååããæ°´ããžãããĒãããã¤ããããã ã
ãåŖãĢčãé ããĻåē§ãčžŧãŋãæ°´įãŽæ°´ãä¸åŖéŖ˛ãã¨ãéããäŋåéŖãåãåēããåããŽãĢčĻæãããįĄŦãããŗã¨åš˛ãčã ã
ãéŖãšãīŧã
ãåãŽæå
ãčĻãĻãã¨ãˇãĨã¯č
°ãä¸ããããããŗã¨åš˛ãčãä¸åãåˇŽãåēãã¨ããããæå
ã§ã¤ãžãŋããã°ããčĻã¤ããĻããããŗãåŖãĢéãļãå°æ°åŗããéŗãéŋããã
ãåã¯å°åēéãŽåš˛ãčãåŖãĢåĨããĒãããå°åŗãåēãããįēå
ãããŗãŽåžŽåŧąãĒå
ãé ŧããĢãæŽããŽéįã荿ļãĢįããĻããã
ãįŽįå°ãžã§ã¯ããã¨æ°åēįģã ã
ã
ã
ãįēå
ãããŗãåŽå
¨ãĢå
ãå¤ąããčĻįã¯å¤å°æĒåããããããĒãã¨ãããįŽä¸ãĒããŦįŽä¸ãŽčǞéĄã¸ãŽå¯žåĻã ã
ãåšŗéĸãŽå°åŗä¸æãĢãįĢäŊčŋˇčˇ¯ãŽãããĒå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽããŠãæ¸ã襨ããĻããããæåããįåã¯ããŖãããé莝ã襨ãįˇãŽå¤Ēãã䏿ãã§ãããã¨ãĢãæ°ãĨããĻãããå°åŗä¸ãŽå¤Ēãįˇãį´°ãįˇãĢå¤ããįŽæãããã¸čļŗãéãšã°ãäŊæč
ãŽæåŗãæĸãããŗããããã¯ãã ã
ãåãĢããŗå
ã§ãŽã¤ãŗã¯čĒŋį¯ãéãĒãŽããæ
æãĢå¤Ēããæ¸ãåããĻãããŽããããŽįãããåãŽåãĢããŖãã
ãčĒčēĢãŽįŽã¨č¨æļãįããããĒãããčĄãæĸãžãã§ããæĨãĒåéã§ããĒããįģããĒããã°ãããŽå
ã¸ã¯é˛ããĒãã
ãįŽįå°ãčŋããčŋå莝ãæĸããŽã¯æįĩææŽĩã ã
ã
ã
ãįĒčĩˇã¯å°ãĒããčãĢčĻããã襨éĸã¯æģããããã
ãå°įŗãé莝ãŽå
ã¸æããåéŋéŗãĢčŗãæžãžããĻã大ãžããĒå°åŊĸãčŗå
ãĢæããæãæąēããĻæ¯ãčŋãã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æĸãĢč
°ãčŊã¨ããĻãåž
ãĄæ§ããĻããã
ãããŽčåžãĢåãã严čŠãĢæãæˇģãããã¨ãˇãĨãčãäŧ¸ã°ãã¨ãčĻįãæãĄä¸ãããæŽãŖãĻããįãæ´ãŋãč
ã¨čŠãčļŗå ´ãĢããĻãããįģãŖãã
ãå
ãã¯ãå¨å˛ãŽæ§åãčĻãããžã æ´ããĻããįĨįĩčŗĒãĒåŋčãåŽĨããįŠēæ°ãŽå¤åãĢæčãåãããé莝ã¯åš
åēããéĢããĢãäŊčŖããããæšŋãæ°ãčããå
į¨ãžã§ã¨ã¯å
čãŽč˛åŗãéãæ°ãããã
ãåã¯č¨æļããå°åŗãåŧãŖåŧĩãåēããįˇãŽå¤ĒããéĢäŊåˇŽãį¤ēããĻãããĒããããã¯åĨéåą¤ã ã
ã
ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãåŠčĩ°ãããããĢåžãã¸éãããå°éĸãčš´ããåĸãč¯ãåŖãé§ãä¸ããŖãĻãį¸ãĢæããããčēĢäŊãæãĄä¸ãããį˛åĄĩãæãäģčãããŠããå°æ
ŖããĻããã
ãæã貸ããĒããŖããã¨ã¯æåž
ã¨äŋĄé ŧãŽč¨ŧããããžã§ãŽčĻŗå¯ããæããĢãã¨ãˇãĨãĢčļŗããĒããŽã¯įĩé¨ã ãæéˇãŽæŠäŧãæãŋåããŽã¯č¯ããĒããæãŋįļããå§ŋåĸãå¤ããŽãåæ§ãĢæŦ ããã
ãâĻâĻįģãããã¨ã¯č¨ããåãč¸ãŋã¤ããäģļãĢã¤ããĻč¨ããããã¨ãããã°ãäģãŽããĄãĢãŠããã
ãæããããĒč¨čãĢãčãŽå ãčĻãĻããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻįˇãå¯čļãã
ã帰ããæĨŊããŋã ã
ãįĄčĄ¨æ
ããįš°ãåēãããä¸č¨ã§ãä¸åŽãčįãčĨ˛ãŖãã
ã
ãâ
ãããããå°ãé˛ãã¨ãį¸ĻéˇãŽįŠēéãåēããŖãĻãããåŖéãĢã¯å´Šããããæ¸æļãŽæŽéǏãå°åŗä¸ãŽå°ãį¤ēãå ´æããããįŽįå°ã ã
ãčžēãã¯éãžãčŋãŖãĻããããäēēåŊąããĒãã
ãå
ããĒæåž
ãč¸ãĢãããŗčļãŽåããæĸããããčã¨ãĢããå¤į´ãŽčããåŧˇãããã
ãįĄäēãĢįãããŋããã ãã
ãčĻįˇãŽå ã§ã¨ãˇãĨãé ˇãããåŖãŽåģå°ãĢįŽãįããĻããããã ãåģå°ã¯ãé鿏ãŽåé ãĢããŖãå°åˇã¨ãããŗãĢããĢåēįšãããĻãææ¨Ąæ§ãĢé ˇäŧŧããĻããã
ãäŧãããäēēãĢã¯äŧããĒããŖããã ããŠããããĢæį´ãæŽããĻįŊŽãã°ãčĒæ¸äŧãŽä¸ģåŦč
ãĢåąãã¯ãã ãåŊŧåĨŗãĒããããŖã¨åãŽįåãĢįããĻããããäēæ
ãčãããĢčŋŊãčŋããããĒäēēã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãåã¯éããå°åŗãåãåēããããããĢæãã§ããååãŽčã¨éãäģŖãããŽįŗãįŊŽããå°åŗã¯éãĢæģãã
ã
ã
ãčŋˇåŽŽæĸį´ĸã¯ãããã§æãčŋãã ãããčĒåãĢč¨ãčãããããéį̝ãĢč¸ãŽåĨĨãæĨéãĢåˇããĻããã
ãããŽæãææēãŽįå°ãĢįŽãæĸãžãŖããčįãŽäģŖãããĢįēå ãããŗãåēããããäšžįŠäŊããĢäŊŋãããĻãããããĒéǍčŖåã ãæąããæã§æãã¨ãåŖãŽåģå°ãĢäŧŧãåŊĢãčžŧãŋãæĩŽããŗä¸ããã
ãæå ãŽæčĻãé ŧããĢææēãčĒŋãšããæēãŽčãĢįĒčĩˇããããåŧãåēããŽããã ããåŧãŖåŧĩãŖãĻãéããĒããéĩįŠ´ãããæēãčĻã¤ããįå°ãŽį´°ãé¨åãåˇŽãčžŧããįŠ´ãŽåĨĨãããĢããã¨éŗããããåæé¨åãåŧããčģãéŗã¨å ąãĢãä¸ããå¸åŧĩããŽååãįžããã
ã貸åēå°å¸ŗã ãŖããå 叺éĸãĒæåãä¸Ļãã§ãããįĨãŖãåããããæåžãŽããŧã¸ãĢã¯ãããããŖãã
ãåģå°ãŽä¸ãåŧãŗé´ãéŗ´ãããã¨ã
ãææēãĢãåãŽä¸ãĢåãåŊĢãčžŧãŋããããåãŽå°ããĒįĸå°ãåŖãŽåģå°ãæãį¤ēããĻãããããŽéãĢã¯ãäēēãæ¨ĄããåŊĢåģãŽįŊŽįŠãããŽå¨čžēã ãåãå°ãĒãã
ãäģã¯ãåæąåãŽéĢãåŖãæŊãĄãããæ¸æļãåãå°ŊãããĻãããæ¸į°ĄãŽéĄã¯čĻåŊãããĒãã䞥å¤ãĒãããŽã ããæŽãããååãčĸĢããčãĢäžĩéŖãããĻãããããããã¯äŊååš´ãåããã
ãäģæããé ãããĻã¯ããĒããã¨ãåŊĢåģãåãããã¨ãããããŗãã¨ãããĒããéĄãæãŽåããčããããŠãå¯åããįŽæã¯čĻã¤ããããĒããŖãã
ã
ã
ãä¸čĻãäēēãĢčŋãããã§ãéĻããä¸ã¯ãĒããčä¸ãĢã¯ãããä¸å¯žãŽč
ãé°ãŽåæŽãã䏿 ŧåĨŊãĢįĒãåēãĻãããå°ä¸ãŽįįŠãæ¨ĄããäŊåã ãããã
ãå°ãæĸãã°ãįĸå°ã¯é¨åąä¸ãĢįšå¨ããĻãããåŖãĢåŊĢãčžŧãžããĻããããæ§ã ãĒč˛ãŽã¤ãŗã¯ã§æ¸ãããĻããããæ§ã ã ã
ã大ããĒæēãæ¯ãåããåã¯äēēįŠåãŽå°åē§ãĢč
°ãä¸ããã
ã
ã
ãåãŽå°åē§ã¨į į¤ĢãæĻããåĢãĒæĩææãŽåžãĢãå°ããįããéŗãå°åē§ãįŗåēã¸å
ããĢæ˛ãŋčžŧãããŦããŗãã¨åãŋåããããĒéŗãåŖãŽãŠããã§éŗ´ããååãčãŖããåŖãŽåģå°ãčĻä¸ããã¨ããããå˛ããããĢåč§ãčŧĒéįˇãæĩŽããŗãčãŽä¸é¨ãåĨããčŊãĄãã
ãããéŖã§ã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãĻããã
ãé ãæãŽåãĢįŊŽįŠãããŖããéĒéã ããīŧã
ãéŠãã¨čåĨŽãŽæä¸ã§ããããåãããåŖčĩ°ãŖããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãé ãæãŽåããå°åē§ãã¨æŧãéãããã¨ããããåããĒããŖããåŖããĒãį¨åēĻãĢå æ¸ããĻãããããã ã
ãåã¯å°åē§ãŽä¸ã§æããããæĸããčĻæ ŖããåŊĢãčžŧãŋã¨įĸå°ãčĻã¤ããã
ãããåããã ã
ãč ãŽåãã§åããŽæį¤ēãåēããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄč¨ãŽãžãžãããä¸åēĻãå°åē§ãæ´ããæŠæĻéŗã¨ã¨ããĢå°åē§ãåēãŽä¸ã§åŗåčģĸãããéĻãŽãĒãäēēįŠåãŽæå ã§ãéˇãæžįŊŽããįļããĻããé´ãŽéŗããããĒã¨éŋãããåŖãčãĢįĢãŖãĻããåãé ãæã¸åããããã
ãįĢæãĄįŗãæã¤ãããĒéŗãéŋããéã ããįŗãŽæãéããĻãããã
ãįãŖãããĢäŧ¸ãŗãé莝ãįžããã
ãããŽéĨãåĨĨã§ãįēå
čãŠãŗããæēããĻããã
ã
ã
ãä¸čĻãĢããããéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã§ãããæåž
ãææãã¯åãĢãåãããĒããč¸ãŋåēããšããæŖã
čŋˇãŖãåžã§æ¯ãåãã
ããŠãã§æĩã¨ééãããã䏿ãĒãŽãĢããããžã§ã¤ããĻæĨãįĄåŖãĒåčĄč
ã¸åãį´ãŖãã
ã
ãã帰ããæĨŊããŋã ãã¨åã¯č¨ãŖããããŽã夿ŗããĢ帰ãããã¨æããĒããåã ãã§ãäģããåŧãčŋããšãã ã
ãããŽå ãĢé˛ãã°ãåŊŧåĨŗãĢäŧããããįĨããĒããã§ããæĩãåž ãĄæ§ããĻããå¯čŊæ§ãããã
ãããã¨ããåãæąããĻ帰ããīŧãäēēãéŖŧããŽãåãŽįŽįãĒãããæŖæŠã¯åŽå ¨ãĒå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽæĸį´ĸã§ååã ããīŧãã
ãããŽįŗãåãæããĻããã
ãåãĢã¯čãããĻãããŽãīŧãããŽå ã§čĩˇããåžãåēæĨäēãéĄæĢãããããĒããæããĻãããåã¯åčĒčēĢãĢčĩˇãããã¨ãįĨããããåãįĨããããįããĻããããĒãåŧãčŋããĻãããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãįããĒããįãŖį´ããĢčĻã¤ããĻããįŗã¸ãčŊčãããããĒæēãæ¯ãæēĸããã
ãäŊãããčĢĻããĻæãåēããããĒããããŽæ°æãĄãåŽĨãããããĢã¯ãč¨ã荺ãåŋ
čĻã ã
ãåãåŋãŽæēåãæ´ããåŠããĢã¯ãĒããĒããããã§ããã¨ãˇãĨãäŊãŽåŋæ§ãããĒããįĄįã§æĩéŖãĢįĒãŖčžŧãäēæ
ã ãã¯éŋããããã
ãåąéēãĢčŋãĨããæãæąããã¨ããĒããå¤åĨãæąãããŽã¯åĢãĒãã ããīŧãããã¨ããããčĻããĻããã ããīŧã
ãäģŽãĢãã¨ãˇãĨãäēããæãã§ãããĒããäŊã芹ããã¨įĄé§ã ãåãĢã¯æĸããããĒãã
ãå
čãŽäģããĒæãããåããæˇĄãéãéãįĨįãĢå
ãžããéãįŗãåã¯įãŖåããčĻæŽããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãåãããåŧãļãŽã¯ãããã§æåžããįĨããĒãã
ãåãåŖ°ãĢåēããĒããŖãč¨čãžã§čããĻãããĒããã¨ãˇãĨãåãé¸ãã įįąãå°ãã¯įč§Ŗã§ããæ°ããããåã¯ããäēēåĨŊãã§ã¯ãĒãããŠãåǿ䏿ãĢčĻããĻčĒååæã ããã
ãäŊã芹ããĒããĻč¯ããéããéãããã¯åãĢäģģãããã ããŠãåãåŽããã¨ãããĒã
ã䏿šãæŽããããŽčĒåˇąį į˛ã§ã¯ãĒããäēããŽįåįãæå¤§éãĢéĢãããããŽįã ã
ãåäēēįãĒæ¨ãŋã§åãŽåŊãįãč
ã¯ããĒãã¯ãã ããäēēčŗĒã¨ããĻåŠį¨ã§ããã¨æãããã°ãäēæ
ã¯æĒããĒãå¯čŊæ§ãéĢãã
ãåąéēã¯æŋįĨãŽä¸ã§åã¯é˛ããįåŽãįĨããããĢã
ãåŋãæąēããĻé莝ãŽåĨĨã¸åãį´ãŖããããäģĨä¸ã¯äŊãč¨ããžãã
10
ãé莝ãĢå Ĩãã¨įŠēæ°ãå¤ããŖããååã¨čãŽčãã¯čãã垎ããĢįãéĻãŽãããĒåããæŧãŖãĻããã
ãčļŗå
ãŽįŗįŗã¯įŖ¨ãããĻãããåŖãĢã¯čļŗå
ãį
§ããįēå
čãŠãŗããįééãĢč¨įŊŽãããĻãããčŋˇåŽŽãŽčãå
ˇåã¨ã¯æŽĩéãã ããããĻåēåŖãŽå¤ããæãããĒå
ãåˇŽãčžŧãŋãããŽčãĢįĢã¤äēēåŊąãčĻããã
ãčŋˇãã¤ã¤å¤åĨãŽããŧããæˇąãčĸĢããčļŗãæĸãããéģãįĩĻäģæãĢįŊãæčĸãčēĢãĢįããäēēįŠããčŊãĄįããåŖ°ã§æ¨æļãčŋ°ãšãã
ããåž ãĄããĻãããžãããčĒæ¸äŧãŽæšã§ããã
ãåģä¸ãĢã¯éĄį¸äģããŽįĩĩįģã¨ããŠãŗããŽå ãåããĻæˇĄãčŧãį˛žåˇ§ãĒãŦãŠãšį´°åˇĨãä¸Ļãã§ããã
ãä¸čēžãæŋįĨã§æ¯ãčŋããã¨ãˇãĨã¨čĻįˇãäē¤ãããčŋäēã¯æãã§ããĒããåŋĩãŽãããŽįĸēčĒã ã
ãįĩĻäģã¯æããä¸į¤ŧããåģä¸ãŽåĨĨã¸é˛ãã
ã
ã
ãæãéããĢéãããã¨ã渊ããĒå
ã¨éĻã°ãããããŗčļãŽéĻããæĩãčžŧãã§ããã
ãåēéãŽä¸å¤ŽãĢã¯éˇæēã¨æ¤ åãįŊŽãããåĨĨãŽčæãæ¤ åãĢåĨŗæ§ãåē§ãŖãĻãããįŊéãŽéĢĒãããŖããã¨įĩãããĻåˇĻčŠããåãĢæĩããĻãããįããæ¨ãŽåŽãŽãããĢį´ ãįŽã¯ãæˇĄįŊč˛ãŽčã¨ãŽå¯žæ¯ã§éįĢãŖãĻããã
ãåš´éŊĸã¯ããããĒããäēåäģŖããããĢãčĻããããéˇåŊį¨ŽæãĒããããŽååãäēååãããåžãã
ãįĒįļãŽč¨ĒååŽĸãĢ寞ããĻã垎åĄĩãåããĒãå§ŋåĸããã¯ãįĨæ§ã¨åēĻéãæããããããããĒåŊŧåĨŗãŽįŦãŋã¯ãæ§åãĢåããããããŽãŽãããĢæããã ãŖãã
ãããããããããåē§ãŖãĻãå¤åĨãŽããŧãã¯é æ ŽããĻããįå˛ããĄãããŽéĄãčĻããĒããŽã¯åĢã ãã
ãéŊæ°ãĒåŖ°ãĢãå ´ãŽįŠēæ°ãæããããĒãŖãæ°ãããã
ãįå˛ããĄãããããŽä¸č¨ã§ãåŊŧåĨŗãåãčĻããĻããĻããããã¨ãåŽæããã
ãããŧããåãéãĢã¯įˇåŧĩã§åãåãã ããåŋéŋãŽįŽãåĨåŖ°ã§å ąãããããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãããŽããŗãĢãã貴åĨŗãŽæãĄįŠã§ããīŧã
ãåã¯čä¸ãĢįŊŽããéããįŊãå¸ãåãåēãã¨ããããåŊŧåĨŗãĢčĻãããčŋįãĢčŋˇãŖããŽããæŖãĢä¸ĻãļéŖå¨ãčŖ éŖžãįēããĻåãčä¸ã¸ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ä¸įŦã ãčĻįˇãčĩ°ãããã
ããããã¨ãããæ°ãĢå ĨããŽä¸æãĒãŽã
ãåãĢåãį´ãã垎įŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ããĄããŖã¨įŠããīŧã
ãâĻâĻãããčĻããžããīŧã
ãčãéįŊãå¤åããĻããåã¯åãŽãžãžã ã¨ãčĄåã§į¤ēããĻããããåŋčēĢãŽä¸čĒŋãå¯ããĻãæ°é ããã§ããåŊŧåĨŗã ãããåŽå ĩã¨åæēãåæãĢæŧãå¯ããĻåĻįãčŋŊãã¤ããĒãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åžŽįŦãæšãããžãžįĩĻäģãĢååŗãéããæš¯æ°ãįĢãĻãéĻã°ãããããŗčļããåã¨åŊŧåĨŗãŽåãĢįŊŽãããã
ããžãã¯ããčļããéŖãã芹ã¯åžãĢããžãããã
ãåã¯čēĢãæŠãŖãĻã¨ãˇãĨãčĻããå¯ãããŽããäŊãč¨ããčŋãĨããĻãããŽãįĸēčĒããĻéŖãŽæ¤ åãåŧãã
ãéŖãĢéĸããĻã¯įĨããĒãããŠãæ°ããããŽãĢã¯čåŗãį¤ēãããčļã¨čļčåã§éŖãã°ãč °ãčŊãĄįããĻãããã¯ãã ãåŽļå ˇã¨éŖå¨ãŽæąãã¯ãããããčēĢãĢã¤ããĻããããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãåē§ããŽãåž
ãĄãåŊŧåĨŗãååŗãéããčŋŊå ãŽãããŗčļããã¨ãˇãĨãŽåãĢįŊŽãããã
ã
ã
ãåã¯ãĢããããįĢãĄä¸ã暯æ°ãéģãŖãĻčĻã¤ããã
ãåš´éˇč ãéĢãčēĢåãŽč ãįĢãĻããŽã¯æäŊéãŽį¤ŧåã ãå ãããĻåããšãã§ã¯ãĒãããžãã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽäŊæŗãčĻŗå¯ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åĒé ãĒäģčã§ãĢãããæãĢåããéããĢåŖãã¤ããã
ãâãå ãĢãŠããåæĻããããĢæ¸ãã åãŗãåãŋᎠããä¸åŖåĢããæããããããŗčļãŽéĻã°ããã¨å¤§å°ãŽæģåŗãåēããŖããã
ãéŖãŽãĢãããĢãįĩĻäģãæ°ãã䏿¯ãæŗ¨ãã§ãããããã䏿¯ãĢéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ãã¨ãˇãĨãæŗ¨ãį´ãįĩĻäģã¯å°æããĻãããããŽæ¸ŠåēĻãįãå§ããã
ããæ§ããĒããĢå°ããĒčļčåãã¤ãžãŋãåããå
ã大įˇãæšããĻčĻãã¨ãčŖ
ãããčĄããžã§ãŽå
¨ãĻãå ´éãã ã
ãé ãæŠãžããåãŽčĻįˇãĢã¨ãˇãĨãæ°ãĨããã訹ããããĒãäģã ãäģäēēãŽæ¯ãããããĻãããããã
ãæ°ãĢå ĨãŖãĻ貰ããĻč¯ããŖããã
ãå įŧãããšãąãããåŋĩå ĨããĢæ¤ããã¨ãˇãĨãĢããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åžŽįŦãŋãå´ŠããĒããåã¯čįŽã§čĻåŽããã¨ãĢããã
ãâãããĻåąæãŽæ¯åŋãã¨į´ æ´ãĒåŗãããå ĒčŊããååŧéŗãéŋããčĒįąéãããčĻč¨ããŖããããĢį´°ããĒæ°éŖããčĻãããã¨ãããããããŽé ã¯ã¯ãŦããæžéĄã ã
ãåããĻčĻãããŽãĢčåŗãåŧããããŋããã§ãã
ãããīŧãåĨŊåĨåŋããŖãąãã§ååŧˇįąåŋãĒãŽããčǰããĢäŧŧãĻããã¨æããĒãīŧã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įãŖį´ããĢåãčĻããį´ ãčšåŊŠãŽåĨĨãĢæŊãįŗããå ¨ãĻãčĻéãããã¨ããĻãããããĢæããããã
ã貴æšãä¸įĒæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããã¨ãã芹ããžããããīŧãããŽčãŽč˛ãĢã¤ããĻã
ãį¨ãã éããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽčēĢäŊãĢčĩˇããį°å¤ãŽįããįĨãŖãĻããã
ããŠããžã§įĨãŖãĻãããŽã ããīŧãåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊč
ãĒãŽã ãããīŧãäŊæ
ãä¸åą¤ãŽčĄã§čĒæ¸äŧãéããĻãããŽã ããīŧ
ãį§ãæã¯äģãŽåæããĄã¨åãč˛ã ãŖããããæãåĸãĢäģãŽč˛ãĢå¤ããŖããŽã
ãåã¯éããĢčŗãåžãããããã¨ã¯éãŽæšåã§ãå
įŧãããšãąãããåãŋå˛ããååŧããéŗãéŋãã
ãčãæãĢåžšããĻæ
å ąãéãããåæããĻæŖåĻãčĻæĨĩãããŽã¯ã帰ãŖãåžã§ããã帰ããã¨ãã§ããã°ãŽčŠąã ãâĻâĻã
ãįŽčį ã§ã¯ãĒãããåŽåŋããĻãããŽčãįįąãĢčŋĢåŽŗãåããããåŊãčŋŊããããã¨ããĒãããį§ãäŋč¨ŧããã
ãæåžãŽä¸č¨ãåĻãĢåŧãŖãããŖããæ éãĢč¨čãé¸ãã§ãããããĒæ¯åããŽæĒããæããã
ãåãŽčēĢäŊãĢäŊãčĩˇãããŽããåå ãæããĻãã ããã
ãįēããåãããåãĢãåŊŧåĨŗã¯å°ãå°ãŖããããĢčĻįˇãæŗŗãããã
ãããã¯ã芹ãã¨éˇããĒããŽãã
ãįĨããĒãã§ã¯ãĒãã芹ããĒãįįąãããæãĢäŊŋã常åĨåĨã ã
ãåēéãĢãããŽã¯åŊŧåĨŗã¨ä¸äēēãŽįĩĻäģã ããåŧˇåŧãĢæ
å ąãåŧãåēããã¨ããã¨ãˇãĨãĒãå¯čŊã ãæãããĻãããŽäžĄå¤ã¯ããã ãããīŧ
ã
ã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãããŗãĢããŽæãĄä¸ģãĒããã¨ãˇãĨã¨éĸčããããã¨ã¯įĸēåŽã ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãã¨ãˇãĨãĢæĩ寞åŋãåŽŗæãåããĒããŖããį°į¨ŽæãĢ寞ããĻãæãããĒįŠč
°ã§æĨããåēæŦæšéããä¸ãŖéĸã ããŽæŧæã§ã¯ãĒããŖããã¨ãŽč¨ŧæã§ãããã
ãéŖäēēã¨æ¨æļãäē¤ãããããĢåēäŧããããŽåããããŽãžãžåĨããããã§ã¨ãˇãĨãŽåąéēæ§ãįĨããĒããŽã ãįĨãŖãĻããã°ãéĢ䞥ãĒåŽļå ˇãčŖ éŖžãä¸ĻãļåŽĸéã¸éãã¯ãããĒãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãããŗčļãĢéŖŊãããŽã ãããčļčåãĢæãäŧ¸ã°ãé ģåēĻãæ¸ãŖããããŽãžãžæžãŖãĻãããĻåéĄãĒãã
ãåŋãéãåãŖãĻãããŽãã貴æšããĄãčĻãĻããã¨ããããĒæ°æãĄãĢãĒããã
ããžãã§äŊãŽäēæ ãįĨããĒãããŽãããĢãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åæ°ãĒãã¨ãåãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄåŖã ããé ãäēãåŊčŖ ãĢæ°ãåãį¨åŋæˇąãã¯ãĒãããĒããæ°ãĨããĻããĒãæ¯ãããããŽã ãããīŧ
ãåŊäēēã¯ãĢãããŽæš¯æ°ããŧãããįēããĻãããį æ°ãææ ĸããĻãããããĒčĻãįŽã ããčŦãįãããã¨čãããŽã¯æ°ãæŠããåˇŽãčŋĢãåąæŠããĒãæã¯ããã¤ããããĒãŽã ããã
ããããé æ ŽããĒãã§ã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãĢčĻįˇãæģããčļčåãå§ããĻãããã¨ãˇãĨãŽåĨčĄãĢåįļã¨ãã常čäēēãčŖ ããĢãéåēĻããããįãã°ããããĒããæ¯čĻã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãæ¸ãžãããããæãŖãĻč šãæąēãããã
ããģã¨ããŠã¯čĒæ¸äŧã§ãæ¯ãčãããĻããčļčåã ãåčĻã¯ã丸ãäšžįĨããããããŗãčã§į ŽčаããäŊããčĻãįŽã¯į´ æ´ã ããéĻãã¯įããæããããŖãããã
ãįå˛ããĄããã¯ãåŊãŽįžįļãĢéĸããĻããŠãŽį¨åēĻãžã§čããĻãããããīŧã
ãåã¯ãĢãããæēãĢæģããã
ãäēã¤ãŽåĸåãĢåããã寞įĢããĻãããã¨ãæšéŠãæąããčĨãäēēããĄãææŗãåēããåĸåãæĄå¤§ãããĻãããã¨ããã¤æĻåčĄįĒãčĩˇããŖãĻã䏿č°ã¯ãĒããã¨ã
ãčĻĒã¨čĻĒæãåããĻããåãåŖ˛ãã ãééããææãããĻããåãŽčããåĻåŽããããã¨ãĢã¯ãĒããĒãã
ããĄããŖã¨ã ãæ å ąãå¤ããããå§čĒæŽĩéã¯įĩããŖãĻãããŽããããĒããæĻåčĄįĒãå§ãžããĒããŽã¯äŊæ ãããīŧã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æãããĢ荿ŖããĻãæ°ããĒåããæããããĻãããããŽčŗĒåãĢã¯æļæ¸Ŧã§ããįããããĒãã
ãåã¯å įŧãããšãąããã䏿é ŦåŧĩãŖããčĻãį´ããŽæéį¨ŧãã ãčŋįæįĩļã¨čĻãĒãããĻä¸čŠã財ãæããããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯æåŋĢãããĢįŦãŋãæēĸããã
ãįå˛ããĄãããããæēįšãŽč§Ŗįã ããã¤ãžãããåæšãæããĻããããã ã¨ãį§ã¯æããŽãã
ããĒããģãŠãããŽč¨čã§åįšãããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãåãŽæ§æ ŧãįĨãŖãĻããããããĢį
§ããåããããĒããäē大åĸåãæããĻãããŽã¯å¤ąæããĻäŊããå¤ąããã¨ã
ãæŽæããåĸåããļã¤ããåãã°ãå¤ããŽæåŽŗãåēããéˇåŊį¨ŽæãæĨæŋãĢæ°ãæ¸ãããĻįĩąįåãå¤ąãã°ãčããããĻããį°į¨ŽæãåäšąãčĩˇãããĢã¯įĩļåĨŊãŽæŠäŧã ã
ãåãčĻŗå¯ããĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯æēčļŗããĢãĢãããåžããã
ãåģēåŊįĨ芹ãčĻããĻãããããīŧãčĄã§å ŦéãããĻãããŽã¯į°ĄįĨåãããããŽãįåŽãŽä¸é¨ãĢãããĒããã
ãįĩĻäģãĢå°įŽąãæãŖãĻæĨãããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æčĸãåĩããæã§å¤ãŗãį´ãåãåēããã
ãå¤č˛ããį´éĸãĢå¤ãæåãä¸Ļãã§ããã
ãįĩãããŦåŦãĢįĨããæ§ããč ããã¨ãĢãéĸ¨ãäŧ´ãåŋããåŖ°ã¯ãæ¨ã ãæēããã大å°ãåŧãčŖããããŽæã夊ä¸ãĢãåąãį°įã¸ãŽå ĨãåŖãéãããã
ãåãŽįĨããĒãä¸į¯ã ãããããčĄå¤ããŽčĒæ¸äŧ补å°ã§čããåãč¨ãããĻãããããã¯åļįļã ãããīŧ
ããžãããåããĒãįĨãåŽå¨ããã¨īŧã
ãå¯įŠčĒãå˛åŽãå ãĢããĻãããĒããĻãäģããč¨ãããĻãäŋĄãéŖããã§ããããããæããããå 厚ã¯åæã§ãéãããč ããįĨããĒãéčĻæŠå¯ãŽã¯ãã ã
ãåãåãŋããĢãããĢæŽãŖããããŗčļãčĻã¤ããã
ãįĨããã¨ã¯æĨŊãããããæãŖãĻãããŽãĢå ãčããŽãæããåãĢįĨãčŗæ ŧã¯ãããŽã ãããīŧãæéããäēēéãã§ããã°ãããããŽæãĢåãã§čĻæãčļŗããĻããĒããã¨ãįæããã
ãį§å¯ãŽäŋæč
ãįįąããĒãæããã¯ãããĒããæ°ãĨããĒãå
ãĢæˇąãŋã¸čļŗãč¸ãŋå
Ĩããåžæģãã§ããĒãå ´æãžã§æĨãĻããžãŖããŽã ãäģãŽčǰã§ããĒããįšåž´ãåæããĒãåãã
ãããæãã°ãä¸å¨åãŖãĻäŊã芹ãįãŖãĻããžããããĒãã
ã芹ãŽįļããčžéãããã¨ã¯å¯čŊã§ããããīŧã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æåžãŽä¸åŖãéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ãã¨ãéããĢįããã
ãããŽå ´åãįå˛ããĄãããĢã¯ããåŽļãĢ帰ãŖãĻ貰ããã
ãåãᎠãäģãããããĒæ¯čĻãããčĨ˛ããåãåãŋãããã
ãčǰãŽåãåãããčŋˇæãããããĢåä¸äēēã§įããĻčĄããã¨ã¯ä¸å¯čŊã ãåãĢé¸ææ¨Šã¯ãĒãã
ãäģãŽã¯ããĄããŖã¨æå°æĒãéããããããŠãããĻã芹ãŽįļããčããĻ貰ããããĻâĻâĻã
ãčĻįˇãããã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æ¤ åãŽčãĢčēĢãé ããããŖããå¯ãã§ããã
ã帰ããããĒããĒãããããĢæŽã鏿čĸãããããåŋčĢãéčĻĒãäŋč¨ŧäēēãŽæįļãã¯åŋ čĻã ãããŠã䏿ĨäēéŖãĢããčļã¨ãčåãæŧå¯äģãããŠããããīŧã
ãčŗãįãŖãĻéĄãä¸ããã¨ãįéĸįŽãĒéĄãåããããĻãããããããįããåĸããčŋįãĢ芰ãžããį¤žäē¤čžäģ¤ã ã¨ãããŖãĻãããŽãĢãå¤ĸãŽãããĒįŠēæŗãé ãéããŖãã
ãé
åįãĒãææĄã§ãããä¸åēĻæãĄå¸°ããįļãã¯æĨãæšããĻã¨ãããŽã¯īŧã
ãįĻãããããŖããčããĻãããĻč¯ããŽãã
ãããåãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ã䏿č°ãĒįŊããããéĻãįĢã¤ãĢãããæēãããã
ã
ãéčĻæŠå¯ã ãããŠãįžåŽéĸãããå
厚ã ãããã芹ãããŽãæĸãĢåˇģãčžŧãžããĻããäģĨä¸ãįĨããĒããžãžã§ããæšãåąéēã ãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯čĒãå§ããã
ãåģēåŊäģĨæĨãâįĨéããâãŽååŧã¯ä¸æãåãäģåãŖãĻãããããããŠãéŠæ°æ´žã¯ãããŽå°ãĢį ããįĨããį˛åŧãã大å°ã¨åŊãæ´ģæ§åãããéå ˇãĢå¤ãããã¨įŽčĢãã ãã§ããåŊŧããĢã¯ååŧãŽæé ãįĨãčĄããĒããã ãããååŧãĢäģå ĨããĻãããŽä¸ģå°æ¨ŠãåĨĒããã¨ããã
ãåžč´ããĻããããäēã大ãéããĻåãĢã¯įĄéĸäŋããã ã
ãįˇåŧĩãįˇŠãŋãčŠãčŊã¨ããåã¯ãįĄæčãĢã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãĻããããã¤ããŽãããĢčĻįˇãčŋããĻããããããäģĨå¤ãĢååŋã¯ãĒãã
ãããŽä¸įŦé
ããŽčĻįˇã¯ãææãæĒãã éĄãčĻããããĒæčĻãåŧãŗčĩˇãããäģãããžããĢã ãŖããäžãããĒããä¸įãæ¸ããĻãįč§ŖãåžãĒã䏿ĄįããåēãŽįĨããĒãéãŽæãĻãčĻããããĒæ°åã ã
ãčĻįˇãåãããå ã§ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æ æã¨ãææĢã¨ãã¤ããĒãįŧåˇŽããã¨ãˇãĨãĢåããĻããã
ããããĻãåŦåããããŽãåŊŧãįĨãŽãäžäģŖãããæŦ įãããäēēãŽåŊĸãããåįŊãã¨åŧãļäēēããããã
ãįŗãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ãããĢãåŋãéãæ˛ãã
ãâåĻåŽãããæ°æãĄãæš§ãčĩˇããčŖã§ãåŊŧåĨŗãåããč¨čãŽä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ãããããžã§įŽãčããčããĒããããĢããĻããįŠēįŊãĢããŋãĒã¨åĩãžãčžŧãã ã
ãįĄįĨã§įĄé įã§é常čãäēēééĸãããæĒåã¨ä¸å¯č§ŖãĒå垊åãææ
ãŽæŦ åĻãããŽå
¨é¨ããä¸ã¤ãŽäēåŽã ãã§čĒŦæã§ããĻããžãã
ãéæžããĢã¯ã§ããĒããæåšåŠį¨ãčŋéãåļããĒããĒããéãčžŧããĻįŽĄįããããããåŊä¸åą¤é¨ãŽæąēåŽãã
ãčĒãįļããåŖ°ããåįļã¨ããåãįžåŽãĢåŧãæģããã
ããžãéĄãįĨããĒãčǰããŽæąēåŽã ãåã¯åžãã ããããããããããŖã¨ã
ãčĢĻåŋĩãĢæ˛ãåãŽčĄ¨æ ãäģčããåéåŋãčĒãŋåããã¨ã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽįŽãĢãä¸å¯čŊã ãŖãã ããããããĒããŽããåãŽä¸ãĢæŽãŖãĻããã¯ãããĒãã
ãįĩĻäģããããŗã¨æ¸éĄãåãåããããŽæéĸãĢįŽãčŊã¨ããįŦéãæããæ¯ãåãã ã
ãæŦåĨį´ãĢãããčĸĢäŋčˇč ãŽéčĻĒãããŗäŋč¨ŧäēēãŽæ¨ŠåŠã¨įžŠåã¯ããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸãģãĒãĢãģãŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšãĢį§ģč˛ãããããŽã¨ããã
ãįŊ˛åæŦãĢã¯æĸãĢåãŽä¸ĄčĻĒãŽåã¨ãčĻčĻããŽãĒãåãč¨ãããĻãããæŽãããįŠēæŦã¯ãåãŽæŋčĒã ãã
ãä¸įæļ¯ã¤ããžã¨ãããããŽã¨čĢĻããĻãããč§ŖæžãĒãŠåããŠãã ãæãã§ãåŊŧãã¯č¨ąå¯ããĒããããäŋĄããĻãããŽãĢããŠããĒæšæŗã§čĒŦåžãããŽã ããīŧ
ããããžã§ãŽčĻå´ãåĒåãå˛įŦãããŽããã ãæĸãžãŖãĻããéã¯äŊãããĻãåããĒããŖããŽãĢãä¸åēĻåãåēãã°čǰãĢãæĸããããĒãéãã§čģĸããčŊãĄãĻãããããĒã
ãã ãããčĻæãæąēããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã
ãåã¯čŗãįãããĢåą ãããĒããŖãã
ãããžããĢãį´į˛ã§åąéēãĒãæŦ įãã¨ããŠãäģãåãŖãĻããããį ´åŖč ã§ãããããããããããį¯ãåãĢå¤ãããã貴æšãé¸ãļãŽããįå˛ããĄããã
ãåžãäģãĢã鏿čĸããããé¸ãᅪŠåŠããåãĢããããããĒč¨ãæšã
ãįĩĻäģããããŗã¨æįļããŽæ¸éĄãåãåããããŽæéĸãį¨ãã§ããåã¯ãč¨čãŽæåŗãįč§ŖãåãããĢéĄãä¸ããã
ãâĻâĻå°ããčããããĻãã ããã
ãæéããããããŖã¨įĩãåēããããĢãããã ãįããã
ããããããŖããčããĻãæéãŽįļäēã¯å°ããĒãåģļã°ããããŽãįå˛ããĄããã¯į§ãé ŧããč¨ĒããĻããããŽã ãããäģåēĻããæåž ãĢåŋããĻãŋãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įŠãããĢ垎įŦãã ã
ãæįļããæ¸ããžã§ãŽéãåŋ ãããåŽļãĢæģãåŋ čĻã¯ãĒããããããĢįãžããĒããåŊŧãŽčĻŗå¯č¨é˛ãæåēããĻãããããīŧãåŋčĢãį´ã¨įč¨å ˇã¯į¨æããã
ãäģãĢãåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊã芹ããĻããããįĨããĒãããåã¯čãäēãĢå¤ĸä¸ã§ããģã¨ããŠčãããĻããĒããŖãã
ããžã äŋĄããããĒãããããĒãã¨ãæŦåŊãĢããåžãã ããããåŊã¨ä¸æãŽéåŊãåˇĻåŗãããģãŠãŽé¸æãåãĢč¨ããããĒããĻããããčǰã訹ãã ããīŧ
ãããŖããåŊŧåĨŗãŽįŽįã¯äŊã īŧ
ãåŊãŽä¸åą¤ã¯į´åžããã§ããããīŧã
ãčŗĒåãčŗãĢããåŊŧåĨŗã¯čãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ãåäžããĒããĻã寞åŋãĢčŋŊãããĻãããŽããåŊãæĒãåēĻãĢįŽãčĻãžãã¨č¨ãäŧããããįĨããŽããŽããæĒãŋãįĄãĢéããšãéŖããããåäŊããæãã¯ãå ¨ãåĨãŽäŊãâĻâĻã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãįēãã¤ã¤åŊŧåĨŗã¯čĒãįļãããæéĸãããŽã¨ãˇãĨã¯ã鎿ēãŽåãããŽåŖãį¨ãã§ãããåŖãŽåãããį¨ãã§ããå¯čŊæ§ããããããããã¯æ˛šæã§ããĒããåļįļã§ãĒããĒãåĢãĒå ãã ã
ãããããĢããĻããæåšåŠį¨ããããŽãä¸åą¤é¨ãŽæŦéŗããæĻįˇãåēãããã¯ãĒãããåãæã¯å¤ãæšãč¯ãã
ãæĻåčĄäŊŋãéŋããĻįŠäēãč§ŖæąēããããŽã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæŦéŗã ãããããããåŊãææŗã§äēåããæäģŖãĢãä¸åą¤ãå ¨äŧä¸č´ã§äēæŋããã¨ã¯æããĒããã¨ãˇãĨãæŧãããåžã§ãåŧˇåŧãĢčĒŦåžããč šįŠããã ãããīŧ
ãįĩĻäģãŽæ°ã¯æ¸ãŖãĻããĒãããåąæˇãŽäŊŋį¨äēēãä¸äēēã ããŽã¯ãããĒããéĄãé ããĻããããŠããããŽįĩĻäģã¯į°į¨Žæã ãããããã¯čĻååĄããåļæãįããã ããŽčĻæãåãã ããã
ãčĻæããšãã¯ãåŊãŽæ˛ģåŽãåŽãæĻčŖ įĩįšã ãéˇčŠąãããĻããéãĢåŧã°ããå ¨åĄã§äšãčžŧãžããĻããžãŖãåžã§ã¯ãčǰãåŊŧããįĄäēã§æ¸ãžãĒãã
ãåŋ čĻãĒæĄäģļãããã°č¨ãŖãĻãåãŽåŽļããæãĄåēãããįŠã¨ããä¸įēæŽ´ãããã¨ããåžčĻäēēã¨ããĻįĢäŧãããĻ貰ããããčŠĻããŖãĻãã¨ã§ãæ°æĨŊãĢå§ããĻãŋããŽã¯ããŠããããīŧã
ãįĻãŖãį´ æ¯ããä¸åčĻããĒãåŊŧåĨŗãŽææĄã¯ãã¨ãĻãé åįã ããįžåŽįã ãããŖã¨åã¯åããĻããĒãã
ãããããįĢå ´ãåŧąãč ãŽéŊåãåŧˇãč ã¯æģãæŊ°ãããŠããĒ叿ãåŖãĢããĻããč¸ãŋčēããããŽãåŧąč ãŽå¸¸ãįĩæã¯įŽãĢčĻããĻããã
ãéĸåäēã¯æ˛ãæ˛ãã§ããæéãã§åŦåãããã¨äģ°ããäžäģŖããĒãããŽããčŋãããã°ãããĄããŽįŽįã¯éæãããžãããīŧãããããĻ፿¸ãŋãĢãĒãŖãåããããããåŽå ¨ãĢåēãĻčĄããã¨ãã訹ããã ãããžããīŧã
11
ãâæ¸ŠããĒåēéå
¨äŊãŽįŠēæ°ããä¸įŦãĢããĻåãã¤ãããããĢéãžãčŋãŖãã
ãâåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãå°ãå°æãããããĒįŽã§åãčĻãĻããã大æĩãŽå¤§äēēãĒãééĢĒãå
ĨããčĒŦåžãčŠĻãŋãĻãæåžããããã¨ãããããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽæčĻãåãŋᎠããä¸ã§ãããããšãč¨čãæĸããĻãããŽã ãããåŖããããŽãåãããããĒįŽã§čĻãããããã¯ãããŖã¨ããˇã ã
ãéŖãĢããã¨ãˇãĨã¯éĸåŋããĒããŽããä¸åŋãĢčŗãåžããĻãããŽããčēĢåããããĒãã
ãâãĒãããããĒãã¨ãč¨ãããŽããčŊįããããĻãããããããĒãįĩãčĒãæãĄåããããĒæčĄãį¯ããŽããåãŽäēēįãä¸åãŽæŦãĢãããããĻčĒãč
ãåå¨ããã°ããããĒįåãæããããįŊĩåãããĢéããĒããåæ
ãįĩãĒãŠã¨åŧã°ããããŽããįããä¸ã§äŊãŽåŠããĢãĒãīŧ
ãåã¯ãããŽæĨãŽč¨æļãĢčãĒããããĻããĒãã
ãâââ
ãâããŽæĨãčĒæ¸äŧãŽįŠēæ°ã¯ããã¤ãĢãåĸããĻãļã¯ãļã¯ããĻããããįĨããĒããä¸ģåŦč ãéĄãčĻãããžã§ãåã¯čŗãåĄããããĢããĻæŦãčĒãŋé˛ããã
ãäģæĨã¯å°æĨãŽå¤ĸãŽįē襨äŧã§ããčããĻæĨãĻããããããīŧã
ãâä¸ģåŦč
ãŽįēč¨ãčããĻæįļã¨ãããéĸåčããŖãĻã¤ããŗããŽæĨã ãã¯éŋããĻãããŽãĢãæŦãŽįļããæ°ãĢãĒãããžããåŋããĻããã
ãįãæēãé¨åąãŽé
ãĢį§ģåãããæ¤
åãåããåãåŊĸãŽčŧĒãĢãĒãããä¸ĻãšãĻãããčĒåãŽæ¤
åãæãŖãĻčŋˇãŖãĻããéãĢãäģãŽåããĄã¯æ
Ŗããæ§åã§ããããã¨čĄåããĻããã
ãããˇãŖãŽéŖãĢåē§ãããåãä¸äēēäģĨä¸ããĻãå°ãæããäģã¯ãéããã ãŖãã
ãâæēåãæ´ãã¨ãæĒå¤ĸãŽãããĒæéã¯å§ãžãŖããä¸äēēãã¤ãããŽå ´ã§įĢãĄä¸ãããįē襨ããĻããã
ããããåŊããåã¨č¨ããããĢčŋˇãããĒãã ãŠããčĒãããã ãåã¯įž¨ãžãããããĒåžãããããããĒæ°æãĄãĢãĒãŖããæŦãŽįļããæ°ãĢãĒããããŠãäģããéãåēãããã
ãåãããŽå¸ã§ããˇãŖãčĻãĻããã
ãâé įĒãčŋãĨãã¨ãåŋčãéŗãįĢãĻå§ãããæąã°ãæãŽåšŗãæã§æãŖãã
ãæŦĄã¯ãįå˛ããĄãããã
ãâããŖããåŽįãããĸãåã§åŧã°ããåã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããčĻįˇãéãžãŖãã
ã䏿ãĢ芹ããã¨æããĒããĻãč¯ããŽãããŖãããčĒåãŽããŧãšã§č¯ããŽãīŧã
ãâä¸åēĻã¯åŖãéããããĻéãããįē襨ããåžãŽãã¨ãæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻãåã¯äŊãč¨ããĒããŖãã
ãâĻâĻããããĒããããžã æąēããããžããã
ãâä¸ģåŦč ã¯å°ãéŠãããããĢįŦããããããŠããããĢæãããįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻé ˇããã
ãããīŧããããĒããã芹ãããŖããčããĻčĄãŖãĻããäŊãčĻã¤ããããįĨããĒãããčĻã¤ãããããã¤ã§ãčãããĻã
ãâåãå¸ãĢåē§ãã¨ãããˇãŖãŽéŖã§åĨŗãŽåããĄãã¯ãšã¯ãšã¨įŦãŖãĻããã
ãįē襨äŧãįĩããŖã帰ãéãåã¯įŦãã§æŠããĻããã
ããŋããĒãããããĒå¤ĸãããŖãĻããããããŗãŽããŗåąããã大åˇĨãããææãĢčå°åĨŗåĒãéčãč˛ãĻãäēēã¨ãã
ãâčåžããčãããĻãããŽã¯ããˇãŖãŽåŖ°ã ãŖããčŋŊããããĻæĨããããã
ãâĻâĻãããããã ãã
ãâįĄčĻãããã¨æãããĒããããĢãåã¯é ˇããĒãããããã ãįããã
ãããããããããã¨æŦåŊãĢãĒããŽīŧãæŦãčĒãäģĨå¤ãĢã
ãâéĄãčĻãčžŧããããĢããĻãããˇãŖã¯å°ããĻãããåã¯éĄãé¸ãããã
ãããŽåããĄããããĒ芹ãããĻįŦãŖãĻãã
ãâį´ ãŖæ°ãĒãåŖ°ã ãŖããããˇãŖãč˛Ŧããæ°ãĒããĻãĒããŖããŽãĢâĻâĻã
ãčãããĄããŖãĻããã ãã´ãĄãŗããããļããæĒæ°ã¯ãĒãã¨æããŽã
ãåĨãĢæãŖãĻãĒãããæŦãčĒãã§ã°ããã§åããĒãããåéãããĒãããã§ããīŧãåã¯æ°ãĢããĒãã
ãããŖīŧīŧãåã ãĄãããĒããŽīŧãä¸äēēãīŧã
ãâããˇãŖãéŠãããããĢ大ãããĒæŧæããããåã¯æēãæ¯ãåããĻæĩããã
ãâåŊįļãŽãããĢå˛ãžããĻããããˇãŖãĢã¯ãįãããŽãããããĒããããĢãĢãããĻããå¯čŊæ§ãįãŖãããŠãæ§ããé˛ããã§ããéģãčžŧãã§čļŗãæĸããããˇãŖãæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻæ¯ãčŋãã
ãåã ãĄãããĒããŽīŧãã¨ãŖããĢåã ãĄã ã¨æãŖãĻããŽãĢã
ãâãããĒč¨čãæããããéĻãåžããããããčĻãããˇãŖã¯ããĢãŖããã¨įŦéĄãåãæģãã
ãįĩĩãæããŽãåĨŊãã§ããīŧãäģåēĻã§ããããå°æĨãŽå¤ĸãããããĢãæããĻãã
ãâããč¨ãæŽãã¨ãããˇãŖã¯æĨãéãčĩ°ãŖãĻåŧãčŋããã
ãâäģåēĻã¯č¨ĒããĒããŖãã
ãæŦĄãŽčĒæ¸äŧéåŦæĨãįĨãããåããčĒæ¸äŧãŽé¨åąã¯ãååŊã¨æļãĢæ˛ãã ãåäžã°ãããįãŖãĻčĨ˛ããããéãéãĢééããããããåã ããåãæŽããããŋãããĢæŧãéģãŖãĻãåšŗįļã¨æŦãåēããĻããã
ãčǰãããåĨŊãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåå¨ãįãã åæãŽé°čŦãĢããããåŽåŽļãįļãčĄãŽäŊæ°ãįŦéĄãĢãããã¨ããå¤ĸã¯ãæ°¸é ãĢįĩļããããŽã ã
ããããĒåãčĻĒéĄããčãããŽã¯ãéååžãŽãã¨ã ãŖãã
ãâââ
ãâããŽæĨãĢåãåĻãã ãŽã¯ãį°į¨Žæã᏿ãĢåŋãéããããã¨ãŽåąéēæ§ãį´æĨãŽåå ãåã§ã¯ãĒããŖãã¨ããĻããéĸãããĒããã°éŋããããããįĨããĒãã
ããããããåãĢåãåĻãã§ãããŽã¯ã大ããĒå¤ĸãčĒãã°å˛įŦããããã¨ãäģč
ãĢåŋã訹ãã°ãå¤ąãŖãæãčŖåãããæãŽįãŋãåĸããã¨ã
ã大åãĢæãã°æããģãŠåŧąįšãĢãĒãã䞥å¤ããããŽãåŧąč
ãäŋæãįļãããĒãŠæąēããĻåļããĒããæŗŖãį¸ãŖãĻãįä¸å°ŊãĢåĨĒãããæ¨ãã§ãæãã§ãåžæãĢčãžããã ãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¨ãŽéãĢããå¤ĸãããåæ
ããĒãŠã¨ããčãä¸įĸēããĒåšģæŗãæãĄčžŧãžãĒããį´įļãĒåŠåŽŗéĸäŋã ãã§åŋ
čĻååã ãäēåēĻã¨ééããčĩˇãããĒããããĢã
ãâåēäŧãŖãĻäģĨæĨããåĨį´ããäē¤ãããčĻãããĒããäēããĢåŠį¨ãåãäģĨå¤ãŽéĸäŋã¯ãĒããŽã ãããåã¯äŊãčŖåãŖãĻãĒãŠããĒãã
ãâ
ãéĸãããããããžãããåŊã¯æããã§ãããããããĢä¸ģäēēã¯ããžããããåãäģ˛äģåŊšãĢæŽããã¨ããã§įŽĄįãããžããĻãäŊŋåŊšãĒãŠä¸å¯čŊã§ããã
ãåã¯ä¸Ąæã§å ãã ãĢãããĢåããĻåãæ¨ãĻããåŖãĢä¸Ļãļįēå čãŠãŗããŽå ãæēãããčǰããŠããĒ襨æ ãããĻãããčĻãããĒããčŊčããéĄãĢåˇã¤ããæ ãĻãĻåãå ĨããããĒč¨čãæĸããĻããžãã
ãâĻâĻãåãŽææãå°éããã
ãæˇĄã
ã¨ããåŖ°éŗã§čŋãããŽã¯ã¨ãˇãĨã ãŖãã
ãäģäēēãåãæ¨ãĻãčĒåˇąä¸åŋįãĒ鏿ãæį¤ēããåãĢ寞ããæããčĢĻåŋĩããĒããå§åããããĻč°čĢãŽæšåæ§ãæŖãæåŗããĒããĒãéģčĒãé¸ãã ã¯ããããŽãŠãĄãã§ããĒãååŋããåãŽč¸ãããããããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãčĻįˇãã¨ãˇãĨãĢåããæããã垎įŦãŋãããã
ãåŖ°ãčããĻåŦãããã貴æšãŽæčĻãčãããĻããããããīŧãã夿ŗããŽįã§éåŽŋãįļããããããŽé¸åŽ ã§ä¸čĒįąãŽãĒãæŽããããããã
ãéŖåޤãŽéãčĄæãäŧãããæēãæŦæŖãĢįĄŦãããŽããļã¤ãããããĒéŗã ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ä¸įŦįãä¸ããįĩĻäģãĢåããĻåãã
ãæŖãããéãããããããĄããŖã¨į´ããĻæĨãĻã
ãįĩĻäģã¯ä¸į¤ŧããĻéŖåޤãĢįļãæããåēãĻčĄãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨããįĨãŽäžäģŖãã¨č¨ããĒãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įæãæąããĻãããããĒį´ æ¯ãããĒããåįãŽįĨæ§ãæãĄãåšŗåįãĒéĸäŋãį¯ããå¯čŊæ§ããããã¨ãäēãčĒčããĻãããŽã ããã
ãå寞éŖãŽã¨ãˇãĨãĢčĻįˇãį§ģãã¨ãåįŧãĢéããįŧã¨įĢæ¯čļããĢåãčĻãĻããã
ãįãã˛ãããæēãæ¯ãåãã
ãæ¨Ēæ´ãĒåŧˇč
ãĢéãããĒãčĸĢåŽŗč
ãčŖ
ãŖãĻãåŊŧåĨŗãĢåŠããæąãããã¨ãˇãĨããč§ŖæžãããįŽæŽĩããäŊãŽæåŗããĒããĒããããĒä¸č¨ã§æŊ°ããã
ãįå˛ããĄãããĢã¯ãæ é¤ãŽããéŖäēã¨åŽå ¨ãĒį°åĸãåŋ čĻã ããįæŋãã፿ããããåŋ čĻãĒãå¤åēį¨ãŽå¤čŖ éå ˇããæĒãææĄã§ã¯ãĒãã¨æããŽã ãããŠīŧã
ãã¨ãˇãĨäŧãĢ丸ãčžŧããã¨čĻčžŧãã ãããĢäģãå ããããã
ãå¤åĨãč
°åˇģããĢããå§ŋãŽã¨ãˇãĨããäģãããĒãˇãŖãŦãĢįŽčĻããã¨ã¯æããĒããããã§ããæ°æ
å ąãčĻãĻč§ĻããæŠäŧãĢã¯éĸåŋãį¤ēããéæĄå
åŊšã¨ããĻčĒããĻããã°ãããæŦæĨãĒãä¸čĻãĒãã¨ãĢæ°ãããããŽã ã
ãåŊäģ¤ãį´°ããæį¤ēãåĢãåããäēį´°ãĒč¨čå°ģãĢä¸åŋĢãį¤ēããĻãæžãŖãĻįŊŽãã ããéģãŖãĻãããã¨ã§é ãäēãåĸãããĻããæ§čŗĒãæã¤ããåã§čŦããĒããŽãã¨ãˇãĨã ã
ãåãåŊŧåĨŗãŽææĄãæįĩļããĻ帰ãããã¨č¨ãã°ãããŽč¨čãĢåããĒãéããã¨ãˇãĨã¯čãå
Ĩããã ãããéĸčãããåŊŧåĨŗãĢã¯æãåēããĒãåŊĸã§ãããŽå ´ãéãåēããããįĨããĒãã
ãåéĄã¯ãããŽåžã
ãæˇąãæ¯ãåããæēãĢčĻįˇãčŊã¨ããã
ãâĻâĻčĻãããĢãįŽĄįå¯čŊã¨ããč¨ŧæ ãä¸åą¤é¨ãĢį¤ēããã貴æšã¯ãããŽä礿¸ææãåžããåã¯čĄŖéŖäŊãäŋč¨ŧãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯čŋŊãããĒããĒãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯é ˇããįŠãããĢ垎įŦãã
ããããįå˛ããĄãããæãčĒįąãĢã¯é ãããįĨããĒããããã¯ã夿ŗããģãŠéãã§ã¯ãĒããããŠãåŽåŽããįæ´ģãåžããããåŊãŽå𞿏ãæå°éãĢæãããããã
ãåã¯čãŽéãæĄããããĒããč¨čãé¸ãļã
ãčĻŗå¯č¨é˛ã¯č˛´æšãčĒčēĢããįĩĻäģãĢäģģããã°č¯ããŽã§ã¯īŧã
ãį§ãåŋããčēĢãĒãŽããåąæˇãŽįĩĻäģããĄããæéå¤ãĢã¯åŽļæã¨éããčĒįąãčĒããĻãããŽãéŠæéŠæãĢåžšããĒãã¨äŊäēã䏿ãåããĒããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽč¨ãéããč¨é˛äŋã¯åĄäēēåããŽå°åŗãĒäģäēã ã
ãįŠēããįŋãååããĻãæ°ããčåãéãļįĩĻäģãĢįŽãåãããéĄãčãé ããĻããããŠãįĩĻäģã¯å
¨åĄãį°į¨Žæã ã
ãå´åč
ãäŊŋãæŊ°ããŽã¯įãã芹ã§ããĒãããããŽåĨŗä¸ģäēēã¯æŦæ°ã§æŽããæšåãčããĻãããŽããįĨããĒããåã§ããã°ãįĩĻäģããĄããįŦįšãŽįˇåŧĩæãäŧããã¯ãã ã
ãé¨åąãŽå¤ã¸įļãæã¯äēã¤ãåģä¸ããå
ĨãæãĢéãŖã大ããĒæã¨ã鎿ēãŽåãããĢããå°ããĒæã
ãéããããããŽč¨čãäŊåēĻãæãåãããããã¤ãžã§ãåĻšãįŊŽããĻéãįļãããããĢã¯ãããĒãã
ãæˇąãæ¯ãåããĻãåšŗéãčŖ
ãŖãåŖ°ã§åã¯æĄäģļãåēãã
ãåŽļãĢåĻšãããã¯ãã§ããäŧãããĻãã ãããåĻšãæããĒããä¸įˇãĢæŽãããããåãč¨ããŖãĻãããžãããīŧã
ãããŖããã¨įŦãããĻãåŊŧåĨŗã¯é ˇããã
ãããããããĢæŽããĒããåĻšãĄãããäŊäēēã¨ããĻåãå Ĩããããįæ´ģã¨åŽå ¨ã¯äŋéããã
ãčĻįˇãæ¨Ēã¸æĩãã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æ°ããįŋãŽčåãįēããĻããããããåãåããĻčĻãčåã ã
ãč¸ãŽåĨĨãä¸įŦã ãčģŊããĒããã§ããåŽå ĩãããĢã¯æŠããéåãĒä¸åäēēãŽé¸æãĒãŠæ¨Šåã§į°ĄåãĢčĻãããåŖį´æãåæ
ãĢãããã
ãäŋč¨ŧäēēãŽæ¸éĄã¯åĻšã¨čŠąãåãŖãåžãäēäēēã§įŊ˛åããĻæåēããåŊĸãĢãããĻãã ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯é ˇããæčĸčļããĢæãæãĄéŗ´ãããã
ããããæ§ããĒãããä礿¸æįĢãã
ããããååŗãĢã¨ãˇãĨãäŊãå¸ãŖãã
ãå
ĨãŖãĻãč¯ããããĩããĢã
ã
ãéŖåޤãĢįšããæãéããéå
ˇãŽæĻããįĄŦãéŗãæˇˇãããæĻčŖ
ããįˇãŽįģå ´ã§ãé¨åąãŽįŠēæ°ãåŧãᎠãžãŖãã
ãåŊŧãŽčĻįˇãé¸åŽ
ãŽåĨŗä¸ģäēēãæŦĄãã§ã¨ãˇãĨãĢæŗ¨ãããã
ã
ã䏿ŠåãĢåēãĻãåŊŧåĨŗãĢåãį´ãŖãã
ãä礿¸ã¯æįĢãããč¨ŧäēēã¨ããĻįĢãĄäŧãŖããã¨ãä¸ãĢå ąåãããããã§ãããĒīŧã
ãããŽä¸æŠåĢãĒåŖ°ãĢã¯čĻãããããååãŽéŋããĢãã
ãæŖåŧãĒå ąåã¯å°ãåž ãŖãĻãããããããīŧãåĻšããã¨čŠąãæéãåŋ čĻãĒãŽãåæĨåãŽčϺ坿ĨčĒã¨åãããĻæåēãããĻããããīŧã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯čģŊãé ˇããčŊãĄįããåŖ°ã§čŋããããããĢ寞ããčĻå´æ§ãŖãŊãį˛ãã襨æ ãŽįˇã¯æˇąã大ããæ¯ãåãã
ãäēæŋããã
ãäēäēēãŽããåããčãæŧãããĒãããåã¯įĨįĩãéä¸ãããã
ãããŽæåž
ãäŊæãĢãéčĻæĄäģļã¯åæ°ãĒãįĩããŖãããããåŊŧã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãĢåˇããããĒä¸įĨãæããã
ãäŊč¨ãĒãã¨ãããã°įļäēã¯åŗæãĢįĩãããã
ãããã ãč¨ãæŽããĻãåģä¸ã¸įļãæããåēãĻčĄãŖããåŊŧã¯ä¸åą¤čĄã§čĻãããåļæãŽįˇã ãæĻåŽįšæãŽéãįŽã§ã¨ãˇãĨãį¨ãŋãå¨åãããããĒæ åēĻã§æãåēããã
ãæãéããããåãŗéå¯ãæģãã
ãæŽãããįŠēæ°ãĢã¯ãįˇåŧĩãŽäŊéģã螿ŋãæŧãŖãĻããã
ã
ãâ
ãįĩĻäģãŽæĄå
ã§éãããååŽ¤ãŽæãéãããããã¯æé¤ãčĄãåąããį°Ąį´ ãĒé¨åąã ãŖããææēã¨æ¤
åãĢå¯å°ãæäŊéãŽåŽļå
ˇãæããããæ¸
æŊãĒå¸åŖãžã§į¨æãããĻãããææēãĢã¯į´æã¨įč¨å
ˇãŽä¸åŧã
ãįĩĻäģã¯ææēãŽåˇĻæ¨ĒãŽåŖãĢįēå
čãŠãŗããæããä¸į¤ŧããĻé¨åąãåēãĻčĄãŖããåŖãĢã¯įĩĩæŦãŽæŋãįĩĩã§čĻããããĒįĩĩįģãæããããĻãããå°ä¸ãŽéĸ¨æ¯įģã ãããīŧ
ãåã¯æ¤
åãåŧããĻč
°æãããéˇã䏿¯ãæēĸãããåæĨåãĢããĻã¯å¤éããį´æãã䏿ãåŧãæããã¤ãŗã¯åŖˇã¯čããé ãå ´æãĢįŊŽããčãĢįŊŽããããããŗčļãŽæš¯æ°ãįēããã
ãæãčŋãã°ãå§ãããįĩãããžã§äģįĩãžããĻãããŽã§ã¯ã¨įããããĒããģãŠãéãããĢäēãéãã ã
ããžãã§åŊŧåĨŗãĢč¸ããããĻãããããĒæ°åã ããäēåŽãĒããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĨããĒããįãĢäšãŖããŽã ãããã¨ãˇãĨãŽįŽįã¨éĸäŋããĻãããĢéããĒãã
ãéĸ¨æ¯įģãįēããĒãããé ãæĨãĢæããéĻŗããĻããã
ãâ
ãéæŦį¨ãŽčˇå°ãĢčēĢãé ããéãŗãéãŽčģčŧĒãčģãéŗãčããĒãããä¸åēĻã ãå°ä¸ãæãåēãããã¨ãããã
ãå°ããŽéčãčã§čŗããå°åãŽåŽļįã¨ãéčãããŧããįįŖãããįĢĒįŠ´æ´įĒãåŊåãŽä¸é¨ã¨čĒããããĻããĒãããå°ä¸ãŽå
ãåˇŽãčžŧãå ´æã
ãããã¯åĨä¸įã ãŖãã
ãéæãĒå ãåˇŽãčžŧãæ´įĒãŽå˛ŠåŖãĢã¯ãįˇãŽčããŗãŖããã¨č˛ŧãäģããĻãããįãĢã¯čĻããã¨ããĒãæ¤įŠãä¸Ļãã§ããã
ãįŠēæ°ã¯æšŋãŖãĻããĻãåãŽåããĢåŽļįãŽčãã¨éĻčãŽéĻããæˇˇããåãŖãĻãããåã¯åĻšãŽæãæĄãŖãĻčˇå°ããéĸããã
ãããâĻâĻã
ãå°ããæåãŽåŖ°ãæŧããåĻšãåãŽčĸãåŧãŖåŧĩããããŽįŗã¯éŠãã¨åĨŊåĨåŋã§čŧããåãč¨čãå¤ąãŖãĻãããæ¸įŠã§ããįĨããĒããŖãå°ä¸ããįŽãŽåãĢåēããŖãĻããã
ã大äēēããĄãĢčĻã¤ãããĒãããäŊįŠãŽé°ãĢé ããåĻšãã¯ãšã¯ãšã¨įŦããããŽįŦãåŖ°ãčŋŊããããå˛ŠåŖãŽæšã¸čĩ°ãŖããįŠēæ°ãŽéããĢåãããĻããŋãŽčããããããåŽļįããĄãŽåžŽããĒéŗ´ãåŖ°ãčãããĻããã
ããĩã¨éĄãä¸ããã¨æ´įĒãŽå¤Šäēã¯ãããŖã¨é ããĢããŖãã
ãéãéĢãæžãã č˛ãįŠããããĻįŽãéããĻããããĒããģãŠãŽå
ãéãæŗ¨ããčãŧãããããåŊĸãŽįŊãæš¯æ°ããããŖããã¨æĩããĻčĄãã
ãäēäēēããĻįĢãĄæĸãžããããŽå
æ¯ãĢé
å
ĨãŖãĻããã
ããããããã¯ãâĻâĻããīŧã
ãåĻšãŽåããĢãåã¯č¨čãčŋããã¨ãã§ããĒããŖããããŽå æ¯ãčŗčŖãĢįŧãäģãããããĒæ°æãĄã§ãéģãŖãĻčĻã¤ãããåããįããä¸įãĢãčĄãŖããã¨ãŽãĒãå ´æãĢãįžããč˛ããžã ããããããã
ãæãŽéãŽãéãå¤ĸãã¯ãåįŠĢãŽįŠãŋčˇäŊæĨãįĩãããžã§ãŽæéäģããåģä¸åģã¨å¤č˛ããĻããįŠēã¨ãŽåĨããæããŋãĒãããåãã¯čˇå°ãĢäšãčžŧãã ã
ãåˇããĒãæåã¨čåĨŽãåãŋᎠããåãŽéŖã§ããžã åšŧããŖãåĻšã¯įŽãæĻãŖãĻãããæŗĨã¨åãŽčãããžã¨ãããå°ããĒæãĢã¯ãåĨåĻãĒåŊĸãŽå°įŗãä¸ã¤ã ãã
ãããŽæĨãĢčĻãæ¯č˛ã¯ãäģã§ãåŋãĢį¯ã垎ããĒ叿ã§ããįĩļæã ã
ãâ
ãæãĢæãŖãĻããããŗå
ãæēãåŠãéŗã§ãåã¯įžåŽãĢåŧãæģãããã
ãčļčåãåããéŗãčããããäēæŋãåžãäģäēēãŽå¯åēãĢä¸ããčžŧãã ã¨ãˇãĨããããã§čļčåãč˛ĒãŖãĻãããŽã ã
ãæŖããããĒããããĢãæŖãããããčĒåã§įäģããĻããã
ãčåžã¸åããĻåŖ°ããããããäēč§ŖãŽčŋäēããã¯į¨é ãååŧéŗãéŋããã ãã ãŖãã
ãå¤åē訹å¯ãéããĒãããã夿ŗããĢæģãããéåąããĻãããŽã ãããåąæˇå
ãčĒįąãĢåžåžãããĻã¯äŊããããããä翏Ŧã§ãããčŋˇæãããããã§æããããŽåš´éŊĸä¸čŠŗæã¯åēäŧãŖãé ãŽãžãžã ã
ããããĢããĻããåŊæã§ã¯æŗåãã§ããĒããŖãįæ´ģį°åĸã ãå¤ĸãčĻãĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã䏿ãĢįŽãčĻãžããĻããžãããã§ä¸åŽãĢãĒãã
ãããŽįžįļã¯ãäšãčžŧãåãŽåãæãã æĒæĨã¸čŋãĨããĻããã ãããããããĒæããææĨãåĻšãĢäŧãã°æ´ããã¯ãã ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯į´æããĻããããã¨ãˇãĨãéģãŖãĻčããĻããã
ãæēãĢåēããįãŖįŊãĒį´ãįēããæˇąãæ¯ãåããåããčĻãã°ãčϺ坿ĨčĒãæ¸ããã¨ã¯åŽļä¸ģããčǞããããįžŠåã ããããã ãã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ãˇãĨãåå¨ããĻããč¨ŧãæŽãčĄįēã§ãããåããããĢæŽãįįąã ã
ãčǰãčĒãããĒãŠã¯éĸäŋãĒãããčåŗããĒãã
ãåã¯ã¤ãŗã¯åŖēããããŗå ãĢæļ˛äŊãå¸ããããåįį´ã¨ã¯éãčŗĒæãŽį´ãĢãæåãŽč¨čãč¨ãããåąæˇã¯éãã§ãããŗå ãį´ãæĻãéŗãčåãåãéŗã ããéŋãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨčϺ坿ĨčĒãįŦŦä¸é
įŽãã
ã
ãæåãčĻã¤ããĒããå°ããæ¯ãåãããææĨããŠãčģĸãļãã¯åãããĒããäģã¯ãããŽä¸čĄãåãŽįããįįąã¸åŊĸãå¤ããĻčĄããããĒäēæãããã ãã ã
ãâ
ããŗãŗãŗãŗãŗãŗã¨ä¸åēĻãã¤ãčĻåįãĢįĄŦãããŽãåŠãéŗãéŋããį
ŠããããæããĒãããåã¯ããŗãčĩ°ããįļããã
ãčåžã§äŊãčģãéŗãæˇˇãããã¨ãˇãĨãå¯čŋãã§ãæãŖããŽã ãããæåĨãč¨ãŖãĻããã¤ããã§ããŗãįŊŽããæ¯ãčŋãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯å¯å°ããįĢãĄä¸ãããé¨åąãŽæãéããããããĢä¸äēēãŽįĩĻäģãįĢãŖãĻãããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻããĒãčēĢéãããĻãæ¤ åãĢåē§ãŖããžãžãŽåã¸åããĻä¸į¤ŧããã
ããåŽĸæ§ãåĨĨæ§ããåŧãŗã§ããããžããčēĢå æ¸éĄããæåãã ãããžãããäģ°ãã¤ããŖãĻãããžãã
ãéããåŖ°ã§åŊŧåĨŗã¯äŧããĻãããã
ããããĢæ¯åēĻããžãã
ãåã¯æēãĢåãį´ãŖãĻã¤ãŗã¯įļãŽčãᎠããæ¸ãéä¸ãŽį´ãŽį̝ãĢįŊŽããĻãį´ã丸ãžããĒããããĢåēåŽãããæ¸éĄã¨įč¨å ˇãæãŖãĻæãåēãã¨æ¯ãčŋãŖãã
ãåã¯ãŠãããīŧã
12
ãįēå
čãŠãŗããæ˛ããĻåãæŠãįĩĻäģãŽæĄå
ã§ãåã¯æ¸éĄã¨įč¨å
ˇãæĄããããã¨ãˇãĨãåŧãéŖããĻåģä¸ãæŠãã
ãä礿¸ãŽå ´ã§åĻšã¨ãŽéĸäŧãæĄäģļãĢåēããããããããäŊãŽéŗæ˛æą°ããĒããä¸åēĻãŽéŖäēãéã°ããĻæĨãé¨åąã§ä¸¸ä¸æĨãéããããäģããĒããæåž
ããå
ãĢįåŋĩãé ãããããĻããã
ããããåĻšãĢã¯äŧããĒãã¨č¨ããããīŧããããã¯ãįĸãĢéãčžŧããããĻäēēčŗĒåįļãĢæąããããīŧ
ãæĒãæšã¸ã°ããæčãčģĸããŖãĻããã
ãįĩĻäģãčļŗãæĸããæããčã¸å¯ããä¸ã¤ãŽæãŽåãžã§æĨãĻããã
ãããŽãé¨åąã§ãåĻšæ§ããåž ãĄã§ããããžãã
ãåã¯é ˇããåˇããæå ãä¸åēĻåŧˇãæĄãããããčåžãŽã¨ãˇãĨãĢčĻįˇãããã°ãåŖãŽįĒĒãŋãĢéŖžããčĒŋåēĻåãįēããĻããã
ã䏿¯ãåããĻæãåŠããčŋäēã¯ãĒãã
ãæãĢæãäŧ¸ã°ãįĩĻäģãŽæäŊãããŠãããæããåž
ãããĢæãéãããããã¯éŊå
ãæ¨ĄãããããĒį
§æãčŧããåēãé¨åąã ãŖããæåãĢå
ĨãŖãåŋæĨ厤ãããå°ãįãããčĒŋåēĻåãŽä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ããæ´å˛ãŽéãŋãæããããã
ãåĨĨãŽå¤§ããĒčæãæ¤ åãĢãå°ããĒäēēåŊąãčĻã¤ããĻæŠãŋå¯ããčåžã§æãéãžãŖããããŽįŠéŗãčãã¤ããäēēåŊąããããŖããã¨æ¯ãčŋãã
ãčĻįˇãåããåĻšã¯įŽãčĻéãããžãžåããĒããŖããããŽįŽãĢæ ãå§ŋããäŋĄããããĒãã¨ã§ãč¨ããããĢã
ãåãåŖ°ãåēãĒããŖãã
ãäŊããäēæ
ãčĒŦæããã°č¯ããåãããĒããåŽļãåēãĻããåäģãĒåĨ´ãĢééããĻãéģããŖãčã¯ä¸æ°åŗãĒãģãŠéįŊããĒãŖããåĻšã¯åãĢæ°ãĨãã ãããīŧ
ãåãæ¨ãã§ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããīŧãåĨŊåĨåŋãĢåããããŠããĒåąéēãåž
ãĄæ§ããĻãããã䏿ãĒįļæŗãĢãåĻšãåˇģãčžŧããã¨ããĻãããčēĢåæãĒåãĢäŊãæãã ããã
ãå ãĢåãããŽã¯åĻšã ãŖãã
ãâĻâĻã¨ãĢīŧã
ãįĩãåēããããĒæ ããåŖ°ãåãŽčŗãĢåąããã
ãããŽčãŠããããŽīŧãäŊãããããŽīŧãããã§äŊãããĻãããŽīŧã
ãåĻšã¯æ¤ åããéŖãŗéããã¨ãčĩ°ãå¯ãŖãĻãããåãŽæ°æŠæåã§æĨåæĸããå°ããĒæŗãæĄããããããŽįŽãĢæļãæēããĻį¨ãŋä¸ããã
ãäŊã§å¸°ãŖãĻæĨãĒããŽīŧãããŖã¨åž
ãŖãĻããäŊåēĻãæĸããĢčĄãŖããã§ãããŠããĢãããĒããŖãīŧãäŊã§įŊŽããĻãŖããŽīŧããĻãŊã¤ãīŧãããŖã¨ä¸įˇãŖãĻč¨ãŖããŽãĢīŧã
ãããã¯âĻâĻã
ãããäŧããĒãããããĒãããŖãĻīŧãä¸äēēãŧãŖãĄã§ãâĻâĻæããŖããã ããīŧã
ãâååŊãæˇˇãããããã¤ããŽå¤§į˛ãŽæļãæēĸãčŊãĄãã
ãåŽå ĩãŽæļã§ã¯ãĒããåã䏿šįãĢä¸ããä¸åŽã¨å¤įŦãĢ寞ããééŖãŽæļã ã
ããŠããĒč¨čã§åãæĸãããŽãæŖãããŽããåãĢã¯åãããĒããŖããåäŧãåãļãšãããäēæ
ãäŧããĻčŦããŽãå
ããã¤ãããĻæŗŖããšãå ´éĸã§ã¯ãĒããŽãã
ããĒãããããĒãã¨ãčããĻãããŽã ããīŧãäŊããããĢãä¸įˇã ãŖããåĻšãĢäŧãã°ããŠããã§čŊã¨ããĻããžãŖãããŽãåãæģããæ°ãããĻãããŽãĢâĻâĻã
ãåãæĒããŖãã
ãčŦãŖãĻãģããããããĒãīŧã
ãæŋããéĻãæ¯ãã¨ãæãããĒįŊéĢĒãé ŦãåŠãããæŋĄããé ŦãĢéĢĒãåŧĩãäģãã
ãįããĻãĻããããŖãã
ãâåãŽč¸ãĢéĄãããããåĻšã¯åŖ°ãä¸ããĻæŗŖãããããŖããåã¯éããčä¸ãæĻããĒããæąããããã
ãé¨åąãŽå
ĨãåŖãĢįĢã¤ã¨ãˇãĨããåããĻčĻãįãįŠãčĻŗå¯ããããŽãããĢä¸é¨å§įĩãįēããĻããã
ããããĻåĻšãããããä¸ããĒããéĄãä¸ããåãŽčåžãĢããã¨ãˇãĨãĢæ°ãĨãããčēĢäŊãéãããåĻšãåãŽåžããĢé ããã
ãããŽäēēãã ãīŧã
ãææã¨čĻæãæˇˇããŖãå°ããĒåŖ°ã ãåã¯æ¯ãčŋãŖãĻãæãįĢãĄåĄãã§ããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãã
ããŠãį´šäģããããŽãã
īŧã¨ãˇãĨããĻãŠãæããããå§ŋåĸãäŊãããĻããīŧ
ããããŽååą
äēēã ã
ãåŋãŽä¸ã§åąããĒãããåĻšãĢįãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãč¨ãããããŖããããåäŊã§æãæčŋãĒæ¤ åã¸į§ģåããĻããããĢåãžãŖããåĻšãŽčĻæãč§ŖããĢã¯ãéˇãæéãåŋ čĻãĢãĒãããã ã
ã大äēãĒ芹ããããããŽåŽļãĢæģãããããã§æŽãããæąēããĻãģããã
ãčŊãĄįããĻããé ãčĻč¨ããŖãĻåãåēããããã§ããŗã¨ããã§éĄã§åãčĻã¤ãčŋãã¨ãåĻšã¯å°ããįŦãŖãĻįããã Â
ãã¨ãĢã¨ä¸įˇãĒãããŠãã§ããããã Â
ããããã¨ããâĻâĻãããĢååãæ¸ããĻãčĒæ¸äŧãŽå
įãčĻããĻãīŧã
ããããäŊã¨ãĒãã ããŠã
ãæãããã¯ããéŗãéŋãããéããĢéãããæãŽåãããĢã¯ãåãĢä¸ããŖãã°ãããŽåĨŗæ§ãåž
ãŖãĻããã
ãåããĄã¯æ¸éĄãĢįŊ˛åããĻæå°ãæēããåŊŧåĨŗãĢææ¸Ąãããį´éĸãĢįŽãéããåŊŧåĨŗãåŖå
ãįˇŠããã
ãįĸēčĒãããĻãããŖãããããããæãåŽļã¸ããžãã¯éŖäēãĢããžãããã
ãã严čĻĒã¯äŊčŖãæ°ãĢããã°ããã§ãåĻšãĄãããŽãã¨ã¯įãŋãĻããĒããŖããããã
ãéŖå ã¸åããéä¸ãåąæˇãŽåĨŗä¸ģäēēã¯åģä¸ãæŠããĒããæˇĄã ã¨åãããåĻšã¯åãŽæãŽčŖžãæ´ãã§ã¤ããĻæĨãã
ãå ąåãĢããã¨ãå°įĢ ãčĻããĻäŋčˇãįŗãåēãæããåŊŧããŽéĸåŋäēã¯ãč˛ŦäģģãŽæå¨ãã¨ãč˛å čŗæ ŧãã ãŖããããããããĒ芹ãäģäēēããčããããĻããäŋĄããããĒããããããĒããããŠã
ãããããããžããĢãæŗåéãã§ãæããããå ãĢčĢĻåŋĩãåãį´åžããããåĻšã¯ããŠããŠããčŖ éŖžãæ°ãĢãĒãããã§ãããŖã¨ãã§ããã§ãããĻãããã¨ãˇãĨãį¸å¤ãããã ã
ãåĨããåããæéã¯č¨ąããããŖããŽã ãããŠãäēēįŽãĢã¤ãã¨éĸåã ãããŖãĻãåããããæåĻããã¨ããä¸åą¤ãŽæ¨Ēįšããã¯ãããģãŠč¤éãĒãŽãã
ãįĩĻäģãåŊŧåĨŗãŽåãĢé˛ãŋåēãĻãéŖå ãŽæãéããã
ãåæĨåžãŽč°äŧãįĩããŖãåžãĒãããã¤ã§ãäŧããĢčĄãŖãĻæ§ããĒãããæ°æãĄãŽæ´įãŽãããĢããäēããĢč šãå˛ãŖãĻ芹ãåãã°ãããéããčǤ觪ãč§ŖæļãããããįĨããĒãã
ãį´ į´ãĢåĒãããé æ Žã¨ããĻåãåãŖãĻč¯ãããŽã ãããã
ããã¯ãåŊåŽļãŽåŊéã¨åããŽįæ´ģããæĨčĒã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãĢãããŖãĻããã
ãããč¨å¤ãĢåããĻãããŽã ãåããĄã¯äģŽåãŽåšŗįŠãĒæŽãããä¸ãããããĢéããĒãã
ã
ãâ
ãéŖå ã¯åãŽįĨãåą
éãããåēããŖãã鎿ēãŽä¸ãĢã¯ãæĸãĢéŖå¨ãä¸ĻãšãããĻãããæš¯æ°ãįĢãĻããããŗãšãŧããæãããããĒããŗããããĻãå°åēã§ã¯įŠåã貴éãĒįˇéčãŽãŊããŧãå°ä¸ãŽčž˛åã§č˛ãĻãããããŽã ããã
ãéŖã§åãéŗ´ããéŗãčãããããŠãįĄįããĒã芹ã ã
ãããåē§ãŖãĻãåˇããĒãããĄãĢã
ãäŋããããžãžåã¨åĻšã¯ã鎿ēãŽä¸į̝ãĢä¸Ļãã§č
°æãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯åŊįļãŽãããĢåãŽåãããåąæˇãŽä¸ģäēēããčĻãĻå寞éŖãĢč
°ãæããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãååŗãéãã¨ãįĩĻäģãé ãĢéŖ˛ãŋįŠãæŗ¨ãã
ãčĒåˇąį´šäģãé ããĻããžãŖããããį§ã¯ãŦã´ãĄããĒãĸãį§ãŽãã¨ã¯æį§°ãŽãŦãããå įã¨åŧãļãããĢãčĒæ¸äŧãĢæĨãĻããåããĄããããåŧãã§ããã§ãããīŧã
ãåäžããĄã°ããããäŋčˇč ãžã§ããåŊŧåĨŗãå įã¨åŧãã§ãããããŖã¨åŊŧåĨŗãįŠįĨãã§ãčĻĒããĄãĢãæããŋãĒãįĨčãå ąæããĻãããäēēįŠã ãŖãããã ããã
ãã¯ããå
įã
ããããããã§ã¯ããčĄåč¯ãåŦãä¸ããã
ãåãåŋããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æēčļŗããĢ垎įŦãã ã
ããããĒããåããããĻããéããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įŽåãŽãšãŧãįŋãčĻä¸ãããĻãããčãäēãããĻããå¯čŊæ§ãããããããã¯čǰãĢãįĨãåžãĒãã
ã貴æšãŽãã¨ã¯ããã¨ãĢã¨åŧãã§č¯ããŽãããīŧã
ããŦããčĻįˇãåãĢå¯čļããĻãããåŖãĢå
ĨããįŠãįĄįãĢéŖ˛ãŋčžŧããŽã¯čēčēããããããčēĢæ¯ãã§č¯åŽãį¤ēããããŽåžãéč˛ãŽæ¯ããä¸åŖåĢãã§æĩãčžŧãã ã
ãæ¸éĄãĢã¯čĻĒããä¸ããããååã¨åŽļåãæ¸ãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŠãã§įĨãåžããŽã ãããīŧãããã¨ãĢããŽéŗãæŦåãįãããæį§°ãĢčŋããã¨ãäēåŽã ããã¨ãˇãĨãåãããåŧãã åæ°ã¯ãįæã§æ°ããããį¨åēĻãããĒãã
ãããã§ãæ
å ąãæŧãããĒããæĒãããŽã¯ãĩããĢã¨åŧã°ããĻããæŋåēéĸäŋč
âĻâĻã
ãã§ã¯ãåŊŧã¯īŧã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãã¨åŧãã§ããžãã
ããããã¨ãˇãĨãâĻâĻįãŽãčĩ¤ãč¯ãååãã
ããŦãã¯įŦæãĢååãŽæåŗã¨įąæĨãįč§ŖããĻ垎įŦãŋãã¨ãˇãĨãĢåãį´ãŖãã
ãæšããĻãããããããã¨ãˇãĨã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éŖäēãŽæãæĸãããä¸įĨã ããčŋããããŦãã¯æ°ãĢããæ§åããĒãåããĄãĢåãį´ããčĻįˇãåĻšã¸į§ģããããŽéããšããŧãŗãæĄãŖãĻããžã¨ããããéŖäēããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãåã¯ãåąãããšãŧããåšããããĢãĒãŖãã
ãåŗæãã§æŋããããéŧģãįãã
ãåĻšãĄããã¯īŧã
ã芹ããããããįˇåŧĩã§ãšããŧãŗãæĄãããããžãžãåĻšã¯åãčĻããé ˇããĻäŋãã¨ãæļãå ĨããããĒåŖ°ã§åĻšãįããã
ãâĻâĻãĻãŠã
ãããããããĻãŠã
ããŦãã¯įŠãããĢ垎įŦãã ã
ãäģæĨããį§ãŽåŽļæã¨ããĻããããŽäŊäēēãĢãĒããŽã ãããįĩĻäģããĄã¨ãäģ˛č¯ãããĻãããã¨åŦãããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãšãŧããĢäŧ¸ã°ããããæãæĸããããŖããã¨éĄãä¸ããĻåĻšãčĻã¤ããããããĢéĄãčããéŖäēãåéããããäŊã ãä¸åŽãĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ãåŖ˛ãããĒããã°č˛ˇããĒãããåŖ˛ãããå§åŠã¯é¸ãåĨŊãŋãã財ããŽãã¨ãˇãĨã ãåĻšãã¨ãˇãĨãæčããĻææãããģãŠãã¨ãˇãĨãåĻšãįĄčĻã§ããĒããŽããįĨããĒãã
ã大ä¸å¤ĢãããĻãŠãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åããĻčĻãåãĢčåŗãåŧãããĻããã ããæãããã¨ãĒããããããã¨ãˇãĨīŧã
ããŦããĢåããããããã¨ãˇãĨã¯éĻãåžãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŠãŽį¨åēĻãžã§åąéēæ§ãįč§ŖããĻãããŽã ãããåãæŗ¨æããĻčĻåŧĩããĒããã°ã
ãã¨ãĢīŧã
ãåĻšãä¸åŽããĢåãčĻã¤ããã
ãåšŗæ°ã ããã¨ãˇãĨã¯čĻãããããããŖã¨åĒããã
ãæããéããč¯ããĒãã¨č¨ããŽã¯ãįžæŽĩéã§ã¯äģŽčĒŦã§ãããĒãããããĢåŋãåļåžĄãããŽã¯éŖããã
ãâĻâĻããã
ããžã åäŋĄåįãŽããã ããããããã¨ãšããŧãŗãæĄãŖãã
ã
ã
ãå¤éŖãŽåžãåĻšã¯å¯åˇģãå§ŋã§éŖãŽé¨åąããå¸åŖä¸åŧãæąããåãŽé¨åąãĢįžããã
ãã¨ãĢãä¸įˇãĢå¯ãĻããīŧãäģæĨã ãã
ãæēãæ¯ãåããå¸åŖãæˇãæäŧãããããããĢįĢãĄä¸ããŖããįĨããĒãé¨åąãĢä¸äēēããã§čŊãĄįããĒãã¨ãããŽã¯įč§Ŗã§ãããäŧããĒãæéãéˇããŖããããčããããã¨ãäŧããããã¨ããããŽãããäēãæ§ã ã
ãé¨åąãĢå ĨãŖãĻæĨãåĻšã¯ãåŧãã¤ãŖããããĒæ˛éŗ´ãä¸ããå¸åŖãæĄããããĒããé§ãå¯ãŖãĻæĨããããŽčžēã§čĄåē§ããããæ§åãįēããĻããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻæããĻãããããã
ãįéǍéã ãŽåˇ¨äŊãĢãæ´žæãĒããĩããĩé ã¨ææ ãŽčĒããĒãįŖæãŋãįŗãå¤åĨ䏿ãč °ãĢåˇģããĻããã ããŽéčŽäēēã ãææãããŽãįĄįã¯ãĒããåčĒčēĢã¯æ°æĨã§æ ŖããããæĸããåžãĒãįļæŗããããããéĸãå¤åãĢããã
ãåĻšãŽé ãæĢã§ã¤ã¤ãäēæ
ãŽåæžãåŗããããĢčēĢãäšãåēããããããããŠãäŧããããŽã ãããīŧ
ãæãŖåãæŠãåĻšãŽæąããææãåãé¤ããããĒããã¨ãˇãĨã¨ãŽéãĢä¸ģåžéĸäŋãããããŽãããĒæ¯ãčããčĻããã°ãåŗæãĢåšæãåŽæã§ããã ãããčĻã¯ãč¨čã§åŊäģ¤ããĻåŋã§ãéĄãããäŊæĻã ãããŽäŊæĻãŽåéĄįšã¯ãåĻšãåãŽčĄ¨éĸįãĒč¨åã ããįäŧŧãå ´åãĢčĩˇããåžãäģŖåãŽå¤§ãããĢããã
ãčĻãããģãŠåĨŊæĻįã§ãĒãã¨ããæŽ´ãããã°æŽ´ãčŋããŽãã¨ãˇãĨãŽåēæŦčĄåã§ãããč
åãæ´čŊãĢãĒããĒããŽã ããã
ããã¤ããŽéãã芹ãã°įč§Ŗãį¤ēããĻãããéŖäēēã¨ããĻæ¯ãčãįĄéŖãĒææŽĩãæåã ããã
ããĻãŠãæãããããããããčĻããŽã¯æ§ããĻããã
ãč¨čããããåŋãŽåĨĨåēãĢããæąēæãįč§Ŗããã¨ãˇãĨãĢãĒãäŧããã¯ãã ããžã å¯å°ããéããĒãã¨ãˇãĨãĢãåã¯å ˇäŊįãĒčĄåãčĻæąããã
ãæĒãããŠãããŽå¸åŖã¯åä¸äēēã§äŊŋãŖãĻãããããäģå¤ã¯åēã§å¯ãĻãããĒããīŧã
ãåãŽå¸åŖãåēãĢæˇããĻãã¨ãˇãĨãĢã¯ããã§å¯ãĻããããäģŖãããĢåĻšãŽå¸åŖãå¯å°ãĢæˇããåĻšã¯åŖå´ãåã¯ã¨ãˇãĨå´ã§å¯ããããã§åéĄãĒãã¯ãã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã ãé¨åąãããĻããããĻããĒãįįąã¯äŊã ããīŧ
ãâčĻæąãĢ寞ããã¨ãˇãĨãå¯å°ããéããææãčĻããããããčĻãåã¯ãæ¤
åãæēãŽä¸ã¸æŧãčžŧãã§ãæˇå¸åŖãå¯å°ããåēã¸į§ģåãããã
ãåãããģãŠéæãĒã¨ãˇãĨãĢã¨ãŖãĻãå¯ãå ´æãæãããčãŽä¸ãįĄŦãå˛ŠãŽä¸ããĒããĻãã¨ã¯äēäēã ãããããã夿ŗããĢã¯ããĩããĩãæˇå¸åŖããĒããŖããŽã ããã
ãåã¯įŠēããå¯å°ãĢãåĻšãæąããĻæãŖãĻããå¸åŖãæˇãį´ããã
ããĻãŠããããĒã大ä¸å¤Ģã
ãåĻšã¯åēãŽå¸åŖãĢåē§ãčžŧãã ã¨ãˇãĨãé åˇģããĢčĻæããĒãããå¯å°ã¸é§ãå¯ãŖãĻå¸åŖãŽä¸ãĢæŊãčžŧããåãįēå čãŠãŗããĢå¸ããããåĻšãŽéŖãĢæģãčžŧãã ã
ãåĻšãŽå¯æ¯ãčããå§ãããžã§ãããæéã¯ããããĒããŖããįˇåŧĩãŽįŗ¸ãåãããŽããį˛ããĻãããŽãĢį ãããĢãããŽãã¯åãããĒããåã¯ããŖã¨čēĢãčĩˇããããŠãŗããŽå¸ãæ˛ãŖãĻææēãĢåããŖãã
ãâåēãããããžãžãŽæĨčĒã¯ããžã æ°čĄããåãžãŖãĻããĒããæ¨æĨãŽããĄãĢåŋ
čĻãĒæ
å ąäē¤æãæ¸ãžããĻãããĻæŖč§Ŗã ãŖãã
ãããŗå
ãã¤ãŗã¯ãĢæĩ¸ããåã¯æ¨æĨãŽãč§Ļč¨ēįĩæããč¨é˛ããšããéŠåãĒæįĢ čĄ¨įžãæ¨Ąį´ĸããã
ãâââ
ãæå¤ãŽéŖäēãĢå ããéĻããŽč¯ããčļã¨įŧãčåããįĩĻäģãĢããŖãĻéãŗčžŧãžããéŖå¨ãååãããĻãããé¨åąãŽæãĢéĩã¯ãããããĻããĒããŖããæãåēããã¨æãã°å¯čŊã ãŖãã ããããåĻšãĢäŧããæŠäŧãéããããĢã¯čĄããĒãã
ãäģãĢãããã¨ããĒããããæĨčĒãĢã¨ãˇãĨãŽéŖäēéãææŗã¨įĄį ãŽä¸åŋ
čĻæ§ãĒãŠãåĄãįæ
ã¨ãåŧãšãĒãããŽãčŠŗį´°ãĢč¨é˛ããĻããŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éŖ˛éŖããããåŋ
čĻæ§ãéįéãĢã¤ããĻã¯æĒįĨæ°ã ãããæ¨å¯ããæ šæ ã¨ããĻãææŗįžå ´ãčĻããã¨ã¯ä¸åēĻã¨ããĻãĒããįĄčĢãäģäēēãĢčĻãããĒããå ã
ã¨čĄįēãĢåãļåĨ´ãŽåæ§ã¯įããããããé ããã¨ãæãŖãĻããããĒãŽãã¨ãˇãĨã ãį补ããæŽããĒããŽã¯ãį°å¸¸ã¨ããč¨ãããããĒãã
ãäģŽčĒŦãéŖįŠãã¨ããĢãŽãŧãĢ夿ããåšįãŽéĢãããį¤ēåããã¨ããĻãããŽčģįĻįæ´ģä¸ãŽčĻčĻŗå¯é
įŽãĢå ãããã¨æãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¨åēäŧãŖãĻãããįĨãŽå¤æŗãã§ãŽįæ´ģä¸ãĢåžãæ å ąãæ¸ãåēãããžã¨ãããĢã¯æéããããããã ãæ°åčģĸæãå ŧããĻãäģã§ãããã¨ãå ãĢæ¸ãžããĻãããã
ãæĨčĒãĢč¨é˛ãããããåãčĻŗå¯ããããč§ĻãŖãĻãæ§ããĒãã ãããīŧã
ãå¯å°ã§å¯čģĸããŖãĻããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãčĻįˇã¨įĄč¨ãčŋãããæįĩļãããæįĩļããããĒãéããäēæŋã¨åãåãŖãĻåéĄãĒãã¯ãã ã
ãåã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽæãĢč§Ļãããč¤č˛ãŽčã¯ãįčēĢãŽäēēéã¨å¤ãããĒãį¨åēĻãŽæ¸ŠåēĻã¨åŧžåãæãŖãĻãããįŽčãŽä¸ãŽéǍãčĄįŽĄãŽæč§ĻãįčãŽéčĩˇãčĻŗå¯ããéĻįãĢč§ĻããĻåŧå¸ã¨čæãčĒŋãšãã
ãįĒãŽå
ãæ¯å
ãŽčŗĒæãĢčŗããžã§ãæąēããĻį§ģãããĒããæŦįŠãŽéčŽäēēãĒãčããĻãããŽãæŽéã ããããžãã§įĩĩįģãåŊĢåģãĢãããããĒåŽæãããįžã ã
ãč¸ãĢčŗãæŧãåŊãĻãĻãåŧå¸éŗãéŧåãæĸããčĻåįã§å¸¸čįãĒéŗãŽãŋãįš°ãčŋãããĻããã
ãåēäŧãŖãé ã¨æ¯ãšãã°ä¸éããã¨æãã
ãå ąåįæ´ģãããä¸ã§éåæãĢæ°ãĨããã¨ãããŖããããäŊãčĻã¤ããĻã大ããĒéŠãã¯ãĒããã¨ãˇãĨãŽčäŊã常čãčļ ããããŽã§ãããã¨ãæšããĻįĸēčĒã§ããäģã大ããĒææã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãåĒåã¯čĒããããŠãį´°é¨ãããå°ãä¸å¯§ãĢåįžã§ããĒãīŧãããããĒãã¨å࿎ãŽäēēããĄãé¨ããĒãããããŽéããåĢããĻéĸįŊãã¨æãããŠã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽéĻãĢč§ĻããĒããã大ããĒæãåŧãå¯ããĻåãŽéĻãĢč§Ļããããã
īŧããã¨ããåąæˇãŽäŊäēēã¯æĸãĢįĨãŖãĻãããŽããĒīŧãåã¯åãŽéĒéãããĻãããŗãĢããŽæãĄä¸ģã§ããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŗæšããããåã¨åēäŧããããåããåŊŧåĨŗãåãŽä¸ģã ãŖããĒããããŽčĄåãĢį´åžããããåã¯čǰãŽåŗæšãĒãã īŧīŧ
ããããĒčããåŖãĢåēããĒããžãžãåã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽįŗãčĻã¤ãããįĨįč˛ãŽä¸ããčĻã¤ãčŋãåã¨įŽãåãŖãã ãã§ãčŋįã¯ãĒããŖããäŊ渊ãĢäŧŧãåŋå°ããæ¸ŠåēĻãæå
ããäē¤ããå
ãĢãåŧå¸ã¨čæãŽééãéãĒãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽãããįˇŠãããĒããŽã¸å¤åããĻãããčĻŗå¯ããĻããå
ãĢãåčĒčēĢãŽéŧåãįŠããããåãæģããĻããããŠãĄããæ¨ĄåŖããĻãããŽããããŽåĸįãããč§Ŗãå´ŠããĻããæčĻã
ãâââ
ãäģŽčĒŦīŧæåããææŠįŠãã¨ããĢãŽãŧãĢ夿ããåšįãæĨĩããĻéĢãããããã¯įŠčŗĒãäŊå ã§åč§Ŗãģæļæģ ãããæĒįĨãŽå¨åŽãåå¨ããå¯čŊæ§ã
ãäēēãŽåŊĸãããĻãããããĢčĻããĻããããããŽæŦčŗĒã¯äēēéãŽįč§ŖãéĨããĢčļ
ãããäŊããã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¨ããåå¨ãŽåēįĨããĒããĢãåã¯ææããããããį¨ŽãŽįĨįčåĨŽãŽãããĒããŽãčĻããĻããã
ãâããŗãæĸããæ¸ãä¸ããæįĢ ãčĻčŋãã
ãææããéãããããããĢčĒåã¨ã¯éãč
ãåŋãŋåĢããæé¤ãããĢã¯ããããĒããŽãäēēãŽæ§ãįšãĢãããŽééįãĒåŊã§ã¯ããããéĄčã ã
ããããããŽæ
å ąããããŽãžãžæåēãããīŧ
ãåŊŧã¯äēēéã§ã¯ãããžãããæĨĩããĻéĢåēĻãĒæŦæ čŊåãæã¤ãæĒįĨãŽæéŖč ã§ããįåŊäŊã§ãããĒãå¯čŊæ§ããããžãã
ããããĒå ąåã¯ãäŋåŽæ´žãã¨ãˇãĨããåĻåããšãæĒįŠãã¨æåŽããéŠæ°æ´žããč§ŖåčĒŋæģããšãåŽé¨åįŠããæãã¨ãĢå¯čļãã¨ä¸ģåŧĩããįžįļãåžæŧãããã ãã ã
ããŠãĄããĢčģĸãã§ããã¨ãˇãĨã̿ǿĨã¯ãĒãããããĻãã¨ãˇãĨãŽãįŽĄįč
ãã§ããåã¯ææĒãŽå ´åãåŽé¨åįŠã¨ä¸įˇãĢæĒģãŽä¸ã ã
ãææŗãĢéĸããĻã¯ãå厤å ãŽč¨åãäŊŋį¨ããĻããã¨æãããããæĒįĸēčĒã
ãåã¯æ¸ããĻããĒããįĸēčĒããĻããĒããŽã¯äēåŽã ã
ãčäŊæ§é ã¯æäēēᎿ§ã¨å¤§åˇŽãĒãããåēį¤äŊåãčããéĢãã
ããããåã§ã¯ãĒããå¤§åˇŽãĒããããĢãčĻããããĻãããã ãã ã
ãåã¯čĒŋãšå°Ŋãããæ
å ąãŽä¸ãããįĨãããĻãåéĄããĒãæ
å ąãæŋæ˛ģįãĢåŠį¨ããããæ
å ąãé¸åĨããã¨æąēããã
ã
ãã¤ãŗã¯ãŽčãéããå¯å°ãŽæšãæ¯ãčŋããåĻšãŽåŽãããĒå¯éĄã¨ãåēã§ä¸¸ãžãŖãĻããčä¸ãåŽããšãããŠãĄããã¯æããã ãäŊãŽåããĒããŽãĢãããã§ãå¤ąããããĒãã
ãããŽįįžã¨å˛æ
ĸãĢæēãĄãå襥ãåįļããããããĢãããŗã§äēåŽã¨čæ§ãŽåĸįįˇãåŧããã
ãææĨã¯ãåąæˇå
ãčĻãĻåããããææĄããĻãŋããããã¨ãˇãĨãŽååŋãįĸēãããããã¨č¨ã荺ããã°ã大æĩãŽãã¨ã¯čéããĻããããããĒæ°ãããã
ããŠãŗããĢå¸ãčĸĢããåĻšãŽéŖã§įŽãéããã
13
ã垎ããĒå°éŋãã¨å ąãĢįŽãčĻãžãããããã¯å°åēä¸įã§ä¸æĨãĢä¸åēĻã卿įãĢčĩˇãã大ããĒå°éŋããŽä¸ã¤ã ã
ãéŖã§į ãŖãĻãããŽåĻšãŽå¯éĄãčĻãĻãéããĢčēĢãčĩˇãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯æĸãĢįŽãčĻãžããĻãããé¨åąãŽé ããåãĢčĻįˇãčŋããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãį ããĢã¤ãå§ŋãåã¯ä¸åēĻãčĻããã¨ããĒããããŽä¸į ã¯ãįĨãŽäžäģŖãã¨ããĻãŽįšį°äŊčŗĒãĒãŽããįĩļãéãĒãčãããæčãĢéģåŽŗãããĻããåŊąéŋããããã¯åãããĒããæŦäēēãä¸äžŋãæããĻããĒããĒãåéĄãĒããŽã ããã
ããããĒãã¨ãčããĻããæãé¨åąãŽæ¸ãããã¯ãããã
ãâåããĄã¯įĩĻäģãŽæĄå ã§ãéŖå ãĢéãããããŦãã¯æĸãĢæåŽãŽæ¤ åã§æãŽãããŗčļãéŖ˛ãã§ãããåã¨åĻšãæ¨å¤ã¨åãå¸ãĢįãã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ä¸åãŽæå¸ŗãéããã
ãããã§įæ´ģããĻããããĢãããŖãĻãä¸ã¤ãŽãĢãŧãĢãčĒŦæããããã
ãįŠãããĒåŖ°ã§čĒããããĻããããåãŽč¯ãåĻšã¯įˇåŧĩã§åēã襨æ ãããĻããã
ãįŦŦä¸ãĢãčĄŖéŖäŊã¨åŽå
¨ã¯į§ãč˛ŦäģģãæãŖãĻäŋč¨ŧããžããåŋ
čĻãĒããŽãããã°ãįĩĻäģãĢįŗãåēããã¨ãå¯čŊãĒéã፿ããããã
ããããã¨ãããããžããå
įã
ãåãåŋããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æēčļŗãã̿叺ãŽããŧã¸ããããŖãã
ãįŦŦäēããã¨ãĢã¯æĨčĒãæ¸ããĻãæ¯æŠæåēãããã¨ããããį§ãŽæ¸æã§į´æĨææ¸Ąãã¨ããĢãæ¸ãį´ãããé¨åãããã°åŋį¸čĢãã
ããããæŋįĨããĻããžãã
ãæš¯æ°ãŽįĢã¤ãããŗčļãŽãĢããã严æã§å ãŋčžŧãŋãæå ãæ¸Šããã
ããããĻãįŦŦä¸ããããä¸įĒéčĻãã
ããŦãã¯åãįãŖį´ããĢčĻæŽããã
ãããããåæĨéãå ˇäŊįãĢã¯æĨčĒãč°äŧãĢæåēããĻæŖåŧãĢčĒãããããžã§ãåąæˇå¤ã¸åēããã¨ã¯ä¸åįĻæĸããžãã
ãäēæŗããĻãããã¨ã ããéŠãã¯ãĒãã
ãå¤é¨ã¨ãŽæĨč§Ļãæį´ãäŧč¨ãįĻæĸãä¸äžŋãåŧˇãããã¨ãĢã¯ãĒããããŠãæ å ąæŧæ´Šãé˛ããåŽå ¨ãåŽããããã
ãįåąã¯éãŖãĻããããéŖįĩĄãåããã᏿ãå¤ãĢããĒããããåļéãããĻãåŊąéŋããĒãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ã夿ŗããĢæģãããã ãããīŧãåãããŽå¸ãĢčĻįˇãæããã¨ãããŗããĄããŖãĻåããå
ãã§ããã¨ãˇãĨããããŽæãæĸããĻåãčĻãã
ãčŗĒåãããã°åãäģããžããã§ãããšãŧããåˇããåãĢéŖäēãæ¸ãžããžãããã
ãåž ãĻãĒããŖãåĨ´ããããã¨ãįĨãŖãĻãįĨããããæå¸ŗãčãĢįŊŽããĻᎠãããããĒããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãšããŧãŗãæãĢåãŖãã
ãåã¯åĻšããšãŧããæŦãæ§åãįĸēãããĻããããããŗããŗãĢæãäŧ¸ã°ããããŽį̝ããĄããŖããããŖã¨ãããéĻããåēãããããĩããĩãĢäšžįĨããĻãããĒããã°ããĢããĻãããĒããæ¸Šãį´ããŽå¤ąæã§įĻããĻãããĒãåŽį§ãĒįļæ
ã ã
ããžããã¨ã¯æãããåąæˇãŽãŠãããĢįŧãįǝããããŽã ãããã
ãå įãããŽå ´æãįĨãŖãĻããå¤é¨ãŽäēēã¯ããžããīŧã
ãåã¯čŗĒåãæããããããžã åąæˇå
å
¨äŊãčĻãĻåãŖãĻãããĒãããæˇå°å¤ãå˛ãå°åŊĸãįĨããĒãã
ããŦãã¯å°ãææĄããĻãå°ããæ¯ãåããã
ãããããäŋč¨ŧãããĒããĻč¨ãããĻãåŽåŋã§ããĒãããããäēãéŋéŖįĩčˇ¯ãææĄããĻããããã¨æããŽã¯åŊįļã ããæéŖãŽåžãįĩĻäģãĢæĄå ãããããããã¨æĄå¯¸ãâĻâĻã
ãåŽå ¨æ§ãįãããĻããã¨įĨãŖãĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åĢãĒéĄããããĢįč§Ŗãį¤ēããä¸ãčĻįˇã§įĩĻäģãĢååŗãéãŖãã
ããããã¨ãããããžãã
ãč¨ãŖãĻãŋãããŽã ãĒã¨æããĒããéŖãŽåĻšã¨įŽé
ãããããé ŦãããŖãąããĢč¨ããžããåĻšããå°ãã ãčļŗãããŠããŠã¨æēããããåąæˇå
ãæĸæ¤ã§ããã¨čããĻãåŦãããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãčĻĒã᏿ã§ã¯ãææĄããåēĻãĢåčĢãčããããã°ããã ãŖããåã¯čĻãæãåēãåš˛ãčã¨ä¸įˇãĢåãŋãããã
ãéŖäēãŽåžįäģããå§ããįĩĻäģããĄãäŊæãĢãä¸äēēãŽįĩĻäģãåã¨åĻšãŽåãĢé˛ãŋåēããå ãģãŠããŦããŽååŗãĢäēæŋãčŋããĻããįĩĻäģã ã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽæĄå
ã§åã¯åĻšãŽæãæĄããéŖå ãåēããåžããã¨ãˇãĨãã¤ããĻæĨããåĨãŽé¨åąã§ä¸äēēåãŽæĄå¯¸ãįĩããã¨ãåąæˇå
æĸéēãæŦæ ŧįãĢå§ãžãŖãã
ãæĄå
åŊšãŽįĩĻäģãã卿ŋã¨éŖæåčåēĢãä¸åēãæ¸åēĢãåãããããčĒŦæããĻãããã
ãįŗįŗãæˇãããä¸åēãĢåēãæãŽãã¨ã ãæåžå°žãŽã¨ãˇãĨãčļŗãæĸãããäŊãįĄãå°éĸãčĻä¸ãããĻããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨīŧã
ãåŧãŗãããĢåŋãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯åãŗæŠãåēããã
ãåąæˇã¯å°ä¸æˇąããŽå˛Šį¤ãĢå˛ãžãã褿°ãŽįˇæĨčąåēįĩ莝ãåå¨ãããã¨ãåããĄãŽé¨åąãåŧˇåēãĒå ´æãĢäŊįŊŽããĻãããã¨ãæããĻãããã
ãäģå¤ãŽæĨčĒæåēæãĢã§ãããããããįįąãã¤ããĻæ¸åēĢãŽåŠį¨č¨ąå¯ãæąãã䞥å¤ãããããã ã
ãé¨åąãĢæģãã¨ãããææēãĢåããŖãã
ãåĻšã¯čĒåãŽé¨åąãĢã¯æģãããåãŽããããĢåē§ãã卿ŋãčĻãĻåãŖãéãĢåãåãŖãäšžįŠãéŖãšãĻãããããŽäšžįŠã¯ããŦããæĄäģļã¨ããĻæį¤ēããã䏿ĨäēéŖãĢããčļã¨ãčåãæŧå¯äģãããŽããčåããĢåŊãããæ¨æĨãŽæŧé ãé¨åąãĢéã°ããĻæĨããŽã¯ãឿĢãããŗãŽããšãąããã ãŖãã
ããããŗčļãŽæš¯æ°ãįēããĒããåã¯é Ŧæãã¤ããæēãæ¯ãåããåĻšãå¯å°ããæģãéããčļŗéŗãčåžããčãããã
ãé§ãå¯ãŖãĻããĻãåãåē§ãæ¤ åãŽæ¨Ēã§č¸ãŖããããäģĨå¤ãĢã¯åŽåŋã§ããå ´æããĒããŋãããĢãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĻįˇããé ããããŽã ãããã
ãåã¯ããŗãæãŖãĻããĒãæšãŽæã§ãåĻšãŽé ãæĢã§ããæãããéĢĒãŽæč§ĻãäŧããŖãĻãããčŗå
ã§æįĢ ãæ§į¯ãã¤ã¤æåãæ¸ãč¨ããæĢã§įļããã¨ãããŽã¯å°åŗãĢéŖåã ããããĒãã¨ãæãŖãĻããã¨ãåĻšãåãŽæãĢæãįĩĄãžããĻããã
ãããã§åĻšãŽæ°æãĄãčŊãĄįããĒããįæã貸ããããã¯äŊã§ããĒããåéĄã¯é ä¸ãŽæ°é
ã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ææēãŽčãĢįĢãĄãæ§åãčĻåŽããã¨ãĢããããããåãŽæå ãčĻãčžŧãčĻįˇã¯ãããŗå ã¨ã¤ãŗã¯ãŽčģ补ãčŋŊãŖãĻãããæåãĢã¯įĄéĸåŋã ãŖãã¯ãã ããããŖããäŊãĢčåŗãæąãããŽã ãããã
ãæ¯æĨãŽãčåããį´ãã¤ãŗã¯ãĒãŠãŽæļčåããéåą¤ãéãã°åäžãŽæãĢã¯åąããĒãč´ æ˛ĸåãč§Ļãããã¨ã ãã¯é æ ŽããĻ貰ãããããŽã ã
ãããæãŖãįĸå ãĢã大ããĒæãäŧ¸ãŗãĻãããæ¸ããã°ãããŽæåã¸æå ãč§Ļããį´åãããŽæéĻãæ´ãã§éģæĸããã
ãåž ãĻãč§ĻããĒããžã äšžããĻããĒãã
ãčĻä¸ããã¨ããĩãĻč
ãããããĒåįŧãåãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ããããå é ããĢåããŖãã
ãããŽįæ´ģã¯å§ãžãŖãã°ããã ã
ãâ
ãåąæˇå ãŽæĄå ãįĩããé¨åąãĢæģãŖãĻæĨčĒãæ´įããããĄãĢå¤éŖãŽæéã¨ãĒãŖãã
ãįĩĻäģãŽå å°ã§éŖå ã¸ã¨åããéä¸ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽį°å¤ãĢæ°ãĨããããã¤ããĒãåŊąãŽãããĢįĄč¨ã§ã¤ããĻæĨããŽãĢããĩããã¨åãé¸ããå¤ãŽæ°é ãæĸããããĒį´ æ¯ããčĻãããŽã ã
ãâĻâĻã¨ãˇãĨīŧã
ãåãåŖ°ããããĻãæ¯ãčŋããĒããä¸åŽããĢåãŽčĸãåŧãåĻšãŽæãæĄãį´ããįĩĻäģãĢæããå
ĨããĻã¨ãˇãĨãŽåžãčŋŊãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãåããŖãå
ã¯ä¸åēã ãŖãããããĢã¯å°ä¸æ ŊåšãŽčž˛åããããåŖãĢ螲å
ˇãįĢãĻãããããĻãããįēå
čãŽéįŊãå
ããæ´įļã¨ä¸ĻãļčŦčããããŗãį
§ãããĻãããããŽä¸č§ãå¤ãįŗįŗãæˇã芰ããããå ´æã§įĢãĄå°Ŋãããčļŗå
ãŽįŗįŗãį¨ãŋã¤ããĻããã
ãéŖãĢããããŋčžŧãŋãčĻįˇãŽå ãæĸãããã ãŽå¤ãŗãįŗįŗã ãčãããĻæã ãĢãããčĩ°ãŖãĻããããįšãĢå¤ããŖãæ§åã¯ãĒãã
ãâĻâĻæ°´ãŽåŖ°ã ã
ãäŊãåŖ°ã§åãããå ããĢįãå¯ããĻããã
ãæ°´īŧãâĻâĻå°ä¸æ°´čããĒã
ãåã¯å¨å˛ãčĻæ¸ĄãããããŽå࿎ã¯įļēéēãĢįŽĄįãããĻããããããŽåēį¤ã¯æ°įžåš´ãåããåå¨ããĻããããĒå¤ãéē补ãåŠį¨ããããŽã ãæĒæ´åãŽæ°´čãčæŊåããé įŽĄãčļŗå ãæĩããĻããå¯čŊæ§ã¯ååãĢããã
ãæĩããéŗãčããããŽīŧãããã¨ããæŧããĻããéŗīŧã
ãâĻâĻč§ŖããŦã
ãããŽč¨čãæåžãĢã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããéŖå ãŽæšã¸æŠãåēãããåã¨åĻšã¯éĄãčĻåãããã¨ãˇãĨãŽåžãčŋŊãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãĢã¯ãäēēéãŽåŋãŽåŖ°äģĨå¤ãĢãããŖã¨åĨãŽåŖ°ãčãããĻãããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãâããŽæĨãŽå¤éŖæããŦãã¯å§ŋãčĻããĒããŖããįĩĻäģãĢããã°ãæĨãĒå Ŧåãå ĨãŖããã¨ãŽãã¨ã ãčŠŗããäēæ ã¯æããããĒããŖããããšãŧãã¯æ¸ŠãããŖãã
ãé¨åąãĢæģããæ¨å¤ããäģãžã§ãĢčĻŗå¯ããã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĄåãæĨčĒãĢãžã¨ããĻããã¨ãæ§ãããĒããã¯éŗãéŋããã
ãåĨĨæ§ããåŧãŗã§ããæĨčĒãæãŖãĻãčļããã ããã
ãįĩĻäģãŽåŖ°ã ã
ããĻãŠã¯īŧã
ãčĄãã
ãæ¯ãčŋããããæŠããåŧžããããããĢįĢãĄä¸ããŖãåĻšãåãŽčĸãæ´ãã ãä¸äēēã§é¨åąãĢæŽããããŽãæãããããã¨ãˇãĨãåŊįļãŽãããĢįĢãĄä¸ããã
ãåããĄã¯įĩĻäģãĢæĄå ãããåąæˇãŽæåĨĨãĢããæ¸æã¸åããŖããįĩĻäģãæãéããįŦéãæ¯ãéŖ˛ãã ã
ãåŖã¨ããåŖãŽåēãã夊äēãžã§ãããŖããã¨æŦã§åãå°ŊããããĻãããæ´å˛æ¸ãį§åĻčĢæãåģē᝿§åŧãåŋįåĻæ¸ãå°ä¸ãŽå°čĒŦããã¤ãĻåãéã芰ããåŋãŽæ ãæã¨ããĻãããį§å¯ãŽčĒæ¸äŧããŽäŧå ´ã§ãããåäžãŽéãŗå ´ãĢæãããģãŠãŽå§åįãĒčĩæ¸éã ã
ãéŠåŊãĢåē§ãŖãĻã
ãé¨åąãŽä¸å¤ŽãŽæ¸éĄãįŠãžããåˇåæēãĢåããããŦãã¯éĄãä¸ãããæ¸éĄäģäēãĢæ˛Ąé ããĻãããåããĄã¯æēãŽåãĢįŊŽãããåŽĸį¨ãŽæ¤ åãĢæĩ ãč °æããã
ããããĻãŦããããŗãįŊŽããæĨčĒãæãĢåãŖãĻįĸēčĒããã
ãâĻâĻéŖäēå 厚ã¨éãįĄį æéãįēč¨ãâĻâĻä¸åēã§ãŽæ§åãĢã¤ããĻãč¨ãããĻããããã
ãããŽéãåã¯įˇåŧĩãį´ãããããããĢãæŦæŖãĢä¸Ļãļč襨į´ãŽæåãįŽã§čŋŊãŖãããå¤äģŖå°åēčĒãŽå¤éˇããįēå čãŽæ Ŋåšã¨åŋį¨ããå°ä¸ãŽįŠēãĢéĸããčå¯ãâĻâĻčåŗãæšãããéĄåãŽæŦã°ããã ã
ããã¨ãĢã
ã䏿ãĢååãåŧã°ããåã¯čĻįˇããŦããĢæģãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯æĨčĒãéããįåŖãĒįŧåˇŽããåããĻããã
ãããŽæĨčĒã¯åãĒãįæ č¨é˛ã§ã¯ãĒãããã¨ãˇãĨã¨į§ããĄããå ąåãã§ããå¯čŊæ§ãč¨ŧæãããããŽč¨ŧæ ææ¸ãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æĨčĒãŽčĄ¨į´ãæããããĢæå ã§æĢã§ãã
ããããĢæ¸ãããæåãŽä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ãã䏿ã¨åŊãŽæĒæĨãåˇĻåŗããå¯čŊæ§ãį§ããĻãããŽãäģæĨã貴æšãã¨ãˇãĨãŽãį°å¸¸ããĢæ°ãĨãããããĢãįč§ŖãåļåžĄã§ãããã¨ãį¤ēããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã
ãč¨čã¯įŠããã ããããŽčŖãĢã¯č¨ãįĨããĒãéå§ã¨åˇåžšãĒč¨įŽãæŊãã§ãããããĢæããããŠããĒįæŗããæ˛ããã ãã§ã¯äŊãæããĒãããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įč§ŖããĻãããŽã ã
ãæĨčĒãŽå
厚ãããŦããŽæąããåēæēãæēããããããŽäēåŽãĢéææã¨åŽå ĩãčĻããåéĸã§ããããæŋæ˛ģã¨ããå ´ã§äŊŋããããŽã¯äŊã¨ãĒãåĢãĒæããããã
ãâĻâĻå
įãä¸ã¤ãäŧēãŖãĻãīŧã
ããããäŊãããīŧã
ãå
įã¯įĩåąãŽã¨ãããã¨ãˇãĨããŠãããããŽã§ããīŧãįŽĄįããĻåŠį¨ãããŽããããã¨ãâĻâĻã
ããŦãã¯å°ãéŠãããããĢįŦããããããããĻããĩãŖã¨čĄ¨æ ãįˇŠããã
ãį§ã¯ãæĒæĨã¨åšŗåãæãã§ãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽįŗãĢã¯ãæēãããĒãæåŋãåŽŋãŖãĻããã
ãããé ãããįļãã¯äģåēĻãĢããžãããããĻãŠãĄãããį ããã ãã
ãåãŽčŠãĢå¯ããããåĻšãčĻãĻããŦãã垎įŦãã
ãããã¨ãæŦãã貸ãããããŽã§ãããã訹ãããã ããžããīŧãæĨčĒãæ¸ãéãåĻšãéåąãããĢããĻãããŽã§ã
ãč¨čãé¸ãŗãĒããįŗãåēãã
ããããããĄããããæ¸åēĢãĢãĒãįĩĩæŦãäēå ¸ãããããäŧæŠæéãĢčĒãåããããããå ąæãŽč˛ĄįŖã§ãããã¨ãåŋããĒãã§ãã
ãåã¯į¤ŧãčŋ°ãšãåĻšãŽæãåŧããĻæ¸æãåžãĢããã
ãããŽå¤ãæãŽéééŗã§įŽãčĻãããåĻšã¯éŖã§å¯æ¯ãįĢãĻãĻãããå¯čŋããæã¤ãããĢčēĢäŊãŽåããå¤ããæéãĢįŽãåããããã¨ãˇãĨãŽå§ŋããĒãã
ãéŗãįĢãĻãĒããããĢå¸åŖããæãåēããæãå°ãã ãéããĻåģä¸ãčĻãããæãããæļããä¸ã大ããĒäēēåŊąãé ãŽããĻčĄããããŽåžãčŋŊãã¨ãåããŖãå
ã¯ä¸åēã ãŖãã
ãæˇąå¤ãŽä¸åēã¯ãæŧéã¨ã¯éãéãããĢå
ãžããĻãããįēå
ãããŗãčãæˇĄãå
ãæžãŖãĻããåã厤å
ãããæããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æŧéã¨åãįŗįŗãŽä¸ãĢįĢãŖãĻãããčēĢåãããããå°éĸãčĻä¸ãããĻããããžãã§ã大å°ãŽåēããéŋãåŖ°ãĢåŧã°ããããã¸åŧãå¯ããããĻããããŽãããĢã
ããã°ããæ§åãįĒēãŖãĻããããäŊããį ´åŖããããæ´ãããããį´ æ¯ãã¯ãĒãã坿°ã¨į æ°ãææ
ĸã§ããĒããĒãŖãåã¯ãåĻšãŽããæ¸Šããå¯åēã¸æģãŖãã
ãčæ°åŗãŽæĒãäēæãããããŽãč¸ãŽåĨĨãĢæŧãčžŧããĒããã
ãâ
ãæéŖãæ¸ãžããåã¯åĻšã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãåŧãéŖããæ¸åēĢãĢåããŖãã
ãæãéããéį̝ãåĻšã¯æåŖ°ãä¸ããĻãįĩĩæŦãŗãŧããŧãĢé§ãåēããã¨ãˇãĨã¯éˇæ¤
åã§å¯čģĸãããåã¯å°čĒŦãŽįļåˇģãæĸãæŠããã
ããã¨ãĢæ§ã大å¤ãäš ããļãã§ããčĒæ¸äŧäģĨæĨã§ããīŧã
ãæĨãĢ芹ããããããĻæ¯ãčŋãããããĢįĢãŖãĻãããŽã¯äŊŋį¨äēēãŽæãįãčĨãįˇã ãŖãã
ããĒãäģãŽåã¨åŊæãŽåãåä¸äēēįŠã§ããã¨åããŖããŽã ãããīŧãčãŽč˛ãååããããŽé ã¨ã¯éããŽãĢâĻâĻã
ãč¨ããã§ããã¨ãåŊŧã¯å¸ãŽä¸ã§įŦãŖãĻãããããĒæ°é
ãčĻããã
ããããĢæ°ãĨããžãããããã¤ãĻãį§ãčĒæ¸äŧãĢéãŖãĻããžããããã
ããããããããĢäģããĻããäēēã¯įãä¸åą¤čĄããį§ģãäŊãã į°į¨ŽæãčĒæ¸äŧã§čĒãŋæ¸ããį¤ŧåãåĻãã åäžããĄããäŊãŋčžŧãŋã§åããĻãããŽã ã
ããããčĻããĻããĒãã¨ãįĄįã¯ãããžãããį§ããĄãŽãããĒč ãĢãã¨ãĢæ§ã¯įĄéĸåŋã§ãããŖããããžããããã
ãåŊŧã¯æ ã¨ãããäģčã§įļããã
ãã§ãããããˇãŖãŽãã¨ã¯čĻããĻããã§ã§ãããīŧãå¯ä¸åŋã訹ããåäēēã¨ãåŧãšãåå¨âĻâĻã
ãä¸čēžãĒåĨ´ã ããããĒåĨ´ãĢæ§ãŖãĻããæéãæããã
ããããĢã§ãäŧ芹ãåãä¸ããįĢãĄåģããã¨ãåã¯čēĢãįŋģããããĒããčēĢäŊãéããæããããĢé˛ããĒãã
ãåŋããã¯ããããžãããããã ãŖãĻãããˇãŖã¯âĻâĻã
ããããĢčŋŊãã¤ããĻįĢãĄã¯ã ããŖãåŊŧããéĄãŽå¸ãåãæããããŽä¸ãĢã¯ããããšãããŽãäŊããĒããŖãã
ãåã¯čēĢäŊã莺ããããĒããįŽãčĻãžãããæŋãã忏ãåãᎠãã¤ãããããįŽãŽåã§ã¯ãåĻšã垎ããĒ坿¯ãįĢãĻãĻããã
ãé¨åąãčĻæ¸Ąããå ã§ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽéģéč˛ãĢčŧãįŗãããĄããčĻãĻãããåãæĒå¤ĸãĢããĒãããĻããéããããŖã¨čããĻãããŽã ãããã
ãâ
ãįŋæãææēãĢåããŖãĻæ¨å¤ãŽåēæĨäēãæ´įããã
ãå¤äģŖéčĄã襰éããįžäģŖãĢãããĻãįŽĄįå¯čŊãĒįįŠããæŧåēãããĢã¯ãäēåŽãæ˛ããĒããžãžãį§åĻįįĨčĻã§ãžã¨ããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã
ãæ¸ãįĩããã¨ããã§ãæéŖãįĨãããããã¯ãéŋããã
ãæéŖãįĩããĻéŖå ãåēãã¨ãåã¯åĻšãŽæãåŧããĻæ¸åēĢãĢåããŖãã
ãåģä¸ãæŠãåĻšã¯įãã䏿ŠåĢã ãŖããæ¨æĨãŽå࿎å
æĸæ¤ã§å°ãã ãææåŋãčãããŽãããã ãããįĩĩæŦãæĨŊããŋãĒãŽããįĨããĒããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄč¨ã§ã¤ããĻæĨãã
ãæãéããéį̝ãĢãį´ã¨ã¤ãŗã¯ã垎ããĒčŦčãŽåããéŧģãããããŖããå§åįãĒčĩæ¸éãĢãåĻšãå°ããĒæåŖ°ãä¸ããĻãã§ãŗãã§ãŗã¨čˇŗããåãŽæãåŧãŖåŧĩãŖãã
ãã¨ãĢãčĻãĻãããŽæŦãæŋãįĩĩããããããããŽããčąãã ãŖãĻããããããŖãĄã坿ãã
ãåĻšãåēããĻãããŽã¯å°ä¸ãŽæ¤įŠåŗéã ãčŠŗį´°ãĒæŋãįĩĩãĢæšããããããã
ãâĻâĻãããæŦįŠīŧãæŗåã§æãããŽãããĒãīŧã
ãæŦįŠã ããããŖãĄãŽčãŖãąã¯čĻããã¨ããã§ããīŧãäģæãŽãšãŧããĢæˇģããããĻããããŧãã
ãįŽãčŧãããĻããŧã¸ããããå§ŋãĢåŽå ĩããåãčĒãŋããå°čĒŦãŽįļåˇģãæĸããĻåãŖãã
ãâéä¸ãæŦæŖãĢå¯ããããŖãĻč
įĩãŋãããĻããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻã¤ãããįĢãŖããžãžäģŽį ãå§ãããããĢãčĻããĻããããããŽčŗã¯äģãéŗãæžãŖãĻãããŽã ããã
ãå°čĒŦãŽæŦĄã¯ãįĨčŠąãæ´å˛æ¸ãæĸããã¨ãĢããã
ãããŽå࿎ãŽįĩĻäģããĄã¯ãæéŖãŽįäģãåžãĢæ¸åēĢã§äŧæŠãåãįŋæ ŖãããããããããŽæéãĢãĒãã¨ãã¨ãããŗãå¤ããįĩĻäģããĄãæ¸åēĢãč¨Ēããã
ãããããåŽĸīŧãâĻâĻå°ãŖãããã
ããåŽĸæ§ãäŊŋį¨ä¸ãŋããã卿ŋãĢæģãããīŧã
ãæ°ãéŖãŖãĻåŖ°ãã˛ãããĻããããå ¨é¨čãããĻãããåą åŋå°ãŽæĒããæããĻæŦãéããã
ãããŽãįããåããĄãĢæ§ããäŧæŠããĻãã ãããããé¨åąãĢæģãã¨ãããĒãŽã§ã
ãåąæˇãæĄå ããĻ貰ãŖãåŊąéŋãããããã¯ãčĄãå ã ã§æ ŖããĒãæ¨æļãčŠĻãŋãåšæããįĩĻäģããĄãŽæ åēĻã¯å°ãæããããĒãŖããããĢæãã
ãããããããĒâĻâĻã
ããč¨čãĢįããããĻããã ããžãããīŧã
ãį¨ŽæãįĢå ´ãŽéããĢããéããããįŦįšãŽčˇéĸæãįãã§ãããããŽæããããŠããĢãčŊãĄįããĒãã
ããããããã°ããæäŧãããžããããīŧã
ãįĩĻäģãŽä¸äēēãåãŽæąããæŦãčĻãĻįŗãåēããåŗéä¸åã¨å°čĒŦã¨åģēåŊįĨ芹ãåŊ垿¸ãåãããĻåæ°åãįĸēããĢéããåã¯åĨĨãŽæããįĨé ŧãŋããäŊŋããã¨æ¯ãčŋãã
ãæåžãĢå§ŋãčĻãå ´æããããĢã¨ãˇãĨã¯ããĒããŖãã
ãäŧæŠä¸ãĒãŽãĢããčŋˇæã§ã¯âĻâĻīŧã
ãããããããæ°ãĢãĒãããã
ãįĩåąãåŗéãé¨åąãžã§éãã§č˛°ããã¨ãĢãĒãŖããåŊŧåĨŗããĄãŽäŧ芹ãčŗãĢå ĨãŖãĻããã
ãããŽé ã¯ããčåįŽįã§éãŖãĻããã
ãããĄãŽåããããŗä¸ã¤ãåãåãŖãæĨãåŽļãĢ帰ãŖãĻãããĒãããæ¯ãããĢããããŖãĻã
ãį§ããčĒæ¸äŧããĒããŖããã¨æãã¨âĻâĻã
ããã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãã¯čĒæ¸äŧãŽåēčēĢč
ã¨éĸäŋč
ããĄãŽããã ãå°čąĄįãĒåēæĨäēãæããä¸äģŖãŽéããįŦãŖããããĻããã
ããŦãã¯äŊåš´åããčĒæ¸äŧãä¸ģåŦããĻãããŽã ããã
ãâĻâĻã§ããããŽåãããŖãĄã§čĻãããĒãããīŧã
ãįĩĻäģãŽä¸äēēãããĩã¨æãåēãããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãããŽåãŖãĻīŧã
ããģãããããããŽééĢĒãĢæããå
æ°ãĒįŦéĄã§ãčĄãŽäēēæ°č
ã ãŖãåã
ããããããĒãæĸčĻæãĢäŧŧãããŽãããããã
ãåŽåŽļãŽåēãįļãäēēãããã§ãããīŧã
ããããããããããŽåãåēįĒããããããŠããĒãåēã§ããäēēã ãããã§ãããã ãã
ãæãããããĢįŦãåãåŊŧåĨŗããŽäŧ芹ãåã¯éģãŖãĻčããĻããã
ãâįĩĻäģããĄã¯ææēãĢæŦãįŠãŋéããé¨åąãåģãŖãĻčĄãŖããæãéããããéį̝ãåã¯å¯å°ãĢįĒãŖäŧãããæŦæĸãã¨ã¯åĨãŽį˛å´æããŽããããã
ãããŽæ¨ĒãĢåĻšãč
°æããĻãäŊãæãŖããŽãåãŽé ãæĢã§å§ãããæãŽæ¸ŠãããããļãŠãļãŠããäŊãããĒã ãããĢčŊãĄįãããĻãããã
ããĩã¨ãéĄãä¸ããĻé¨åąãčĻæ¸Ąããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãããĒããæ¸åēĢããå§ŋãæļããĻããžã é¨åąãĢæģãŖãĻããĒããĒãããžãä¸åēã¸čĄãŖããŽã ãããīŧãããŽãæ°´ãŽåŖ°ããĢåŧã°ããĻã
ãåã¯åŖãĢæããããéĸ¨æ¯įģãčĻã¤ããããããĢã¯å¯éããæ¤įŠãĢå˛ãžããéæãĒæēãæą ãčŧããĻããã
14
ããäēæšã¨ããäģæĨã¯ä¸åēãĢåēãĒãã§ãã ããã
ãææŠãäŊŋį¨äēēãæ ãĻãæ§åã§é¨åąã¸éŖãŗčžŧãã§æĨããĒããããč¨ãŖãã
ããŠããããã§ããīŧã
ãããããä¸åēãŽä¸é¨ãå´ŠčŊããžããĻâĻâĻã
ãé¸ããĢãé¸ãŖãĻä¸åēīŧãäģããįļæŗãįĨãããããäģäēãŽéĒéããããããĢã¯čĄããĒãã
ãããããžãããčŠŗããčãããĻ貰ããžããīŧããŦãå įãĢäžé ŧãããĻããæĨčĒãĢãæˇąãéĸãããã¨ãĒãŽã§âĻâĻã
ãåŋĩãŽãããĢæˇģããåčĒãåãåĨãããã¯åŽãã§ãĒãããŽãŽãäŊŋį¨äēēã¯é ãčŋŊãŖãĻčĒŦæããĻãããããããĢããã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨãčĻã¤ããĻããå¨čžēããæãŽå°éŋããĢäŧ´ãéĨæ˛Ąããã¨ããã
ãâĻâĻãããŖãĻãããŽå ´æīŧã
ãå¸åŖããéĄãåēããåĻšãä¸åŽããĢåãã
ãæĒæäēēã¯īŧãčĸĢåŽŗãæĄå¤§ããå¯čŊæ§ã¯īŧã
ã嚸ãčǰããã§ãããå¨å˛ãŽå°į¤ãįˇŠãã§ããå¯čŊæ§ããããžããåå ã垊æ§ãŽįŽåĻãĢã¤ããĻããčŠŗããã¯ãžã âĻâĻã
ãåã¯æ¯ãčŋãŖãĻé¨åąãčĻæ¸Ąããã
ããããĒæãĢč¨ãéŖããŽã§ãããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãããžããã§ãããīŧãããŽä¸åēã¸åããŖãã¨æããŽã§ããīŧã
ãå°ãããĻããžããã¨ã¯æŋįĨãŽä¸ã ããããŖãąãæ¸ãéĄããããã
ãæˇˇäšąã大ããããããžã§ã¯âĻâĻããåŽĸæ§ãåąéēãĒå ´æã¸æĄå ãããããĢåããžããã
ãããŽå࿎ã§åãäēēããĄã¯ãį䏿§ãĢéĄãčãé ããããŽå¸ãäģŽéĸãã¤ããĻãããč¨ĒååŽĸãŽåã§ã¯åžšåēããĻį˛ã
ã¨åããĻããããåŽŋæŗåŽĸãŽåã§ã¯åããããæ ŧåĨŊãčĒããããĻãããããã
ãããŽäŊŋį¨äēēã¯éčĻãĒįĨãããããĄæŠãåąãããããããĒãįĻãŖãĻãããŽã ãããéĄãé ãããŧãĢãé ãĢåŧãŖæãããžãžãŽå§ŋã ãŖããããŽčã¯č˛éģã§ãéĄãåŖ°ãčĨãå˛ãĢãå°ããŖãąããã¨ããįãčļéĢĒãĢã¯įŊéĢĒãæˇˇããŖãĻããã
ãããã¨ãæ¸åēĢãĢčĄããããŽã§ããâĻâĻã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽãã¨ã ãäžãå´ŠčŊãĢåˇģãčžŧãžããĻããåŊãčŊã¨ããģãŠčģåŧąã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããäēæ
ãåŠį¨ããĻã夿ŗããŽįã¸éãåģļãŗãå°įąå˛ŠãĢåē§ãå§ŋãĒãã厚æãĢæŗåã§ãããããããããŽãããŽįŠ´ãčĒãéããįãããããįļæ
ã ã
ãįŽĄįč
ã¨ããĻãå
¨åŽšãææĄããĒããã°ãĒããĒããã
ãåš¸ãæ¸åēĢã¯įĄäēã§ãããåŋĩãŽįēãä¸įˇããžããããĄãã¸ã
ãčĄŖæãŽäšąããæ´ãããįŽäģãåŊšãåŧãåããĻããããįĨããŦéãĢé¨åąãæãåēããããĻããĻããããããããããŽæšãåŽå ¨ã ã¨å¤æãããŽã ããã
ãįĄįãč¨ãŖãĻãããŋãžããã
ããããæ°ãĢããĒãã§ãã ãããæ°ããåŽļæãčŋãå
Ĩããæã¯įã§éĸåãčĻããŽãããåąæˇãŽčĻåã§ãã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻåŊŧã¯æŠããĒãããåąæˇã§ãŽæŽãããļããčãããĻããããįŠåŋã¤ãåããæ¯čĻĒã¨äŊãŋčžŧãŋã§åããĻããã¨ããåŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻãããŽå࿎ãĢäŊãå
¨åĄãåŽļæãŽãããĒããŽãããã
ãčĻæåŋãŽäŊãã¨į´į˛ãã¯ãããæ
ã ãããå¤ãŽį¸äēįŖčĻã貧å°ãįĨãä¸äēēã¨ããĻãįŠããããããåąãããčĻããã
ãæ
ãã ããéãéããĻčĄãäģäēäģ˛éã¸ãåŊŧã¯įŠæĨĩįãĢæ¨æļããããįĄčĻããč
ã¯ããĒããŖããåŋĢãæ¨æļãäē¤ãããåžã§åã¨åĻšãŽčĻįˇãĢæ°ãĨããããããã¨įĢãĄåģããã¨ããįĩĻäģãĢãåã¯æãåãŖãĻåããããã
ãä¸åēã§čĩ¤éĢĒãŽå¤§įˇãčĻãžããã§ãããīŧã
ãå°æãããããĒ襨æ ã§čĻãĒããŖãã¨čŋããããŽįĩĻäģã¯äģäēãĢæģãŖãĻããŖããæŦĄãĢããéãŖãäŊŋį¨äēēãĢã¯å¤čĻãŽįšåž´ãããčŠŗããčĒŦæãããããããåžå´ãĢįĩãããįåŋĩãč¨ããã§ããã
ãį§ģåä¸ãäēéãŽåģä¸ããä¸åēãįãŋčĻãããã¨ãˇãĨãŽå§ŋã¯čĻãĒããŖããæ¸åēĢãĢįããåžããčĒãŋįĩããæŦãå
ããŖãæŖãĢæģããĒããæĸãåãŖãã
ãæŖãĢæģããŽãčĨãäŊŋį¨äēēãæäŧãŖãĻããããããã§æŠãįĩããŖããåŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻæ¸åēĢã¯åšŧå°æãããŽéãŗå ´ã§ãããåĻãŗãŽå ´ã§ãããŖãããããäģäēãŽåéãĢč¨Ēãã大äēēããĄãããčĒãŋæ¸ããįŋãŖãã¨ãčãããĻãããã
ãããĄããŽæŦã¯ãããã§ããīŧãčĒæ¸äŧã§ãäēēæ°ã ãŖãã¨čããĻãžããã
ãåŊŧãåˇŽãåēãããŽã¯ãåéēå°čĒŦã ãŖãã
ãâĻâĻčĒæ¸äŧīŧã
ãåĻšãåãæ¯ãčŋãã
ããããåãčĒãã ãã¨ãããã
ãčĒæ¸äŧãĢéãŖãĻãããããŽã§ããīŧã
ãįŽãčĻéããĻåãčĻãåŊŧčĒčēĢã¯ãčĒæ¸äŧãĢéãŖããã¨ããĒãããã ã
ãäŊåš´ãåãĢâĻâĻã
ãããã§ããããå°ãįž¨ãžããã§ãã
ãåąæˇå
ãŽéį¨ãäģģãããĻã°ããããããä¸åą¤čĄãŽãã¨ãåĢããå¤ãŽčŠąãčããããŖãã
ãįĩåąãæ¸åēĢãĢãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ããĒããŖãã
ãæéŖãŽæéãĢãĒããéŖå ãč¨ĒãããããããĢãã¨ãˇãĨãŽå§ŋã¯ãĒãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãĒãä¸åēã§čĻããããããããŠãããããŽīŧã
ãéŖå ãŽįĩĻäģãĢæŦæĨäŊåēĻįŽãčŗĒåãæããããæããŦããįããã
ãæ§åãčĻãĻããžãã
ãåžãĢãĒããããšãŧããåˇããĻããžãããâĻâĻãããĢãäģã¯æãéĸããĒãããã ãã
ãåēãĻčĄããããåããŦããåãããåŖ°č˛ã¯æãããããæįĄãč¨ãããĒãæ°čŋĢãæããã
ãããããã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĻŗå¯ãåŊåŽļãŽåäēĄãĢéĸããã¨č¨ãŖããŽã¯åŊŧåĨŗčĒčēĢã ãä¸įŋãŽãšãŧããåĒå
ããšãã¨ä¸ģåŧĩããįįąããåãĢã¯įč§Ŗã§ããĒããŖãã
ã貴æšãæĨčĒãæ ãŖãĻãããããĢãéŖäēãæ´ããč ãįäģããæ ãč ããããŽãä¸äēēãŽéŊåã§åąæˇå ¨äŊãŽį§ŠåēãäšąãčĄįēã¯ãįéã§ããĒããã
ãåã¯åŖãéããããšãŧãįŋãĢčĻįˇãčŊã¨ããĻåãåãã ã
ãįŖčĻããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã¨æãŖãĻãīŧã
ããŦãã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽåąéēæ§ãæĒã ãĢįč§Ŗã§ããĻããĒããé常čã§ä¸éįĨãããĒã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãåĢįčĻŗãįŊǿǿãæŦ åĻããĻããããããĒãŽãĢãåēį¤čŊåå¤ãéĢéãããŽã ãããäŊãčĩˇããĻããã§ã¯æé
ãã ã
ãåãŽåæēãå¯ããåŊŧåĨŗã垎įŦãã
ããããããĻãåŊŧãåãĢããĒãã¨ä¸åŽãĒãŽãããīŧã
ãããããčĻåŊéããįã ãããæŠäēēã§ãĒããã°åŗåē§ãĢåĻåŽããϿǿ ããåããã ãããããšãŧãã¨å ąãĢéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ã
ãæŠã ãĢéŖäēãįĩããåã¯ããŦããŽč¨ąå¯ãåžãĻä¸åēã¸åããŖãã
ãâ
ãã
ãåĻšãŽæãæĄãŖãĻä¸åēã¸æĨãã ã
ãããã§ã¯äŊŋį¨äēēããĄã垊æ§äŊæĨãĢåãįĩãã§ãããå˛ãįŗãįäģããåãåããį˛ãį åŠįŗãæēåããĻããã Â
ããããĢæˇˇããŖãĻãã¨ãˇãĨãéģã
ã¨įŗãéãã§ãããäēäēēãããã§éãļãããĒįŗãåšŗįļã¨æãĄä¸ããæį¤ēéããĢä¸ĻãšãĻãããå¨å˛ãŽč
ã¯įŽãčĻåŧĩããĒããããåį ãããéããããį åŠãéãã ãããĻããããããŽäŊæĨãĢåãįĩãã§ããã
ãåž ãĻãããŖãĄãéĄã ãâĻâĻãããä¸ãĢåããã ãã
ãäŊæĨãææŽããåš´é ãŽįˇããč °ãæŧãããĒããåŖ°ããããĻãããčēĢæ¯ãææ¯ãã§įŗįŗãŽåãŋåãããĢã¤ããĻäŧãããã¨ããããŽãŽãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æ¯ãčŋãããããĢįŗãčģĸãããããšãŗã¨éŗãįĢãĻãĻįŗãåãžãŖãã
ããīŧããĄããŖã¨åž ãŖãĻããâĻâĻéĢãããĄãããã
ãåļįļãåŋ įļããį´åžãŽããæšåãĢåãžãŖãããããčĻããããĒããåš´é ãŽįˇãčĻįˇãäŊãããĻįŗååŖĢãŽéĢäŊåˇŽãčĻæ¯ãšããããŽéãĢããã¨ãˇãĨã¯æŦĄãŽįŗã¸æãäŧ¸ã°ããã
ããĒãĄã§ãåž ãĻãŖãĻâĻâĻīŧã
ãæåˇãŽãããĒåŖ°ãéŖãã ããããĢã¯äŋŽįšãææŽããč˛Ŧäģģč
ã¨ããĻãæå°č
ã¨ããĻãŽįĻããããŖãã
ãåã¯éĸããå ´æããæ§åãįēããĻããããããĒéĸ¨ãĢäģäēēã¨æĨããã¨ãˇãĨãŽå§ŋã¯åããĻã ãåãåĻšããããããŖã¨å࿎ãŽäŊäēēããĄã¨éĻ´æãã§ãããããĢčĻããã
ããããžã§ã¯ä¸å¨į¨ã§åäģģããĒé¨åããčĻãĻããĒããŖãããčˇäēēãå¸ããããģãŠãŽéãã§įŗįŗãŽæ§é ãįč§ŖããĻįŠãŋį´ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčä¸ãĢãåĨåĻãĒé ŧããããčĻããã
ãããŽæĨãŽå¤ãåã¯æĨčĒãæãŖãĻéŖå ã¸åããŖãã
ãâĻâĻå°ä¸æ°´čˇ¯ãŽå´ŠčŊäēįĨã¨äŋŽįšã§čĻããæĒåãã
ãéŖäēãæ¸ãžããåžãæĨčĒãŽé įŽãįĸēčĒãããŦãã¯ãããŽįŽãčŧãããã
ãããŽãå°ä¸æ°´čˇ¯ãŽå´ŠčŊäēįĨããĢã¤ããĻã ããŠãããŽæãŽåŖ°č˛ã襨æ ã¯īŧããããčĻčãããĻãŠãæããīŧãä¸ģčĻŗãæé¤ããĒããĻãããŽããããã貴æšãéããĻã¨ãˇãĨããŠããčĻŗæ¸ŦããããããįĨããããŽãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æå¸Ģãæŋæ˛ģåŽļã¨ãããããį´į˛ãĒåĨŊåĨåŋãåēæŋãããåĻč ãį įŠļč ãŽãããĒ襨æ ã§čĒãŖãã
ãããããã¨ãĢã貴æšãĢã¯ã¨ãˇãĨããŠãčĻããĻãããŽīŧã
ãåįĒãĒåããĢåã¯éåŖããã
ãæĨčĒãĢã¯ãååįé åŋããæĒåããäēįĨãã¨ããŖãäēåŽãä¸Ļãšãããããã¯čĻŗæ¸Ŧč
ã¨ããĻãŽč¨é˛ãĢéããĒããåčĒčēĢãŽææ
ãåãããĻãããŽã ã
ãâĻâĻåąããåå¨ã§ããé常čã§ãä¸éįĨããã§ãäŊããããåãããĒããįŽãéĸããéãĢäēēãčĨ˛ããããĒãįįŖã§ãã
ãããã¯įŽĄįãäģģãããĻããč ã¨ããĻãŽįžŠåæã¨ãããããäŋčēĢããåēãč¨čã ãŖãããŦãã¯éĻãåžãã垎įŦãæĩŽããšãã
ãããã ããããīŧã貴æšã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãåãĢããã¨ãå°ãåŽåŋããĻãããããĢčĻããããä¸åēã§åŊŧãčĻã¤ãã貴æšãŽįŽã¯ãįįŖã¸åããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããŖãããã
ãåã¯ãšããŧãŗãæĄãį´ããããĢæŗãåēãããåēäŧãŖãæãŽææãæãã°äŋĄãéŖããã¨ã ããããčĻãããĻãäģæšãĒããããĒäģčãčĻããĻããããįĨããĒãã
ãæĨčĒãĢã¯ãåŽĸčĻŗįäēåŽã ããæ¸ãã°ããã¨æãŖãĻããžããã
ãäēåŽã大åããã§ããčǰããäģããĻã§ããčĻŗæ¸Ŧã§ããĒãįåŽãããã
ããŦããŽč¨čãŽæåŗãįč§Ŗãããã¨éģãčžŧãã ãå¯ããŽč¯ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãåãæãããŖãĻãããã¨ãĢæ°äģãããŽã ããã Â
ããããã¨ãˇãĨãŽå¤čĻįãĒįšåž´ãčãããĻãããĒãīŧã
ãåã¯å°ãčããæãį¸åŋããč¨čãæĸããã
ãčĩ¤ã῝ãĢč¤č˛ãŽčãįéǍéã ãŽå¤§įˇã§ããįĨįč˛ãŽįŗåãįŖãŽãããĒįŽãããĻããĻãåããĻčĻãæã¯ãäēēéŖããŽæĒįŠãã¯åŽå¨ãããŽãã¨æããžããã
ãåŊæãŽįļæŗãæãčŋãã¤ã¤æˇĄã ã¨čŋ°ãšãåãĢããŦãã¯éããĢé ˇãããããĻãæå¤ãĒãã¨ãåŖãĢããã
ãį§ãĢã¯ãįãŽéŦŖãæãĄãæŧéģįŗãŽãããĒčãããå°åš´ãĢčĻããããåããĻčĻãæãããããŖã¨ã
ãæĨãĢéģãčžŧãã åãčĻãĻãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æĒæ¯ãŖãŊã垎įŦãã ã
ãååŧˇãããããæĒåŽæãĒåąãããæãããŽãæãããæĒįŠãĢčĻãããŽã¯ãããŽæãŽč˛´æšããåŧˇãä¸åŽã¨ææãæąããĻããããã§ã¯ãĒããããīŧãã§ãããã ããããį§ã¯ãåŊŧãŽæéˇãå¤åãŽå¯čŊæ§ãäŋĄãããããŽãã
ãåãčĻãĻããã¨ãˇãĨã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĻãã¨ãˇãĨã§ã¯ãå§ŋãéãīŧãäŋãĢã¯äŋĄãéŖã芹ã ã
ãããŖã¨å¤ããŽčĻįšããčĻŗå¯ããĒããã°ãįåŽãĢčžŋãįããĒããŽããįĨããĒããčãčžŧãŋčĒŋæģãããåŋ
čĻãããããã ã
ãé¨åąã¸æģãéä¸ã芹ãįĩãããžã§åž ã¤ã¨č¨ãåŧĩãŖãåĻšãŽæãæĄããåã¯åããããã
ããĻãŠã¯ãã¨ãˇãĨããŠãæãīŧã
ãããã¨åĻšã¯čãčžŧããããĢé ãæēãããã
ããžã æããã§ããã¨ãĢãä¸įˇãĢããæã¯å°ãåŽåŋã§ããã Â
ãå¤čĻã¯īŧã
ã大ãããĻåæãĄã ããŠãæã
ããĄããŖã¨åäžãŋããã
ãåäžãŋãããŖãĻããŠããĒã¨ããīŧã
ãå ˇäŊįãĢčãåēããã¨ããã¨ããžãåĻšã¯é ãæŠãžããã
ãããã¨ããįäŧŧãŖãããã¨ããã
ã大ããäģĨå¤ãŽįšåž´ã¯īŧãããĩããĩãŽįæ¯ãå¤ããŖãĻãããīŧã
ããããâĻâĻãģããŽãĄããŖã¨ã ããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčŊåã¯ãäēēéãŽæčãææ ãŽãč´åŋãčŊåãĢįãžãããä¸įŠãŽåŖ°ãããäēå ããįĨčĻã§ãããŽããįĨããĒãã
ãé¨åąãŽæãéããåã¯ãä¸ãįĸēčĒããĻčåžãæ¯ãčŋãŖãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯īŧã
ã大äēãĒã芹ãŽéä¸ã§éŖå ãåēãĻčĄãŖãĄããŖããããčĻãĻãĒããã
ããžãã¨ãˇãĨãŽå§ŋããĒãããŠãããé¨åąãæãåēãã¯ãģãã¤ããããã ã
ãåã¯æēãæ¯ãåããåĻšãé¨åąãĢæŽããĻæĸããĢåēããä¸åēãĢã¯ããĒããŖããåģä¸ãé˛ãã¨ãæ¸æãŽåã§įĢãĄå°Ŋãã大ããĒčä¸ãčĻã¤ããã
ãæãŽåããããã¯įŠéŗã˛ã¨ã¤ããĒããããŦãã¯æ¸æãĢãããŽã ããããæãéããã§ããĒããããã¯ããã§ããĒãããã æãŽåãĢįĢãŖãĻčŗãæžãžããĻããã
ãããŽå§ŋã¯åŋ åŽãĒįĒäēēãŽããã§ããããį˛įŠãŽéãįĒēãįŖãŽããã§ãããŖããå°åš´ãæãããčĻį´ ãĒããĻããŠããĢãčĻåŊãããĒãã
ãâ
ãįŋæãæéŖãŽįäģããããĻããįĩĻäģãæãžããã¨ãˇãĨãįĢãĄåģãŖãåžãŽæ¤ åãæãį¤ēããĻå°ããã Â
ãéŖäēãŽæãããŽå¸ãĢåē§ãŖãĻããäēēãĢã¤ããĻããŠãæããžããīŧã Â
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯éŖå¨ãéããĻããæãæĸããæ éãĢč¨čãé¸ãļã Â
ãčĻãããĢäŧŧåãããéŖãšæšã¯éãã§įļēéēã§ãããããĢãį´°ãããĒæ°é
ããã§ããæšã§ããã
ãæ°é
ãīŧã
ãįĄé įãĒč °å¸įˇãĢã¯äŧŧã¤ãããããĒãåčĒã ã
ããããåĨĨæ§ã¯ãããŽæĨãŽæ°åãäŊčĒŋã§ãčļčãčĒŋåŗæãå¤ããããžããã§ãããããŽæšã¯ããããæŖįĸēãĢå¯ããããããĻãåĨĨæ§ãæãäŧ¸ã°ãåãĢåĄŠãåˇŽãåēããããčļãŽãäģŖãããčĻæąãããâĻâĻãžãã§éˇåš´éŖãæˇģãŖãåˇäēãŽããã§ããã
ãããŽããčĻãããĢããããã¨č¨ããŽã¯īŧã
ãįĩĻäģã¯å°ãŖããããĢéĻãåžããåŖ°ãæŊããã
ãâĻâĻįŗãä¸ããĻč¯ãããŽãĒãŽããåĨæãĒãåŦãįŠãčēĢãĢãžã¨ãŖãĻããžãã§ãããīŧããããĒãŽãĢã䏿č°ã¨å卿ãčãã¨įŗããžããâĻâĻæ°é ãæļããŽããã䏿ãĒãŽãããããžããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãæčŊã ãåŊąãŽčãåžč ããŽãããĢčĻããĻãããããã
ãæŧé ãĢããčļã¨čåãé¨åąãžã§éãã§ãããčĨãįĩĻäģãĢčããĻãŋããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įãæąãããžãžãå¤ĸčĻããããĢčĻįˇãå°ãä¸ãĢåŊˇåž¨ãããã
ããé¨åąãĢčŋãĨãã¨ããã¯ããåãĢãæãéããĻãããæšã§ãããīŧããããĒãĢįãŖį´ããĢčĻã¤ããããĻããžãã¨å°ãį §ããžããåŋãŽåĨĨãžã§čĻéããããããĒįļēéēãĒįŗãĒãã§ãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽé ŦãæąãĢæãžãã
ãåãåãæã¯ä¸å¯§ã§ããĩããĢæ§ãããããŖã¨į´ŗåŖĢįâĻâĻããŖãįŗã荺ããããžãããä¸č¨äŊč¨ã§ãããããã ããŽã芹ã¨č¨ããã¨ã§âĻâĻã
ãå¤čĻãĢã¤ããĻã¯ããŠãæããžããīŧã
ãå¯ĄéģãĒįžä¸å¤ĢããŖãĻæãã§ããããžãã§ãããĒãˇãŖå§ĢãŽæéŦąããĢįģå ´ãããĒãĒã¨ãŧãĢįåãŽããīŧã
ãææå°čĒŦãĢįģå ´ããᎿ§ãåŧãåããĢåēããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åŽšå§ŋãĢéĸããĻčŖ
éŖžéå¤ãĒãģãŠįąįãĢčĒãŖãĻãããã
ãããŽå°čĒŦãĒãåãčĒãã ãã¨ãããã襨åãã¯å°åĨŗåããŽææčã ããåæĸãĒįåãä¸ã¤ãŽčŠĻᎴãĢįĢãĄåãããåãããŽå§Ģãæãã¨ããįéãŽä¸ãĢãįįãĒį¤žäŧéĸ¨åēãčžŧããããäŊåã ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŽãįéããŽé¨åãã¨ãˇãĨãĢéããĻãããããã
ãããŽåžãä¸åēã§å´ŠčŊãŽåžįäģããããĻããäŊŋį¨äēēããã¨ãäŊæĨįŖįŖãčĻã¤ããĻåŖ°ããããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãĢã¤ããĻããŠãæããžããīŧã
ãįˇã¯ææãã§éĄãŽæąãæããĒããããļãŖãããŧããĢįããã
ãããããĸã¤ããã大ããæĒåã ãŖãã§ããĒãããŖãĄãŽæį¤ēãĢã¯åžãŖãĻãããããįĄåŖã§įĄææŗãĒåĨ´ã§ããããã
ãå¤čĻãĢã¤ããĻã¯īŧã
ããããããžãĢå¤ãĒéĄããããã
ãå¤čĻīŧãããĢããĻįččŗĒã ãŖããã¨äģĨå¤ãčĻããĄãããžãããĒãįˇãŽéĄãĒããã
ãåŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯ãäžŋåŠãĒå´ååã§ãããĒãããã ãã§ããåžä¸ãŽč˛æãĢã¤ããĻčããæŗãčŋããåŊŧã¯ãããŽéĸã§čåŗãæãŖãããããŖãã
ãé¨åąãĢæģããä¸äēēãŽč¨čãæĨčĒãĢæ¸ãä¸ĻãšãĻãŋãã¨ããžãã§åĨäēēãŽč¨é˛ã ããéå¯ã¨æ°é ããŽåžč ããå¯Ąéģã§åšģæŗįãĒįåããįĄææŗãĒåæãĄããįšį´°ããåšģæŗæ§ãååŧˇããä¸č 䏿§ãŽč¨ŧč¨ã¯ãã¨ãˇãĨã¨ããåå¨ãä¸ã¤ãŽæ ãĢåŽãããã¨ãæãã§ããããŽããã ã
ãåąæˇãŽčǰãåŊŧãããåãčĻãĻãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽč¤č˛čãŽå¤§įˇãã¨ã¯éãåããããããŽįŽãĢæ ããĻãããŽããįĨããĒããčŦã¯æˇąãžããããŽįžčąĄããŠãč¨ããšããããžããžãå°éŖãæĨĩããĻããã
ãé ãæŠãžããĻããã¨ãåĻšãŽåŖ°ãčãããĻãããåĻšã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽéŽŽãããĒéĢĒč˛ãĢčåŗãæãŖãããã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽéĢĒãįããĻããŋããã
ããããã ããã¨ãˇãĨãŖãĻåŧãã§ãã
ãåã¯ææēãĢåēããį´éĸããįŽãéĸãããĢįããã
ãâĻâĻč§ĻãŖãĻããããããĒīŧã
ããŠãããĒīŧãčããĻãŋããīŧã
ãåã¯ããŗãįŊŽããĻãæãŽčãĢč
°æããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻããã῝ãĢåãããĻããčŗã垎ããĢåããã
ãåĻšãããŖã¨æãäŧ¸ã°ããčĩ¤ãéĢĒãŽå
į̝ãĢå°ãã ãč§Ļãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄč¨ã§čĻã¤ãčŋããĻããããæįĩļã¯ããĒãã
ãæ¸ŠãããĒãããĩã¤ãã
ãæå¤ãããĢåããäģåēĻã¯čĩ¤éĢĒãã˛ã¨æŋã大čãĢãããä¸ããã
ãâĻâĻãããã
ãåŽŗæãŽãĒããįĨãŖãĻããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãããããžãžã ããããĻåĻšãŽčĻæãč§Ŗããé ãã¨ãˇãĨãåĻšãŽéĢĒãĢč§Ļãããã¨æãäŧ¸ã°ããã
ãæ°äģããéį̝ãĢãã¯ãã¨čēĢãéãããåĻšããį´ æŠãæãåŧãŖčžŧããĻåžãããããããčĻãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ã大ããĒæãããŖããã¨å
ãŽäŊįŊŽãĢæģãã䏿č°ãããĢéĻãåžããããããįäŧŧãĻåĻšãéĻãåžããã
ããžã čˇéĸæãŽåĻįŋãåŋ čĻãĒããã ã
ãå¤éŖãŽåžãåã¯æ¸æãĢåãããæ°ããæ¸ãä¸ããæĨčĒãåˇŽãåēãããåãåãŖããŦãã¯į´éĸãããããčĻįˇãčĩ°ãããããããĻåŖå ãĢæãããĒįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ãäģå¤ãčåŗæˇąããŦããŧããã
ãæēčļŗãããĢé ŦįŦããŦããŽæ§åããããä¸čžæããŽæŦåŋããåēãį§°čŗã ããã¨æããã
ãéŖå ãŽįĩĻäģã¯ãåžč ããčļčåãéãã§ããčĨãįĩĻäģã¯ãįåããä¸åēãŽäŋŽįšãææŽããäŊŋį¨äēēã¯ãå´åč ããâĻâĻčĻäēãĒãžã§ãĢããŠããŠãã
ãåã¯é ˇããã
ãčĻŗå¯ãįļãããģãŠãčŧĒéãææ§ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããžããããŽč¨é˛ã¯ãč°äŧãčĒŦåžããææãĢãĒããŽã§ããããīŧã
ãææ§ãĒããŧãŋãĒãŠį§åĻįãĢã¯įĄäžĄå¤ã ããããįĨããĒãããŽãããĢãŦãã¯ãĢãããåžããäŊčŖããŖãˇããĢįããã
ãããŽææ§ããããæĻå¨ãĢãĒããŽãã夿§ãĒčĻįšãéãĒããã¨ã§ãåãĒããæĒįŠãã§ãĒããč¤éãĒå¤éĸæ§ãæã¤ãåãã¸čĒčããããããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨããäēēãã¨ããæ ãĢåéĄããĻčĒčēĢãåŽåŋããããŽãããäēēãã¨ããĻæąããã¨ã§ã¨ãˇãĨãå¤åŽšãããã¨ãæåž ããĻãããŽãããŠãĄããĒãŽã ããīŧ
ãäēēã¯čǰããäģč ãčĒåãŽįŽãéããĻããčĻãããĒããéãįļããããããĻåããĻæĩŽããŗä¸ããããŽããããŽãã
ããŦããŽįæãæ¸ŦããããĒãããåã¯æ¸æãåžãĢããã
ãé¨åąãĢæģãã¨ãåĻšãčĒåãŽå¸åŖãæąããĻå ĨãŖãĻããã¨ããã ãŖãã
ãã¨ãĢãã帰ããĒããã
ãåŊįļãŽãããĢä¸ããčžŧããã¨ãˇãĨã¯åŽäŊįŊŽã§įčãįĢãĻãĻåē§ãŖãĻãããåŽčŗĒãããŽé¨åąãäēäēēã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãŽå¯åޤã¨ããĻåŽįãã¤ã¤ããŖãã
ãåĨåĻãĒå
ąåįæ´ģãåæĨįŽãįĩãããããŽåšŗįŠãĒæĨã
ãããã¤ãžã§ãįļãã°ãããæĨ常ã¨ã¯ããããĒãã¨ãčããéį̝ãĢå´Šããæ°¸é ãĢå¤ąãããããŽã ã
15
ããŧãŧä¸įã¯éŗãĢæēãĄãĻããã
ãäēēéãå¯éãžãŖãįå¤ãŽä¸åēã§ãããã
ãæēčŠãčãŽãããĢãåããåŖ°ãã¸čēĢãé ããã
ãįēå
čãčåãéŖã°ã垎ããĒį ´čŖéŗãå°ä¸æ°´čãįĩļããæĩãįļããæ°´éŗãå˛Šį¤ãåãæŠæĻéŗãåŋå°ããéŗč˛ãåãããå ´æã
ãä¸åēã¯įįŠããĄãŽåãã§æēãĄãĻãããå´ŠããįŗįŗãŽééãŽåĨĨã§ãæ°´ãé ãéĸããå ´æãŽãåŖ°ããéãã§ããã
ãåŊŧã¯å¤§įŠ´ãŽæˇĩã§įŽčãéãããčļŗå
ã§ã˛ãããįēå
čãĢæããããã垎åŧąãĒãåŖ°ãã¸æčãį ãæžãžãã
ãå ļãŽæãæĨčŋããæãããĒãåŖ°ããæįĨããã
ãéãã§į´ æĩãĒå¤ãã
ãé ä¸ããåã¨ããåŖ°ãéŋããčĻä¸ããã¨ãäēéãŽããŠãšããä¸åēãčĻä¸ããäēēåŊąãããŖããå¯éįãŽä¸ãĢãŦãĻãŗãįžŊįšããæš¯æ°ãŽįĢã¤ãĢãããæãĢããĻããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯å´Šããįŗįŗã¸čĻįˇãåããã
ãä¸åēãŽäŋŽåžŠãæäŧãŖãĻãããĻããããã¨ãããããã§æŠãįäģãããã ãã
ãįŠãããĒãåŖ°ããĢãããŽã¯ãį´į˛ãĒæĸįŠļåŋã¨åį᏿ãĢ寞ããæŦæã ãįˇã¯čĻįˇãé¸ãããã
ããããå°ãã芹ãããããããŖãĄã¸ä¸ããŖãĻæĨãĻãããĒããããīŧã
ãææēãããčēĢãäšãåēããããĢããĻããŦãã¯æãäŧ¸ã°ããįˇã¯å¨å˛ãå°ãčĻåãããįŠēéã¨įŠčŗĒãŽåŧˇåēĻãč¨ãã¨ãåŠčĩ°ãã¤ããĻå°éĸã¨å˛ŠåŖãčš´ããããŠãšãŽææēããæ´ããįŠįæŗåãįĄčĻããĻãæ ŧåãŽééãĢčēĢäŊãæŠãčžŧãã ã
ãįĢãĄä¸ãããå¤åĨãåŽäŊįŊŽãĢãããã¨ãįĸēčĒããã
ãå¨į¨ããéæŽĩããæĨãĻãããĻãč¯ããŖããŽãã
ãå°ããĒããŧããĢãĢįŊŽãããéļå¨ãŽæŗ¨ãåŖãããĢããã¸ãéæãĒæļ˛äŊãæŗ¨ããããæéŖæãĢåĨŊãã§éŖ˛ãããŽã¨ã¯éãéĻããåēããŖããåŊŧåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããĢããã°ãåŋãčŊãĄįãããį ããčĒãåšæããããããã
ããĢãããįæãĢæ¯ãčŋããå¯éįãĢčēĢãå
ãã åŊŧåĨŗãŽåããĢåãããĻčŖžãæēããæĩãããããĒãŠã¤ãŗãéããĻããã
ãããŧãããŖãŧã¯ãããããããīŧã
ãåˇŽãåēããããĢãããåãåãã¨ããŦãã¯æ¤ åãĢč °æãããįēå čãŽæˇĄãå ãåããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčã¯ãéãéãŖãĻããããŽããã§ããŖããįˇŠãããĢįĩãããããįŊéãŽéĢĒã¯ãčãŖããã¨åšģæŗįãĒå ãæžãŖãĻãããããĢããčĻããã
ããĢãããåžããåŊŧåĨŗãŽéŧåãŽå¤åãĢčŗãæžãžãããããããå
ãĢãčĨå
ããčĻãččĒã¸čĻįˇãå¸ãå¯ããããĻããã
ããã¨ãĢãĒãã°į´čĻãéŋããäŊãæãããĒãããæå¤§éãŽæŗ¨æãæããä¸čĒįļããĒãčĻįˇãŽããå ´ãæĸãã¨ããã ã
ãå
ļåĻãĢãããŽã¯ããĩããĢãŽãããĢåŧˇåēãĒįčã¨ãããã¨ãĢãŽãããĒæĒįēéãĒäŊčē¯ã¨ãéããæēĸãåēãĻããããĒį¨ãĢčąãã§ãæãããããĒččĒãŽéčĩˇãéĒéãĢãĒãããã ã
ãéåŋãå¤ãããåããéģåŽŗãããé˛åžĄåãäŊããäŊæ
ããŽãããĒčŖ
éŖžãčēĢãĢäģãããŽãīŧ
ãâĻâĻäŊīŧã
ãįĄé æ ŽãĒčĻįˇãĢæ°ãĨããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãčĒåãŽč¸å ãčĻä¸ããã
ããããããĻããããæ°ãĢãĒãīŧã
ãæĒæ¯ãŖãŊãįŦãŋãæĩŽããšããŦãã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããåĨåĻãĒäŊčē¯ãčĻããŗããããããĢč¸ãåŧĩãã
ããããã¤ããĢã貴æšãæ°äģããĻããžãŖããŽãīŧã
ãč¸å ãŽččĒãįŽįĢããããããĢãį´°ãæå ãéãããã
ãããã¯įˇãįãããéæ§ãŽãæĻå¨ããĒãŽããč°äŧã§ã¯å°ãã ãåŊšãĢįĢãŖãĻããããããåŠæ§ãĢã¯éį¨ããĒããããŠã
ãæĻå¨ãå
ļãŽä¸č¨ã§æ
å ąãįšããŖããčĻčĻæ
å ąã¨ããĻčŗã¸äžĩå
Ĩãã夿čŊåãčããéãããį˛žįĨåš˛æ¸å¨ã
ã常ãĢåąéēãä翏Ŧããå
åãããĻéŋãããããã¨ãĢããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåã§ã ãčĻįˇãåŊˇåž¨ãããįįąãããã¯į˛žįĨæąæãåéŋãããããŽčĒåˇąé˛čĄã§ããŖããŽã ã
ãæŦĄã¯č˛´æšãŽã芹ãčããããã
ãåãŗæ¤ åãĢč °ãä¸ãããĒãäŋããã
ãä¸åēãŽä¸ãå˛ŠãåãéŗãčŋäģããĻãããäēēæ°ã¯ä¸įĸēåŽã
ããŦããŽįŗãįēæŋč ãŽå ãæžãŖãããĢãããįŊŽãéŗãéå¯ãŽä¸ã§įĄŦčŗĒãĢéŋãã
ãâĻâĻãããå ãã¤ãããããŽãã
ãããŧããĢãŽä¸ã§ä¸ĄæãŽæãįĩĄãžããã
ãæŗŗãããĻãããžããããæ°´čãåããĻåĄããŽãåąéēã ããããã§å¯žåĻããã°ãåŊŧãã¯åĨãŽäžĩå ĨåŖãæĸããäē¤äģŖã§čĻåŧĩããįŊŽããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ä¸åēãŽéãčĻæŽãããå ļåĻãĢã¯ãčĒåãŽåŊããį¤ä¸ãŽé§ã¨ããĻč¨įŽããåˇãããããŖããã ããčĻįˇããã¨ãĢããĄãį ãå ´æã¸åããįŦéãããŽčĄ¨æ ãå´Šããã
ãããŽåãäģĨåã¯įŦãåã ãŖããŽããã¨ãĻãä¸éã§įãŖį´ããĒåã ãŖãã
ãéåģãæããããŦããŽãåŖ°ããĢæããæˇˇããã
ããããĢįãĻãããåŋãéããããžãžčĻããã§ãããæ¨ãã§ããã§ããããããčĒæ¸äŧãã¨ããæĨŊåããåŽããĒããŖãį§ãã
ãææ¨ãčžŧããæãåŧˇãæĄããããã
ããéĄãããŠãããã¨ãĢãæ¯ããĻãããĻã
ãæ¤ãŽåĨŗã¯įĄįžã ã᏿ãŽčĄåįįąãįč§Ŗããä¸ã§ãæč¯ãŽįĩæãåŧãåēããã¨ãããå
ļãã§ãããã¨ãĢãæĄãããåŖ°ãã¯ãį´ãããĒãįåŽãŽįĨãã ã
ãįˇã¯ãĢãããŽä¸čēĢãéŖ˛ãŋåš˛ããããŧããĢãĢįŠēãŽãĢãããæģããã
ãâĻâĻ大åãĒãã°é¨åąãĢéãčžŧããĻããã
ãåĒãããŽããããŖãąãå°ãã ããã¨ãĢãĢäŧŧãĻãããã
ã大ããčĻéããįŧã§į¸æãčĻä¸ãããŦãã¯åŖå ãé ããã¯ãšã¯ãšã¨įŦãŖãã
ãæããåŋæĨ厤ãåēãĻãåģä¸ãæŠããéŗãįĢãĻãĒãããæ
éãĢæãéããã¨ãé¨åąãŽä¸ã¯åžŽããĒã¤ãŗã¯ãŽčããæŧãŖãĻããã
ããã¨ãĢãŽå¯æ¯ãĢčŗãæžãžããåŖéãĢč
°ãä¸ãããįŽčãéããã
ãâââ
ãåĻšã¨čŋããäēæĨįŽãŽæãåąæˇã§ãŽįæ´ģãĢæ Ŗãå§ããåĻšã¯ãčĒæ¸ãĢãéŖŊããäģãŽéãŗãæĸãæąãããããĢãĒãŖãã
ããããã¨ãĢãä¸įˇãĢãčåéŖãšããã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻããŗãæĄãŖãĻããĒãæšãŽåãŽč ãĢãããŋã¤ãã
ãäģãåŋãããã ããŠâĻâĻīŧã
ãããŗãæãŖããžãžæ¯ãčŋãã¨ãåĻšã¯åãŽčĸãæĄããããææēãŽå寞å´ãĢįĢã¤ã¨ãˇãĨãį¨ãŋã¤ããĻãããåĻšãŽįŗãĢã¯æįĸēãĒæĩæãį¯ãŖãĻããã
ããĒãã§īŧããŠãããĻãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ã¨ãĢã¨åãé¨åąã§ãį§ã ãåĨãĒãŽīŧããĒãã§ãåããããĻãããĒããŽīŧã
ãåäžįšæãŽįŦå æŦ˛ãããããã¯ãæĨæŋãĒį°åĸå¤åãĢ寞ããæˇˇäšąã¨æįĩļããæ°éŖãŖãĻãããã°ãĒããĒãææãĢãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĻŗå¯ã¨æĨčĒäŊæãčãčžŧãŋčĒŋæģãĢæ˛Ąé ããĻãããŽã ãããįĄįããĒãååŋã ããã
ãåĻšããããã°ãã¨ãˇãĨãæĨčĒãããããčǞãããŦããããåãŽéĸåŋãåĨĒãæĩãĒãŽã ãåããŖãã¨ããã§ãäģã¯åĻšãĢæ§ãäŊčŖããĒãã
ãããŽæãčåžã§äŊããčģãã ã
ã垎åã ãĢããæ§åãčĻãĻããã¨ãˇãĨãåĻšãį´čĻããããã¤ããŽįĄéĸåŋã¯æļãå¤ąããåĻšãåããĻããããŽã¨åãåˇããéãææĨããããŽįŗãĢåŽŋãŖãĻããã
ãâĻâĻãããããåããĒã
ãäŊãå°ãéããããĒåŖ°ããã¨ãˇãĨãŽåããå¸ãåŖ°ãäŧ´ãŖãĻæŧãããåĻšã¯æ¯ãåãŋãįĢĻãŋä¸ããŖãĻåãŽčåžãĢé ããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨīŧīŧã
ãåã¯æ¤
åãčš´åãåĸãã§įĢãĄä¸ãããåĻšãŽéããčŠãæąãå¯ããã
ãčŊãĄįãã寞åĻãééãããĒãåĻšãåŽĨãããŽãå
ã ãįč§Ŗã§ããĻããĻããäģãĢãæŽ´ããããŖãĻããããĒ大įˇãĢįĄé˛åãĒčãåãããŽã¯æãã
ãåŽäŊįŊŽããčˇéĸã芰ããĻããæŽĩéã§æ°äģããšãã ãŖããåĻšãŽææãæįĩļãã¨ãˇãĨãĢãŠããĒåŊąéŋãåãŧãããå¯čŊæ§ãŽæŗåŽã¨å¯žįãæ ãŖãåãŽčŊãĄåēĻã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯čåŗãå¤ąãŖããããĢčĻįˇãé¸ãããé¨åąãåēãĻčĄãŖãã
ãæãéãžãŖãéį̝ãĢãåŖ°ãä¸ããĻæŗŖãå§ããåĻšãããŽčä¸ãæĻããåããæ¤
åãčĩˇããããæãŽåãããããæ˛éŗ´ãį ´åŖéŗãčãããĻããĒããã¨ãįĨããĒããã
ãããã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽæãã§ã¯ãĒããåĻšãŽåĢåĻŦãĢå ããåĻšãį ŠãããæããåãŽčįĢãĄãåŊąéŋããĻãããŽã ãããčåŗãå¤ąãŖããŽã§ã¯ãĒããåããŽåŋåĸãä¸čģĸãããã¨ã§æˇˇäšąãįããããŽä¸åŋĢããã¨ãˇãĨã¯éãããŽã ã
ãäēēæ°ãŽãĒãå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽãŽį̝ã§ãåãã¨ãˇãĨãĢææãåããĻããæãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éãåēããĒããŖãããããããåãŽčŋˇããĢååŋããĻãããŽã ã
ãããŖã¨ããŦãã¯åã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãŽéĸäŋãæˇąãžããã¨ãæãã§ãããŽã ãããææ ãäŋĄé ŧã§åļåžĄã§ãããĒããįŠįįãĒéãæĒģãŽåŋ čĻããĒããå¤ãĒčŦãĢé ŧãããäēēéįã ã
ãč˛Ŧäģģé大éããĻå§ãæŊ°ããããã ããããĒãã¨ãĒãã夿ŗããžã§éã帰ãŖãĻãã˛ãŖããã¨æŽããããã
ãâ
ãããŽå¤ãåĻšãå¯éãžãŖãåžããåã¯į ãããĢãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯æŧéãŽäģļäģĨæĨãé¨åąãĢæģããĒãããžãä¸åēãåģä¸ãŽãŠããã§éãããĻãããŽã ããã
ãæˇąå¤ãéå¯ãĢå ãžããåąæˇãŽåģä¸ã§ã垎ããĒ芹ãåŖ°ãčããããįĩĻäģããĄãŽåŖ°ã§ã¯ãĒããįˇčŋĢããįˇãŽäŊãåŖ°ã ã
ãåã¯å¯å°ããæãåēããããŖã¨æãéãããåģä¸ãŽįĒãåŊããããŦããŽæ¸æãŽæšããåŖ°ãæŧããĻããã
ãæ¯ãæŊããčļŗéŗãįĢãĻãĒãããåŖäŧããĢčŋãĨãã
ãâĻâĻã ããč¨ãŖããã īŧã
ãįĻįĨããįˇãŽåŖ°ããĩããĢã ãæ˛ģåŽįļæåąãŽåŊŧãããĒããããĒæéãĢīŧ
ãčŋãã ãĒããĻãæ°åŽãč¨ãŖãĻãããããã
ã寞ãããŦããŽåŖ°ã¯æ°ˇãŽãããĢåˇéã ã
ããįĨéãããã¯å¤§äēæĨã ãããĒãäģæã¸æ¸ĄãŖããžãžãĢããĻįŊŽãããŽã ãããããŖãĄãŽé˛æã¯īŧã
ãåããįĨãŽå¤æŗãã§čĻã¤ããåŖįģããŦããč¨ãŖãĻããåģēåŊįĨ芹ãĢéĸããč°čĢãīŧ
ãåŽåŽããĻãããããŠããžã æéãåŋ čĻããåŧãéĸããéį̝ãĢå å¤ããå´ŠããĻã坿ĒãããĒããã
ããĩããĢãŽããŽã¨æããã大ããĒæēãæ¯ã
ãâĻâĻéŠæ°æ´žãĢčŗãŖãĻã¯ãåŧˇåĨĒãčžããĒãæ§ãã ãäŋēãŽé¨ä¸ãĢãæ°æ´žãããĻãĒã䏿ēããŋãŠãŋãŠã¨čãããĻããããã
ãéŠæ°æ´žããčŋˇåãŽįĨæ§ããæĸãéä¸ã§ãåã县ãĢčŋŊãããåããæļããã¨ããéŖä¸ã ã
ãåŊã¯å¤§åãĢããĻãģããããŽãã
ãæ éˇãĒãã¨č¨ãŖãĻãå ´åãīŧãč°äŧãŽæĨãžã§æãããã严éŖåļãčĄįŧã§æĸãåãŖãĻããã
ãããčŋããžã§æĨãĻãããŋããããã¨ãˇãĨããéŗããčãããã
ããŦããŽåŖ°ãŽããŧãŗãå°ãä¸ããŖãã
ãâĻâĻãããäģäēãæŠããĒã
ãæ
å ąãŽåēæãæĸãã¤ã¤ãä¸Ąæ´žéĨãŽåããåĩå¯ãįŊåļãããŽã貴æšãŽäģäēãé ŧããĢããĻãããããĢã
ãåšŗå¸¸åŋãå´ŠããĒããŦããŽæãããĒåŖ°ãéŋããã
ãįĄčļãĒčĻæąããããŖãĻã
ãéŧģã§įŦããĩããĢãŽį˛åŧãããŖãåŖ°ã
ãã ããåŊã¨åŋä¸ããæ°ããĒãããŦããããããŽæã¯ããåã ãã§ãâĻâĻã
ãããŽæã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãéŖããĻéãããããã¨ãĢã¨ãĻãŠãä¸įˇãĢã
ãč°äŧåŊæĨãžã§å°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽãåŊˇåž¨ãæ°ãīŧããįŊéå§ĢããŽã¤ãĄãŧã¸ããļãŖåŖãããĒã
ãįŦãčŠąã§æ¸ããã¨ãéĄãŖãĻããã
ãâĻâĻãããããã ãĒã
ãæˇąãæēãæ¯ã¨å ąãĢæ¤ åãčģãéŗãããããĩããĢãŽčļŗéŗãæãĢčŋãĨããĻããã
ãįŠé°ãĢé ãããã¨æ ãĻãĻæ¯ãčŋãŖããčļŗããã¤ããããĢãĒããæ¯ãåãã įŦéãčåžããäŧ¸ãŗãĻããæãåãŽåŖãåĄãã ãéŠãéããĒããåŧˇįãĒåã§åģä¸ãŽæąãŽåŊąã¸ã¨åŧãŖåŧĩãčžŧãžããã
ãæãããĩããĢãåēãĻãããįéĸããŧãĢã¸åãčļŗæŠãĢåģãŖãĻãããéåãĒæãéãžãéŗãčããåãææãã大ããĒæãŽį˛ãæå
ã§įĒããã
ãããŖããčĻä¸ããã¨ãæéãŽä¸ã§éģéč˛ãŽįŗãåãčĻä¸ãããįŦãããã
ãããŖã¨äēäēēãŽčŠąãčããĻãããŽã ããããããã¨ãããããĒæéãĢåēæŠããŽãįãããĻãåãŽåžãã¤ããĻæĨããŽãã
ããŠãĄããĢãã大ããĒéãã¯ãĒããåãŽéåŊãæąēãžãæĨãžã§æŽãäēæĨãããŽäēæĨéãããåŽå ¨ãŽäŋč¨ŧã¯ãĒããŽã ã
ãâ
ã鎎ãããĒåŖ°ãį°č˛ãŽæ¯č˛ãĢå˛ãčžŧãã§ããã
ãįĄé æ
ŽãĢčĻãčžŧãŋããã¤ãåįĒãĢ芹ããããĻããĻã¯ãããããããééĢĒãæēãããĻéį´ãį¨ŽæãįŦãéŖã°ãããˇãŖã
ãäģãŽåãåŧãã§ããã ããīŧãåãčĄãŖããäģãŽåãĢčŋˇæã ã
ãčĒįč
ãŽããããæĨãĻãŖãĻč¨ãŖãĻããŽīŧã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻããˇãŖã¯é Ŧãč¨ããžãããčĩ¤ããã éĄãåãĢã¯įãããĻãããŖã¨čĻãĻããã¨ããããã¨ã°ãããĢįŗãŋæããã
ããčåã¯æãĄå¯ãã ããŠãåŦãįŠãčããããåĻšãĄãããä¸įˇãĢãį´æãã
ãâĻâĻãžããããŽå¤ĸããäŊã¨čŋãããã¯čĻããĻããĒãããããŽå
ãŽåąéãåã¯įĨãŖãĻããã
ãåã¯čĒįæĨäŧãĢčĄããĒããŖããããˇãŖãããĒããĒãŖãčĒæ¸äŧã¯ãæãå¯ããå ´æã¸å¤ããŖãĻããžãã
ã大ä¸å¤Ģã ãīŧããžã å¤ããããīŧãįĩļ寞ãįå˛ããĄãããĢãĒãåŊãå¤ãããããīŧã
ãããã¨ããĻéĄãä¸ãããææēãĢįĒãŖäŧããĻį ãŖãĻãããããã
ãåãå¤ĸãįš°ãčŋãčĻããã¨ã¯ããŖãããŠãæåžãŽįēč¨ã¯äģåãåããĻã ãã§ããããˇãŖãĒãč¨ããããĒæ°ã¯ããã
ããĩããĢãŽčŠąãįãŋčãããåžãé¨åąãĢæģãŖãĻå¸åŖãĢæŊãŖããããģã¨ããŠį ããĒããŖãã
ãããããŦããŽä礿¸ãå¤ąæããã°ãäģåēĻã¯åĻšãåˇģãčžŧãã§åŊããéãããã¨ãĢãĒããåã¯åãŗããŗãæĄãŖãã
ãæŧé ããããŗčļã¨å įŧãããšãąãããäšžįĨãããæ¨ãŽåŽãé¨åąãĢéã°ããĻãããããããĢč °æããåŦããããĢé ŦåŧĩãåĻšãåįĒãĢåãåēãã
ããããã¨ãĢãã¨ãĢãåŽļãåēãåžãŽãã¨čãããīŧã
ãåĻšã¯é ãčŋŊãŖãĻããããĒãããĒã¨čĒãå§ãããåãããĒããĒãŖããã¨ã§ä¸ĄčĻĒãŽå§åŠã¯æŋåããč˛å
ãåŽļäēãæžæŖããããã¨ãč˛ŦäģģããĒããã¤ãåãæåˇãŽä¸ã§ãå¤įŦãĢčããäŊåēĻãåãæĸããĢåēããã¨ã
ãå
ããæžįŊŽæ°åŗã ãŖãã¨æãããŠã芹ãŽč
°ãæ˛ãããããĒéæŽã¯æ§ããĻãããã
ãį§ããŖã¨ä¸äēēã ãŖããčĒæ¸äŧããĒããĒãŖãĻãį§å¯åēå°ã¯čǰããĢåŖãããĻãĻããããĢãã¨ãĢã¯ããĒããããŠããĢãåą å ´æããĒããŖãã
ãæļãæĩŽããšãåĻšãčĻãĻãįŊǿǿã¨čĒåˇąåĢæĒãĢčãžãããåã¯åĻšãįŊŽãåģããĢããĻãčĒåã ãæĨŊãĢãĒããã¨ãããäģãĒãį°å¸¸ãĒčĄåã ãŖãã¨įč§Ŗã§ãããį˛žįĨįãĢčŋŊã芰ããããĻãåĻšãæããããã¨ããã§ããĒããĒããæčåã夿åãå¤ąãŖãĻãããŽã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯ææ
ãŽæēããĢčŗãåžããĻãããŽã ãããįĄčĄ¨æ
ãŽãžãžã§ããįĄéĸåŋã¨ã¯éããĒãã
ãįŊŽããĻčĄãŖããããĻããããã ããŠãããããã¯âĻâĻã
ãããäēåēĻã¨éããĒããæąēæãæ°ããĢããĻį´æãããŽãæŖããã¨įč§ŖããĻãããåŖį´æãĒããĻį°ĄåãĒãã¨ãĒãŽãĢããŠããããããĒãååĢãĢæãããåãåĻšãåŽããåŽåŋãããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã
ãåãč¨čãĢ芰ãžãŖãĻããã¨ãåĻšã¯éĻãæ¯ãã
ãéããŽãã¨ãĢãä¸įˇãĒãäŊãããŖãĻãåšŗæ°ãŖãĻæãŖããŽãä¸įˇãĒãé åŧĩãããŖãĻãã ãããã§ãããã¨ãããã°æäŧãããĻã
ãåã¯åĻšãĢæãäŧ¸ã°ããåŧˇãæąãããããåĻšãĢæąãããčŋãããĒãããåã¯åŋãčģŊããĒããŽãæããĻããã
ãå¤éŖãŽæéãĢéŖå ã¸åããé ãåąæˇã¯ãé ãåŽļããããčĻåĄãã¸å¤č˛ããĻãããįéĸããŧãĢã¯åŋčĢãæˇå°å¤ã¸įšããé ãé莝ãŽåãĢãé˛čˇæĩãį¯ãããĻãããããã°ãããäŊŋį¨äēēããĄãžã§ãããčãéåąãéŠãŽé˛å ˇãčēĢãĢįããč °ãĢã¯åŖãįæ§ã帯ãŗãĻããã
ãåąæˇä¸ãįˇčŋĢããįŠēæ°ãĢå ãžããįĩĻäģããĄãŽį§čĒã¯æĨĩį̝ãĢæ¸ããčĻåŧĩããŽäēēæ°ãåˇĄåæ°ãåĸãããããŽįŠã ãããĢæ¯ããåĻšã¯ãč ãĢãããŋã¤ããĒããåãŽéŖãæŠããĻãããåąæˇãæēããįˇåŧĩã¨čĻæãŽåŖ°ãĢæãããã¨ãˇãĨãåŋé ã ã
ãåĻšãé¨åąãĢéããæĨčĒãæåēãããããĢãŦããŽæ¸æãč¨Ēããåã¯ãæãæąēããĻåãåēãããé¨åąãĢã¯åã¨ãŦããé ãĢæ§ããĻããįĩĻäģãŽä¸äēēã ãã ã
ãå°ãã ãããæéãããã ããžããīŧã
ããããæ§ããĒãããã
ãæĨčĒãĢįŽãéããĒããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įããã
ããŦãã¯å¸¸ãĢčŊãĄįããĻããĻãææ
įãĒæ¯ãčããčĻããĻããæã§ããããããæŧæã ã¨åããããããĒ᏿ãĢã¯įĄæåŗã¨įĨããĒããããããŽæéãé¸ãã ãŽã¯åãĒãįŋæ
Ŗã ãåŊŧåĨŗã䏿ĨãŽä¸ã§æã䏿ŠåĢãĒãŽã¯ãæĨčĒãŽæåēæãæŦĄįšã§ãéŖäēä¸ã ãããã
ãâĻâĻå įã¯ãããˇãŖãčĻããĻããžããīŧã
ããŦãã¯æãæĸãããã°ããããĻããæ¯ãåããã
ããããčĻããĻããããčǰã¨ã§ããããĢæãĄč§Ŗãã䏿č°ãĒåããã¤ãå
æ°ã§æããåã ãŖãããã
ãåããããæããžãã
ããã¨ãĢãæãŖãĻããé
åã¨ã¯ãéãé
åãæã¤åã ãŖããæå¤ãĢæ°ãŽåãã¨ãããããŖããŽãããīŧã
ãåŊåãŽåãŽäē¤åéĸäŋãæ°ãĨããĻãããŽã ãããããŦãã¯ä¸įŦã ãįŽãį´°ããäŊããč¨įŽãããããĒåˇããå ãåŽŋããã
ãããˇãŖã¯ãå°ãæãããããŽãįŽįĢãĄããããŽãã
ããŠãããæåŗã§ããīŧã
ããŦããčĻįˇãčĩ°ãããã¨ãįĩĻäģã¯æ
ãĻãĻįŽãäŧããã
ãããŽååŋãå
¨ãĻãįŠčĒãŖãĻãããããˇãŖãŽčŠąéĄã¯ãããŽå࿎ã§ãįĻåĨãĢčŋã芹éĄãŽããã ãããˇãŖãčǰããŽä¸čã財ããį§å¯čŖãĢæé¤ãããã¨ãããã¨ãīŧ
ãåãããžãããįĄįãč¨ãŖãĻããŋãžããã
ãããããæãæããããŽã¯æĒããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒãããäēåēĻã¨åãéãĄãįš°ãčŋããĒããããĢããæãåēã¯å¤§åãĢãĒããã
ãäēåēĻã¨éãĄãįš°ãčŋããĒããããĢãããŽč¨čãéãéŋããã
ãæ¸æãåžãĢããĻé¨åąãĢæģãéä¸ãåã¯čãäēãĢįąä¸ããĻããã
ãããˇãŖã¯ä¸åš¸ãĒåļįļãæããäēæ
ã§ã¯ãĒããčǰããŽææã§æé¤ããããŽã ãéŠæ°æ´žããäŋåŽæ´žããããã¯åãããĒãããŦãã¯ãŠããžã§ææĄããĻãããŽã ããīŧ
ãéåģãŽäēäģļãįžå¨ãŽåąæŠã¨éãĒãåããčåžãŽæ°é ãĢæ°ãé ããĒãããåã¯čæãåģä¸ãæŠčļŗã§æŠããã
16
ã䏿ĨįŽãŽæãéŖå ã¸å Ĩãã¨ãįĩĻäģããĄãæ¨æļãããĻããããã¤ãåãŽčåžãĢé ããããéãããĻããåĻšã ããããŽæĨã¯åããĻæ¨æļãčŋããã
ããã¯ããããããžãã
ãæ ŖããĒããĒãããį˛žä¸æ¯ãĢåŖ°ãåēããããŽåĨæ°ããĢãįˇåŧĩæãæŧãããĻããįĩĻäģã垎įŦãŋčŋããããããĢæ°ãč¯ãããåĻšã¯ãæąēæãæ°ããĢãããããĒéĸæãĄã§å¸ã¸åããŖãã
ããŦããæãŽæ¨æļãäē¤ããããããįĩããã¨åĻšã¯čįãäŧ¸ã°ããįãŖį´ããĢãŦããčĻæŽããã
ããŦãå įããéĄããããããžãã
ãããŽįãžãŖãįŠč¨ããĢãéĄãä¸ãããŦãã¯čåŗãåããããããĢ垎įŦãã
ãäŊãããīŧããĻãŠã
ãåĻšã¯æšããĻæˇąåŧå¸ããĻããåŖãéããã
ãããŽå࿎ãĢįŊŽããĻããã ããĻããčēĢã¨ããĻãį§ã ãäŊããããåŽãããĻããã ãã§ã¯įŗã荺ãįĢãĄãžãããį§ãĢãããæäŧãããããĻããã ããĒãã§ããããīŧã
ãåĻšãŽč¨čãčããįĩĻäģããĄãéŠãããããĢéĄãčĻåããããããã ãåĻšãŽįŗãåēã¯ãããŽå࿎ãŽäŊæ°ãĢã¨ãŖãĻį°äžãĒčĄįēãĒãŽã ããã
ãæŦæĨãæŋæ˛ģãĢéĸããæ§åŽļãĒåŽļæã§ããã°ãä¸åą¤ãŽååĨŗãčĄåčĻįŋãã¨åŠį´č
åčŖæĸããå
ŧããĻåēäģãããŽãéäžããããĒåąæˇãŽäģäēãį°į¨Žæã ãã§åãįããããĻãããã¨ãŽæšãį°äžã ã
ããããããããåąæˇãŽä¸ģã§ãããŦããŽææãĒããåĻšãŽįŗãåēã¯å¤ąį¤ŧãĢåŊãããåã¯æĸããĢå ĨããšããčŋˇãŖãããč¨čé¸ãŗãĢčŋˇãŖãĻããéãĢãŦããčŋããã
ãã¨ãĻãč¯ãåŋããããã§ãã貴åĨŗã¯åŽĸäēēã§æĒæäēēãĒãŽã ãããæ°ãäŊŋããĒããĻč¯ããŽãīŧã
ãããããį§ãããããããŽã§ããäŊããããã¨ããĒãã¨ä¸åŽã§ãæããã¨ã°ããčããĻããžããžããæãåãããĻããããŽã§ãã
ããŠãããåĻšãŽææã¯åēãããã ããŦãã¯å°ãčããåžããĩãŖã¨čĄ¨æ ãįˇŠããã
ãåããŖãããã§ã¯ã卿ŋãŽæäģäēãæäŧãŖãĻ貰ãããããīŧãčąãæ¨ãŽåŽãŽæŽģåĨããéĻčãŽé¸åĨãĒããæĒæãŽåŋé
ããĒãã§ãããīŧã
ããããã¨ãããããžãīŧã
ãå æ°ãĒåĻšãããæ§ãįŽãĒįŦéĄã ãŖãããããŽįŗã¯čŧããĻããã
ãæéŖåžã卿ŋãŽįé
ãĢæĄå
ãããåĻšãŽåžãĢã¤ããĻčĄãŖãã
ãããŽæéãŽå¨æŋã¯ãéŖå¨ãæ´ãéŗã䏿ĩããĢå¤ããįŠéŗã§čŗããã ãŖããįĩĻäģããĄã¯æåããæ¸æãŖãĻããããåĻšãčĸãæ˛ãä¸ããčąãŽįŽåĨããå§ããã¨ã渊ããįŽã§čĻåŽããããĢãĒãŖãã
ãåĻšã¯æããã鎿ééä¸ããĻčĒæ¸ããããããčēĢäŊãåãããŽãåĨŊããĒæ§åã ãåŽåŽļã§ãčąčåãäŊãŖããããŦãããč˛ãåããããŦãšãč§ŖããĻãäēäēēåãŽå¤åĨãäģįĢãĻããããĻãããããŽä¸ã¤ããįžå¨ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽč °å¸ã¨ããĻäŊŋãããĻãããŽã ãâĻâĻã
ãåąæˇãĢæĨãĻããåãŽåãéĸãããã¨ãããäŊãæãĢäģããĒããŖããŽã¯ãį°åĸå¤åã¨åĻšãĒããĢé æ ŽããĻããããã ããã
ããĒãēã č¯ãäŊæĨéŗãéŋããįĄŦãæŽģãå¨į¨ãĢå˛ããä¸ãŽéŽŽãããĒįˇč˛ãŽčąãåãåēããĻããã
ãã䏿ã§ããããåŦĸæ§ã
ãįĩĻäģãŽä¸äēēãæåŋããĻåŖ°ããããã
ãčąã¯ã¨ãĢãŽåĨŊįŠã ããâĻâĻã
ãå°ãį
§ãããããĢåĻšã垎įŦããã¤ãããĻæ§åãčĻãĢæĨãã¨ãˇãĨããæ¨Ēããæå
ãčĻŗå¯ããĻãããåĻšãįäŧŧãĻįą ããčąãæ´ãŋåãã
ãä¸čēĢãåãåēããããæå
ãĢåãčžŧããéįĢ¯ãæŽģãã¨å§ãæŊ°ãããčąãééããæēĸãåēãã
ãåãå Ĩãããããé§įŽã ããåĒããããĒãã¨ã
ãåĻšãé Ŧãč¨ããžãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯čĒåãŽæãĢã¤ããįˇč˛ãŽįŠäŊãčĻã¤ããčãåãŖãã
ã垎ããĢįãå¯ããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãĻãåĻšã¨įĩĻäģãã¯ãšã¯ãšã¨įŦããåŧĩã芰ããĻããįŠēæ°ãå°ãã ãč§Ŗããããã ãŖãã
ãåãŗčĻŗå¯ãããĻãæŦĄãŽčąãæãĢåããæå
ãŽæčĻãĢéä¸ããĻãããŽãäŊã¨ãĒãäŧããŖãĻãããäģåēĻã¯įļēéēãĢå˛ãããä¸ãŽčąãįĄåˇã ã
ãã§ããīŧãã¨ãˇãĨããããã
ãåĻšãæãåŠããĻč¤ãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯å°ãã ãčąã¨æŽģãŽæč§Ļãæå
ã§įĸēãããæŦĄãŽčąã¸æãäŧ¸ã°ããã
ãčĻæ ŧå¤ãŽæĒåãåļåžĄã§ããããäŋŽįˇ´ãįŠããŽã¯ããã¤ãåŊšãĢįĢã¤ã ããã
ãããã§åã¯ãåĻšãŽéĸåãčĻãĻããã¨ããč¨ã荺ã§ãæĨčĒæåēãé ãããæãäŊŋããĒããĒãŖããæĨčĒäŊæãŽãããä¸åŖ°ãããĻé¨åąã¸æģããã¨ãĢããã
ãįŦãã§é¨åąãĢæģãŖãåã¯æēãĢåãããæ¸ããšãå 厚ãé ãŽä¸ã§ä¸Ļãšãã
ãčĻŗå¯å¯žčąĄã¨ãˇãĨãŽåžŽį´°ãĒåå æ¸ãŽåļåžĄãĢã¤ããĻã
ãåĻšã¨ãŽåčĒŋäŊæĨãĢããį˛žįĨįåŽåŽãŽå
åã
ããããžã§æ¸ãįããĻãããįēå čãŠãŗããčĻãã¨ããĒããĢįēãããåģä¸ãåˇĄåããæĻčŖ ããäŊŋį¨äēēããĄãŽčļŗéŗã¨å ąãĢãéŠé§ãĒãŠã޿пĻéŗãčãããĻãããåąæˇã¯åšŗåããŽããŽã ã
ãäģæĨã¨ããįŠãããĒ䏿Ĩããå§é¨ã¨æ¨ååãŽæåžãŽäŧæĨã§ãããããĒæ°ãããã
ãæŧãŽå°éŋããéããĻããŖãé ããčļã¨čąčåãįãĢäšããåĻšãé¨åąã¸æģãŖãĻãããåã¯åĻšãŽčŠąãčããĒãããåãããĒäŧæŠãæĨŊããã ã
ãâããŽå¤ã¯ãæĨčĒãŽæåēããæģãŖãåžãææēãĢåããŖãã
ãå
ã
å¯äģããŽč¯ãåĻšã¯ãæ°į˛ããããŖãĻãåŋå°č¯ãããĢį ãŖãĻãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯åŽäŊįŊŽãĢãĒããããĻããæãŽæ¨Ēã§čĄåē§ããããįŽãéããĻããã
ãæŦ äŧ¸ãããĻãããããå¸åŖãĢæŊãããã¨čããé ã垎ããĒčĄŖæĻããŽéŗãĢæ¯ãčŋããã¨ãˇãĨãįĢãĄä¸ãããæéãŽä¸ã§įŗãå ãããĻããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨīŧã
ãæ°ãĢãĒãŖãĻåŖ°ããããããååŋã¯ãĒãããã°ããæ§åãčĻãĻããã¨ãé ãã§įŠéŗãčããå§ããã
ãéãįĄŦãéåąãčĄįĒããéŗã¨įĨããĒãįˇãŽæåˇã
ãæĩčĨ˛īŧãæĩčĨ˛īŧãæŖéĸįéĸīŧã
ãéåēãåŠããĒããåģä¸ãčĩ°ãįĩĻäģãŽåĢãŗåŖ°ãã¤ããĢå§ãžãŖããŽã ã
ãé ãããéŋãéåąéŗã¨čĄæã§åĻšã莺ãčĩˇããã
ãâĻâĻã¨ãĢīŧīŧã
ãįļæŗãæããĻããã
ãįĄč¨ã§åēãĻčĄãŖãã¨ãˇãĨãŽåžãčŋŊããæãŽåŊąããé ãåēããã¨ããã§éãåŖ°ãéŖãļã
ããã¨ãĢãé¨åąãĢæģããĒããīŧã
ãéä¸ããčãããĻãããŽã¯ãŦããŽåŖ°ã ãŖããæĸãĢåããããããĒæčŖ ãĢįæŋããĻããã
ãæĩčĨ˛īŧãæŖéĸįéĸãĢäēåīŧã
ãįĩĻäģãåĢãŗãäŊŋį¨äēēããĄã大įžãæąããĻįéĸããŧãĢã¸æĨããããŽæä¸ãĢããįéĸæãåŠãįļããéŗã¨åãæŖããįˇãŽåŖ°ãå¤ããéŋããĻããã
ãåž ãĻããããäēäēēã§į ´ããæãããĒãã
ãåŧãŗæĸãããŽã¯ããã¤ãŽéãĢãåąæˇã¸æģãŖãĻãããĩããĢã ãŖããčĻåŧĩããŽįĩĻäģãæ ãĻãåŖ°ãä¸ããã
ããĩããĢæ§īŧãæ˛šãåˇģããĻãžããåĨ´ãįĢãâĻâĻã
ãæŖæ°ãīŧīŧã
ãåŊŧã¯įéĸåãŽæ§åãčĻãįŠ´ããįĸēčĒããã¨ãčæãĄããĒããæ˛åãæãæžãĄãįéĸæãŽåãĢįĢãŖãã
ãâĻâĻã¯ãŊãīŧããŠããįŊ ã ããããæžįĢã¯įéã§ãããæãéãããäŋēãåēãã
ãæ¯åãŋããĒããč¨ãæžã¤ãį ã§å࿎å ãŽåŖĢæ°ãä¸ããããããåãĢãæé¤ããšãã¨å¤æããããã ã
ãæĩæŦéãå§ŋãčĻãããžã§čĻæãč§ŖãããåŽããåēããã
ãå°ãã ãéãããæãããĩããĢãåēãĻčĄãã¨ããããĢéããããã
ãæĻéč¨įˇ´ãåããčģäēēãĒãããã ãŽæ´æŧĸãĢåžããåããã¨ã¯ãĒãã ãããå¤ãŽéŗãéãžãã¨ãåŽå ĩãããããĒįŠēæ°ãæĩãå§ããã
ãâä¸åēãåčĻããĻããã¨ãˇãĨããäēéãŽåģä¸ããčēĢãäšãåēããĻéŖãŗéããã
ãįĩĻäģãŽæ˛éŗ´ãčããåã¯ææēãčļããĢä¸åēãčĻä¸ãããæ°æĨåãĢäŋŽįšããįŗįŗãæ˛ããæŗĨæ°´ã§æēĸãčŋãŖãĻãããããããæŦĄã
ãĢä¸å¯Šč
ãéãåēããåŖãæ¯ãããããįãä¸ããŖãįŗįŗãŽä¸ãĢįå°ããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãčļŗå
ããäŧ¸ãŗãč
ãæ´ãŋãåäģģããĢæãéŖã°ããã
ãæ°æĨåãĢã¨ãˇãĨãæ°ãĢãããĻãããæ°´éŗããããã¯æ°´čãŽå˛Šį¤ãåããäžĩå Ĩ莝ãæãéŗã ãŖããŽãã
ãåãåĢãļããæŠããããéãåŖ°ãéŋãæ¸ĄãŖãã
ãįžé¨éãä¸åēã¸æĨãã§īŧãéåãįĩãŋãĒããīŧã
ããŦããŽæį¤ēã§ã大įžãæãŖãäŊŋį¨äēēãįéĸããŧãĢããé§ãã¤ãããįžãčļŗããĒãåã¯ãæēãæŖãé˛åŖãŽäģŖãããĢããĻčŖãŖããįĩĻäģããĄã¯éããæã§ãĸãããã¯ã¯ãæ§ããä¸åēãåãå˛ããããĢåãŖå ãåããã
ãį įãæããĻīŧã
ããŦããŽåŖ°ãĢåˇäģ¤ã§įĩĻäģããĄã䏿ãĢå¸čĸãæããåēæŋčã帯ãŗãįŊãį˛åĄĩãä¸åēãčĻãé ããããããåŗãčžŧãåŖ°ãčããå§ããã
ãäŊã īŧãããŽčãâĻâĻčåį ãīŧã
ãč¨ãããããĒįˇãŽåŖ°ãä¸ãããããŽåŖ°ãĢææããįĩĻäģããéˇãæãŽįŽãæģ čļčĻčļãĢįĒãåēãã
ãéŦąéļããīŧããŠãīŧã
ãæåˇãä¸ããŖãį´åžãįŽãŽįĩĻäģãæ˛éŗ´ãä¸ããĒããį ãŽä¸ã¸åãčžŧãã ãåēããããĢåé˛ãã大įžãĢæŧãããį ã大ããæēããã
ãæéãį¨ŧãã ãã§č¯ããįĄįã¯ããĒãã§īŧã
ãããŽåŖ°ããįŊéããīŧããåãįŠãããŠããĢé ããīŧīŧã
ããžãæåˇãéŖãļãį
ãŽä¸ããæãåēããã¨æĩæããįŠéŗã¯æŋãããåĸãããŽãŽã大įžã莺ãé¤ããåč
ããĒããã°ããããĒæĻå¨ãæąããããĒããããã§ããå
ãĢå´ŠãããŽã¯äŊŋį¨äēēããĄãŽį˛žįĨã ããã厚čĩĻãĒãæ¯ãä¸ããããåŖæãĢčããããã¯ãããĒãã
ãããŽæãįžåãŽį̝ã§čĨãäŊŋį¨äēēãéããåŖ°ãåŧĩãä¸ããã
ãâĻâĻããã¯äŋēããĄãŽåŽļã īŧã
ãčãčĻããŽããåŖ°ã ãåŊŧã¯æãĢæãŖãã¯ã¯ãåæšã¸įĒãããããčĨ˛æč ãįŊåļããã
ãããã īŧãåŽļæãåŽãīŧã
ãäŋēããĄãŽåŽļæãīŧã
ãåŖ°ãéŖéããįžåãåã¸æŧãčŋãããŦãã¯åŖ°ãåŧĩãä¸ããã
ãéåãįļæããĻīŧãåŽããĢåžšããĒããīŧã
ãæåãĢåŖ°ãä¸ããäŊŋį¨äēēã¸ãæŗĨãžãŋããŽįˇãįĒé˛ãããããŽæãĢæãŖãĻããįŗåŖã§ã¯ã¯ãåŧžãéŖã°ããã
ãéĒéã īŧã
ãįŗåŖãŽįˇãäēæįŽãæ¯ãä¸ããæãæŗĨãžãŋããŽčŠãã¨ãˇãĨãæ´ãŋãæŗĨæ°´ãĢåŠãäģãããããŽéŖæ˛Ģãé ãčãĢããĻãä¸äēēãŽäžĩå Ĩč ãé˛åŖãŽééãįãŖãĻæŦãčžŧãŋããĸãããæĄããããĻããįĩĻäģãåŧãã¤ãŖãæ˛éŗ´ãä¸ããã
ãäŧããīŧã
ãåŖ°ã¨ã¨ããĢéŖãŗčžŧãã ãŽã¯ãĩããĢã ãŖããæŖéĸãŽæĻéãįĩããĻãä¸ãŽé¨ããčãäģãããŽã ãããįĩĻäģãįĒãéŖã°ããäŊåĸãįĢãĻį´ããĒããæ˛åãæ¯ãä¸ããã
ãįĢãĄä¸ããŖããĩããĢãĢäžĩå
Ĩč
ãčŋŊæãäģæããããåŊŧã¯æ˛å䏿Ŧã§æŦãæ¨ãĻãã
ããĩããĢæ§ã
ãä¸ããŖãĻãīŧã
ãé§ãå¯ããã¨ããįĩĻäģããæ¯ įļã¨æ¯ãæããĩããĢãĢãäžĩå Ĩč ãčĨ˛ãããããå é ãŽä¸å¤Ēåãįč ã§åãæĩããčļŗãæãŖãĻåēãĢåŠãã¤ãããæ¯ãåãæããĒãåĨãŽåãčĨ˛ãããæ˛åãæ¯ããŖãĻåŧžãčŋãã
ãčãããĒãīŧãã¯ãŊééå ąīŧã
ãæ°ä¸ãĢåŧãããĩããĢãŽåļæã¯čŠåŖãčŖããčĄãĢæŋĄããĻããã
ãããĢãåžãīŧã
ãäžĩå Ĩč ãŽä¸äēēãåŊŧãŽčãĢåããįĸãįĒããĻãããæŗĨæ°´ãčš´ãä¸ãããĩããĢãŽčåžãĢåãčžŧãã ã¨ãˇãĨããįĸãį´ æã§åããããããåŧãæããåŗåē§ãĢæãããįŽãĢčŋŊããĒãéãã§éŖãã§čĄãŖãįĸã¯ãå°æãŽč ãå˛ŠåŖãĢį¸Ģãæĸããã
ãâĻâĻåãįŠãīŧã
ãįåŖãæĄãŖãäžĩå Ĩč ãčĨ˛ãããããã¨ãˇãĨã¯įåŖãį´ æã§ã¸ãæããããŽį ´įãæĩãŽčļŗãĢįĒãåēããã
ããžããâĻâĻããã¤ãīŧã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æĨæãæŖįĸēãĢæããå
¨åŖãããĒãį¨åēĻãĢå æ¸ããåãåŠãčžŧãã§čĄãããã°ããããã¨ãčĨ˛æč
å
¨åĄãæŗĨæ°´ãŽä¸ã§č¸ããå
ããĢåģããĻããã
ãįĩĻäģããĄããŦããč¨čãå¤ąããæ¯ãåãããã¨ããĒãįĢãĄå°Ŋããã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĩ¤éĢĒã¯ãæĻéãŽäŊéģããå
ããĢæēããĻãããããĢčĻããã
ãåã¯æ¯ãčŋããå¸åŖãčĸĢãŖãĻč
ãĢãããŋã¤ãåĻšãčĻããããŽå°åģãŋãĢéããčŠãæąããããã
ãããĢīŧã
ãįˇåŧĩãŽįŗ¸ãåããĻããĩãã¤ããããåŊŧãĢãŦããé§ãå¯ãã
ãæĸčĄããĻããããããĩããĢãåŽĸ厤ã¸ãäģãĢč˛ åˇč
ã¯īŧã
ãäģã¯ãäŊŋį¨äēēãŽč¤æ°åãææ˛ã¨åãåˇãâĻâĻčģŊåˇã§ãã
ãäģãŽč
ãæåŊãĻããäžĩå
Ĩč
ããĄã¯į¸ãä¸ããĻįŠįŊŽã¸ãä¸åēãŽįäģãã¨äŋŽįšã¯ãããŽåžã
ãæˇãŋãĒãæį¤ēãéŖãŗäē¤ããããããåãåēãããĸãããŽæã¨å¸ã§æĸčĄãæŊããããĩããĢãäŊŋį¨äēēããĄãéãã§čĄãŖãã
â
ãéããčä¸ãããããåĻšãčŊãĄįããŽãåž
ã¤ãåŧˇåŧĩãŖãĻããæå
ãĢäŊ渊ãæģãŖãé ãäēäēēã§å¯å°ã¸į§ģåããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãæģããĒãããžã čĨ˛æãŽäŊéģãåˇããĒãä¸åēãĢæŽãŖãĻãããĒããčŋããĢčĄããšãã ãããã
ãåĻšãĢäēæ
ãčĒŦæããĻãåã¯é¨åąãåēãã
ãä¸åēã¯ãæĻéãŽį补ã¨äŋŽåžŠäŊæĨãŽįąæ°ãæšŋæ°ãããããæˇˇããŖãč¤éãĒæŽãéĻã§ãããčŋãããã ãŖãã
ãįĩĻäģãæ˛ãããŠãŗããé ŧããĢãį¸ãä¸ããäžĩå
Ĩč
ãäŊŋį¨äēēãŽįˇããĄãéãŗåēããĻãããæŦæ ŧįãĒäŋŽåžŠã¯ææĨäģĨéã ããããäžĩå
Ĩįĩ莝ã¨ãĒãŖãįŠ´ã¯ååĸã¨įĻį¤Ģã§åãæģããĻããã
ãåãåąæˇãč¨ĒããæĨã¨åãããčǰããįĄč¨ã§åãįĩãã§ãããããããåãéĸããããããĢãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åŖéãĢããããŋčžŧãã§įēå ãããŗãįēããĻãããæŗĨæ°´ãčĸĢããč¸ãŋčãããããããŗããĄã¯ãããŖã¨åŠãããĒãã ããã
ãæ°´čããäžĩå ĨããĻãããŖãĻããã¤ããæ°äģããĻãīŧããŠãããŖãĻãããŽå ´æãįĨãŖãã¨æãīŧã
ãåããããã¨ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éĻãåžããĻåŋããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčŊåãį´ĸæĩãĢåŠį¨ããĻæ
å ąãå
ąæã§ããã°ãåąéēãĒįļæŗãæĒįļãĢåéŋã§ãããããč¸ãã ããã¨ãˇãĨæŦäēēãįĨčã¨įĩé¨ãįŠããžã§ã¯ãéŖæēãåããŽãéŖãããã
ããĩããĢâĻâĻãããŽåˇã¯æˇąããŽīŧã
ããããĒäŧ芹ãããĻããæã ã
ããã¨ãĢã¯įĄäēããã¨ãˇãĨãããããã¨ãããããã§åŠããŖããã
ãåŖ°ããããĻãããŦããããåšŗéãåãįšãŖãĻãããããĒé°å˛æ°ãæããã
ããĩããĢãããŽåŽšæ ã¯īŧã
ãį¤žäē¤čžäģ¤ã¨ããĻå°ããã¨ããŦãã¯å°ãč¨ãæˇãã ã
ãåŊãĢåĨįļã¯ãĒããããããŠãåˇåŖãŽįļæ ãč¯ããĒããŽãįąãåēå§ããĻããã
ãæŗĨã§æąããåįŠã¯ãæ¯ãåĄãããĻãããŽã¨å¤ãããĒãã
ãæ˛ģįå¸Ģãåŧãļæé ã¯ãããããŠãäģåžãŽč¨įģãĢæ¯éãåēããŽã¯éŋããããĒããã
ãč°äŧãžã§ãŽäģæĨã¨ææĨãäŧå ´ã¸åããéä¸ãŽåŽå ¨ããã¨ãˇãĨãĢé ŧããããåžãĒãã
ãåã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãããã¤ãã¨å¤ãããĒã襨æ ã ãä¸åŽãåŋé ã¯æããĒããã ããŠããĩããĢæŦäēēã¯ãŠãã ãããäģäēãŽãããĢįããĻãããããĒčģäēēããč°äŧåŊæĨãĢčĻčˇå¯žčąĄãéĸãããŽããŗãįé¤ãĒããĻâĻâĻã
ãčŠĻã䞥å¤ããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããīŧ
ãåŠãããã¨ããæŽåãĒåŋæãã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ãˇãĨãŽå垊čŊåãįĸēčĒãããĢã¯ããžãã¨ãĒãæŠäŧã ãå
įŠã ãããŦãã¨ãĩããĢãäēããĢäŋĄé ŧããĻãããĒããååãäģ°ããã¯ããäŊãčĩˇããĒããã¨ãįĸēčĒããã ãã¨ããĻããčŠĻã䞥å¤ã¯ããã
ãâĻâĻå įããĩããĢãããŽåˇãčĻããĻããã ããžãããīŧãåãŽæĒæãã¨ãˇãĨãæ˛ģããĻããããã¨ããããžãã
ãឿšãŽč¨įŽãįĩããĻããåã¯åŖãéããã
ãåŊŧčĒčēĢãŽåˇãå垊ãããŽã¯į§ãčĻãããŠã貴æšãŽåˇãīŧã
ããŦããŽæčĄ¨ãįĒããããããåˇŽãåēããžãããĢįãžãããæŠãžãŖãããįĨããĒãã䏿ãčĄããĒãããĒæ°ãããĻããã
ãåäžã¯ä¸åēĻãããæ˛ģããįĸēč¨ŧã¯ãããžããã
ããŦããŽįŽãããģããŽä¸įŦã ãį įŠļč ãŽčŧããčĻããã
ãâĻâĻããŽæãŽįļæŗãčŠŗããčãããĻããããããīŧã
ãåã¯ããã¤ãĻãįŧįąæ˛ŧãã¸åããåãŽåēæĨäēãæãčŋããĻããã
ãããŽæãåã¯įĩãããčĻæãããæĒįŠãĢéŖãããĻčĄčã¨ãĒããĒãããããä¸ã¤ãŽææ¸ã ã¨ãæĩæããããĢčĒåãæãæ¸ĄãããŽã ãã ããããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãæãčēĢãŽä¸é¨ãã¨čĒčããĻãåãŽį ´æãäŋŽåžŠãããåŊąãŽãããĢäģãįēããŽãåãįįąãĒãããããĢčŋãįļæŗããåįžãããã
ãåããĄã¯ãĩããĢãéãŗčžŧãžããåŽĸ厤ã¸åããŖãã
ãæãéããéį̝ãĢãčĄã¨æļæ¯čŦãŽčããéŧģãįĒãããĩããĢã¯å¯å°ã§ä¸åčēĢãčĩˇãããå
帯ãåˇģãããåˇĻč
ãæąããĻããããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻããĒãįãå¯ããã
ãâĻâĻãĒãã ãããããã¨ãčĻčããĒãįĩæ§ã ã
ãããĢãå°ãã ãææ
ĸããĻã
ããŦããåŽĨãããã¨ããĻãããĩããĢã¯é ãĒã ã
ãæčŋãããĒããŽã¯æŗåŽå ã ãå¯å°ãŽčãĢįĢãĄãã¨ãˇãĨãĢčĻįˇãéãŖããæåŗãäŧããã¨ã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄč¨ã§čŋãĨãããĩããĢãŽč ãčĻä¸ãããčĒåããæ˛ģããã¨ã¯ããĒããããŽæããæ˛ģããã¨ããĻæ˛ģãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããŽã ããã
ããĄããŖã¨æåããžãã
ããĩããĢãŽåŗæãæ´ãŋãįĄįããã¨ãˇãĨãŽæãĢéããããĻãä¸äēēãŽčãč§ĻãåããããĢããã
ããããäŊãâĻâĻīŧã
ãåããĒãã§ãã ããã
ãåã¯įŽãéããããŽæĨãŽæčĻãåŧãŗčĻãžããã¨ãˇãĨãŽéĻįãĢč§ĻããæãäēããŽéŧåãéãĒãåããåĸįãæēļããĻãããããĒæčĻã
ãâ
ãåãŽčæã¯įˇåŧĩã§éãããĩããĢãŽčæã¯įˇåŧĩã¨čåĨŽã§äšąããĻããã寞ããĻãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčæã¯éĸįŊããģãŠä¸åŽã§įˇŠããã ã
ãåŧå¸ãåãããĻãã ãããã§ããį¯å˛ã§ã
ãåã¯åŧå¸ãæ´ããã¨ãˇãĨãŽčæãĢéä¸ãããããŠããŠãĒä¸ã¤ãŽéŧåããä¸ã¤ãĢåæããĻãããããĢã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éåģãŽæåˇãčįŠããĒããåŧå¸ãéŧåãæŦæĨãĒãįĄé§ãĒãŽã ãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯čĻŗå¯ããĻæ¨ĄåŖãããããŽãããŽä¸čĻãæããĻãåŋ
čĻãåãå
Ĩããã
ãå¤åĨãæ°´ãĢæĩ¸ããæēãããĻãįšįļãĢįĩĄãžãŖãæąããåãé¤ããããĢããããšããããããĢããã¨ããã ããŽįļæ
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽč
°åˇģãã¯åžã§æ´ããšãã ã
ãâĻâĻããã ã âĻâĻīŧã
ãåģãåŖ°ãĢæ°ãåãããĻãįŽãéããã
ãæéãéåˇģãããããããĢãį°å¸¸ãĒæĒãŋãįĄįããæŖå¸¸ã¸æ´ãããããããĒåŧˇåļįãĒäŋŽæŖã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãæãéĸããåã¯å¤§ããæ¯ãåãããčãéãããčǰããĢįĨãããåãĢåē§ããããããčããéį̝ã大ããĒæã§čŠãåŧãå¯ããããã
ããĩããĢã¯čãæ¯ãåããĒãããéããæã§åˇĻč
ãŽå
帯ãåŧãååãŖãããããĢã¯åˇčˇĄä¸ã¤ãĒãįŽčãæåããæĒæãĒãŠåå¨ããĒããŖãããŽãããĒåŽæ˛ģã ã
ããŦããæ¯ãéŖ˛ãããĩããĢã¯åįļã¨č
ãčĻã¤ããįč§Ŗãåã°ãĒãããŽãĢåããįŽã§ã¨ãˇãĨãčĻãã
ããååãæéŖãããããžããããããã§č˛´éãĒæ å ąãåžãããžããããæŗåŽäģĨä¸ãĢį˛ããžãããŽã§äēåēĻã¨ãããžããã
ãããã ãč¨ãŖãĻčģŊãä¸į¤ŧããã¨ãåŽĸ厤ãåēããæĨčĒãĢč¨čŋ°ããšãé įŽãčŗå ã§įˇ´ãã¤ã¤åģä¸ãæŠãã
ãå垊įžčąĄãĢã¯ãå¯žčąĄã¨ãŽãåčĒŋããĢããčĒåˇąé åã¸ãŽåãčžŧãŋãåŋ é ã§ããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãåŽĸ厤ãĢæŽããĻæĨãĻããžãŖããŽã§ã¯ã¨æãčŗããæ¯ãčŋããįĨįãŽä¸ãŽåããåãčĻã¤ãčŋããĻãããčļŗéŗãįĢãĻããĢåžãã¤ããĻæĨããããã
ããã¯ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯éĄã ããããĢäŊãæ ãããŠãå ąéŗ´ãããã¯ãčĻãč ãĢå§ããããĻããã
17
ãâãã¨ãĢãŽåŧå¸ãæˇąãįˇŠãããĢãĒãŖããŽãįĸēčĒããĻãã¨ãˇãĨã¨åäģããããįˇã¯įĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ãåŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻãéããããéå¯ã¯åŋå°č¯ãã¨åæãĢãåŖ°ãäģĨå¤ãŽæ
å ąãéŽæãããįļæ
ã§ãããã
ãįˇã¯éŗãįĢãĻãĒãããæãŽééããåģä¸ã¸ã¨æģãåēããå
ļãŽéãčĄŖæĻããŽéŗã¨å
ąãĢæãæŽģãé¨åąãŽå
å´ã¸čŊãĄããæ°ãĢãįãããä¸čēĢã ããå
ã¸é˛ãã
ãæˇąå¤ããææšãĢãããĻåąæˇã¯éå¯ãĢå ãžããĻããããåŽå ¨ãĢį ãŖãĻã¯ããĒããæ´ģåãįļããäēēéãŽãåŖ°ãã¨įŠéŗãäŧããŖãĻããã
ãį§ģåä¸ãįŊéĢĒæˇˇãããŽįˇãå ¨čēĢãåŧˇåŧĩãããčãĢæąããæŦãčŊã¨ããããĢãĒããĒããįĢãĄæĸãžãŖããčž˛å ˇãæ§ããĻååŽããĻããåäŊã ã
ãåŊŧã¯åģä¸ãĢäŊããããåčĻããĻãããé ããįĒå
ãžã§æŗĨãčĸĢãŖãįĢã¤äēēåŊąãæãã¯ãčŧĒéãæēļãåēããčäēēåŊĸãéĄãĢãããšãããŽããå¤įļã¨ããĒãä¸åŽåŊĸãŽãããĢã
ãæ¯ããäŊŋį¨äēēãĢæ§ãããįˇã¯éãéãããã¨č¸ãŋåēããã ããéĸåãĒåéĄãįēįãããčĒčãĢæããããčļŗãããžãã§æŗĨæ˛ŧãĢåãããããŽãããĢéãã
ã䏿šã§ãčĨ˛ãæããŖãĻæĨãĒããŽãåããã¨ãåŊŧã¯äēēåŊąãŽæŖäŊãĢæčãåˇĄããå§ããããããã¨åãæ§ãĢčēĢãåŧãã¤ã¤ãčļŗå
ãĢæŗĨãŽį补ããĒããã¨ãĢæ°äģããĻéĻãã˛ããã
ãæĩã§ã¯ãĒã大æãĒäēēįŠãåŊŧãŽä¸ãĢãæ°æĨåãĢãã¨ãĢããčããĻãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽå¤§įˇãã¨ããæ
å ąãæĩŽããļãå
ļããåŧãŗæ°´ã¨ãĒãŖãã
ããããããĻããĸããŋãã¨ãˇãĨâĻâĻããīŧã
ãå ļãŽä¸įŦãæŗĨãŽãããĢæēããéĄãŽä¸ãĢãį ããįĨįč˛ãŽįŗåãčĻåēããããåŊŧã¯æ ãĻãĻäģäēįããžãããŖãã
ãâĻâĻå¤ąį¤ŧã§ãĒããã°ããããīŧã
ãåŊŧãããąããããåãåēããåēãããŽã¯äģäēį¨ãŽåæãã§ããŖããįˇã¯åŊŧãŽãåŖ°ãã¸æčãå¯ããæåŗãæĸãåŊãĻãã
ãå
¨čēĢæŗĨã ãããŽįˇãĢãæãŦããäģŖãããŽéå
ˇãå¯čļããã¨čããããã ãå°ãäēæ
ã¯éãããå¸ãåãåãŖãã
ãå¤ąį¤ŧããžãīŧã
ãč
°ãŽéĢãčžēãã§åæããŽå¸¯į´ãæãåãããĻããã¨ãæåŗãįč§ŖããäŊŋį¨äēēãæŗĨäēēåŊĸãŽå¤Ēãæãããį´ãåĨĒãåãŖããį´ æŠã᏿ãŽč
°ãĢåˇģãäģããčåžã§ãŽãĨãã¨įĩãļã
ãæŦĄãŽįŦéãčŧĒéãįšãæĸãããããããĒæčĻãčĩˇããŖããæĄæŖãããã¨ããĻããããŽããæ ã¨æĨãĢæŧãčžŧããããæĨéãĢååēããĻããã
ãéĄãä¸ããäŊŋį¨äēēãčĻãããŽã¯ãåąæˇãčĨ˛æããåŽãæããæĻåŖĢã§ãããåŊĢåãŽãããĢæ´ãŖãéĄįĢãĄãŽįˇã§ããŖãã
ãâĻâĻããŖãąãã¨ãˇãĨããã§ããããæ¨å¤ã¯æéŖãããããžãããã¨ãˇãĨãããį ããĒããã§ããīŧã
ãäŊŋį¨äēēã¯ãįŧãŽåã§äŊãčĩˇãããįč§Ŗã§ããĻã¯ããĒããå
ļãã§ããåŋãŽå
ãĢįããĻããä¸č¨ãäŧãããããã¨ãĢæēčļŗããĻãåŽå ĩãŽæ¯ãåããã
ã寞ããĻåŊĸãåãæģããįˇã¯ãäŊŋį¨äēēãčãĢæąããæŖčĄãŽææŦãä¸įĨããå
ļãŽå ´ãåžãĢããã
ãåģä¸ãŽįĒãåŊããã卿ŋããæããã¨č¸æ°ãæŧããĻãããä¸ã§ã¯įĩĻäģãå¤éŖãŽåžįäģããããĻãããæé¤éå ˇãæĻå¨ãĢããĻåąæˇãŽé˛čĄãĢåãããĩããĢãĢįĒãéŖã°ãããįĩĻäģãŽãåŖ°ããéŋãã
ãâĻâĻãĩããĢæ§ãŽãå æ¸ãč¯ããĒãŖããŋãããã§ããå¤åˇãå¤ããĻããã¯ãĒããĄããŖãã
ãæĩãå¤ãåžĄæšãĒãŽããååãããåĻŦãžããĻãããâĻâĻã
ãããŽæ§æ ŧã§ã¯įĄįããĒãããããĒãīŧããããĢãŦãæ§ã¯éĢ貴ãĒåĨŗæ§ã ããŽãããŽå°åąčˇčĄã§ãããīŧã
ããããå
æĨããĩããĢæ§ãæãŖãĻãããããįããčļčããčĻããĻãīŧã
ãããå¯åŽãŽåĨŗæ§ãããŽåˇŽãå
ĨããĒãã§ããŖãĻãīŧã大ä¸å¤Ģãããīŧã
ã卿ŋãŽå ĨãåŖãĢįĢã¤ã¨ãįĩĻäģãŽä¸äēēãåŖ°ããããĻããã
ããããããŗį˛ãŽåčãéŖæåēĢããæãŖãĻæĨãĻããããĒãīŧã
ãéŖå¨ãæãæãæĸãããį¸æãæ¯ãčŋããããĒããįˇã¯įĩĻäģãæåŗããæšåã¸įŽãåããããŗã¨åãåããŽį˛čĸãä¸ã¤æ´ãŋãäŊæĨå°ãŽæ¨ĒãĢįŊŽãã
ããããã¨ããåŠãããžãŖâĻâĻīŧīŧã
ãæããåŖ°č˛ã§įããįĩĻäģããæ¯ãčŋããĒã襨æ ãåŧˇåŧĩãããĻæ˛éŗ´ãä¸ããã
ãããįŗã荺ãããžããīŧããåŽĸæ§ãĢäŊãĻå¤ąį¤ŧãĒãã¨ãâĻâĻã
ãéĄãįãŖčĩ¤ãĢããĻé ãä¸ããåŊŧåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ãã¯ããææãããããįĻããã¨ãįˇãŽčäŊįžãĢ寞ãããįžæĨãã§å ããããĻãããåąæˇã§åãč
ãŽå¤ãã¯ããã¨ãĢããŦããäžå¤ã¨ããĻã襨æ
ãé ģįšãĢå¤åããã
ãčĻŗå¯ãįĩããįˇã¯äŊãįãããĢč¸ĩãčŋããã
ãä¸åēãĢåēãã¨ãæšŋãŖãčãŽåããããã
ãį ´åŖãããįŗįŗãæ°´å ´ã¯ååĸãæŋã§åĄãããäŋŽåžŠäŊæĨã¯ä¸æãããĻããã
ãįˇã¯é
ãĢããããŋčžŧãã ãæŗĨæ°´ãčĸĢããč¸ãŋčããããĻå
ãå¤ąããããŖããã¨åããĻããįēå
ãããŗãĢæå
ã§č§ĻãããäģĨåãĢãåĸããĻå°ããį´°ããåŖ°ãã ã
ãå
åŊĸãäŋãĻãĒãããĻããåå ãŽãŋãåãé¤ããæåˇãäŋŽæŖããĻãããã
ãä¸įŦãŽåžããããŗã¯æŗĨãåŧžãéŖã°ããįã
ããåŧĩããåãæģããĻãåãŗéįŊãå
ãæžãĄå§ããã
ããããã¨ãã
ãåã¨ããåŖ°ãéŋããæ¯ãčŋãã¨ãããŽããŠãšãããŦããčĻä¸ãããĻãããå ãåãæģãããããŗãčĻãĻãįŠããããĢįŽãį´°ããã
ãåēãŽæãããæģãŖãĻãįããĒãåãļãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĻįˇãčŋŊããå˛ããįŗãåŖããįĩĻæ°´åŖãæ ŊåšãããĻããčéĄãé ãĢčĻããŖãã
ããã¤ãã¨ã¯éãčŖ ãããč°äŧį¨ãĢčĒããããæããæ°ãĢå ĨãŖãĻããããåŦãããŽã ãããŠīŧã
ãčĒåŽ¤ã§æĨããŽéäģäēãäģģãããįĩĻäģãŽåå¨ã¯ãåŊäēēãŽãåŖ°ãããææĄæ¸ãŋã ãįˇã¯čåŗãį¤ēããįĄč¨ãŽãžãžįĢãĄåģãŖããäģŽį ããįŽãčĻãžããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãåŽĸéã¸åããããã ã
ãé¨åąãĢæģãã¨ãæãŽééããå¤åĨãŽį̝ãã¯ãŋåēããĻããã
ãå¯ãĻããäēäēēãčĩˇãããĒãããæãéããįĩãŗįŽãæŽãããžãžãŽå¤åĨãæžãä¸ãããåããĻããåæããŽį´ãč§Ŗããį´åžãĢãčŧĒéãæēããã ãéãéãããæãããæãããŽã¨åãčĻé ã§å¤åĨã¸æģãčžŧãã
ããĢããã¸æŗ¨ãããæļ˛äŊãŽãããĢãæãã¯ãįŠēãŽįļãæēããæ°äŊãŽãããĢãããã¨ãĢãŽčĒčãã¨ããæ ãĢåãžãŖãįˇã¯ãįéǍéã
ã¨č¨ã襨ããĢį¸åŋããå§ŋã¨åŧˇåēĻãåãæģãã
ããã¨ãĢã¯æĒã į ãŖãĻãããå¯éĄãčĻä¸ããããåŖ°ããĢæčãåãããįˇã¯åŖéã§č ãįĩãŋãæãŽéãŽéå¯ãĢčēĢãæĩ¸ããã
ãâââ
ãįŋæĨãŽæŧéããåąæˇå
¨äŊãæ°æ ããĒéå¯ãĢå
ãžããĻããä¸ãåã¯é¨åąã§æéŖãŽãããĒæŧéŖãæãŖãĻããã
ãčĨ˛æé¨åããį ãããĢããåĻšããéãŗį˛ããåäžãŽãããĢ垎įĄãã§ããã
ãâããŽéå¯ãį ´ããããĢãé¨åąãŽæãäšąæ´ãĢããã¯ããããčŋäēãããéããĒãæãéãããĩããĢãå
ĨãŖãĻããã
ãéĄč˛ãåĒããĒããŽã¯ãæˇąå¤ãŽæŋåã¨įĄį ä¸čļŗãŽããã ããããį æ°čĻãžããĢčĻčžãčã§ãåãŋᎠããĻããããŽãããĒ襨æ
ã ã
ãæ¨å¤ãčŖåˇãč˛ ãŖãĻč
ĢããĻããč
ã¯ãäŊäēããĒããŖãããŽãããĢæ°ããåļæãŽčĸã¸éãããĻããã
ãâĻâĻãã¯ããããããžãīŧã
ãä¸č¨ãåããå Ĩ厤ããĻæĨããĩããĢãĢ寞ããåããåŖ°ãããããåŊŧã¯ä¸åŋĢãããĢéĄãããããįĄé äŊãĢåˇĻč ãæ¯ãã
ããããæŧã ãīŧãč ã¯čĻãĻãŽéãã ãįãŋããĒããã°ãåˇčˇĄãããĒããâĻâĻæ°åŗãæĒããģãŠãĢãĒã
ããĩããĢã¯å¤§ããæ¯ãåããé¨åąãŽé ãĢããã¨ãˇãĨãä¸įĨãããå ãģãŠãžã§å¯ãæ¯ããããĻããã¨ãˇãĨãã厚čĩĻãŽãĒãéãčĻįˇãčŋãã
ãčãã芹ãĢããã°ãåĻšã¯įĩĻäģãŽæãĢįæŋããããããĻåŽåŽļãåēãåžãé ãé莝ããåąæˇãĢå
ĨãŖãããããããŽé ãããŦãã¯ãé¨å¤č
ãŽčĻįˇã¨æ
å ąæŧæ´ŠãčĻæããĻãæĨč§Ļãåēå
ĨããæããĻãããŽã ãįžå¨ãŽåž
éãæ¨ãĻãĻãŦããčŖåãäŊŋį¨äēēãããã¨ãčãéŖãã
ãããŽé ãåŽļã¸æåŧãããč
ããããã¯ãå°žčĄãããč
ãããã¨ããã°âĻâĻã
ããããå°ãããããã
ãåã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãæŽããĻé¨åąãåēããåģä¸ãæŠããĒããããĩããĢã¯čãåãããžãžåãåēãã
ãæ¨æĨãŽãã¨ãį¤ŧã¯č¨ãããã
ãåŋ
čĻãããžããã
ãåãįããã¨ããĩããĢã¯æ°ãĢéŖããĒããĢæ¯ãčŋããããŽéãįŗã§åãå°æããã
ãâĻâĻããããåãããã¤ãéŖŧãæ ŖãããĻããã¤ãããīŧã
ããĩããĢãŽåŖ°ãŽããŧãŗãčŊãĄãã
ãããã¯äēēéãããĒãããįãįŠã§ããĒããåžé ãĒãããĢčĻããĻãããã¤ãžã§įļããįĨãããŽã ãīŧã
ã常ãĢæąããĻããä¸åŽãįįĸēãĢč¨ãåŊãĻãããããäģäēēãĢæãããĻå°ãæ å ąã§ã¯ãĒããčĻĒååŋããåēãč¨čã ããããįŠäžŋãĢåãæĩããããããåš´éˇč ã¸ãŽį¤ŧåã ã
ãâĻâĻčãĢéããžãã
ããåãäŊãããåããŖãĻããĒããåĨ´ãéŖããĻãããŽãīŧã
ãéĄãæ åēĻãĢčããæ åēĻãæŧãåēãĻãããŽã ãããīŧã䞎ããããããįĨããĒãã
ãéŠæ°æ´žãäŋåŽæ´žãããäžäģŖãããŦããŽæãĢæ¸ĄãŖããã¨ã§įĻãŖãĻãããæŦĄãĢäŊãčĩˇããæãŽæ¨įã¯ããåã ãīŧã
ãåãæ¨ãĻããããĢč¨ãŖããåŊŧã¯čæãĄããã
ãããŗããĒãīŧãæããĻåŖ°ãåēãĒããīŧã
ãä¸å
¨ãæãããĢããäģããã§ã¯éãããããžããŽã§ã
ãããįããã¨ããĩããĢã¯åãå¤č¸ãŋãããããĢįēãåããéŧģã§įŦãŖãã
ãããããããããã ããããŽįŠããŖãŊãĄã§ã¯ããããŖãĻæãĢåĻšãåŽããã
ãåã¯åãŽčŖãåãŋããããæŦåŊãĢä¸čēžã§ã厚čĩĻã¨ããã大äēēãããĒããčįĢãĄãéŽãããããéããĢæ¯ãåãã
ãã§ã¯ããŠããããŽãæŖãããŖãã¨æããžããīŧã
ãåãåãã¨ããĩããĢã¯åįĒãĢåãŽæéĻãæ´ãã ãæĩæããéããĒãåŧãå¯ãããããžããžãã¨čĻŗå¯ãããã
ãį´°ããĒãæãį´°ããããŗã ããīŧã
ãåãããããĢæãéĸãã¨ããĩããĢã¯æãã䏿ŦãŽįåŖãåãåēããã忏Ąãã¯įããå¤ĒãéãŽãããĒåŊĸįļãããĻããã
ãããŽäŊæ ŧãããåŖãæãĄä¸ãããã¨ãã§ãããįããĒããįļãįŽãã ãéĸį¯ãéĻãŽééãįŽãŽįŠ´ãæĩãŽæĨæãĢå ¨äŊéãäšããĻįĒãåēãããããĒãåäžã§ãåãĻããâĻâĻéãé ãã§ããã°ããããä¸įĒã ããĒã
ãæå ã§å¨į¨ãĢåããĻãŋããåžããĩããĢã¯įåŖãåãĢæŧãäģããã
ãåäžį¸æãĢäŊãĻįŠé¨ãĒ芹ãããĻãããŽīŧã
ãåããåŖ°ãå˛ãŖãĻå
ĨãŖãã
ãåģä¸ãŽåãããããŦããæŠããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽæãĢããéįļãŽįåŖãčĻãĻãåããããã̿翝ãã¤ããã
ãčˇčēĢčĄãæãããŽã¯æ§ããĒããããŠãčģäēēåēæēãŽčãæšãæŧãäģããĒãã§ãĄããã ããčǰãåŊŧããæ´åã§įŠäēãč§ŖæąēãããããĢãĒãã°ãåŊãæŊ°ãããã
ãäŋēã¯äēåŽãč¨ãŖããžã§ã ã
ãåŖãå°ããããĩããĢãŽåãĢįĢãĄããŦãã¯č °ãĢæãåŊãĻãã
ããã¨ãĢãĢã¯ãæĻæŗãčĻæĨĩããčĻŗå¯įŧã¨įĨæĩããããã常ãĢå§åŠč
°ã§įŽäģããæĒããŦãĩãįˇã¨ã¯éããŽã
ãčǰãâĻâĻīŧã
ããããčĒčĻããĒããŽīŧããčļãŽãĢãããããã¤å˛ãŖããčĻããĻãĒããŽãããīŧã
ããããįįãĢåšããããã§ããĩããĢã¯č¨čãĢ芰ãžãããããæĒãããĢčĻįˇãé¸ãããã
ãäēäēēãŽéã§äē¤ããããč¨čã¯åēã
ããããé æ
ŽãŽãĒããä¸åãäŋĄé ŧãčĻãĻåããããĢãããŽäģļã¨ãããįå¤ä¸ãŽå¯čĢãŽäģļã¨ãããããŖã¨äģĨåããäģãåããããããã ã
ãåãĢåãį´ãŖããŦãã垎įŦãã
ããã¨ãĢããĩããĢãŽæčĢã¯æĨĩį̝ã ãããŠãåãããĢčļãããã¨ã¯ãĒãããåŊãŽåąéēãæããæãĢčēčēãŖãĻã¯ããĄãã
ãåŧĩã芰ããĻããįŠēæ°ãå°ãã ãįˇŠãã ãããĢæããã
ãį§ããã¯ãããį ãããčŦãč´ãããäŊŋãæšãééããĒãã§ãã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻåŊŧåĨŗãææ¸ĄããĻãããŽã¯ãã¨ãĻãéĢ䞥ãããĒéĻæ°´įļã ãŖãã
ãâĻâĻãããéĒéãå ĨãŖããĒã
ãįĢãĄåģããã¨ãããĩããĢãĢãåã¯åŊŧãŽįŽãčĻãĻå°ããã
ããĩããĢããã¯ããããžã§ãĢäŊäēēčŦãŖããã§ããīŧã
ãåããĻåãŽéĄããžã¨ããĢčĻããĩããĢã¯įŽãčĻéããä¸įŦã ãéģãčžŧãã ããããĻããŦããĢčĻįˇãčĩ°ãããåžããžãåãčĻãã
ããåããžãããŖâĻâĻãããåŋããĻããã
ãäŊãč¨ããããããŽãŽæ°ãå¤ããŖãããããéĄãããããĻããēãĢãēãĢã¨éæŽĩãéããĻčĄãŖãã
ããŦããã¯ãšã¯ãšã¨įŦããĒããåžãå§ŋãčĻéãã
ãããããĒããããããã ãåããŽã¯įããããéĒéãããã¯ãĒããŖããŽããã§ãããĄããŖã¨åããčĻéãããĒããĻâĻâĻã
ããĩããĢãŽæ´åįãĒįžåŽčĢãĢ寞ããįæ§įãĒæčˇãįŠäēãå ŦåšŗãĢ夿ããįŽãé¤ãŖãĻãģããã¨éĄãčĒæ¸äŧãŽįåŋĩãĢæ˛ŋãŖãčĄåã¯ãåŽãĢčĒæ¸äŧä¸ģåŦč ãŽåŊŧåĨŗãããã
ãåã¯æãŽä¸ãĢããåˇããæč§ĻãįĸēãããéĻæ°´įļãæēãããĻä¸ãŽæļ˛äŊãčĻãåžãããããæãĢããžãŖãĻé¨åąã¸æģãŖãã
ãâ
ãå¤éŖåžãåã¯æ¸ãä¸ããã°ãããŽį´æããŦããŽåˇåæēãĢįŊŽããã
ãå įãæŦæĨåãŽčϺ坿ĨčĒã§ãã
ããŦãã¯æ¸éĄããéĄãä¸ããåĒé ãĒæã¤ãã§åãåããæ¸éĄãį¨ãã§ããįŽããåĨŊåĨåŋãĢįĒãåãããããããĒįąãŽãããŖãįŧåˇŽãã¸å¤åãããããŽéãĢãåã¯éčĻäēé ãæ¸ãžãããã¨ãĢããã
ãããã¨ãããåãĢã¤ããĻįĸēčĒããããžããįĩĻäģããĄãé¨ãã§ããžããããäģæã卿ŋãĢåŊĢåãŽãããĒįžįˇåãčŖ¸ã¨ãããŗå§ŋã§įžãããã¨ã
ãå ãäŋããããĒãŦããŽčĻįˇãåããåã¯æēãæ¯äē¤ãããĢįļããã
ãåŋčĢããããĒåĨčĄãå įãäŊŋį¨äēēãĢãããã¨ã¯æããžãããåãå¯ãĻããéãĢã¨ãˇãĨãæãåēãããŽã§ããããå įã¯ããčϧãĢãĒããžããã§ãããīŧã
ããŦãã¯åŖå ãé ããæĨŊãããĢįŽãį´°ããã
ããããããŽæãŽåŊŧã¯ãâĻâĻããããåæãä¸ã¤ãč °ãĢåˇģããåĨåĻãĒæ ŧåĨŊã ãŖããããŠãč¸ãŋčãããããããŗãĢæãåˇŽãäŧ¸ãšãå§ŋã¯ãį§ãŽįĨãåŊŧã ãŖãããīŧã
ãįĩĻäģããĄãŽč¨ŧč¨ã¨éŖãéãŖãĻããã
ããŦããŽč¨ããį§ãŽįĨãåŊŧããæãį¤ēããĻãããŽã¯ãäģĨåãĢčãããįãŽéŦŖãæã¤æŧéģįŗãŽãããĒčãããå°åš´ãã ãããããšãĻãŽč¨ŧč¨ãįåŽãĒããčǰãŽįŽãããéãå§ŋãĢčĻããĻãããã¨ãĢãĒãã
ãåãĢčĻããĻãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽå¤§įˇãã¯ããããŽãžãžãŽã¨ãˇãĨãĒãŽãīŧãåēäŧãŖãåŊåãŽå
å
ĨčĻŗãåŧãããŖãĻãåšģčĻãčĻããããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããīŧ
ãâĻâĻããã§ããã
ãé ãéããããŽãĒãããããããäēé
ãŽä¸ã¤ã ãããŠããããã¨ãã§ããĒããåãå¯ãĻããéãŽã¨ãˇãĨãåčĒčēĢã§čĻŗæ¸Ŧã§ããĒãäģĨä¸ãåä¸äēēã§ãŽč§Ŗæã¯ä¸å¯čŊã ã
ãæŽæŽĩã¯ãįĄææŗã ãįĄåŽŗãĒ大įˇãã¨ããčĒčãĢåēåŽãããĻããããåãŽčĻįãæčããå¤ããéį̝ãĢãäŊãčĩˇãããŽãīŧ
ãããŽæããããåĻšãčĻã¤ããĻããããã¨ãæåž
ããĻãã䏿šã§ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽåįēãæããĻéãčžŧãããããæãčĄããĢäģģããįĩæããããã
ãåäžäēäēēãå¯ãĻããã ããŽé¨åąãĢãéããããŖãĻãããŽã¯éåąã ããããããĒčãã§åžåžããããŽã¯ãåčĒčēĢãŽåēåŽčĻŗåŋĩããįĨããĒããé ãŽįããĒã芹ã ã
ãâĻâĻãã¤ãĢãĒãæãæŠãã§ãããĒ襨æ ããåšŗéãåãįšããĒãããã§ã¯ãé°čŦæ¸ĻåˇģãéãŽåˇŖįĒã§čĻå´ããããīŧã
ããŦãã¯æĒ厧ãŋããããããĒ襨æ ã§åžŽįŦãã ã
ãæåžæĨãŽč°äŧãĢã¯ã貴æšã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãĢãåēå¸ããĻããããã
ãįĢãæ˛ããĻįĢčŦåēĢãŽä¸ã¸įĒãŖčžŧãã¨č¨ããŽãīŧ
ãį¨ãŋã¤ããããĒãįŽãéãããŦããĢčãåããĻãä¸åãåãŋãĒããæˇąãæ¯ãå¸ããã¨ãˇãĨãŽæ¨Ēã¸č
°æããã
ãæŖæ°ã§ããīŧã
ãčĻãäēēãĢããŖãĻå§ŋãå¤ãããĒããæĩæãæã¤č ãã¨ãˇãĨããæĒįŠãã¨čĻåŽããįŦéãããŽå ´ã§åŗåĻåãæąēåŽããããįĄčĢãéčĄã¯ä¸å¯čŊã ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯åŋ ãåæããããããĒãã°ãäģåãŽãããĒæį¸ãŽãŋãĢįãžããĒãã
ãæ¸åŋĩã¯įč§ŖããĻããããã§ããį§ãĢã¯į§įããããŽã
ã垎įŦãŋãæĩŽããšããŦãã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããåãŽåããå´ãŽæ¤ åãĢč °æããĻãããŗčļãåãã¨ãˇãĨãčĻä¸ãããã
ãä¸čēĢãåŽãžããĒããĒããå¤å´ããåēãããããĒããčǰãčĻãĻããããäģĨå¤ãŽäŊč ãĢãčĻããĒããããĒãč¨åˇããįēããããŽããããŖãĄã¸æĨãĻã
ãâæŦæŖãŽåãĢįĢãŖãåŊŧåĨŗããããã严æã§æŧãčžŧãã
ãããŖããã¨æŦãä¸ĻãšãããæŖãĢã¯ãäģæããé ãããĻããããããéŖãŽæŖãŽåĨĨčĄãåãžã§éŖãĒãåžéããããĢããã¨éŗãéŗ´ãéŋããããã¨äģåēĻã¯ãæŧãčžŧãã æŖãåŧãæ¸ãŽãããĢæ¨Ēã¸æģãããã
ãããŽåãããĢã¯åēãåį´įŠēéãããŖãã
ãåēļæ°ã§ã¯ä¸įãããŖãĻãįŽãĢã§ããĒãã§ãããčąĒč¯įĩĸįãĒčĄŖčŖ
é¨åąãåãããģãŠå§åˇģãŽå
æ¯ãč´
ãå°ŊããããããĒč˛ã¨ããŠããŽããŦãšãä¸Ļãã§ããã
ããããĢæããããĻããä¸ã¤ãåŊŧåĨŗãæãĢåããéģãį´ŗåŖĢæã ãŖããéĻå
ãįĩãããŋã¤ãå
¨čēĢãčĻããĢãããŖãŗã°ã
ãäžãã°ãããããããŽæãįãĻããéããčǰãŽįŽãĢããä¸ģãĢäģããåŋ åŽãĒåŊąãã¨ããæ ããĒããã
ãããŽäēæ ãæŗåŽããĻããĒããŖãåã¯ãååŋãĢå°ãŖãĻéģãčžŧãã ã
ãäģãĢã¯ãéĄãé ããååŧį¨ãŽįĨåŽæã¨ããå äģãå ¨čēĢį˛åãããŖãĄã¯ãĩããĢãŽæĄãã大æĨãã§į¨æããããããŠããã é ãã ãã§ã¯æåŗããĒããŽã
ãæąēįļã¨ããæ åēĻã§åŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããã
ãããŽæã¯ãåļåžĄããŽčąĄåž´ããč°äŧãŽéŖä¸ãæããĻãããŽã¯ãįč§Ŗä¸čŊãĒåå¨ãã¨ãå§åįįä¸å°ŊãĒæ´åããã§ããåˇäēã¯ãä¸ģãĢæåžããįæ§įãĒåå¨ãã ããããŽæãįãåŊŧã貴æšãŽåžããĢæ§ãããããã ãã§ãåŊŧãŽæįļąãæĄãŖãĻããã¨ããäēåŽãéåŧãĢčĒãããŽã
ãåã¯æčãåˇĄãããããįĨãåžããæ¨ŠéãæãŖãĻãããã¨čĒį¤ēãããããŽį大ãĒæŧåēãããã¯åŧˇįãĒå°čąĄãä¸ããããã ããã
ãæŗåããã ãã§å˛æ
ĸããĢåãæ°ããããããããäģŖæŋæĄãåēãããĢæšå¤ãããŽã¯įĄč˛Ŧäģģã ãåãŽäŋĄåŋĩãĢåããã
ãããĄããã貴æšãŽåããããã
ãæŦĄãĢåŊŧåĨŗãæãĢåãŖãããŽã¯ãčĨå ã芰ãžãŖãæˇąįˇãŽį¤ŧæã ãŖããåˇäēæã¨æ¯ãšãĻéåã¨å°ããã
ããã¨ãĢã¯ãįĨãŽčĒŋåžč ãã§ãããį§ãŽãæ¸č¨åŽããããŽįĢå ´ãĢį¸åŋããæ ŧåĨŊãããĻãããããã
ãåŖ°ã¯čãããĻãããŽãĢãæ
å ąãå
ĨãŖãĻããĒãã
ãčĒčēĢãčŊãĄįããããããĢæˇąãæ¯ãåããåæēãæãããåãĢãä¸čĒįļããæãããããå¤ąį¤ŧãŽãĒãåŊĸã§ãããŽå ´ãéĸããĒããã°ã
ãããŽãããĢããéŠåŊãĒé
įŽãä¸ã¤ã ãįĸēčĒããĻäŧ芹ãįĩããããã
ãæŋããŽæã¯ãããžããīŧããžã¨ããĒæãįãããã¨ããĒããŽã§ãæ
ŖããåãĢį ´ãããã§æããŽã§ããīŧã
ããīŧããããᎴįŋį¨ãŽäēåãĒã፿ã§ãããã大ä¸å¤Ģã
ãåã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽãããĢ፿ãããæãčĻã¤ããã
ãåˇäēãä¸ģãŽåŊąãããããįãæŽããããŽãæŖčŖ
ãã§ãããææčĄŖããĢãĒããŽããäŊã¨ãæĒčžŖã§įŽčãĒ芹ã ã
ãææĨã¯åŋãããĒããžãããããããå¤ąį¤ŧããžãã
ãããŖããäŧãã§ã
ãäŧ芹ãæãĄåãŖãĻåã¯æ¸æãåžãĢããã
ãč¸ãŽčžēãããããããã¨ãĻãį ããããĢãĒããæēãĢåããŖãĻæĨčĒãæ¸ãããå°ãã§ãæčãæ´įãããããĢã
18
ã9æĨįŽãŽæãéŖå ãĢã¯įŧãããĻãŽããŗãŽéĻãã¨å
ąãĢãåŧĩã芰ããįˇåŧĩæãæŧãŖãĻããã
ãå
¨åĄãå¸ãĢįãããŽãčĻãĻããŦãããĢãããįŊŽãã
ãäģæĨãŽäēåŽãįĸēčĒãããããžãã¯ãčĄŖčŖ åãããããŽåžãã¨ãˇãĨã¯įæŋããĻä¸åēãĢį§ģåãåäŊįĸēčĒãå ŧããĻįčĄŖįļæ ã§æ¨ĄæŦæĻãããĻãããããããŽéããã¨ãĢã¨į§ã¯æįĩįãĒįĸēčĒããããããããŽã¤ããã§ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æéĸããã¨ããŖãæ§åã§ãčĄåč¯ãããŗã丸åãŋããĻããã
ããããĢæĨãåŊåã¯ãéŖæãŽåããåŗãįĸēããããããã¤ãã¨ããŠãŧã¯ãŽäŊŋãæšãčåŗæˇąããĢčĻŗå¯ããĻãããã§ããæåã ãã ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨæŦäēēãéŖäēãåŋ
čĻã¨æããĻããĒããĒããįš°ãčŋãäģãåããããããŧããĢãããŧčŦįŋãĢéŖŊããĻããžããŽãäģæšããĒããįããéŖæãæ°ãĄããĨãŧãåēãæäģĨå¤ãããŽæéã¯ããŧãããããĻãããã¨ãåĸããĻããã
ããããããã¯åãåãããã ã¨ããã°åãŽãããīŧ
ãéŖã§ã¯åĻšããšãŧããéŖ˛ãã§ãããéĄč˛ã¯æĒããĒãããŽãŽããžã čĻįˇãčŊãĄįããĒããįŠéŗãĢã¯å¤§ãããĒååŋãããã
ãéŖåžãåĨ厤ãĢãĻčĄŖčŖ åãããčĄãããã
ãæ¸æãŽæŦæŖãĢé ãããčĄŖčŖ é¨åąã§ãįĩĸįčąĒč¯ãĒããŦãšãä¸Ļãļå æ¯ãčĻãåĻšãæ¯ãåãã
ãâĻâĻãããã
ãåŽįŗįŽąãã˛ãŖããčŋãããããĒč˛åŊŠãŽæ´Ēæ°´ãåãĢãåš´į¸åŋãŽčŧããæģãŖãã
ãéŠããīŧãäģãããĢã¯į¨æã§ããĒããããŠããĻãŠãĄãããŽåãåžã§ä¸įˇãĢé¸ãŗãžããããã
ãåĻšã¯čããĻãããŽãããĒããŽããããŦãšãčĻããŽãĢå¤ĸä¸ãĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ãããŽéãĢ፿ããããŽã¯ãããŽæŧéģãŽåˇäēæã ãéĻå ãᎠãããŋã¤ãæéĻãžã§čĻãæčĸãčēĢäŊãŽãŠã¤ãŗãĢæ˛ŋãããäģįĢãĻãããããšãã¨ä¸įãįĄæ°ãŽįĩãŗįŽã
ãįæŋããįĩããã¨ãˇãĨããä¸åŋĢãããĢčĨå
ãåŧããåŧˇåēãĒåæãŽå¸å°ã¨įšį´°ãĒį¸ĢčŖŊãĢããᎠãäģããįĩãŗįŽãŽéå°ããäŊč¨ãĢææčĄŖãæŗčĩˇãããã
ãå°ãåãžã§č
°å¸ä¸æã ãŖãįˇãĢã¯ãįåŋå°ãĒãŠčããžã§ããĒãã ããã
ãããŽåãåšæã¯åįã ãŖããéæ§åŗãå°ãčžŧããããåˇåžšã§éãŽãĒããåˇäēããåŽæãããæã¨ããįŠįįãĒæ ããčįãæäŊãžã§ã᝿ŖããĻããããã ããšãŧããã¨ãšããŧãŗã丸åãŋããĻããåĨ´ã¨åä¸äēēįŠã ã¨ã¯å°åēäŋĄãéŖãã
ãã¨ãĻãį´ æĩããčĄŖčŖ ã§ã¯ãĒãããåˇäēãã¨ããåŊšå˛ãįããŽãããŽæãįãĻããéã貴æšã¯åŊąã§ãããåŖã§ãããã
ããŦãã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãĢåŖ°ããããããããĻãæ¸č¨åŽãŽæãĢįæŋããåãŽæšã¸åãį´ãã
ããã¨ãĢã¯ãŠãīŧãæ°ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻããããããīŧã
ãã¨ãĢãããŖãããã
ãå°ããĒåŖ°ã§åĻšãåãã
ãåĨäēēãĢå¤č˛ããã¨ãˇãĨãčĻããŽã¯æ°éŽŽã§ãææ
¨æˇąããããããããŽåŋåĸãäģäēēãĢčŠąãæ°ãĢã¯ãĒããĒããŖãã
ãããŽåžãåŊæĨį¨ãŽæãŽä¸įã¯į´°ããĒ垎čĒŋæ´ãŽãããĢãčŖį¸Ģãåžæã¨ããåĨŗæ§ãĢč¨ããããčĻčĻããŽãĒãåš´é ã ãŖããããŦããŽå¤ãéĻ´æãŋãĒãŽã ããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯įŊãˇãŖãã¨ããšãããšãŠãã¯ãšã¨ããå§ŋãĢãĒãŖãã
ãããžãæčãããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖããããĢãããĒããæãĢčēĢãå
ãã¨ãč
ã¨čãį°æ§ãĢéˇããåæ´ãåããĻãããã¨ãĢæšããĻæ°äģããããã
ãæ¨ĄæŦæĻãŽį¸æãåãããŽã¯ãĩããĢã ãŖããåˇĻč ãč˛ åˇããĻäēæĨã¨įĩãŖãĻããĒããŽãĢãæŦäēēã叿ãããããã
ãããŽåžãŽįĩéã¯čããĻãžããīŧã
ãããŠãšããä¸åēãčĻä¸ãããŦããĢå°ãããåĻšã¯åãŽåžããĢé ããæĩãŽééããčĻãčžŧãã§ããã
ãããŽåžããã°ããįąã¨įēãã¨įãŋãããŖããŋãããã§ããéŖæŦ˛ã¯ãã¤ãäģĨä¸ããåŽéãĢããããå§ãããããŠããéãŖãčēĢäŊãåŠãčĩˇãããĢã¯ä¸åēĻããããŖãĻã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã᏿ãĢæēåéåã¨ã¯âĻâĻã
ãããã¯ããã¨ããĻãã¨ãˇãĨãŽæ˛ģįãåããåžãĢéŖæŦ˛ãåĸããŽã¯ãåãĢãčēĢãĢčĻããããã
ãå§ãīŧã
ãæ¨åŖãæĄããåããåãŖãäēäēēãĢãäŊŋį¨äēēãåˇäģ¤ãããããããŽåŖ°ã¯ã¯ã¯ãŽéåš´ã ãä¸åēãĢįĢã¤åŊŧãŽįŽã¯ãäēäēēãŽåããĢéäģããĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯įĄčĄ¨æ
ãŽãžãžããĩããĢãŽå
åļæģæã¨æĩãããããĒéŖæãčēąãããåéĄã¯ãããŽåžã ã
ãæĩãæ´ãã§ã¯å¤§ããæ¯ãä¸ããĻåŠãäģããåäģģããĢæãéŖã°ãããããĒåããããã°ããŠããĒãĢéĢ䞥ãĒįå°ãčä¸ãčŠå¨ãããä¸įŦã§åŧĩãčŖããĻããžãã
ãå¤ãĒįˇåŧĩæãæąããĒããåã¯éģãŖãĻčĻåŽãŖãã
ãâčĻŗæĻãĒããããĻãåãĢã¯æĻčĄãŽįĩé¨ããĒããããã§ããã¨ãˇãĨããĩããĢãŽåããįäŧŧãĻãæĨéãĢå¸åããĻãããã¨ã¯įč§Ŗã§ããã
ãæãŽå¯ååéįã¨įš°ãčŋããããĩããĢãŽãˇã´ãã§ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽåããå¤åããĻãããįĄé§ãĒ大æ¯ããæļããæäŊéãŽæ¯ãã§įĸēåŽãĒ䏿ãįãã
ãæĩãããããĒäŊæãã§ãĩããĢãŽæãĢå
ĨããæĨæãįãåããčĻãããã¨æãã°ããã¤ãŠãã§čĻãããįĨããĒãæåããĩããĢãŽéĻįã¸æ¯ãä¸ããã
ã寸æĸãã ãŖãã
ã䏿ãããã°æčãŽãŋãĒãããåŊãžã§åãåããããĒéåēĻã ãäŊæ ŧãĢæĩãžããĻããã ããŽį´ äēēããčĻæ§čĻįäŧŧã§ãããŽã¯æ§ããĻãģããã
ããŦãã¯åšŗæ°ãĒãŽã ãããīŧãäēæ ãčĩˇããĻããã¨ãˇãĨãĒãæ˛ģããã¨äŋĄããĻãããŽãīŧ
ãæŋããéŧåã¨æ¯čĻãããæããĻãããŽã¯åã ãã§ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æąä¸ã¤ãããĻããĒãã
ãããããäģŖčŦæŠčŊãéããŽã ãããããŽæļŧããéĄããåˇäēã¨ããĻãŽãåŽį§ãããããéįĢãããĻããã寞ãããĩããĢã¯į¸å¤ããããŽä¸æŠåĢéĄã ã
ãåēäŧãŖãé ã¯åˇ¨äēēã¨åŧãļãšãæĒįŠãĢčĻããĻããããįŠįįãĢäŋ¯į°ããã°ãåšŗåįãĒčēĢéˇãŽãĩããĢãããå°ãéĢãã¨ããã ããææãĢããčĒčãŽæĒãŋããæ ãĢåãããåŊąéŋãâĻâĻã
ãį´ æ´ãããããéæžåŗãĒæ´åãæ´įˇ´ãããæĻčĄãĢãĒãŖãĻããããããĒããčǰãŽåãĢåēããĻãæĨãããããĒãããã
ãããŠãšããčēĢãäšãåēãããŦããæåãŽæ¯ãæŧãããã
ãâæ¨ĄæŦæĻãįĩããã¨ãåˇäģ¤ããããĻããäŊŋį¨äēēãŽéåš´ããĩããĢãĢæŠãŋå¯ãŖãã
ãããŽâĻâĻãĩããĢæ§īŧãäģãŽåããäŋēãĢãčĻããããžããīŧã
ãįĄčŦããããæĄãŽåŽããĩããĢã¯éŧģãéŗ´ãããã
ãããã䏿ä¸å¤ã§įŋåžã§ããã¨æããĒãããŖã¨įčãäģããã芹ã¯ããããã ã
ãã¯ãã¯ããŖīŧã
ãįŠãåã§æåĻéåš´ãĒå¤čĻãããĻããåŊŧã¯ãåŦããããĢåēãŽæé¤į¨å ˇãåããĢčĩ°ãŖããããŽåä¸åŋã¨ãããį¨ããããĒįŽã¤ããåããããĻãåããĒãčåãéããããã
ãåã¯ããŠãšããé¨åąãŽä¸ã¸æģãŖããåŖãŽåãããã芹ãåŖ°ãčãããĻãããåĻšãŽåŖ°ã ã
ããããĒãĢįļēéēãĒãŦãŧãšãåããĻčĻãžããã
ããĩãĩãæ°ãĢå
ĨãŖãīŧãããã¯å°ä¸ã§æĩéããĻããįļŋãã
ãčĻãčžŧãã¨ãããŧããĢãĢåēããããč˛éŽŽãããĒãĒããŗãįŽãčŧãããåĻšãŽįŦéĄããããčĻåŽããŦããŽå§ŋãããŖãã
ãå æĨãŽææãĒãŠåŋããããŽãããĢįŦãŖãĻãããåãĢæ°ãĨããåĻšãé§ãå¯ãŖãĻããã
ãã¨ãĢããŦãå
įãããäģåēĻãį§ãĢãæ°ãããæ´æã፿ããĻããããŖãĻīŧã
ãããã¯č¯ããŖãããĻãŠã ãäģ˛éå¤ãã§ã¯åãåŋčĻãããããã
ãåĻšãŽé ãæĢã§ãåãčĻãĻããŦããæĒæ¯ãŖãŊããĻãŖãŗã¯ããã
ãåĨŗãŽåãĢã¯ãããĄãã¨å¤ĸãåŋ čĻãĒãŽãįžåŗãããįļēéēã坿ããéčĻãīŧã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯å ã ãæŋæ˛ģįãĒæįŽã ãã§ãĒããããããį´°ãããĒæ°éŖããã§ããäēēã ãããŖã¨åããįĨãŖãĻããã¯ããĒãŽãĢããããĒä¸éĸãäš ããļããĢčĻãã
ãåĻšãŽįŦéĄãčĻãĻããã¨ãč¸ãŽåĨĨãå°ãã ãčģŊããĒããããã¨åæãĢãåãæŽããããããĒæčĻãčĨ˛ãããããã¯ãäŊŋåŊæã¨åŧã°ããåēåŽæĻåŋĩã
ãįŦéĄãå¤ąãããĒããããĢãåŽããĒããã°ãĒããĒããããŽãããĢã¯äŊãããšããâĻâĻã
ãå
įãå°ãããæéãããã ããžããīŧã
ãæ§ããĒãããã
ããŦãã¯įãããĒãæ§ããĻããįĩĻäģãĢåĻšãŽį¸æãäģģããé¨åąãį§ģåããã
ãååä¸ã¯ããĒãå´ŠãįãĢæēåãé˛ãã§ããžãŖãããäģæĨä¸ãĢæįĩįãĒææčĄ¨į¤ēãããĻãããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã
ãæ¸æãŽæĨåŽĸį¨ããŧããĢãĢã¯ãå°åŗã¨é§ãåēããããĻãããåˇåæēãĢã¯ãč°äŧã§čĒãŋä¸ããåŖ°ææãæ¨æ˛ããĻãããããį补ãčĻãããã
ãå įãã¨ãˇãĨãĢæãįããåŋ čĻæ§ã¯åãįč§ŖããĻããžããã§ãããäģŽãĢããįĨãŽäžäģŖãã¨åŧã°ããåå¨ãĢåŦäŊŋããŽæ ŧåĨŊããããĻã¯ã䏿Ŧã ã¨é¨ãããžãããīŧã
ãåãčĻããŦããŽįŗãĢįåŖãĒå ãåŽŋãŖãã
ããã¨ãĢãããŽæã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãč˛ļããããã§ã¯ãĒãã貴æšãåŽããããĢé¸ãã ãŽãã
ãåĢããĒč¨čã ã貴æšãŽãããããŽä¸č¨ã§čĻæåŋãåŧˇãžãã
ã大äēēããĄããčĻãã°ã貴æšã¯ãåļįļãĢãįĨãæžãŖãã ããŽåäžãã ããã§ããåˇäēæãįēãŖãåŊŧã貴æšãĢãŽãŋå ãããããŠãčĻãããããīŧã
ãããã¯é
ˇãåŋå°ãæĒããã ãå°ããĒč¯čãåãŧãå̿ǿããæĨ常ãĢå¤ããã°æŦĄįŦŦãĢčãããã¤ãã¯æ
ŖããĻããžããčåžŗãŽåŋéŋãéæĒãĒåŋĢæĨŊã¸čĻãã°æåžãįžįļãžã§ããčĻãã
ãåã¯č¨čã¨å
ąãĢãå
ã
ã§čĩˇããåžãäēæãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ã
ããæĒįŠãåžããããããå¯ä¸ãŽæ¯é č ããããčĒčããããŽãã
ããŦãã¯æãæãŖãĻæ°ããã
ãįĨåŽæãįããã°äŋåŽæ´žããįĨæŽŋãĢįĨããšããã¨é¨ããé§ãįããã°éŠæ°æ´žããããŖã¨åšįįãĒæ´ģį¨ãį įŠļããšããã¨é¨ãããã ãããåĨ´ããéģããããĢã¯ããã¨ãĢåäēēãŽåŖã§ãããã¨åŽŖč¨ãããããĒãã
ãâ
ãæŋæ˛ģįãĒãįŦŦ䏿ĨĩããäŊããããŽæŧåēãããŽįåąã¯į´ äēēãĢãįč§Ŗã§ããĒãã¯ãĒãã
ãæˇąãæ¯ãåããæå¤§ãŽæ¸åŋĩãåŖãĢããã
ãéåšæãĢãĒããžãããīŧãã¨ãˇãĨãåļåžĄã§ããå¯ä¸ãŽãä¸ģãã¨åŧˇčĒŋããã°ãåãįãããžããäēēčŗĒãåãŖãã¨ããã§ãã¨ãˇãĨãčĒįąãĢã§ããã¨ãæããžãããã
ãį¨ŽæãŽįšæ§ã¨ããĻãįæ§ã¨įĨæ§ãéãããã¨ã¯č¨ããæŦ˛ãĢįŽãįŠãžããč ãããĒãããã§ã¯ãĒããåŽéãčĨ˛æãåããã°ããã ã
ãããŽåąéēã¯ãããã
ããŦãã¯ãããŖããã¨čĒãããåčĢãŽéãįŊŽãããĢįļããã
ããããĒæãĢããåˇäēããĒãéŊåãč¯ããŽãčĻåã§ã帯åŖããå ĩåŖĢãčˇčĄã¯č°äēå ãŽäŧå ´å ãĢå ĨããĒããå ĨãåŖã§ãŽåž æŠãåŊããããããįĨåŽãĒãå°į¨ãŽå¸ã¸ãã§ãããåžč ãã¯äžå¤ã
ãåãŽčåžãĢåãčžŧãŋãčŗå ã§åããã
ãåˇäēã ãã貴æšãŽįåžããæãŽåąãčˇéĸãĢįĢã¤ãã¨ã訹ããããæåŧˇãŽįžããŧãčˇéĸãĢãããããäģĨä¸ãŽåŽå ¨įããããããīŧã
ãåŽæã¨čģäēãŽå𞿏ã莺ãé¤ãããã¤įŠįįãĒčĻčˇãŠã¤ãŗãåãŽččēĢãĢãžã§åŧãå¯ãããããŽæéŠč§ŖããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãããŽæ°æĨéã§åŧžãåēããåŋ čĻãĒéå ˇãæããĻãããŽã ã
ãč¨ŧæããã°č¯ããŽãã貴æšããåŊåŽļã¨åŊéãå ąãĢããåŋčãã ã¨ãããã¨ããįæ§įãĒæãåčãĒããįĄįããåĨĒãããĒããĻčããĒããâĻâĻãããįæ§ãŽãĒãčŧŠãæĨãæã¯ãã¨ãˇãĨã¨ãĩããĢãĢæé¤ããĻããããžããã
ããŦããįŦããåã¯æˇąãæ¯ãåããæšããĻčå°čĄŖčŖ ãčĻãã
ãæŋįĨããžãããææĨã¯å įãæ¨ãåˇäēæã§åããããžãããã
ãæēčļŗããĢé ˇããŦããčĻãĻãåã¯įļããã
ãããã¨ããæ å ąįĩąåļããŽįĸēčĒããããĻãã ããã
ãåĒããĻåˇéãĢäēåįãĒåŖčĒŋãäŋã¤ã
ãå ãä¸ã¤įŽããčĒčãĢããåŊĸįļå¤åããŽäģļãå ŦåŧãĒå ąåæ¸ããåé¤ããããŽã§ãããčŗåããĻãã ãããžããīŧã
ãč°äŧãŽčäēēããĄãĢįĨãããã°ããįĨãŽåĨ补ãã ãŽãåšģæãŽæĒéãã ãŽã¨é¨ãįĢãĻããããäēäēēã§åŖčŖãåãããæ¸éĄãæšįĢããããããįŽĄįč˛Ŧäģģč ã¨ããĻæåįã ã
ãããããä¸įĸēããĒæ
å ąãåé¤ãããŽã¯ãį§ãčŗæãã
ãã§ã¯ãäēã¤įŽãã¨ãˇãĨãŽãåįčŊåãã¤ããĻããåé¤ãæ¨ãããã§ãã
ãåãĢįŦãŋãæŽãããžãžããŦããŽįŧå ãéããĒãã
ããåįãã¨ãæ˛ģįčŊåããé ããŽãčŗæãäēããæãã ãã ããŽããæĻéåãã¯é ããĒããããŠãææĸåãĢæ´ģããã°č¯ãããããã¨åãããĻå Ŧ襨ããšãã¯ãåĒããæ´å¯åãæ´ģãããåąæŠå¯įĨčŊåãããīŧã
ãäģč ãŽåŋãčãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčĒåŋčĄãĢéĸããĻã¯ãæĨčĒãĢč¨é˛ããĻããĒãããã§ãĢåŊŧåĨŗãåäģããĻããäēåŽã§ããäģĨä¸ãæ¸ããžã§ããĒãã¨å¤æãããããããåĒããæ´å¯åããã
ããããã¨ãããããžããã¨ãˇãĨãĢã¯æĒæãããĻãæ˛ģãããææ ĸããããč¨ãåĢããĻãããžãããã
ãäŊæĻãŽæĻãåããã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãĢäģģããĻãč¯ãããã ã
ãæåžãĢä¸ã¤ãæã፿ããĻããã ããĻæį¸Žã§ãããåã¯čžéãããĻãã ããã
ãåã§ããåŋ čĻã¯ãĒããããããæŋæ˛ģãĢįãåãåå¸ããã°äŊč¨ãĒåąéēãåĸããããããĒãåã¯čŖæšãĢåžšãããšãã ã
ãåã§ã¯ä¸éŠäģģã§ããč°äŧã¯ååŽļãŽäēēéã ããå
Ĩããčåã§ãããīŧãåã¯ä¸åą¤ãŽåŽļåēäēēã§ãããčãŽč˛ã ãŖãĻâĻâĻã
ããžãéãããŽãããã¨ãĢã
ãåˇåžšãĒåŖ°ãįĒãåēããŖããå į¨ãžã§ãŽæåãĒįŦãŋãæļããįåŖãĒ襨æ ã§åãčĻæŽããĻããã
ãčãŽč˛ã¯åéĄãĢãĒããĒãããããŽåŊãĢãããĻãįĨčˇč ã¯äžå¤ãĒãčãįŊããŽãããŽčŗæ ŧãåžãã ãã§ãįĨčãæããĒã貴æšã§ããäŋåŽæ´žã¯ãįĨãŽæåŋããįĄčĻã§ããĒãã
ãåããĻčŗãĢããæ å ąã ããæ§ããåčĢãįļããã
ãåãĢã¯æŧæãĒããĻã§ããžããããããŋãĒãåŋ čĻãĒå ´ã§ãčļŗãåŧãŖåŧĩãå¯čŊæ§ããããžãã
ãįä¸ã¤åããã ãã§åŊåããĢãĒãããåãããĒãããŦããĒããã¨ãˇãĨãåļåžĄããĒããã§ã䏿ãįĢãĄåããã¯ãã ã
ããããä¸ã¤ãŽæŖč§Ŗã ããã§ããį§ãĢã¯åŽįžãããããã¨ãããéãããŽããåŊæ°ãŽįĒŽįļãæããããæ´žéĨãæãčžŧãŋãããį ´æģ ã¸åããæĒæĨãå¤ãããããããĒæŦ˛æã¨įŽįã§æēĸããĻããã
ãããč¨ããĒããããŧããĢãĢåēããããå°åŗãä¸įĨããã
ãåŧˇãéĄæãĢåŊãĻãããåŊŧã¯ããŠããĒå¤č˛ãéãããããīŧã
ãčĒ垿°åŗãĢįŦãåŊŧåĨŗãåãŽč¸å ãĢæãåŊãĻããåŋčãŽéŧåãįĸēããããããĢåŧˇãã
ã貴æšã¯ãããããžãžãčĻãĻãåŊŧãįč§Ŗãããã¨ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽįŗããåĨĨåēãžã§čĻéãããããĢåãå°æãã
ãįšåĨãĒčŊåãįŦå ãããã¨ãããæŦ˛ãããĒããŽã§ãããīŧãã ããããįŦãåãããĒį ´æģ ãĢãææ¸ãĢãåžåããĒãč ãã¨ããĻéĄįžãããâĻâĻåŊŧã貴æšãŽåãĢįžããįįąãããããĢããã¯ãã ãã
ãåãæąēããĻįĄæŦ˛ãĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒãã
ãä¸åš¸ãéãĒããåŋãŽåēããįĩļæããĻãäŊãäŋĄããããĒããĒãŖãĻãããé¨ããããã¨ãæããå¤ąããã¨ãæããããšãĻãææžããã¨ããĻããæãå˛įŦãããŽãããĢįžããå§åįãĒåã
ãã ãããããåŧãå¯ãåããããĢåēäŧããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ææã¨įĩļæãæ¯ãæãį ´åŖčŖ
įŊŽã¨ãĒãæãĻããĢæ¸ãã īŧ
ãåŊŧåĨŗãæŗåããĻããããĒįžããåēäŧãã§ã¯ãĒããčĒæ´čĒæŖãĢãĒãŖãåã¯éåŊãåĒããåŊãŽæģ
äēĄããæãã§ããã§ã¯ãĒããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åˇåæēãåãčžŧãŋãåãŽæŖéĸãĢįĢãŖãã
ããã¨ãĢã貴æšãããĻããããã¨ã¯ãåĨ补ã¨åŧãã§ãč¯ããģãŠãŽåš¸éã ãŖãã¨æããã
ããŠããĒãĢį莝æ´įļã¨ããčĒŦåžããããããŽããŖãä¸č¨ã§åčĢããææãæģãæļããĻãããŽãæããã
ãč¯åŽãããæ°ããããŽã ãä¸åēĻã¯æ¨ãĻããã¨ãããŽãĢãããŽä¸įãĢåå¨ãããã¨ã訹ããããããĒåŋå°ã
ãåĻšãä¸äēēãĢããĒãã¨į´æããžããã
ãåąæˇã¯äŋĄé ŧã§ããč
ãĢčĻčˇããããã
ãäēēåã§åããžããã
ãä¸ģåŊšã¯į§ããã¨ãĢã¯į
§æäŋããã į§ãčĻãĻããĻãããã ãã§č¯ããŽã
ãäģäēēãŽčĻįˇãæããĻå ĒããĒããããã§ããåããããããĒããŽãĒãã
ã大ããæ¯ãå¸ããéããĢåãåēãã
ãâĻâĻåãããžããã
ãâãããããŦãã¯ããã¤ããŽč¯ãããĒįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ããããããŽææ°ããææĨã¯åŋãããĒããã
ãäŊæĻãŽæĻãåããã¯åŽäēããããã¨ã¯ãããŽæąēåŽãåĻšãĢäŧããĻããåŋ čĻãããã
ãæ¸æãåēãĻčĒ厤ãĢæģãã¨ãæ¯å¸ãĢãããžãŖãåĻšã坿¯ãįĢãĻãĻãããåŖéã§č
ãįĩãã§äŊãŋãå¯éĄãčĻåŽãŖãĻããã¨ãˇãĨããčĻįˇãåãĢå¯čļãã
ãåãŽįĨããįĄææŗãĒ大įˇããĢæģãŖãĻãããããŽãã¨ãĢåŽå ĩãã¤ã¤ãåĻšãŽčŠãæēããŖãã
ããĻãŠã
ãåŧãŗãããĒããčŠãåĒããæēããļãã Â
ãâĻâĻã¨ãĢīŧã
ãåĻšã¯éãįŧãæĻããĒããä¸äŊãčĩˇããããåãŽčĄ¨æ ãčĻãĻå¯ãããŽããį æ°ãææ ĸããĻåą äŊãžããæŖãã
ã大äēãĒ芹ãããã
ãåã¯åĻšãŽįŽãįãŖį´ããĢčĻãã
ãææĨãåŊãŽåãäēēãéãžãŖãĻ芹ãåããã ããŦãå
įãåå ãããããã§ãåã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãĢãæĨãĻãģãããŖãĻã
ãã¨ãĢãčĄããĒãį§ãčĄãīŧã
ãåãŽč ãĢãããŋã¤ãã芹ãéŽãŖããä¸åŽãĢæēããįŗãåãįšãæĸãããã¨ãããåã¯åĻšãŽæãĢč§ĻããčĢããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ããĻãŠã¯čĄããĒããč°äŧãĢã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãåŋĢãæããĒãäēēããããããããåĢãĒįŽã§į¨ãã§ããããæéŗ´ãŖãããã¤ã¸ãéŖã°ã大äēēãããã¨æãã
ãåĢīŧããåąæˇãĢã ãŖãĻæãäēēããĄãæĨãīŧããããåŽå
¨ãããĒãīŧã
ãåĻšãŽč¨ãéãã ãčĻåĄãŽãããĒåąæˇã§ããåŽå
¨ã¨ã¯č¨ãåããĒããããã§ãé°æšŋãĒæŦ˛æãæĒæãĢæãããããã¯ãããŖã¨ããˇã ã
ãåąæˇãĢã¯å°ããã¤æãĄč§ŖããĻããįĩĻäģãããããŦããčĻčˇãããã¨č¨ãŖãĻããã
ãã¨ãĢã¨ä¸įˇããããįŊŽããĻãããĒãã§īŧã
ãããŽįŽãã大į˛ãŽæļãæēĸããåĻšã¯åŖ°ãä¸ããĻæŗŖããã
ããžãįŊŽãåģããĢãããã¨æãŖããŽã ãããåäžãããäģĨä¸ããŠããĒč¨čãč¨ã荺ãĢãããĒããĒããåã¯äŊãč¨ããããã éããčä¸ãæĢã§įļããã
ãâãã°ããããĻåĻšãŽååŊãæĸãã ãčĸã§æļãæãã¨ãįãŖčĩ¤ãĢãĒãŖãįŽã§åãčĻãã
ãâĻâĻį§ãåž ãŖãĻããã¨ãĢãæ¯æĨæ¸ããĻããæĨčĒããããæåēããĢčĄããã§ããīŧãååãæ¸ããį´ãããããããããŽå࿎ãŽįããĒã¨åŽļæãĢãĒããŽããīŧã
ãåããåããĻåã¯é ˇãã
ãåãã¯æŖåŧãĒé¤åã¨ããĻãããŽåąæˇã§æŽãããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãä¸įˇīŧã
ãâĻâĻãããĒãã¨æãã
ãåãŽåžããĢé ããĻã°ããããåĻšãäģäēãããã¨č¨ãåēããæãéŠããããããŠãįĨããĒãéãĢåĻšãæéˇããĻãããŽãã
ãį´æããĻãå¤éŖãŽæ¯åēĻãããĻåž
ãŖãĻããããåŋ
ã帰ãŖãĻæĨãĻã
ãå¤éŖīŧã
ãããīŧãææĨãŽå¤ã¯ãã¨ãĢãŽåĨŊįŠãčąãŽãšãŧããäŊããŽãį§ãæäŧãããæ¸ŠããããĄãĢ帰ãŖãĻãã
ãå°ããĒæãåãŖãĻãåŧˇãæĄãčŋããã
ããããŖããį´æããã
ãåĻšãŽč¨čãč¸ãŽåĨĨæˇąããĢéŋããã帰ããšãå ´æããããåž ãŖãĻããĻãããäēēããããããŽå¤§åããå°ãã ãįč§Ŗã§ããæ°ãããã
ãåŖéãĢįĢã¤ã¨ãˇãĨããįĄč¨ãŽãžãžįŧãéããã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãĢåēäŧãŖãé ãŽåã¯ãåŊãŽčĻåãĢįåã¨åĢæĒæãæąããĻãããã ããããŠããĒæĸææĻåŋĩããã莺ãé¤ããäŊč˛ãĢãæãžãåžãĒãã¨æãããå§ŋã§ã¨ãˇãĨã¯įžããã
ãããã ã¨ããã°ãæŦæĨãŽå§ŋãčĻããĢã¯ããŠãããã°ããīŧ
ã
19
ãč°äŧåŊæĨãŽæãéŖå ãĢã¯ããšãŧãããæŧãéĻčã¨éŗĨčãŽéĻãã¨å ąãĢãåŧĩã芰ããįˇåŧĩæãæŧãŖãĻããã
ãåĸååŗãŽæįĩįĸēčĒãããĻããããã
ããŦãããĢãããįŊŽãã
ãäŋåŽæ´žãį§ãĢé ãä¸ãããĒããŽã¯ãåãĢãč¨ãŖãéããã夿ŗã§č˛ãå¤ąãŖãįŊčã¯įĨãĢé¸ã°ããč¨ŧãâĻâĻį´°ããčĒŦæã¯įããããŠãčǰã§ãč¯ãããã§ã¯ãĒããŽã
ãåãŽéĄãįãŖį´ããĢčĻãããįĨãŽå¤æŗããĢč§ĻããåŊąéŋã§ãįæĨãŽč˛ã¨åšŧå°æãŽįĢåˇčˇĄãå¤ąãŖãį°æ§ãĒč˛ãŽčãã
ããããĻãéŠæ°æ´žãåŊŧãã¯å°ä¸ãŽäēēéã¨ä礿ãããĻãããããŠãå°ä¸ãĢã¯ãéģãæĒéããŽäŧæŋããããŽããå įĨæ§ããĄãæ´žæãĢæ´ãããŽããã§ããį§ã¯äžå¤ã
ãæããããããĢįŽãį´°ããã
ãåããã§ã¯ãæãŽåĨŗįĨãããįŊéãŽå§ĢããĒããĻåŧã°ããĻããããåæãĢįĨæ ŧåããĻæãéŖããŖãĻãæįŠãįŠįŠãéļå¨ãŽč´ãįŠãžã§ããããŽãã
ããĩããĢãį¨ãŋãåšãããæ¨Ēã§ããŦããåĨŗįĨãŽãããĢ垎įŦããããããŖãĻå°ä¸ãŽį°į¨ŽæããĄã᏿åããå°ä¸ã§ããįįŖã§ããĒãéŖæãå åˇĨåã§ããå ã
ã¨ä礿¸ããå§ŋãããžãã§įŽãĢæĩŽããļããã ã
ãįžč˛ã¨ããæĻå¨ãĢå ããĻã芹čĄã§åĨŊæãåãĄåžãĻåŊãå¯ãžããããããžã§ããã°ããã¯ãåĨŗįãŽå¤äē¤ã ã
ããããã§åŊãŽéŖįŗ§äēæ ã¯å°ãæšåãããããäŊåš´ãįļããå ãĢããä¸č䏿ģãŽį§čŦãæãŖãĻãããã ãŽããéæ§ãŽåĨŗįãæããããã ãŽãŖãĻãįäž¯č˛´æãå¯čąĒãæ¸čŗéãæ¸ãããããĢãĒãŖãĄããŖããããŠâĻâĻã
ã芹ããĒããæĒæ¯ãŖãŊãčŠãįĢĻããã
ããžããæåãĢãĒãéããäģŖåãã
ãæčŋãŽåēæĨäēã¨åãæčĻã§æ°ååš´åãŽčŠąããããåæį¸æãĒãéį¨ããããäēååš´ãããã°čããį°į¨Žæã᏿ã§ã¯ããå¤ãããŦįžč˛ãã¯æ§ããéãčļããĻææãŽå¯žčąĄã ããã
ãå°ä¸ã§ã¯ãįĨãŽåˇĢåĨŗããå°ä¸ã§ã¯ãä¸čãŽåĨŗįĨããäēã¤ãŽéĄãäŊŋãåããĒãããåŊå å¤ã§ä¸įĢãč˛ĢãéãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãäŊæŗãĒãŽã ããīŧã
ããŦãã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãĢåãį´ããæãĢæ
Ŗããããã¨ããčŠĻãŋãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯äēåãŽãˇãŖãã¨ãšãŠãã¯ãšãįãå§ŋã§ãåããĻčĻãå°ä¸įįŠãŽčãį¨ãŋã¤ããĻããã
ãããŽæ°ããįŠåĨŊãã¯ãåãŽåŊąéŋã ãããīŧ
ãã ããããå垊čŊåãã¯įĩļ寞ãĢčĻããĒããã¨ãčãã¸ãŽææãĢį¨Žæã¯éĸäŋãĒããŽããæ°¸é ãŽåŊããĢįšããå¯čŊæ§ãå ãã¤ããã°ãäŋåŽæ´žãéŠæ°æ´žãæå ãĢã¨čĨ˛ãŖãĻãããã
ã芹ããããããĻãæŽæŽĩãĒãå
¨ãæãĢäģããĒãã¨ãˇãĨããįĒįļåŊãå§ããã
ããããåãŽåŊąéŋã ãããīŧãäģæã¯æ¸ŠãããšãŧããŽåŗãåãããĒãããįŧãããĻããŗãčããããĩããĩããĻããĻåãĢåŧãŖãããã
ãéŖåžãåēįēãŽæēåãæ´ããã
ãčĨãŽčаãžãŖãį¤ŧæãĢčĸãéãåãŽæ¨Ēã§ãã¨ãˇãĨã¯æãåããĒããåˇäēæãĢįæŋããã
ãå¤åĨã¯įŊŽããĻčĄããĒãããįšãåŋ
čĻããããŽã ããã
ãįččŗĒãĒäŊčē¯ãéåæãĒãįļēéēãĢåãžããįĻæŦ˛įãĒįžãããįēãŖãĻããã鎎ãããĒčĩ¤ã῝ã ãããéģä¸č˛ãŽčŖ
ããŽä¸ã§é
ˇãéįĢãŖãĻããã
ããŦããåž ã¤éãåã¯ä¸åēã¸åããŖãããžã įčˇĄã¯æŽãŖãĻããããæŠããŽå ´ã ãįēå ãããŗãåĨ补įãĒ垊æ´ģãéããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããããããč¨ããéããĒããããŋããŋã¨čģŊãčļŗéŗãčãã¤ããĻæ¯ãčŋãã
ãčĻã¤ããīŧã
ãé§ãå¯ãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãæˇąãéč˛ãŽãĒããŗãæĄãŖãåĻšã ãŖãã
ãããŽããéĢĒãããŽãžãžã ã¨ããéĄãčĻããĒãããã
ãįĒå įĢãĄãããĻã¨ãˇãĨãŽčä¸ã¸æãäŧ¸ã°ãåĻšãã¨ãˇãĨã¯å°éĸãĢčãã¤ããĒãããå¨į¨ãĢåąãã ã
ããããã¨ããããŖã¨ããĻãĻãã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãŽčãĢåãčžŧãã¨ãčĩ¤éĢĒãä¸å¯§ãĢææĢã§æĸŗãããįĄé äŊãĢåēããŖãĻããéŦŖīŧããĻããŋīŧãä¸ã¤ãĢæããããĻãããããĒããŽäŊãäŊįŊŽã§éĢĒããžã¨ãããĒããŗã§ããŖããã¨įĩãã ã
ãâĻâĻã§ããīŧã
ãæēčļŗããĒåŖ°ãä¸ããåĻšã¯æ°æŠéĸããã
ãæŧéģãŽåˇäēæãŽčä¸ãããŽä¸ãĢãéĢį´ãĒæ¯ã°ãããŽãããĢããĒãĨãŧã æãŽããčĩ¤éĢĒããéãŽãĒããŗã§įããããĻããããˇãã¯ãĒčŖ
ããŽä¸ãããã ãåĻãĢæ¸Šããŋãæããã
ãåįãĢå¤åãããŽã¯ãįæŖéĸãããŽčĻãįŽã ãåéĢĒãŽä¸é¨ãæŽããĻæŊãæĢã§äģãããããã¨ã§ãå
ãŽå°ãŖãčŗãŽčŧĒéã¨į˛žæãĒéĄįĢãĄãé˛ããĢãĒãŖããå¤Ēįãįãäš
ããļããĢčĻãæ°ãããã
ãįĄäēãĢ帰ãŖãĻæĨãĻãã
ãåĻšãĒããĢčããããåŽãããĒãŽã ãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯ãĒããŗãĢč§ĻããĒããžãžįĢãĄä¸ããŖãã
ãããŖãĄã¯ãã¨ãĢãŽããįĩãļããããŖã¨ããĻã
ãįļããĻåĻšã¯ãæ¸č¨åŽæãĢåãããįˇãŽãĒããŗãåãåēããæããã¯ãããĒããã¨ãˇãĨã¨åãéĢĒåŊĸãĢããããéĢĒčŗĒãéˇããéããããé°å˛æ°ã¯åĨįŠãĢčĻããã¯ãã ã
ãäēäēēã¨ããã¨ãĻãäŧŧåãŖãĻãããã
ãįŊéãŽããŦãšãįããŦããįŦãŋãæĩŽããšãĻããã
ãįéĸãåēãã¨ãčĻããã¨ããĒãäšãįŠãåž
æŠããĻããã
ãå¤ĒãįãåčĸãĢãå¸į¤ãŽãããĒæãæã¤åˇ¨å¤§ãĒįŦčĢéĄãå°åēčĨč´īŧããŗããĢãŠãŗããŧīŧããåŧããåąæ šäģããŽããŖãĒãã¸ã ã
ãåžĄč å°ãŽäēēįŠããå¨å˛ãĢæ§ããĻãã大äēēããĄãããĩããĢã¨åãåļæãįãĻãããææŽãåˇãŖãĻããåĨŗæ§ããŦããĢåãį´ããæŦį¤ŧããã
ããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸæ§ãčˇčĄįãé įŊŽåŽäēããĻãããžãã
ãįãåãæããããįŊéĢĒã¨æåŋãŽåŧˇãããĒįŽå
ãč
°ãĢã¯éŖžãæ°ãŽãĒãį´°åŖã帯ãŗãĻããã
ããŦããŽåžãĢįļãåã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãĢã¯å¤č¸ãŋãããããĒčĻįˇãåããčģŊãäŧéããããæåžãĢãĩããĢãį¨ãã
ãééˇããčēĢäŊãŽå
ˇåã¯âĻâĻīŧã
ããã ãŽå¯ä¸čļŗã ãããŽäģļãįäģãããããžã¨ãžãŖãäŧæĨãįŗčĢãããäŊåēĻãč¨ããããĒã
ããéĄããį˛å´ãæļãããžã§ã¯ãäŊåēĻã§ãé˛č¨ããžãã
ãčĸĢãããããĢč¨čãéŽãããį ŠããããĢéŧģãéŗ´ããããĻããããŽåĨŗæ§ã¯æļŧããéĄã§åãæĩããã
ããĩããĢãé¨ä¸ã¯å¤§åãĢãĒããã
ããŦããã¯ãšã¯ãšã¨įŦããĒãããããŖãĒãã¸ãĢäšãčžŧããåãæˇąåŧå¸ãããĻäšãčžŧãã ãããŽåžãåˇäēå§ŋãŽã¨ãˇãĨãįļããčģãéŗãįĢãĻãĻæãéããããã
ãčæãčģå
ãčģčŧĒãåãå§ããããŽæēããæããĒããåããĄã¯č°äŧå ´ã¸åēįēããã
ãįĒãŽå¤ãæĩããæ¯č˛ãčĻã¤ããĒãããåã¯éĻå
ãŽãĒããŗãĢč§ĻãããåĻšãŽéĄããčžŧããããå°ããĒãåŽãã
ããã¨ãĢãčˇčēĢį¨ãŽæĻå¨ã¯č°å ´ãĢæãĄčžŧããĒããŽãæãŽããã¯åžã§ãĩããĢãĢé ããĻãããĒãããããŽäģŖãããããã貸ããĻããããč¸ããąãããĢå ĨããĻįŊŽããĻã
ããŦããåãåēããããŽã¯ãčŖ éŖžãæŊãããéãŽéįã ãŖããčĻãįŽãĢåããĻčŗĒéãããã
ããããĒéĄããĒãã§ãäŊŋããã¨æããĒããĻč¯ããŽãåé¤ããŽãåŽããã
ãâ
ãå°åēčĨč´īŧããŗããĢãŠãŗããŧīŧãŽããŖãĒãã¸ãĢæēãããåããĄã¯å°åēä¸įãŽæä¸åą¤ãå˛Šį¤ãæãåãåēįģã¸å°įãããããã¯įĨå ãæåãĢåŽäŊããčåã¨ãåŧãšãå ´æãããã
ã夊įļãŽįŠēæ´ãĢé ãããč°äēå ãŽå¤čĻŗãčĻããã¨ã¯åļããĒããŖããã厍大ãĒįŗé ããŽæãŽä¸ĄčãĢã¯ãæ§ãæãŖãčĄå
ĩããĄãæ§ããĻããã
ãå¤ĒãįŗæąãįĢãĄä¸Ļãļ厍大įŠēéã§ãįēå
čãįĩ¨æ¯¯ãŽãããĢįž¤įããĻãč¸ãŋå¤ããæãĢã ãčļŗéŗãåéŋãããæąã¨åŖéĸãŽåŊĢåģã夊įļįŗãĒãŠãŽčŖ
éŖžããéčŦãĒį°åŊŠãæžãŖãĻããã
ããĩããĢįããčˇčĄįã¯äŧč°åޤãŽå ĨãåŖã§åããããããããå ã¯ãæĻåã§ã¯ãĒããč¨čã¨æŦēįãéŖãŗäē¤ãæĻå ´ã ã
ãį§ãįēč¨ã訹ããžã§ã¯åŖãéãããĻãčĄåč¯ãčŋŊåžãããã¨ãč¯ãããīŧã
ãåã¯é ˇããčåžãĢįĢã¤åˇäēãæ¯ãčŋããããŖããã¨įŦãããåžã§ãčĻã¤ãčŋããããâĻâĻäēēããããįäŧŧãã¨ãˇãĨãĒããŽæŧæã ã
ãéåãĒæãåģããããĒéŗãįĢãĻãĻéããããåŖãĢä¸Ļãã éįŊãįēé
ĩčãŠãŗããŽæˇĄãå
ãčĻįãĢéŖãŗčžŧãã§ããã
ããŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšåŽļãŽįžåŊä¸ģããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸãģãĒãĢãģãŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšæ§ããå°įãããžããã
ã鎎ãããĒįˇã¨įŊãåēčĒŋã¨ããéŖžãįžŊæ šãŽæãåēããčŋˇããŽãĒãčļŗåãã§é˛ããŦããããŽčä¸ãåã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãčŋŊãã
ãâã
ãč°å ´ã¯ååŊĸãŽããéĸįļãĢãĒãŖãĻããããã§ãĢæ°ååãŽå¤§äēēããĄãįå¸ããĻããã
ãåŗæãĢã¯ãæŗčĄŖãĢčēĢãå
ãäŋåŽæ´žãŽåžįļč
ã¨å´čŋã
ãåˇĻæãĢã¯ãå ´éããĒãģãŠč¯įžãĒæãįēãéŠæ°æ´žãŽäģŖčĄ¨č
ãåäēēãį įŠļč
ãæãããčēĢãĒããŽč
ãå¤ãã
ãåŊŧããŽčĻįˇã䏿ãĢå
Ĩå ´č
ã¸įĒãåēãããæĩæãŽæˇˇããŖãčĻįˇãåãã¤ã¤ããŦãã¯æ įļã¨ä¸å¤Žã¸é˛ãã ã
ãč°å ´ãŽææˇąé¨ãååãå˛ããããĢéŽåē§ããĻãããŽã¯åååŽļãŽåŊä¸ģã§ãããįžå¨ãŽæéĢéŊĸč
ããĄã ãæŗčĄŖãĢčēĢãå
ãå
äēēãčĻãįŦéãæĒå¯ãčĩ°ãŖãã
ãââįããĻãããŽãīŧ
ããããįŦŦä¸å°čąĄã ãåŊŧããŽčã¯éąįŗãŽãããĢįĄŦčŗĒã§ãčĄãéãŖãĻããæ°é
ããĒãããŦãŠãšįãŽãããĢæŋãŖãįŗãčįŠēãčĻã¤ããĻããã
ãéˇãæãįããæãĻãĢãčäŊãįĄæŠįŠã¸å¤čŗĒããĻããéį¨ãĢããč
ãäŋåŽæ´žãŽééŽããéˇčäŧããŽčŗĸäēēããĄã ã
ãâĻâĻé ããããŦã´ãĄããĒãĸã
ãįēå éąįŗãåãčžŧãžããååãŽåããã§ãéˇčãŽįˇãåŖãéãããč šãŽåēããéŋããããĒéäŊéŗãåēããã
ãæããåž
ãããã¨ã¯ãį¸å¤ããã䏿ŦãĒå¨ããã
ããåž
ããããĻįŗã荺ãããžãããčēĢæ¯åēĻãĢæéåããžããĻã
ãæĒãŗããæ§åããĒãåĒé
ãĢ垎įŦãŋããŦãã¯ååãĢæŽãããĻããįŠēå¸ãĢåē§ãã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽæãåžããæ¸č¨åŽį¨ãĢ፿ãããå°ããĒæēã¸åããã¨ãįŽįĢããĒããããĢæ¯ãæŊãããæ¤
åãŽįåžããĢã¨ãˇãĨãįĢã¤ã
ããŦãŠãšįãŽãããĒįŗãã¨ãˇãĨã¸åããããããŦããŽåŗéŖãĢåē§ãéãããĒčŗéŖžããŽåĨŗæ§ããčåŗæˇąããĢįŽãį´°ããã
ãâĻâĻãģããæ˛å
ĩããŽå ąåã¯čããĻããããããã¨ã¯éåã¨čļŖãį°ãĒããããããĒã
ãåžĄäŊŋãæ§ãĢä¸åãŽæãįããã¨ã¯ããŠãããŖãčļŖåãīŧãčŋįãŽæŦĄįŦŦã§ã¯âĻâĻã
ãåž
ããããæããå¤ããããģããĢããããĒã
ãåŊŧããŽčĒčãĢãããĻãæ¸č¨åŽãŽåã¯åå¨ããĒããåįļãŽãäģåąåããŽããã ãčĻįˇã¯ã¨ãˇãĨãŽãŋãĢæŗ¨ãããĻããã
ãããĻããŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšãŽå¨ããããŽãäžäģŖããåĨį´ããã¨ãããĒããæŽåãĒåŋæããč¤ããĻéŖãããã
ãéˇčãŽä¸äēēãå¤č¸ãŋãããããĢč¨ãŖãããŦãã¯įžŊæ šæãéããåŖå ãé ãã
ããåčĢããããŽåēĻã¯ãæææ¨ŠãŽįĸēčĒãĢč¨ĒãããŽã§ãã
ãéãžãčŋãŖãč°å ´ãĢåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŖ°ãéŋãã
ãåŊŧãį§ãŽåžįļč čĻįŋããŽåŽčˇč ã¨ããĻãčĒããĻé ããããŽã§ãã
ãåžįļč
čĻįŋããåãĒããããŽå ´ããŽããã§ã¯ãĒãã ããã
ãããŽįŊčã¯ãįĨæããåžãč¨ŧãįžåãããŽã¯ãåã¨ãŦããŽäēäēēã ãã
ããããžã§ãŽæ
å ąãįåŽãĒããäŋåŽæ´žã¯åãåžįļč
ã¨čĒããããåžãĒãããããĻãæå°ãäģģãããããŽã¯ãŦããŽãŋãčĻãããĢãããŽå ´ãåãæããĻãããããåĻåŋãĒãåŊŧåĨŗãŽå°äŊãįļããããã
ããŦããŽå¯ŋåŊãå°ŊããåãĢįļãã°č¯ããĒããįžåš´åžãäēįžåš´åžãžã§ãĢ寞įãčŦããĻãããã
ãéˇčããĄãŽįĄæŠčŗĒãĒéĄãĢããããå ĨããããĒæããŽææ ãčĩ°ãã
ãâĻâĻæ¯č¨īŧãããã¨īŧãã
ãåˇĻéŖãŽäēįĒįŽãŽéˇčãæēãæå ã§åŠããããĢããŗã¨įĄŦãéŗãéŋãã
ãåäēēãŽį§æįŠãĢãĒãŠãã§ããéįããĒãã
ãįļãäšãããčŗæ ŧãã¯åžãĻãããããããåžįļč
ãčĻã¤ããã¨ã¯åŽãĢåã°ããã
ãåĻäŊãĢãããåã¨ããã补įļãããããããĢãåŊãåēãĻåąéēãĒéãŗã°ãããčŠãŽčˇãä¸ããåŋå°ããããã
ãéãčĻįˇãåããĻåãĢåãããããéå§ãäŧ´ããããĒįŧåˇŽããĢãåŋčãæŠéãæãĄãåãåŧĩãäģãã
ããĩããããĒīŧã
ãéŠæ°æ´žãŽå¸ããä¸äēēãŽįˇãįĢãĄä¸ããŖããįŽãŽé˛å ˇãčēĢãĢįããéãįŽãããĻãããčĻãįŽããå¯ãããĢãč°äŧãĢåå ãããšãæĻčŖ č§Ŗé¤ãĢåŋãå Ĩ厤ããæĻéæ´žã¨æãããã
ããįĨéããããæãããæĨãé¨ä¸ãŽä¸åãå°ä¸čŋˇåŽŽã¸åããŖããžãžæļæ¯ãįĩļãŖãĻããīŧã貴æ§ããéŖŧãŖãĻããæĒįŠãŽäģæĨã§ã¯ãĒããŽãīŧīŧã
ãįŗžåŧžãŽåŖ°ãéŋãã
ãåã¯čĄ¨æ
ãåããããã¨ãˇãĨãĢééããæĨãŽãã¨ãæãčŋãããã¨ãˇãĨãĢæģæãäģæããä¸åã¯ãæ
ã厚čĩĻãŽãĒãåæãåããĻåŊãčŊã¨ããã
ãįåŽãčĒããã°ãåŗåģåĻåã¸åžãæããããã
ãããã¯ããæ°ãŽæ¯ã§ãããâĻâĻããããæĒįģé˛ãŽåéãĢčŋˇãčžŧãŋãå´ŠčŊãĢåˇģãčžŧãžãã§ããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããĻīŧã
ããŦããåˇããããĒåŖ°ã§åããã
ã貴æ§ãäŊããŦããŦãã¨âĻâĻã
ãæ°æĨåãæãæˇå°ãĢäžĩå
ĨãããčŗããŽåŽåĻãæããĒããč°äŧãŽåžãžã§åž
ãŖãĻããã ãããã§ãããéå
ŦåŧãŽæĻčŖ
éåŖãĒãŠãåŊčģãĢįĒãåēãã°åŗåģãįĸįéãã§ããŽãīŧã
ããããŗã¨įĄŦčŗĒãĒéŗãéŋããããŦããįžŊæ šæãéããã
ãįˇã¯č¨čã芰ãžãããæãããĢåē§ãčžŧãã
ãããĻãæŦéĄãĢæģããžãããã
ãâåŊŧåĨŗãŽæãŽä¸ã§įŋģãããč¯ãããĒæããĩããĩãã¨ããéŖžãįžŊæ šãŽä¸ãĢãįŊéãŽåˇéãä¸įŦã ãį ããã
ãéˇčæ§æšã¯äģ°ããžããããããåäēēãŽį§æįŠãĢã¯ã§ããĒããã¨ãâĻâĻã§ã¯ããčãããžããäŋåŽæ´žãįŽĄįãããã¨ãéŠæ°æ´žã¯į´åžããã§ããããīŧã
ãäģåēĻã¯éŠæ°æ´žãŽå¸ãä¸įĨããã
ãéãįļããéŠæ°æ´žãĢå§ããã°ãéˇčæ§æšã¯åæļã ã¨įããåŽŖæĻå¸åãããŽã§ã¯īŧã
ãåĻčļãĒ垎įŦãŋãæĩŽããšãã
ãããããĢããĻãå æĻã¯éŋãããããæĢ莝ãĢã¯å ąåãããĒãã°ããŠãĄããĢãåąããĒããä¸įĢãŽå¨ãã¸é ãããŽããæãåįįã§ã¯ãããžãããīŧã
ãéãžãčŋãŖãč°å ´ã§ãéˇčããĄãŽįŗãåã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãčĻåŽããéŠæ°æ´žãŽäģŖčĄ¨č ããĄã¯åŖã ãĢãŠãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĢįã¯åŽį§ã ãåæšãã¨ãˇãĨãŽæææ¨ŠãæŦ˛ããæĩåĸåãĢæ¸Ąããã¨ãäŊãããæããĻãããŽãĒããįŦŦä¸č
ãĢããįŽĄįã¯įãŋåãããæŦĄåãŽįãã¨ããĻæŠčŊããã
ãäēēéããææ
ãã¨ããéåįãĒããŽãæãĄåãããĻããããĒããã°ã
ãâĻâĻįåąã¯åããã
ãååãŽåãããŽéˇčãéã ããé ˇãããããŽæŋãŖãįŗãåˇåžšãĒå ã帯ãŗãã
ãįļããŠãåäžãĢåžĄãããŽãīŧããįĨéãããã¯åŊãŽå¤§äēãåäžãŽéãŗį¸æãããĻããäŊčŖãĒãŠãããŦãã
ãéˇčãŽčĻįˇããéŠæ°æ´žãŽå¸ãĢåē§ãæĻéæ´žãŽįˇã¸åãããããå į¨ã¨ã¯åĨãŽįˇãæåŖ°ãä¸ããã
ãčŠåŧã īŧã
ãããŧããŽãããĒããŽãįēãŖãåĻč éĸ¨ãŽįˇã ã
ãčĒãããīŧãããŽãŦããåˇäēãããŠãã貴æ§ã፿ããååĄīŧããã¤īŧã ããīŧīŧã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻãįˇã¯æŠåŖã§čŠ åąãå§ããã
ãããŽæč¨ãåã¯įĨãŖãĻããããã¤ãĻåãã¨ãˇãĨãĢåããĻčĄäŊŋãããŽã¨åããå¯žčąĄč
ãŽįŊĒãŽéããĢåŋããåšģįãä¸ãããį
įãŽįãã
ãåã¯æããč °ãæĩŽãããããŦããĢčĻįˇãéãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įžŊæ šæã§åŖå ãé ããĻåˇããããĒįŽã§įˇãįēããæĸããĻãĒãŽãåãčĻãĒããč°å ´ã¸å ĨãåãŽįēč¨ãčŗčŖãéããã
ãå
ããĒ叿ãč¨ããĻéŠæ°æ´žãŽå¸ãčĻãããčŽåãčĢããč
ã¯ãĒããåã¯åŊŧãŽčēĢãĢčĩˇããåžãéĄæĢãåãå
ĨããĻįŽãéãããčŠ åąãįĩãããéįŊãįãŽæ¸Ļãæžãããã
ãčǰããæ˛éģããä¸ã县°ãåãŽčēĢäŊãããæããããŽčåžã§åŧžãããįã¯ãįĢãŽį˛ãæŖãããĒããčĄč
ã¸čãæģãã
ããĒããĒãã ã¨âĻâĻīŧīŧã
ãįãĢå ãžããčĄč ãæ˛įãĒåĢãŗåŖ°ãä¸ãããčįãå¯ããĒãŖãã¨ããã¸ãæ°ˇãå˛ãããããĒåˇåžšãĒéŗãéŋãã
ãââéį˛ãĢã
ãįãã¨čĄč ãæŦãäŧãããŽã¯ãį°éč˛ãŽéĢĒãæã¤éˇčēĢãŽįˇã ãŖãã
ãéãįã¯įĩļãĄæļããčĄč
ã¯ããŽå ´ãĢå´Šæããã
ãããŽä¸įŦåžãååãĢåē§ãéˇčãŽįæ¨Ēã¸æŠãŋåēããŽã¯ãį°éč˛ãŽéĢĒãããŖãĄãã¨ä¸åŋã§åããåˇĻåŗå¯žį§°ãŽååŧæãįãįˇã ãæˇĄãéč˛ãŽįŗåãåããĄãčĻä¸ããã
ãč°å ´å ¨äŊãŽįŠēæ°ãåãã¤ããéˇčããĄã§ããæŦæãæããããĢåą äŊãžããæŖããã
ããģããĢæ§ãâĻâĻããŽæ¨ŠčŊã§ãįč´ãčĻæĨĩããã ããã
ãéˇčãåŧãŗãããã¨ãįˇã¯ææãŽãĒãåŖ°ã§įãåŋãããæŦĄãŽįŦéãåŊŧãŽå§ŋãããŦãã
ãåãŽįŽãĢã¯ãããŽååēĻããčĒčã§ããĒããŖããčˇéĸã¨ããæĻåŋĩããæãĄåããããĒįĨéãŽč¸ãŋčžŧãŋãæ¨ĒčããĢæ¯ãããéč˛ãŽéå
ããåãŽåå
ã¸čŋĢããåŊãŽåąæŠãįč§Ŗã§ããĻãããŽãĢãæãŽä¸æŦããåããĒãã
ããã¯ãįžčąĄã¨ã§ãåŧãļãšãæŦæã
ãéãéåąéŗãéŋããčĄææŗĸãåãŽåéĢĒãæēããã
ãįŽãéããã¨ãéģãčä¸ãããŖããåãŽåã§ã¨ãˇãĨãéˇåŖãåãæĸããĻããã
ãâĻâĻãģããæãæįŊĒãŽåãįãã¨ãã§é˛ããã
ããģããĢã¨åŧã°ããįˇã¯čĄ¨æ
ãå¤ãããĢåãããã¨ãˇãĨã¯äŊãįããããããåããĒãã
ãįãã¨ãīŧ
ãåã¯č¸ããąãããįĸēčĒããããŦãããé ããŖãĻããéįããĒãã
ãâĻâĻãžããĢåžĄæĨããã
ããģããĢæ§ãŽåŖãé˛ãã¨ã¯ã
ãéˇčããĄãåŖã ãĢæåã¨į§°čŗãéããéæŋæ´žãŽéŖä¸ã¯åŖãéãããžãžéãžãčŋãŖãã
ãčåŗãå¤ąãŖããããĢčĻįˇãå¤ããåŖãéãĢį´ãããã¨ãˇãĨãŽį°čŗĒããčĻæĨĩããįŗããäģåēĻã¯åãčĻæŽããã
ãããŽįŗã¯ãéĄãčĻãĻãĒãŠããĒããŖããåãäģãžã§ãĢį¯ããįŊĒãå°ããĒįãŋãåãæąããæĒæãéãŽåąĨæ´ãžã§ãčĻéãããããĢįĩļ寞įãĒãæįŊĒããŽæ°é
ããŠããžã§ãéãåˇåžšãĒčĻįˇã
ãįŊĒãŽčããããŦã
ãåŊŧã¯į´įĢããåŗããĢåããã
ãč¨é˛ã¯čĻããããæĸãĢįŧãæĩããããĻãããåãäšąãæ§åãįĄããäģãĢéŠäģģãåą ããžããæ ãæĨããĒãåŊˇåž¨ãããĻããããã¯č¯ãã
ãâå¨å˛ãčĻæ¸ĄããéŧģæãĄãĒããĒãã¨ã°ãããĢéĄã饰ãããéˇčããĄãŽéĄč˛ãå¤ããŖãã
ãäŋåŽæ´žãįĩļ寞įãĒäŋĄé ŧãįŊŽããåĻåäēēãã§ãããããåŊŧããã¨ãˇãĨãŽæã¤æéãå
ŦčĄãĢčĻãã¤ããĻãåãŽæŊįŊãčĒãããŽã ã
ãâĻâĻã¸ã´ãããåã¯ãŠãčĻãīŧã
ãéãžãčŋãč°å ´ãããã¸äģåēĻã¯éŠæ°æ´žå´ãŽå¸ãããé´ãčģĸãããããĒåŖ°ãæŧããã
ããīŧãč¨ãŖãã§ããīŧã
ãåäēēããĄãŽééããįžãããŽã¯ããąãŧããĢčēĢãå ãå°æãĒäēēåŊąã ãŖãã
ãåž
ãŖãĻãã¸ã´ãĄããã
ãã¸ã´æ§ãéããĢīŧãåąéēã§ãã
ãåäēēãčĢããããããŽäēēįŠã¯æããååãŽæ¨ĒãéãéããåãŽåãĢæŠãŋå¯ãŖããččļã¨éãŽæˇˇããŖãéĢĒãæēããįˇč˛ãŽįŗåãį ããããĒãããįŠãããĒåŖ°ã§åããããĻããã
ãããŽåãããããããĒãããĒīŧããįžå¨ããæãžããĻãããĒããĻãčǰãĢã§ãã§ãããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒãããããã
ãããŽåã¯åãčĻã¤ããĻãå°éĻãåžããã
ãããããååã¯īŧã
ãâãžãã§čŋˇåãŽåäžãĢå°ãããããĒæ°čģŊãã ã
ãååãįĨããĒãã¯ãããĒããããã§ãå°ãããŽã¯ãåãŽåŖããčããã¨ããäēæŋãŽč¨ŧã¨čããããã ãããã
ããã¨ãĢâĻâĻãããããã¯ããŧã´ã§ãĢã§ãã
ãæ°ãĨããæãĢã¯čĻĒããä¸ããããååãĢįããĻããã
ãã¯ããŧã´ã§ãĢãããååã ããæį§°ã¯ã¨ãĢããĒīŧã
ãããč¨ãŖãĻåŦããããĢ垎įŦãã ãååãåŧã°ããã ããĒãŽãĢ䏿č°ãĒčĻĒčŋæãæš§ãããžãã§æ§åãĢ芹ãããããããããĒæ¸Šããã
ããããããåžãĒããããŽįŗãĢčĻã¤ããããåˇĻåŗã§č˛ãéãŖãĻčĻããįŗåãčĻŗå¯ããéãæįĩļã¨ãã鏿čĸãé ããæļãå¤ąããĻããã
ãčĻæåŋãåŧˇåļįãĢč§Ŗé¤ããããããããĒã
ãã¨ãĢãŽæĒæĨãĢã¯ãįĄæ°ãŽåå˛ãčĻãããį ´æģ ããįšæ ããéå¯ããâĻâĻã ããŠãã
ãäģåēĻã¯ãããŽįŗã§ã¨ãˇãĨãčĻã¤ããã
ãä¸įˇãĒãææĒãŽįĩæĢã¯åéŋã§ãããããīŧãããį¸ã¯įĩã°ããĻããããŽã
ãéŠæ°æ´žãŽå¸ãĢåãį´ããå ããå ´æã¸é§ãä¸ããŖãĻčĄãã
ãäšąæ´ã¯ããĄã ããį¸ãéåããĄããã
ãâįĄįĨčĢč ãŽéãžãã§ããã¯ããŽéŠæ°æ´žããįĨč¨ãåããäŋĄč ãŽãããĢéãåãæĸããé åãããčĄæ°įããĒæšéŠæ´žãŽéæŋæ´žãžã§ãããčĻæļãŽčĄ¨æ ã§åŖãéããã
ãįŊéĢĒã¨éģčãį´
ãįŗåãæã¤åæã ããå
Ĩ厤ã訹å¯ãããč°å ´ã¸ãåįĒãĢįžããäēäēēã
ããŠãĄããį°æ§ãĒåå¨æãæžãŖãĻããããã¸ã´ã¯čãŽč˛ãæˇĄããé Ŧãæå
ãĢčĩ¤ãŋãčĻãããéčŋã§čĻããģããĢã¯ãåčã¨åŧã°ããåš´éŊĸãŽį°į¨ŽæįšæãŽãˇã¯ãéĄãĢåģãã§ããã
ãéãžãčŋãŖãč°å ´ã§ããŦããåãĄčĒãŖããããĢįžŊæ šæãåēããã
ãâĻâĻãĩãĩããŠããããä¸Ąæ´žãŽãåãæãããĄããį§ãŽčĻč§Ŗãæ¯æããĻãããããã§ããããéåģãčĻéãããæįŊĒč ããå¨ãŽį´ čŗĒãčĒããæĒæĨãčĻããå°ãæããå ąåãæ¯æãããããäģĨä¸ãŽč¨ŧæãåŋ čĻã§ããīŧã
ãååŠãįĸēäŋĄããįŦãŋã§ãåįļã¨ãã大äēēããĄãčĻæ¸Ąãã
ãâĻâĻãģããĢæ§ãŽäģ°ãã¨ããã°įãããããĒãã
ãéãæ˛éģãŽåžãéˇčãįŗæąãŽãããĒæããĢããŗã¨æãĄéŗ´ãããåããã
ããŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšãŽå¨ãéŖããĻæĨããäžäģŖããŽįŽĄįã¯ããŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšåŽļãĢä¸äģģããããã ããåŽæįãĒå ąåã¨įŖčĻãŽåãå
ĨããæŦ ãããŦãã¨ãč¯ããĒīŧã
ãį°č°ãĒãã
ãéŠæ°æ´žãŽäģŖčĄ¨ããã¸ã´ãĢčĸãåŧããããããĢããĻé ˇããã
ãæ
å ąéãĢįŠæãčĻããĒãããčåžãŽåˇäēãĢčĻįˇãéããã¨ãˇãĨã¯éįãåãŽč¸ããąãããĢæģããäŊäēããĒããŖããããĢäŊãã§ããã
ãéč˛ãĢčŧãéįãŽčģ¸ãĢã¯ãæŦæãåãæĸããį补ãããããŽãäŊãæŽãŖãĻããĒãã
ãčŗéŖžããŽéˇčãããĄããæ¯ãčŋããä¸å¯žãŽæŋãŖãįŧįã䏿°åŗãĢå ãã
ããįĨæããįļãč ããæ¸ ãæŖããäŋŽčĄãĢåąãŋãį˛žé˛ããã
ãåã¯éããčãæããé ãä¸ããã
ãããããĻåããĄã¯æå¤§ãŽåąæŠãäšãčļããįĨãããįãĒįļąæ¸Ąãã§ååŠãåžããŽã ãŖãã
ãâæ¯æ¯ãŽãããĒååŠãéĻãŽįŽä¸æã§įšããŖãįžįļįļæãåŊãįšãã ãŽã¯åã§ã¯ãĒããããŽåŊã ã
20
ãįŖčĻäŊåļãŽčŠŗį´°ã¨å ąåįžŠåãĢã¤ããĻãŽééããĒãããč°äŧã¯č§ŖæŖã¨ãĒãŖãã
ãæŠã ãĢæ¤åããéŠæ°æ´žãããŽåžã§ãéˇčããĄã¯æ¤ åãã¨éã°ããĻčĄãŖããããŽå§ŋã¯ä¸č䏿ģãčŋŊãæąããæããŽæãĻãããããã¯âĻâĻã
ããį˛ãæ§ããã¨ãĢãå ã ã¨ããįĢãĄæ¯ãčãã ãŖãããã
ããŦããå´ããããĢåŖ°ããããĻããããįŽčãĢããčãããĒããåã¯äŊãããĒããã¨ã鏿ããã ãã ã
ãč°å ´ãåēãåžãé¤åį¸įĩãŽæįļããčĄããããæĄå
ãåããĒããåĨ厤ã¸į§ģåãããįŊ˛åæ¸ãŋãŽæ¸éĄãæåēããã ãã§ãčēĢå
ãŽįĸēčĒããĒãåŽäēããã
ãããã§ååŽã¨ããĢãåã¨åĻšã¯ãŠã´ãĄãŗãąãšåŽļãŽäŋčˇä¸ãĢå
ĨããããžããĢæŦĄæåŊä¸ģåčŖã¨ããčŠæ¸ããžã§čč˛ ããããã
ãé¨åąãåēããã¨ããæã ã
ãå Ĩããã
ãäŊãäšžããåŖ°ã¨å ąãĢãį°éč˛ãŽéĢĒãæēãããģããĢãæããå ĨãŖãĻæĨããįļããĻãčģŊãčļŗåãã§ã¸ã´ãįžããã
ãįģé˛į¨ãŽåãåŋ čĻã ã
ãåŖãĢčãåããĻįĢã¤ã¨ãˇãĨãįĄæŠčŗĒãĒįŗã§čĻããããģããĢãåŽŖč¨ããããŦããå°ãå°æãããããĢįãå¯ããã
ãæåēčŗæãčĒãã ããäģãŽåã§ã¯éããåã¯äŊã襨ããå¨ãæšãį¸ãįĨįĻã§ããåĒãã ã
ããįĢį¨Žãã¯įãåēããŖãĻãæĨįĢãã¸ã¨å¤ããããīŧã
ãéŖã§ã¸ã´ãåŧžããããĒåŖ°ã§äģãå ããã
ãåãåŧãŗįļããã°ãæĻåŋĩãéåŊãåēåŽããããį§ãčãããã¨ããããžããããŠãčŋˇäŋĄã§ã¯īŧã
ãåãããããŽã¯ãŦãã ãåãįĨį￝ããčãããã¨ããããæ éãĢæĨãæšãæ¸ŦãŖãĻããæ§åãŽãŦããĢãį´įĢä¸åãŽãģããĢãä¸įĨãčŋãã
ãäēēãįļããįĨãįļãã ã大ããĒãåãæã¤åå¨ãĒãã°ãåŊąéŋã¯åŗãįĨããŦã
ãã ããããã¯ããčãããããããããŠãã¯ãŠãĢâĻâĻãŠããããīŧã
ãæããåããããã¸ã´ãŽæ¨Ēã§ããģããĢã䏿ãŽį´ãåēãããææŦãŽãããĢįļēéēãĒå¤äģŖæåã ãæ¸åēĢã§čĒãŋãããŖãæ´å˛æ¸ãŽč¨æļãããįžäģŖčĒ荺ããæåŗãæĸããįĸēããâĻâĻåéŋãéĄãåŖ°ã
ãã¨ãˇãĨãčĻããããčĻįˇãčŋãã ãã ãŖãã
ãããŽããææĄããã ããäģĨå¤ãŽååã§ãæ§ããžãããīŧã
ãį§ŠåēãäšąããŦãĒãã°ã
ãį´ããåãããĻãâĻâĻīŧã
ãåããĒãåŗåē§ãĢåˇŽãåēãããį´ãåãåãã¨ãäēåæēãŽä¸ãĢåēããæ´ãŖãæåãŽä¸ãĢéįã§æ¸ãåēããã
ãâĻâĻãĸãŧãēã¤ã¨ãŗããŧīŧããéãŽå¤§įžãæãã¯ãåããæĻå¨ãâĻâĻãããīŧã
ããŦããæ¨Ēããč§ŖčĒããĻ䏿č°ãããĢåããčĻä¸ããã¨ããģããĢã¯įŧãéãããĻããã
ããé ä¸ãĒ厍æ¨ãģæąãģ大å°ãã¨ãįŧãģæŗãã¨ãäģãģįĨããã ãĒãâĻâĻįžå¨īŧããžīŧãčĻŗæ¸Ŧããæąãã¨ãčĒãããâĻâĻã
ãæŗåŽäģĨä¸ãĢįčããĻãããģããĢãåãĢãããããžããĒãåŋå°ãĢãĒãŖãã
ãåãæ¸ãããŽã¯ããįĨãŽå¤æŗããŽæ§į§°ãå
ãŽåēåããæŠãŖãé čĒãčĒäŊãŽčŠŠãčĒãŋä¸ããããĻãããããĒæ°åã ã
ãã¯ãŠãĢãĢããžãããåŖ°ãģéŋããã§ãããīŧã
ããĒããããąãŠãąãŠã¨įŦãåēãã¸ãã
ãč¯ããããįŦŦä¸ãŽéĄįžäŊãå ŦåŧãŽåããã¯ãŠãĢãã¨įģé˛ãããåŧãŗåã¯åĨŊããĢãããč¯ãã
ãåŗããĢé ˇãã¨ããģããĢã¯į´ãäēååĄãĢč¨ããã
ãããŽãäģããäžäģŖãã§ã¯ãĒããéĄįžäŊãã¨ããŖããããžããããīŧããŠãããæåŗã§ããīŧã
ãč¨čéãã ã
ããģããĢãįãåŗįããčĒãčŖčļŗããã
ããäžäģŖãæãã¯ãåžĄäŊŋããã¨åŧį§°ããæšããäēēéãĢéŊåãč¯ãã
ãéãåããå
åŧããã¯ãã¯åãããĻ䏿ąãŖãĻãã¨ã ãã
ãäģã¯æŦæĨãŽåãå¤ąãŖãĻããã¨ãããã¨ãīŧã䏿ąãæãŖããĒããããĄãå´ãŽéŊåãĒãŠįĄčĻããžããã¨ãå¯čŊã§ã¯īŧãåŧãįãããããã大æ¨äēãčĩˇããåãĢ帰ããšãã ã
ãã§ãããããĒãã¨âĻâĻã
ããããäžäģŖã§č¯ããŖãããã ããããčģĸæįšãčĻããã¨æããããžãããã¨ãĢã
ãčåžãŽčĻįˇããããããåãĢã垎įŦãã¸ã´ãæãæ¯ããĒããå ãŽį˛ã¨ãĒãŖãĻå§ŋãæļããããģããĢãä¸įĨãåãĢå¯čļããĻæģãæļããã
ãâĻâĻå
įã¯ããåįĨã§ãããīŧã
ãéŠæ°æ´žãŽäģå
Ĩã§ãåŦåæãĢåčŖããĄããŖããã¨īŧãããã¨ããåŊŧããäŋåŽæ´žã¨éŠæ°æ´žãŽããããã§åŋãããĻãããã¨ãããīŧã
ãæåŗããããĢ垎įŦãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãããäģĨä¸įããĒããŖãã
ãč°äēå ãåēãã¨ã䏿ŠåĢéĸãŽãĩããĢãįĢãŖãĻãããå§ŋãčĻããĒãčŠããåãæãããŽãčĻãæ°ãããã
ãįĄäēãĢįĩããŖãããã ãĒã
ãåŊįļããããããããããĢãäŊãč¨ããã¨ã¯īŧã
ãããŽå ´ã§ã¯ãĢãĒã¨åããããŦãšãŽčŖžãæēããããããŦãã
ããīŧãâĻâĻããããčĻå´ããã
ãåŊŧãŽčåžã§įéĢĒãŽåĨŗæ§ãæēãæ¯ãåããã
ãâ
ãčĻåĄãŽãããĒéãæããããŖãĒãã¸ãéãããéåãĒįéĸæãéãããåĻšãéŖãŗåēããĻããã
ãã¨ãĢãããããīŧã
ããã ããžããĻãŠã
ãæąãã¤ãããčĄæã§ãããããĒãããæąãᎠãčŋããåĻšãŽäŊ渊ã¨įĄéĒæ°ãã§ãåˇãããŖãĻããč¸ãŽåĨĨãæēļããĻããããã ãäš ããļããĢæãåŽļã¸å¸°ãŖããããĒåŽåŋæã¨į˛å´æããåæãĢæŧãå¯ããĻããã
ãåąæˇãŽčĻåãĢæŽããĻããé¨ä¸ã¨åæĩãããĩããĢã¯ãäŧæĨįŗčĢãå ąåãäģŖčĄããããäŧããããĢ芰ãå¯ãããåŖčĢãå§ããã
ããŦãã¯čąĒåĨĸãĒããŦãšãįæŋãããããįĩĻäģãäēäēēåŧãéŖããĻčĒ厤ãĢåãããåã¨ã¨ãˇãĨãįæŋããã
ãããŽãžãžå¯åēã¸æ˛ãŋčžŧãŋãããŽãææ ĸããĻéŖå ãįŽæããæãéããéį̝ãéŖæŦ˛ããããåããéŧģč ãããããããã¤ããĒãã¨ãˇãĨãåē§ãå¸ãĢããĩããĢãåē§ãŖãĻããã
ãããããã¯å ã ã¨å¤åēã§ãããããŠãã¸čĄãããäēåãĢå ąåããįžŠåãįēįãããããŠâĻâĻã
ããŦããŽčŠąããææĨãĢæããåˇĄãããæäžããããããŗã¨čąãŽãšãŧããä¸åŖéŖ˛ããå°ãåˇããĻããããŽãŽãæãããĒčąãĢåĒããåŗãæãŋčžŧãã§ããã
ãåįŖčŠąããããžãããšãŧããč¤ããĻããéãããį
§ãããããĢįŦãåĻšãčĻãĻããã¨ãį´°ãããĒåšŗįŠãåŽæã§ããã
ãåĻšãŽéŖã§ã¨ãˇãĨãåĒé ãĢãšãŧããéŖ˛ãã§ããããããĒå§ŋãčĻãåēĻãéåæã¨čãããåãŖãĻããã
ãå¤éŖåžãįŋæ Ŗã§ææēãĢåããŖããæ°ããį´ãåēããããŗå ãã¤ãŗã¯ãĢæĩ¸ãã
ãææĨã¯åĻšã¨ã夿ŗãã¸čĄãį´æããããįŠįãéŖį¨æ¤įŠãå åˇĨããįĨčãéãããããããã¯åŽčˇĩãéããæčĄãįŖ¨ããĻãããã
ãæģį¨ŊãĒ芹ã ãæžããããŽã¯åã§ãéŖŧãããĻãããŽã ãŖãĻåãŽæšãããããĒããŽãĢãããŽå ´ãĢããčǰããåããįŽĄįč
ãã¨čĻãĻãããåŋåēãŠãã§ãããã
ãčĒåã§ãåãããģãŠčēĢåæãĒčããĢåĢæ°ãåˇŽãã
ãããŽæĨãŽãåããĢäŧãããã
ãéŖåã ãĒã
ãåãããæããäēēãŽåŋã¯į§ģãããããã
ãæˇąãæēãæ¯ã¨ã¨ããĢæ¯ãčŋãã¨ããˇãŖãã¨ãšãŠãã¯ãšå§ŋãŽã¨ãˇãĨã¨įŽãããŖãã
ããŠããæŦåŊãŽåãĒãŽīŧã
ãįããã°ããåã¯äŋĄãããŽãīŧã
ããããããã ãįããčããĻãæēčļŗããĒãã
ãåã¯ãåãæãŖãĻãããããã¯ãŦããã§ãããŖã¨æŦ˛æˇąãã垿
ĸã ã¨æ°äģããããã
ãããããŋãã¨ãˇãĨã
ãæĨįĢãĢįŧãããĻãæ§ããĒãã
ãâââ
ãââčãããã
ãå
ļãŽãåŖ°ãã¯įĩļããéŋããĻããã
ã䏿ĄįãĢæ¤ããæ˛éãåããįĨããæ§ããéŖĸããĢč ããåŖ°ãåšžåãŽč¨čĒãæãéãĒããæŋæĩãŽãããĢæ¸Ļåˇģãã
ããããĻä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ãæåŗãæãĄãįč§Ŗãããä¸įã¯å¸¸ãĢãåŖ°ãã§æēãĄãĻãããŽã ã¨ã
ãįĒåĻãįéŗã¨įąéĸ¨ãåŧžããã
ãéãįŽčãæãĄä¸ãããįŧåãĢä¸ã¤ãŽäēēåŊąãæããã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãæēãããããį°æ§ãĒå§ŋã¯ãåŊŧããĢäģį¨Žæã¸ãŽčãŋã¨ãå
ļãã¨ã¯čŖč
šãĒįæãæąããããåŧĩã芰ããįŠēæ°ãéå¯ãæ¯é
ããã
ãããããŠããŽåĨ´éˇã īŧã ããã§äŊããĻãããīŧã
ãæåãĢåŖ°ãæžãŖããŽã¯ãé ŦãĢå¤åˇãæã¤įŊéĢĒãŽįˇã§ããŖããæéãŽä¸ã§ã鎎ãããĢæĩŽããŗä¸ããæˇąį´ ãŽįŗããį˛įŠãčĻåŽããã
ãčãį°į¨ŽæãĒããĻãŠãã§ãããããæŠãå§æĢããĻã
ãåãįšåž´ãæã¤åĨŗããé ŦåˇãŽįˇãŽčåžããéŦąéļããããĢéŧģãéŗ´ãããé ŦåˇãŽįˇã¯åŖå ãæĒãžããĒããåãčããį´°čēĢãŽåŖãéŗããĒãåŧãæããã
ãå ļãŽéããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯čįŠēãčĻã¤ããĻãããæĩæãčǰãĢåããããĻããããĒãŠãå ¨ãææĄããĻããĒããå ļãã¯įĩļããæĩãįļãããåŖ°ããŽå ããĒä¸é¨ãĢéããĒããŖãã
ãããĩãã¨ãããĒīŧã
ãé ŦåˇãŽįˇãéåãã芰ããåŖéãéĸ¨ãčŖããåŗč ãĢéãįãŋãčĩ°ãŖãã῏ŠããäŊæļ˛ãčŋ¸ããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽčäŊãåããĻæįĸēãĒä¸åŋĢãæįĨãããåããæŧããäŊãå¸ãåŖ°ã¯ãåŊŧãåããĻįēããä¸įã¸ãŽãåŋįãã§ããŖãã
ãé ŦåˇãŽįˇã¯ãæåŋããŽãĒããĢįŽãčĻéããååãĢčˇéĸãåããåŖčēĢã¨æå ãŽæčĻãįĸēãããæåŖãŽæãæĄãį´ããã
ãããå æ¸ãĢããĻãčŋˇåãŽįĨãĩããæĸããŽãå ã§ããīŧã
ãčįĢãĄãé ãããĢčæãĄããåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯čãæ´ŠãããĒããŖããæåŗã¯įč§Ŗã§ããã¨ããæčãŽåĨĨåēã¸åģãžããĻããã
ãčĻãīŧã åˇãâĻâĻīŧã
ãããŧããčĸĢãŖãįˇãåŖ°ãä¸ãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽååˇããæŠããåĄããå§ããĻããã
ãéąå¤Ģã§ã¯ãĒãããããæ´čˇãããīŧã
ãåĨŗã¯åããããĢåĒæãåąããč °ããĢãåãŽéãĢæãæˇģãããããŧãįˇã¯æããã¤ããæ§ãããé Ŧåˇįˇã¯ããã䏿¯ããŽåŖãæããåãŗčĨ˛ããããŖãã
ããããč¯ãæããĢéŗ´ããĻããīŧīŧã
ãååŖãč¸ãĢæˇąã ã¨įĒãåēãããé Ŧåˇįˇã¯æåž ãĢæãįŧãčŧãããåã ã¨ããĻåŧãæãããåˇåŖãã鎎čĄãå´ãåēããåĢãŗåŖ°ã¯ä¸ãããĒããŖããééĢĒãå Ĩãããčč šãåã¸ã¨čŋŊæãå ããããč˛Ģãããįˇã¯åããĒãã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãæåã§åæãįš°ãåēããå ļããé Ŧåˇįˇã¯åčēĢéããĻčēąãããįļãåãčč šãįãŖãéŖæããéĻãæģããåŖčēĢã§åãæĩãã
ãé Ŧåˇįˇã¯ãæĩãæĻčĄãŽį´ äēēã¨åæãã¤ã¤ããéˇåŧãããĻã¯ãĒããĒãã¨į´æãããč¸ãŽåēåˇãåĄããå§ããĻããã
ãååŖãįŋģããįŧãįãŖãĻéãįĒããæžã¤ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯éĻãæģãŖããå ããĢé ããåŖéãé Ŧãæ ããčŗå ãæããæ¯ãžãčˇéĸã芰ããäŧ¸ã°ããæãé ŦåˇįˇãŽåãæ´ãã ã
ãããŖâĻâĻãããããīŧã
ãčĻæļãŽåŖ°ãéŋããé Ŧããčŗãžã§åãčŖãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽįŧããæéŖč
ãŽåĻãå
ãčĻããã
ãæã¨įĒãéŖãčžŧãžããĻᎠãä¸ããã¨ãéǍãŽčģãéŗããããå
ããĢåŖå
ãåčįãĒææĻãĢæĒãã
ããããīŧã
ãããŧãįˇãŽæãããã¤ãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽčŠã¨č ãĢįĒãåēãããåĨŗãåĒæãŽä¸č¨ä¸åĨãįããĒãåąãįĩãããį´åžãåēįžããéãįãæ¸Ļãåˇģããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãåãŋčžŧãã
ãéčŽäēēãĢįãžããä¸éãåĒãããããã
ãããåãæ¨ãĻãæŦĄãŽįŦéãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įŧãįãŖããįã¯åŧžããããããĢčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇããéĸããčĄč čĒčēĢã¸čĨ˛ãæããã
ãåã§ããīŧīŧã âĻâĻãĒãã§ãŖīŧã
ãæ˛éŗ´ãįŗåŖãĢåéŋããã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯č¨ãããããĢįã饰ãããããŧãįˇãŽãã¤ããčŋĢããé ŦåˇįˇãįžãĢããĻåãã
ãæĻæ§ã¨ããĒããããé Ŧåˇįˇã¯čĒčēĢãŽčč
šãĢåēããŖããã¤ããĢįŽãããŖããæ¯ãéŖããã°ããĒããåŧãæãã¨ãæŽãããåãæ¯ãįĩããããĢãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¸åããĻæ¯ãčĸĢãŖãã
ãåãžããéŗã¨å
ąãĢéĻãæãæ˛ããŖããåãå¤ąãŖãčēĢäŊã¯åŖãĢåŠãã¤ããããå
ļãŽãžãžããŧãįˇã¸æãéŖã°ãããã
ãåããĒããĒãŖãé Ŧåˇįˇãæŧãé¤ããįãĢå ãžããåĨŗãŽåŧąã ããåŖ°ãĢæ°äģããããŧãįˇã¯ãå§åįä¸åŠãæããæĻå¨ãæ¨ãĻãĻåĢãã ã
ãåž ãŖãīŧã éåã ãčĻéããĻããīŧã
ãåŊäšããããããŧãįˇã¯čļŗãéãããĒããįĢãĄä¸ãããåžéããĻčˇéĸãį¨ŧãã
ãããŧãįˇãŽãåŖ°ãããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽæčã¸æĩãčžŧãã§ãããå
ļãã¯ãéŧčãæ¯ããããč¨čã¨ã¯čŖč
šãĢãæĩãŽæ˛šæãčĒãįĸēããǿǿãåãã§ããã
ãéä¸ããã᏿ã¯čéãŽį迍åļã ãããããéēģįēãåšããĻããããããžã§ã¯čˇéĸãåãŖãĻãæéãį¨ŧãããããĒæãĢčŠ åąãæããããŖãĻãããåĨŗãâĻâĻã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯ãčĻįãĢæļããĻããåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ãããåŽå ¨ãĢæļããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°äģããã
ãå ļãŽæãæåãĢéããčåĨŗãŽãåŖ°ããæįĨãããé įã¨é¯čĻããį¨ãĢį˛éĢããä¸įãŽäŊåĻãĢåą ãã¨ãįĨããĒãåĨŗãŽčŗéããĒéåãåŖ°ã严čŗãæã§åĄãã§ãããåŖ°ãã¯čŗå ã§åéŋãįļããã
ãå¤é¨ãŽåēæŋã¨å é¨ãŽæ å ąãčŗãæēããļããããĢæčãæˇˇæŋãããåŧˇãåąæŠæãåŧãŗčĩˇãããã
ãæĢãããĻãå ļãŽåŖ°ããææ įãĒéĢæãåŧããåŖ°éãåŖ°č˛ãįŠãããĒããŽã¸ãéãĢã¯æŋæĩãåŊĸæããä¸į˛ã¸ã¨æģãŖãã
ãä¸éŖãŽįžčąĄãįˇã¯æ å ąã¨ããĻæčãŽåēãĢčŊã¨ãčžŧãã
ãããŧãįˇã¯éčĩ°åŖãčãĢįĢãŖãĻããããããĻãåĨŗã¨åãčŠ åąãåŊŧã¯čŗå
ã§åˇ§ãŋãĢåŽäēããããååŠãįĸēäŋĄãããåŖ°ããéŋããåãŗéãįãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãå
ãŋčžŧãã ã
ãįŧįąãĢįŧãããæ˛įãĒåĢãŗåŖ°ãéŋããå
ļãã¯ããŧãįˇãŽææĢéã§ããŖãã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇã¯ä¸é¨å§įĩãčĻŗå¯ããã
ãåšžåããŽãã¤ããįĒãįĢãĻããããããĒæŋįãĢåãåĢãŗåŖ°ã¯åžã
ãĢåŧąãžããåģããããĒåŖ°ãĢå¤ãããčĻįãį˛žįĨåãåããįåæŦčŊãŽæ¸æã¨ææŦ˛ã¯čãããåŖ°ããåŖ°éãå¤ąãŖãĻããã
ãæčãææžãã¨åæãĢãčĻãããĒæ¯éŖããčēĢåããæĸãŋããåŖ°ããéįĩļããã
ãčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽæčã¯ãååãŽãŋãĒãããåŖ°ããŽæŋæĩã¸ã¨éŖ˛ãŋčžŧãžããĻããŖãã
ãâââ
ãâįŧãįĻããčããéŧģãįĒããå ļãã¨ã¯å ¨ãåĨãŽåããįˇãŽå čĻã¯čĒčãããéį̝ãæãéŖãįŠēč šæãčĨ˛ããčĒčēĢãŽč ãĢæŽãčĄãčããããčļŗããĒããŖãã
ã垎ããĒåããčžŋããįŗæĢãŽé°ãĢäēēåŊąãčĻã¤ããã
ãå į¨ãŽä¸äēēãããå°ãããč ããčĄãæĩããĻãããææãĢéããĒãããæ¯ãæŊããåäžã
ãåŧãįĩã°ããåããã¯čãåēããã¨ãŽåļããĒããåŖ°ããæįĨãããããæŽãããã¨ã¸ãŽåžæãåŽåĻãŽåãããŦåĻšã¸ãŽæŗããįĩļæãĢéŖ˛ãžããĒãããæããã¨ããåŋã
ãæŋããįŠēč
šãŽåã§ã¯ããŠããäēæĢã ã
ãč ãæ´ãŋãåäģģããĢåŧãä¸ãããæģ´ãčŊãĄãčĄãčããéį̝ãįēãããããĒéļé æãčãĢįĩĄãŋã¤ãããæ¸ãåãŖãĻããåãååŋããĻčēåããã
ãåˇãčˇĄãæŽããåŽæ˛ģããã¨æ°äģããåäžã¯ãįãå¯ãããįˇã¯įŗåŖãĢå˛ãžããį åãčãééįã§é°éŦąãĒįŠēéãčĻæ¸Ąãã
ãåäžã¯įãč
ãæĢã§æŠããããæ°ãĒãåžéãããã
ãéĸåŋäēããåĨãŽéĸåŋäēã¸åŋããĒãéŖãŗåããåŖ°ããããæ¤åĻãå°åēãŽåŊã§ãããåäžã¨åå
ĩã¯éˇåŊį¨Žæã§ãããã¨ãįĨãŖããįļããĻãå°ä¸ãįŽæãæ
ãŽč¨įģã¸į§ģããčĩ¤éĢĒãŽįˇãŽæčã¯æŋæĩãŽæ¸ĻãĢæ˛ãã
ãâââ
ãčǰãŽåŊäģ¤īŧã
ã䏿ĻãŖãåŖ°ã§åäžãåããå ļãŽãåŖ°ããããåšžåēĻãįš°ãčŋãããåžæã¨ææãæĩãčžŧãã
ãåãĢäŊãŽį¨ããããŽããŖãĻčããĻãããŽã ããŠīŧã
ã᏿ãŽéĻãĢįåŖãįĒãäģããæ éãĢ芰ãå¯ãåäžã
ãããããĒãããéĸåŋäēã¯ãįžįļãæãįĩæĢã¸æäŊãããã¨ãčŦãŽįˇãæĸããã¨ãĢãããŽã ããåŖ°ããĢäŋããããžãžãįˇã¯čĒčēĢãŽč¨æļãčžŋããã¨čŠĻãŋãã
ããããĻãæ°äģãããŠããĒįįąã§æ¤åĻã¸æĨãããäŊåĻã§įãžããäŊãããĻããããåˇąãŽåãããæãåēããĒãäēåŽãĢã
ãčŗå ãæĩããåšžåãŽãåŖ°ãã¸æčãåããĻããčĒããŽåå¨ãĢįšããæ å ąãæĸãåēããĢã¯åļããĒããŖãã
ãâããŽåå ĩãæģããĒããã°ãåŊŧããŽäžé ŧä¸ģã¯æŦĄãŽæãæãŖãĻãããåäžãŽãåŖ°ãããããåąæ§ãå§ããã
ãįˇã¯æčãŽååã§å
åã¨æãããåŖ°ããįĨčĻããåäžãæąãä¸ãããéį̝ãåäžã¯æ¯éĸæģ
čŖãĒãåŖ°ãã§é¨ãįĢãĻããᎿĨæ§ã¨éčĻæ§ãčĢããæéĄãčããåēãĢéããã
ãåäžã¯įĻį¤Ģä¸ããå¤åĨãåŧãåēããįˇãŽč
°ãĢåˇģãäģãããįžįļã§å¯čŊãĒéããŽåŋæĨåĻįŊŽã¨čĒčēĢãĢč¨ãčãããäģæšãĒãã¨ãããåŖ°ãã
ãįˇã¯čļŗå
ãĢå°ããĒæéĄãčĻã¤ããæžãä¸ããã夊äēãåŖãŽįŗãæ ãåēãããĻãããč§åēĻãå¤ããĻããéĄéĸãĢã¯čǰãŽå§ŋãæ ããĒãã
ãæããæģãčŊãĄãæéĄãåēįŗã¸čĄįĒããéŗãįĢãĻãĻå˛ããã
ãčĻæ¸Ąãã¨åäžãŽå§ŋã¯ãĒããŖããæčãæ˛ãã§ããã
ãâââ
ãčŦãč§Ŗãæãããã¨čå¯ãįš°ãåēãããåŖ°ããčãã¤ããįˇã¯ãå ļããčŋŊãããããčžŋãįãããŽã¯įŠãããĒå°åēæšãŽįã
ãå ļåĻã§ãåäžãĢææĄããã
ãåãæŦ˛ãããīŧã
ãčį ã§įãæˇąãåäžã ãčĻæãããæįĩļããããã¨ã¯æįŊãæ ãĢã䞥å¤ãããã
ãéĄã¯įããå¯čļããĒããŖãããĒãã°ãäģč ãŽčĻįšããčĻŗæ¸ŦããäģãĒããåˇąčĒčēĢãŽåŊãããåąéēãĢæãåĨŊåĨåŋããįããčĻã¤ãåēãæĨãžã§ã
ãâåˇąãįĨããå¯ä¸ãå ļãã ããŽãããĢã
ãå°åēæšãĢæ ãčžŧãåŊąã¯ããäēēå°ããŽæĒįŠãã§ããŖããŽããįĨãå¯čļãããææ¸č ãããæãã¯ââã