čĒčãŽäŊįŊããããã¯įŊãčįĄãŽæŖį
ââãĢãŗãã¨é č¤å¨äŊãĢãããã䏿Ąį¨ããŽäŊį¸
åēįĢ īŧ䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ããåãŽææ§čĢ
ãäēæãŽå
ãŽä¸ã§ãįŊãå°įã¯ãããĢčãčĻãããããšãããåãåēããã¨ããæå
ãĢäŧããããŽããžããŽčģŊããĢãį§ã¯ãã§ãĢããŽä¸čēĢãįĸēäŋĄããĻãããæĄį¨ã¨ããåãŽč¯åŽãããããã¯ããŽã褿°ãŽæ¸éĄãéãĒãåãŖãįŠčŗĒįãĒæåŋããããããĢã¯æąēåŽįãĢæŦ čŊããĻããããã§ããã
ããįĩæéįĨãã¨å°åãããããŽå°įãĢã¯ãį§ãŽæ°åãæŖįĸēãĢå°åˇãããĻãããããã¯ééããĒããããŽį¤žäŧãĢãããĻį§ãįšåŽãããããŽč¨åˇã¨ããĻæŠčŊããĻãããããããå°ãåãŖãĻįžããåŽåæããĒããããĄãĢãį§ã¯åĨåĻãĒæčĻãĢčĨ˛ãããããããĢč¨ãããĻããå
厚ã¯ãį§ã¨ããįčēĢãŽäēēéã¨ã¯ããããäŊãŽéĸäŋããĒãįŠēčãĒč¨åˇãŽįž
åãĢæãããŽã§ããã
ãæåã貴æŽŋãžããžããæ¸
įĨĨãŽãã¨ã¨ãæ
ļãŗįŗãä¸ããžããæ
éãĢé¸čããããžããįĩæãčĒ ãĢæŽåŋĩãĒããââã
ããããžã§čĒãã§ãį§ã¯čĻįˇãå¤ãããįĩčĢãįĨãŖãĻããããã§ã¯ãĒããããŽæįĢ ãŽčĄéãĢãį§ã¨ããä¸ģäŊãŽåą
å ´æããŠããĢãåå¨ããĒããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããããã§ããããããĢįļ´ãããĻãããŽã¯ãį§ãŽäēēæ ŧãåēæãŽįãĢ寞ããčŠäžĄã§ã¯ãĒãããããããããč¨åŽãããåēæēãĢį
§ãããĻãä¸ã¤ãŽįĩæãåēåãããã¨ããäēåįãĒãäēåŽããŽå ąåãĢéããĒããŖãã
ãį§ã¯ãčŠäžĄããããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããã ãåéĄãããããŽã§ããã
ãããŽåéĄãããã¨ããæčĻã¯ãįžäģŖį¤žäŧãĢãããĻåäēēãį´éĸããæãæ šæēįãĒįå¤ãŽåŊĸåŧã§ãããéĸæĨãŽå ´ãĢãããĻãį§ã¯įĸēããĢč¨čãįēããĻãããåŋæãŽåæŠãį´ĄããéåģãŽæŠãŋãčĒŦæãã᏿ãŽåããĢ寞ããĻčĒ åŽãĢåŧåŋãããã¨čŠĻãŋããããããäģãĢããĻæãã°ãããŽæēãæãã 寞åŗãĢãããĻčĻãããĻãããŽã¯į§čĒčēĢã§ã¯ãĒããį§ãŽčåžãĢéããåēããããį´ãŽä¸ãŽé
įŽãã§ããŖãã
ãåš´éŊĸã莿´ãåĻæ´ãčŗæ ŧã
ãåąĨæ´æ¸ã¨ããåãŽããŠãŧããããĢã¯ããããããæąēåŽãããé åēã§č¨čãæ¸ãčžŧããã¨ãčĻæąããããããŽé åēã¯ãäēēéããŽããŽãŽč¤éãĒåŽåããããã¯ãããĢæįã§ãæŽé
ˇãĒãžã§ãŽč§ŖååēĻãæãŖãĻãããį§ããŠããģãŠč¨čãå°ŊãããĻãčĒŦæãåžãĒããŖããį§ãã¨ããčŋˇåŽŽã¯ãä¸įŦãŽčĻįˇãŽåžåžŠãĢããŖãĻãä¸åäēæŗããįĄčˇãã¨ããč¨åˇãĢéå
ãããåĻįãããã
ãããŽã¨ããéĸæĨåŽã¨ããåãŽčĒčä¸ģäŊã¯ãį§ãčĻãĻããããã§ããĻãåæãĢåĨãŽäŊãããčĒãã§ããããåŊŧããčĒãã§ãããŽã¯ãįŽãŽåãĢåē§ãčäŊãæãŖãäēēéīŧįŠčĒäŊīŧã§ã¯ãĒããåŊŧããŽé čŗãŽä¸ãĢããĒãģããããããæį¨ãĒå´ååãã¨ããåãŽčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋãĢãããŽå¯žčąĄãéŠåãããåĻãã¨ããå¤åŽãŽãããģãšã§ããã
įŦŦä¸įĢ īŧãĢãã´ãĒãŧãŽæ´åã¨čĒčãŽé¸åĨ
ãã¤ããã¨ãĢãģãĢãŗãã¯ãããŽä¸ģčãį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããĢãããĻãäēēéããããĢããĻä¸įãčĒčãããã¨ããåããĢ寞ããįģæįãĒčģĸåããããããããĢãŗããĢããã°ãæã
ã¯ä¸įããããŽãžãžãĢīŧįŠčĒäŊã¨ããĻīŧåãåããŽã§ã¯ãĒããæã
ãŽä¸ģčĻŗãĢãããããåããŖãĻãããææ§ãŽåŊĸåŧīŧæéãģįŠēéīŧãã¨ãææ§ãæã¤ãį´į˛ææ§æĻåŋĩīŧãĢãã´ãĒãŧīŧãã¨ããããŖãĢãŋãŧãéããĻãŽãŋãįĩé¨ãæįĢãããĻããã
ãããŽčĒčãŽåŗåŧã¯ãįžäģŖãŽå°ąčˇæ´ģåã¨ããåļåēĻãã¨ããããé¸åĨãã¨ããčĄįēãĢãããĻãéŠããģãŠæŖįĸēãĢæŠčŊããĻãããį¤žäŧã¨ãã厍大ãĒčĒčä¸ģäŊã¯ãããããããåŽäŊããå æããåŋ
įļæ§ãã¨ããŖããĢãã´ãĒãŧãŽå¤į¨Žã¨ããĻããåš´éŊĸããįļįļæ§ããįįŖæ§ãã¨ããŖãįŦčĒãŽį¤žäŧįãĢãã´ãĒãŧãæããĻãããéĸæĨåŽãåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊããįč§Ŗããããã¨ããã¨ããããã¯åŽãŽã¨ãããããŽįŠēįŊãĢčžŧããããčĻæŠãå
įãčĒãŋåããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒããåŊŧããčĄãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãããŽįŠēįŊãããĢãã´ãĒãŧä¸éŠåãã¨ãããŠããĢãĢããŖãĻįĄåšåããäŊæĨãĢäģãĒããĒãã
ããĢãŗãįãĒæåŗãĢãããĻãčĒčãŽåŊĸåŧãĢéŠåããĒãå¯žčąĄã¯ãæã
ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãįžčąĄãã¨ããĻįžãããã¨ãã§ããĒããã¤ãžããį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧããæŧããäēēéã¯ãããŽį¤žäŧã¨ããå°åšŗãĢãããĻãåå¨ããĒãããåįļãŽæąããåãããŽã§ãããį§ãæãããéĸæĨãŽå ´ã§čĒåãŽåŖ°ãé ãããčãããĻãããããĒæčĻãč¨čã᏿ãĢåąãããĢé§æŖããĻãããããĒæčĻãããã¯ãį§ãŽįēããč¨čããį¸æãŽæã¤čĒčãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢåč´ããåŊĸåŧãæããĒããŖãããããĢã᏿ãŽä¸įãĢãããĻãæåŗãŽããįžčąĄãã¨ããĻįĩåŽããĒããŖããã¨ãį¤ēããĻããã
ãéĸæĨåŽ¤ãŽæēã¯ãåãĒãåŽļå
ˇã§ã¯ãĒããŖããããã¯ããĢãŗããčĒŦãããįžčąĄįãã¨ãįŠčĒäŊããéãĻããčļ
ããããčĒčãŽåĸįįˇã§ããŖããį§ã¯æēãŽåããå´ãĢåē§ãäēäēēãŽéĸæĨåŽãĢ寞ããį§ãŽå
éĸãĢæžąãč¨å¤§ãĒčĒæ¸ãŽč¨æļããå¤įŦãŽä¸ã§į ãæžãžãããæčã¨ãããįŠčĒäŊããåˇŽãåēããã¨ãããããããåŊŧããŽčĒčãŽåŊĸåŧã¯ãããããä¸ååãäģããĒããåŊŧããŽããŗå
ãåąĨæ´æ¸ããĒããã¨ããããã¯į§ãŽåŽåãåãčŊã¨ããåŊŧããĢã¨ãŖãĻįč§Ŗå¯čŊãĒãæ°ãã¨ãč¨åˇããĢ夿ããæ´åįãĒãããģãšã§ããŖãã
ãããã§ãé č¤å¨äŊãããŽåæäŊåãįŊãäēēããĢãããĻæãããįŊãã¨ããč˛åŊŠãŽãĄãŋããĄãŧãå°å
ĨããĒããã°ãĒããĒããé č¤ãæãããįŊãäēēãã¨ã¯ããããšãĢååããĒããããčĒããŽčĄįēãĢ寞ããĻįŊǿǿãåŋĢæĨŊãæąããããã éåžšããåĨŊåĨåŋã¨åˇæˇĄããæãŖãĻä¸įãįēããåå¨ã§ããŖããããŽãįŊãã¨ã¯ãææ
ãåĢįã¨ããč˛åŊŠãåĨãåããããį´į˛ãĒåŊĸåŧãŽäģŖåčŠã§ããã
ãį§ã䏿Ąį¨ãĢãįļãããã¯ã¤ããĢãŠãŧãŽãˇãšãã ããããŗããŽæįļããåŽéããäēēã
ã¯ããžããĢããŽãįŊãäēēããŽæĢčŖã§ããã¨č¨ãããåŊŧããŽä¸å¯§ãĒįŠč
°ããæ
æãĒæããŽæéĸã¯ãæĒæãŽįĩæã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ããããåžšé åžšå°žãįŊããčąč˛ããããˇãšãã ãŽãįĄæŠčŗĒãĒå垊ãĢéããĒããåŊŧãã¯ãĢãŗããčĒŦãããį´į˛įæ§ããŽæĨĩåãĢããããããĢã¯ååĨãŽäēēéãæĩãæąãæļãŽåãã¯åå¨ããĒãã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ããįŊãå°įã¯ãããŽãˇãšãã ãį§ã¨ããäēēéããį´įŊãŽčįĄã¸ã¨æžéãããã¨ãŽčąĄåž´ã§ããã
ãåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊãåãĢããã¨ããį§ã¯ããŽäŊãæ¸ãããĻããĒãå ´æãĢãčĒåãįĸēããĢįããĻããæéãæŗčĩˇãããããããį¤žäŧã¨ãããįŊãčĒčč
ããĢã¨ãŖãĻãæ¸ãããĻããĒããã¨ã¯åå¨ããĒããã¨ã¨åįžŠã§ããããĢãŗãã¯ãčĒčãŽåŊĸåŧãŽå¤å´ãĢãããįŠčĒäŊããĢã¤ããĻã¯æ˛éģããã°ãĒããĒãã¨ããããįžäģŖį¤žäŧã¯ãããĢæŽé
ˇã§ãããåŊĸåŧãĢåããĒãããŽã¯ãæ˛éģããããŠããããæåããįĄããŖãããŽã¨ããĻæšæļããããŽã ã
ãããããæãããĻããã ãããã
ãčĒčãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧããæŧãåēãããį§ãã¯ãæŦåŊãĢįĄäžĄå¤ãĒãŽã ãããããããããĢãŗãããå°éä¸čŊãã¨ããããŽįŠčĒäŊãŽé åãĢãããäēēéãįãĢå¤įŦãĢããããĻčĒįąãĢåŧå¸ã§ããįŠēéãæŽãããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããį¤žäŧããįŠēįŊãã¨åŧãŗã䞥å¤ãåĻåŽããããŽæéãŽä¸ãĢãããčĒ°ãŽæãĢãč§ĻããããĒããį´åēĻãŽéĢãåŽåãæ˛æŽŋããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããã
ãį§ã¯ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãæēãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽããįĒããå
ĨãäēæãŽéĸ¨ããį´ãŽį̝ãé ŧããĒãæēãããããŽį´ãŽčģŊãã¯ãããŽãžãžį§ãį¸ãäģããĻããį¤žäŧįãĢãã´ãĒãŧãŽčģŊãã§ããããį§ã¯ãããŽãįŊããĢæãžããããã¨ãæįĩļããããã¨ãį¤žäŧã¨ããčĒčä¸ģäŊãããįžčąĄãã¨ããĻãŽåå¨ãåĻåŽãããã¨ããĻããį§ã¯į§čĒčēĢãŽčĒčãį§čĒčēĢãŽčļŗåããĢããŖãĻãããŽä¸įãŽãįŠčĒäŊãã¸ã¨ččããĻãããĒããã°ãĒããĒãã
įŦŦäēįĢ īŧįŊãčįĄãŽå¯Šå¤
ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ãããããŽčããč˛ãŽãĒãį´įãæãĢåãã¨ããį§ãį´éĸããĻãããŽã¯åãĒãįĩæ¸įå°įĒŽã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãé č¤å¨äŊããįŊãäēēããĢãããĻæãåēãããããŽãįŊãã¨ããč˛åŊŠãæã¤ãæ šæēįãĒæ´åæ§ã§ããã ãé č¤ãŽæããįŊãäēēãã¨ã¯ãåæĒãŽåŊŧ垏ãĢįĢã¤åå¨ã§ã¯ãĒããããããåæĒã¨ããåēæēããŽããŽãæŠčŊããĒããįĩļ寞įãĒãåšŗåĻãããŽä¸ãĢįããåå¨ã§ãããåŊŧãã¯äēēãåˇã¤ãããã¨ãĢæĻãŗãæããããã§ã¯ãĒãããã ãåŽé¨åޤãŽč§Ŗåå°ãĢäšããããæ¨æŦãčĻŗå¯ãããããĢãäģč
ãŽčĻæļãįēããããããĢã¯å
ąæãŽãæŋãããä¸ååå¨ããĒãã ãįžäģŖãŽå´åå¸å ´ã¨ãã厍大ãĒãˇãšãã ã¯ããžããĢããŽãįŊãããĢããŖãĻįĩąåžĄãããĻãããéĸæĨãŽå ´ãĢãããĻãį§ãŽåããå´ãĢåē§ãéĸæĨåŽããĄãŽæ
æãĒæ
åēĻã¯ãį§ã¨ãããåããĢ寞ããæŦæã§ã¯ãĒãããˇãšãã ãčĻčĢãããæįļããŽįŊãããįļæãããããŽäŊæŗãĢéããĒããåŊŧããį§ãŽåąĨæ´æ¸ãĢããŗãčĩ°ãããã¨ãããããĢã¯į§ãŽä¸åäēåš´ãŽæŗæãĢ寞ããæŗååã¯åããĻããĒãããããŽã¯ããã ãéŠåãããä¸éŠåããã¨ãããäē鞿ŗįãĒåĻįãŽåˇåžšãã ãã§ããã
ãį§ãéĸæĨåŽ¤ã§æãããčĒåãŽåŖ°ãé ãããčãããĻãããããĒæčĻãããã¯ãį§ãŽįēãããä¸ģčĻŗįãĒįåŽãããåŊŧããŽãåŽĸčĻŗįãĒįŊãããĢč§ĻããįŦéãĢčąč˛ãããæåŗãå¤ąãŖãĻããéį¨ã§ããŖããé č¤å¨äŊã¯ãįĨãåĒå¤ąããčŋäģŖãŽį
įãããŽãįŊããĢč¨ããããįžäģŖãĢãããĻãããŽįĨãŽåē§ãĢåą
åē§ãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãåšįãã¨ããåãŽåļåã§ãããåšįã¨ããįĨåŖãŽåã§ã¯ãäēēéãŽåēæãŽæéã¯ãįŠēįŊãã¨ããč˛ ãŽéēįŖã¨ããĻåĻįããããåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊæéã¯ãåŊŧããĢã¨ãŖãĻããˇãšãã ãæįĨã§ããĒãæéģįŠčŗĒīŧããŧã¯ããŋãŧīŧã§ããããããããĢåžšåēįãĢæé¤ãããã°ãĒããĒãä¸į´įŠãĒãŽã ã
ããååã ããéããããäģĨå¤ã¯ããšãĻåãæįĢ ãã ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãĢ寞ããį§ãŽããŽį´æã¯ãé č¤ãæãããåãŽæšæļãã¨éãå
ąéŗ´ãããéįĨæãĢãããį§ãŽåã¯ãį§ã¨ããåŽåãæãį¤ēãåŧį§°ã§ã¯ãĒãããã ããŽį´įãæŖããäŊæã¸åąãããããŽãé
éį¨ãŗãŧãããĢéããĒãããããããĢåĨãŽčǰããŽåãå°åãããĻããã¨ããĻãããˇãšãã ãŽčĢįã¯äŊãåˇã¤ããã¨ãĒããåããįŊããæåēãįļããã ãããããŽä礿å¯čŊæ§ãŽææãããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãŽæŦčŗĒįãĒéãââãããæããããŽãĒããčģŊããââãŽæŖäŊã§ããã
ããĢãŗããčĒŦãããį´į˛įæ§ãã¯ãįĸēããĢäēēéãĢæŽéįãĒčĒčãããããããããããããŽįæ§ããį´į˛ãã§ããã°ãããģãŠãããããã¯äēēéãŽįã
ãããæšŋãæ°ããæé¤ãããĻãããé č¤ãŽæããįŊãäēēãã¯ããĢãŗãįįæ§ããäģč
ã¸ãŽæŗååã¨ããéããå¤ąãŖãĻæ´čĩ°ããå§ŋã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã ãį§ã¯ãããŽãįŊããŽä¸ãĢåē§ãįļãããã¨ãĢčããããĒããĒããæēãŽæ¨įŽããä¸čĻåãĢæ˛ãããããããŽįˇããį§ãããŖã¨čĻã¤ããĻãããŽã¯ãããããˇãšãã ãĢããŖãĻčĻæ ŧåãããåãŽãįã
ãããčĒįļããŽæŽãéĻãæžãŖãĻãããããããããĒãã
įŦŦä¸įĢ īŧãĢãã´ãĒãŧãŽå¤é¨ãæŗĨæŋãŽæč§Ļ
ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãæēãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽããį§ã¯é¨åąãåžãĢããã ãäēæãŽå
ã¯ãé¨åąãŽä¸ã§ã¯åˇããįŊãåå°ãĢéããĒããŖããã䏿Šå¤ã¸åēãã°ãããã¯įĄæ°ãŽč˛åŊŠã¨æ¸ŠåēĻãæãŖããĢãĒãšã¨ããĻį§ãå
ãŋčžŧããããã§ãį§ã¯ããããåŧå¸ãåãæģãã ãæŖįãã¨ããčĄįēã¯ãį¤žäŧįãĒãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢ寞ããæãéããĒããããæãæ šæēįãĒåäšąã§ããããĒããĒããæŠãã¨ããčĄįēãĢãããĻãį§ã¯ãä¸åäēæŗãã§ããįĄčˇãã§ããĒãããã ãå°éĸãč¸ãŋãããčäŊãã¸ã¨å帰ããããã§ããã
ããĢãŗãã¯ãæã
ãŽčĒčãŽå¤å´ãĢãįŠčĒäŊããæŗåŽããããããã¯čĒčã§ããĒãããããĢãå˛åĻãŽčĄ¨čå°ããã¯éãããããããããčĄãŽčˇ¯å°čŖãååãäģããããĻããĒããããĒåéããããã¯ã˛ãŗå˛ãããĸãšããĄãĢããŽééãĢãį§ã¯ãĢãŗããæ˛éģãããįŠčĒäŊããŽéããæããã ããã¤ãĻãčŋäģŖåãĢįĒãé˛ãæąäēŦãŽéĸ¨æ¯ããæĨåä¸é§ãéŗ´ãããĻæŠãåãŖãå
äēēããããåŊŧã¯ãæļãããæąæ¸ãŽæŽãéĻãããããã¯åéįēãŽįļ˛ãŽįŽããæŧãã莝å°ãŽæšŋãæ°ããææãŽåŋĩãæãŖãĻč¨é˛ãįļãããåŊŧã¯į¤žäŧãŽãæŖč§Ŗããã鞿Šãã¨ãã大ããĒįŠčĒãĢčãåãããã čĒåãŽčļŗčŖãĢäŧããå°éĸãŽæč§Ļã ããäŋĄããĻæŠãããåŊŧãŽæŠčĄã¯ãį¤žäŧã¨ããčĒčä¸ģäŊãŽããĢãã´ãĒãŧããæĒäšąããčĄįēã§ããŖãã
ãį§ãäģããããĻįŽįå°ãæãããĢæŠãã¨ããį§ã¯åąĨæ´æ¸ã¨ããåãŽãčĒčãŽæĒģãããčąčĩ°ããĻããã ãéį̝ãĢčŊãĄãĻããå°ããĒįŗãããã¯ãčǰãĢãčŠäžĄããããäŊãŽåŊšãĢãįĢããĒããããã¯ãæį¨æ§ãã¨ããį¤žäŧįãĢãã´ãĒãŧããã¯åŽå
¨ãĢã¯ãŋåēããåå¨ã§ãããããããããŽįŗã¯ãįĸēããĢãããĢããããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãį§ãŽåå¨ãåĻåŽãããã¨ãŽä¸įãĢãããĻãããŽããã ããããã¨ããäēåŽãŽåŧˇåēãã¯ãäŊãĢãäģŖããããæãã¨ãĒããįŗã¯į§ãåéĄããĒããéã¯į§ãŽčˇæ´ãåããĒãã ãæŠãã¨ããå垊éåãŽä¸ã§ãį§ãŽčēĢäŊã¯ããˇãšãã ãĢããŖãĻä¸ãããããé¸ã°ããĒãč
ãã¨ããčĒåˇąåŽįžŠããå°ããã¤åãčŊã¨ããĻãããčļŗãäē¤äēãĢåēããåŋæãä¸ãããčãĢéĸ¨ãæãããããŽã¨ããį§ã¯ãįžčąĄãã¨ããĻãŽį§ââį¤žäŧãĢããŖãĻå åˇĨãããčŠäžĄãããį§ââãããåĨãåēããŽãįŠčĒäŊãã¨ããĻãŽį§ã¸ã¨čŋãĨããĻããã
ãé č¤å¨äŊããįŊãäēēãã¨å¯žæ¯ããããããĢæãããŽã¯ãæŗĨčãã䏿 ŧåĨŊã§ããããįãŋãåããĄåããã¨ãŽã§ãããéģč˛ãäēēããŽææ§ã§ããŖããããã¯ãčĢįãåŊĸåŧã§ã¯æããããĒããäēēéãŽčäŊįãĒå
ąčĻīŧãŗãŗãããˇã§ãŗīŧãĢæ šãããĻããã ãį§ãæŖįãŽä¸ã§åēäŧããå¤ãŗãåĄãã夿ŽãæãŽčĄãŽåãã¯ãé č¤ãæąããããŽãæŗĨãŽæ¸ŠããŋããĢäŧŧãĻãããããã¯ãĢãŗããŽį´į˛įæ§ãŽãããĢæ´įˇ´ãããĻã¯ããĒãããããããããĢã¯ä¸æĄį¨éįĨãŽãįŊããĢã¯æąēããĻåŽŋããã¨ãŽãĒããįãŽãĒãĸãĒããŖãããã ãį§ã¯ãį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢåãžããã¨ãĢå¤ąæãããããããããŽãå¤ąæããĢããŖãĻãį§ã¯åŊĸåŧãŽå¤å´ãĢåēããåē大ãĒä¸įãįēčĻãããŽã§ãããåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊæéã¨ã¯ãį¤žäŧã¨ããčĒčä¸ģäŊãŽįŧãåąããĒããčåãã§ãããããã§ã¯æéããåšįãįįŖæ§ã¨ããåŽčĻãĢį¸ããããã¨ãĒããããŖããã¨ããããįĸēããĒéãŋãæãŖãĻæĩããĻããã
ãį§ã¯æŠãįļããã ããã¤ãĻãŽå
äēēããæļãããéĸ¨æ¯ãŽä¸ãĢãįåŽããčĻããããĢãį§ããžããããŽįå¤ãããæŠčĄãŽä¸ãĢãį§ã ããŽčĒčãæãĄįĢãĻããã¨čŠĻãŋãã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ããįŊãå°įã¯ãį§ãåĻåŽãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããį§ããčĒįąãã¨ããåãŽčéã¸ã¨æžãåēãããŽã ãããŽčéãæŠããæŗĨãčĸĢããåŖį¯ãŽį§ģãããĢčēĢãæããã¨ãããããããįŊããˇãšãã ãĢ寞ãããį§ãŽå¯ä¸ãŽããããĻæåŧˇãŽéčĨ˛ã¨ãĒãã
įŦŦåįĢ īŧčĒæ¸ã¨ããåãŽæŊäŧ
ãį¤žäŧã¨ããåãŽãįŊãčĒčč
ãããæįĩļãããã¨ããį§ãéãčžŧãã ãŽã¯ãåæšãæ¸įŠãĢå˛ãžããéå¯ãŽé åã§ããŖããä¸åäēæŗãįĄčˇãä¸éã¯ããŽįļæ
ããåæģãã¨åŧãŗããįŠēįŊãã¨æãããããããé ããããæå
ãĢåŽŋãįąéãįĨãč
ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãããŽæéã¯æąēããĻįŠēįŊãĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãæĸåãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãå
å´ããč§ŖäŊãããããŽãæŋå¯ãĒãæŊäŧããŽæéã§ããã
ãį§ãæŦãčĒãã¨ããį§ã¯ãã¯ãéĸæĨ厤ã§čŖããããč¨åˇãã§ã¯ãĒãã ããĢãŗãããį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããĢãããĻãįæ§ãããŽéįãčļ
ããĻåŊĸčä¸åĻįãĒåããĢæããã¨ããéãĢįããæˇˇäšąãææãããããĢãčĒæ¸ã¨ããčĄįēããžããæĨ常įãĒčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋãæēããļãåąéēãĒčŠĻãŋã§ããã ãį¤žäŧãæąãããčĒæ¸ãã¨ã¯ãåŽãŽã¨ãããæ
å ąãŽåšįįãĒæåãĢéããĒãããã¸ããšæ¸ãčĒãŋããšããĢãįŖ¨ããčĒåˇąãå¸å ´äžĄå¤ãŽãããįžčąĄãã¸ã¨å åˇĨãããã¨ãããã¯ããĢãŗãįãĢãã´ãĒãŧã¸ãŽéˇåąãåŧˇåããčĄįēãĢäģãĒããĒããããããį§ãæąããĻãããŽã¯ãããŽãããĒãįŊãčĒæ¸ãã§ã¯ãĒããŖããį§ãæ¸æãããŽã¯ãé č¤å¨äŊããįŊãäēēããŽčåžãĢæ˛ããããŽãæãæšŋãæ°ãã§ããããããã¯ããã¤ãĻãŽå
äēēãæĨåä¸é§ãŽéŗã¨ã¨ããĢčĻåēãããéŊå¸ãŽčˇ¯å°čŖãĢæŊããåããĒãč
ãŽäŊ渊ãã§ããŖãã
ãæåãčŋŊãčĄįēãŽä¸ã§ãį§ã¯čĒåˇąãŽåĸįãčč§ŖããĻãããŽãæããã ãä¸åãŽæ¸įŠãæˇąãčĒãŋčžŧããã¨ã¯ãčč
ãŽčĒčãŽåŊĸåŧãĢčĒããå§ããčĒããŽãææ§ãŽåŊĸåŧãã䏿įãĢč§ŖäŊãããã¨ã§ãããããã§ã¯ãåąĨæ´æ¸ãåŧˇãããæéããŽæĻåŋĩââéåģããæĒæĨã¸ã¨į´įˇįãĢãåšįįãĢæĩããã¯ããŽæéââã¯ããã¨ã厚æãå´ŠåŖãããįžåš´åãŽæģč
ãŽæčããäģããŽįŦéãŽį§ãŽéŧåã¨åæããį§ãŽå¤įŦãč¯åŽããã ãããŽãčĒæ¸ãŽæŊäŧããĢãããĻãį§ã¯į¤žäŧãæŧãäģããã䏿Ąį¨ãã¨ããčŠäžĄããéĢæŦĄãĒčĻįšããį¸å¯žåããåãåžããéĸæĨåŽãį§ãŽčˇæ´ãŽįŠēįŊãææããã¨ããį§ãŽčŗčŖãĢã¯ããĢãŗããčĒŦãããčĒįąããŽæĻåŋĩãåģæĨããĻãããåŊŧããĢã¨ãŖãĻãŽčĒįąã¨ã¯ã鏿čĸãŽä¸ããä¸ã¤ãé¸ãļãčŊåããĢéããĒãããį§ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãŽčĒįąã¨ã¯ãåŊŧããŽčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋããŽããŽãããé¸čąããããã¨ã§ããŖããŽã ã
ãčĒæ¸ã¨ã¯ãããį¨ŽãŽãé éãã§ããã ããã¤ãĻãč¯ãããĒį¤žäē¤įããčēĢãåŧãããã įŦãã§éåģãŽæįŠãæã§ãæļãããåŖį¯ãč¨čãĢæ¸ãįããæŖįč
ããããããĢãį§ããžããæ¸įŠã¨ããčŋˇåŽŽãĢé ãäŊããį¤žäŧã¯į§ããčĻã¤ããããĒãīŧ䏿Ąį¨ãĢããīŧããŽã§ã¯ãĒããį§ããåŊŧããŽč˛§å°ãĒčĒčãŽįļ˛ãŽįŽãĢãããããĒããå ´æã¸ã¨į§ģåãããŽã§ããã ãčĒæ¸ãŽã¨ããšããŧããĢãĒãã¨ãããã¨ã¯ãæ
å ąãŽåĻįéåēĻãä¸ãããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒãã䏿åãŽčåžãĢæŊããįŠčĒäŊããŽéãããį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧããããč¨åˇåããåãĢãį´ æã§æ´ãŋåããã¨ã§ãããããŽæŊäŧãŽæéãæˇąãžãã°æˇąãžããģãŠãį§ãŽå
éĸãĢã¯ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãŽãįŊããåĄãæŊ°ããããŽãæˇąããæŋãŖããããã§ããĻįåŽãŽč˛åŊŠãčįŠãããĻããã
įŦŦäēįĢ īŧãĸãŗããããŧãŽčé
ãããããčĒæ¸ãŽéå¯ããéĄãä¸ããã¨ããį§ã¯åãŗããĸãŗããããŧīŧäēåžčåīŧããŽčéãĢįĢãããããã¨ãĢãĒãã ããĢãŗãã¯ãįæ§ãä¸ã¤ãŽåããĢ寞ããĻãæŖå寞ãŽäēã¤ãŽįĩčĢīŧåŊéĄīŧãå°ãåēããĻããžãããŠãĄããčĢįįãĢåĻåŽã§ããĒãįļæ
ããĸãŗããããŧã¨åŧãã ãį§ãŽįãĢãããĻããããŽãĸãŗããããŧã¯č§Ŗæąēä¸čŊãĒįįžã¨ããĻæ¨ĒãããŖãĻããã
ãæŖåŊéĄīŧį§ã¯į¤žäŧãŽä¸åĄã¨ããĻå´åãã䞥å¤ãč¨ŧæããã°ãĒããĒãã ãå寞åŊéĄīŧį§ã¯į¤žäŧãŽåäŋãĒ䞥å¤åēæēãĢåąãããåēæãŽåŽåãåŽããã°ãĒããĒãã
ãããŽäēã¤ãŽčĻæąã¯ããŠãĄããæŖãããįããĻãããããĢã¯ãįŊãå°įããŽč¯åŽãåŋ
čĻã§ãããäēēéã¨ããĻčĒãéĢããããããĢã¯ãããŽč¯åŽãŽæĄäģļã§ãããč¨åˇåããæįĩļããã°ãĒããĒãã ãéĸæĨãĢåããéģčģãŽä¸ã§ãį§ã¯ããŽãĸãŗããããŧãĢåŧãčŖããããįĒãŽå¤ãæĩããéĸ¨æ¯ã¯ããã¤ãĻãŽå
äēēãæããææ
įãĒčĄä¸Ļãŋã§ã¯ãĒããåšįã¨æŠčŊãĢããŖãĻåĄãåēããããįĄæŠčŗĒãĒãįžčąĄããŽéįŠã§ããã ãį§ã¯ãčĒåããĢãŗããŽč¨ããåŽč¨åŊæŗãââããĒããŽæåŋãŽæ ŧåžãã常ãĢåæãĢæŽéįãĒįĢæŗåįã¨ãĒããããĢčĄåããââãĢåžããã¨ããĻãããã¨ãĢæ°ãĨããããããįžäģŖį¤žäŧãĢãããæŽéįãĒåįã¨ã¯ããä礿å¯čŊãĒæ¯čģã§ãããã¨ãããäēēéæ§ãŽį°åĨĒãĢäģãĒããĒããããŽãįŊãéåžŗããĢåžããã¨ããį§ã䏿Ąį¨ã¨ããæˇĩã¸čŋŊããããåæãĢããããĢåžããĒãčĒåããããå¯ä¸ãį§ãã¨ããäēēéãŽå°åŗãįšãæĸããĻããã¨ããįŽčã
ãããŽįįžãæąãããžãžæŠããã¨ã¯ãæŗĨæŋãŽä¸ãé˛ããããĒčļŗãŽéããäŧ´ãã ãé č¤å¨äŊã¯ãäŋĄäģ°ã¨čåžŗãåŧˇãã¨åŧąããŽããã ã§æēãåãäēēéããįĩįæãįļãããåŊŧã¯ãåŧˇåēãĒæåŋãæã¤čč
ããããč¸ãŋįĩĩãåãĢããĻéããåŧąč
ãŽåããĢãįãŽæããããã¨čãããį§ãŽã䏿Ąį¨ãã¨ããæĢæããžããä¸ã¤ãŽč¸ãŋįĩĩã§ã¯ãĒãã ããããį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢåąããĻãčĒåãåŊããŽč¨åˇã¸ã¨å åˇĨããæĄį¨ã¨ããåãŽãčĩĻãããåžããŽããããã¨ããæįĩļããįļããįãŋīŧéģč˛ãäēēãŽæŗĨčãįãŋīŧãåŧãåãããĸãŗããããŧãŽčéãįŦãã§æŠãįļãããŽãã
ãį§ã¯ãåžč
ãé¸ãŧãã¨ããĻãããããã¯ããĢãŗããįæ§ãŽéįãį¤ēããå ´æããããããĢ䏿Šč¸ãŋåēããã¨ã§ãããįåąã§č§Ŗæąēã§ããĒãįįžããįåąã§č§ŖæļãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããã ãæŠčĄãã¨ããčēĢäŊįæįļãĢããŖãĻãããŽãžãžæąããĻįãããã¨ã ããã¤ãĻãŽæŖįč
ã¯ãčŋäģŖåã¨ããåãŽãĸãŗããããŧãĢ寞ããĻãæŋæ˛ģįãĒéåã§æããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããã ãæĨåä¸é§ãã§čĄãįˇ´ãæŠããããŽįįžãŽį´°é¨ãåčĻãįļãããã¨ã§æãŖãã ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¯ãį§ãŽåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊããįĄãã¨å¤åŽããããį§ãŽãĸãŗããããŧã¯ãããŽįŠēįŊããããåŽåãŽå
åĄĢãããæéãã§ãããã¨ãåĢãŗįļããĻãããį§ã¯ããŽčéãĢãããĻãį¤žäŧã፿ãããįŊãã¨ããåŽæãĒįĩąåãæįĩļãããį§ãŽčĒčã¯ãįįžãããžãžãåŧãčŖããããžãžãããŽäēæãŽéĸ¨ãŽä¸ãĢæãããĻãããããŽįčĻããããį§ããįŊãäēēãã¸ã¨å¤čŗĒããĻããĒããã¨ãŽãäŊãããŽč¨ŧæ ãĒãŽã ã
įŦŦå įĢ īŧ夿åãŽåŊŧæšããããã¯įĄéĸåŋãŽįžåĻ
ããĢãŗãã¯ãããŽįŦŦä¸ãŽæšå¤æ¸ãå¤æåæšå¤ããĢãããĻãįžįãĒå¤æãŽæŦčŗĒããįĄéĸåŋīŧ disinterestednessīŧãã¨ããč¨čã§čĒŦæãããããã¯ãå¯žčąĄãčĒåãĢã¨ãŖãĻæį¨ã§ãããããããã¯éåžŗįãĢæŖãããã¨ããŖããåŠåŽŗããä¸åéĸããĻããã ããŽå¯žčąĄãŽåŊĸåŧããŽããŽãį´į˛ãĢčĻŗį
§ããæ
åēĻã§ããã ãįŋģãŖãĻãį§ãčŖããĻããæĄį¨ã¨ããåãŽãˇãšãã ãįēããã¨ãããããĢã¯ãįĄéĸåŋããŽå¯žæĨĩãĢãããéæĒãĒãžã§ãŽãéĸåŋããŽéįŠããããåŊŧããį§ãĢåããįŧåˇŽãã¯ã常ãĢãåŠį¨äžĄå¤ãã¨ããå°ēåēĻãĢæąæãããĻãããį§ã¨ããåå¨ãããããĢåšįįãĢåŠįãįŖããããããĢįĩįšãŽį§ŠåēãäšąããĒãããããããäŊæŦĄãŽåŠåŽŗéĸåŋãĢåēãĨãã夿ã¯ããĢãŗããčĒŦããéĢ貴ãĒãįžį夿ãã¨ã¯ãããįĄį¸ãŽãåãĒãč¨éãĢéããĒãã
ãį§ãčŠčĢã¨ããéãé¸ãã ãŽã¯ãããŽãč¨éããŽä¸įããããčĻŗį
§ããŽä¸įã¸ã¨äēĄåŊããããã§ããã ãé¸čã¨ããåãŽå¯Šå¤ãä¸ãč
ããĄããį§ãŽåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊããæŦ éĨãã¨čĻãĒãã¨ããåŊŧãã¯ããŽįŠēįŊãĢåŽŋããéå¯ãŽåŊĸåŧããčĻčŊã¨ããĻãããåŊŧããŽįŧã¯ãåŽæãããææįŠīŧįžčąĄīŧãŽãŋãčŋŊããããŽčåžãĢããæˇąãæčãŽččŊīŧįŠčĒäŊīŧãæãããã¨ãã§ããĒããããããįãĢã¨ããšããŧãã¨ããĻæŦãčĒãŋãč¨čãį´Ąãč
ã¯ãį¤žäŧããįĄãã¨æããå ´æãĢãããæãčąããĒå¯čŊæ§ãæŊå¨ããĻãããã¨ãįĨãŖãĻããã ã ããã¤ãĻãæļãããčĄãŽéĸ¨æ¯ãææããæŖįč
ã¯ããããčŋäģŖįãĒéŊå¸č¨įģãĢãããĻãįĄį¨ãĒéåŽŗįŠãã¨čĻãĒãããĻããããããããããĢįžãčĻåēãããåŊŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻãŽįžåĻã¨ã¯ãæį¨æ§ãŽį§ŠåēããéļãčŊãĄãããŽãĢãįŦčĒãŽäžĄå¤ãŽå
ãåŊãĻããã¨ã§ããŖãã ãį§ããžãã䏿Ąį¨ã¨ããæįĩļããä¸ã¤ãŽãįžįčĒįąãã¨ããĻåãå
Ĩãį´ããį¤žäŧãĢãæĄį¨īŧåŠį¨īŧããããĒããã¨ã¯ãäģč
ãŽåŠåŽŗéĸåŋããč§Ŗæžãããį´į˛ãĢããŽä¸įãããããĻč¨čãčĻŗį
§ããæ¨ŠåŠãåžããã¨ã¨åįžŠã§ãããį§ã¯ãåŊŧããŽå¤æãŽåäŋĩãĢįģãŖãĻæĻããŽã§ã¯ãĒããåŊŧããŽįč§Ŗãåã°ãĒããããéĢæŦĄãĒčĒčãŽå°åšŗãĢãããĻããã éããĢãčĒåžããč¨čãįŠãŋä¸ããĻãããŽã§ããã
įŦŦä¸įĢ īŧįŠčŗĒã¨ããĻãŽæŦããããã¯č¨æļãŽčč§Ļã
ãããŽčĒčãŽčĒåžãæ¯ãããŽã¯ãæŊ蹥įãĒįčĢã§ã¯ãĒããä¸åãŽæ¸įŠãæã¤ãįŠčŗĒæ§ãã§ããã ãæ¨äģãč¨čã¯ãã¸ãŋãĢãĒč¨åˇã¸ã¨éå
ãããå
ãŽéãã§æļč˛ģãããĻãããããã¯ãĢãŗãįãĢãã´ãĒãŧãæĨĩéãžã§å éããäēēéãŽčēĢäŊãįŊŽãåģããĢãããčąč˛ãããä¸įããŽčąĄåž´ã§ãããããããį§ãŽæå
ãĢããå¤ãŗãæåēĢæŦã¯ãįĸēããĒéãŋãæãĄãį´ãŽįšįļãŽåããæžãĄãããŧã¸ãįš°ãæå
ãĢ垎ããĒæĩæãä¸ããã
ãé č¤å¨äŊããįŊãäēēãã§čĻããããŽįŠēčãĢ寞æãåžããŽã¯ãããŽãããĒãčč§ĻããŽãã荿ļãã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã ãčĒæ¸ã¨ã¯ãåãĒãæ
å ąãŽčģĸéã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãčč
ãæ ŧéããæéãŽį补ããčĒããŽčēĢäŊãéããĻčŋŊäŊé¨ãããæĨĩããĻãčäŊįãĒååŧãã§ãããåąĨæ´æ¸ãį§ãŽä¸åäēåš´ãŽæŗæãæ°čĄãŽč¨åˇãĢå§į¸ŽãããŽãĢ寞ããčĒæ¸ã¯ãäģč
ãŽæ°ååš´ããããã¯æ°įžåš´ãŽæéããį§ãŽįžå¨ãŽä¸ãĢæĄåŧĩããå
åĄĢãããããŽæéãŽčąįŠŖããããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ãããčãŖãēããĒįžåŽããį ´į ããå¯ä¸ãŽéãã¨ãĒãã
ãį§ã¯ãæ¸æŖãŽåãĢįĢã¤ã ããããĢã¯ãį¤žäŧãŽåēæēã§ã¯č¨æ¸Ŧä¸čŊãĒãč¨å¤§ãĒãæēãŽå įŠãããããä¸åãŽæŦãčĒãŋįĩããããŗãĢãį§ãŽčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋã¯æ¸ãæããããį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧã፿ããæĒģã¯ãããŽééãåēããĻããã ããã¤ãĻãŽæŖįč
ã¯ãæĨåä¸é§ãŽéŗã¨ã¨ããĢãå°åŗãĢã¯čŧããĒãį´°é¨ãæŠããããããéĸ¨æ¯ãã¨ããĻåæ§į¯ãããį§ããžããč¨å¤§ãĒæ¸įŠãŽæŖŽãæŠããį¤žäŧããįŠēįŊãã¨åŧãã æéãĢãį§ã ããŽįˇģå¯ãĒæåŗãæ¤ãäģããĻããã ã ãæŦãčĒãã¨ããšããŧããĢãĒãã¨ã¯ãį¤žäŧãä¸ããæŖč§Ŗãåšįããæžãéãããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒããããããį¤žäŧãæį¤ēãããčãæŖč§ŖããŽčŖå´ãĢæŊããæˇąããåãããŽæŗĨæŋãĢčļŗãč¸ãŋå
Ĩãããã¨ã§ãããé č¤ãæããããŽæŗĨãŽãããĒäēēéčããããĢãŗããŽåˇåžšãĒįæ§ã§åæããããŽä¸Ąč
ãæąãããžãžãååãŽåēããĒãããŽæŖįč
ãŽãããĢãįŦãéããĢæŠãįļãããã¨ã ãããŽã¨ããį§ãŽæãĢãããŽã¯ãã¯ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãčǰãĢãåĨĒããã¨ãŽã§ããĒããä¸įãčĒãŋč§ŖããããŽãįŦčĒãŽįž
éį¤ãã§ããã
įŦŦå ĢįĢ īŧæ˛éģãŽé åããããã¯įŠēįŊãŽéãŋ
ãåąĨæ´æ¸ãŽįŠēįŊããį§ã¯ãããžã§ãčåãããįšæ¨ŠããĒãŠã¨ããč¨čã§į˛éŖžãããã¨ããĻãããŽãããããĒããããããįžåŽãŽããŽæéã¯ãããŖã¨æŗĨčããããŖã¨åŋ訹ãĒãããã ãŽãæ˛éģããŽå įŠã§ããŖãã¯ãã ãæãčǰãĢãåŋ
čĻã¨ããããĢįŽčĻããé ããããéŗã ããé¨åąãĢéŋããããŽéå¯ã¯ãéĢæŊãĒå¤éĢãĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒããį¤žäŧã¨ãã厍大ãĒæåããåãéĸããããã¨ã¸ãŽã垎ããĒããããæļããããææãåãã§ããã
ãé č¤å¨äŊãããŽäģŖčĄ¨äŊãæ˛éģããĢãããĻæãããŽã¯ãéé
ˇãĒæˇåãĢčããčč
ã§ã¯ãĒããįĨãŽæ˛éģãĢæļããč¸ãŋįĩĩãåãĢããĻéããäēēéãŽåŧąãã§ããŖãã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ãããããŽãįŊãæ˛éģããåãĢããĻįĢãĄå°Ŋããį§ããžããåŧˇåēãĒæåŋãæã¤ææŗåŽļãĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒãããã čĒåãŽåą
å ´æãåŋ
æģãĢæĸããĻãããé ŧããĒãä¸äēēãŽäēēéãĢéããĒãã ããĢãŗããčĒŦãããį´į˛įæ§ãã¯ãįĸēããĢäēēéãĢä¸įãŽåŽĸčĻŗįãĒæ įĩãŋãä¸ããĻããããããããããŽįæ§ããŠããģãŠææ°ã§ããŖãĻãã䏿Ąį¨ã¨ããåãŽãæįĩļããããããåŽåįãĒéããæĸãããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒããįæ§ã¯ããĒãį§ã¯é¸ã°ããĒããŽããã¨ããåããĢ寞ããå¸å ´åįãįĸēįčĢã¨ããåˇåžšãĒč§Ŗãæį¤ēããããããŽč§Ŗã¯ãåã¨ããĻãŽį§ãŽãįãŋããĢã¯äŊãč§Ļãããã¨ããĒãã
ãããã§į§ãåĻãŗį´ããšããĒãŽã¯ãį¤žäŧãčĻčŋããããŽįĨæ§ã§ã¯ãĒããããŽæ˛éģãŽä¸ã§ããã ãããããã¨ãĢčãããããŽãčŦčãĒåĢįã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã ããã¤ãĻãæļãããčĄãŽį´°é¨ãæŠãįļããããŽæŖįč
ããčĒããæäģŖãŽå
é§č
ã ã¨čĒį¤ēãããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖããåŊŧã¯ãã ãį§ģãå¤ããåŖį¯ãŽä¸ã§ãčĻæ¨ãĻãããĻããããŽãåŋããããĻããããŽãĢéããĢå¯ãæˇģãŖããåŊŧãŽæŖįã¯ãį¤žäŧãŽä¸ģæĩããå¤ããčĒåãæŖåŊåãããããŽį¤ēå¨čĄįēã§ã¯ãĒãããããä¸ģæĩããå¤ããããããčĻããĻãããä¸įãŽåžŽį´°ãĒįžããĢ寞ãããä¸äēēãŽäēēéã¨ããĻãŽčĒ åŽãĒåŋįã§ããŖãã¯ãã ã
ãį§ãäģãæ¸įŠãéããæåãčŋŊãčĄįēããžããããŽãããĒãããããĒåŋįã§ããããã¨æãã ãčĒæ¸ãŽã¨ããšããŧããĢãĒãã¨ãããã¨ã¯ãäģč
ãå§åããįĨčãåžããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒããããããč¨čã¨ããæˇąãæˇĩãĢčēĢãæ˛ãããã¨ã§ãčĒåã¨ããåå¨ããããĢå°ãããä¸åŽå
¨ãĒããŽã§ããããįĨããããģãšã§ããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãįĒãã¤ãããį¤žäŧįãĒįĄäžĄå¤ãããčĒæ¸ã¯ãäēēéįãĒæéæ§ãã¨ãããããæŽéįãĒå°åšŗã¸ã¨č§ŖãæžãŖãĻãããã ããĢãŗãããį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããŽįĩį¤ã§ãįæ§ãŽéįãčĒããããŽå
ãĢãããäŋĄäģ°ããã叿ãã¸ã¨įŽãåãããããĢãį§ããžããčĒåãŽčĒčãŽéįãčĒããĒããã°ãĒããĒããį¤žäŧãĢæĄį¨ãããĒãã¨ããäēåŽã¯ãį§ãŽäēēæ ŧãåĻåŽããããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããåæãĢį§ããį¤žäŧãŽä¸åĄã¨ããĻãäģč
ã¨éĸãããåŊšå˛ãæãããããã¨éĄããä¸äēēãŽåšŗåĄãĒäēēéã§ãããã¨ãããæŽé
ˇãĒãžã§ãĢæĩŽãåŊĢããĢããã
įŦŦäšįĢ īŧéŊå¸ãŽčŋˇåŽŽã¨ãæ¸įŠãŽčŋˇåŽŽ
ãé¨åąãåēãĻãį§ã¯åãŗæŠãå§ãããäēæãŽéĸ¨ã¯į¸å¤ãããįŠããã ããããŽéĸ¨ãåããĻæŠãį§ãŽčļŗåãã¯ãæąēããĻčģŊãããĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããããĢã¯ãčĒããŽå°æĨãĢ寞ããä¸åŽããéåģã¸ãŽåžæã¨ããįŽãĢčĻããĒãéãããļãä¸ããŖãĻãããããããããŽéãŋããããį§ãããŽå°éĸã¨ãããįžåŽããĢįšãæĸããããĻããč¨ŧæ ã§ãããã
ãæŠãã¨ããčĄįēã¯ãæ¸įŠãčĒãŋč§ŖãčĄįēãĢäŧŧãĻããã ããŠãĄãããããããã፿ãããæŖč§ŖãĢčžŋãįããããŽæįčˇéĸãčĩ°ããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒãããããããããĻéãĢčŋˇããčĄãæĸãžããĢįĒãåŊãããããŽä¸äžŋããéåĄæãŽä¸ã§ãčĒåã ããŽãéĸ¨æ¯ããįēčĻããĻããéį¨ã§ããã ãį¤žäŧãæąãããŽã¯ãčŋˇããŽãĒãæįįĩ莝ã§ãããåąĨæ´æ¸ãĢãããĻãįŠēįŊããåŋãŋåĢããããŽã¯ããããįŽįå°ãŽåŽãžããĒããčŋˇãããŽæéãããĒããĄįįŖæ§ãŽãĒãæģįã¨čĻãĒãããããã ããããããĢãŗããčĒŦããčĒčãŽåŊĸåŧãæēããļããä¸įãŽæˇąæˇĩãĢč§ĻãããããĢã¯ãããŽãčŋˇããã¨ãããããģãšãä¸å¯æŦ ãĒãŽã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã
ããã¤ãĻãŽæŖįč
ã¯ãå°åŗã¨ãããåŊĸåŧããæããããĒããéŊå¸ãŽæšŋãæ°ãåããæãããåŊŧã¯ãæ´įļã¨åēįģæ´įããã大éãããããä¸čĻåãĢæ˛ãããããŖã莝å°čŖãĢãäēēéãŽįãŽįåŽãčĻåēãããããŽčˇ¯å°čŖã¯ãåąĨæ´æ¸ãĢãããįŠēįŊããŽããŽã§ããã ãį§ãäģãčĒæ¸ãéããĻæ
ããĻããčŋˇåŽŽããããŽãããĒ莝å°čŖãŽéįŠã§ãããä¸åãŽéŖč§ŖãĒå˛åĻæ¸ããããã¯ä¸įˇ¨ãŽéåãĒå°čĒŦããããĢã¯ãåšįãæŖč§Ŗã¨ããåãŽã大éããããã¯æąēããĻčĻããĒããäēēéãŽéãŽéããč¨é˛ãããĻãããé č¤å¨äŊããįŊãäēēãã§æããããŽåˇåžšãĒįŊãããį§ã¯čĒæ¸ã¨ããåãŽãčŋˇåŽŽæŠčĄããĢããŖãĻãå°ããã¤åĨãŽč˛åŊŠã§åĄãæŋããĻãããããã¯ãå´éĢãĒč¸čĄæ´ģåãĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒãããã ä¸äēēãŽäēēéããčĒåã¨ããå¨ãåŖããĒããããĢåŋ
čĻãĒãååŽãĒãčĒčĄããŽäŊæĨã§ããã
ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ããåãŽã寊å¤ãã¯ãäģåžãįš°ãčŋãããã ãããį§ã¯ããŽããŗãĢåˇã¤ããčĒããŽäžĄå¤ãįãã ãããããããããŽįãŋãæããĻããéããį§ã¯ãžã ãįŊããˇãšãã ããĢåŽå
¨ãĢã¯ååããĻããĒããŽã ã ãįãŋãæãããã¨ãčŋˇããã¨ããããĻčǰãĢãčŠäžĄãããĒãæéãŽä¸ã§ããã éããĢč¨čãį´Ąããã¨ã ãããããŽãä¸čĻããĻįĄæåŗãĢæããæįãįšãåãããĻãããã¨ããį§ãŽãããããŽæŠãŋã¨ãĒããį§ã¯ãį¤žäŧã¨ãã厍大ãĒåå ´ã§ä¸ģåŊšãæŧãããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒããããããĒããããããããŽåå ´ãŽå¤å´ãååãäģããããĻããĒã莝å°ãŽįé
ã§ãä¸įãŽåžŽį´°ãĒåŧå¸ãč´ãåãčĻŗåŽĸãŽä¸äēēã¨ããĻãį§ã¯į§ãŽįããčŦčãĢããããĻ县ãĢč¯åŽãįļãããã¨æãã
įŦŦåįĢ īŧæŗĨæŋããŽå厚ããããã¯čãĒãåĄåē¸
ãé č¤å¨äŊãããŽæŠåš´ãĢčžŋãįãããæˇąãæ˛ŗããŽå
æ¯ããį§ã¯ãĩã¨æãåēããã¤ãŗããŽãŦãŗã¸ãšåˇãŽãģã¨ãããããĢã¯æģãåž
ã¤č
ãį
ããč
ããããĻčĒããŽįŊĒãįŠēčãæąããč
ããĄãéããããŽåˇã¯ãæąēããĻæ¸
ãããĒãįŊãã§ã¯ãĒããããããäēēéãŽææŗįŠãį°ãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãŋãæŋããæˇãŋãĒããããããšãĻãįããåãå
ĨããĻæĩããĻããã ããã¤ãĻį§ã䏿Ąį¨ãĢãããããŽãįŊããĒããŖãšããŽæ¸
æŊãã¨ãããŽåˇãŽæŋãã¯ãããžããĢ寞į
§įã§ããããĒããŖãšãĢãããĻã¯ãä¸į´įŠã¯åžšåēįãĢæé¤ãããįŖ¨ãä¸ããããæŠčŊæ§ã ããčŗčŗããããããããäēēéã¨ããåå¨ãŽįåŽã¯ãæãããĻãŠãĄããĢãããŽã ãããã
ããĢãŗãã¯ãįæ§ãŽæŊįãĒãžã§ãŽį´į˛ããčŋŊæąããããåæãĢåŊŧã¯ãäēēéããæ˛ããŖãæ¨ããŽãããĒåå¨ã§ããããããããžãŖãããĒããŽãé ãåēããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒãã¨ãčĒŦããĻãããį§ã¯ãčĒåã¨ãããæ˛ããŖãæ¨ãããį¤žäŧãŽãžãŖãããĒčĻæ ŧãĢåããããã¨ããĻãããŽããŗãĢčģãŋãæããããĢãĒãŖãĻããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ã¯ãããŽčĻæ ŧãĢéŠåããĒããŖãã¨ããåŽŖåãĢéããĒãã ãããããããŽæŗĨæŋããŽæ˛ŗãŽãããĒčĻįšãĢįĢãĻã°ãį§ãŽãįŠēįŊããã莿´ãŽãæŦ æãããããã¯åãĒãäēēéãŽãæ¨Ąæ§ããŽä¸ã¤ãĢéããĒããĒããį¤žäŧããįĄäžĄå¤ãã¨æããį§ãŽæéã¯ãããŽæ˛ŗãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãįĄæ°ãŽį°ãŽä¸į˛ã¨ããĻã大ããĒæĩããŽä¸ãĢæēļãčžŧãã§ããã
ãį§ãäģãčŦčãĢčĒããĒããã°ãĒããĒããŽã¯ãį§ãæįĩļããį¤žäŧããæĒããĒãŽã§ã¯ãĒããããŽį¤žäŧããžããåšįã¨ããåãŽãåŧˇčŋĢčĻŗåŋĩããĢé§ãįĢãĻãããä¸åŽå
¨ãĒäēēã
ãŽéãžããĢéããĒãã¨ããäēåŽã§ãããéĸæĨåŽããžããčĒããŽãįŊãããįļæãããããĢãåŋ
æģãĢčǰããé¸åĨããããåžãĒããåŧąãäēēéãŽä¸äēēãĒãŽã ã ãããčããã¨ããį§ãŽåŋãŽä¸ãĢããŖãå°ãŖãæãã¯ãéããĒæ˛ããŋã¸ã¨åŊĸãå¤ãããį§ã¯ãį§ã䏿Ąį¨ãĢããåŊŧããåĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒããåŊŧããæąēããĻčĻããã¨ãŽãĒããããŽæŋãŖãæ˛ŗãŽæˇąãããįŦãã§éããĢčĻåŽãč
ã§ããããã¨æããããã¯ãį¤žäŧãŽãŦãŧãĢããå¤ããč
ãĢã ã訹ããããããį¨ŽãŽæåããŽãããĒããããããĒįĨããŽæéã§ããã
įŦŦåä¸įĢ īŧæĨåä¸é§ãŽåĢįããããã¯čˇ¯å°čŖãŽæĩæ
ããã¤ãĻãéŊå¸ãæĨéãĢãįŊããåĄãæŋããããĻããæäģŖãĢãæĨåä¸é§ãéŗ´ãããĻ莝å°čŖãæŠãįļããããŽæŖįč
ããåããããĒæ˛ããŋãæąããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã ããããåŊŧã¯ãææã¨ããåãŽãåšįãããæąæ¸ãŽéĸåŊąãæŽãä¸äžŋã§ããããéĸ¨æ
ããį´°é¨ãåŖããĻããæ§ããåˇåžšãĢããã¤æ
ãããããĢčĻã¤ããĻãããåŊŧãŽæŠčĄã¯ãį¤žäŧãŽé˛æŠãĢ寞ããæ´žæãĒį°č°įŗãįĢãĻã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãåŋããããĻããããŽããĄãŽãæåžãŽč¨ŧäēēããĢãĒããã¨ãããæĨĩããĻåäēēįã§ãæ
ãžããããĒčĄįēã§ããŖãã
ãįžäģŖãŽãã¸ãŋãĢåãããį¤žäŧãĢãããĻãį§ãŽãįŠēįŊãŽæŖįãããžããããŽãããĒč¨ŧč¨ã¨ããĻãŽæåŗãæãĄå§ããĻããã ããšããŧãããŠãŗã¨ããčĒčãŽæĒģãĢéãčžŧããããæįãĢãŧãã ããæŠããããįžäģŖäēēãĢã¨ãŖãĻãéį̝ãŽã´ãããåŖãŽæãŋããããã¯čĄãæĸãžããŽéåĄæã¯ãåãĒãããã¤ãēãã§ãããĒããããããį§ãŽãããĢį¤žäŧãŽæŠåš
ããåãæŽãããäēēéãĢã¨ãŖãĻãããŽãã¤ãēããããä¸įãįããĻããč¨ŧã¨ãĒãã ãį§ã¯ãčĒåãį¤žäŧãŽåŊšãĢįĢãŖãĻããĒããã¨ãããã¯ãéåēĻãĢåä¸ãããã¨ã¯ãĒããåŊšãĢįĢããĒããããããį§ã¯ãåŊšãĢįĢã¤ãã¨ã ããæąããããäēēã
ãčĻčŊã¨ãããä¸įãŽæŠåžŽããæžãä¸ãããã¨ãã§ãããããã¯ããã¤ãĻãŽæŖįč
ããæŗĨæŋãŽä¸ãĢæ˛ãįžããįĻį¤ĢãčĻã¤ãåēãããŽã¨åããéããĒæåã§ããã
ãããŽåĢįã¯ã垿
ĸãĒčĒåˇąč¯åŽã¨ã¯įĄį¸ã§ãããããããčĒåãŽįĄčŊããåŧãåããããã§ããĒããããŽä¸įãŽä¸é¨ã¨ããĻåŧå¸ãįļããã¨ãããåžšåēãããåĄåē¸ããã¸ãŽčĻæã§ããã ããĢãŗããčĒŦãããåŽč¨åŊæŗãããį§ã¯į§ãĒããĢč§Ŗéãį´ããããã¯ãčąéã¨ããĻįãããã¨ããåŊäģ¤ã§ã¯ãĒãããčĒããŽåŧąããčĒããããŽåŧąããŽãžãžãĢãäģč
ãä¸įãĢ寞ããĻčĒ åŽã§ãããã¨ãããæ˛éģãŽåŊäģ¤ã§ããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãåãåãŖããã¨ãŽãããŽéããæã§ãããã§ãä¸åãŽæŦãéãã䏿Šãč¸ãŋåēããã¨ãããŽįš°ãčŋããŽéåãŽä¸ãĢãããį§ã¨ããäēēéãŽãå¯ä¸įĄäēãŽãåŊĸåŧããåŽŋãŖãĻããã
įŦŦåäēįĢ īŧæ¸įŠã¨ããåãŽč§ĻčĻããããã¯ãã¸ãŋãĢã¸ãŽåé
ãããŽæŖįãæ¯ãããŽã¯ããã¯ãįŠčŗĒã¨ããĻãŽæ¸įŠã§ããã ãįģéĸä¸ãŽæåã¯ãæå
ã§ãšã¯ããŧãĢãããããŗãĢæļãåģãããããĢã¯äŊãŽæĩæãæŽããĒããããããį´ãŽæ¸įŠã¯ãįŠįįãĒãåŖãã¨ããĻį§ãŽåãĢįĢãĄãĩããããããŽåãŋãããŽæč§ĻããããŽéãŋãããã¯ããĢãŗããčĒŦãããįŠēéãģæéãã¨ããåŊĸåŧããæãæŋå¯ãĢäŊįžããĻããįŠčŗĒã§ããã
ãį§ãéŖč§ŖãĒå˛åĻæ¸ãčĒãŋé˛ããã¨ããį§ã¯æ
å ąãŽæĩˇãæŗŗãã§ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããį§ã¯ããļãŠã¤ããį´ãŽå˛Šå ´ããįĒãįĢãĻããããĢããĻįģãŖãĻãããŽã ãããŽčĻįãããŽé
ãããããåšįåãããįžäģŖãĢ寞ããæå¤§ãŽæĩæã¨ãĒããé č¤å¨äŊããæŗĨčãäēēéãŽæ
åŋĩãč¨čãĢåŽįããããã¨čĻéãããããĢãį§ããžããį´ã¨ããįŠčŗĒãéããĻãčĒããŽčēĢäŊæčĻãį ãæžãžããĻããã
ãį¤žäŧã¯į§ãããã¸ãŋãĢãŽč¨åˇãã¨ããĻåĻįãããã¨ãããããããæŦãčĒãį§ãŽæå
ã¯ãã¤ãŗã¯ãŽåãã¨į´ãŽįšįļãæãããããĢåģãžãããäģč
ãŽéãã¨į´æĨč§ĻãåãŖãĻãããããŽč§ĻčĻįãĒįĩé¨ã¯ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ãããčãŖãēããĒįžåŽãããå§åįãĒčŗĒéã§æŧãæŊ°ãã ãį§ã¯ãæŦãčĒããããã¯ãį¤žäŧã¨ãã大ããĒįŠčĒãĢæĄį¨ããããããŽæēåã§ã¯ãĒããããããį¤žäŧã፿ããįŠčĒããããĢ貧į¸ãĒããŽã§ããããæ´ããį§čĒčēĢãŽå
å´ãĢãããåĨãŽįŠčĒããč˛ããããŽååŧã§ããããã¤ãĻãŽæŖįč
ããå°åŗãĢãĒã莝å°ãĢčĒåã ããŽåŽåŽãčĻåēãããããĢãį§ããžããæ¸įŠã¨ããčŋˇåŽŽãŽä¸ã§ãčǰãĢãæ¯é
ãããĒããčĒįąãĒæ˛éģããæ§į¯ããĻããã
įŦŦåä¸įĢ īŧčĒčãŽéįããããã¯å¤įŦãŽãå´éĢã
ããį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããčĒãŋįĩããã¨ããį§ãŽåŋãĢæŽãŖããŽã¯ãįæ§ãä¸čŊã§ããã¨ããįĸēäŋĄã§ã¯ãĒãããããįæ§ãæąēããĻå°éãããã¨ãŽã§ããĒããåŖããŽåå¨ã§ããŖãããĢãŗãã¯ãäēēéãä¸įãææĄãããã¨ããéããŠããģãŠįæ§ãį ãæžãžããĻããããŽå
ãĢãããįŠčĒäŊããĢã¯č§Ļãããã¨ãã§ããĒãã¨åŗããæãããį§ããĄã¯ãčĒåããĄãäŊãåēããčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋã¨ããå°ããĒåŗļãŽä¸ã§ãįžčąĄã¨ããæŗĸæãĄéãįēããĻãããĢéããĒããŽã ã
ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãåãåããį¤žäŧããæįĩļãããæĨã
ãŽä¸ã§ãį§ã¯ããŽãčĒčãŽéįãããčēĢãåããããĒįãŋã¨ã¨ããĢåŽæããã ãéĸæĨåŽãį§ãŽåąĨæ´æ¸ãįēãã䏿Ąį¨ã¨ãã寊å¤ãä¸ãã¨ããåŊŧã¯į§ãŽãįŠčĒäŊããčĻãĻã¯ããĒããåŊŧã¯ãåŊŧãŽčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋãæããããįžčąĄīŧ莿´ãåš´éŊĸīŧãã ããåãåãããããåŊŧãŽä¸įãŽčĢįãĢéŠåããĒãã¨æããĻããã ãã ããããããĢãŗããæãããããĢãčĒčãĢįžããĒãããã¨ããŖãĻããããĢåŽå¨ããĒãããã§ã¯ãĒããããããį¤žäŧãŽčĒčãŽįļ˛ãŽįŽãĢãããããĒããé¨åãĢãããį§ãŽåŽåãŽæŦäŊããčǰãĢãäžĩãããĒãéãŋãæãŖãĻæ˛æŽŋããĻããã
ãããŽãčĒčã§ããĒãããŽãã¨å¯žåŗããã¨ããäēēã¯åŊĸ厚ããããææ
ãĢčĨ˛ãããããĢãŗãã¯ããããįžãŽãããĢå
ãĢãããå´éĢãã¨ããč¨čã§äģãããããããã¯ãããžããĢ厍大ãĒããŽããããã¯ããžããĢæˇąæˇĩãĒããŽãåãĢããĻãčĒããŽįĄåããæãã¨åæãĢãããŽå§åįãĒåå¨ãĢč§ĻããĻãããã¨čĒäŊãĢãéããĒéããčĻããæčĻã§ããã ãä¸åäēæŗãįĄčˇãé¨åąãĢįŦãåãæŽãããį§ã¯ãį¤žäŧįãĒåŊšå˛ãåĨãåãããåĨãåēããŽãåãã¨ããĻãããŽä¸įãŽåēįĨããŦæ˛éģã¨åãåãŖãĻãããããã¯å¯ãããåŋį´°ããã¨ãĢã¯éããĒããããããããŽæ˛éģããããį¤žäŧãŽåŽãŖãŊããĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢæąæãããĻããĒããį´åēĻãŽéĢããįŠčĒäŊããŽæ°é
ãĒãŽã§ã¯ãĒãããį§ã¯ãį¤žäŧãĢæĄį¨ãããįč§Ŗå¯čŊãĒãįžčąĄããĢãĒããã¨ãĢå¤ąæããããããŽãããã§ãčǰããįŽãčãããå´éĢãĒå¤įŦããŽæˇĩãĢããã ä¸äēēãčŦčãĢįĢã¤æ¨ŠåŠãåžããŽã§ããã
įŦŦååįĢ īŧååãĒãæŖįãŽæãĻããããã¯æļãããč ãŽįžåĻ
ããã¤ãĻãæąäēŦãŽé
ã
ãæŠããæļãããéĸ¨æ¯ãæ
ããã ããŽæŖįč
ããčĒããį¤žäŧãŽä¸ģåŊšã¨ããĻčå
ãæĩ´ãŗããã¨ãæãã§ã¯ããĒããŖããåŊŧã¯ããããæĨéãĢå¤č˛ãéããéŊå¸ãŽé°ãĢé ããåŋãåģãããĻãã莝å°ããčǰã饧ãŋãĒãåģåąãŽäŊãžããĢãčĒåčĒčēĢãŽå¤įŦãĒéãéãåãããĻããã ãåŊŧãŽæŠåš´ã¯ãæąēããĻč¯ãããĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒããŖãã¨č¨ããããä¸éãŽæĩčĄããåãæŽãããįŦãéããĢčĄãæŠããįŦãéããĢæåãįļ´ããããŽå§ŋã¯ãåšįãéãããįžäģŖãŽåēæēããčĻãã°ãåãĒããå¯ããé éč
ããĢæ ããããããĒããããããåŊŧãããŽå¤įŦãĒæŠčĄãŽæãĻãĢčĻã¤ããĻããããŽã¯ãį¤žäŧãæį¤ēãããčãŖãēããĒæŖįžŠãããããã¯ãããĢæ°¸įļįã§ãã¯ãããĢæˇąãäēēéãŽįåŽã§ããŖãã¯ãã ã
ãåŊŧãæãããæŖįãã¨ã¯ãäŊããŽįŽįãéæãããããŽį§ģåã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãä¸įãčĒåãįĄčĻããčŋŊãčļããĻããä¸ã§ãããã§ããĒããčĒåãŽčļŗčŖãæããå°éĸãŽæč§Ļãæ
ãããæĩæããŽåŊĸåŧã§ããŖãã ãį§ã¯ãåŊŧãŽååããããĻåŧã°ãĒããååã¨ããč¨åˇããžããį¤žäŧãäēēéãåéĄãããããŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãŽä¸ã¤ãĢéããĒãããã ãåŊŧã¯ãã ãŽãæŖįč
ãã§ãããį§ããžããäģã¯ãã ãŽã䏿Ąį¨č
ãã§ãããããããããŽč¨åˇãŽä¸ãĢã¯ãčǰãĢãåäģããããĒããčǰãĢãåĨĒãããĒãæéãæĩããĻããã ãåŊŧãčǰãããĒãå¤ãŽčˇ¯å°ã§ãčĄį¯ãŽåžŽããĒå
ãĢįžãčĻåēãããããĢãį§ããžããããŽãįĄčˇãã¨ããæéãŽä¸ã§ãæ¸įŠãŽé ãæžã¤åžŽããĒįĨæ§ãŽå
ãĢãä¸äēēãŽäēēéã¨ããĻãŽįæãčĻåēããį¤žäŧãĢįåããããčĒããããã¨ãããã éããĢãčĒããŽčĒčãŽéįãæąããĻįãåããã¨ãããã¯æ˛åã§ã¯ãĒããä¸ã¤ãŽãåŽæããããįãŽåŊĸåŧãã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã
įŦŦåäēįĢ īŧ䏿Ąį¨ã¨ããåãŽåēæ
ãæēãŽä¸ãĢįŊŽããããããŽįŊãå°įããį§ã¯ããä¸åēĻčĻã¤ããã ããã¤ãĻã¯į§ãåĻåŽãããæģååŽŖåããŽãããĢčĻããããŽį´įããäģã¯å°ãéãŖã襨æ
ãčĻããĻãããããã¯ãį§ã¨ããäēēéããį¤žäŧã¨ãããä¸åŽå
¨ãĒčĒčä¸ģäŊããĢããŖãĻčĒãŋč§ŖãããĒããŖãã¨ããããã ããã ããŽč¨é˛ã§ããã ããĢãŗãããį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããŽåēæãĢãããĻãåŊĸčä¸åĻãéĨãŖãĻããæˇˇčŋˇãæ´įãããã¨ãããããĢãããŽä¸æĄį¨éįĨããžããį§ãŽįãĢããããæˇˇčŋˇããæ´įãããããŽåēæã¨ããĻæŠčŊãå§ããĻããã
ãį§ã¯ãį¤žäŧã¨ãã厍大ãĒæ¸įŠãŽä¸é ãĢãæŖããå°åˇããããã¨ãĢå¤ąæãããããããããŽčŊä¸ã¨ããĻãŽčĒåãåãå
Ĩããã¨ããį§ã¯į§čĒčēĢãŽįŠčĒããį§čĒčēĢãŽæäŊã§æ¸ãå§ãããããŽãäŊįŊããæãĢå
ĨãããŽã ã ãé č¤å¨äŊããããŽæŗĨæŋããŽå¤§æ˛ŗãŽãģã¨ãã§ãä¸åŽå
¨ãĒäēēã
ãčŠãå¯ãåãå§ŋãĢæããčĻåēãããããĢãį§ããžããčĒããŽä¸åŽå
¨ãããčĒããŽãåŧąããããããŽãžãžåˇŽãåēããã¨æããį§ã¯ã¨ããšããŧãã¨ããĻæŦãčĒãŋãč¨čãį´Ąããããã¯äģč
ããåĒäŊãĢįĢã¤ããã§ã¯ãĒããį§ã¨åããããĢãį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢéĻ´æãããįŦãã§éããĻããčǰããŽãããŽããããããĒãåž´ãã¨ãĒãããã§ããã
ã䏿Ąį¨ãããŽä¸æåããį§ã¯ãã¯ãæįĩļãŽč¨čã¨ããĻã¯čĒãžãĒããããã¯ãããåãŽåą
å ´æã¯ããã§ã¯ãĒãããåã ããŽčˇ¯å°ã¸æŠãåēããã¨ãããåˇåžšãĒãããčĒ åŽãĒãããŽä¸įãããŽå°ãã§ããã¨åãæĸããã ãäēæãŽéĸ¨ãããĢãŧããŗãæēãããį§ã¯ããŖããã¨įĢãĄä¸ãããæĨåä¸é§ãéŗ´ãããããĒæ°æãĄã§ã䏿Šãč¸ãŋåēãããããĢã¯ãåšįãæŖč§ŖããæĄį¨ã䏿Ąį¨ããĒãããã åē大ã§ãéããĒãį§ãŽãããŽãįŠēįŊããåēããŖãĻããã
įŦŦåå įĢ īŧåž æŠãŽįžčąĄåĻããããã¯ãåž ã¤ããã¨ãŽåĢį
ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨãåãåããžã§ãŽæ°æĨéããããã¯æŦĄãŽéĸæĨãæ§ããįŠēįŊãŽæ°éąéããããĢã¯ãåŊĸ厚ãããããåž
æŠããŽæéãæ¨ĒãããŖãĻãããį¤žäŧã¨ãã寊å¤č
ãããŽåŽŖåãåž
ã¤ã¨ããæéã¯ãã¯ãį§ãŽææįŠã§ã¯ãĒããĒããããã¯ãäģč
ãŽæŖæįãĒ夿ãĢããŖãĻåģãžãããäģåžįãĒæéã¸ã¨å¤čŗĒããĻããžããŽã ããĢãŗãããį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããĢãããĻãæéã¯æã
ãŽå
įãĒį´čĻŗãŽåŊĸåŧã§ããã¨čĒŦããã¨ãããããĢã¯ä¸ģäŊãŽčŊåæ§ãåæã¨ãããĻãããããããįžåŽãŽãåž
æŠããĢãããĻãæéã¯éåŠãĒåįŠã¨ãĒãŖãĻį§ãŽį˛žįĨãåãåããäŊãããĒãã§ãããã¨ãŽčĻįãäŊč
ã§ããĒãįļæ
ã§įãžããã¨ãŽææã
ãããããããŽååįãĒãåž
æŠãããčŊåįãĒãåž
æŠãã¸ã¨čģĸæãããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒãã ãããã ãé č¤å¨äŊãŽæåĻãĢãããĻããåž
ã¤ãã¨ããčĄįēã¯ãã°ãã°éčĻãĒæåŗãæã¤ãæ˛éģããįĨããã¤ãčĒãããããŽãåž
ã¤ãã¨ããããã¯ãåãčŋããŽã¤ããĒãéãĄãį¯ããčĒåãããã¤ã訹ãããæĨãåž
ã¤ãã¨ãããŽåž
æŠã¯ãæąēããĻįĄįēãĒįŠēįŊã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãčĒåãŽå
éĸãĢæžąãæŋããčĻã¤ããä¸į´įŠãæ˛æŽŋããããããŽãéããĒã鏿ããŽæéã§ããã
ãį§ã¯ãįĩæãåž
ã¤ã ããŽčĒåãããã¯ãæĨãããã¨ã¯ãĒãã ãããŽåž
æŠãŽæéããããį§ãĢãæčãŽč´
æ˛ĸããä¸ããĻããããæĄį¨ãããååģãŋãŽãšãąã¸ãĨãŧãĢãĢčŋŊããããįŊãäēēã
ããĢã¯æąēããĻ訹ãããĒããããŽæžąãã ããããæˇąãæéãį§ã¯ããã§ããĢãŗããŽéŖč§ŖãĒčĢįãä¸čĄãã¤ååŧããčĒåãŽčĄčã¸ã¨å¤ããĻãããį¤žäŧãį§ããäŋįããĢããĻããéãĢãį§ã¯į§čĒčēĢãŽčĒčããåŽæãã¸ã¨čŋãĨããĻãããããŽéčģĸãŽįēæŗããããåŧąč
ãĢ訹ãããå¯ä¸ãŽããããĻčŦčãĒæĩæã§ããã
įŦŦåä¸įĢ īŧæščŠã¨ããåãŽæį´ããããã¯åŽå ãŽãĒãįŦįŊ
ãį§ã¯äģãããããĻč¨čãįļ´ãŖãĻããã ãããã¯ãčǰããĢčĒãžãããã¨ãåæã¨ããã襨įžãã§ããã¨åæãĢããŠããĢãčžŋãįããã¨ãŽãĒããįŦįŊãã§ãããã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¨ããã䏿šįãĒæįĩļãŽæį´ãåãåãŖãį§ãĢã§ãããŽã¯ãããŽæįĩļãŽåããå´ãĢããį¤žäŧãĢ寞ããä¸éãŽãæščŠãã¨ããåãŽæį´ãæ¸ãéããã¨ã ãã ã
ããĢãŗãã¯ãįæ§ãčĒããŽéįããããžããæŖããæŠčŊãããã¨ããæšå¤īŧã¯ãĒããŖãŧã¯īŧãã¨åŧãã ãį§ãŽããŽæįĢ ããžããį§ãæįĩļããį¤žäŧãæģæãããããŽæĻå¨ã§ã¯ãĒããį§čĒčēĢãŽčĒčããŠããžã§åąãããŠãã§æĢæãããŽããįĸēããããããŽãčĒåˇąæšå¤ãŽč¨é˛ã§ãããį§ã¯ãį§ã䏿Ąį¨ãĢããéĸæĨåŽãč˛Ŧããčŗæ ŧãæããĒããåŊŧãããžããéãããčĒčãŽæ įĩãŋãŽä¸ã§ãæåãå°Ŋãããã¨ããĻããä¸åŽå
¨ãĒåå¨ãĢéããĒãããã ãį§ã¯ãã ãåŊŧããčĻčŊã¨ãããäŊįŊããĢãããŽãããĒå°ãéãããåãčĒ åŽãĒæį´ĸãæ¯ãĨããĻããã¨ããäēåŽããéããĢį´ãŽä¸ãĢåŽįããããã¨éĄãã
ããã¤ãĻãŽæŖįč
ããčǰãĢé ŧãžãããã¨ããĒããæļãããčĄãŽč¨æļãį´°å¯ãĢč¨é˛ãįļãããããĢãåŊŧãŽæįĢ ã¯ãåŊæãŽį¤žäŧãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯ãįĄį¨ãŽéˇįŠãã§ããŖããããããĒããããããæäģŖãä¸ãããã¤ãĻãŽéĸ¨æ¯ãåŽå
¨ãĢå¤ąãããã¨ããåŊŧãŽįļ´ãŖãč¨čã¯ãå¤ąãããäēēéæ§ãåŧãŗæģããããŽå¯ä¸ãŽå莝ã¨ãĒãŖãã ãį§ãŽããŽã䏿Ąį¨ãŽč¨é˛ãããžãããã¤ãčǰããŽįŽãĢįãžãæĨãæĨããããããĒããį¤žäŧãŽãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢéĻ´æãããįŦãã§éããĻããčǰãããããŽæįĢ ãčĒãã ã¨ãããããããããĢãä¸äēēãŽã䏿 ŧåĨŊãĒæŠčĄč
ããããŽã ãã¨ã垎ããĒåŽãããæããĻããããĒããããŽã¨ããį§ãŽã䏿Ąį¨ãã¨ããįĩé¨ã¯ãåããĻäģč
ã¨įšãããããŽãå
Ŧå
ąįãĒæåŗããį˛åžããã
įŦŦåå ĢįĢ īŧæŗĨæŋãŽčĒįģåããããã¯åŧąããŽč¯åŽ
ãé č¤å¨äŊããããŽįæļ¯ããããĻčŋŊãæąãããŽã¯ãåŧˇãč
ããĄãŽæ´å˛ã§ã¯ãĒããæ´å˛ãŽåŊąãĢé ãããåŧąãč
ããĄããŽååŽã§ããŖãã ã䏿Ąį¨ãįš°ãčŋãä¸ã§ãį§ã¯čĒåããåŧˇãäēēéãã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ãåĢã¨ãããģãŠæãįĨããããããĢãŗããŽįčĢãæĻå¨ãĢį¤žäŧãčĢį ´ãããã¨ããĻããč
šãæ¸ãã°æčã¯äšąããéå¸ŗãŽæŽéĢãčĻãã°åŋã¯čãããį§ã¯ãįæ§ãŽå
ã ãã§įãããããį´į˛ãĒä¸ģäŊããĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒããčäŊãŽčĻæąãĢįŋģåŧãããä¸éãŽįŽãĢæ¯ãããæŗĨčããéģč˛ãäēēãããŽããŽã§ããã
ãããããããŽãåŧąããããããį§ããĢãŗããŽįŦåįãĒįæ§ããæãåēããé č¤ãŽæˇąãæ
æ˛ã¸ã¨įšãæĸããĻãããã ãčĒåãŽä¸åŽå
¨ããčŦčãĢåãå
Ĩãããã¨ãį¤žäŧãŽãŦãŧãĢãĢäšããĒãčĒåããįĄįãĢãéĢæŊããĢäģįĢãĻä¸ãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãããã ã䏿 ŧåĨŊãĒãžãžãã§ãããĢįŊŽããã¨ãããŽåą
åŋå°ãŽæĒããĢčãįļãããã¨ã ã莝å°čŖãŽæŗĨæŋãĢčļŗãåãããĒããããæĨåä¸é§ãéŗ´ãããĻæŠãįļããããŽæŖįč
ãŽãããĢãį§ããžããčĒåãŽæŦ æãæąãããžãžãããŽéŊå¸ãŽįŽčããĒããįļãããį§ãŽčĒįģåã¯ãæąēããĻæ´įˇ´ãããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ã䏿Ąį¨ã¨ããåãŽæļãã´ã ã§äŊåēĻãäŋŽæŖãããéģããŋãį ´ããããããŋããŧããããšãąããã§ãããããããããŽæąããŽä¸ãĢãããį§ãããŽä¸įã§ãįããĻãããããããã¨ãŽãįĸēããĒæč§ĻããæŽãŖãĻããã
įŦŦåäšįĢ īŧčļ čļčĢįįĩąčĻããããã¯æŖäšąããčĒåˇąãŽįĩąå
ã䏿Ąį¨ãéããį¤žäŧįãĒåąæ§ãåĨãåãããĻãããããģãšã¯ãčĒåˇąã¨ããåå¨ãããŠããŠãĢéŖæŖããĻãããããĒææãäŧ´ããæ¨æĨãŽį§ã¯ãæåž
ãĢč¸ãč¨ããžããåŋåč
ãã§ãããäģæĨãŽį§ã¯ãįĨãããæåč
ãã§ãããææĨãŽį§ã¯ãäŊč
ã§ãããĒããĒããããããĒããããŽæįĩļããæŖäšąããįĩé¨ãŽæįããä¸äŊäŊãįšãæĸããĻãããŽã ãããã
ãããã§ããĢãŗãããį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããŽæˇąæˇĩã§æį¤ēãããčļ
čļčĢįįĩąčĻãã¨ããæĻåŋĩãããĢãããĢååŽãĒãĒãĸãĒããŖãæãŖãĻįĢãĄįžããĻããããĢãŗããĢããã°ãããããčĒčããį§ãŽãčĒčã§ãããããĢã¯ãããããŽå¤æ§ãĒ襨įžãä¸č˛ĢããĻįĩãŗã¤ãããį§ã¯čããīŧIch denkeīŧãã¨ããæ šæēįãĒæčãŽįĩąä¸ãåŋ
čĻã§ãããããããããįĩé¨ãå¯čŊãĢããįŠļæĨĩãŽæĄäģļã§ãããčĒåˇąãčĒåˇąã§ãããããŽæå°åäŊãŽå
ã§ããã
ãį¤žäŧãį§ãĢã䏿Ąį¨ãã¨ãããŠããĢãč˛ŧããį§ãŽæéããįŠēįŊãã¨åŧãŗæ¨ãĻãĢããã¨ããåŊŧãã¯į§ãŽå¤éĸįãĒįžčąĄãčŖããĻãããĢéããĒããããããããŽæįĩļãŽįãŋãåãæĸããåŗæ¸é¤¨ãŽåˇããæ¤
åãĢåē§ããããŧã¸ããããį§ãŽå
å´ãĢã¯ãäžįļã¨ããĻæēãããĒããįĩąčĻããŽåē§ãéŽåē§ããĻããããį§ã¯ãæįĩļãããã ããį§ã¯ã莝å°ãæŠããĻããã ããį§ã¯ããĢãŗããčĒãã§ããã ãããããŽãä¸čĻããĻįĄéĸäŋã§ãæ¨ããĒæįããä¸ã¤ãŽãį§ãŽäēēįãã¨ããĻįĩąåãįļããĻããããŽåãããã¯ãčǰãĢæĄį¨ãããåŋ
čĻããĒããčǰãĢæŋčĒãããåŋ
čĻããĒãããã ãį§ãį§ã¨ããĻãããĢãããããã¨ããįæ§ãŽæãæˇąãå ´æã§č¨ŧæãįļããĻãããããŽįĩąčĻãŽéããĒåããããéããį§ã¯į¤žäŧã¨ãã厍大ãĒčæŗĸãĢéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãžããĻé§æŖãããã¨ã¯ãĒããį§ã¯ãį§ãŽæčãŽä¸ģã¨ããĻãããŽä¸æ ŧåĨŊãĒįĩé¨ãä¸ã¤ãŽãįåŽãã¸ã¨įˇ¨ãŋä¸ãããã¨ãã§ãããŽã ã
įŦŦäēåįĢ īŧäēæãŽå ã¨ãįĄéĸåŋãŽįĨįĨ
ãé¨åąãåēãĻãį§ã¯åãŗčĄã¸åēãã ãåé ã§į§ãįĒãæžããããŽäēæãŽå
ã¯ãäģãåĨãŽčĄ¨æ
ãčĻããĻãããããã¯į§ãé¸åĨããåˇé
ˇãĒå
ã§ã¯ãĒãããã ãããĢå¨ãããŽããããŽä¸åŽå
¨ããŽãžãžãĢįããį
§ããåēãããĢãŗãįãĒãįĄéĸåŋãŽįžããæšããå
ã§ããã ãčĄčˇ¯æ¨šãŽčĨčãå¤ãŗãããĢãŽã˛ãŗå˛ãããããĻ䏿Ąį¨éįĨããĢããŗãĢåŋã°ããĻæŠãä¸äēēãŽäēēéãå
ã¯ããããã䞥å¤ãŽå¤å¯Ąã§åãããã¨ãĒãããã įžčąĄã¨ããĻå
ãŋčžŧãã§ããã
ãé č¤å¨äŊããããŽæŗĨæŋããŽå¤§æ˛ŗãŽå
æ¯ãĢčĻãããŽããããããããŽãįããį
§å°ãã§ããŖãã¯ãã ãčč
ããčŖåãč
ãããããĻį§ãŽãããĒčŊé¸č
ããå¤§æ˛ŗãŽæĩããŽä¸ã§ã¯įããå°ããįããŽæįã§ããã ãį§ã¯ãčĒåãŽãįŠēįŊããåãããããĢįĻããŽãããããįŠēįŊã¨ã¯ãäŊããĒããã¨ã§ã¯ãĒããäŊããįæããããŽãåž
ãŖãĻãããį´į˛ãĒæéãããŽããŽã§ãããčļ
čļčĢįįĩąčĻã¨ããå
ãæãĢããĻãį§ã¯ããŽįŠēįŊãŽä¸ãĢãį§ã ããŽčˇ¯å°ãčĻåēããĻããã ãããŽæŖįč
ããæĨåä¸é§ãŽéŗãéŋãããĒãããčŋäģŖåã¨ãã大ããĒįŠčĒããéļãčŊãĄããå°ããĒįžããæžãéãããããĢãį§ããžããããŽįå¤ãããæéãŽä¸ã§ãč¨čãŽčŖå´ãĢæŊããįŠčĒäŊããŽåžŽããĒéããã䏿åãã¤ä¸å¯§ãĢæŦãåãŖãĻããããã
æįĩįĢ īŧ䏿Ąį¨éįĨãåēæã¨ããĻãææĨã¸
ã䏿ĨãŽæŖįãįĩããį§ã¯åãŗæēãŽåãĢæģãã ãæå
ãĢã¯ãčãŖãēããĒįŊãå°įã¨ãéåãĒãį´į˛įæ§æšå¤ããŽä¸åããããããŽå¯žį
§įãĒäēã¤ãŽįŠäŊã¯ãäģãį§ãŽä¸ã§ä¸æč°ãĒčĒŋåãäŋãŖãĻããã ã䏿Ąį¨éįĨã¯ãį§ãŽãį¤žäŧįãĒæģããåããããŽã§ã¯ãĒããŖããããã¯ãį§ãį§čĒčēĢãŽčĒčãŽä¸ģ樊ãåãæģããããŽãéé
ˇã ãčĒ åŽãĒãååŧãã§ããŖããŽã ã
ãį§ã¯ããŗãįŊŽããæåæ°ã¯ãį§ãŽæį´ĸãŽæŠåš
ã¨åãã ãįŠãŋéãĒããåį¨ŋį¨į´ä¸åæã¨ãããä¸ã¤ãŽãéãŋããĢãĒãŖããããŽäēä¸åãŽéįŠã¯ã䏿Ąį¨ãĢããĻããč
ããĄã¸ãŽåžŠčŽã§ã¯ãĒããããã¯ãä¸äēēãŽäēēéããå¤įŦã¨įĩļæãŽæˇĩã§ããããĢããĻįæ§ãŽå
ãį¯ãįļããčĒããŽåŽåããįĩąåããįļãããã¨ãããčŦčãĒč¨ŧč¨ã§ããã
ãææĨãŽæãį§ã¯åãŗįŽãčĻãžãã ããã ããããĢã¯äžįļã¨ããĻãåŽčˇãŽãĒãä¸åŽã¨ãä¸éãŽåˇããããĒčĻįˇãåž
ãŖãĻãããããããĒããããããį§ãŽãĢããŗãĢã¯ãããŽä¸æãŽįŊãéįĨãå
ĨãŖãĻãããããã¯ãį§ãį¤žäŧãŽåŽæãĒãĢãã´ãĒãŧãĢåąãããčĒåčĒčēĢãŽãįŠčĒäŊããåŽãæãããã¨ãŽãäŊãããŽå˛įĢ ã§ããã ãį§ã¯ãæŦãéããããããĻããžã čĻãŦ莝å°ãŽå
ãĢãããæ°ããããŧã¸ãããããããĢãéããĢããããįĸēããĒčļŗåãã§ãææĨã¨ããæĒįĨãŽæŖįã¸ã¨č¸ãŋåēããĻããã
ãčĒčãŽéįãŽå
ãĢãããã§ããĒããįĸēããĒå°åšŗããããã¨ãäŋĄããĻã