
įᎍå°čĒŦããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæåžãŽįåŊã
// ãããã //
æäēēã¨ãŽéŖįĩĄãéįĩļããéæĨãéčŋãĢæ§ãããĒããˇãŧãēãŗãŽãĒãžãŧããããĢã¸ã˛ã¨ãã§ããŖãĻãããåããæĸ 鍿æãŽå¯ããæĩˇčžēã§ãåŊŧã¯æ°åããžã¨ãåčãŽåĨŗæ§ã¨åēäŧãã
į°č˛ãŽįŠēã¨æĩˇãŽã¯ããžã§ãäēäēēã¯éããĢč¨čãäē¤ããå§ãããåŊŧåĨŗãæˇĄã ã¨čĒãåēãããŽã¯ãäēååš´åãŽéåąąãŽããŧãŽæãåēã¨ããããĢéŖžãããĻããį°åŊãŽįžããčåįģãåˇĄããįžåŽã¨čæ§ãå ĨãæˇˇããåĨåĻãĒ荿ļã ãŖãã
åŊŧåĨŗãŽåĒé ãĒčäŊãĢåģãžããåžŽį´°ãĒéåæããããåãã¯åŊŧåĨŗãčǰãĢãæãããĒããŖãįæ°ãŽæ ¸åŋã¸ã¨čĒãããĻãããå¤ąãããããããĢãčå°ãĢãåŧĩã芰ããéå¯ãŽãĒãã§åŊŧåĨŗãŽįŠčĒãį´č§Ŗãããã
1
ããããĢãŽé¨åąãŽããĢãŗããŧããã¯æĩˇéŗ´ããčãããããããĢã¯å˛ŦãčĻãéģãæŖŽãĢæŧãåēãããããŽãããĢããĻå˛ŦãŽå į̝ãĢå¤įŦãĢįĢãŖãĻãããããĢãŗããŧãŽįŧä¸ãĢã¯å¤Ēåšŗæ´ãåēãããŽã ãããããĢãĢãã§ãã¯ã¤ãŗãããŽã¯å¤ãé ãæéããããããĢãŽæãããĢį §ããããįŊæŗĸãå˛Šį¤ãĢæãĄã¤ãããį ããæ§åã ããčĻããã
é ããĢã¯æ˛åãĢåæŗããčšããĄãŽå ãŽįšããé§é¨éãå¤ãŽæĩˇãŽä¸įŠēãĢéãã§čĻãããããããŽčšããĄã¯ææĨãŽå Ĩ港ãåž ã¤č˛¨įŠčšãå¤ãŽæŧãĢå¤ããæŧčšãŽããã ãŖãã貨įŠčšã§ã¯ãããããčšåĄããĄãįŋæãŽå Ĩæ¸¯ãŽæēåãæ´ãã¤ã¤ããããžã§ãŽéˇæ ãŽį˛ããįããšãį ããĢã¤ããĻããé ã ããã
æŧčšã§ã¯ãå¯éãžãåŽļæããĄãåŽļãĢæŽããĻããįˇããĄããæĨã ãŽįŗ§ãåžããããĢäģå¤ãŽæŧå ´ãæĸããæŧįĢãŽãã¨įļ˛ãæĩˇãĢæããĻã¯åŧãæããĻãããŽã ãããåããˇãŖã¯ãŧãæĩ´ãŗãĻããéããããããĢæ¨ĒãĢãĒãį ããĢã¤ããĻããéããæĩˇãŽä¸ãŽå ããĄã¯į¯ãįļããã ããã
ãåã¯æĨãĢããããĒåŊããåãŽãã¨ãåąããäģŽåŽãŽãããĢæãįĢãŖãĻãããããĢæããĻãããåŽã¯ããããŽå ã¯åãįŽãéĸããĻããéãĢį¯ããã¨ãããŖããã¨æĸããĻã¯ããĒãã ãããã
åãããããŽå ãĢãĩãããŗįŽãããã¨ããããäēåãĢį´ æŠãå¯įĨããĻå ããĩãããŗį¯ãã¨ãããã¨ãããĻã¯ããĒãã ããããåãŠããŽé ãĢããéãã ãã ããžãããčģĸãã ããŽãããĢįŽãã¤ããŖãĻããéãĢããããŽå ããĄã¯æããããã¨ãĒãææģ ãįš°ãčŋããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã ãããã
ãããĻåãįŽãã¤ããŖãĻããã¨ãã ããããŽä¸įã¯ããŽå§ŋãããĄãå¯ããĢãããããĢããããĻãããããĢå¤ããĻããĒãã ããããããŽãããĒå¯čŊæ§ã¯ãžãŖãããŽãŧãã¨ã¯č¨ãåããĒããããĢæãããããããŽãããĒå¤åãããŖãã¨ããĻããįŽãã¤ããåãĢã¯ããããįĨããĒãã
ããŽãããĒå¤åãåĻåŽãããã¨ã¯åãĢã¯ã§ããĒããããŽä¸įã¯åãįĨããŦéãĢãåããããããããĢæ¯ãã˛ãããĒããåŖŽå¤§ãĒã ããžãããčģĸãã ããããĻãããŽãããããĒãã
ãåã¯ãããĒä¸įãčŠĻããã¨įŽãã¤ããŖãĻä¸į§æ°ãããŽãĄãåĸããããžãļããéãå¤ãŽæĩˇãĢæĩŽããļå ããĄãĢįĻįšãåãããããå ããĄãææģ ãããããĢã¯čĻããĒããŖããįŽãã¤ããåã¨æ¯ãšãĻæ¸ãŖãå ãåĸããå ãįĄããããŽä¸įãåãĢäģæããåŖŽå¤§ãĒãããããŽå°ģå°žãæ´ããã¨ã¯ãã厚æãã¯ãĒããŖãã
ããããĒããĢãããã¨ãčããåãĢæ§ããã¨ãĒããå¤ãŽæĩˇãĢæĩŽããļå ããĄã¯ãæĩˇãįæĨãĢããäēēã ãŽåå¨ãį¤ēãå ã¨ããĻãįæ´ģãŽįŗ§ãåžããããĢå´åããäēēã ãŽæ´ģåãŽå ã¨ããĻããįļããĻãããåã¯é ãæ¨ĒãĢåšžåēĻãæ¯ããį˛ããé ãč§Ŗããģãããã¨æĩˇéŗ´ããĢčŗãæžãžããã
2
ãįŋæĨããããããčĩˇããã¨ãã¤ãéãåˇããæ°´ã§éĄãæ´ããæ¯ãįŖ¨ããéĢãåããå°ãæ°´ãã¤ããææĢã§éĢĒãæ´ãããå¯åˇģãããčģŊčŖ ãĢįæŋãããããĢäēéãŽéŖå ãĢčĩ´ãã¨ããããĢãŽåģä¸ããããĸã§ã¯æšŋãæ°ãåĢãå°ãå¤ãŗãåģēįŠãŽåããæŧãŖãĻããã
æĸ 鍿æã¨ããæåŖå¤ãããéŖå ãžã§čĩ´ãéãĢäģãŽåŽŋæŗåŽĸã¨äŧããã¨ã¯įĄããŖãããäŊååš´ããããĻããžããžãĒäēēã ãããŽãããĢãĢããŖãĻããĻã¯åģãŖãĻããŖãæ°é ãŽãããĒããŽãã館å ãĢãããã ãįåŽãĢæ˛ãŋčžŧãŋãåš´čŧĒãŽãããĢåą¤ããĒããĻãããããĢæãããã
åã¯ãžã čǰãããĒãéŖå ãŽåĨĨãŽįĒéãŽå¸ãĢåē§ããæéŖãŽãĄããĨãŧãæãĢåãŖãããĄããĨãŧã¯ãĒãŧãŊããã¯ãšãĒããŽã°ããã§ããŠããããã¨ããŖãæąēãæãä¸ããĻã¯ããããéæŖæãŽãããĢãŽæ°ã ããæãŽæ°åãå°ãã§ãå¤ããĻããããã¨ãæåž ãããŽã¯ãæéŖãĄããĨãŧãĢįŊĒã¯ãĒããŽã ããå°ã čˇãéã芹ãŽããã ãŖãã
åã¯äģæšãĒããĄããĨãŧãŽä¸įĒä¸ãĢãããĩãŠãäģããŽããŧãšãã¨ããããŗãŧããŧãé ŧãã ãæéŖããĒãŧããŧãįĩããĻãéŖå ãĢã¯ãžã äģãŽåŽŋæŗåŽĸã¯æĨãĒããŖãã
ãįĒãŽå¤ã§ã¯į°č˛ãŽįŠēããį°č˛ãŽæĩˇãĢãį°č˛ãŽé¨ãéŗããĒãéãŖãĻãããããŽé¨ã¯æ¨æĨããããŖã¨éãįļããĻãããé ããŽæ°´åšŗįˇã¯į°č˛ãŽįŠēã¨æĩˇã¨é¨ãŽããã§ãŧãããã¨ãĢããã§čĻããã
æéŖãæĨããžã§ãŽããã ãåã¯éããĒæĩˇãĢéãé¨ã¨ãããŽæĩˇãŽä¸ãæŗŗãéããĄãŽãã¨ãčãããäģæĨãŽé¨ã¯æĩˇãĢéãæŗ¨ãã¨ãããŠããĒéŗãįĢãĻããŽã ããããéããĄã¯æĩˇãĢé¨ãéãæŗ¨ãã§ãããã¨ãįĨãŖãĻãããŽã ããããé¨éŗã¯čãããĻãããŽã ãããã
ããããæ°´ãŽä¸ã§æŽããéããĄãĢã¨ãŖãĻãé¨ã¨ã¯ãŠãããåå¨ãĒãŽã ãããéãŽã¤ãããĢãĒãŖãĻæ°´ä¸ããæĩŽä¸ããé ãå°ãã ãæĩˇéĸãĢåēãæ§åãæŗåããé¨ãŽããããæĩˇéĸããåēããéŧģå ãĢéæãĒãæãããĢæãĄã¤ããæč§ĻãæãŖãã
éãĢã¨ãŖãĻããã¯åŋå°ãããŽã ããããããã¨ãä¸åŋĢãĒãŽã ããããįĸēããĒãã¨ã¯äŊãããããĒããŖãããéãĢã¨ãŖãĻé¨ãŽæč§Ļã¯ããžã čĻãŦä¸įãŽåå¨ãäēæãããããŽãŽãããĢæããã
åŊŧãã¯æąēããĻæĩˇããéĸãããã¨ã¯ã§ãããå°ä¸ä¸įãĢčžŋãįããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒãããåĻåŋãĒãããŽåå¨ãæããããããŽãé¨ãŽãããĢæãããããé¨ãĢčĒãããĻå°ä¸ä¸įãĢčžŋãįããå ãĢãããŽã¯æģãŽãŋã ããįã¨åŧãæããĢå°ä¸ãĢæãĄä¸ããããéãŽããã ãĢéãé¨ãŽãã¨ãæãã¨ãããŽé¨ã¯æŽé ˇã§ããã¤ã¤ãįĨįĻã§ããããããĢãæããã
ãįĒãŽå¤ãŽæĩˇãĢéãé¨ãčĻãã¨ããĒãįēããĒãããåããããĒãã¨ãã¨ããŠãĒãčããĻããéãĢãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãæéŖãéãã§ããããĸã¤ããŗãããĄãã¨ãããããįŊãˇãŖããįãčēĢãĒããŽããåš´ãããŽãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧããåãéã¨é¨ãŽéĸäŋæ§ãŽčŧĒããįžåŽãĢåŧãæģããĻãããã
ãåãæéŖãéŖãšãĻããéãåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ã°ãĢãŧããæéŖãåããĢéŖå ãĢæĨããåŊŧåĨŗããĄã¯åč˛ãĻããĄãããŠįĩããããããŽæŗã§ãŋãĒ䏿§ãĢčã¯äŊããåäēēæãŖãĻæãĒãããŽååēčĄãå¤ãčĻŗå
ãããĢãŽãŋãããŗãŧããŧãŽįé
ã§åŖ˛ãããĻãããããĒåŠĻäēēæãįãĻããã
ãããããĒéãã¯ããŖãĻããããããčĻåãããŽã¯éŖãããããĢæããåŊŧåĨŗããĄãåãŽįĨããŦéãĢæãä礿ãåãŖãĻããĻãåã¯æ°ãĨããããĢãĒããŖããé¨ãĢéãčžŧããããäģæĨãŽæ§ãĒæĨã§ãåŊŧåĨŗããĄã¯æĨŊããããĢããããšãããĒããããĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãæĄå ãããŽãåž ãããĢéŖå ãŽå ĨãåŖčŋããŽããŧããĢãĢã¤ããã
ãåã¯ãĩãŠãã¨ããŧãšããéŖãšįĩãããŗãŧããŧãéŖ˛ãã ãæéŖãæŗ¨æãįĩããåäēēãŽåĨŗæ§ã¯ãĩãããŗããããšããĢæģãŖãĻãããæãããããĒãĢ芹ããã¨ããããããĢã¯åãĢã¯æããĒããŖãããåŊŧåĨŗããĄãĢã¯ãžã ãžã ãããšããĒããã°ãããĒãäŊãããããŽã ãããåã¯åŊŧåĨŗããĄãŽčŠąãåŖ°ãå ĨãŖãĻããčŗãŽããĒãĨãŧã ãä¸ããįĒãŽå¤ãŽé¨ã¨æĩˇãįēããĻããã
3
ãåããŗãŧããŧãããããä翝įŽãŽãŗãŧããŧãæŗ¨ãã§ããã¨ããã˛ã¨ããŽåčãŽåĨŗæ§ãéŖå ãŽå ĨåŖãĢįžãããåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ããĄããå°ãåš´ãåãŖãĻãããããĢčĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽããããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗč˛ãŽãããŧãšãĒãŧãã§ã˛ãä¸ãžã§ãŽããŦãĸãšãĢãŧããŽã¯ãŗããŧãšãįãĻãããããŽä¸ãĢã¯čãįŊãŽãĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãįžŊįšãŖãĻããã
č °ãĢã¯å¤ĒãããŠãĻãŗãŽã¨ããĄãĢãŽããĢããᎠããããããĢãã¨åãããŠãĻãŗãŽããŧãĢãŽãããĩãŗããĢãåąĨããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãããŧããĢã¸ã¨æĄå ãããĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãĢã¤ããĻæŠãã¨ãäŊããŗããŗãã¨ä¸åãĒéŗãéããĒéŖå ãĢéŋãããåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ããĄã¯ããããšãããããĻãããããŽåčãŽåĨŗæ§ãããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽããŦãĸãšãĢãŧããæēãããĒããæŠãããžãįēããĻããã
åŊŧåĨŗãįĒéãŽå¸ãĢã¤ãã¨åĨŗæ§ããĄã¯ããããšããåéããããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåå¨ãæčããĻãããããļãåŖ°ãŽå¤§ãããæãããããĢæããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æéŖãĄããĨãŧãįēããã¨ãããŧãĢããŗã¨ããã¯ãšãĒã ãŦãã¨ã°ãŦãŧãããĢãŧããģã¸ãĨãŧãšã¨ãŗãŧããŧãæŗ¨æããããããããæąēããĻããããŽãããĢåŊŧåĨŗã¯čŋˇããĒãæŗ¨æãããåŊŧåĨŗããĄããĨãŧãæãĢåãįēãããŽã¯ãããžã§ããŧãēã ãŖããŽãããããĒãã
ããã¯ãšãĒã ãŦãã¯ããŧãŗãŗãæããĻãã ãããã¨ãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãĢäŧããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŖãļãããã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æĨé ããįšåĨæąãããããã¨ãĢæ ŖããĻãããããĢæãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽãĒã¯ã¨ãšãã¯æąēããĻéåēĻãĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒããããããĒããŽã ããæ éãĢååŗããããšãããŽã§ãããããį¨ŽãŽįˇãĢã¨ãŖãĻã¯åãŗãĢããæããããã ãããä¸ãŽä¸ãĢã¯ããããåĨŗæ§ããããŽã ã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æŗ¨æãįĩããã¨æ¤ åãŽčããããĢããããã§ããĒããčįãäŧ¸ã°ããĻįĒãŽå¤ãĢéĄãåãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åã¨äēã¤ããŧããĢãæãã§åãããĢãĒããããĢåē§ãŖãĻãããåã¯įĒãŽæšãĢéĄãåããĒããæ¨ĒįŽã§åŊŧåĨŗãčĻãã
åŊŧåĨŗãé¨ãįēããĻãããŽããæĩˇãįēããĻãããŽãåãĢã¯ãããããããĒãĢãčĻãĻããĒããããĢãæããããé¨ãĢéãčžŧãããããããĢããåŊŧåĨŗãæãåēããĻããããĒãĢãããå§ŋåĸãæŖããĻåž ãĄæãã§ãããããĢãæããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ã¨ãããããŧããĢãŽä¸ã§įĩãã§ããčļŗãįĩãŋæŋãããããããĒãã¨čãŽåˇĻåŗãŽããŠãŗãšãå´Šããã¨ã§ããããããĒåžåããããããããããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽããŦãĸãšãĢãŧãããčĻãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčãããã¨ãģãŖããã¨ããčã¯ãåčãŽåĨŗæ§ãĢããĻã¯īŧåčãŽåĨŗæ§ãŽåšŗåįãĒčããŠãããããŽãã¯įĨããĒããīŧčļããã§įžãããããŽãããĢãĢéŖžãŖãĻãããŠãŽįĩĩįģãčĒŋåēĻåãããæ´å˛ãããæ°åãåããĻããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĢĒãåŊŧåĨŗãŽããŦãĸãšãĢãŧãã¨åããããĢåããæ´ãŖãĻãããéĄãŽããããžã§ãŽįļēéēãĒããŧã¯ã°ãŦãŧãŽéĢĒã¯ãĩããã¨æãããĢãĻã§ãŧãããããŖãĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ã¨ãããåéĢĒãéĄãĢãããã¨ãåŗæãŽäēēåˇŽãæã¨ä¸æã§åéĢĒãæãŋæ¨ĒãĢæĩããŽã ããã¤ããĢããŽäēæŦãŽæã§éĢĒãæ´ããäģčãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽå 叺éĸãããããããã
åéĢĒãæ´ãįĩããåŗæãŽæããĄã¯ããŧããĢãŽä¸ãĢãã¤ãããŖã¨ããããããã¤ã§ãåéĢĒãæ´ãããããĢæãããĒãåããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŖããã¨æåŋãæããããįã¨ãéˇããžã¤ãã¨å°ãį ãããĒįŽãéĢãã¯ããããããŧãŖãĻãã¨ããéŧģįãããĻãããåã¯čģŊãéããĻãããããĢčĻããããæ§ãããĢã˛ãŖãããä¸åãĢããŖãĻããŽåŖããåēããã¨ããĻããč¨čãæŧãã¨ãŠããĻãããããĒå°čąĄãä¸ããã
åŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄãĢæˇąãåģãžããįēã¯čĻå´ãįŠčĒãããŽã§ã¯ãĒããåŊŧåĨŗãŽįžæčãĢåããããããæåŗãããåģãžããĻãããããĢæãããįžäēēãŽé¨éĄãĢå ĨããŽã ãããããããããå°čąĄįãĒãŽã¯åŊŧåĨŗããŠãŽãããĒįãįĢãĄãįĩãĻäģãĢčŗãŖããŽããã¤ãčããåˇĄãããĻããžãããŽé°å˛æ°ã ãŖãã
ãŠãŽãããĒåŽļåēį°åĸãĢįãžãããŠãŽãããĢå°åĨŗæäģŖãéããããŠããĒᎿ§ã¨ææããããŠãããŖãäģäēãĢå°ąããĻãããŽãããžãŖããäģäēãĒãŠããåŋ čĻãŽãĒãåĸéã§ãããããŗã¨ããĻč¸čĄæšéĸãĢæēããŖãĻãããŽãããããĒãã
åŊŧåĨŗãŽäēēįãĢã¯ãŠãŽãããĒåŧˇãäŋĄåŋĩãč˛ĢãããĻãããŽã ããããããã¯åˇããčĢĻåŋĩãã严æãĢã¯æčŧĒãã˛ã¨ã¤ããĒãããįĩåŠããĻãããŽããŠãããããããåãŠãããããããĢãčĻããĒãããããåŊŧåĨŗãæ¯čĻĒã¨ããĻæã¤æ¯åããããĒãã°ãæäēēãĢã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽãããĒåĨŗæ§åãæąããĻããžããããããã¯åŊŧåĨŗãĢåįēããĻãžãŖããéãŽåĨŗæ§ãæąãããããĢæãããåŊŧåĨŗããããžã§čĒčēĢãĢåģãã§ããæ´å˛ãã¤ãæŗåããĻãŋãããĒã厚č˛ã ãŖãã
ãåããããĒãã¨ãčããĻããããĄãĢåŊŧåĨŗãŽãã¨ãĢæéŖãéã°ããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŽčēĢäŊã¨åŊãįļæãããã¨ã ããįŽįã¨ãããããĢãæˇĄã
ã¨ããŧãĢããŗã¨ããŧãŗãŗæããŽããã¯ãšãĒã ãŦããéŖãšãåéãĢã°ãŦãŧãããĢãŧããģã¸ãĨãŧãšããšãããŧã§å°ããã¤åŖãĢããĻãããåã¯ä翝įŽãŽãŗãŧããŧãéŖ˛ãã§ããžãã¨ã°ãŠãšããæ°´ãã˛ã¨åŖåĢãŋãåš´ãããŽãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãåŧãã§ååŽãĢãĩã¤ãŗãããã
ãæŧããé¨ã¯ããããã§ããã¨ãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧã¯č¨ãŖããæ¨æĨããé¨ãéãįļããĻãããŽã ãããå°ãã¯åŽŋæŗåŽĸãĢ叿ãæãŖãĻããããã¨ããåŊŧãĒããŽãããããĒåŋéŖãã ãŖãã
ãã ã¨ããã§ãããããéĄããžããã¨åã¯įããã
ãåã¯å¸ãįĢãĄããŧããĢãŽéãéãæããéŖå ãåžãĢãããã¨ãããããŽéãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãŗãŧããŧãĢåŖãã¤ããĒãããčįãäŧ¸ã°ããĻãĩãããŗįĒãŽå¤ãŽé¨ãæĩˇããããã¯ããŽä¸ĄæšãįēããĻãããåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ããĄã¯éŖåžãŽãŗãŧããŧãį´ čļãéŖ˛ãŋãĒãããåãŽãģããĒãŠčĻåããããããããããããããšããįļããĻãããčǰãåãŽåå¨ãĒãŠæ°ãĢããĻããĒããŖãã
4
ãåã¯ããŽãããĢãĢåš´ãĢä¸äēåč¨ĒããĻãããã´ãŧãĢããŗãĻãŖãŧã¯ãå¤å ´ãåš´æĢåš´å§ãéŋããæąēãžãŖãĻãĒããˇãŧãēãŗãĢåŽŋæŗãããããããŽãã¤ãˇãŧãēãŗã§ã¯åŽŋæŗæéãåäģĨä¸ãĢ莺ãä¸ããã¨ãããŽãããããåŽŋæŗåŽĸã§ããŖãčŋããŽããĒãĢãããéŋããããŖãã
ãã¤ãˇãŧãēãŗãĢã¯ãĢãããĢãåŽļæéŖããæŧãå¯ããåãŠãããĄãčĩ°ãåãããããæŗ¨æããæ¯čĻĒããĄãŽåŖ°ããããĸãĢéŋãã ãããããŽãããĒããŧãããŧã¯ããĒãããŽãããĢãĢåŽŋæŗãããŽã¯ãããããį˛å´ãæēããĢčĄããããĒããŽã ãŖãã
ãžããã¤ãˇãŧãēãŗã¯å¤éŖãŽãĄããĨãŧãéãããĻããã䏿ŗã ããŽåŽŋæŗåŽĸãæŗåŽããäēä¸ãŽãŗãŧãšã鏿čĸã¨ããĻãããŽãŋã§ãéŖæŗã§ããããæ¯æŠéŖãšãæ°ãĢã¯ãĒããĒãå°ã éããĄããĨãŧã°ããã ãŖãã
ãĒããˇãŧãēãŗã§ããã°ããããããã¨ãĢãĸãŠãĢãĢããĄããĨãŧããé¸ãļãã¨ãã§ãããŠãããˇãŗããĢãĒãĄããĨãŧã°ããã§ã¯ãããéããĒéŖå ã§ããŖããã¨å°å ãŽæ°éŽŽãĒéčãæĩˇãŽåš¸ãäŊŋãŖãįžåŗããæįã¨é ãæ¯æŠæĨŊãããã¨ãã§ãããã ããåã¯ãã¤ãäģãŽæĸ 鍿æããå䏿ãããŽåŦãŽå ĨåŖããããĢæŗãžããŽãåĨŊãã ã
ãéŖäēäģĨå¤ãĢåãããŽãããĢãåĨŊãã§ããįįąã¯ããĄããããã¤ãããããžãã˛ã¨ã¤ã¯ããŽéããã ããããĢã¯ååŗļããå¤Ēåšŗæ´ãĢåããĻįĒãåēãå˛ŦãŽå ãĢãããå˛Ŧå ¨äŊã¯åŊįĢå Ŧåã¨ããĻäŋčˇãããæŖŽã§čĻãããĻããã
ä¸éããå°ã éįĩļããããããĢãããĢã¯åģēãĻãããĻãããč´ãããĻãããŽã¯æŗĸãŽéŗã¨æĩˇéŗĨãŽéŗ´ãåŖ°ãããã§ããã¤ãˇãŧãēãŗãé¤ãã°ä¸ãŽä¸ããåãæŽããããããĢæããããŽéãããåã¯åĨŊãã ãŖãã
館å ã¯åēã ã¨ããĻããæ°æãĄãããã夊äēãéĢãåšãæãã¨ãĒãŖãĻããä¸éãããŧã¯čãŽéĢããŦãŠãšįĒãĢå˛ãžããããŠãšããå ãĢã¯å˛ŦãŽįˇã¨æĩˇãįēãããã¨ãã§ãããããŽæ¯č˛ãæĨŊããããããĢįĒéãĢé įŊŽããããŠãĻãŗã¸ãŽéŠãŽãŊããĄãŧã¯åē§ãåŋå°ããããå˛ŦããčĻããæ¯č˛ãããŽãŊããĄãŧãĢåē§ããĒããããŖã¨įēããĻããããã
åŽĸ厤ã¯įãããĄãžããããŋã¤ããĢãĒãŖãĻããããã夊äēãéĢãããĢãŗããŧãĢįļããŦãŠãšæ¸ã¯å¤§ãããåŽĸ厤ã§ãååãĒč§Ŗæžæãåŗãããã¨ãã§ããããĄã¤ãŗãĢãŧã ãĢã¯ããŽåãĢãĒãŖãåäēēæããŽãŊããĄã¨ååãĒåēããŽããšã¯ããããããŽéŖãĢã¯ããŧã¯æãŽãã§ãšããããŖãã
äģæĨãŽãããĒé¨ãŽæĨãĢã¯ãŊããĄãĢčēĢãæ˛ããčãŽéĢãįĒããčĻããæĩˇãįēããĒããčĒæ¸ãæĨŊããã ãã§ãååãĢãããããĒæ°åãåŗããããéæŽĩãä¸ããŖããããĸãĢã¯å¤Ščã§éŖžãããããŗã°ãĩã¤ãēãŽããããããŖãã
åãããŽãããĢãĢæŗãžãã¨ãã¯åēæŦįãĢã¯æäēēãéŖããĻåŽŋæŗãããããŽæã ãŽæäēēã ãå¤ã¯å¤ŠčäģããŽããŗã°ãĩã¤ãēãŽãããã§æäēēã¨ã¯ã¤ãŗãéŖ˛ãŋãããŖããã¨ãģãã¯ãšãæĨŊããŋãčããããŽããæãããĒãĒããŗãĢãããžããĒãããĩããã¨ãæé ããžã§į ãŖãã
ããããŽéãĢå˛Ŧã¨ãããĢãæŽããĻä¸įãæĩˇãĢæ˛ãã§ããåããĄã¯äŊãæ°ãĨããĒããŖãããæ°ãĢãããĒããŖãã ããã
ããããĒãæ°ãĢå ĨããŽãããĢãäģåš´ãŽå¤ãæåžãĢä¸åēĻéæĨããåģēįŠãåģēãĻæŋããå ¨éĸãĒããĨãŧãĸãĢããããã¨ãæąēãžãŖãĻãããããã¯äģæšãŽãĒããã¨ã ãŖãã
åģēįŠčĒäŊã¯å¤ããåš´ã čæŊåãé˛ãæ§åãįŽãĢã¤ãããããŧãåģä¸ãŽãĢãŧãããã¯æĻãåããåŖãĢã¯ã¨ãããŠãã鍿ŧããŽãã¨ãæãŋã¤ããĻãããåŽĸ厤ãŽã¨ãĸãŗãŗã¯æĸ 鍿æãĢã¯å¯ãããå䏿ãĢã¯æãããã¨ãŦããŧãŋãŧãŽčĄãå ããŋãŗãŽããĄãããŧãããĸãŽããŋãŗãĢč¨ãããâLâãŽæåã¯æĻãåãããģã¨ããŠå¤åĨãã¤ããĒããĒãŖãĻããã
ãĩãĻãæŊč¨ã¯ãã¤ãŠãŧãŽä¸čĒŋãŽããããäŊåš´ãåããéãããããžãžã ãŖããåã¯éŖå ãŽå¤ãæäģŖãæãããããĸãŗããŖãŧã¯ãĒæ¤ åãåĨŊãã ãŖãããããããŽããã¤ãã¯åŖããããįĄåŗäšžįĨã¨ããéĸįŊãŋãŽãĒã大éįįŖãŽæ°ããæ¤ åãĢåãæŋããããĻããŖããåš´ã ããŽæ°ã¯åĸããĻãããããŽããžã¯čããĢæããĒãčēĢäŊããéãĢåãããŽä¸éŖãåããĒæ°ããé¨åã§įļãã¯ãããĻããããã ãŖãã
åŽĸ厤ãŽããšã¯ãĢã¯ãĒããĨãŧãĸãĢåžãŽã¤ãĄãŧã¸ãčŧãŖããããĢãŽããŗããŦãããįŊŽãããĻããããããĢã¯æ°ããæ¸ æŊã§įžäģŖéĸ¨ãŽãˇãŗããĢãĒåŽĸ厤ãŽã¤ãŠãšããčŧãŖãĻããã
夊äēã¯äŊããããĄãããĄãžãããã§ã¯ãĒããä¸å¤ŽãĢã¯å¤ŠčãĒãŠįĄãããããįŊŽãããããŧã¯æãŽãã§ãšãã¯ãã¯ããĒããįĒéãĢã¯ãããĒããĒãã§ãĸäēčã¨ä¸¸ããŗãŧããŧããŧããĢãįŠēéãã¨ããããåãããããĢįŊŽãããĻããã
æ°ãããããĢãŽåŽĸ厤æ°ã¯äģãããåĸããããå¤ããŽåŽŋæŗåŽĸããã°ããæčŗå¯žåšæãéĢãããã¨ããĻããããããĢã¯äģãŽãããĢãĢæŧãį˛žįĨã¨ããŖãããŽãåãįļãæ°é ã¯čĻåãããããããã¯įžäģŖįãĒãã ãŽãĒãžãŧããããĢãĢéããĒããŖãã
ããŽãããĢããĻããŽãããĢãŽã˛ã¨ã¤ãŽæäģŖãįĩãããã¨ããĻããããã¯ã夊äēãŽéĢããĄãžããããŽč§Ŗæžæãåŗãããã¨ãã夊čäģããŽåēããããã§ããŖããã¨ãããģãã¯ãšãæĨŊãããã¨ããčãŽéĢãįĒããåˇŽãææĨã§æäēēã¨ä¸įˇãĢįŽãčĻãžããã¨ãã§ããĒããĒãåãŽå¯ããã¨ã¨ããĢãããŽãããĢã¯éåģãŽããŽã¨ãĒããã¨ããĻããã
ããããĒæåžãŽãããĢãåã¯äģãŽæäēēã¨ãĩããã§éããã¤ããã ãŖãããããåŊŧåĨŗã¨ã¯æ čĄãĢåēããã䏿ĨåããéŖįĩĄãåããĒããĒãŖããåã¯ããããŽãããĢãŽåēã夊čäģããããã§æäēēã¨ãģãã¯ãšãæĨŊãããã¨ãã§ããĒãã
5
ãåãŽéąæĢãĢåããĄã¯ãĄããŖã¨ããå§åŠãããããģããŽäēį´°ãĒãã¨ãããŖããã ãŖãããããããŽäēį´°ãĒãã¨ãåĨãŽäēį´°ãĒåäģãã¨ããããĢåŧãŗčžŧãŋããããã¯å¯ããĢå
ąåæĻįˇãåŧĩããåããĄã¯æ°ãĨãã¨åžæģãã§ããĒãå°įšãĢãžã§čŋŊãããããĻããžãŖãĻããã
ãåã¯æäēēãčĒãŖãĻäģŖã
æ¨å
ŦåãæŖæŠããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽé´ãŽä¸ãĢå°įŗãå
ĨããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻé´ãčąããããĢåãŽčŠãĢã¤ããžããã¨ããããŽã¨ããčãŽæ¤æ¨ããåãŽčļŗå
ãĢįĢãæĨãĢéŖãŗåēããåã¯ã¨ãŖããĢãããéŋããã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽčŠãã¤ããŋæããĻããŠãŗãšãå´Šããé´ãčąãã čļŗãŽã¤ãžå
ãå°éĸãĢã¤ãããããŽéãĢæ¤æ¨ãĢãšããããŗã°ãã˛ãŖãããĻããžãäŧįˇããĻããžãŖãã
ã大ä¸å¤Ģīŧãã¨åã¯åŊŧåĨŗãĢåŖ°ããããã
ã財ãŖãã°ãããĒãŽãĢãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãäģåēĻ財ãŖãĻãããããããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããããã¨ãããĒããŽãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãĻããæ¯ãã¤ããã
ãããŽæĨã¯éĸ¨ãåŧˇããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įŽãĢå ĨãŖãį ãŧãããæããã¨ããĻå¤ãããŗãŗãŋã¯ããŦãŗãēããéĸ¨ãĢéŖã°ããå¤ąãããã°ããã ãŖãã嚸ãããã¯äŊŋãæ¨ãĻãŦãŗãēã§äēåãããŖããããčĻå´ããĻæĸãåŋ čĻã¯ãĒããŖããã
ãããĢããŽåãĢã¯ãåäžããĄãæãæããĻčģĸããŖãĻããããŧãĢãåã¯åäžããĄãĢæãčŋããã¨ããããåĸãããžãŖãĻé ããĢæãéããããĒãã ãčĒåãæå°æĒãĒ大äēēãĢãĒãŖãæ°åã ãŖãã
ãã¤ããĒãæģããĒãé˛ããããããŽãã¨ããããŽæĨã¯ãĒãĢããããå°ããã¤äģæããĻããããŠããŗã¯ãč šãĢäšããč˛ãåŠãæããããã¤ããŽč˛ãæĩˇãŽåēãĢæ˛ããĻããããĸãˇãĢãˇã§ãŧãŽãĸãˇãĢã¯ããŧãĢãäŊåēĻãããŖãããæããããžããĢã¯ãžã°ããĒčĻŗåŽĸå¸ããããæ¯ãæŧããĻããã
ãåããĄã¯å
ŦåãŽæŖæŠãæŠã
ãĢåãä¸ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽããŗãˇã§ãŗãĢæģãã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽé¨åąãŽããĸãĢã¯č˛ŧãį´ãããĻããŖãã
âããããããŦããéããĢãããâ
ãããŽčĻåæã¯ãä¸ãŽé¨åąãŽäŊäēēãããŽããŽã ãŖãããããžã§ãäēåēĻããŽãããĒč˛ŧãį´ãč˛ŧããããã¨ãããŖããŽã§ãåããĄã¯éä¸ãŽäŊäēēãĢį´æĨ芹ãã¤ããĢčĄãŖãã
ããåããĄãŽãã¨ã¯įĩļ寞ãĢ訹ããĒããããĒãã¨ããĸãŽééããããããããŽīŧ´ãˇãŖããįãå°å¤Ēãã§ä¸¸åä¸ģãŽä¸åš´įˇãč¨ãŖããæŗã¯åããå°ãä¸ãŽä¸åäģŖä¸į¤ãĢčĻããã
ã芹ãčããĻãã ãããã¨åã¯åŊŧãŽįŧãčĻãĻč¨ãŖãã
ããããããéģããã¨įˇã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããããåããĄãĢã¯åäžã¯ããžãããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãéããĢããããã¨įˇã¯č¨ãŖãĻãããĸãåĸãããéãããååēĻã¤ãŗãŋãŧããŠãŗã§åŧãã§ãåŊŧã¯åēãĻæĨãĒããŖãã
ãåããĄã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽé¨åąãĢæģããåã¯č˛ŧãį´ã丸ããĻããŋįŽąãĢæãæ¨ãĻãåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŧįˇãããšããããŗã°ãčąãã§æ¨ãĻããåã¯ããããŗã§ãŗãŧããŧãæˇšãããã¨ããĻããŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãį大ãĢåēãĢããŧããã
ãã¤ãŦããæģãŖãĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãįįãæĨããã¨č¨ããåããŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãæé¤ããĻãããŽãčĻããŖãã
ãããįĄįã帰ãŖãĻãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯įŽãĢæļããããĒããč¨ãŖãã
ãåã¯ãŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãããŧãããã¨ãčŦãŖãããå ¨įļããããããããĒããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãããŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãæŖäšąãããžãžãŽåēãĢããããŋčžŧãã§æŗŖãã ãããåã¯ããããã¨č¨ãŖãĻåŊŧåĨŗãŽčä¸ããããŖããããã§ããæŠãåēãĻãŖãĻãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ããŽã§ãåã¯ãŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãããŽãžãžãĢäģæšãĒãåŊŧåĨŗãŽé¨åąãåžãĢããã
ãããäģĨæĨãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽéģ芹ãĢåēãĻãããĒããĒãŖããæŦĄãŽæĨãŽå¤ãĢæšããĻåŊŧåĨŗãŽããŗãˇã§ãŗãč¨Ēããããä¸éã¨ãŗããŠãŗãšãŽããã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯éããĻãããĒããŖãã
6
ãéŖå ããé¨åąãĢæģãŖãåã¯ããŊããĄãŧãĢæ¨ĒãĢãĒããĄãžããããŽéĢã夊äēãžã§ãŽããã ãåããįŠēéãįēããĻãããæŦæĨã§ããã°æéŖåžãŽããŽæ°ã ããæéããããããŊããĄã§åŊŧåĨŗã¨ä¸įˇãĢéããããĒããĒãããã˛ã¨į ããããããĻããã ããã
äŊåããŽįᎍéã¨ãä¸åãŽæĸåĩããŽãŽå°čĒŦãæãŖãĻæĨãĻã¯ãããããŠããčĒãæ°ãĢã¯ãĒããĒããŖããããŠããŠã¨ããŧã¸ããããŖãĻãŋããéŖå ãŽæéŖãĄããĨãŧã¨åãããŠããäģæãŽåãŽčåŗãåŧããããŊããĄãŧãĢå¯ããšããĒããäģæšãĒãããŦããã¤ããããã¤ããŽããŖãŗããĢãčĻãĻåãŖãã
å Ŧå ąæžéã§ã¯ãĸããĒãĢãŽã¨ããå°ããĒįåŊãŽįšéãåæžéããĻãããã˛ã¨æåãŽįĒįĩãŽããã ãŖããããŽįåŊã§ã¯æŠä¸ããåŊįãŽãã¨ãįåĻãįļããåĨŗįãĢåŗäŊãããã¨ããĻããã
ããŦããŽä¸ãŽåĨŗįã¯ãžã čĨãä¸åæŗãčŋããã°ããã ãŖããå°æã§į´°čēĢãĒåŊŧåĨŗã¯å°ã éĄãä¸ãĢåããæ°ä¸ãĒæ§åã§åŗäŊåŧãĢč¨ããã¨ããĻãããčãĢã¯åšŧãįåããĄãĩãããåŧãéŖããĻããã
č¤č˛ãŽčãŽåŧãᎠãžãŖãåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄããã¯åĨŗįã¨ããĻãŽčĻæã¨éĸ¨æ ŧãæãããããããŽįšéã¯åŊŧåĨŗãĢįĻįšãåŊãĻãĻããã
ãããŽįåŊã§ã¯ã¤ãŗãæ´ããåšãæšŋãŖãéĸ¨ãéĢãåąąčãĢé˛ãã¤ããé¨ãéããããããæ°´ãčąå¯ã§įˇčąãã§ãææ¨šãįŠįŠãŽæ ŊåšãĒãŠãŽčž˛æĨã¨į§įãįãã ãŖããįåŊãå˛ããããĢããŗããåąąčã¯ãæĩãŋãŽé¨ãããããã¨ã¨ããĢå¨čžēåŊããįåŊãåŽãåŖã¨ãĒãŖãĻããã
įåŊã¯ä¸įˇ¯åēĻãĢäŊįŊŽãããããæ°åã¯æ¸Šæã§ããŦããĢæ ãéĸ¨æ¯ã¯ãĸãĢããšããĒããã§ãããåŽéãĢããŽįåŊã¯ãĸããĒãĢãŽãĸãĢããšã¨į§°ãããĻãããį厎ãåãå˛ããããĢåēããčĄä¸Ļãŋã¯ãåäžãŽé ãĢčĒãã įĩĩæŦãĢåēãĻãããããĒį´ æ´ãĒčĄä¸Ļãŋã ãŖãã
åŊæ°ããĄã¯ãŋãĒãããŖããã¨ããæéãæĩããį§æįã§įŠãããĒæŽãããĢæēčļŗããĻããããã ãŖããåŗäŊåŧã§ã¯å¤ããŽåŊæ°ãæ°ããåĨŗįãŽčĒįãįĨįĻããããã¨åŽŽæŽŋåãĢéãžãŖãĻããã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯įæãįšæ¨Šéį´ãŽåēčēĢã§ã¯ãĒããåēļæ°éį´ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽåēčĒã ãŖããååŊįã¯č˛§ããæãŽå¨ãĢæãããå¨å˛ãŽå寞ãæŧãåãŖãĻįåĻã¨ããĻčŋãå Ĩããã
ãæããåŊæ°ãŽãŋãĒãããã¨æ°ããåĨŗįã¯åŧãŗãããĻãããããããĻį§ãŽåãŠãããĄãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããããįãããæ¯æå¸æãããŖãĻįŽčĻãã大åãĒåŽļæãåäēēããĄã¨éŖåãå˛ãŋãå¤ãĢã¯åŽåŋããĻį ããĢã¤ãããã¨ããããį§ãŽéĄãã§ããåãã§ããããŽãããĢį§ã¯ãį§ãŽæãĻãããšãĻãŽæéãæ§ããžããį§ã¯ãã¤ã§ãįãããŽããåãĢããžã ã
ãč´čĄããĄã¯æ°ããĒåĨŗįãŽč¨čãĢæļããææåéãéãŖããããããŽã¯æļãæĩããĒããåĨŗįãĢããŗãĢããæ¯ããããããŽã¯å¤ŠãĢåããĻ严æãæ˛ããĒããéĢãããĢæãåããããããŽã¯įĨįĻãŽããŗãšãč¸ãŖãĻããããã¤ãžã§ãææã¯éŗ´ãããžãĒããŖããåĨŗįã¯åŊæ°ãæããåŊæ°ããžããåĨŗįãæããĻããã
ãįĒįĩãįĩããã¨åã¯ããŦããæļããæäēēãĢéģ芹ããããæäēēã¯æįĩĻäŧæãåãŖãĻããã¯ãã ãŖããåŧãŗåēãéŗã¯éŗ´ãįļãããåã¯įŽãã¤ãããå°ããĒįåŊãŽåŊæ°ããĄãåŊŧããŽæ°ããåĨŗįãĢåããĻéãįļããææãŽéŗãããŽåŧãŗåēãéŗãĢéããããããããŽį˛æããĒãįåŽįĒéģ芹ãĢåãæŋããã¨ãåã¯éģ芹ãåãŖãã
7
ãååžãĢã¯ãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãŽč¨ãéãé¨ãä¸ããŖãããįŠēã¯ãŠãããã¨ããéãé˛ãĢčĻãããå˛ŦãŽæŖŽã¯é¨ãĢæŋĄããéãįˇč˛ãããããĻãããæĩˇã¯įŠēã¨åãéãį°č˛ãĢæãžããå˛ŦãŽå˛¸åŖãĢããŽį°č˛ãŽæŗĸãæãĄã¤ããĻããã
åã¯ãããĢãŽčããæŖŽãĢčĻãããįŗãŽéæŽĩãä¸ããå˛ŦãŽä¸ãŽæĩčžēãĢéãįĢãŖããå˛ŦãŽãĒãã§ããã ã垏åŖãĢå˛ãžãã夊įļãŽį æĩãĢãĒãŖãĻãããå¤å ´ãŽåŽŋæŗåŽĸãčĄæĨŊåŽĸãŽįŽåŊãĻãããŽį æĩã ãŖããã ãäģã¯åäģĨå¤ãĢã¯čǰãããĒããŖãã
æšžæ˛ããį æĩãĢã¯įŠãããĢį°č˛ãŽæŗĸãããĄå¯ããĻãããįŗãŽéæŽĩãŽãããã°ãĢã¯å°åąãĨãããŽããŧãããĻãšãåģēãŖãĻãããæŗĸæŋãŽåąæ šãããããŠãšãŽä¸ãĢã¯įŊãããŠãšããã¯ãŽãĒã¯ãŠã¤ããŗã°åŧããããã§ãĸããĄãå¤ãŽåēįĒãåž
ãŖãĻããããããã¯åŋãåģãããĻįŊéǍåããįŠãŋä¸ããããå¤ãŽč¨æļãŽããã ãŖãã
ãåã¯į æĩãŽį̝ããį̝ãžã§ãæŠããĻæģãŖãĻãããã¨ãįŠãŋä¸ããããããããã§ãĸãŽã˛ã¨ã¤ãåãä¸ããæŗĸæãĄéčŋããĢåēããĻå¯ããšãŖããå°ģããąãããĢå
ĨããĻããæåēĢæŦãæãĢåãŖãã
ããã¯ã´ãŖãŗãģãŗããģããĢãŗããŽįᎍéã§ãååš´äģĨä¸åãĢä¸åēĻčĒãã ãã¨ãŽããæŦã ãŖãããžãŖããå 厚ãčĻããĻããĒããŽã§ãæã¤ãļãããããĢã¯ãĒãã ããã¨æãŖãĻæãŖãĻæĨãĻããã
ããŽæåēĢãŽčĄ¨į´ã§ã¯ãčäŊå´åãįĩããäģäēããããŽįˇããĄãéãžããããĒé å ´ãŽãĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãŽãšããŧãĢãĢãįŊäēēãŽåĨŗãã˛ã¨ãč °ãããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įãŖįŊãĒéĢĒãããĻããã
ãĸãã¯ãåįãĒãŽã§ããããåŽéã¯ééĢĒã ãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įˇããĄããåŖ°ãããããããŽãåž ãŖãĻããããã ãŖããåŊŧåĨŗãĢåŖ°ãããããĒãã°ãå°ã ãŽéãããąãããĢ፿ããĻããåŋ čĻãããããã ãŖãã
ããã ãĢã´ãŖããã¨ãããĒããˇã§ãĢããŧãŽãããããčĻããčŠãĢã¯ãããããããŠã¸ãŖãŧãŽį´ãčĻããåĨãåēããŽä¸¸ã ã¨ããå¤ĒãããŽčã¯ãˇã§ãŧãããŗããŽčŖžãĢᎠãä¸ããããĻããã
ããããĢčĻãããč šãŽčã¯ãˇã§ãŧãããŗããŽãĻã¨ãšããĢäšããããŠã¸ãŖãŧãŽããĢãã¯čä¸ãŽčãæŧãåēããĻããããããĒåŊŧåĨŗãŽæå ãĢã¯ãžã ãģã¨ããŠæãäģããĻããĒãããŗã°ãĢã¯ããĢãŽã°ãŠãšãããŖãã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯é ŦæãįĒããĒããįˇããĄãŽããĒãæšãĢéĄãåããįĻįšãåããããĢãĻãŗãŋãŧã¨ãããĢãŠãã¯ãŽéãŽäŊããčĻã¤ããĻãããããããæ°¸é ãĢåŊŧåĨŗãéŖãåēããĻããããĒãĢãããããžãæåž ãããĢåž ãĄãĒããããããã¯åŊŧåĨŗãããŽé å ´ãŽãĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãĢãžã§éŖããĻæĨããããžããã¤ãĻããã¨ã¯č¨ããĒãéåģãæãčŋããĒããã
ãåã¯į čãå¸ããĒããããŽčĄ¨į´ããã°ããįēãããã¨ãããŧã¸ããããŖãĻæåãĢåããããĻããįᎍãčĒãŋå§ããããĄããˇãŗãããŽä¸æŗį§ģæ°ãŽä¸ĄčĻĒãæã¤ä¸äēēå§åĻšãŽæĢãŖåã§ãįēã§ããĄã°ãæãŽããžãå¨ãŽčŠąã ãŖãã
8
ãããã¤ããŽįᎍãčĒãŋįĩããé ãå˛ŦãŽéæŽĩããæŗĸæãĄéãĢæŠããĻããäēēãŽæ°é ãæãããåã¯æŦãčĒããĩããããĒããæ¨ĒįŽã§čĻãã¨ãæãŽéŖå ã§čĻãããåčãŽåĨŗæ§ã ãŖãã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯æã¨åãããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽã¯ãŗããŧãšãĢãĢãŧããŖãŦãŗãįžŊįšãŖãĻãããčļŗå ã¯įŊãŽãšããŧãĢãŧãĢåąĨãæŋããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãæåãĢãããããĢį æĩãŽåãããŽį̝ãžã§æŠããĻãããčļŗãã¨ãããããį å°ã§ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯å§ŋåĸãå´ŠãããĢæŠããĻããã
åã¯åŊŧåĨŗãčĻããŽãããããĒããšãæ°é
ãæļããĻãããã¨ãéĄããĒããæŦãčĒãã§ããããã°ããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗãŽãšããŧãĢãŧãŽį å°ãč¸ãéŗãã ãã ãã¨čŋããĒãŖãĻããã
ãį
čã䏿Ŧããã ããããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯åãŽéŖãĢįĢãĄč¨ããã
ãåã¯æŦãįŊŽããčĩˇãä¸ããŖãĻããããã§ãĸãĢåē§ããĒãããããã§ãĸãĢįŊŽããĻããįŽąããį čã䏿Ŧåãåēããå¸ãåŖãåŊŧåĨŗãĢåããĻåˇŽãåēãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯į čãæãĢæãŋãĒããåŖãĢããããã
åã¯ãŠã¤ãŋãŧã§åŊŧåĨŗãŽį čãĢįĢãã¤ãããã¨ããããä¸åēĻįŽãŽãŠã¤ãŋãŧãŽįĢã¯ãããĢæļããĻããžãŖããåã¯æãããããĒããããä¸åēĻįĢãã¤ãããããŽéãåŊŧåĨŗã¯č °ããããčēĢãããã˛ã¨ã¤ãããĢį čãĢįĢãã¤ããŽãåž ãŖãĻããã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯įĢãŽã¤ããį čãåãĢããããĒãããéĄãĢãããŖãåéĢĒãåŗæãŽäēēåˇŽãæã¨ä¸æã§æ¨ĒãĢæĩãããį čãæã§æãŋãĒããã¨ãį ãå¸ãčžŧãŋãããŖããã¨æĩˇãĢåããŖãĻį ãåãåēããã
ãéŖãĢįĢã¤åŊŧåĨŗãčĻãã¨ãæãŽéŖå ã§æããå°čąĄãããéĄãĢåģãžããįēã¯æˇąããæ¯æĨåŋĩå ĨããĢæå ĨããããĻããã§ãããčã¯ãčļã¯ããããŽãŽåŧĩãã¯æŗãĢæãããĢãããã¨ãããŠãããŽå°ããŽãããŋã¯ããåžæģãã§ããããĢãĒããŖãã
ããããĒããčįããžãŖãããĢããĒããį°č˛ãŽæĩˇãããŖã¨čĻã¤ããããŽãžãĒããã¯čĨãæãããããŽãžãĒãããĢããŖãĻä¸åæŗãčŋããåĨŗæ§ãæŦĄãŽæĨãĢčēĢäŊã ãįĒįļå
åæŗãĢãĒãŖãããŽãããĒå°čąĄãä¸ãããä¸åæŗãŽįžããåĨŗæ§ãæã¤ãčĨãã¨įĩé¨ããã¨ãĢããããį¨ŽãŽčĒäŋĄã¨åŧˇããŽãããĒããŽããžã åŊŧåĨŗãĢã¯æããããããŽãĸãŗããŠãŗãšãã¯åãå°ãåą
åŋå°æĒããããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åšžåēĻãį
čããĩãããããŖã¨æĩˇãčĻã¤ããĻãããåãããããæ°é
ãæļããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãĢã¯åãåå¨ããĻããĒãããã ãŖããåã¯įĢãĄä¸ãããããŽæ˛éģããéãããããĢããŧãããĻãšãĢåããŖãã
åŊŧåĨŗãŽãããŽããããã§ãĸãã˛ã¨ã¤æãĢåããããŧããĢãĢéããĻããŖãį°įŋãã˛ã¨ã¤æãĢããåã¯ããããåŊŧåĨŗãŽãã¨ãĢéãŗãããããã§ãĸãåŊŧåĨŗãŽãããĢåēããã
ãããããããã¨ããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯į¤ŧãč¨ãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããããã§ãĸãĢč °ãä¸ãããĻæåžãŽį ãããŖããã¨å¸ãčžŧãŋãåãåēããããããĻį čãį°įŋãĢä¸å¯§ãĢæŧãåããĒããįĢãæļãããæ¨æ¨ĩåĨŗãŋãããĢį čãåŧˇãæŧãæŊ°ããĻæļããããĒãã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãį
čããããã¨ããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããé¨åąãĢåŋããĻãããŽã
ãįļããĻåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããããĒããäģæãŽéŖå ãĢãããããã
ããããããžãããã¨åã¯įããã
ãããĒãããã˛ã¨ãīŧãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ããã
ãåã¯éąæĢãŽäģŖã
æ¨å
ŦåãŽäēį´°ãĒåēæĨäēãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽé¨åąã§ãŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãããŧãããã¨ãžã§ãæãčŋããã
ããããã˛ã¨ãã§ããã¨åã¯įãããããã¨ãã¨ã¯ããããã¤ããã§ã¯ãĒããŖããã§ãããã¨åŧč§Ŗããžããäģãå ãããåžæãããä¸åãčļ
ããįˇãæåŖå¤ããŽåšŗæĨãŽãĒãžãŧããããĢãĢããããä¸äēēã§æĨããĢã¯äŊãããįįąãåŋ
čĻãĒæ°ããããããã¨č¨ãŖãĻčǰããããĒ芹ãĢčåŗã¯ãĒãã ããã
ãããĒããã˛ã¨ãã§ããīŧã
ããããããããį§ã¯ãã¨ããã˛ã¨ãã§æĨãã¤ããã ãŖããããŠãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããŽæŗãĢãĒãã¨čǰãã¨æĨãããã˛ã¨ãã§æĨãæšãæ°ãæĨŊãĒãŽãã
ãåã¯éŖå ã§čĻãããåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ããĄãæãŖããããŽåĨŗæ§ããĄãããå°ãæŗãåãã°æåŖå¤ããŽãĒãžãŧããããĢãĢã˛ã¨ãã§æŗãžããããĢãĒããŽã ãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åã¨åããåãããĢãĒããããĢããĻããããã§ãĸãĢč °ãããčļŗãįĩãã§ãããåã¯į°č˛ãĢåēããæĩˇããããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽãšãĢãŧããŽčŖžãããŽããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčããããĢįŽãį§ģããããšããããŗã°ãã¯ããĻãããį´ čļŗã ãŖãã
ãšããããŗã°ããŠãããĢåŧãŖæããĻäŧįˇããããããĒåŋé ã¯ãããĒããã¨ãĢåã¯åŽå ĩãããæãŽéŖå ã§é įŽããčĻãå°čąĄãŽéããčŋãã§čĻãĻãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčãĢã¯æ´å˛ãæãããæ°åããããį̝æŖãĢįĩãŋåããããäēã¤ãŽčãããã¯ãããŽãžãžįžčĄé¤¨ãĢéŖžãããĻããããããĒããããĢæãããåã¯ããŽäŊåãĢã¤ãããšããŋã¤ããĢãčããã
ãäŊãčĒãã§ããŽīŧãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ããã
ãåã¯ã¨ãŖããĢįŽãæåēĢæŦãĢį§ģããĻč¨ãŖãããã´ãŖãŗãģãŗããģããĢãŗãã¨ããäŊåŽļãŽįᎍéã§ããããäēååš´ãåãŽããŽã§ãã
ãéĸįŊãīŧã
ãã˛ãžã¤ãļããĢã¯ãĄãããŠããã§ããåŊŧãéŖ˛ãã ãããŽãĢãĢãäŊåŽļãĒãããããŠãŽįᎍãéåģįã§ããžãæãããĒããããĢæããžãã
ããããããŽãåĨŊããĒãŽīŧã
ããããããããžãããã¨åã¯įããã
æäēēãŽé¨åąã§ãŗãŧããŧãŽį˛ãããŧããåŊŧåĨŗã¨éŖįĩĄãåããĒããĒãŖããã¨ããåã¯ã˛ãããĢæãã§ãããŽãããããĒãã
ããããããŖãããčĒãŋãĢãĒããžããīŧåˇŽãä¸ããĻã大ä¸å¤Ģã§ããäģãĢãããã¤ãæŦãæãŖãĻæĨãĻãããŽã§ãæã¤ãļããĢã¯å°ããžããã
ããæ°éŖããããã¨ããã§ãįĩæ§ããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯čŋˇããĒãįãããããããããããĒã¨ããã§ãããĒ芹ãčĒãžãĒããĻããããããĒãã
ãããããĢããŽéãã ãã¨åã¯æãŖããæĸ é¨ãŽé¨ä¸ãããŽå¯ããæĩˇčžēã§éåģįãĒįᎍéãčĒããĒãŠããžããĢãã¤ãŧãã§čĒčįã§čĒæčéå°ãĢæãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŋåēĻããĒãčŋˇããŽãĒãæãæšãĢã¯æŊãã¨åŋå°ãããæããã
ãããĒãããŠãããæĨããŽīŧã
ãæąäēŦããã§ãã
ããããį§ãäģĨåã¯æąäēŦãĢäŊãã§ããããéåąąããããĢãã
ãããã¨ãããĢãäŊãžãã ãŖããã§ããã
ããžããä¸čŦįãĢã¯ããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãåãĢã¨ãŖãĻãŽéåąąã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽč˛ˇãįŠãĢäģãåãčĄã§ããã財ãįŠãŽãã¨ãŽäŧæŠãĢããŧãĢãéŖ˛ãčĄã§ããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãĻįŦãŖãã
ãããĒããããŧã§ãé
éŖ˛ããŽã¯åĨŊãīŧã
ããããããã§ãããé ģįšãĢã¯čĄããĒãã§ãããåĨŊãã§ãã
ãéåąąãĢã¯ããæããéãŖãĻããæ°ãĢå
ĨããŽããŧãããŖããŽãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãå°ä¸ä¸éã§ããĢãĻãŗãŋãŧã¨ããã¤ããŽããŧããĢãããããããŽããããĒãĢ大ãããĒããåēã ããŠãææã¸ãŖãēãŽãŠã¤ããããĻãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããĻč¨ãŖãããããŽãåēãĢã¯äēåäģŖãŽčĨãããŧããŗããŧãããĻãåŊŧãŽäŊããĢã¯ããĢãįžåŗãããŖããį§ãããããĒããŧãĢčĄãŖããã¨ã¯ããããŠãåŊŧãäŊããĢã¯ããĢã¯ã˛ã¨åŗéããŽãããžãčĒŦæã§ããĒãããŠãããļãäŊãŖãĻãæŦäēēãčĒŦæã§ããĒããŖãã¨æããã§ãįĸēããĢã˛ã¨åŗéãŖããããĄããåŊŧãŽåĒåãããã ããããŠãããã¯åŊŧãŽæãŖãĻįãžããæčŊãã
ãä¸ãŽä¸ãĢã¯ããããŖãæčŊããããåãĢã¯ãĒãããŠãã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ããããããããäģãŽäēēããŠãã ãåĒåããĻãæĩããĒãããŽããããæŽåŋĩãĒãããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖããããããĻåŊŧã¯ã˛ã¤ã ãŖãã
ãæŦäēēããčãããã§ããīŧã
ããããã
ããããããŽãŖãĻãããããã§ããīŧã
ããĒãã¨ãĒãããæŦåŊãŽã¨ããã¯ããããĒãããŠãããļãããããã ããã¨ããŖãĻããŠããŖãĻãããããĒããŽãã ãŖãĻįžåŗãããĢã¯ããĢãäŊãŖãĻãããã°ãĒãã ãŖãĻããããŽã
ããã¤é ãŽčŠąã§ããīŧã
ãããäēååš´ãåãŽčŠąããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖããããããĒå¤čã芹ãčããããããīŧã
ããããããĄãããããŽæŦããããŖãŊãŠæ°ãããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãĻãåä¸į´ãåãĢæ¸ãããæŦãŽčĄ¨į´ãčĻãããĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãšããŧãĢãĢåē§ããĒããįˇããåŖ°ãããããããŽãåž
ã¤åŊŧåĨŗã¨ãæčŊããã˛ã¤ãŽããŧããŗããŧãäŊãã˛ã¨åŗéããĢã¯ããĢãŽéãĢã¯ãŠãããããŽčˇéĸããããŽã ããã
ãæŧãã¤ãããžãããĒãåãŽããã¸ãŖãēãæĩããĻãã¨ããŠããããŽããĨãŧã¸ãˇãŖãŗããĄãŽįãŽæŧåĨãč´ããĻããåŽĸãæĨŊããŋæšããããŖãĻããĻãæčŊããããŧããŗããŧãäŊããĢã¯ããĢãåŗããããč¨čãĢããã¨æä¸Ļãŋã ããŠãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãåã¯ããŦãã§čĻããĸããĒãĢãŽå°ããĒįåŊãæãåēããããããããããįˇčąãã§åšŗåãĒįåŊããããžãããããã§ã¯åå°ãĢæ šäģããį´ æ´ãĒæŽãããåļãžããĻããžããã
įžããéŗĨãŽããããã¨æäēēããĄãŽæĨŊãããĒæåŖ°ããã¤ãåŊä¸ãŽæã ããč´ãããĻæĨãžãããæ°åĨŗįãŽåŗäŊåŧãŽæĨã厎æŽŋãĢ芰ããããåŊæ°ããĄã¯æ°ããĒåĨŗįãŽčĒįãĢæããŋãĒãææãéããžãããåĨŗįã¯åŊæ°ãæããåŊæ°ããžããåĨŗįãæããĻããžãããããŽæäģŖãĢã¯ãžã ãããĒåŊããããžããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããĻč¨ãŖãããéåąąããã¨ãĢããĻäģĨæĨããããĒãĢã¯ããĢãĢåˇĄãåãããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯æļįŠēãŽãĢã¯ããĢã§åãæŊ¤ããããĒ襨æ
ãæĩŽããšãĒãããããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽãšãĢãŧããĢčĻããããããĢæãįŊŽããããŽæã§čģŊãããŗããŗã¨ãĒãēã ãåģãã§ããã
ãã§ããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãããããĒãã¯ãã åŊŧãŽãĢã¯ããĢãįãŽæŧåĨãæąããĻéãŖãããã§ã¯ãĒããŖããæŦåŊãŽįįąã¯åĨãĢããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åŖãĢåĢãã§ããæļįŠēãŽãĢã¯ããĢãéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã ãåãäŧãéŗãéŋãããããĢæããã
ããããããŽéããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãĻåãŽéĄãčĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ã¯ãããĻåã¨įŽãåããããããããããŖãããã
ããžããã§ããã¨ã¯č¨ããããĒããŽãããĒã˛ã¨ã¯å¤§äēãĒãã¨ãæåãĢã¯č¨ããĒãã
ãããããĢãããããããåŊãããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
9
ãåã¯æ°´åšŗįˇããããčĻã¤ããåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄãčĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯éĄãĢãããŖãåéĢĒãäēæŦãŽæã§æ¨ĒãĢæĩããããããĻåŊŧåĨŗã¯åˇĻčãä¸ãĢããĻįĩãã§ããčļŗãããĄãŠč§Ŗãã¨ã严æã§åŗãŽčãčŋããĢčĄããããĢããĻæãĄä¸ããåŗčãä¸ãĢãįĩãŋį´ããã
ãį čããã䏿Ŧ貰ãããããã
ãåã¯į čãŽįŽąãæ¯ãŖãĻ䏿Ŧåãåēãã¨åŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄãŽåãĢåˇŽãåēããåŊŧåĨŗãį čãåŖãĢããããã¨ãåã¯æãããããĻįĢãã¤ãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ã˛ã¨æ¯å¸ãŖãåžãį ãããŖããã¨åããã
ãããŽåēãŽåŖãĢã¯ããããåŊãŽįæ§ã¨åŽļæãŽčåįģãéŖžãŖãĻããŖããŽãåŊįã¨įåĻããããĻåŊŧããĢæãžãããããĢããĻįåã¨įåĨŗãæãããĻãããåŊįã¨įåĻã¯ä¸åããååãŽããã ãããããããįåã¯åæŗãããã§ãįåĨŗã¯ããå°ãå°ããã
ããŠããŽåŊãŽįæ§ããĄãĒãã§ãããã
ãããļããŋã¤ã ã¨æãããŋã¤ãŽæ°æčĄŖčŖ
ãįãĻãããããįåĻã ãæ¤
åãĢåē§ãŖãĻčļŗãįĩãã§ããããããĻåē§ããĒããåˇĻæãĢæãã¤ããĻãããŽã
ããããĒéĸ¨ãĢããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãĻããããã§ãĸãĢåē§ããĒããįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽåĨŗæ§ãŽæ ŧåĨŊãįäŧŧãããã¨ãåˇĻæãįŠēä¸ãĢæĩŽããšãčĻããĒãæãį æĩãĢįĒãįĢãĻãã
ããžãåŊãĻãĻãããã§ããīŧãã¨åã¯ãããŖãŊã严æãåãããĻįéãĢããĻããã°ããčãããĩããããĻč¨ãŖãã
ãããããŠããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åˇĻæãåŽãĢæĩŽããšããžãžãčĻããĒãæãã¤ããĻããã
ãåŊįã¯ããĒããŽæãŽæäēēã¨įäēã¤ã ãŖãããããĻįåãŽãŠãĄããã¯åŽéãĢããĒããŽæäēēã ãŖãã
ãäŊãŽæ šæ ããĒããžãŖãããŽããĻããŖãŊãã ãŖãã
ãã¯ãããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ããä¸ããĻããåˇĻæãčãŽä¸ãĢä¸ãããããããĒããæĄå¤įēæŗãããããããĒãŽããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãĻįŦãŖãã
ãããŋãžãããã¨åã¯čŦããã¤ãããĻįŦãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãåã᏿ãĢããĻ芹ããã¨ãĢæ
ŖããĻãããããĢãåãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčŠąãŽčãåŊšãĢãĒããã¨ãĢå°ããã¤æ
ŖããĻããĻããã
ãããŽįåĻã§ããåĨŗæ§ã¯ãį§ã ãŖããŽãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããå¤ãĒ芹ã ããŠã
ãåã¯äŊãč¨ãããåŊŧåĨŗãįļãããŽãåž
ãŖãã
ãããĄããåŽéãĢã¯åĨäēēã ãããããĒãã¨ã¯ããåžãĒããįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽåŊŧåĨŗã¨į§ã¯å ¨įļäŧŧãĻããĒãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãŋã¤äēēã§į§ã¯æĨæŦäēēãã§ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯į§ã ãŖããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãåã¯č¨ãŖãããããã¯ããĒããããŽįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽįåĻãĢčĒåčĒčēĢãæåŊąãããã¨ãããã¨ã§ãããããããĒããŽå¤čēĢéĄæã§ããŖãããããåžããããããĒãããĒããŽå¯čŊæ§ã¨ããĻãŽåŊŧåĨŗãčĻãĻãããã¨ãããã¨ã§ããããã
ãäēēãĢããŖãĻã¯ããį¨ŽãŽįĩĩã¨åˇĄãäŧãã¨ãããããã¨ããããããããĒããã§ãį§ãŽå ´åã¯éãããįĩĩãŽä¸ã§įåĻã¨ããĻæãããĻãããŽã¯ããŖãã¨ããį§ã ãŖãã
ããããĻããĒãã¯ããŽįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽčĒåãčĻããããĢãããŽããŧãĢéãŖãã
ãããããããããã¨ãã
ãããĒãã¯ãĒããåŊŧåĨŗãčĒåã ã¨æãããŽã§ãããã
ãåŊæãããŽãã¨ãĢã¤ããĻããããčããããŠãããããĒããŖããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããäģãããããĒãã
ãčǰããĢããŽįåĻã¨ããĒããčĻæ¯ãšãĻããããžãããīŧã
ããããããŧããŗããŧãŽåŊŧãĢč¨ããĻãŋãããããŽãåĻããžãčǰããĢäŧŧãĻãĒãīŧãŖãĻãã§ãæãã¤ããĒããŖãĻč¨ãããããäģ˛ãŽãããåŽĸãĢãčããĻãŋããåĨŗåĒãĢäŧŧãĻããŖãĻč¨ãŖãããæãŽæäēēã ãŖãããäēĄããĒãŖãåĻšã ãŖããããããŠãčǰãį§ã¨ã¯č¨ããĒããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åŗæãŽæãĢæãã§ããį čãæãåēããããŽãããĢčĻããŖãĻããåŖå ãĢæãŖãĻãããį ãå¸ãŖããåãį čãããããįĢãã¤ãããį°č˛ãŽæŗĸã¯åãæĨãæã¨å¤ãããå¯ããĻã¯åŧããĻãããã¨ããããĢãĸãĄãé ãŽä¸ãéŖãã§čĄãŖãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčŠąãĢã¤ããĻäŊãããŗãããããããĻãããĒããŖãã
ãã ããããŽįåĻãããĒããĢäŧŧãĻããã¨ã¯č¨ããĒããŽãĢãããĒãã ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããĒãã ã¨æããããããĻããŽįĩĩãčĻããããĢããĒãã¯ããŽããŧãĢéãŖããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãåã¯ããŖãããããŖã¨åããã¨ãįš°ãčŋãåŖãĢããĻãããããĢæãããæ´įĒãŽéãĢåããŖãĻäŊåēĻåŧãŗãããĻãčǰãäŊãįããĻãããããã éãĢåŖ°ãå¸ãčžŧãžãããã°ããã§åã¯ã˛ã¨ãåãæŽãããĻããã
ããããĒåããããĢåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŖããã¨į čãŽį ãåããããä¸åēĻå¸ãŖãĻåŖãŽä¸ãĢį ãįãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčãéããåŖããã¯į ãå°ãæŧãåēãĻããããããĻãžãããŖããã¨į ãåãããåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽãĩãã¤ãŽį̝æŖãĒčããããčĻãã
ãåã¯æ´įĒãŽéãĢåããŖãĻįš°ãčŋãåŧãŗããããŽããããčŠĻããĢčļŗå
ãĢčģĸããŖãĻããįŗãéŠåŊãĢæããĻãŋããã¨ãĢããã
ãã¨ãããããå¤ãããĒãããã¤ãéããĢããŽåēãĢčĄãã¨ãããŽįĩĩã¯åŖããåãå¤ãããĻããããįĄããŖããããĒãã¯ããŽįĩĩãčĻããã¨ãã§ããĒããĒãŖããããĒãã¯æˇˇäšąããããäģĨæĨããŽåēãĢéããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãįŗãŽčģĸããéŗãæ´įĒãŽéãŽä¸ãĢéŋããããŽéŗã¯å°ãããæéãĢå¸ãčžŧãžãããã¨ãĒãéˇãéŋãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯į°įŋãĢį čãæŧãäģããĻįĢãæļãããããã¯åŊŧåĨŗãĢããĻã¯å°ã æčãæãããåžããŽéæŽĩãŽæšããåŖ°ãčãããĻãããåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ããĄãããããšãããĒããæĩčžēãžã§éããĻæĨãã¨ããã ãŖããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãšãĢãŧããŽčŖžãĢčŊãĄãĻããį čãŽį°ãæããĒããč¨ãŖãã
ããããããããžããĢããžãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãããããã§ãĸããįĢãĄä¸ããããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽãšãĢãŧããŽčŖžãæ´ããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽč¸čĄåį´ãŽčãããã¯čĻããĒããĒãŖããåŊŧåĨŗã¯į°č˛ãŽæĩˇãčĻããŖãĻããåãŽæšãĢéĄãåããį čããĄããããžãã¨č¨ãŖãĻãįŗãŽéæŽĩãĢåããĻæŠããĻčĄããã¨ããã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯æĨãæã¨åããããĢãį å°ãĢčļŗãåããããã¨ãĒãå§ŋåĸãå´ŠãããĢæŠããĻããŖããåŊŧåĨŗãčĒãŖãįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽåĨŗæ§ã¨éãŖãĻãåŊŧåĨŗãĢæã¯ãžãŖããåŋ čĻãĒããŖããã ããããåãĢã¯ããã˛ã¨ã¤ãŽãã¨ãåŧãŖæããŖããåŊŧåĨŗãåŗčãä¸ãĢããĻčļŗãįĩãã¨ãããã¤ã严æãåŗčãĢæˇģããĻæãĄä¸ãããããĢããĻããã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãåŧãŗæĸããã
ãããŽããã¨ã˛ã¨ã¤ã ãčŗĒåããĻããã§ããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻåãŽæšãĢæ¯ãåãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĄ¨æ ã¯æãŖãĻãããããĢãå¤ąæããĻãããããĢãæããĒããŖããããã ãããĢã¯į čãŽåããäģæšãĒããĢčŋããããĒ襨æ ãããŖãã
ãããããŠããããĒãĢããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããã¯ããĒããŽåŗčã¨éĸäŋããããŽã§ããīŧã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊã襨æ
ãå¤ãããĢåãŽéĄãčĻãĻããã
ãããĒãã¯čļŗãįĩãã¨ãããã¤ãåŗčã严æã§æąãããããĢããĻãããã¨åã¯č¨ãæˇģããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĄ¨æ ããã¯äŊãčĒãŋåããĒããŖããåã¯ãäģŖã æ¨å Ŧåã§åäžããĄãĢããŧãĢãčŋįããã¨ããĢé ããĢæãéãããã¨ãæãåēãããåãŽãããã¨ãĒããã¨ããšãĻãããéããããæ šæŦįãĢééãŖãĻããããŽãŠãĄãããĢæãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊãįãããĢãããĢãĢæģãŖãĻããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãįŗãŽéæŽĩãä¸ãæŖŽãŽä¸ãĢæļããĻãããŽãčĻåąãããšããŧãããŠãŗãéãããæäēēãããŽįäŋĄã¯ãã¯ãįĄããŖãããããããĻæãĢåãŖãįᎍéãŽčĄ¨į´ã§ã¯ãį¸å¤ããããšããŧãĢãĢåē§ãŖãåĨŗãįĻįšãåŽãããĢãĢãĻãŗãŋãŧåãããŽäŊããčĻãĻããã
ã˛ã¨åŗéããĢã¯ããĢãĢį¸ããĒããŽã¯åŊŧåĨŗã ãã§ã¯ãĒããåããããĒãĢã¯ããĢã¨åēäŧããããĢįĄããŖããããããŽæŦãčĒãæ°ãĢã¯ãĒãããäēã¤ãŽããããã§ãĸãįäģãį æĩããã¨ãĢããã
10
ããããĢãŽãããŧãĢæģãã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŠãščļããĢæĩˇãæããįĒčžēãŽã˛ã¨ãæããŊããĄãŧãĢåē§ãŖãĻãããããã¯ãŠãĻãŗã¸ãĢãĒãŖãĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãŗãŧããŧãéŖ˛ãã§ãããåã¯åŊŧåĨŗã¨įŽãããŖããŽã§ãčģŊãäŧéãããĻéãéãããã¨ããã
ãããĒããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯åãĢåŖ°ããããã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽã¨ãããĢæŠããĻčĄãŖãã
ããŗãŧããŧã§ããããīŧãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãåã¯ãããã ããžããã¨č¨ãŖãĻåŊŧåĨŗãŽéŖãŽã˛ã¨ãæããŊããĄãŧãĢč °ãä¸ããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãåŧãã ãåã¯ãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãĢããŠãã¯ãŽããããŗãŧããŧãæŗ¨æãããåã¯äŊããããšãããå˛ŦãŽåãããĢčĻããæ°´åšŗįˇãįēããĻããã
é˛ã¯į¸å¤ãããéãįŠēãĢåããããĻãããäģã¯ãžã é¨ãŽéãæ°é ã¯ãĒããŖããã夿šãĢãĒãã°ãžãéããããĒæ°ããããåŊŧåĨŗãäŊããããšãããĢåãæ°´åšŗįˇãčĻãĻããããĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãåãŽã¨ãããĢãŗãŧããŧãåąããĢæĨãã¨ãåŊŧã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽãŗãŧããŧãįŊŽããĻãã丸ãããŖãŧããŧããĢãĢåãŽãŗãŧããŧãįŊŽãããåã¯åŊŧãĢį¤ŧãč¨ãŖãĻããŗãŧããŧãĢåŖãã¤ããã
ãããããã§ãĸãįäģããĻããããŽīŧãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ããã
ããããįäģããžãããã¨åã¯įããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããããã¨ããã¨č¨ãŖãã
ããããģãŠã¯ããŋãžãããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãããäŊãããĒããŽæ°ãĢéããããĒãã¨ãč¨ãŖããĒãčŦããžãã
ãåã¯čŦããĒãã¨ãããĒããããĒæ°ããããįĨããįĨãããŽããĄãĢãžãäŊããæãããŽã ãããčĒčĻãĒãæäēēãĢããĻããžãŖããããĢã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯äŊãč¨ããĒããŖãããåãŽæšãčĻãĻããããŽããã¨ãããããĒįŦãŋãåŖå
ãĢæĩŽããšãã
ã夿šãĢãžãéãåēãããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯ããŠãšãčĻãĒããč¨ãŖãã
ãį§ã¯ããé¨ãåĨŊããĒãŽãäŊãããæ´ãæĩããĻãããæ°ãããĻãã§ãããŽæŗãĢãĒãã¨ãé¨ãããããæ´ãæĩããĒãããŽããããä¸ãĢããŗãã¤ããĻãããããĒããĢãå°ããããããããããŽã¯ããã§ãããã
ãããããããžããã¨åã¯įããã
ããããĢãã¨ãé¨ã§æ´ãæĩããã¨ããĻãããžãåããããĒéãĄãį¯ãæ°ãããžãã
ãããĒãããžã čĨããŽãĢãããĢæãŖãéĸ¨ãĒãã¨ãč¨ããŽããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãã§ãįĸēããĢããĒããŽč¨ãã¨ããããããŽæŗãĢãĒãŖãĻãčĒåãŽæ šæŦã¯äŊãå¤ãããĒãããŽãããĒããæŽåŋĩã ããŠããŽãã¨ã¯čĻããĻãããĒãããį§ãč¨ããã ãããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯åžŽįŦãŋãĒããč¨ãŖãã
ãčĻããĻãããžããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
åã¯ããããä¸ååš´įĩãŖãĻããããå¤ããããįĨããįĨãããŽããĄãĢäŊãããæããčǰããčįĢããããŽã ãããé˛ã¯é¨ãéããããŠã¯ãã¯ã¤ã°ãåããåã¯čǰããčįĢãããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãåŗæã§ããŧã¯ã°ãŦãŧãŽéĢĒããããããã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĢĒãŽåãįŽããã¯éĢĒãŽæ šå
ãŽãžã æããããĻããĒãįŊãé¨åãå°ãčĻããã
ãããĒãã¯äŊããįãã ãã¨ã¯ããīŧãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯åãĢč¨ããã
ãåã¯å°ã
éŠããĻåŊŧåĨŗãčĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĄ¨æ
ããã¯ããŽčŗĒåãŽæåŗã¯ããããĒããŖãã
ãããããããžããã¨åã¯æŖį´ãĢįããã
ãįĒįã¨ããæåŗã§ãĒãä¸åēĻä¸åŧãããããã¨ããããžããåĻįãŽé ã夿Ŧåąã§æŦãä¸åŧãããžãããããļãįžåããããŽæŦã§ããããæãĄåãããååčļŗãããĢä¸åŧãããžãããããŦããĢæ¸ãŋãžãããããããååãŽãããĢį¯ãããĒãšã¯ãæããĒãŖãĻãããããããããããŽãčĻããĻããžããããäģĨæĨãįãŋã¯ããĻããžããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããããã¨ã ãč¨ãŖãĻãŗãŧããŧãĢåŖãã¤ããã
ããã°ããããĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããį§ã¯ããŽįĩĩãįãã ãŽã
ããžãã§éãĢå˛ãčąãæãã ããŽãããĢãåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖããåã¯äŊãč¨ãããåŊŧåĨŗãįļãã芹ããŽãåž
ãŖãã
ãããŽæĨãŽããããéåēãŽæéã¨ããé ããåŽĸã¯į§ã ãã ãŖããããŽå¤ã¯åĨãĢįãã¤ããã§čĄãŖãããã§ã¯ãĒããã ããŠããããĸãĢã¯į§ãŽäģãĢããŧããŗããŧãŽåŊŧããããĒããĻãéåēãŽįãĨãã§åŋãããã ãŖããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯åŖ°ãŽå¤§ãããįšãĢå¤ãããããĢč¨ãŖãã
ãåã¯å¨ããčĻåããã ããčãčŗãįĢãĻãĻããĒããįĸēããããããŠãĻãŗã¸ãĢã¯ãģããŽåŽĸã¯ãããããĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãŽå§ŋãčĻåŊãããĒããŖãã
ãããĒãã¯ãŠãããĻãããĒãã¨ãåãĢ芹ããã§ããããã¨åã¯å°åŖ°ã§č¨ããã
ãããããŠãããĻããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãããŽå¤Šæ°ãŽãããããããĒããããããã¨ãããããŽããããĒãã¯å°ãåãããããã ãã
ããŠãããĻįããã¨æãŖããŽã§ããããã¨åã¯č¨ããã
ãåēæĨåŋã¨ããã°ãããžã§ã ããŠãããŽįĩĩãį§ãŽæå
ãĢįŊŽããĒãã¨ãããĒããã¨ããčĄåãį§ãįĒãåããããããäģĨä¸ãŽįįąã¯ãĒããã
ãįãã ãŽã¯ããããåããĻã§ããīŧã
ããããããããåžãĢãå
ãĢãããã ãã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãåēãŽįĩĩãįããĒãšã¯ãčãããįēčĻããå ´åã常éŖåŽĸãŽåŊŧåĨŗãĒãåēã¨ãŽį¤ēčĢã§æ¸ãã å¯čŊæ§ã大ããã ããããã¨ãčĻå¯ãĢįĒãåēãããĻčĩˇč¨´ããããĻããåį¯ãĒãã°ããããå°ã ãŽįŊ°éã¨åˇčĄįļäēãã¤ããããã ããã
ãããåŊŧåĨŗãĢã¯ãããĒããŽį¤žäŧįčēĢåããããããĢčĻãããããããŽäŋĄį¨ãĢåˇãã¤ããã¨ãæãã°ãžãŖããå˛ãĢåããĒãã ãããã§ãããŽåĨŗæ§ã¯ããŽãããĒãã¨ãčãããžã§ããĒããįĩĩãįãã ããããã¯įãžãĒãã¨ãããĒããŖãã
ãįããŽã¯į°Ąåã§ãããīŧã
ããããæĄå¤ãįĩĩãįããŽãŖãĻį°ĄåãĒãŽããããŧããŗããŧãŽåŊŧãããã¯ã¤ãŧããĢä¸ããŖãĻãéãĢãããŽįĩĩãŽã¨ãããĢčĄãŖãĻåŖããå¤ããĻåēãåēããŽããããĻéãã§ãŋã¯ãˇãŧãã¤ããžããĻčĒåŽ
ãĢ帰ãŖããã´ã
ãŧãŖã¨ããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ããåŗãŽäēēåˇŽãæãįĢãĻã˛ã
ãŖã¨įŠēãåãŖãã
ãä¸åŋã貥å¸ãŽä¸ãĢå
ĨãŖãĻãããéãå
¨é¨ãĢãĻãŗãŋãŧãĢįŊŽããĻãããã
ãå°ããįģã ãŖããã§ããīŧãã¨åã¯č¨ããã
ããããããããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãĻãåē§ãŖããžãžč¸ãŽéĢãããããĢæãį¤ēãããå°ããã¯ãĒããŖããåŊŧåĨŗãæˇąå¤ãŽéåąąãŽéãã§ããŽįĩĩã严æã§æąããĒããããŋã¯ãˇãŧãã¤ããžããæ§åãåã¯æŗåããã
ãčĒåŽ
ãĢæãĄå¸°ãŖããã¨ãããŽįĩĩãéŖžãŖããã§ããããã
ããããéŖžãŖããããĒããŗã°ãŽä¸įĒããã¨ãããĢãããæ°ãĢå
Ĩãã ãŖãįĩĩãããããå¤ããĻããŽįĩĩãéŖžãŖããŽãéŖžãããĢã¯ããŧãŧãããĢããžãŖãĻãããã¨ãã§ãããããŠãéŖžããĒãã¨ãããĒãæ°ããããŽããããĻį§ãŽåŽļã§ãįåĻã§ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯į§ã ãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããĻč¨ãŖãããčĄåįãĢįĩĩãįãã§éŖžãŖãããã ããŠãčĒåã§ããŖãĻãããĒããéæšãĢæŽããã¨ãããŽããããŽã¨ããŽæŦéŗãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãããžã§č¨ãŖãĻãŗãŧããŧãéŖ˛ããã¨ãããããĢãããĢãŗãŧããŧã¯æŽãŖãĻããĒããŖããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãåŧãã§ããĢãĸããŧãĢããŖãŧãé ŧãã ã
ãããŽæ°æĨåžãį§ã¯ããŽåēãĢčĄãŖããŽã
ãåąéēãåããĻããããããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãį¯äēēã¯įžå ´ãĢæģãããŖãĻč¨ããããĒããããããžããĢå°ã§čĄãŖãæããã
ããããĻããĒãã¯æãžãŖããã¨ããããã§ããĒããŖãã
ããããčǰãį§ãæãžãããã¨ãåãããã¨ãããããã¤ãéãåãŽããã¸ãŖãēãæĩããããŧããŗããŧã¯ã˛ã¨åŗéããĢã¯ããĢãäŊãŖãĻããããã éãŖããŽã¯ãããŽįĩĩãããŖãå ´æãĢã¯éįŠįģãäģŖãããĢéŖžãŖãĻããŖããã¨ããã¤ããŽãããĢį§ã¯ããã¤ããŽãĢã¯ããĢãéŖ˛ãã§ãããŧããŗããŧã¨å°ãããããšããããĻãäģŖéãæãŖãĻ帰ãŖãã
ãããŽįĩĩãŽãã¨ãĢã¤ããĻ芹ããžãããīŧã
ããããããŧããŗããŧãĢįĩĩãå¤ããŖããã¨ãč¨ããããåãŽããŽã¯ãĒãŧãšãŽæéãåãããŽã§åĨãŽįĩĩãĢå¤ããžãããã¨įããããããŽåēãĢčĄãŖããŽã¯ãããæåžãããäģĨæĨããŽåēãĢéããã¨ã¯ãĒããŖããããĒããč¨ãŖãã¨ããã
ããĻã§ã¤ãŋãŧãåŊŧåĨŗãŽå
ãĢãĢãĸããŧãĢããŖãŧãæãŖãĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãããã˛ã¨åŖãåŖãĢããã
ããžããã§ããæŦåŊãĢãã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
åŊŧåĨŗã¯ãããŖãĻãããã¨ãããããĒįŦãŋãæĩŽããšããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåžŽįŦãŋã¯ããããĒåŖ°įĄãč¨čã襨ãã
ããããĻåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããããŽå¤ãĢ䏿č°ãĒãã¨ãčĩˇããŖããŽã
11
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããĻč¨ãŖãã
ãį§ãå¯åޤã§å¯ãĻããã¨ãĒããŗã°ããããŗãããŗã¨éŗããããåēãĢäŊããæãĄã¤ãããããĢãããŖããã¨ããŗãããŗãã¨ãį§ã¯į ããæˇąããĻå¤å°ãŽãã¨ã§ã¯čĩˇããĒãããŠãããŽæã¯įŽãčĻããã
ãã¤ãžã§ããŖãĻãããŽéŗãæĸãžãĒããããæ°åŗãæĒããŖãããŠãĒããŗã°ãčĻããĢčĄããé¨åąãŽæãããã¤ãããĢããŖããã¨ããĸããčĻããããŠãčǰãããĒããŖããåēãĢäŊããčģĸãčŊãĄãĻãããã¨ããĒããŖããã§ãæããĢįŽãæ ŖããĻããã¨ããĢããŽįĩĩãčĻãã¨ãããŽéŗãĢåãããĻįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽåŊŧåĨŗããįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽåēãĢæãæãĄã¤ããĻããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯ããč¨ãŖãĻãã˛ã¨ãæããŊããĄãĢåē§ããĒããåˇĻæã§äŊãŖãæŗãä¸ä¸ãĢæ¯ããæãåēãĢæãĄã¤ããäģčãããŖããã¨äŊåēĻãããã
ãåēãĢæãæãĄã¤ããĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯į§ã§ãããŖãããįč§ŖããããåŊŧåĨŗã¯æãŖãĻãããã¨ãĻãæãŖãĻãããæããæãåãããæãåēãĢæãĄã¤ããĻããããããĻį§ãŽä¸ãĢããĩã¤ãĩã¤ã¨æããæš§ããĻããã
äŊãĢ寞ããĻãŽæããããããĒããŖãããŠãį§ãæŋããæãŖãĻãããåæãĢį§ã¯åŊŧåĨŗãĢåæ
ããåŊŧåĨŗã¯į§ãĢéŖå¸¯ãŽãããĒããŽãæããĻããããã¤ããį§ã¯åŗčļŗã§åēãããŗããŗã¨č¸ãŋã¤ããĻããããåŊŧåĨŗãæãæãĄã¤ãããŽãĢåãããĻãåŧˇãã
ãåã¯ãŗãŧããŧãĢãããæãĢåãã˛ã¨åŖéŖ˛ãã ããĢãããŽä¸ãŽãŗãŧããŧã¯æŽãå
ããĢãĒãŖãĻããã
ãããŽæãįéĸããčǰããå ĨãŖãĻãããŽãéĩãéããã¯ããŽããĸãéããåģä¸ãäŧãŖãĻããŖããã¨ãĒããŗã°ãĢåããŖãĻæŠããĻãããããããŽéŗãčããį§ã¯æããĒãŖãĻãŊããĄãŧãŽåžããĢé ãããããŖããã¨ããĸãéããĻå ĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯åŊįã ãŖããįĩĩãŽä¸ãŽåŊįãã
åŊįã¯į§ãĢæ°ãĨãããå ã ã¨é¨åąãŽä¸ãĢå ĨãŖãĻããããããĻåŊŧã¯įĩĩãŽåã§įĢãĄæĸãžãŖãĻããŽįĩĩãįēãå§ããããããčĻãį§ã¯åŧˇãæããæãããŽããããĻį§ã¯įč§Ŗããããį§ãæããĻããæãã¯åŊįãĢ寞ããããŽã ã¨ãããã¨ãã
įĩĩãŽä¸ãŽįåĻã¯ä¸åą¤åŧˇãæãåēãĢæãĄã¤ããã ãã ãã¨ããŽãĒãēã ãæŠããĒãŖãĻããŖããį§ã¯ããŽåŊįãåããĒãã¨ãããĒãã¨æãŖããäģããŽå ´ã§åŊįãäģįããĒãã¨ãããĒããã¨åŧˇãæãããŽãį§ã¯ãŊããĄãŧãŽæ¨ĒãŽããŧããĢãĢããŖãčąįļããåŊŧãĢæ°ãĨãããĒããããĢããŖã¨æãĢããããããĻåŊįãŽåžãããããŽåžé é¨ãåãŽéãã̿޴ãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄãčĻãã¨įåŖããŽããŽã ãŖããåŊŧåĨŗã¯įĒãŽå¤ãĢįŽãåããĻããããããŽįŽãåŽéãĢčĻãĻããããŽã¯ãįãã įĩĩãŽåã§åŊįãŽåžé é¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã掴ãã¤ããæ§åãŽãããĢæãããåã¯äŊãåŖãæãžãĒããããĢããã
ãæããŖããåžé é¨ã掴ãã¤ããããåŊįã¯æčãå¤ąãŖãĻåēãĢåããããããĻį§ã¯ããã§ããã¨ãããããåŊŧãčš´ãã¤ããč¸ãŋã¤ãããæããĢčēĢãäģģããĻãåŊįãããäēåēĻã¨čĩˇãä¸ããŖãĻæĨããĒããããĢã
åŊŧãčš´ãã¤ãč¸ãŋã¤ããĻãããŽã¯į§ã§ãããįåĻã§ãããŖããäēäēēãä¸įˇãĢãĒãŖãĻåŊįãįãã¤ãããŽããŋãŦãå¤ãããããĢãæããããžã§ãĢã
ãããĒãããĄã¯åŊįãæŽēãããŽã§ãããããã¨åã¯č¨ããã
ãããã¯ããããĒããããįĸēãããããã§ã¯ãĒããããã§ãåŊįãŽäŊã¯ã´ããã¨ãåããĒããŖãããåŧå¸ãããĻããæ°é
ãįĄããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įļããããããããŖãĻåŊįãäģįããåžãåēãĢčģĸããããŽå§ŋãčĻãĻããã¨æããåŧããĻãããŽãį§ãŽæããåŊŧåĨŗãŽæãããããŽããããĢã˛ãŠãæˇˇäšąãããããããĻéãį˛ããĢčĨ˛ãããĻį§ã¯ãŊããĄãŧãĢã¸ããčžŧãŋãããŽãžãžį ãŖãĻããžãŖãã
ãæčĩˇããã¨ãŠãã§ãããã
ãããããã芹ãŽéãããįŽčĻããã¨ãŊããĄãŧãĢããããŠãåēãĢåŊįãĒããĻããĒããŖãããįãã įĩĩãĢã¯äŊãå¤åã¯ãĒããŖããå¤ĸã ãŖããŽããŠããããããããĒããããŠããčąįļã¯å˛ããĻåēãĢæŖãã°ãŖãĻããããããĻåŗčãã˛ãŠãįãã ã
ãåŗčãã˛ãŠãįãã ãã¨åã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽč¨čãįš°ãčŋããã
ããããįãŋãã˛ãŠããč
ĢããĻããããį
éĸãĢčĄãŖãĻč¨ēãĻãããã¨éǍæããĻããããã ããããŽãã¨ãã°ããã¯æãäŊŋãįæ´ģãããĻãããŽã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽåŗčãčĻããåŊŧåĨŗã¯åŗčãä¸ãĢããĻčļŗãįĩãã§ãããæĩˇčžēã§ãčĻãéããæ°åãŽããįžããčã ãŖããã ãããŽčã¯ãéǍãæããããããĢåŊįãããããčļŗčš´ãĢããĻįãã¤ããčã§ãããŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããåŗčãä¸ãĢããĻčļŗãįĩãã¨ããĢ严æãæˇģããĻããžããŽã¯ããæĒæãããĻããããŽã¨ããŽã¯ãģãĒãŽããã¯ãģãį´ããĒããŽã
ãåŊįčščēãŽįå°ã¨ããĻãã¨åã¯æãŖãã
ãããŽįĩĩã¯ããŽãã¨ããŠããĒãŖããã§ãããããã¨åã¯č¨ããã
ãæãæãĄã¤ããéŗããããŽã¯ããŽæŠã ãã§ãããããäģĨæĨããŽéŗãč´ããã¨ã¯įĄããŖãããããŽãã¨ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯į§ã ãŖãããŠãå°ããã¤ããŽå°čąĄãčããĻããæãã¯ããŖããåžã
ãĢåŊŧåĨŗã¯į§ã§ã¯įĄããĒãŖãĻããŖããŽãããããĻåŗčãæ˛ģãŖããããĢį§ã¯ããŽįĩĩãčģã§å¤æŠåˇãĢéãã§ãæ˛ŗåˇæˇã§įãããã
ãåã¯ãããĢåŖãĢããšãč¨čãæãã¤ãããäŊãč¨ãããĢããããŗãŧããŧãéŖ˛ããã¨ãĢãããåŖãĢã¤ããããããįŠēã ãŖãã
ããã°ããããĻåã¯č¨ããããäģãŽčǰããĢãããŽčŠąãããžãããã
ãããĒããåããĻããã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖããã芹ããĻãŋãã¨å¤ãĒããŽããčĒåãŽčēĢãĢčĩˇããŖããã¨ãããĒããŋããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄããã¯ããããžã§ãŠãã¨ãĒãæŧãŖãĻããéēãŽãããĒããŽãčããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄãĢããŖãéēã¯ãåŊŧåĨŗããžã¨ãéĢæŊãã¨æ°åãæãčĻį´ ãŽä¸é¨ã§ããŖãããäģããããã¯å°ã įŽæšãæ¸ãããäģŖãããĢįŠããããåĸããĻãããåŊŧåĨŗã¯ãĢãĸããŧãĢããŖãŧãéŖ˛ãŋãĒããåŗããããããŖãĻããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããåŊįãčš´ãä¸ããĻãč¸ãŋã¤ããã¨ããŽæč§Ļã¯ãžã ããŖããã¨æŽãŖãĻãããŽãį§ãŽčļŗãåŊŧãŽčäŊãĢéŖãčžŧãŋãčļŗãŽä¸ã§åŊŧãŽéǍããããæčĻããįšãĢåŊįãŽããããŋãč¸ãŋã¤ããã¨ããŽéãåĢãĒæč§Ļããã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãŽčļŗãĢæŽãæ´åãŽæč§ĻãŽč¨æļãčããå˛ŦãŽå ãĢåēããæ¯č˛ããžãŖãããĢčĻããé˛ã¯åããĄãį æĩãĢããæããããããĢéãåãčžŧããĻãããããĢæãããåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãĢã˛ã¨ã¤ãŽãããã¨ãå°ããĒããã°ãĒããĒããããĢæãããããã¯ãĩãããŗåŊŧåĨŗãčįĢããããããããĒããããã§ãå°ãããĢã¯ããããĒããŖãã
ããããåĢãããĒããã°ãã¨åã¯åŊŧåĨŗãčãããããŽãčĻãĒããå°ããããããĒããŽåŗčãĢč§ĻããĻãããã§ããããã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãčĻããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčĄ¨æ
ãĢčģŊčãŽč˛ãæĩŽããļãã¨ãčĻæããããããŽãããĒãã¨ã¯ãĒããŖãã
ããããããã¨ã ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯č¨ãŖãããããĻããã¯č¨ŧæ ãŽåãčĒãåˇŽãåēããčĒčēĢãŽį¯čĄãč¨ŧæãããã¨ããããŽãããĢčãããã
ãåã¯åŊŧåĨŗãįĩãčãŽåãĢã˛ããžããããįžčĄåãįšåĨãĢéčŋã§čĻãæŠäŧãåžããããĒéĸæãĄã§ãããŗãã°ãĒãŧãŗãŽããŦãĸãšãĢãŧããŽčŖžããé˛ããĢãĒãåŊŧåĨŗãŽäēæŦãŽčãįēãããį¸å¤ãããįžããčã ãŖãã
åŊŧåĨŗãŽéĄãčĻä¸ããã¨ãåãŽæãåŊŧåĨŗãŽčãĢč§ĻãããŽãåž ãĄæ§ããæ¯ãã˛ãããĻãããŽããããŖãããĄãããŠæĩčžēããæģãŖãĻããåäēēįĩãŽåĨŗæ§ããĄããããŧãéããããŖããåŊŧåĨŗããĄã¯ãŊããĄãŧãĢåē§ãåčãŽåĨŗæ§ã¨ããŽåãĢã˛ããžãããããĨãåãåčĻããĒãããéģãŖãĻéãéããĻčĄãŖãã
åã¯ãããĒåŊŧåĨŗããĄãŽãã¨ã¯æ°ãĢããããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåŗčãĢ严æã§ããŖã¨č§ĻãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčã垎ããĢéãããæ¯æĨ业åŋĩãĢæå ĨããããĻããã§ããããčļããã§ããį´°ããĒčãŽæč§Ļã¨åŊŧåĨŗãŽäŊ渊ããģãŽããĢæå ããäŧããŖãĻããã
åŊŧåĨŗãŽæãããĒãĩããã¯ããĢčģŊãæãæˇģããĒããéŧģå
ãčŋãĨããã¨ããšããŗãąãĸã¯ãĒãŧã ãŽãĩãŗããĢãĻãããŽåããå°ããããããŽéãåŊŧåĨŗã¯įŽãįãŖãĻããããããĻå°ã忝ãåãããããĢčãããã
ããããã¨ãããããžããã¨åã¯ãŊããĄãŧãĢæģãŖãĻč¨ãŖãã
ãæēčļŗãããããīŧãã¨åŊŧåĨŗã¯įˇåŧĩãč§ŖããåŖ°ã§č¨ãŖãã
ãã¯ããįžããčã§ããã¨åã¯č¨ãŖãã
ãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åãč§Ļããčãįĩãŋæŋãããã¨ãĒãããŽãžãžãĢãæĩˇãįēããĻãããå¤ãŽããŠãšãĢã¯į´°ããĒé§ãŽãããĒé¨ããĄãéĸ¨ãĢåšããčãŖãĻããã
ãįŋæãåã¯ãã§ãã¯ãĸãĻãããããæ¯æããæ¸ãžãããã¨ããã¨ãããĢããŗãč¨ãŖãã
ãåŊãããĢãŽãĒãŧããŧããããĒãæ§ãŽåããæ¯æããĢãĒããžããã
ãåãŽäēæ
ãåãŋčžŧããĻããĒãæ§åãčĻãĻãåŊŧã¯įļããĻč¨ãŖãã
ãæ¨æĨãŠãĻãŗã¸ã§ä¸įˇãĢã芹ããããĻãããåŠĻäēēããåŊãããĢãŽãĒãŧããŧã§ãããĒãŧããŧã¯äģææŠããĢãįĢãĄãĢãĒããžããã
ãåã¯äŊãč¨ãŖãĻãããŽããããããã¨ããããããããã¨ããã¨ã ãč¨ãŖãĻãã§ãã¯ãĸãĻããæ¸ãžããããŧããã¨ãĢãããæģå¨ä¸ãĢæäēēããéŖįĩĄãæĨããã¨ã¯įĄããã¨ãããåãæããéģ芹ãĢãåŊŧåĨŗã¯åēãĒããŖãããããĻåã¯ãããĢãŽåŽŋæŗäģŖãæ¯æããã¨ãã§ããĒããŖãã
ããŽãããĢããĒããĨãŧãĸãĢãããã°ãããæŗãžããã¨ãįĄããåŊįļåŽŋæŗäģŖãæ¯æããã¨ãįĄããæåžãŽæ¯æããã§ããĒããŖãåŋå°æĒããŽãããĒããŽãæŽãŖããåã¯ä¸įä¸ãŽãŠãŽįåŊãĢčĄãŖãĻãæčŋãããĒããããĒæ°ãããã
ãčģãĢäšãčžŧãŋã¨ãŗã¸ãŗãããããåã¯ã¨ãŗã¸ãŗãããããžãžãã°ãããŽéãéčģĸå¸ãŽãˇãŧããĢæˇąãčēĢãæ˛ãããæ¨æŠãããĩãããŗåŧˇãéãå§ããé¨ããããŗããŦãŠãšãĢæãĄã¤ããĻããã
åã¯æäēēãŽããŗãˇã§ãŗãĢäģããčĄããšããææĄãããäģæĨã§ã¯ãĒããĢããĻããåŊŧåĨŗãĢäŧããĢčĄããšããĒãŽã ãããäŧãŖãĻããããžã§äŊåēĻã§ãããããäŧãŖãĻãããã¨ããĻãåŊŧåĨŗãĢäŊã¨åŖ°ããããã°ãããŽãããããĒããŖãã
ãããŽé¨ãåŊŧåĨŗãŽãã¨ãĢãåąããåŊŧåĨŗãŽåãæãĄéŗ´ãããåŊŧåĨŗãŽčļŗå
ãæŋĄãããĻããæ§åãåã¯æãæããã