
26 Books
See all
Read as part 3/3 of Le Vicomte de Bragelonne:
Quelle dÃĐception! All three books in the musketeers cycle have pretty disappointing endings, but this one is by far the worst. Up until the denouement, I wouldâve called this the best section of Le Vicomte de Bragelonneâthe story here is very rich and exciting (even if everyone feels a bit out of character). But the ending is just so depressing that it completely overshadows the rest of the book. Alexandre Dumas hates me and doesn't want me to be happy ( âĒ áī âĒ ï―Ą)
It is astounding to me just how spectacularly this manages to fail on every conceivable level. It's almost impressive.
The plot in and of itself is pretty lackluster, but its blatant disregard for Dumas' canon is frankly insulting coming from what is LITERALLY a fanfiction. Multiple major plot points directly contradict the timeline of events in the original novel, and the four protagonists are so wildly out of character that it's difficult to believe that D'Almeida even read the source material to begin with.
The prose is nothing to write home about, but it's nothing compared to the atrocious spelling and grammar. It's especially baffling to me that some of the proper nouns are repeatedly misspelled. This is fanfiction of a BOOK, the names are literally RIGHT THERE. And the abysmal French is the icing on the cake. I mean, it's fine if you don't speak French, but you can't just pretend you do and then make stuff up!!! "BIEN vivant"?! COME ON.
I'm genuinely astonished that this was published like this.
Anyways I thought it was awesome and I WILL be reading all 5 of these